U.S. Senator seeks to cut aid to elite IDF units operating in West Bank and Gaza
Senator Patrick Leahy claims Shayetet 13 unit, undercover Duvdevan unit, and the Israel Air Force Shaldag unit are involved in human rights violations in occupied territories.
By Barak Ravid Tags: IDF West Bank Gaza Ehud BarakU.S. Senator Patrick Leahy is promoting a bill to suspend U.S. assistance to three elite Israel Defense Forces units, alleging they are involved in human rights violations in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
Leahy, a Democrat and senior member of the U.S. Senate, wants assistance withheld from the Israel Navy's Shayetet 13 unit, the undercover Duvdevan unit and the Israel Air Force's Shaldag unit.
 |
A checkpoint between the West Bank village of El Khader and the outskirts of Jerusalem, 2003. |
| Photo by: AP |
Defense Minister Ehud Barak, a long-time friend of Leahy's, met with him in Washington two weeks ago to try to persuade him to withdraw the initiative.
According to a senior Israeli official in Jerusalem, Leahy began promoting the legislation in recent months after he was approached by voters in his home state of Vermont.
A few months ago, a group of pro-Palestinian protesters staged a rally across from Leahy's office, demanding that he denounce the killing by Shayetet 13 commandos of nine Turkish activists who were part of the flotilla to Gaza last May.
Leahy, who heads the Senate Appropriations Committee's sub-committee on foreign operations, was the principle sponsor of a 1997 bill prohibiting the United States from providing military assistance or funding to foreign military units suspected of human rights abuses or war crimes. The law also stipulates that the U.S. Defense Department screen foreign officers and soldiers who come to the United States for training for this purpose.
Leahy wants the new clause to become a part of the U.S. foreign assistance legislation for 2012, placing restrictions on military assistance to Israel, particularly to those three units.
Leahy says these units are responsible for harming innocent Palestinian civilians and that no system of investigation is in place to ensure that their members are not committing human rights violations. According to Leahy's proposal, U.S. military assistance to Israel would be subject to the same restrictions that apply to countries such as Egypt, Pakistan and Jordan.
The senior Israeli official said that the Israeli Embassy in Washington had been trying unsuccessfully now for some months to persuade Leahy to back down from the initiative.
Two weeks ago, during Barak's visit to Washington, Israel's ambassador to the United States, Michael Oren, asked Barak to meet with Leahy to dissuade him from promoting the legislation.
Leahy, who is on the Democratic Party's left flank, has for many years promoted human rights issues globally. He has been sharply critical of Israel in recent years, especially following Operation Cast Lead in late 2008.
However, he also signed Congressional resolutions supporting Israel's right to self-defense.
Leahy, 71, has served in the Senate for 35 years. He was a personal friend of former Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin and has known Ehud Barak since the latter was IDF chief of staff.
Barak, who met with Leahy privately, was quoted by the senior Israeli official as telling the senator: "The difference between Israel and terror groups or other countries in the Middle East is that we give an accounting and there is monitoring."
Barak also said the IDF had a strict judiciary with broader powers than the judiciary in the United States armed forces.
Barak was also quoted as telling Leahy that the IDF military advocate general is not subservient to the military command, but rather to the attorney general, and has complete autonomy.
"If a Palestinian is injured, he can approach the High Court of Justice," Barak said. "The investigations undergo judicial review that is independent of commanders. There are dozens of hearings every year that are based on Palestinians' complaints against soldiers. They reach the highest and most independent authorities," he said.
Leahy listened to Barak, but he did not say whether he would withdraw his initiative. According to the senior Israeli official, Israel does know whether Leahy has done so.
However, the official said Barak felt Leahy had understood his message, and that the Israeli Embassy in Washington was following the matter. If necessary, Barak and Leahy would hold another talk, the official added.
Leahy's spokesman, David Carle, said the senator did not comment on his private conversations.
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
In the article it says: "Should American politicians intervene in Israeli defense strategy?" I would like to ask Israelis if Israeli/Jewish lobby groups such as AIPAC should intervene and influence US foreign policy. If the answer is yes, then American politicians should intervene in Israeli business too.
typical left wing upper west side type (via Vermont) attitude. Every Jew a .22!! (make mine a .38!)
ignoring Obama and Clintons pleas to freeze settlement building, Bibi has damaged the American Israeli relationship in a devastating way, and exposed israel to unprecedented danger., Bibi, the man who stalled, denied, and evaded dealing with the emergence of a Palestinian state will ironically be in the prime ministers chair when it happens, and the tsunami of demonstrations and ripple effects will reverberate in unimagineable ways.Bibi should listen to the Americans, Israel's only true powerful friend, and start to negotiate now without precondition or further building announcements..
what is the record of this senator on the killings of thousands of "innocents" by the US forces in the past yeras in Afghanistan, Irak, libya, etc to name only a few.? The US like Israel is faced with Islamic despots and terrorists and NEED to defend their citizens and their democracies in assymetric wars that by their very natiure cause "innocent" victims. Why only in one camp? .
He dances to the tune of our fiddle.
We are broke. Not one country regardless of human rights violations should receive one US Dollar as long as we have a budget deficit. I am pro Israeli but enough is enough save America and use those US tax dollars to fund American employment.
You have always benn supportive of human rights. Thank you for once again standing up for what is right. Yours may be a losing battle in a Congress brougth and paid for by the most powerful lobby in America but you have struck a blow for freedom.
He'll never be elected anymore ! Anyhow very courageous.
its about time somebody has his balls...........
Shayetet, Duvdevan and Shaldag are no different than US Navy Seals, Rangers and other US Elite Special Forces, who are deployed in Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan, the Horn of Africa, and other tough places. Maybe Senator Leahy should review how Human Rights are respected by US Special Forces also.
they are a mixture of 1960's hippies and libertarians. don't nearly represent American opinion and are anti any thing. also Leahy's bias is showing. , he was against cast lead and he hasn't provided documentation
What nonsense from this uber leftist fool. complete naivetee...and why? because some radical palestinian group in boston lobbied him.... can you say leahy is a glutton for muslim terrorist dollars?
or a Retraction. Proof of AIPAC power or at least not being in Israel's pocket
or a Retraction. Proof of AIPAC power or at least not being in Israel's pocket
We in the US should support Israel. At the same time, Israel should not depend on the US, but on God. He will avenge His advesaries. A time in the not so distant future is coming when Israel will need intervention and the US wont be willing or able, or possibly even be your enemy. Call on Yehowshuwa and He will not fail thee. Beware The Lamb!
