A Decade On, Splintered Coalition Reflects Fate of Egypt's Uprising

Ten years later, some former leading members of the Revolution Youth Coalition that drew together the uprising's disparate strands and social justice demands are in prison, others are in exile. Here are some of their stories

Send in e-mailSend in e-mail
Send in e-mailSend in e-mail
On the left, Egyptians rally at Tahrir Square in downtown Cairo February 1, 2011. On the right, a general view shows Tahrir Square, after its renovation on July 13, 2020.
On the left, Egyptians rally at Tahrir Square in downtown Cairo February 1, 2011. On the right, a general view shows Tahrir Square, after its renovation on July 13, 2020.Credit: (L): Amr Abdallah Dalsh, (R): Mohamed Abd El Ghany / Reuters

Ten years ago protesters surged onto Egypt's streets, emboldened by the success of Tunisia's Arab Spring uprising.

Some young activists formed the Revolution Youth Coalition to draw together the uprising's disparate strands and give the protesters occupying Cairo's Tahrir Square a coherent voice.

Why Bibi won't stand up to ultra-Orthodox COVID scofflaws: LISTEN

-- : --

They demanded freedom, dignity, democracy and social justice amid battles with police and state-hired thugs, and on February 11 President Hosni Mubarak resigned.

But the coalition fragmented as it faced two much more established forces: the Muslim Brotherhood that swept to power in later elections, and the military that toppled it in 2013.

Egypt now faces a different landscape. Abdel-Fattah al-Sissi, who became president in 2014 after leading the overthrow of the Brotherhood's Mohammed Morsi, has overseen a crackdown that activists call the harshest for decades.

Sissi says in response that he has brought stability, allowing the country to move on from the turmoil that followed 2011. Officials did not respond to a request for further comment.

Sissi has referred to the uprising as a "great revolution" while blaming it for unleashing economic disruption and security problems. Tahrir Square has been redesigned, and a new capital is being built in the desert.

Some former leading members of the coalition are in prison, some are in exile. One is a pro-Sissi member of parliament. Here are some of their stories:

Islam Lotfy, a former member of the Muslim Brotherhood and Egypt's Revolution Youth Coalition, looks on in his office in London, Britain, March 19, 2018. Credit: Ahmed Abou Husain / Handout via Reuters

Islam Lotfy

A senior member of the Muslim Brotherhood's student division as the uprising started, Islam Lotfy was dismissed from the movement later that year as youth members split with the more hesitant senior leadership.

Lotfy, 42, left Egypt in 2013 amid a crackdown on those associated with the Brotherhood, and now works in television production from London.

Egypt has placed him on a terrorist list and frozen his assets. Many of his former political companions are in jail, he says.

"Personally we are in a difficult position but we will keep fighting," he said. "My mother got dementia and she's very old, and I didn't get a chance to be beside her or to visit her."

He is marking the 10th anniversary of the uprising by contacting fellow activists outside Egypt "and trying to build a real political movement."

"What we are calling for, it doesn't disappear because we are not here or because we are in jails or because we are in exile."

Bassem Kamel, a leading representative of the Revolution Youth Coalition during Egypt's 2011 uprising and former parliament member, looks on during an interview with Reuters, Cairo, January 12, 2021. Credit: Sayed Sheasha / Reuters

Bassem Kamel

Bassem Kamel was active in liberal opposition politics in Mubarak's final years in power.

After the uprising he co-founded the Egyptian Social Democratic Party and was elected to a short-lived parliament. By June 2013 he was among the organizers of anti-Brotherhood protests.

His optimism at Morsi's fall quickly turned to concern that civilians were being sidelined by the military.

Now 51, he remains deputy head of his party, which gained seven seats in parliament by joining an election list headed by a strongly pro-Sissi party. But he didn't take a seat, dividing his time between party activities and the interior decoration company he owns in Cairo.

"There is no political life, really. There is a very, very limited margin for political or party activity, and in light of that I'm there," he said during an interview at his office.

"Change must come from cumulative work and organization, long-term persistence."

Sally Toma, a Coptic Christian and former member of the Revolution Youth Coalition, speaks during an interview with Reuters in Cairo, January 20, 2021. Credit: Sayed Sheasha / Reuters

Sally Toma 

Doctor Sally Toma remembers being chased out of Tahrir Square on Jan. 25, 2011 and watching in awe as protesters moved to reclaim it three days later.

A representative of Egypt's Coptic Christians in the coalition, she continued protesting until 2013, campaigning against both the military and the Muslim Brotherhood.

"Agreeing to bring down a regime is one thing and then agreeing on how to build is another, and you had a counterrevolution working against you from the very start," she said in an interview.

Now 42 and a practicing psychiatrist, she says most of her companions are in detention or exile and those who remain are trying to survive the trauma of the past decade.

An informal network from the "revolutionary camp" works discreetly on human rights issues, she says.

Toma says she still meets people who profess attachment to the uprising and its goals.

"Revolutions don't just happen like that like and then die. Seeds are there and you find them in the strangest of places."

Tarek el-Khouly, a lawyer who joined the April 6 opposition movement pre-2011, looks on during an interview with Reuters in Cairo, January 21, 2021. Credit: Sayed Sheasha / Reuters

Tarek El-Khouly

Lawyer Tarek el-Khouly blames the Brotherhood for undermining the uprising by seeking to impose Islamic rule. He backed the overthrow of Morsi in 2013, seeing it as an extension and "correction" of 2011.

Khouly, 35, was re-elected last year to a second five-year term in parliament after joining the pro-Sissi Nation's Future party.

"Ten years ago, I was among the thousands of young people who participated in this great revolution that called for bread, freedom and social justice. I believe that we are in the middle of the road," he said in an interview.

Security measures post-2013 were needed to prevent militant attacks, and those jailed for social media posts were inciting crimes, he said.

Tens of thousands of civil society organizations are allowed to operate in Egypt, he added, praising government efforts to improve living conditions and saying parliament was gaining strength as an expression of popular will.

Shay el-Ghazaly Harb

A surgeon active in opposition politics before the uprising, Shady el-Ghazaly Harb was jailed from 2018-2020 on charges of spreading false news and joining a terrorist organization, accusations frequently levelled at opposition figures.

Harb, 42, believes he was arrested due to social media posts critical of government policies. He has returned to his Cairo clinic but remains suspended from a university teaching job.

"I moved away completely from political participation not just because of the risk of prison but because the political climate and the political field are not encouraging any political participation whatsoever," he said.

The priority now is pressing to get detainees released. But he believes the uprising's ideas have lived on, both in protests in Sudan, Algeria and Lebanon, and in Egypt itself.

"It changed the collective consciousness of a nation of 100 million," he said.

Click the alert icon to follow topics: