Israeli Female Cinematographers Keep Their Viewpoint in a Male Dominant Field

Send in e-mailSend in e-mail
Send in e-mailSend in e-mail
Go to comments
Israeli cinematographer Talia Gal’On on the set of “A.K.A. Nadia.”
Israeli cinematographer Talia Gal’On on the set of “A.K.A. Nadia.”Credit: Marc Hankins
Nirit Anderman
Nirit Anderman
Nirit Anderman
Nirit Anderman

The camera lens of American cinematographer Rachel Morrison shattered an important glass ceiling last month, when she became the first woman in the 90-year history of the Academy Awards to receive an Oscar nomination for best cinematography (for her work as director of photography on “Mudbound”). 

Rachel Morrison poses for a portrait at the 90th Academy Awards Nominees Luncheon at The Beverly Hilton hotel on Monday, Feb. 5, 2018.Credit: Chris Pizzello/AP

Surprising? Not necessarily.

Whether or not Morrison wins the award, the very fact that she was nominated has attracted attention to the minuscule percentage of women in the field. In 2006, for example, only 5 percent of the cinematographers for the year’s 250 most profitable Hollywood films were female.

In Israel the situation is even worse: Of 256 cinematographers currently registered in the Israel Film and Television Technicians and Workers Union, only five are women, about 3 percent. Although a local female cinematographer, Talia (Tulik) Gal’On, was twice nominated twice for the Ophir Prize (the Israeli Oscar) for “Beautiful Valley” and “A.K.A. Nadia,” she failed to win both times. 

Gal’On says the nominations in her case did not have the usual effect of upping the nominees’ professional prestige, leading to a steep rise in the number of job offers. “It didn’t change a thing, unfortunately. I didn’t receive any additional requests as a result,” Gal’On says.

Rachel Morrison on the set of “Mudbound.” Discouraging reactions in an Israeli WhatsApp group. Credit: Steve Dietl/AP

Avigail Sperber says that when she posted the news about Morrison’s  Oscar nomination on a WhatsApp messaging group for cinematographers, the responses were less than encouraging.  Needless to say, most of the group’s members are men.

'No woman I know would be able to film a series like 'Fauda,' unless she is as fit as the [elite army unit] Sayeret Matkal,' said 'Fauda' cinematographer Nitai Netzer

“All the reactions to the item were that [Morrison] is a lousy photographer, that it’s a lousy film and the only reason she was nominated is that Netflix, which produced ‘Mudbound,’ put a lot of money into it,” Sperber says.
“I didn’t see the film, but in my opinion, the fact that those are the group’s reactions underscores the unforgiving attitude toward women in this field.”
The set director

Although in other technical professions on the set, such as lighting and sound, there are also very few women, it is particularly interesting to understand this exclusion in cinematography, one of the most important professions in filmmaking.

“A cinematographer is the set director to some extent. The director is the supreme decider in conceptual terms, but the person who actually directs the set is the cinematographer,” Gal’On says.

“The masculine method of direction on the set is almost always louder, conveys something that makes an impression on many producers, conveys some supposed quality, even if it’s not true. There’s also the technical issue: Men, in general, love to emphasize the technical aspect and to bandy about terms that producers know nothing about, and therefore think it’s important. Women, in my opinion, concentrate more on content, and that may not look sufficiently professional to the producers.”

Amit Chachamov.Credit: The set of "Ben Mamshich" (Heritage)

Gal’On completed her cinematic studies in the mid-1990s, and won a Golden Lens award for a film that she shot as a student. “If I were a man that would certainly have tracked me directly into cinematography, but for a woman it was — and still is — very difficult to get into this field. And of course it didn’t happen, so for many years I worked as an assistant director, and I would film student films for free to accumulate experience. I had several failed attempts to get filming jobs. Usually after you do a good project they turn to you, but I discovered that that happens mainly to men.”

All the female cinematographers who were interviewed for this article agree that on the sets of Israeli feature films there is often a mentality of army reserve duty

Sperber also says that after completing her studies she went to look for work in cinematography, and discovered that it was almost a mission impossible. “First I went to the news, to studios, but there they told me, ‘You’re very small to be a photographer, how will you hold a camera?’

When I wanted to be an assistant photographer, few many filmmakers wanted me. Some didn’t feel comfortable having a girl carrying the equipment for them, which is one of the tasks of a photographer’s assistant. I think if I had been a man they would have wanted me more.”