Senator Patrick Leahy lives on the land stolen by his ancestors from American Indians, which makes him a genetic thief. During colonization of America, between 17 and 25 mln. American Indians was killed. The rest Senator Patrick Leahy keeps in concentration camps “RESERVATIONS”, which makes Senator Patrick Leahy a mass murderer. His position on Israel clearly shows that he has no credible high school education in ME history and his knowledge is limited for wahhaby school for muslim dummies and a highway billboard university. Only in America, such profoundly ignorant idiots can be senators. No surprise that he is a democrat.
Far more cluster bombs have been used in other wars but leahy jumped when israel used them in 2006 but this time the democrats don't control the house so his opinion is meaningless.
I think US should stop ALL its foreign support. The US is also entitled to stop only Israeli support, but I would find this strange from a country I view as our friend. But stopping support from only units acting in Gaza (never mind that such a selective stopping of support is clearly impossible) only shows the opinion of this Senator concerning the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Those posts supporting it are de-facto supporting Hamas regime, as well as supporting the Itamar's murder of a whole family. A journal hosting these posts in such proportions - obviously legitimate in itself - should ask himself on what basis he consider the journal as "Israeli" - only as a procedural statement of paperwork it seems, while de-facto supporting Hamas chart calling for the annihilation of Israel maybe? In this case may I suggest the journal registers itself in Ramallah and begins viewing itself as a Palestinian journal.
as to be expected. all the usual claptrap...hamas, destruction and annihilation, anti-semitism, ad nauseum. I suggest you stick with Arutz Sheva. Stick with the rah-rahs of your own peanut gallery trying to make a western style democracy out of a brutal occupation.
I read in this article that the US was considering stopping support to units operating in BOTH the West Bank and Gaza. Selective reading? Hamas is the elected government in Gaza, but the Itamar murders were supposedly committed by West Bank Palestinians. You seem very intent on having your views as the only legitimate ones. There are also moderate Israelis who are not so hate-filled.
from one israeli to another israeli!
I have tried to post the same notion, only that my posts don't see the light of day. Amira Hass is already living in Ramallah and dedicating her life to catering anti-Semites, while believing she is the prophet of righteousness. At least there is some coherence in her move. Haaretz should definitely reflect whether it is a Zionist, Israeli newspaper, or an anti-Semitic one, that should rather be based in Malmö, Ramallah or Cairo.
just go back to reading Arutz Sheva and be done with it. There you don't need to deal with facts, only self satisfying propaganda.
just go back to reading Arutz Sheva and be done with it. There you don't need to deal with facts, only self satisfying propaganda.
So we can contact them and thank them!
Say, it ain't so Leahy. Are your sure on this? I didn't know we had anyone in US congress that can stand up to AIPAC. I finally got it. Leahy must be retiring and not running for reelection.
I do hope indeed he will not sit in the next Senate
Any Senator that suggests stopping any help to Israel should be sent home. Stop All his perks and retirement security for being so stupid. Israel is Gods chosen people, the apple of his eye, and to curse them in any way will be a curse upon them! Look at all America has suffered since Katrina and each time our administration makes harm against the Jew--America suffers loss in finance or weather! In a matter of days this occurs! Check it out.
Was that true in Auswitch as well ?
Can we limit comments in this forum to people with common sense and keep the radicals out please? I am a Christian by the way...
It is about time someone in the US had the guts to question Israeli thugs in uniform. They have been getting away with murder. It is about time these criminals financed by the United States are broguht to task. Thank you Mr. Leahy. God bless you for standing up for the helpless Palestinians who have to endure the daily attrosities by these thugs in uniform.
his puppet masters of the islamic regimes are getting desperate. they are trying to attack Israel from every angle they can and this is just one of them.
the AIPAC sharks are surrounding the senator ready for the kill if he does not tow their line. Hopefully, he will harpoon them and send them sinking. Wouldn't that be refreshing!
The Jewish population of Vermont is less than 1% of the total. Yes, Leahy may lose AIPAC support, but may gain some votes.
so it's high time israel started to listen and take some advice from Obama and Hilary clinton, specifically that the resumption of negotiations is vital to both Israel and Palestine. The two recent announcements of further building in occupied areas is an outrageous and perverse thumbing of the nose and provocation, at a time when thoughful wise restraint was needed. Bibi has one chance to redeem himself, and that is to open negotiations as soon as possible without conditions. He doesn't have to fromally announce a freeze, just implement it off the record. When the Palestinian tsunami comes, it will be too late. Bibi, the man that refused to relate to the problem except by repression, will be obliged to deal with the new state he strove so long to undermine and prevent. irony of ironies.
thats a good thing.
This would be a good start. But it is time the US ends all aid to every nation, Israel included. We are piling up debt on our children's and grandchildren's heads at an alarming rate. End the welfare for every other nation and look after America's interests first, last and always.
A US senator who has some spine and stands up to the arm twisting from the Israelis and their militaristic lobbying of our government! Congratualtions Senator Leahey.
What is more the IDF operations are not as he supposes.They are defending Israel..You should come and see for y9urself.You want to CUT THE AID................Wasn't aware you AID the IDF..The ones who help the IODF is SOVEREIGN ISRAEL. Not the USA ..And please do cut the said aiod..Israel does NOT need it.You are bancrupt look to your economy that is in tatters.What is more you are being disingenuous..knowing full well yours is a precurser to the Pals who are jumping at the chance trying to subvert by going to the UN to acquire a state.Put your RECORD straight rather than deviate from the subnject at hand by accusing the IDF of human rights violations in occupied territories. They are NOT.
Check with your local Doctor. Its urgent
Well according to the law hey are but i guess because rabid right wingers like you who are foaming at the mouth say so, then hell it simply must be true. They dont defend israel by killing unarmed civilians on a boat who are of no threat to them or the state. And before you scream about "iron rods" being used to attack them remember that the report your country is so desperately trying to block being published says that most of those killed on the marmara were killed in a manner consistant with execution. No in a firefight where soldiers were trying to defend themselves but when the people were tied up and of no threat they were executed. But i suppose you will try and defend that behaviour too. Even tho its the same as the islamists do to those who dare to oppose them too.
who succumbed to Israeli money
There's not enough petrodollars to do that
Less than 40 % Americans actually vote in our country's election and I surely wouldn't interprete that as 300 million American's support for Israel. Americans are used to their Goverment having the wrong priorities and wasting money (some on Israel).
