Clinton, Trump Conclude a Contentious Second Debate

While the debate took off to a chilly start with the two rivals refusing to shake hands with one another, after sparring over taxes, emails and ISIS they left the stage having reluctantly complimented each other.

Send in e-mailSend in e-mail
Presidential hopefuls Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton during their town hall debate in St. Louis, Missouri, U.S., October 9, 2016.
Presidential hopefuls Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton during their town hall debate in St. Louis, Missouri, U.S., October 9, 2016.Credit: Lucy Nicholson, Reuters

Watch full debate | Read full transcript

A defiant Donald Trump on Sunday attacked former President Bill Clinton for his treatment of women and vowed, if he won the White House, to put Hillary Clinton in jail for operating a private email server while U.S. secretary of state.

In a contentious town-hall debate, Trump, the Republican presidential candidate, said he would appoint a special prosecutor to look into his Democratic rival's email use because she had endangered national security during her tenure as President Barack Obama's chief diplomat from 2009-2013.

Read more: Beware a Trump Who's Got Nothing Left to Lose | Jewish Trump supporters will forgive Donald's sins on Yom Kippur, but not Hillary's | Trump's new tape scandal could decimate GOP and give Congress to Democrats | Has Trump's stomach-turning, misogynist tape finished his presidential bid? | For Jewish Republicans like me, tapes confirm Trump's perversion of values

The 90-minute debate got off to a chilly start when the two candidates for the November 8 election greeted each other without the traditional handshake. It quickly turned into an acrimonious discussion of a 2005 video that emerged on Friday in which Trump was heard using vulgar language and talking about groping women without consent.

Former U.S. President Bill Clinton greets Ivanka Trump, daughter of Donald Trump, before the start of the second U.S. presidential in St. Louis, Missouri on October 9, 2016. Credit: Jim Young, Reuters

Trump said he was embarrassed by the video but dismissed it as "locker room talk." President Bill Clinton had done worse to women, he said.
"Mine are words and his are action," said Trump, who appeared before the debate with women who have accused Bill Clinton of sexual misconduct. In the debate, Trump also accused Hillary Clinton of going on the attack against women who had alleged sexual misconduct by her husband, president from 1993-2001.

Hillary Clinton responded that Trump's comments showed he was unfit for the White House.

"He has said the video doesn't represent who he is but I think it's clear to anyone who heard it that it represents exactly who he is," Clinton said.

Trump also went on the attack against Clinton over her private email server, saying: "You ought to be ashamed of yourself."
Clinton said, "You know it's just awfully good that someone with the temperament of Donald Trump is not in charge of the law in this country." Trump shot back: "Because you'd be in jail."

Marc Mezvinsky, Chelsea Clinton and Former U.S. President Bill Clinton sit at the presidential town hall in St. Louis, Missouri on October 9, 2016.Credit: Jim Bourg, Reuters

A nearly year-long FBI investigation into the emails concluded earlier this year without charges being filed, although FBI Director James Comey said Clinton had been careless in her handling of sensitive material.
Clinton insisted there was "no evidence" that her server had been hacked and that any classified information had ended up in the wrong hands. "I take classified material very seriously," she said.

Trump said: "You said it was fine to delete 33,000 emails. I don't think so."
Clinton shook her head. "Look it's just not true."
She accused Trump of dodging a discussion of policy issues to avoid talking about his campaign because of "the way yours is exploding and Republicans are leaving you."

Republicans withdraw supprt

A flood of Republicans have withdrawn their support for Trump over the video. The controversy has pitched Trump into the biggest crisis of his 16-month-old campaign and deepened fissures between him and establishment Republicans.

The debate's town hall-style format, with undecided voters posing about half the questions and the debate's two moderators posing the others, allowed the candidates to move freely around the stage and address the questioners directly.

Hillary Clinton speaks during the second presidential debate at Washington University in St. Louis, on October 9, 2016. Credit: Jim Bourg, AFP

Clinton, 68, and Trump, 70, both stood up to answer questions, and Clinton frequently stood directly in front of the questioners to try to make a connection with voters. At times Trump stood almost over her shoulder, or wandered the stage, while she spoke.

