Iran Film on Mohammed as a Young Boy Stirs Controversy Before It Wraps

Sunni Islam, the religion's dominant branch, widely rejects any depictions of Mohammed, his close relatives or companions. Shi'ite Islam doesn't.

Send in e-mailSend in e-mail
Iranian filmmaker Majid Majidi, center, director of “Mohammad, Messenger of God” movie conducts a scene of the movie, in Allahyar village south of the capital Tehran, Iran.
Iranian filmmaker Majid Majidi, center, director of “Mohammad, Messenger of God” movie conducts a scene of the movie, in Allahyar village south of the capital Tehran, Iran.Credit: AP

ALLAHYAR, Iran — Here in this Persian replica of Mecca, built at the cost of millions of dollars, an Iranian film company is attempting to offer the world a literal glimpse of the Prophet Mohammed despite traditional taboos against it.

The movie "Mohammed, Messenger of God" already recalls the grandeur — and expense — of a Cecil B. DeMille film, with the narrow alleyways and a replica Kaaba shrine built here in the remote village of Allahyar.

But by even showing the back of the Prophet Mohammed as a child before he was called upon by Allah, the most expensive film in Iranian history already has been criticized before it's even widely released, calling into question who ultimately will see the Quranic story come to life on the big screen.

"How should we introduce our prophet?" asked Majid Majidi, the film's director. "Many relay their messages to the world through cinema and pictures."

Blockbusters in the U.S.

In American cinematic history, films involving the Bible often find the biggest audience and box office returns. Biblical stories have inspired dozens of films from the 1920s all the way to recent blockbusters like "Noah" starring Russell Crowe and Ridley Scott's biblical epic "Exodus: Gods and Kings."

But in Islam, portraying the Prophet Mohammed has long been taboo for many. Islamic tradition is full of written descriptions of Mohammed and his qualities — describing him as the ideal human being. But clerics generally have agreed that trying to depict that ideal is forbidden.

The Paris terror attack on the satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo, which killed 12 people in January, saw gunmen target it over its caricature of the prophet.

But while Sunni Islam, the religion's dominant branch, widely rejects any depictions of Mohammed, his close relatives or companions, Shi'ite Islam doesn't. In Shi'ite powerhouse Iran and other countries, posters, banners, jewelry and even keychains bear the images of Mohammed's son-in-law Ali, revered by Shi'ites who see him as the prophet's rightful successor.

The late Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomenei, who led Iran's 1979 Islamic Revolution and later became the country's supreme leader, reportedly even kept a picture similar to young Mohammed in his room for years.

In the new 190-minute film, the story focuses on Mohammed's childhood, never showing his face. The movie instead uses others to tell his story, like his grandfather Abdul-Muttalib, portrayed by Iranian actor Ali Reza Shoja Nouri.

"It was a very heavy role," Nouri told The Associated Press. "I cannot express my feelings about it."

For his vision, Majidi hired Academy-Award-winning visual-effects supervisor and filmmaker Scott E. Anderson, three-time Oscar-winning Italian director of photography Vittorio Storaro and music producer Allah-Rakha Rahman, who won two Academy Awards for his work on "Slumdog Millionaire."

By making a high-quality film, Majidi said it will give the world the right impression about the Prophet Mohammed. He blamed Islamic extremists and the West for sullying the image of a pillar of faith for 1.5 billion people across the world.

"For Muslims, the Prophet Mohammed is a mercy to the world and the hereafter," he said.

Egypt calls for ban

Yet the film already has seen widespread criticism even before being widely released, largely from predominantly Sunni Arab countries.

In February, Egypt's Al-Azhar, one of Sunni Islam's most prestigious seats of learning, called on Iran to ban a film it described as debasing the sanctity of messengers from God.

Meanwhile, the Sunni kingdom of Qatar has announced plans to have its own $1 billion epic shot on the prophet's life.

Majidi said he would be ready to cooperate with any Islamic country planning a film on Mohammed.

"We are ready to cooperate to produce any movies to introduce Mohammed to the world," Majidi said. "We are an Islamic country, we know the related culture and we have capabilities for production of such movies."

So far, the film appears to have the support of Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, Iran's current supreme leader, who attended an inauguration of the film's set in 2012.

Iranian film critics generally have praised the film as well, like Mostafa Seyedabadi, who declared its color and lighting as "astonishing."

However, critic Masoud Farasati dismissed some of the film's shots, like a low-angle view of the prophet as a teen against the sky, as a "Hollywood" knockoff.

Producers plan to ultimately release the film in Arabic, Persian and English, with showings across Iran and abroad in the summer.

Filming took a year, while postproduction in Germany took two more years. And if this film is successful, its producers say they hope to film two sequels, one focusing on Mohammed's life from his teenage years to his 40s and another after 40 when he became the prophet of Islam.

Mohammad Mahdi Heidarian, head of the private Nourtaban Film Industry company, said his company spent about $30 million in total to make the movie.

He and others declined to elaborate on who provided financial backing for it, though there are wealthy investors and religious institutions in Iran that likely would support such efforts.

In the past, such religious films have done well in Iran. The 1977 Quranic epic "The Message," starring Anthony Quinn as the uncle of the unseen and unheard prophet, drew crowds and long lines to movie theaters in Tehran.

And another that did well was DeMille's own 1956 film, "The Ten Commandments," with Charlton Heston playing the sea-parting prophet Moses. It's yet to be seen whether Majidi's film will be led into the promised land of a wide release.

Click the alert icon to follow topics:



Automatic approval of subscriber comments.
From $1 for the first month

Already signed up? LOG IN


בנימין נתניהו השקת ספר

Netanyahu’s Israel Is About to Slam the Door on the Diaspora

עדי שטרן

Head of Israel’s Top Art Academy Leads a Quiet Revolution

Charles Lindbergh addressing an America First Committee rally on October 3, 1941.

Ken Burns’ Brilliant ‘The U.S. and the Holocaust’ Has Only One Problem

Skyscrapers in Ramat Gan and Tel Aviv.

Israel May Have Caught the Worst American Disease, New Research Shows

ג'אמיל דקוור

Why the Head of ACLU’s Human Rights Program Has Regrets About Emigrating From Israel


Netanyahu’s Election Win Dealt a Grievous Blow to Judaism