Culture Minister Miri Regev speaks to reporter in Tel Aviv, June 6, 2018.
Meged Gozani

Evoking Munich Massacre, Israeli Minister Says Death Threats on Argentina's Messi, Not BDS, Nixed Match

Netanyahu says Argentina cancellation 'disappointing,' warns BDS pressure may lead others to cancel events

Argentina's decision to cancel an exhibition match against the Israeli national soccer team was the result of terrorists' death threats against star player Lionel Messi and his family, Culture Minister Miri Regev said Wednesday. 

Regev blamed the Palestinians for the game's cancellation, accusing them of terrorism, and even evoking the massacre of Israeli Olympians at Munich in 1972 as a comparison.

"This is the same terrorism that led to the murder of eleven slain athletes in Munich," she said. "This is not BDS, but a terrorist incident that intimidates the athletes themselves."

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyanu warned that following Argentina's decision, "there is the possibility that there will be pressure to cancel other events in various areas and we will do as we see fit." 

While Netanyahu did not specifically mention the Eurovision Song Contest, his remarks came soon after a senior Israeli sports and culture official said that the 2019 event might not take place in Jerusalem, despite Israel winning the completion this year.  "Eurovision in Jerusalem? It isn't at all a given," Yossi Sharabi, director-general of the Culture and Sport Ministry, said. 

Argentina Cancels Jerusalem Soccer Match With Israel Following Palestinian Pressure

Regev further dismissed as lies the claims that one of the reasons Argentina cancelled the game was that it was moved from Haifa to Jerusalem. The Argentines never opposed having the game in Jerusalem. This game was born of Messi's desire to visit Jerusalem, kiss the Western Wall and visit the Church of the Holy Sepulchre."  

Regev also ripped into a number of opposition lawmakers, who she said were pleased by the cancellation. "What is your rejoicing about?" she demanded. "That hundreds of thousands of children won't enjoy Messi? What has it come to? If there was a world championship of Schadenfreude, apparently you would win."   

Jibril Rajoub, President of the Palestine Football Association, welcomed the cancellation. "By doing so Argentina refused to be used as a political tool by the Israeli government." Rajoub also said that the game was planned to take place in a stadium built on top of a destroyed Palestinian village. "Thus, the Israeli government tried to use the Argentinian national team to humiliate Palestinian people," he said. 

When soccer turns political

Early Wednesday, the Israeli Embassy in Argentina confirmed that the match had been canceled, citing unspecified "threats and provocations" against Messi.

>> Who Needs BDS: Israel Scores Spectacular Own Goal in Argentina Soccer Fiasco >> If Israel persists, Argentina soccer fiasco will only be the beginning >> The Jewish Doctor Who Helped Save Leo Messi's Career

Argentine media reported that the reason for the cancellation was a series of threats made against Messi and his wife. Argentine sports daily Olé reported that the match was canceled following "threats and controversy."

In a letter on May 28, Palestine Football Association chief Jibril Rajoub  urged the Argentine Football Association to call off the game after it was moved to Jerusalem from Haifa following "political pressure" by the Israeli government. Rajoub specifically mentioned Culture Minister Miri Regev.

"This is a decision that, given the current context, the Palestine Football Association utterly rejects and condemns," Rajoub wrote, adding that Israel was trying to use the match to help celebrate its 70th birthday.

A poster of Palestinian FA chief Jibril Rajoub with Argentina's soccer player Lionel Messi, in Ramallah in the occupied West Bank June 6, 2018
A poster of Palestinian FA chief Jibril Rajoub with Argentina's soccer player Lionel Messi, in Ramallah in the occupied West Bank June 6, 2018 \ MOHAMAD TOROKMAN/ REUTERS

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu spoke with Argentine President Mauricio Macri late Tuesday, at Regev's request, in an attempt to prevent the cancellation. But in a follow-up conversation, Macri told Netanyahu that he could not influence the final decision, sources close to the prime minister said.

>> The week Israelis felt invincible ■ Reality may soon come crashing down on Netanyahu

The Argentine daily Clarín reported that, according to official sources, Macri examined the issue with the Argentine Football Association and learned that "the players don't want to play in Israel because of threats against Messi." Macri apologized to Netanyahu and said the players' motives were not political, the paper said.

A poster in the West Bank city of Hebron urging Messi not to participate in the Argentina-Israel World Cup warm-up match.
A poster in the West Bank city of Hebron urging Messi not to participate in the Argentina-Israel World Cup warm-up match. HAZEM BADER/AFP

Clarín also said Macri had planned to attend the game himself along with   businesspeople from the Argentine Jewish community.

Argentine player Gonzalo Higuaín told ESPN that "they've finally done the right thing. Rationale and health come before everything else. We think it's best not go to Israel."

