The Education Ministry has started letting principals see the list of teachers and students who are exempt from quarantine because they have either been vaccinated or recovered from the coronavirus. At some high schools, other people have apparently seen the list as well. Teachers fear the database will be used to pressure them into getting vaccinated.
The Association for Civil Rights in Israel termed this a “severe violation of privacy.” It urged the Health Ministry both to prevent the information from getting out and to forbid principals to use it.
The list became available to principals on Sunday through a special ministry website also giving the number of patients and people in quarantine at each school, plus data about the town and neighborhood. The list includes names and ID numbers of all teachers and students exempt from quarantine, and the percentage of people exempt in each grade.
Since only people who have been vaccinated or recovered from the virus are exempt, this enables principals to determine who hasn’t been vaccinated.
Last month, Haaretz reported that Attorney General Avichai Mendelblit had authorized the Health Ministry to give the Education Ministry lists of teachers and students who had been vaccinated. But the information was supposed to be used only to help sever chains of infection, and not to encourage vaccination, as the Education Ministry wanted. Principals were supposed to get the information only if there was a coronavirus outbreak at their school, and “in a way that would minimize the violation of privacy,” a Justice Ministry official said at the time.
But on Monday, the Education Ministry said the information is available to principals with no connection to identifying other patients.
One high school teacher complained that disclosing who has been vaccinated strikes “at the heart of medical confidentiality. I support vaccination, but this isn’t the way. A slippery slope of privacy has been opened here. If teachers start discussing this information at school, it will be exposed to everyone.”
- Less than 3 percent of Israeli students tested weekly for COVID in risk areas
- Israelis flocked to get the COVID vaccine, but will they vaccinate their children too?
- Forget two meter COVID rules. Israeli pupils back in school are hugging each other
Another teacher voiced fears the information would lead to “direct or indirect” pressure on 11th and 12th graders and their families to get vaccinated so that in-person learning could resume. The health and education ministries have decided that in areas where over 90 percent of students in these grades have been vaccinated or recovered, classes can resume with no restrictions.
Attorney Gil Gan-Mor of ACRI said the information given the principals is protected by “the constitutional right to privacy” as well as medical confidentiality. “There’s no place for sending the names wholesale to all schools,” he wrote in a letter to Health Ministry director general Chezy Levy.
Moreover, he noted, ACRI and Physicians for Human Rights petitioned the High Court of Justice against the law allowing the information to be given to the Education Ministry, and a week ago the court issued an injunction prohibiting the law’s implementation. Providing a list of people exempt from quarantine appears to be an attempt to circumvent this ruling, since “even if it doesn’t explicitly violate the injunction, it violates its spirit,” he wrote.
The Education Ministry said the issue is in court and it will present its position there. The Health Ministry has yet to comment.