Israel’s diamond exchange is turning to digital currencies to inject new life into a marketplace long ruled by cash and backroom handshakes. But first it must persuade traditionally conservative players the technology can actually work.
One of the world’s largest diamond centers, the exchange hopes its virtual currency will make trading more efficient and less opaque.
Current transactions are “often carried out anonymously, with the shake of a hand and minimal documentation,” according to a recent report by Israel’s Justice Ministry. That murkiness has led the FBI and Europol to target the trade as a vehicle for money laundering and crime financing.
Narrow profit margins between rough and polished gems make it hard for polishers to get financing, and banks have cut back lending or pulled out entirely.
Backers of the digital currency program believe it will help address those issues.
- Israel to ease taxes on bitcoin and other digital currencies
- For a cyber superpower, Israel is surprisingly vulnerable to hackers
- Israeli startups looking to cash in on a Bitcoin world
“We foresee alignment behind this currency, because it’s going to make things easy,” said Eli Avidar, managing director of the exchange.
“This industry is facing challenges and this is going to, in a lot of aspects, address those challenges – the profitability element of the business, the speed of doing business, money-laundering aspects and the problematic elements of banking nowadays,” he said.
The exchange is planning to launch two coins.
The first, to be known as the Cut, will be available only to dealers on a peer-to-peer basis. Traders from around the world will receive digital wallets after being vetted by the exchange, similar to today’s background checks.
Each transaction will be verified in a matter of minutes and be available to the public on blockchain – a digital ledger maintained by a random group of peers – but the identity of who owns what will be kept private. The exchange can provide that information to regulators upon official request.
The Cut could solve increasing problems moving money between traders and retailers, one midsize diamond dealer said.
“Transfers of money have become increasingly difficult. With banking regulation, even the smallest move becomes complicated. It can take days,” said the dealer, who asked not to be identified because of the sensitivity of the process.
“Buyers don’t want to give the money till they get the stone, and sellers don’t want to give the stone till they get the money.”
However, he wanted to see how it will be regulated – which may take some time given that the coins are being launched without any government regulation in place (as is typical in the cryptocurrency world).
Bitcoin, the original cryptocurrency, has lost 70% of its value from its peak in December, partly because of market concerns about a global regulatory clampdown. Many bitcoin backers say regulation should be welcomed.
A spokeswoman for the Economy Ministry, which oversees the diamond trade, says there has as yet been no in-depth discussion on how the coins would be regulated.
Presale of the Cut went live at International Diamond Week in Israel last week. The coins should enter into use within a few weeks, said Avishai Shoushan, CEO of the year-old CARAT.IO, which created the coins for the exchange.
The coin is based on an index using 14 parameters, compared with just four characteristics used to price physical diamonds.
Price is determined by an algorithm, because whereas gold, for example, is priced by the ounce or oil by the barrel, diamonds are priced individually since each diamond is so different from the next.
A second coin, Carat, will be issued later and is meant for institutional and retail investors who want to invest in the diamond market without taking possession of physical diamonds.
“We are creating a way for people to invest in the market without actually buying and selling diamonds,” Shoushan said.
A quarter of the market value of both coins will be backed by diamonds held by a third party. All this, he said, should make the tokens “much less volatile compared to any other cryptocurrency.”
In the high security, four-tower complex on the outskirts of Tel Aviv, $23 billion changed hands between local and foreign traders in 2017. The area is known as the diamond district, and visitors coming by train access it across Diamonds Bridge.
Visitors are fingerprinted before they can enter the buildings and look down on the world’s largest trading floor. Should a diamond go missing, the entire complex locks down.
Israel’s diamond district is full of polishers who specialize in large, high-end diamonds. The country cannot compete in smaller stones with massive operations in India and China. By nature, the trade is global. The State Bank of India has a branch beside the exchange.
Israel’s diamond exports in 2017 fell 12%, to $15.5 billion. Bain & Company international consulting said in a 2017 industry review that diamond jewelry sales, which according to De Beers hovered at $80 billion in 2016, were “stagnant.”
Slowing long-term demand and the shaky financial position of polishers are two big concerns, it said.
Martin Rapaport, chairman of the highly influential Rapaport Group, whose diamond price list is a global industry benchmark, has a big presence in Israel and may have to compete with the new system.
He applauded the effort to expand diamond demand, but said he thought cryptocurrencies were “a bit of a fad” and is unsure of their sustainability.
“Diamonds have an inherent value, and that inherent value has been around for centuries. Whether or not you can take that and hype it into something modern and something interesting like a cryptocurrency is highly questionable,” he said.