U.S. Man Charged With Aiding Hamas and Threatening Israel Supporters, Trump Tower

In a video Jonathan Xie posted to Instagram, he railed against Zionism, displayed a handgun and said he would 'shoot everybody' at a pro-Israel march

Danielle Ziri
The Associated Press
New York
Share in Facebook
Send in e-mailSend in e-mail
Heavily armed police officers stand guard as a tourist poses for a photo outside Trump Tower, New York, May 16, 2019.
Heavily armed police officers stand guard as a tourist poses for a photo outside Trump Tower, New York, May 16, 2019.Credit: Mary Altaffer,AP
Danielle Ziri
The Associated Press
New York

NEW YORK — A 20-year-old New Jersey man sought to aid the Islamic militant group Hamas and threatened to "shoot everybody" at an unspecified pro-Israel demonstration, federal authorities said Wednesday.

Jonathan Xie was charged with attempting to provide material support to a designated terrorist organization, making false statements and transmitting a threat in interstate commerce. The material support carries a maximum prison sentence of 20 years.

At his initial court appearance Wednesday afternoon, Xie was ordered held without bail. His public defender didn't say whether he would file a motion for a bail hearing.

>> Read more: After San Diego synagogue shooting, U.S. will have to increase online tracking to stop the next murderer | Analysis ■ Liberals, don't celebrate Facebook's ban on anti-Semites and hard right extremists | Opinion 

Xie entered the courtroom in shackles, wearing a green T-shirt and dark sweatpants. His only comments during the brief hearing were to say he understood the judge's instructions.

His parents attended the proceeding but declined to comment afterward.

Xie sent $100 to a person he believed was affiliated with a faction of Hamas last December, and a few days later posted on his Instagram account that he was "pretty sure it was illegal but I don't give a damn," according to a criminal complaint.

The United States has designated Hamas a foreign terrorist organization since 1997.

Xie also allegedly lied on security forms he filled out when he sought to join the U.S. Army by not mentioning the donation.

The U.S. attorney's office also alleged Xie posted on Instagram that he wanted to bomb the Israeli Embassy and Trump Tower in New York.

According to the criminal complaint, a person wearing a black ski mask later identified as Xie said in an Instagram video that he was against "Zionism" and the "neo-liberal establishment." In response to a question, he said he would join Hamas "if I could find a way."

Later in the video, Xie allegedly displayed a handgun and said he was going to go to a pro-Israel march "and I'm going to shoot everybody."

According to the account of a person who interacted online with Xie and later contacted the FBI, Xie said the attack would be at an Al-Quds Day parade, referring to an annual pro-Palestinian event held around the final Friday of Ramadan.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Joyce Malliet said in court Wednesday that authorities believe one of the events is to be held in New York's Times Square on May 31.

After an April trip to Trump Tower in which he was observed by FBI surveillance, according to the complaint Xie posted photos of the building along with his intent to bomb it.

"Okay so I went to NYC today and passed by Trump Tower, then I started thinking about bombing it and I was imagining that the explosion would kill Trump and then I started laughing hysterically," he wrote, according to the complaint. "I forgot to visit the Israeli embassy in NYC ... I want to bomb this place along with Trump Tower."

The Anti-Defamation League praised law enforcement for the arrest, adding this is the first arrest of a U.S. citizen allegedly motivated by Hamas ties in almost a decade.

“This arrest serves as a clear reminder that foreign terror organizations’ violent and hateful ideologies truly have no borders,” said Evan Bernstein, the ADL’s New York and New Jersey regional director.

“Hamas’ hatred of Israel seems to have motivated this individual to target pro-Israel supporters in the United States,” he continued. “This is once again indicative of the need for Jewish communal security, and we applaud law enforcement for this critical arrest.”

Bernstein called on the community to “remain vigilant against extremism and hate from across the ideological spectrum.”

A spokesperson for the Israeli Consulate in New York told Haaretz that the consulate does not comment on security issues, but that it “works very closely with law enforcement and has total confidence in them.”