Estranged Friends? A View on Israel From Western Europe

Is there a commonality of interest between Germany and Israel, or is Israel gradually turning into a liability for its Western friends?

AMSTERDAM - Last week I spent a few days in Berlin, primarily for a conference entitled: Estranged Friends? Israeli and German Perceptions of State, Nation, Force" organized by the Heinrich Bll Foundation, a German foreign policy organizations allied with the left-leaning Green party.

I have met with members of the Green party and of the Heinrich Bll Foundation quite often, and I can say beyond doubt that many of its members are deeply engaged with and closely connected to Israel. Quite a number of them are true friends of, feel connected to and care for Israel. They know its political and social structure well, and are well informed about current affairs in Israel.

Germanys relation to Israel has always been complex; overshadowed by the tragedy and horrors of the Holocaust. Support for Israel is a fixture of German politics, and Chancellor Merkel has gone as far to say that one of the Federal Republics raisons dtre is its commitment to Israels existential security.

It therefore took some courage for the Bll Foundation to formulate the conferences guiding question: do Israel and Germany still share a true friendship, or has the estrangement become the dominant trait?

Israel was represented by a number of eloquent spokespeople, among them Shimon Stein, who served as Israels ambassador to Germany from 2001 to 2007. Stein made it clear that he no longer represents Israels government and that he chose early retirement from the Foreign Service due to difficulties of representing Israels current government.

Merkel and Netanyahu - AP - Jan. 31, 2011
AP

Steins position was particularly interesting, because he is, by no means, a starry-eyed idealist: he belongs to the realist school in international relations that understands relations between countries as a function of national interests. For him, the notion of friendship between nations is rather vague, and he prefers looking at commonalities of interest.

But here, exactly was one of the themes that resurfaced, time and again. Is there, at this point, a commonality of interest between Germany and Israel, or is Israel gradually turning into a liability for its supposedly Western friends? After all for these, the tense relations with the Islamic world are a source of great concern; partially because of their dependence on Arab oil, but also because of their preoccupation with the evolving relations with their Muslim minorities. In this respect, Germanys friendship with Israel is indeed about to turn into more of a problem for its long-term interests.

By and large I saw remarkable sympathy and understanding for Israels genuine concerns, not only with respect to the possibility of a nuclear Iran. Ralph Fuecks , co-Chair of the Bll Foundation, repeatedly quoted the Muftis recent statement that Jews were the descendants of apes and pigs to show that incitement against Israel is by no means a matter of the past.

There are three major points on which Israel is clearly moving away from the West, as represented by Germany. One is the rise of nationalist rhetoric and the tendency of the ruling coalition to speak of Jews eternal right to the greater land of Israel. German intellectuals and politicians are highly aware that German romanticism has been crucial in developing this kind of rhetoric in the nineteenth century with utterly disastrous consequences in the Nazi period, and they firmly reject such rhetoric wherever it is used.

The second, connected, issue is Israels increasing movement towards ethnocracy: many of the Netanyahu coalitions legislative proposals differentiating between Jews and non-Jews run very deeply against the model of civic equality in the Free World.

The third is the great involvement of religion in Israeli politics in a variety of ways: most importantly in the fateful influence of the national-religious agenda on the colonization of the West Bank; through the fact that Israels Rabbinate is a state agency; and the fact that it is even possible for ultra-Orthodox and national-religious groupings to demand that women be excluded from certain public functions like singing.

One of the participants, Prof. Michael Wolffsohn, a Jewish, Israeli-born historian at Munich University put the situation quite succinctly in one of the panels: he said that he can easily see how there could be an German-Meretz Friendship, but ever less a commonality between Germany and Israel. Because Im quite sure that a number of readers will say ah, another leftist, it might be worth pointing out that Wolffsohn, who has served in the IDF, is considered a political conservative.

Wolffsohns statement highlights the growing chasm between Israel and Germany in particular, and the Free World in general. In terms of its core values, Israel has been moving away from the Free World, certainly during Netanyahus second tenure of the last three years.

I have, during these years, made great efforts to explain to European audiences what it is like to live under permanent existential threat, and I have tried to argue that at least certain aspects of Israels move to the right are the result of Israelis traumatization by the second Intifada and the shelling of southern Israel.

Nevertheless the conference, in my mind, has sharpened the question quo vadis Israel? – where is the country headed? Are Israels growing nationalism and religiosity purely reactive, or do they reflect ethnic and religious identities that have become demographically more dominant?

I think that, certainly in Germans elites, there is still a strong will to maintain and develop friendship with Israel. This is certainly not reciprocated by Lieberman who continues to show nothing but disdain for Europe; judging from his actions, Netanyahu and most of his coalition partners seem not to care either.

In the foreseeable future such friendship will have to be nourished through the institutions of civil society – as for example the Bll Foundations conference in Berlin. For me, as for many in Israel for whom the ideals of liberty, human rights and equality are core values, friendship with Germany in particular and Europe in general is not purely instrumental: it reflects the ideals we share with a continent that has drawn important lessons from its tragic history.