A Tale of Jewish Sibling Rivalry, in the Style of British Politics

Respectively foreign minister and energy minister in the recently ousted government of Gordon Brown, David and Ed Miliband are now running against each other to lead the Labour Party.

J.J. Goldberg, The Forward
Send in e-mailSend in e-mail
J.J. Goldberg, The Forward

Perfectly timed to the publication this month of Trials of the Diaspora, Anthony Juliuss searing history of antisemitism in Britain, comes a new and unprecedented challenge that is tearing British Jews apart. Well, two British Jews, anyway: the Miliband brothers, David and Ed.

Former British foreign and energy ministers, David and Ed Miliband, are running against each other to lead the Labour Party Credit: Getty

Respectively foreign minister and energy minister in the recently ousted government of Gordon Brown, theyre now running against each other to succeed Brown as leader of the Labour Party. Talk about your sibling rivalry.

The Milibands simultaneous ministerial service was considered one for the history books; theyre among a tiny handful of brothers ever to serve together in a British Cabinet, and the first since the Stanley brothers in 1938. But their current competition for party leadership, a possible stepping stone to the prime ministers office, leaves observers groping for an analogy. The only parallel I can think of is the Williams sisters rivalry in tennis, said a leading London journalist who is friendly with both brothers.

At the time this column was written (May 18), they were the only declared candidates in the race, though other candidates are expected to join them soon. Still, odds-makers say that one or the other Miliband brother is likely to win in the fall, regardless of who else weighs in. And, given the fragility of the newly-formed governing coalition between the wildly incompatible Conservatives and Liberal Democrats, theres a decent chance that new elections will be called within a year and a Miliband will emerge as prime minister.

Sons of Polish Holocaust survivors, the Milibands have emerged in the last few years as two of Britains fastest-rising political figures — and, ironically, as senior leaders of the Labour Partys warring factions, the market-friendly Tony Blair faction and the union-allied Brown faction. David Miliband, 44, the better-known brother, served for two decades as Blairs top policy aide, playing a key role in drafting Blairs post-socialist New Labour platform. In 2006 Blair made him environmental affairs minister, heading up the climate-change effort that Blair hoped to make his final signature cause. Brown, succeeding Blair in 2007, made Miliband his foreign minister partly as a unity gesture and partly to keep him on a short leash.

Ed Miliband, 40, a newcomer on the national scene, was an aide to Brown in the Treasury during the Blair years. He joined the Cabinet for the first time in 2008 — in charge, ironically, of energy and climate change, essentially his big brothers old portfolio. Hes hardly in his brothers shadow, though. Telegenic and gregarious in public, he poses a sharp contrast to the stiff, wonkish David. Hes also popular in both factions, while David is widely disliked by the Brownites. Insiders say Ed might end up eclipsing David as the partys new star.

Some thoughtful readers might think it odd that British Labour, the party of the left in a country where left-wing anti-Zionism is increasingly indistinguishable from old-fashioned Jew-hatred, might choose a Jew as its standard-bearer. Sure, some will say that the two brothers are simply the latest in a long line of deracinated Jewish leftists all too willing to turn on their own people. There are whispers to that effect in some corners of the British Jewish community these days. Critics rarely fail to mention that the Milibands father was the late Ralph Miliband, often described as the leading Marxist theoretician of the postwar era, a founder of the New Left Review and other radical publications.

David Miliband is regularly criticized for actions as foreign minister, including the British decision to require that retailers label products made in West Bank settlements, to distinguish them from Israeli products that enjoy certain trade benefits. Miliband is also criticized for his very public display of anger, including the expulsion of the Israeli Mossads London station chief, after an assassination team that killed a Hamas operative in Dubai in January was found to be using counterfeited British passports. The low point in his relations with the established Jewish community came last December, when he met with a group of community leaders to discuss Middle East policy and mistakenly referred to the Israeli government as your government.

But friends paint out a different picture of the Milibands. For starters, its no secret that Ralph, the father, was first introduced to Marxism as a member of the left-wing Zionist group Hashomer Hatzair in his teens in Belgium, where his Polish Jewish family had settled after World War I. Friends go on to note that Davids two sons are named Isaac and Jacob, hardly signs of Marranism.

It was David, as foreign minister, who took the unprecedented step of appointing a strongly affirming Jewish diplomat, Matthew Gould, as British ambassador to Israel. Hes due to take up his post this fall. David also chose Ivan Lewis, who headed the Manchester Jewish Federation before running for Parliament, as his deputy in charge of Middle East affairs. Hes taken a lot of heat from the anti-Israel left for both decisions.

More personally, David took time during an official visit to Poland last June to meet with the planning team of the Museum of the History of Polish Jews, and made a highly publicized visit to the Warsaw Jewish cemetery where much of his family is buried. In a speech, he thanked the Poles who had saved his mother from the Nazis and noted that, but for luck, he might have been a victim.

Ed Miliband had his own family moment last October, during a working visit to Moscow. Appearing on a radio call-in show, he received a call from a woman named Sofia Davidovna Miliband, who identified herself as his cousin and last living relative in Russia. Officials tried to cut her off, assuming it was a hoax, but Miliband sought her out and paid her a visit at home, standing up a diplomatic reception to learn about his family.

Both Milibands vow if elected to reunite the Labour Party, torn by years of bitter rivalry between the Brown and Blair factions. Each calls the other his best friend. Each promises to tap the other as an adviser upon winning. Both insist the campaign wont interfere with their close family bond — though David recently told a reporter to ask me again in September. Both brothers must surely be hoping that the public wont judge their unifying skills by their handling of relations within their own family.

Sibling rivalry? You aint seen nothin yet.



Automatic approval of subscriber comments.
From $1 for the first month

Already signed up? LOG IN


Charles Lindbergh addressing an America First Committee rally on October 3, 1941.

Ken Burns’ Brilliant ‘The U.S. and the Holocaust’ Has Only One Problem

The projected rise in sea level on a beach in Haifa over the next 30 years.

Facing Rapid Rise in Sea Levels, Israel Could Lose Large Parts of Its Coastline by 2050

Tal Dilian.

As Israel Reins in Its Cyberarms Industry, an Ex-intel Officer Is Building a New Empire

Queen Elizabeth II, King Charles III and a British synagogue.

How the Queen’s Death Changes British Jewry’s Most Distinctive Prayer

Newly appointed Israeli ambassador to Chile, Gil Artzyeli, poses for a group picture alongside Rabbi Yonatan Szewkis, Chilean deputy Helia Molina and Gerardo Gorodischer, during a religious ceremony in a synagogue in Vina del Mar, Chile last week.

Chile Community Leaders 'Horrified' by Treatment of Israeli Envoy

Queen Elizabeth attends a ceremony at Windsor Castle, in June 2021.

Over 120 Countries, but Never Israel: Queen Elizabeth II's Unofficial Boycott