Expert: Ammonia Tank in Haifa Bay Could 'Fall Apart Tomorrow Morning,' Kill 16,000 People

'There are four problematic points in the tank,' Prof. Ehud Keinan tells press, after unveiling report on dangers of direct hit to ammonia ship.

Hagay Frid

An internationally renowned chemist has warned that an ammonia tank in the Haifa bay could "fall apart even tomorrow morning," killing over ten thousand people.

"There are four problematic points in the tank. One at the bottom, two on top – less dangerous – and one in the middle. If the tank falls apart we're talking about 16 thousand dead. If we're talking about a hit to the ammonia ship – many more," Prof. Ehud Keinan told a press conference at the Haifa city hall, where the report was revealed to the public.

“This tank should have already undergone three internal checks, inluding the empying of the tank. There’s no such thing that there’s no cracks, the questions is how they advance,” he said. “We’re talking about the biggest threat in the Middle East – where’s the Environmental Protection Ministry?”

Haifa Mayor Yona Yahav said on Tuesday that "had this tank been on Dizengoff, it would have been long gone," referring to a central Tel Aviv street. "This is a matter of life or death. A million people are in danger in the bay, two million are in danger from the sea."

He also demanded that the cabinet convene to discuss the report's findings. 

The warning came a day after it was revealed that a report warning against the danger posed by an attack on the ship that brings ammonia to Israel on a monthly basis was filed several months ago with the Supreme Court. 

According to the report, prepared by a team of scientists under the leadership of Prof. Ehud Keinan, such an attack could kill tens of thousands of people, as a result of a chemical reaction between liquid ammonia and seawater.

A ship brings ammonia to Israel about once a month. It docks at Haifa’s Kishon Port, and it takes most of a day to unload the cargo to the storage facility. The ship carries 16,700 tons of liquid ammonia, 10,000 tons of which are off-loaded in Haifa.

The ammonia on the ship is carried in five storage tanks. According to Keinan, damage to a single tank could cause a disaster whose effects could exceed that of the atom bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in World War II. If all five storage tanks were to be compromised, the resultant deadly cloud of ammonia could cover the Haifa area for at least eight hours: Every person in the danger zone would choke to death within one hour, according to the paper prepared by Keinan.

Haaretz has learned that when the opinion was submitted to the court, a summary of the document was sent to the prime minister and other Israeli officials, in a classified letter.

In a statement, the Prime Minister’s Office confirmed that it had received the letter and forwarded it to the National Security Council, adding that its contents were “discussed with the professionals who deal with ammonia and a response was sent to the letter’s sender and to the mayor of Haifa.”

A person who is involved in the search for an alternative location for the ammonia storage facility said that a proposal to move it to the Eilat-Ashkelon Pipeline Company facility near Ashdod was rejected because of the risks involved in the ammonia delivery ship docking at Ashdod Port, not far from the Gaza Strip. 

“They said that the fact that the boat stands there for a full day is very dangerous because Qassam rockets could be fired at it,” said the source, who was speaking on condition of anonymity, adding that during those hours, “it is more dangerous than any storage tank.”

According to a report submitted to the Environmental Protection Ministry in December 2011, of the 120,000 tons of ammonia that are brought to Israel every year, some 80 percent is used in the making of fertilizer – the vast majority of which is exported.

The ministry report notes that the U.S.-owned Haifa Chemicals uses 70 percent of Israel’s ammonia imports, with Israel Chemicals using the remaining 30 percent.

“The storage tank is a problem, and that’s the only problem anyone has addressed until now, but the real problem is the ship,” said a second anonymous source.

“The state takes the side of Haifa Chemicals,” the source added. “Again and again [Haifa Chemicals] use the same false excuse that Israel needs the ammonia and can’t manage without ammonia. It’s a lie. Ninety-five percent of the ammonia imported to Israel is meant for fertilizer and other products that are sold. It’s purely about business. Nothing will happen to Israel if this business doesn’t exist, other than there will be a plant that won’t run and workers who won’t work. It’s not pleasant when a factory closes, but nothing will happen to Israel’s functioning.”

This source addressed a failed attempt by the Environmental Protection Ministry to solicit bids to build an ammonia factory in the Negev to replace the Haifa Bay storage facility, which the state has promised to retire. He said the five percent of the imported ammonia that Israel needs, for Israel Electric Corporation, hospitals and cooling facilities, “could be made easily. You don’t even need a factory, there are machines you can buy off the shelf.”

In fact, said the source, the problem is that Israel’s ammonia consumption, excluding the amounts that are used in making fertilizer for export, is so low that it isn’t profitable to produce. “Until 1983 they made ammonia here. This claim of ‘for the people and the state’ is simply a lie,” said the source.

A senior army officer said recently that the ability of Hamas and, in particular, Hezbollah, to develop and acquire rockets and highly accurate missiles is “the most significant threat.” 

Hezbollah operates a system of rockets and advanced surface-to-surface missiles, and now has 10 times as many rockets as it had on the eve of the Second Lebanon War in 2006.

Hezbollah has about 130,000 rockets of various types: Grad, with a range of up to 40 kilometers; Fajr (75 kilometers), Iranian Zelzal missiles (200 kilometers), Fateh and M-110 (250 kilometers) and the Syrian Scud-D missile (up to 700 kilometers).

Hezbollah also has diverse launching options: underground launchers, launchers hidden in “nature reserves” and mobile launchers on trucks and commercial vehicles. The Israel Defense Forces estimates that in the next war Hezbollah will be able to fire up to 1,500 rockets a day, compared to about 200 during the 2006 war.

The speech by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in the UN General Assembly in October 2015 implied that Hezbollah had managed to smuggle advanced weapons systems from Syria to Lebanon, including precise ground-to-ground missiles, SA-22 anti-aircraft missiles and Yakhont surface-to-sea missiles. The ongoing supply of high-quality weapons, along with the experience accumulated in Syria, have also provided Hezbollah with new capabilities in essential areas such as commando fighting and the operation of drones, some of them capable of combat.