Trump complained about moderators Anderson Cooper of CNN and Martha Raddatz of ABC News, saying the debate was "three on one."

Trump and Clinton clashed on a series of topics throughout the debate, battling over taxes, healthcare, U.S. policy in the Syria civil war and Clinton's comments that half of Trump's supporters belonged in a "basket of deplorables."

"Within hours I said I was sorry about the way I talked about that, because my problem is not with his supporters, it's with him," Clinton said.

Donald Trump speaks during the second presidential debate with Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton at Washington University in St. Louis on Oct. 9, 2016. Credit: Patrick Semansky, AP

Trump said Bernie Sanders never had a chance in the Democratic primary, and was surprised to see him "sign on with the devil" and support Clinton.

Trump, in a badgering tone, offered a blistering critique of Clinton's handling of foreign policy as secretary of state, repeatedly calling it a failure.
"She talks tough, she talks really tough," Trump said. "She talks about the rebels, she doesn't even know who the rebels are."

Taking a breath through his nose with a loud sniff, he continued, "The fact is almost everything she's done in foreign policy has been a mistake and a disaster."

Disagreement with Pence

Trump also said he disagreed with Mike Pence, his vice presidential running mate, who declared last week in his debate against Clinton's No. 2 Tim Kaine that the United States should be prepared to use military force if needed in Syria.

"He and I haven't spoken and I disagree," Trump said.

Trump met just hours before the debate on Sunday with three women who had accused Bill Clinton of sexual misconduct and a fourth woman who was a victim in a rape case that Hillary Clinton participated in as a defense attorney. All four sat in the first row of the audience at the debate.

Before the debate, Trump had threatened he was going to attack Bill Clinton for his marital infidelities in response to criticism from Hillary Clinton that the Republican nominee is a misogynist who has a history of mistreating women.

Trump appeared with Paula Jones, who filed a sexual harassment suit against Bill Clinton in 1991, Juanita Broaddrick, who accused Bill Clinton of rape in 1978, and Kathleen Willey, a former White House aide who accused Bill Clinton of groping her in 1993.

None of the accusations was new. Bill Clinton was never charged in any of the cases, and he settled a sexual harassment suit with one of the women, Paula Jones, for $850,000 with no apology or admission of guilt.

Also at the event was Kathy Shelton, who was raped at the age of 12. Hillary Clinton, a practicing attorney at the time, defended the rapist who ultimately pleaded guilty to a reduced charge.

Clinton's campaign responded to Trump's pre-debate event by calling it a "stunt" and a "destructive race to the bottom."

Asked at the end to name one thing each admired about the other, Clinton said she respected his children for their ability and devotion to Trump. In response, Trump called her a fighter and said he admired her for her refusal to give up.

As the moderators announced the end of the debate, the two candidates turned toward each other and shook hands.

Read below for a minute-by-minute account of the second presidential debate:

LIVE UPDATES (all times EST)

9.03 P.M.: Second presidential debate about to begin. Candidates will be taking questions from the audience and hosts Anderson Cooper and Martha Raddatz.

9.06 P.M.: Presidential candidates Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump take to the stage, begin taking questions from voters.

9:10 P.M.: Trump dismisses claims of sexual assault, calls recent revelations of past remarks "locker room talk."

9:19 P.M. Clinton quotes first lady Michelle Obama: "When they go low, you go high." Says Trump never apologizes for anything or anyone, including the Khan family, Indiana judge, "racist lie that President Obama was not born in the United States of America."

"He owes the country an apology."

9:22 P.M.: Trump accuses Clinton of not winning Democratic primary "fair and square," and takes his rival to task for missing emails.

"There have never been so many lies, so much deception," he says.

9:25 P.M.: Trump to Clinton: If I'll be in charge of law enforcement, "You'd be in jail."

9:37 P.M.: Trump on Islamophobia: "Whether we like it or not, there is a problem."