Israel may count only on cowards
The irony is if Leahy was visiting those areas without an armed guard he would be kidnapped, sodomized and beheaded quicker than you can say "Marx!"
Thanks to people like you in Israel for making it happen.
I refer to Barak saying he does not expect unrest after the UN vote: he is the first one who claimed the Tsunami" after the vote. I see that Barak has learned to zigzag from his boss: at least we know that after next elections we will never have to put up with him again
knife-slashed to death by palestinians. Probably writing to fund PA and Hamas terrorist prison-time salaries! Prison time salaries and the US taxpayer pays for it. Thanks Senator!
Barak's staff say "Leahy must obey, or he'll be spoken to again"?
Great man. But I wonder why he is not demanding that the US stop murdering thousands of innocent Pakistani civilians with its drone attacks mostly children. He should not allow his personal subordination to Obama cloud his judgement and let those atrocities slide just to protect the closeted gay in chief
but the content all wrong. Zionists, again, always trying to undermine what they are no longer able to argue. As for the senator a great man with a great idea.
nothing has been decided. And of course Haaretz doesn't provide any of the fine details regarding the actons of the special forces on the west bank. More irresponsible reporting.!
Can you name one other incident where a senior American politician has attempted to curb payments to israel?
Leahy CLAIMS that Israel should be subject to the same restrictions as "the US places on Egypt and Pakistan." Last I viewed, Obama ( a man Leahy admits to idolizing) gave the Egyptian terror group theMuslim Brotherhood 125 M1A1 Abrams tanks and $2 billion funneled through the mainly US taxpayer funded IMF. Additionally, Pakistan receives multi-billions a year in military assistance while at the same time harboring terrorists like bin Laden and al Qaeda and funds with those monies the Taliban's push to kill American soldiers and marines. The Pakistanis also use the US taxpayer monies to fund the repeated genocidal terror attacks by its intelligence unit in India. Appears Leahy is true to his convictions in supporting "allies of the US" as long as the targets are innocent civilians
"The difference between Israel and terror groups or other countries in the Middle East is that we give an accounting and there is monitoring." but it's still terrorism regardless. duh
How about sanctions against Israel for human rights violations? Why is that sanctions only apply to non pro-American nations while pro-American nations can commit the same crimes and do not get sanctions imposed on them? Looks like the rules of democracy and forcing these rules are imposed only on those who do not follow or serve American interests.
Israel is never going to stop with the occupation and the settlemententerprise unless it is forced to. Why should Americans subsidize this continuously. It's not like Israel listens to the US anyway.
One should sweet in his hallway before minding his own business!!! What is America doing in Afghanistan, Pakistan, Iraq, (so so in Libya and the rest of the world???) PLEASE... do us all a favor, get lost
America is obeying Israel orders, fighting Islamic world. Note that all countries you mentioned are Islamic, which Isreal hates most.
Senator Leahy needs to shut his mouth. America is guilty of more "human rights" violations than most other nations, especially in Afghanistan and Iraq. I hate 'bleeding heart' liberals.
the best way to appreciate Leahy and his constituents is to stand behind a horse with it's tail up and it's back legs braced. Having lived across the pond from that weenie I can say with certainty Leahy never saw a radical poster he didn't like. He is as far from the center to the left as anyone in my government and proud of it; he will take stands just to make the gesture. Truly, the flakes in Vermont come form NYS.
Senator Leahy is an honest and just American. Now, watch how he is going to be judged and villified in the American press! Ehud Barak is a war criminal.
It's a slap in the face!
Finally an American politician with a liver
While you type away at your keyboard in Gaza City pretending, you may want to use something other the the al qaeda daily journal as your sourcing
When I hear of commandos I usually have an image of elite military unit engaging in daring operation against a real foe.Terrorizing women and children at night in the West Bank or Gaza is not dignified nor is it moral.
but you did well in inventing terrorized women and children at night.
more vicious is killing a child's parent infront of his eyes. Without TRIAL
It is not much, but it is a start toward ending US support for Israel's brutal occupation of a powerless minority in its midst.
Compareance with ageing bottles of wine. After many years some bottles have gone bad, and so has Patrick Leahy. He can be compared with a norwegian right-wing politician, Willoch, who made a 180 degress flip-over and landed in the crouch of left-wing politicians, and started hate-writings against Israel. Bad, bad wine....Their behaviour must be based on lack of popularity and recognition by media. Sure it is hard to go into retirement when years seems to end..
You are implying that Leahy made a flip over, but if you would have read the article properly you could have seen that this is not the case at all. Leahy was the principle sponsor of a 1997 bill prohibiting the USA from providing assistance or funding to foreign military units suspected of human rights abuses or war cxrimes. Obviously Leahy has the courage of his convictions and defends the same principle when the suspected human rights abusers are Israeli military personnel. He must know that by doing this he will risk the ire of the pro-Israel lobby. In today's USA that takes guts. I have good wine in my cellar and the Leahy vintage of 1997 has aged beautifully.
Israel should not worry and actually should completely try to start to look to other options then rely on America, and accept this motion. It is obvious that the opposition by Israel shows that it might not be able to. Where is this proposed economic power now? America is a massive human rights violator historically and even today with its world adventures where tons of civilians have been killed. I don't think Israel should worry about this, at all, but instead should attempt to find ways to mature from these instances - and not listen to hypocritical bills. Also, it is absurd that US taxpayers should fund Israel.
and the numerous human rights violations inflicted by US forces. Of course, I would not demand any country to fund other countries' wars, but this is just very hypocritical. I hope he's against US world adventures as well.
Too bad he's been coopted by the wrong side.
I wonder if the Senator is fussed at all by the U.S supporting the Palestinian budget, and millions of American’s taxpayer dollars are going to convicted terrorists in Israeli jails, Ranges from $400 a month, to terrorists serving up to 30 years receive a $3,400 month wage Bearing in mind many of those serving the longer sentences are for the murder of innocent people including women and children Richardwittman.com
but outside!
supporter of terror and terrorists. I wonder how advised the American people are on the issue of their tax dollars paying PA and Hamas terrorist's salaries while they are in prison?
since few seem to have a problem with the billions sent to the real terrorists (Israel) a few bucks to the oppressed is hardly noticeable.
