• Published 02:41 22.03.10
  • Latest update 10:10 22.03.10

Comment / Israel wants to push Palestinians back into cycle of violence

Are we to understand that the state is destroying the channels of peaceful protest in order to push the Palestinians back into a cycle of violence?

By Amos Goldberg Tags: Israel news

Israel has been waging a bitter battle in recent months against human rights activists and the non-violent struggle by Jews and Arabs against the occupation. To this end, the state has made use of the most questionable means available to it.

They are attacking on all fronts, and it is hard to believe that their actions do not represent official policy. As such, without the citizens noticing it, Israeli democracy is once again heading in the direction of the "democracies" of Russia and Egypt.

It began with harassment and unwarranted arrests of the leaders of the Bil'in and Na'alin demonstrations. When these did not have their desired effect, the army declared the area of the villages a closed military zone on Fridays.

For the next six months, whoever goes to these areas in order to demonstrate will immediately be charged with entering a closed military zone and will be brought to trial.

Designating a closed military zone is a draconian legal measure that limits basic human rights and is meant to prevent security risks, not protest. Of course, the army has never adopted a like tactic to prevent, for example, the rebuilding of illegal outposts after they have been razed. Only the protests of the left and the Palestinians are allowed to be prevented without any limits.

The harassment and the arrests made by the army and the Shin Bet may have failed to break the protests at Bil'in and Na'alin, but they worked in Jerusalem. During the past few years the police have managed to crack down on quiet civil protests in Silwan using these methods. They are now using similar policies in the neighborhood of Sheikh Jarrah.

The settlers there, who are immune, use violence against the residents, especially women and children. The residents turn to the police, which take their time in arriving and do not arrest anyone.

After the Arabs lose their patience, one of them responds with a shove, is immediately arrested for aggravated assault and is brought to trial only after a lengthy waiting period in custody. Sometimes charges of aggravated sexual harassment are brought against residents for nothing more than using strong language. This is happening here and now.

The same method is being implemented by the security forces in Hebron and in the southern Hebron Hills. One of the activists in the struggle for grazing areas for the Bedouin, who have been stripped innumerable times of their lands by the army and the settlers, was charged with cutting a wildflower and has been held for a week. Children and adults, mostly from families linked to groups like B'tselem, are arrested on a near daily basis on false accusations.

The effectiveness of these measures is enormous because in addition to the fear element, the process is so expensive (hiring an attorney, posting bail, etc.) that the activists are unable to meet the costs, even if the legal process does result in the release of those who have been arrested.

At the same time, the state is waging a campaign against human rights groups. Not only does it send its senior officials to European capitals to convince the governments there to prevent funding for these organizations, but in recent days the Justice Ministry has begun working on legislation that will make funding these organizations with foreign donations nearly impossible.

This is the look of the only democracy in the Middle East - one that cannot suffer even non-violent protests by Jews and Palestinians, or the activity of human rights groups, Jewish or Arab, that expose its true colors.

Beyond the issue of democracy, are we to understand that the state is destroying the channels of peaceful protest in order to push the Palestinians back into a cycle of violence? This would then allow it to go back to wrapping itself up in self-righteousness and argue that it is combating terrorism. After all, this is what it considers to be its forte.

The writer is a fellow at Scholion Research Center at Hebrew University and an activist in Ta'ayus - Arab-Jewish Partnership.

  • Print Page
  • Send to a friend
  • Share
  • Text Size +|-
 
 
    This story is by: Amos Goldberg
TalkBacks

Why Facebook Connect?

Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.

Add a comment

Add your reply

  • 10. 0 0
    They were arrested not becquse they protested without a permit bu
    • Sima
    • 23.03.10
    • 04:13

    because they stoned the border police and spat on Jews on their way to the synagogue for the Friday night prayer. This wasn't included in their reports on the incident. Mister Goldberg, the reason a permit is required is so that the organizers are accountable in case something goes wrong. Yes you are responsible for the4 conduct of the demonstration. Spitting on Jews while on their way to the synagogue? This we'll never forgive you or the NIF.

  • 9. 0 0
    And you, Cassie, do read the news -- unfortunately it's distorted
    • DavidAK
    • 22.03.10
    • 18:20

    Anyone in London saying, "Don't you read the news?" is a joke. The British media is so biased against Israel that you have no chance getting an objective understanding of what's going on. You get inflammatory yellow journalism colored by your Lawrence of Arabia complex. Really, Cassie, you need to get some other inputs, but probably your brainwashed mind is made up already.

  • 8. 0 0
    I am drawing no parallel...
    • Iggy of Ophir
    • 22.03.10
    • 18:04

    ...but I am intimately familiar with several countries where the governments (fully believing they were doing what was best) cracked down so hard on dissent (of any sort whatsoever) that they ultimately lost the support of enough of the "average Joes" that it caused those governments to collapse.

  • 7. 0 0
    Exactly Right... Likud Rightists Want, Need Enemies
    • Dolphin
    • 22.03.10
    • 16:44

    as they turn Israel into an unfree right-wing theocracy. Very littel sand remains in the hourglass of Israel as a democratic country.

  • 6. 0 0
    The real fear
    • Ben
    • 22.03.10
    • 16:26

    Yes. This is it--the real fear--that the Palestinian resistance WON'T be violent, that it WILL be peaceful. This is what the Israeli mainstream fears most. Because then it will have no answer and nothing to hide behind. It is so much easier to hide behind "no one to talk to," "the cycle of violence," and of course "they are terrorists." Israel has to face the fact that on some level it does not want terror to stop--it lives in fear of the day it will stop.

  • 5. 0 0
    Why pushing Palestinians back in cycle of violence?
    • John
    • 22.03.10
    • 15:22

    When people start revolting under too much oppressive manipulation, the popular masses start thinking and acting in emotional black and white manners. This creates the perfect smokescreen -and excuse-for a system in power to push through the throats of the 'others/terrorists/extremists/ennemies/etc for a well prepared bunch of even more oppressive 'policies'. So, a destructive cycle is accelerated while the stronger party grabs as much as possible goodies along the way. But this happens not only between countries... Can we not see such behaviour in our own hearts and in our own micro communities?

  • 4. 0 0
    only democracy in the Middle-East
    • John
    • 22.03.10
    • 15:06

    The only democcracy in the Middle East, beside Turkey, Lebanon, Iraq, Iran is sliding down little by little the slippery slope towards a (very) manipulative totalitarian entity. Is there a similarity to be seen with the events that led up to the far right -or left- regimes of times of old? Or even those more recent, say first half 20th century, Europe?

  • 3. 0 0
    Where is the difference to the Iranian regime......
    • Swiss (Dino)
    • 22.03.10
    • 10:51

    ....when it comes to the treatment of people demanding more freedom...???? I would say it's pretty much the same today: Peaceful protests are being oppressed, and if people lose their temper and fight back with stones etc., they will be shot to death (as happened 4 times over the past 48 hours in the West Bank). Again, where is the difference...????

  • 2. 0 0
    #1 Luis
    • cassie
    • 22.03.10
    • 10:36

    Umm, don't you read the news Luis? The state ARE the instigators....

  • 1. 0 0
    sure, blame the state instead of the instigators
    • Luis
    • 22.03.10
    • 10:13

    How can this author say that Israel is trying to curb these protests? the state's goal is to protect its loyal citizens, not indulge populist insanties.