"She won't even mention a word, and neither will President Obama," Trump says of Clinton. "The name is there: Radical Islamic terror."

Clinton answers that U.S. not at war with Islam, and that Trump's rhetoric is "a gift to ISIS."

9:42 P.M.: Trump says that "Muslim ban" would constitute "extreme vetting," blames Clinton and Obama for influx of refugees.

Speaking of fallen American soldier Humayun Khan, Trump says he is an American hero, adding that if he were president at the time of his service, he would be alive today.

9:46 P.M.: ISIS uses Trump's rhetoric to recruit new members, says Clinton. Trump answers that Clinton has "really bad judgment."

"So bad that she should never be president of the United States."

9:50 P.M.: Clinton on Russian hacking controversy: "Believe me, they are not doing it to get me elected."

Trump answers: "So ridiculous."

9:55 P.M.: Clinton: "It's sort of amusing to hear someone who hasn’t paid federal income taxes in about 20 years talk about what he's going to do."

Shifting from the issue of taxes, Trump says that Clinton "made bad judgment on Syria, on Libya, on Iraq."

"The situation in Syria is catastrophic," Clinton says. "I advocate today a no-fly zone and safe zones."

"I want to emphasize that what is at stake here is the aggressiveness and ambition of Russia," she says, adding that she supports investigating war crimes in Syria.

10:07 P.M.: Trump slams Iran deal, says Russia, Iran and Syria are lined up together because of weak U.S. foreign policy.

10:10 P.M.: Trump slams "the stupidity of what we're doing in the Middle East." Clinton says she wouldn't deploy ground forces in Syria, but is in favor of special forces operating there.

10:13 P.M.: Clinton says she would consider arming the Kurds in both Syria and Iraq, despite it not being popular in all circles.

10:15 P.M.: Trump says "I will be a president for all of our people," says will turn inner cities around, slams NAFTA and accuses Clinton of lying in previous debate, "but she's lied about a lot of things."

10:23 P.M.: Asked whether Trump has discipline, Clinton says no, adding, "It's not only my opinion, it's also the opinion of many others – national security experts, Republicans, former Republicans."

10:25 P.M.: On issue of Supreme Court, Clinton says she wants a Supreme Court that fights for women's rights and that doesn’t always side with major corporations, and blasts Congress for not going through with Obama's candidate for the position.

Trump answers that Second Amendment is under siege by Clinton, says that he would appoint justices who respect the Constitution.

Clinton retorts that "I respect the Second Amendment, but I believe there should be comprehensive background checks."

10:34 P.M.: Asked to name one "positive thing" about one another, the presidential candidates were left stumped. Clinton took the lead, saying that she respects Trump's children.

"I'm very proud of my children," Trump says. "I consider it a compliment."

On Clinton, Trump says that "she doesn’t quit, she doesn’t give up, and I consider that to be a great trait."

10:39 P.M.: Clinton and Trump end debate with handshake.


Click the alert icon to follow topics:



Automatic approval of subscriber comments.

Subscribe today and save 40%

Already signed up? LOG IN


Trump and Netanyahu at the White House in Washington, in 2020.

Three Years Later, Israelis Find Out What Trump Really Thought of Netanyahu

German soldier.

The Rival Jewish Spies Who Almost Changed the Course of WWII

Rio. Not all Jewish men wear black hats.

What Does a Jew Look Like? The Brits Don't Seem to Know

Galon. “I’m coming to accomplish a specific mission: to increase Meretz’s strength and ensure that the party will not tread water around the electoral threshold. If Meretz will be large enough, it will be the basis for a Jewish-Arab partnership.” Daniel Tchetchik

'I Have No Illusions About Ending the Occupation, but the Government Needs the Left'

Soldiers using warfare devices made by the Israeli defense electronics company Elbit Systems.

Russia-Ukraine War Catapults Israeli Arms Industry to Global Stage

Flame and smoke rise during an Israeli air strike, amid Israel-Gaza fighting, in Gaza City August 6, 2022.

Israel Should End Gaza Operation Now, if It Can