The Israel Football Association said that it had not yet received official notice about the cancellation and that it has been in "direct contact" with the Argentine Football Association and the soccer world's governing body FIFA. The Israeli association attacked Rajoub, saying that his threats "crossed every red line."

On Sunday, Rajoub urged fans to burn pictures of striker Messi and replicas of his shirt if he played in the match.

Palestinians were not happy that the match would have been held in Jerusalem, and last week Rajoub wrote to Claudio Tapia, the head of the Argentine Football Association, accusing Israel of using the match as a "political tool."

Pressure on Messi and the football association in recent days has included demonstrations in Buenos Aires, and in Barcelona in front of the national team's training camp.

Defense Minister Avigdor Lieberman wrote on Twitter: "It's too bad the soccer knights of Argentina didn't withstand the pressure of the Israel-hating inciters, whose only goal is to impinge on our basic right to self-defense and bring about Israel's destruction. We will not yield to a pack of anti-Semitic terrorist supporters."

Public Security Minister Gilad Erdan also responded to the cancellation. 

"What happened here, truthfully, is less about the boycott. There's a good friendship with Argentina, terrific relations. Due to violent incitement and threats by Jibril Rajoub and the jerseys charade, fears rose about personal safety, and the players started to worry about being physically assaulted in Jerusalem," Erdan told Israel Radio, referring to the burning of Messi jerseys by Palestinians.

"Unfortunately, before they inquired in depth, they preferred to let the whole thing go. This is a submission to violence and terror that the Palestinians are trying to use, but let's look at the big picture and not lose perspective."

Deputy Defense Minister Eli Ben-Dahan said "terrorism must be fought against," calling on Netanyahu to cancel Rajoub's entry permit into Israel. "Rajoub is a despicable enemy," he said. "[Israel] must declare him and the entire Palestinian Authority enemies."

MK Itzik Shmuli (Zionist Union) said: "Instead of soccer, Miri Regev wanted politics and she got politics, and those who will pay the price are the fans who so looked forward to this historic game. It's a great farce that gives immense momentum to the BDS campaign against Israel. Despite everything, we still implore Argentina's players: This is a mistake. Come for the soccer, let go of the politics."

Ayman Odeh, the head of the Joint List of Arab parties, said in a statement: "Netanyahu's government may be gaining Trump, but it's losing the world. You can't just keep enjoying games while the rights of millions of Palestinians are being trampled. There's only one way to win – ending the occupation and a real peace treaty. It's still possible."

MK Haneen Zoabi (Joint List) hailed the Argentines' decision, saying that "holding the match while soldiers butcher the citizens of Gaza is unseemly and may be seen as allowing it."

MK Yousef Jabareen (Joint List) also praised the decision. "The right-wing government has to realize that it cannot crudely trample UN resolutions and the rules of the international court and expect the world to ignore it," he said, referring to the International Criminal Court in The Hague. 

The Argentine national team did not want to play in Israel in the first place but preferred to prepare for the World Cup in Barcelona. The tournament opens on June 14 in Russia.

Argentina coach Jorge Sampaoli said the chances of the Israel team going to Barcelona were small, and Argentina was already seeking another training rival.

Teddy Stadium, which was supposed to host the match, is in West Jerusalem. The match was originally slated to be played in Haifa but Israeli authorities contributed funding for it to be moved to Jerusalem, irking Palestinians further following U.S. President Donald Trump's recognition of the city as Israel's capital. The U.S. Embassy was moved there last month.

On Sunday, Rajoub declared a campaign against Argentina and particularly Messi, noting that he has millions of fans across the Arab and Islamic world. 

"He's a big symbol so we are going to target him personally, and we call on all to burn his picture and his shirt and to abandon him. We still hope that Messi will not come," Rajoub told reporters after leaving the Argentine representative office in the West Bank town of Ramallah.

A small group of youths wearing Palestine soccer scarves demonstrated outside the representation office and tried to set alight an Argentine flag.

Rajoub has long tried to get FIFA and the International Olympic Committee to impose sanctions against Israel. This is mainly because of the Israeli government's settlements policy in the West Bank and because it has imposed travel restrictions on Palestinian athletes citing security concerns. Those bodies have not heeded his calls.

Argentina has made four previous pre-World Cup stopovers in Israel since 1986. The team has been drawn in World Cup Group D and will open its campaign against Iceland in Moscow on June 16.

Most countries do not recognize either Israel's or the Palestinians' sovereignty in Jerusalem and have embassies to Israel in the Tel Aviv area. However, Guatemala and Honduras followed the U.S. lead in moving their embassies last month.


Trending Now


Comments

Required field
Required field

By adding a comment, I agree to this site’s Terms of use

Sign in to join the conversation.