He on,ly received 71% of the votes in the recent 2010, heavily Republican favoring elections. Since he chairs the Senate Foreign Relations ommittee, the bill is likely to at, least minimum reach, the full Senate floor.
I do not think so. The junior Senator of Vermont is jewish, independent and (maybe) the choise of the 1,7 % of the jewish population of Vermont. The more than 60 % are still possible. Wrong hope.
realistically, with AIPAC in the country and just how backwards the elections, are you are probably right
Brad! Thank you for underscoring the entire world's view on the treasonable AIPAC gang.
Bibi, you are committing a blunder of stupendous proportion, endangering israel's security immediately and in the future. Israel's very existence depends on it's support from America: material, moral, military, and political. By dismissing Obamas considered advice to stop settlement expansion, and continue negotions, you are jeoprodizing Israels very existence.
as PerplexedZionist states. It is a rogue state, and I am proud of it. Jenny
Leahy is a right winger in Vermont politics, the conservative so to speak. The Junior Senator from Vermont is Bernie Sanders, well to the left of Leahy. The US is a diverse country. Right and left is relative. Leahy is far to the left of Obama.
Leahy has a bill that is against Israel? He must not want to be re-elected eh? Isn't the IDF the peace keepers there in the Golan Heights? What would happen if they were not supported and pulled out of there?
America needs more accountability. IF some funds allocated to these human right violators are eventually cut, Israel will compensate by re-allocating from other sources including American aid for other purposes. Therefore, America needs the guts to stand up for human rights for all and break away from its long held hypocritical stance which offers Israel endless impunity over terrible war crimes.
If Israel occupies Gaza, then how do you explain Hamas' control of Gaza & it's kidnapping of Shalit?
without the overwhelming support of the American government BUT Bibi's unwillingness to negotiate, and outrageous continuation of settlement expansion and repression of the West Bank has many many fair minded supporters disgusted with Israel's intransigence. Nobel prize winner, Issac Bashevis Singer said the Holocaust was just one black pearl on a long necklace of tragedies to befall the Jewish People in history.. It will be rivaled by the collapse of Israel if it continues on it's course of repression of the Palestinians which has gone on for 44 years. Bibi, for God's sake, listen to your American friends and sit down and begin negotiating.
seems like you're the only politician in America who actually cares about ANYTHING other than money.
Its about time most of these morally deficient politicians break the ice and take action against Isreali Human rights violations which are documented by all major Human rights organisations such as Human rights watch,Amnesty International to name a few.
One Senator can stop anything for a time, or indefinitely if supported by a minority of others. Nothing can become law if a minority of 41 of 100 in the US Senate objects. Something could pass unanimously in the US House and still stall forever in the Senate. The rules may not make sense, but they have been in place for decades. It used to be harder to pass anything, but Senate power has been diminished.
Since when is the US assistance being given to Military specific units?
The declaration of a Palestinian state will trigger massive changes, and israel's procrrastination will be useless in the face of international sanctions and boycotts. Last chance Bibi. Rethink, reboot, and start talking with Abbas, NOW, or witness the drastic decline of Israel on all fronts.
But I am afraid Aipac rules in the US congress! Nothing seems to change that, not the cluster bombs left in Lebonon, the brutal Cast Lead operation in Gaza, the killings at sea of the blockade protesters, the smearing of the name Goldstone, tge stealing of land. All this and a joint session of Congress cheers Netanyahu as he talks of his biblical claim to all of the land from the Red sea to the Mediterranean!
Anti-Semitic slander is never far beneath the surface.
Both countries are as guilty as each other of serious crimes against humanity.
How about sanctions against Israel for human rights violations? Why is that sanctions only apply to non pro-American nations while pro-American nations can commit the same crimes and do not get sanctions imposed on them? Looks like the rules of democracy and forcing these rules are imposed only on those who do not follow or serve American interests.
We all know for what party to vote in the next elections.
We need more men like him in Israel and the USA.
When will American Jews realize that the Democrat Party is no longer on our side. Hamas can commit all kinds of attacks on innocent civilians and we don't hear from Leahy about that.
Perhaps they are on the side of justice and human rights?
If these protesters will get their way with Senator Patrick Leahy they will protest to other sentors like other boycotts elsewhere in the world and it will be another new way for them to fight Israel
I don't see much comming out of this. He promoted Israel's right to seld defense and wants to cut what ever aid goes to these units. It defies logic but it might make a few of his constituancy happy. Also, Israel was vindicated as far as the Turkish flotilla goes.
make it sound respectable and even prestigious - and would probably not be used by many Israelis to describe Palestinians "operating" in Israeli territory, "arresting" people during the night or killing them.
.... and send it all to east Africa where it is needed
We don't need their handouts, but they need our arms purchases, to keep more workers from becoming unemployed.
Dude, what money to do you think pays for the arms? The money that you get from the USA. It is a subsidy.
We don't need their $3 billion military aid. There was an Israeli budget surplus of NIS 12 billion last year. That's over $3 bilion. In bad years, the budget for ultra-Orthodox parasites and settlers can be cut. This way the US will depend on us, Israel, because if we don't buy their weapons systrems, tens of thousands of American workers will become unemployed.
The 'aid' is given in loan guarantees and military aid. Israel has never really bought any US military hardware, it has worked by using the aid money to 'buy' US military hardware. Effectively it is given to Israel. Stop taking the money, please, but you will have to spend on military, money that you have never had to spend before.
Uncle Sugar GIVES Israel $3billion, and then leads him into the US Lolly Shop, where Little Ehud can "buy" whatever he wants. Q: What happens if Little Ehud refuses to spend that money? A: Uncle Sugar will take back his money and buy those lollies for himself.
Given the the extreme pro-israel christian right are republicans anyway, i guess you must mean the Jewish vote? Thats a mere 1.7% of the US population. Surely not enough to win an election democratically. Ooooooh! I see, you mean a whole bunch of anti-democrat attack adverts and other such tools that represent a subversion of democracy will be funded. To be honest with you, a tea-party influenced republican government will simply hasten the end of this horrid US-Israel tie-up. I welcome it
Another democrat to get out of office, Vermonts' other senator is a self styled socialist
He is a lefty who voted 96 percent with the Democrats. He is also up for election in Vermont. With a little luck the bum will be kicked out. Why to American Jews vote Democrat thinking that they are friends of Israel? Most are friends in lip service only.
