Welcome back
Haaretz. Your news source about Israel and the Middle East
Already subscribed? Login
U.S. Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin meets with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at the Prime Minister's Office in Jerusalem, October 28, 2019. Matty Stern/U.S. Embassy Jerusalem

Israel Panel to Monitor Chinese Investments Following U.S. Pressure

Although the proposal is framed as 'supervision over foreign investment,' the real goal is create a mechanism for screening investments by Chinese companies and investment funds in strategic Israeli assets

Israel's security cabinet decided Wednesday to establish a mechanism to monitor Chinese investments, following three years of debate and pressure from the United States.

The meeting came a day after Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu met with the U.S. Secretary of the Treasury, Steve Mnuchin, and was only scheduled last week.

Haaretz Weekly Ep. 45 Haaretz

The proposal calls for creating a body only with the power to advise on prospective foreign investments in Israeli companies. The firms subject to vetting would be in businesses designated as critical to the economy or to national security, including companies involved in infrastructure or with access to Israelis’ personal data, such as telecommunications companies, financial institutions and arms makers.

The security cabinet held a last-minute meeting to weigh the proposal on Tuesday morning, which was formulated by the National Security Council. The council announced Wednesday afternoon that the finance ministry, the National Economic Council, the National Security Council and the security cabinet made the decision to create an advisory committee led by the finance ministry to examine matters of national security in the process of approving international investments in Israel.

>> Read more: All eyes on China: U.S: loses interest in Mideast as Trump completes strategic shift | Analysis ■ If global recession is coming, it will be Trump's to own | Opinion

The announcement said that multiple government agencies will participate in the committee, including the foreign ministry, the defense ministry and various financial bodies. Regulators will consult with the committee voluntarily; business transactions that do not require government approval will not be brought before it.

"Israel is joining many countries, among them the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, Germany, Australia and others, who have also formulated processes to improve oversight of foreign investments for national security purposes," the announcement read. Regulators will be able to consult with the committee starting on January 1, 2020.

Israel has been weighing such a plan for three years. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Prof. Avi Simhon, chairman of the National Economic Council, have told the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee and the cabinet on several occasions that plans were being drawn up.

Israel has blocked Chinese investment in the past, but no single body has been authorized to oversee the process. The Capital Markets Authority blocked Chinese takeovers of Israeli insurance companies, for instance. The proposed body, similar to one former MK Omer Bar-Lev proposed in July 2018, would create a formal and organized process for vetting foreign investment.

The reason no decision has been made until now is the sensitivity of the issue. Although the proposal is framed as “supervision over foreign investment,” the real goal is create a mechanism for vetting investment by Chinese companies and investment funds in strategic Israeli assets.

The U.S. government wants Israel to act on the investment issue amid a bitter trade war with China and anxiety over Beijing’s aspiration to become a global high-tech leader. Israel itself has sought to avoid taking sides in the conflict and remain neutral.

Despite Israeli reservations, the decision to take the proposal to the security cabinet is due to American pressure. Last week at a conference of the World Bank and International Monetary Fund, a senior delegation from the treasury, including Finance Minister Moshe Kahlon and Finance Ministry Director General Shai Babad, took time out to meet with their U.S. counterparts, who again raised the issue of Chinese foreign investment and how to restrict it.

In addition, on Monday, Netanyahu met with U.S. Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin in Israel. At a press conference afterwars, Netanyahu focused on stepping up sanctions against Iran. Mnuchin spoke about the U.S.’s close commercial ties with Israel and Israel’s technology prowess.

While neither mentioned China, Netanyahu is well aware about American expectations from Israel on the matter.

In April, Channel 13 television reported that when U.S. President Donald Trump signed the document recognizing Israeli sovereignty of the Golan Heights, he demanded that Netanyahu cool ties with China. Trump even warned that failure to do so could harm American military aid to Israel.

It’s doubtful that any decision taken by the security cabinet on Tuesday will obligate the next government. Netanyahu’s caretaker government is barred from undertaking major economy-related decisions. To bring it to the Knesset to legislate the decision would require the government to make the case that an urgent national security issue is involved. American officials who are in Israel this week with Mnuchin acknowledge that Netanyahu is in a fragile situation, which was evidenced by the fact that senior White House adviser Jared Kushner met with Kahol Lavan leader Benny Gantz on Monday.

Under the circumstances, the prime minister will do whatever he can to satisfy the U.S. government’s wishes, including calling a meeting of the security cabinet over foreign investment.

