Israeli Orthodox Rabbis Draft Document Aimed at Homosexual Inclusion

Beit Hillel document 'sets forth guidelines,' based on halakhah, 'to contain people with a homosexual orientation within faith communities.'

Participants walk near the Knesset, the Israeli parliament, during a gay pride parade in Jerusalem.
Reuters

An Orthodox rabbinic organization in Israel has drafted a set of guidelines meant to help religious communities deal with gay and lesbian members, in an apparent effort to be more inclusive. 

The document by the nonprofit Beit Hillel, a rabbinical group of 200 members that promotes inclusiveness in Orthodox Judaism, “sets forth guidelines, which are founded in halakhah, on how to contain people with a homosexual orientation within faith communities,” director Rabbi Shlomo Hecht told JTA Friday, using the Hebrew-language word for Jewish religious law.

Successful “containment,” he said, would help “people with a homosexual orientation to feel more comfortable within their Orthodox faith community.”

The document is set for publication Sunday at a conference titled “Halakha and containment – the religious community’s relations to homosexuals” in the city of Raanana, near Tel Aviv. Between 100 and 200 people are expected to attend the conference, which will feature discussions on the document and the issue of Orthodox homosexuals. 

Hecht said his group stopped short of endorsing rabbinical officiation of any ceremonies that would, in the eyes of mainstream Orthodoxy, violate halakhah, including gay marriages. 

“We’re not recognizing any sort of homosexual unions – I mean, they exist, we don’t deny reality, but we don’t sanction them in an official form in the document,” he said. But the document does specify a number of halachic principles related to the need “to contain homosexuals within faith communities and make them feel at ease in their community.”

Hecht declined to answer specific questions about the document prior to its publication.

He said the document was created in response to the fact “that homosexuals choose increasingly to remain within faith communities, which in the past they would leave because of their orientation. It used to be that you were either religious [Orthodox] or homosexual, but now you have both.” This change “creates a need for a halachic document that cements some principles for the relationship.”

The founding director of Beit Hillel, established in 2012 by religious Zionist rabbis, was Rabbi Ronen Neubert, who also worked for the Tzohar rabbinical group, which aims to make Orthodox Judaism more accessible to secular and progressive Israelis. Hecht replaced Neubert last year.