Opinion

Instead of Denouncing a 'Zionist in the Prophet's House!', Muslims Should Welcome Israeli Jews to Mecca

When Arab social media accused an Israeli Jew who posted selfies of himself in mosques in Medina of being a Saudi stooge, impure Jew and a Zionist spy, there was one epithet they forgot: Human being in search of grassroots contact

Ben Tzion, the Israeli Jewish blogger who's just visited Saudi Arabia's mosques and posted Instagram and Facebook posts with pictures about his visit – and set off a huge Arabic media storm
From Ben Zion's Facebook profile

A photo of a smiling man dressed in a traditional Arab thawb, keffiyeh and agal while standing in the middle of the Prophets Mosque in Medina, Islams second holiest site, has sparked massive online outrage from some Arabs and Muslims, from Saudi Arabia to Pakistan to Indonesia.

Thats because the man in question, who has posted his photo posing with a bag emblazoned with Hebrew letters reading 'Ben Tzion', is not a Muslim worshipper but an Israeli Jewish blogger.

Instagram, where Ben Tzion had been chronicling his escapades, suspended his account, he claims, on Tuesday, and the account is, at the time of writing, no longer active, following a deluge of angry comments.

Under the hashtag #صهيوني_بالحرم_النبوي'  ('#Zionist in the Sanctuary of the Prophet'), numerous Arab Twitter users have posted over 100,000 comments expressing severe criticism of Saudi Arabia for allegedly breaking the Arab boycott of Israel, seeing Ben Tzion's visit as proof of a further escalation of the kingdoms apparent attempts to normalize relations with Israel. 

Some took it as an opportunity to spew bigoted anti-Jewish sentiment. "Umar Ibn Al-Khattab...expelled Jews from madina [sic] 1400 years ago and now Saudi government are [sic] allowing them back again," wrote one Twitter user.

The incident became a battleground in the ongoing Gulf propaganda war between Qatar and a Saudi-led alliance which has laid it under siege, supporters of which have accused Qatar of being an Israeli stooge

"You prohibit Qataris from entering it but you allowed your cousin, the Jew, to enter," wrote one Qatari user. 

The truth is most Gulf countries have been discreetly cultivating relations with Israel for many years now.

Despite (false) allegations that the Israeli blogger was on an officially sanctioned visit and that the Saudis had knowingly let him enter, Ben Tzion himself maintains otherwise. Speaking to BBC Arabic, he said that his trip, for which he used an undisclosed non-Israeli passport, was a private visit, to visit Saudi friends he had got to know in college in America (on a previous visit, he had visited a college friend in Iran).

BBC Arabic interview with Ben Tzion BBC Arabic

In a telephone interview with the Times of Israel, Ben Tzion explained that the visit to Saudi Arabia was part of a regional 'goodwill tour' which also took him to Iran and Lebanon, both of which Israel defines as 'enemy states', prohibiting its citizens from travelling there, on pain of possible but unlikely prosecution - unless they happen to be political dissidents or Palestinians.

This two-sided rejection might be the reason why Ben Tzion keeps his full name and current location under wraps. In fact, a source close to the Times of Israel informed me that, although Ben Tzion occasionally blogs for the online news site, nobody there has met him in person.

Of Russian origin, Ben Tzion grew up in the United States, where he graduated from Babson College, a prestigious business school, and worked in real estate in the Boston area – he holds American, Russian and Israeli citizenship.

"No one in the Arab world ever approached me with hostility," Ben Tzion told the Times of Israel. "Among regular people, there is no hatred. I was in Beirut two weeks ago – theres no hatred, people are friendly."

This revelation will shock, even dismay, many Israelis, many of whom, I have learnt through years of interaction, are convinced they would be lynched upon entering Palestinian neighbourhoods of Jerusalem, yet alone travelling deep into 'hostile' Arab territory. This is especially the case amongst Israeli Jews, who equate contact with Arabs as a form of betrayal and self-hatred aimed at the destruction of the Jewish state by other means.

But such contact highlights the importance of direct, grassroots people-to-people contact. It helps demystify and humanize the other side. While by itself this won't solve the complex issues at the heart of the decades-old Israeli-Palestinian conflict, understanding and empathy are vital prerequisites to eventual resolution.

Muslim pilgrims take a selfie at Mount Al-Noor, in the holy city of Mecca, Saudi Arabia August 28, 2017
SUHAIB SALEM/REUTERS

Many Arabs will protest that this contact whitewashes the Israeli mistreatment of Palestinians and normalizes the occupation. In my view, a distinction must be made between private, independent Israeli citizens and activists, and representatives of the state or members of organizations affiliated with the state or defending its crimes – and this distinction should be incorporated into the Arab boycott.

This does not mean that Arabs have to agree with Israelis or turn on the Palestinians. It simply means that they need to engage with Israelis and assist their Palestinian brethren in making their case.

Some Arab activists will counter that the boycott is effective and is working, as evidenced by the panicked anti-BDS legislations and activities of the Israeli state, including the entry ban on pro-boycott foreigners passed in March and the decision earlier this month to deny entry to a delegation of European parliamentarians and officials who had intended to visit jailed Palestinian leader Marwan Barghouti.

However, the limited successes BDS has scored lull activists into a false sense of confidence. Even though Israel has become the subject of greater social and political opposition in Europe, this has scarcely made a dent in its economy and, as protection against possible - but unlikely - European sanctions, Israel has actively nurtured deepening ties with Asian and African states.

Moreover, the current situation empowers extremists, who increasingly call the shots, and opportunists, who take advantage of the chaos.

While principled Arab activists and citizens refuse to reach out to ordinary Israelis, the de facto Netanyahu oligarchical dictatorship is forging ever-deepening ties with equally unscrupulous Arab despots and dictators. And they are doing so not in the interest of peace, justice and security, but to further their own self-interest through conflict and war, injustice and insecurity.

Muslims pray at the Grand mosque ahead of the annual Haj pilgrimage in Mecca, Saudi Arabia August 29, 2017
SUHAIB SALEM/REUTERS

Another feature of the Arab backlash on social media was its promotion of the idea that a non-Muslim entering an Islamic sacred site was somehow impure or contaminating. "In the era of Al Saud [the Saudi royal family], the occupying Zionists, enemies of Islam and Muslims defile the mosque of the seal of the Prophet," said one Twitter user.

As someone who has entered the holiest sites of many other religions, I find this attitude bigoted and intolerant. While there are plenty of mosques, including the fourth holiest in Islam, the Great Mosque of Kairouan (Tunisia), which permit non-Muslims to enter, Mecca, Islams most sacred city, is the exclusive domain of Muslims.

This is completely unacceptable morally and counterproductive on culturally and political grounds. Allowing non-Muslims into Islams most sacred heart would open up its soul to the rest of humanity.

Grassroots contacts founded on principles and dialogue are not simply about paving the way to a better tomorrow – they are also about sidestepping a worse and more destructive future from sucking our region even deeper into the abyss.

Khaled Diab is an award-winning writer, journalist and blogger. He is the author of two books, Islam for the Politically Incorrect (2017) and Intimate Enemies: Living with Israelis and Palestinians in the Holy Land (2014). Twitter: @DiabolicalIdea