Airliner Tragedy Crushes Egypt Hopes of Tourism Revival

Russian and British tourists are deserting the normally-bustling Sharm el-Sheikh resort.

AP

Tourism in Sharm el-Sheikh was picking up again after years of political turmoil, with so many Russians enjoying the sun and fun that local beach aerobics instructors used the visitors’ own language rather than Arabic or English.

Life was at last starting to look good for residents of the Red Sea resort, but that was before an airliner taking Russian tourists home broke up over the Sinai Peninsula, where Islamic State militants suspected of planting a bomb on the plane are waging an insurgency.

Now the future looks grim for thousands of Egyptians, from taxi drivers to diving instructors, who flocked to Sharm el-Sheikh to find jobs. One tour company official predicted holidays might now have to be discounted by up to 50%.

“I have been working in Sharm for three years but this is the first time I have ever seen it so empty,” says Ahmed Rabie. He spoke outside the cafe he runs in Naama Bay, at the resort’s heart. Chairs were stacked on tables and not a single person was sitting inside.

“Right now, all these cafes and restaurants would be full.”

Rabie pays 30,000 Egyptian pounds ($3,700) a month to rent the space, in addition to operational costs.

He told Reuters many small business owners had shut up shop after Western governments announced that the Airbus 321 was likely brought down by a bomb and then suspended flights to Sharm el-Sheikh, with Russia following suit.

“We are waiting for two or three days to see what happens but if it keeps on like this we will shut down and leave,” he said.

With low prices, cheap package deals and plenty of hotel rooms, Sharm el-Sheikh was a driving force behind Egypt’s efforts to lure back visitors.

It was starting to buzz. Then the Russian plane crashed, with Islamic State claiming it was responsible. This immediately alarmed the Egyptians, acutely aware of how vulnerable tourism is to such violence.

On November 17, 1997 Islamic militants descended on Queen Hatshepsut’s temple near the Nile town of Luxor. In short order they shot or hacked to death 58 tourists and four Egyptians.

The following January and February, visitor numbers were down almost 60% from the previous year. The industry staged a remarkable comeback, but it took years.

Invisible hands

Last month, Tourism Minister Hisham Zaazou said tourism – a pillar of the economy – expected moderate growth this year with the aid of a global advertising campaign.

President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi has restored some stability since the army toppled Islamist President Mohamed Morsi in 2013 following mass protests against his rule, but not enough to persuade large numbers of foreigners that it is safe to return.

Last year, 9.9 million tourists visited Egypt, a far cry from the 14.7 million who came in 2010, the year before the Arab Spring revolutions convulsed the Middle East. According to the World Travel and Tourism Council, tourism directly accounts for around 6% of Egypt’s economy and supports more than 1.3 million jobs. Sharm el-Sheikh accounts for about 70% of visits by Britons, a major tourism market for Egypt.

Several airlines have suspended flights to the Red Sea resort since the crash, which investigators and Western governments believe was likely to have been caused by a bomb. Thousands of Russian and British tourists have been flown home.

“Losing 40 percent of our clients will lead to losing around 50 percent of the tourism income in Sharm el-Sheikh and South Sinai,” Guevara el-Gafy, chairman of the South Sinai Travel Agents Association, told Reuters last week.

Speaking in his family-owned Gafy Resort, where portraits of al-Sisi adorn the walls, Gafy said the industry had originally expected a 30 percent increase in tourists this winter season.

“The problem is that the plane crash occurred at the beginning of the season ... Sharm el-Sheikh and South Sinai are winter destinations,” Gafy said.

About 10% of bookings were canceled on the day of the crash, Gafy said, and the number jumped to around 40 percent after Britain and Russia suspended flights into Sharm el-Sheikh.

An official at Sharm Travel Solutions, a British-owned Sharm el-Sheikh tour company, said holidays in the resort could be discounted by up to 50%, if they can be sold at all.

“They may sell these holidays at half price, but with flights suspended will anyone buy them?” the official says.

Other tour operators are offering holidays to Sharm el-Sheikh with price cuts of up to $300.

A walk through Naama Bay reveals idle establishments, all with Russian signs to cater to the resort’s largest clientele.

The resort’s famous beaches fare only slightly better, with most just half full.

The prospect of a sharp decline in tourism receipts has left many scrambling to make sense of the sudden air disaster. Some are in denial.

“There are invisible foreign hands behind this,” says Mohamed Abdelaziz, who runs a safari trip business.

“Egypt lies in a strategic location and other countries are spiteful of this. Sharm is very safe, the police are even sometimes unfair to us to make sure it is safe for all guests.”

Many tourists interviewed agreed that Sharm el-Sheikh felt safe. Airport security was the problem, not the resort itself.

“Personally I felt sorry for Sharm as a resort when I heard about the plane crash. I’ve been here 14 times and I’ve never had a problem,” said British holidaymaker Vini Kneale.

If it turns out a bomb brought down the Russian plane, however, it would “discourage me from coming back,” he said.

They want the airport

The crash is a blow to an already battered Sharm el-Sheikh tourism scene, says taxi driver Mohamed Odei.

“No one used to come here except the fat cats, people with thick wallets. Now if a tourist wants a budget holiday, they come here. And even that is coming to an end.”

Airport security was the main concern that drove British Prime Minister David Cameron to suspend flights to Sharm el-Sheikh. New regulations are now in place, but for many it is too late.

“Egyptians don’t search well until there is a catastrophe,” says Odei, driving his taxi through a checkpoint outside the airport. Policemen with assault-rifles and soldiers circle his car, checking the trunk and his documentation.

Odei, originally from the Nile Delta city of Mansoura, has been working in Sharm el-Sheikh for seven years. He initially ran a restaurant but was forced to shut it down in 2005 after a suicide bomber attacked a market place and a hotel.

He noticed a sharp drop in passengers after flights were suspended.

“We now get maybe 30% of the passengers we usually get, and they all want to go to the airport,” he said. “I have never seen such crowds at the departure gate before, usually it’s the arrivals one.”

Gafy, 43, who is seeking election to Egypt’s parliament in two weeks, said he hoped that the Egyptian government would address Britain and Russia’s airport security concerns.

The son of a retired general who moved to Sharm el-Sheikh in 1984, shortly after Israel withdrew from the Sinai Peninsula under a peace treaty with Egypt, Gafy said not all tourists had been deterred.

“We are losing a big amount by losing the British and the Russians,” he said. “But we have eight countries still sending their clients because they understand Egypt is increasing security at the airport and is taking fast action.”