Look at that! Israel cannot finance its own army and considers itself "independent". Don't you see? Even America is disturbed to be involved in Israel's crimes against humanity.
Israel has few friends, and to ignore and contradict them is a historic folly. Israel could not exist without American support, and it is time to listen and do what they say. NEGOTIATE NOW.
Leahy should go live in Gaza were trying to deport him !!!!
Not even close. The American people and their reps know better, and Leahy has to deal with the fruits and nuts of Vermont who keep him in office.
You might want to learn about Senate power. It is a reason Washington works the way it does. One Senator can stop anything almost ad infinitum.
At alst an American politician says somehting historical. I mean where were the American politicans before?
You who applaud this while there is a tiny country surrounded by much larger countries that want to destroy and push the Jews into the sea. How can you applaud this tiny country losing part of its defense? If it wasn't for the United States and it's power destruction would be constant over there. I'm sure there are many who dislike the Jews but as a people dealing with other people you would want that tiny country to be able to defend itself from people who have it in their constitution to destroy Israel. Unbelievable!!!!
the flotilla-thing could had been thwarted off by simply apologizing for it... but this government is doing really all and everything WRONG... and then expect, it doesnt have any consequences, effects...
the senator is just the first crack in the ice. unless israel starts to negotiate and stops settlement it's situation will decline markedly and be totally isolated on the world stage. more american politicians will speak out, and aipac will not be able to hold back the wall of criticism and sanctions. yes, as has been said here before: a stone wall cannot hold back the tsunami of pro palestinian sentiment. israel failed to negotiate for years and it's position has seriously eroded.
Truth must be said that Israel can survive financially an do well without this aid. Bibi suggested gradual reduction of this aid in the 1990s and was right about it. Especially now that the US economy is in trouble. What I do not like is the "tone" of Leahy's comments. He is no friend of Israel. Never was as it turned out.
the problem for Isreal, the way it acts internationally, it has no friends!!!! Bibi and the rest of the fools in Isreals' present govt, insults and bites the hand of the only friend it has
obama's election has unleashed an unprecedented assault on israel from all quarters. furthermore, people feel free to use that certain "tone" when speaking to or about israel. the double standard is quite striking.
Leahy is the conservative Vermont Senator.
IS A GIVEN..Typical far leftist democrat who can wish,BUT ULTIMATELTY not WIN. However time Israel stop taking UNNECESSARY handouts from the bankruptted USA anyway. Israel is better off economically than the US too It must be remembered.. .
["In Judea and Samaria, the Jewish people are not foreign occupiers," Netanyahu had said to the sound of cheers and applause from the senators and congress members.]
we could use that money here to pay for our own children's education, medicine for our retired population, and social programs to help our poor. Enough is enough!
Leahy is damaging his own party
boycotts, sanctions, cutting aid are all in the future if israel does not heed the warning signs. it must start to negotiate. if not now when? grabbing more land and building more walls will make things worse.
Leahy, a career politician on the far left of the spectrum is known for his off-the-wall ideas. There is no need to pay him much attention as congress and the senate is strongly behind Israel, as are all of us, Americans.
Truly informed Americans, aware of Israel's continued abuse and maltreatment of Palestinians in the occupied territories, are not strongly behind Israel. How could they be? Israel's behavior runs counter to our fundamental values, its "democratic" form of government notwithstanding.
Aipac nor public opinion can no longer keep America's unconditional support and vetoes in the UN. Bibi should heed this wake up call. Israel's only hope for the future is to start face to face negotiations with the Palestinians and come to a settlement. This can be dealed, but the price becomes ever higher. Palestinines recognition as a state will be a turning point in history, and it seems Bibi and Israel have missed the boat. History will not be denied.
This, as Lincoln has said, is to make a point and lay a marker. All US aid to everywhere is likely to either end or be cut 10% automatically by Christmas. If Eric Cantor, - in Israel now - can stomach talking to Steny Hoyer, in town last week, there may be a deal to end all foreign aid to everywhere except Israel. If there is no deal, then all aid to everywhere will be cut 10%.
You cannot make military aid conditional on operational uses ... war is not a game and you can say I will use my American gun to kill bad guy number 1 but I will not use my American gun to kill bad guy number 2. For a politician its so easy for a soldier its not so easy. This bill is going nowhere, this is an election year for Obama so the Democrats must start trying to look Israel friendly, The Republicans now Control Congress and they have been pretty good to Israel and there is no way this will pass so Israel has nothing to worry about.
America sells weapons to Israel on the basis they can be used only in defense...not offense. One would hope the IDF is intelligent enough to tell the difference. The Mavi Mara incident and Cast
1. "You cannot make military aid conditional...." Of course we can. 2. This is not an election year. This is 2011. The election is 15 months from now. The bill doesn't HAVE to pass--this action will expose millions of Americans to arguments against our relationship to Israel that they have never heard before. 3. "The Republicans now Control Congress..." Actually, they PRESENTLY control the House of Representatives. Leahy is a member of the SENATE (controlled by DEMS) and is a leading member of the Appropriations Committee, Leahy is the CHAIRMAN of the Committee's Subcommittee on State and Foreign Operations. 4. As bad as Obama's polling is (for now) the Republicans as a group (BOTH Houses) are getting approval ratings that are much worse. As for the Republicans-in-disguise Obama haters (and actual Israeli's) who portray Obama as the most anti-Israel, anti-Semitic...etc...etc...etc..., please recall that George HW Bush was prepared to cut off ALL aid to Israel at one point in his presidency, that Clinton had extremely ambivalent feelings about Israel and that is was George Bush who denied the transfer to Israel of "bunker busters" for use against Iranian nuclear sites. He also approved the program for equipping, training and funding of the PA security forces. Obama however, who continues to defend Israel at the UN and who is obviously aware "...the United States Army is looking to increase cooperation with the IDF, and will hold one of the largest joint exercises in the two nations’ history in 2012, a senior American general said on Wednesday." (JP 8-11-11 http://www.jpost.com/Defense/Article.aspx?id=233317) MUST be an anti-Semite for ever daring to question Israel's conduct.
