Hubble Telescope Detects Giant Storm Forming on Neptune

Unlike Jupiter’s Great Red Spot, the storms on Neptune – featuring methane ice clouds – will last up to six years, not centuries

Send in e-mailSend in e-mail
Go to comments
composite picture shows images of storms on Neptune from the Hubble Space Telescope (left) and the Voyager 2 spacecraft (right)
Composite shows storms on Neptune taken by the Hubble (left) and Voyager 2 (right). White is methane clouds.Credit: NASA/ESA/GSFC/JPL
Ruth Schuster
Ruth Schuster
Ruth Schuster
Ruth Schuster

Planetary gas giants have epic storms, as everybody and his dog knows from Jupiter’s Great Red Spot, a vast anticyclonic storm with a bigger diameter than Earth. That red spot has been there for at least 190 years, and possibly 350 or more. It may actually have been spotted by the English proto-scientist Robert Hook in 1664, or not. But the solid planets have their weather issues too, and now the Hubble Space Telescope has caught footage of the actual formation of a gigantic storm in space, this time on Neptune.

Pictures of the storm were published Monday in Geophysical Research Letters by lead author Amy Simon, a planetary scientist at NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center in Maryland and the team. It is the first time that astronomers have spotted the formation of a Great Dark Spot on Neptune, Simon says. Actually the spot was first observed in 2018 but is only now being reported.

Though Neptune is an ice giant, not a gas one, and is dense to boot – storms on in the Neptunian atmosphere form like the Red Spot arose on Jupiter: areas of high atmospheric pressure deep in Neptune’s atmosphere, says the team. On Earth, storms famously form around areas of low pressure.

Why exactly are we comparing storms on Jupiter with storms on Neptune, given that the first is a gas giant and the second an ice giant?

A view of the first Great Dark Spot scientists observed on Neptune.
A view of the first Great Dark Spot scientists observed on Neptune.Credit: NASA

“Because the storms are formed by the same mechanism,” Lauren Lipuma of the American Geophysical Union explains to Haaretz. Even if it has ice at its core, while Jupiter isn’t thought to: “Neptune has a thick gas atmosphere that allows these storms to form,” she says.

The cyclic motion of the Great Red Spot imaged by the Cassini spacecraft. Unlike on Neptune, Thin jet streams on Jupiter keep the Great Red Spot from breaking apart and from changing latitude; it rotates around Jupiter but doesn’t move north or south
The cyclic motion of the Great Red Spot imaged by the Cassini spacecraft. Unlike on Neptune, Thin jet streams on Jupiter keep the Great Red Spot from breaking apart Credit: NASA

Neptune changes its spots

Neptune has quite the weather issue. Six dark spots have been observed there so far: The Voyager 2 spacecraft saw two in 1989, and Hubble, launched in 1990, has spotted four more.

“If you study the exoplanets and you want to understand how they work, you really need to understand our planets first,” said Simon. “We have so little information on Uranus and Neptune.”

Understanding blueish Neptune is probably a good way to start. If the Earth is 150 million kilometers from the sun, and Jupiter is almost 780 million kilometers, Neptune is a far, far 4.5 billion kilometers. It is very cold out there.

In contrast to the Great Red Spot, the storms on Neptune may be foul, but they are relatively fleeting. That one on Jupiter has been there for centuries, at least: two seen on Neptune by Voyager 2, the Great Dark Spot – which was the size of Earth – and Dark Spot 2, which was smaller than our wee planet, had passed within five years.

Jupiter's Great Red Spot
Jupiter's Great Red SpotCredit: NASA, ESA, and Amy Simon

“It was certainly a surprise,” Simon said. “We were used to looking at Jupiter’s Great Red Spot, which presumably had been there for more than a hundred years.” 

The Neptunian skies have high-altitude clouds not made of water vapor but of methane ice crystals. Scientists suspect these methane clouds accompany the storms that form the dark spots on Neptune, hovering above them the way lenticular clouds cap tall mountains on Earth, says the American Geophysical Union: Simon and co-authors Michael Wong and Andrew Hsu at Berkeley found that the clouds were brightest just before the giant storms formed.

By the standards of the giants, the storms on Earth are fleeting: If one sticks around for a week, we worry, and our storms do seem to be moving more slowly thanks to climate change. The scientists calculate that storms on Neptune typically last two to six years. But then our orbital period – our year – is 365 days, fleeting compared with Neptune’s, which is 60,225 days (165 years by our count). That planet is not rotating at warp speed.

false-color image of the Great Red Spot of Jupiter from Voyager 1
A false-color image of the Great Red Spot of Jupiter from Voyager 1. The white oval storm directly below the Great Red Spot (right bottom) has about the same diameter as Earth.Credit: NASA, Caltech/JPL

Many questions remain, but as storms on Earth pick up in intensity thanks to global warming, inquiring minds (at NASA at least) wonder about wind velocities in Neptunian storms.

“We have never directly measured winds within Neptune’s dark vortices, but we estimate the wind speeds are in the ballpark of 328 feet (100 meters) per second, quite similar to wind speeds within Jupiter’s Great Red Spot,” said Wong. That is a lot faster than wind speeds here.

Comments