If the security cabinet does back the new investment body, the hope is that Beijing won’t see it as a hostile act.

Hagai Amit contributed to this report.

Israel's security cabinet decided Wednesday to establish a mechanism to monitor Chinese investments, following three years of debate and pressure from the United States.

The meeting came a day after Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu met with the U.S. Secretary of the Treasury, Steve Mnuchin, and was only scheduled last week.

Haaretz Weekly Ep. 45 Haaretz

The proposal calls for creating a body only with the power to advise on prospective foreign investments in Israeli companies. The firms subject to vetting would be in businesses designated as critical to the economy or to national security, including companies involved in infrastructure or with access to Israelis’ personal data, such as telecommunications companies, financial institutions and arms makers.

The security cabinet held a last-minute meeting to weigh the proposal on Tuesday morning, which was formulated by the National Security Council. The council announced Wednesday afternoon that the finance ministry, the National Economic Council, the National Security Council and the security cabinet made the decision to create an advisory committee led by the finance ministry to examine matters of national security in the process of approving international investments in Israel.

>> Read more: All eyes on China: U.S: loses interest in Mideast as Trump completes strategic shift | Analysis ■ If global recession is coming, it will be Trump's to own | Opinion

The announcement said that multiple government agencies will participate in the committee, including the foreign ministry, the defense ministry and various financial bodies. Regulators will consult with the committee voluntarily; business transactions that do not require government approval will not be brought before it.

"Israel is joining many countries, among them the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, Germany, Australia and others, who have also formulated processes to improve oversight of foreign investments for national security purposes," the announcement read. Regulators will be able to consult with the committee starting on January 1, 2020.

Israel has been weighing such a plan for three years. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Prof. Avi Simhon, chairman of the National Economic Council, have told the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee and the cabinet on several occasions that plans were being drawn up.

Israel has blocked Chinese investment in the past, but no single body has been authorized to oversee the process. The Capital Markets Authority blocked Chinese takeovers of Israeli insurance companies, for instance. The proposed body, similar to one former MK Omer Bar-Lev proposed in July 2018, would create a formal and organized process for vetting foreign investment.

The reason no decision has been made until now is the sensitivity of the issue. Although the proposal is framed as “supervision over foreign investment,” the real goal is create a mechanism for vetting investment by Chinese companies and investment funds in strategic Israeli assets.

The U.S. government wants Israel to act on the investment issue amid a bitter trade war with China and anxiety over Beijing’s aspiration to become a global high-tech leader. Israel itself has sought to avoid taking sides in the conflict and remain neutral.

Despite Israeli reservations, the decision to take the proposal to the security cabinet is due to American pressure. Last week at a conference of the World Bank and International Monetary Fund, a senior delegation from the treasury, including Finance Minister Moshe Kahlon and Finance Ministry Director General Shai Babad, took time out to meet with their U.S. counterparts, who again raised the issue of Chinese foreign investment and how to restrict it.

In addition, on Monday, Netanyahu met with U.S. Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin in Israel. At a press conference afterwars, Netanyahu focused on stepping up sanctions against Iran. Mnuchin spoke about the U.S.’s close commercial ties with Israel and Israel’s technology prowess.

While neither mentioned China, Netanyahu is well aware about American expectations from Israel on the matter.

In April, Channel 13 television reported that when U.S. President Donald Trump signed the document recognizing Israeli sovereignty of the Golan Heights, he demanded that Netanyahu cool ties with China. Trump even warned that failure to do so could harm American military aid to Israel.

It’s doubtful that any decision taken by the security cabinet on Tuesday will obligate the next government. Netanyahu’s caretaker government is barred from undertaking major economy-related decisions. To bring it to the Knesset to legislate the decision would require the government to make the case that an urgent national security issue is involved. American officials who are in Israel this week with Mnuchin acknowledge that Netanyahu is in a fragile situation, which was evidenced by the fact that senior White House adviser Jared Kushner met with Kahol Lavan leader Benny Gantz on Monday.

Under the circumstances, the prime minister will do whatever he can to satisfy the U.S. government’s wishes, including calling a meeting of the security cabinet over foreign investment.

If the security cabinet does back the new investment body, the hope is that Beijing won’t see it as a hostile act.

Hagai Amit contributed to this report.

Want to read more?

Haaretz unlimited.
Only $1 for the first month

Trending Now