Well, I never knew.... Sure, go ahead, pull those Israeli funds out of Afghanistan and see how much the USA squeals. Just don't hold your breath while you wait for the outrage, OK?
pleeeeeeeeeeeese israel funding us predators!!!!!!! that is the ultimate lie. oh how i wish it were true!!!
While 29 Republican and 24 Democrat Congress members are on their all expense paid trip to Israel, Leahy has the courage to take a stand for justice and peace. If ever he was one of the recipients of the pro-Israel lobby largesse, he surely will not be now.
He needs to cut back before the situation gets too sticky.
Immoral wars never pay off, but will nonetheless be waged until the very last agura is spent. Now I may love or hate Israel, but this is my only home. Therefore I call for international support to end this terrible, terrible occupation.
obama has proven that even if the majority of americans support israel, a hostile president can do much harm even in a few years. israel's total dependence on the united states is not wise.
No IDF member shall ever be accountable for any act. Got It.
Obama is not hostile to Israel, but, like most civilized people, he's hostile to our occupation. We need to stop being paranoid and understand that the days of colonialism are long since over.
you are basically right to look for new allies. The Senator represent a small state, but he is an influential person. Maybe he is also aware of the fact that Colonels violating human rights ,have the best chances to be promoted in a general rank.
lots of choice to choose from.
I think there are no many countries who would like to be an allies with Israel at the moment. Israels policy is very bad.
1 the major receipients of u.s. military aid are afghanistan, pakistan and iraq, all three terror states and enemies of the u.s. they are all three major violators of human rights in all respects. 2 the u.s. has been fighting numerous wars for decades in which it has committed war crimes. 3 the unslaught on israel since obama became president is despicable and unprecedented.
Iraq pays cash now. Israel gets $3 billion, Egypt - $2 Billion, Jordan - $2 Billion. US is fighting a War in Afghanistan and paying Pakistan for access. Iraq and Afghanistan started by Bush. US has NOT bombed Israel or even shot at an Israeli since Obama became President. All the US has asked is a little civility and a willingness to negotiate in good faith. US moved in Libya to stop a genocide. Where were your troops?
as a matter of fact, obama had increased aid to pakistan. in gratitude, pakistan was hiding bin laden and giving access to top secret american stealth helicopter to the chinese. well done.
dont you know that the afghan and iraqi governments are US sponsored how do you accuse them of terrorism didn't the US occupy these two countries to get rid of the terrorists. aghhh the extent of zionist delusionalism
I believe every president's Mideast foreign policy is affected by the Jewish vote and some of the evangelical vote. I believe If Obama didn't have to worry about re-election he would actually vote in favor of some of these UN resolutions that the works votes for. And maybe just maybe cut off some military/foreign aid if they keep ignoring international law. Keep your fingers crossed. ;)
especially seal team six. Also the army rangers.and predator flights. Also aa cia operatives in afganistan and Irag. BUt he's too cowardly for that.
Someone is finally trying to do something!
They have lost their way for ages. Not even the attack on the USS Liberty in 1967 got them out from under the Zionist yoke.
The first politician has expressed his true opinion and many more will follow, not intimidated by AIPAC. The only sensible course for israel is to listen to America, stop building and start negotiations. It will only get harder to make a settlement if bibi and ehud barack continue on their fatal policy of oppression in the territories. Palestine will be a state in september.
It's about time someone in the american government actually see's the criminals and murders for what they are!
Cutting off aid to Israel in the gaza is suicide on every front - letting a terrorist regime go without any oversight is complete lunacy. Hamas - the Terrorist government that was elected by the palestinian people will grow and grow without anyone being able to stop them - are you people MAD??
We want America to be more independent israel is a wealthy country.
The politicians do not bother about right or wrong. So they join with homosexuals pro palestinians and other anti social elements to garner votes. So politics has become a gambling. So hereafter israel should not put its eggs into one basket called usa. It must concentrate upon african states even if they are ruled by dictators.
The US is giving money to Hamas Egypt the PA and other Muslim and Arab states who are of no benefit whatsoever to the US.Israel instead is the only reliable US ally in the ME.....This guy can Whistle Dixie and no one of any importance will be listening...
More like most problematic child!
An American Senator with decency and courage who needs all the support possible from Americans and others who seek justice for the Palestinians.
and with his list (flotilla, adressing the courts etc), this senator has quite some points to make, in terms of human rights... now, we have heard them again.. and you know what ? just my bet on it - we will hear more and more often, and from more influential people...
The American people are not being served justice while annual billions go to support institutional human rights abuse in an already wealthy country.
Who starts getting their throat cut? Several things come to mind. First, Israel may hope that republicans will be willing to cut the defense budget to pay for welfare for Israel's settlement program. Second, Israel may hope that democrats will take every penny given Israel out of Social Security. Third, we can be real and with replacing the income slashed in the Bush Tax Cuts off the table, then the question is will the USA slash all non-defense expenditure and endure the still imbalanced budget? Or will it slash the entire defense budget and enjoy a tiny surplus? How about seeing welfare for non-voters being sacrificed in an attempt to avoid cutting both defense or Social Security? Israel and Netanyahu destroyed Obama and is worse off than had he not been destroyed. It is an old curse that one should get what they wished for.
obama is a really bad president. furthermore, he created the diplomatic impass by trying to impose his own will on a sovereign state. his hatred for israel knows no bounds. he has set up the region for years of war. he is totally unable to compromise. he has no judgment, as i had posted during the american election campaigns.