The subject of carrying and weight is the most common and clichéd explanation for the low percentage of female cinematographers. In the previous century, before the transition to digital photography, the huge cameras were heavy and awkward, and lifting them onto one’s shoulder really was quite difficult. The photographers and their assistants were forced to carry heavy equipment from place to place, and women were not considered suitable for the task.

However, technology has eliminated this excuse. The cameras today are much lighter, and any woman can load them onto her shoulder with relative ease. Those who aren’t happy to find themselves with a female cinematographer on the set now have to find another excuse.

Avigail Sperber.Credit: \ Alex Levac

Don’t ever cry here

Yvonne Miklosh, one of the few women who worked here as a cinematographer in the 1980s (among other things she filmed Assi Dayan’s films “Photo Roman” and “Hatov, Hara Vehalo-Nora”), says crew members always treated her professionally on the set, but with others she encountered a great deal of prejudice. In one instance, she recalls, a certain director chose her to film his movie, but then the producer came and decided: “No, it’s impossible to raise money with a girl.” It was a very complicated profession for women, she explains.

All the female cinematographers who were interviewed for this article agree that on the sets of Israeli feature films there is often a mentality of army reserve duty. “As though this is some elite unit that’s setting out to make a film,” says Miklosh. “At the time I didn’t make an issue of it. I thought that I would have no problem joining that mentality, and that’s why I made sure on the set that they wouldn’t notice that I’m a girl.”

But it didn’t take long for her to wise up. When she worked as an assistant cinematographer on some set and was forced to deal with a very frustrating technical problem with the old movie camera, she gave up lunch in order to try to repair it. 

“I was so frustrated I started crying; one guy, who was my friend on the set and had come to look for me, saw me crying, looked at me and said: ‘Yvonne, don’t ever cry here! If you want to, kick something.’ 
“At first I was filled with gratitude, because he had come to help me. Only on the way home did I blow my fuse. Suddenly I understood that everything is allowed as long as it’s on their playing field. Kicking, cursing, taking out your anger on someone — that’s all right. But crying? Not that. And it happens to female cinematographers all the time, because sets are a male environment, and you find yourself on a playing field that isn’t yours.”

A scene from Israeli TV series 'Fauda.' A large team composed mainly of men.Credit: Ronen Akerman / Yes

Not only Women of the Wall

A few months ago the tiny group of female Israeli television and cinema photographers, with fewer than 15 women, had an upsetting experience. The admired television photographer Nitai Netzer (“Fauda”) said in an article by Orr Sigoli in the business daily Calcalist that filming a feature film requires dealing with a large team composed mainly of men, implying that that is liable to be quite difficult for a female cinematographer.

He also claimed that “No woman I know would be able to film a series like “Fauda,” unless she is as fit as the [elite army unit] Sayeret Matkal.” 
As a result, the women who film Israeli television and movies decided to band together. They founded a WhatsApp group of their own, decided to meet once a month and now are working on starting a joint website that will present a resume and a showreel  (a work portfolio) of each of them.
This group helps to transfer information and work among themselves, and also provides an open place for a professional discussion. 

“Some of the female cinematographers said that in the other cinematographers’ WhatsApp groups, with a declared male majority, it’s less comfortable for them to ask questions, because they feel they have to prove that they know everything. So our group created a place for an open and nonjudgmental discussion, and it also helps to create some kind of visibility, to show that this thing exists,” says Amit Chachamov, who started the group together with Emmanuelle Mayer. 

They discovered that similar groups of female photographers exist in other countries too, in an attempt to provide female solidarity in a field that is so masculine.

They’re already used to being asked to film scenes that require a woman behind the camera, mainly scenes filmed at the Western Wall or in a mikveh (Jewish ritual bath).“That’s our regular joke in the group, we laughed that we would start a rebellion and wouldn’t agree to film at the Western Wall, so they would stop it,” says Chachamov. They hope that the female photographers will be treated more seriously from now on, will receive more job offers, and that more women will join the profession.

Could Morrison’s widely covered nomination bring about a change? “Look, it’s a fact that you contacted us now,” says Miklosh. “The more it’s discussed, the more legitimacy it has, and it becomes less of a curiosity. And in the film world, where other worlds are created, we can expect people to have fewer prejudices. So I’m optimistic.”