House Republicans’ unbroken opposition to impeachment is their most unapologetic embrace of President Donald Trump yet, binding them to a president whose loyalty from his party’s core conservative voters is matched only by his opponents’ loathing for him.
Rep. Barry Loudermilk compared Trump’s impeachment to the crucifixion of Jesus Christ in a floor speech in the House ahead of Wednesday’s historic vote.
“When Jesus was falsely accused of treason, Pontius Pilate gave Jesus the opportunity to face his accusers,” the Georgia Republican said. “During that sham trial, Pontius Pilate afforded more rights to Jesus than Democrats have afforded this president and this process.” "Trump to Jesus" began trending on Twitter as social media users quickly turned the statement into a meme.
“December 18, 2019, is another day that will live in infamy,” Congressman Mike Kelly added, comparing the impeachment proceedings to Pearl Harbor.
Trump himself kicked off the bizarre comparisons in his letter to Speaker Pelosi earlier in the week, writing, “More due process was afforded to those accused in the Salem Witch Trials.”
“Oy vey...again," Mayor Kim Driscoll tweeted. “Learn some history: Salem 1692 = absence of evidence+powerless, innocent victims were hanged or pressed to death.”
The Jesus comparison was widely mocked and seemed to go too far even for conservative pundit Ben Shapiro who wrote, “People who have received less due process than President Trump: Jesus, women accused of witchcraft at the Salem trials...actually, most people. This is just an impeachment proceeding and is perfectly legal, even if ill-advised and lacking evidence.”
- Pelosi, in extraordinary move, hints will not refer Trump impeachment to Senate until 'fair' trial guaranteed
- Trump blasts Democrats' 'suicide march' at defiant rally after being impeached
- Trump, Israel and the Middle East: Mayhem, betrayal and 'America First'
The New York Time’s Michelle Goldberg wrote, “Years ago some of us naively hoped that someday the fever would break and a few Republicans would stand up for the republic against a grotesque demagogue. Instead here's one suggesting Trump is more of a martyr than Jesus Christ.”
Journalist Sam Sokol quipped, “So is this the Salem Witch Trials or is this the Crucifixion? Is Trump a witch or is he Jesus? I'm getting confused. My rootless cosmopolitan brain can't handle these high level legal arguments.”
Trump’s GOP in lockstep
Just three months ago, initial revelations of a phone call in which Trump tried squeezing Ukraine’s new president to announce an investigation into Democrats gave a handful of Republicans pause. By Wednesday, the Democratic-led House voted to impeach Trump over unanimous GOP opposition, a moment spotlighting his hold on congressional Republicans and raising questions about the vote’s political impact.
“Trump is strong as a tank with Republicans,” said Rep. Patrick McHenry of North Carolina, a member of the House GOP leadership. He said that along with what he called Democrats’ weak evidence against Trump and unfair impeachment process, “The combination of the three make this one of the easier votes we’ll cast.”
In the short-term, it was moderate Democrats from swing districts who seemed most at risk. Nearly all backed impeachment, which could cost some their careers in next November’s congressional elections. The most vulnerable include several of the 31 Democrats representing districts Trump won in 2016, many of whom are freshmen.
“Today may be the only consequential vote they ever cast, because they won’t be back,” said Rep. Mark Meadows, R-N.C., one of Trump’s staunchest defenders.
But Trump’s Republican critics and Democrats said the House GOP’s solid backing inextricably bound Republican lawmakers to Trump and would ultimately inflict a damaging blow.
“You can play to the base and excite the base and turn an election here and there, but that’s not a long-term strategy. Demographics will take care of that” as anti-Trump younger, diverse voters join the electorate, said former Sen. Jeff Flake, R-Ariz., who declined to seek reelection last year after clashing with Trump for years. “There will be a time when we Republicans wake up from this and say, ’We did this for this man?’”
“I don’t think the Republican Party nationally really exists anymore. It is now the Trump party,” said Rep. Kurt Schrader, D-Ore. “When he goes at some point, it will be interesting to see how they define themselves, what they stand for.”
In Trump’s past pivotal fights — including his failed effort to repeal former President Barack Obama’s health care law — congressional Republicans strongly rallied behind him, but there were small but significant numbers of defectors.
A handful of Republican lawmakers had expressed concern when word of Trump’s pressuring Ukraine first emerged in September. While stopping short of abandoning him, several initially took a middle-ground position, saying they wanted to learn more about what happened.
Wednesday’s unanimous GOP vote came after party leaders held numerous impeachment briefings for lawmakers. Those sessions were aimed at making sure they were “getting information to people,” said No. 2 House GOP leader Steve Scalise of Louisiana.
Rep. Francis Rooney, R-Fla., said early on that he wanted to learn more about what happened with Ukraine. After saying he was open to impeachment — and announcing his retirement the next day — he said Wednesday he was opposing impeachment after “agonizing over it” and deciding there was insufficient evidence to justify Trump’s removal.
Rooney said Wednesday’s vote further aligns his party to Trump.
“And that’s not necessarily the Republican Party that I’ve been a part of and been a funder for, for many years,” he said. “This is a different era that we’re in for Republicans, and I don’t know where it’s going to go.”
With the impeachment vote coming just 11 months before the next presidential and congressional elections, Republicans said they believed it was Democrats who would be hurt.
“Pelosi has made this the party of impeachment,” Scalise said of Democrats led by Speaker Nancy Pelosi of California. ”Clearly this has been a personal vendetta they’ve been carrying out to please their most radical base.”
“What we’re defining ourselves as is defenders of the Constitution,” said Rep. Lynn Cheney, R-Wyo., another member of House GOP leadership. Asked if it was risky for the GOP to unanimously align itself with Trump, she said, “There is absolutely zero peril for the Republican Party to align itself with the Constitution.’’
One freshman Democrat from a closely divided district is Rep. Abigail Spanberger of Virginia, who is supporting impeachment.
“It’s about the presidency and I think it’s about upholding rule of law,” she said when asked how the GOP’s solid support for Trump would affect that party’s reputation. “So their conscience and their oaths are their own to consider.”
Peter Wehner, a Republican who served in the White House under GOP Presidents Ronald Reagan, George H.W. Bush and George W. Bush, said the Republican vote against impeaching Trump would only strengthen the “absolute headlock” he has on his party.
“For some period of time, the brand is going to be the Trump brand, which is divisive, misogynistic and unethical,” Wehner said. “The trouble for Republicans is that brand, the searing impression it’s going to leave, is going to be most vivid for the rising generation of voters.”