In the Bush II years, Patrick Leahy signed the Leahy signed Schumer-Graham letter to then Secy. Rice to pressure friendly Arab governments into opening trade with Israel. Now, his interests are shifting against Israel. Now why would this be? Instead of analyzing it, right wingers will try to minimize it and say that this 35 year veteran of the Senate is unimportant, or that his state is unimportant (as if that made a difference in the Senate) or that he's a left winger (from a state that hardly has a left wing tradition - it voted for Hoover for God's sake). Maybe this will pass muster as long as you don't venture out of the right wing bubble, but consider that he's just one of the many who have grown disgusted with Israeli preference for settlements over peace talks (not to mention meaningful economic development that is such an issue in Israel at present) . Couple this with the new Rand Paul Republican isolationists and tea party devotees who want a government as limited as their grasp of reality, and you have a real problem looming in U.S. -Isarel relations. It's going to be increasingly hard for right winges to block reality out of their consideration, but when it comes to ignoring reality, the Israeli right is very proficient, and I'm sure they will rise to the occasion.
the times are changing, and the only wise choice for israel is to start negotiating with the palestinians and stop stalling. Ehud Barak said the tsunami is coming, and a stone wall will be no defence.
israel needs to reboot and realize dealing with the palestinians fairly and negotiating an agreement is the only path to future security. stalling, walls, targetted asassinations, propaganda mean nothing. if israel is to survive and flourish it needs peace and not procrastination. the senator did israel a favor. Bibi, listen and save the country and your role in history.
Is Israel really the problem, or do is the root problem anti-semestism and prejudice? Look what the Syrian government is doing to their own people. Military weapons used on UNARMED civilians, yet everyone turns a blind to them. Its obvious, if Arabs do these things to themselves, they keep quiet cause it looks bad on them, it makes Israel look good, so all the anti-israel protesters out there keep quiet. People just look for an excuse to hurt Israel. It's pathetic and so transparent. ISRAEL FOREVER!
Oh. That is right. Cast Lead. The recent Nakba day against Arab refugees approaching the fence by the Golan. Rachel Corrie. Peace Flotilla 2. Bilin demonstrators. I could go on but I think readers get my point. . .
Ummm I think you'll find the US is not funding the Syrian Army. In fact, more and more sanctions are occurring daily from the US on Syria. The IDF gets way too much money from the US and spend most of it bullying innocent Palestinians trying to live as normal a life as possible under the oppressive israeli government that is occupying their sovereign territory. I fully condemn the Syrian situation as well but you just cannot compare apples with oranges.
Bibi has to negotiate. If not now, then he will only bring down further catastrophe on the country. He and Ehuc Barack are fooling themselves only. Israel cannot sustain the occupation.
lets remeber the words of menachem begin i will rather go collect in every house in israel then giving up land and you could keep your money america
Leahy will be getting a campaign contribution from me and should get ones from those who respect human rights.
...and should get campaign contribution from Iran and Al Qaeda as well. "Oh God, Watch Over Me From My Friends. Of My Enemies I Can Protect Myself"
Bibi can expect America to seriously withold aid vetoes, unless he stops expanding settlement activity and starts negotiating. he has been told repeatedly by virtually every friend of Israel, but he is not listening. This is an historic turning point. Israel cannot stand alone against the world. A tragic turn of evens that bibi is responsible for entirely. There will be no place to hide from the tsunami.
a new anti Semite in the senate we have to get rid of all these stupid senator vote them out of office
What about some well thought out response?
I`ll be the first to call true anti-Semite for who he is. Leahy is not him. He had and has Israeli high rank politicians as friends for many years. Its just left wing templated ideoligy this days, especially radical or far left, may more often than not create the anti-Semitic feeling of unreasonable, unrealistic charges against Israel or her right wing government. As a matter of fact, many true anti-Semites had found convenient cover and blended in behind it in tearing into Israel. Sometimes it is clear who is who, sometimes not so. Leahy is definately not one of the anti-Semites.
What is it with Jewish people. This is not anti semitic. It is anti government policy etc. Just because people disagree with Israeli policy or US funding to Israel, you automatically label it as anti semitic. It's got nothing to do with it.
american, please define "antisemite"
Since when does the United States provide direct financial support to 'elite' IDF units ? Does the US directly support the building of the illegal settlements?. The answer to both is no because if she did the US would be in breach of international law. translation: the large sums of monies which the US transfers to Israel yearly enter one big pocket and are shifted to many other pockets in a process that basically launders the monies as to lose track of where it goes. Israel never gives the US full account of where the monies are ultimately spent. If the good senator wants to do all of us a favor , he needs to cut all the US grants to Israel significantly. Id Israel has money to build hundreds and thousands housing units in the West Bank, it needs and most definitely deserves no financial support whatsoever from the US.
When those elite units send their officers to American military colleges for training, I would suggest......
The IRS gives US citizens tax deductions to US citizens for making contributions to 'non-profit' organiztions which monetarily support the building of settlements and financial support to settlers living in the settlements built in the Occupied West Bank. The IRS has made reports to Congress about this and has asked for changes to the tax code to remove the ability of organizations to recieve tax breaks for doing activities which directly work against stated US foreighn policies - but AIPAC has too much political influence and clout for this to happen at present. I know, I know for many of you this shows that I am either a self-hating Jew or an anti-semite.
demographics and time are changing not just the region but America too - Israel acts more like a relic of a bygone day - it is not a normal state - even the abnormal states of the region, surrounding Israel are falling - the times they are changing,
if you like throwing money down the toilet be my guest...and somehow I have never heard of the U.S. financially supporting the IDF..something stinks here and it smells like leahey...a true uber leftist/commie wanna be.
Israel is trying to act as a Western State, with so called Western pseudo morals. The reality is when Israel starts acting as a Middle Eastern country, which she is, then she be judged as such.
An American politician who actually condemns Israeli abuse of Palestinian human rights in the occupied territories, that really is a novelty - he should be awarded the congressional medal of honor for his courage in the face of adversity - he has my vote.
only open negotiations can help Israel. Bibi's stone walling will be wiped out by the tsunami of Palestinian support.
abuse of human rights is defined as abuse, and Israelis are not excused from their violations.
Both Bush The Elder and Senator Leahy are right in their positions. Israel vindictively attacked Bush for his position, and I expect it will attack Leahy in the same manner.
WE can now expect some incredibly vicious personal attacks on this man and his family and anyone who supports him. In particular, there will be some pretty horrific attack ads through that unaccountable process of front groups. Leahy's opposition could state that he thinks the US currency should be cheese, as long as he wears an 'I love Israel' T-shirt, he will get the financial support he needs. Not the vote though, the adds and money are needed to get the vote itself.
Close to 30 rockets were fired into Israel since the beginning of July. Why is Leahy so silent about that?
And this is a guy that Jewish Americans have been supporting for years - just another knee-jerk leftist.
The best one can say is he's slightly to the right of socialist Bernie Sanders - his Senate colleague also of Vermont.
