'We Saw Jews With Hearts Like Germans': Moroccan Immigrants in Israel Warned Families Not to Follow

Thousands of letters written in the early years of the state by immigrant soldiers to their families in Morocco reveal a gloomy picture. Most wanted to go home

Send in e-mailSend in e-mail
Send in e-mailSend in e-mail
Ofer Aderet
Ofer Aderet
Ofer Aderet
Ofer Aderet

In 1949, in the midst of the War of Independence, an Israel Defense Forces soldier wrote a letter to his family who remained in Morocco. “We came to Israel and thought we’d find a paradise here, but regrettably it was the opposite: We saw Jews with hearts like Germans.” He also had a word of caution for his relatives: “If you want my advice, stay in North Africa; it’s better than the Land of Israel.”

Comments

ICYMI

Pro-Palestinian demonstrators protest against U.S. aid to Israel in New York City, December 23, 2023.

Two Gaza Wars: Why the Gulf Between Israelis and Outsiders Is So Vast, and Jarring

Prof. Moshe Zimmermann.

The Hamas Pogrom Demonstrates That Zionism Has Failed, Says Historian Moshe Zimmermann

לודה איסחרוב (מימין) שהצטרפה לארגון הלל הבינלאומי לאחר 7 באוקטובר ובנג'מן קרסטן שמקדיש יותר זמן לארגון הפרו-פלסטיני Jewish Voice for Peace שאליו הצטרף לפני כשבע שנים

Polarized: Israel-Gaza War Is Forcing Young U.S. Jews to Choose Sides

Israeli soldiers in a tunnel found underneath Al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza City on November 22, 2023

Don't Believe the IDF and Israeli Analysts. There's No Solution to Hamas' Tunnels

Sinkholes at Mineral Beach, with the abandoned hot springs facility at left.

Meanwhile, Israel Is Losing Ground at the Lowest Place on Earth

נוגה פרידמן

'Don't Say He Was a Hero': Her Partner Died Fighting Hamas. She's Telling Her Truth