No, the BEST you can say is that Vermont at least has two of the left most Senators in the country. The rest of the country is too confused to think straight.
There is one American Senator brave enough to speak out.
speak out about what...things he knows nothing about...another useful fool in the u.s.senate that carries water for the commie in chief obama.
Is he brave look at what he is choosing people who fire rockets to Israel and when Israel fire back it is reported by world media that Israel attack gaza sometimes they say at the end of the artical that hamas fired first they dont say hamas fired first and then IDF fired back Palestinians use these tactics and get away with it
Isn't human abuse that the PA is giving convicted criminals a salary for killing civilians? What about this young Israeli who was killed in a bus by a rocket from Hamas territory? I didn't Leahy's stupid denouncing. Okay so he is okay with the right of Israel to defend itself. How do you do it and then called abusive of human rights? Leahy's life is an abuse of human rights.
They don't make a lot of noise in Vermont but when they do you should pay attention.
The American congress is up to their eyeballs in budget concerns. There have been programs for Americans that have been cut even though their cost was less than the aid given to Israel each years. Aid to Israel is now on the table. Leahy put it there. Let's see how many senators rush to support aid to Israel while they are cutting aid to Americans and raising their taxes. This is especially timely as the American voters are ready to sweep them all out of office for their botching of the budget.
Why in the 1st place does USA use so much of its own money aiding foreign countries ? Whats the USA agenda, what strings attached, USA never do it with compassion, always a reason. As far as I am concerned, USA should shove its mickey mouse aid directly up its own behind, then world might become a better place.
The beautiful state of vermont deserves better representation in washington, than is supplied by this buffoon . His thinking has become muddled over the years and his retirement should be speeded up.
Israel takes our money but does not respect our laws. It is supposed to use US weapons only defensively, but it does not know what that word is. Bravo, Leahy. The measure will not pass, but someone should speak the truth, and you are it, man.
Does he now proprose to cut aid to those Us units in Afghanistatn and Pakistan that caused the death of innocent people?
We have no business being in either country so yea, pull them all and stop funding the fake governments we've put into power.
Apartheid could not be sustained, neither can israel's occupation. wake up bibi. Tsunami is coming.
Exactly how does abandoning Israel to the terrorist hordes launching thosunads of missles against Israel, bombing buses, schools and restaurants., murdering families in theri beds advance US interests? Israel is the only democracy and ally of the US in the middle east. Perhaps Leahy would prefer another shraria contolled country like Iran. Is this his goal and obama's?
The only thing more disgusting than a bunch of people who choose to live on welfare is a bunch of arrogant people who choose to live on welfare. America needs to cut ties with those people and let them sink or swim under their own power.
Yes, Israel relied on support to get its feet off the ground, like most countries do, including the aid the Palistians so richly deserve to get their feet off the ground, however newflash, years have passed and Israel has grown to a country with one of the highest GDP per capita, the highest GDP by far compared to its neighbors, excluding one who happens to be sitting on a pile of oil..and off course the higest contributor to science and technology per capita in the world...no matter how baised you are against Israel, you tend to lose so much credibility when you misrepresent the facts so blatantly....it will make it very hard too believe if you do in fact have a sound arguement one day..
The US should stop supporting the PA, Pakistan, Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan and the whole Muslim world for that matter. Nes't pas Harzion?
You mean over 25% of USA population, makes sense especially when the kettle calls the pot black.
Patrick Leahy is a brave soul. Unfortunately, his plan will not even budge an inch. I commend him for taking this on; I only wish the hapless and spineless Congress was conscientious and wide awake to how ruthless the IDF is.
he will get no support, the limited support Leahy does have - and we know here it comes from - has no influence in the US, the majority of North Americans support Israel and its rights to self defence, despite the cowardly approaches of it enemies forcing the IDF behavior.Thsi all steams from the fact, and as an Israeli stateswomen said, there will never be peace until Israel's neighbors love their children more than they hate Israeli's
A proposal like this coming from a senior democrat might be the final straw that leads the Jewish vote to shift republican. It has no chance of passing congress but will harm democrats in 2012 if the issue gains traction.
A proposal like this coming from a senior democrat might be the final straw that leads the Jewish vote to shift republican. It has no chance of passing congress but will harm democrats in 2012 if the issue gains traction.
He bowed down to pro-pal protest in front of his office. Wuss. Unlike in gaza or the west bank I will call him and tell him what I think of his coward self.
However, he is the far left politician. That carries with it human rights template way beyond any reality. If he had been sharply critical of Israel, especially for Cast Lead, it is not surprising it had to eventually boil up and rear its head somewhere. Together with an opportunity to show his constituency he is still the democracy`s `mover and shaker`. It will make some noise and he will come to his senses.
You mean we have one senator who hasn't totally sold out?
Will the senator call for a withdrawal of funding for the US units who kill innocent civilians in Afghanistan?
Three were convicted two weeks ago at Ft Lewis
Time for the US to give equal amount to Jews as they do to Muslims. That would only be fair.
No worries. It seems that whenever an American politician is so remiss as to criticize Israel he is quickly shut up and becomes a Israel fanboy. We saw this happen when Rand Paul suggested cutting aid to Israel earlier this year. We saw it happen to Obama when he asked for a settlement freeze, and now we can see what happens with Leahy. One thing is sure. Whatever it is that Israel does, they better do it quickly.
Republicans control.
The guy is from the still Democratic Senate--still nothing will come of it. AIPAC controls both parties. It has controlled the Dems much longer than the GOP. In fact, I remember when it was Dems accusing conservatives of being 'anti Semitic ' times change
Seems to me that the funder of terror should also be held accountable?
anyone who supplies the PA is definately responsible for terrorism.
Israel should cut all aid to the US immediately!!
When you take your GI joes out of the playbox then you can imagine that you are training US troops and denying them entry into your room. Refuse to give them crayons, pasta, and coloring books! You can practice your checkpoint etiquette by throwing them around and bashing them into the walls in a fit of rage.
If we're going to play this game, then let's play. Not only should we cease aid of all forms to Israel, but we should also recall all diplomats, demand back every single one of our weapons that's in Israel (which includes planes, defense systems, guns, etc,) demand that Israel pay back every single red cent that was sent their way WITH interest, and we'll also drop our decades long policy of Israel apologism in the UN. Think you've seen it bad yet? As a singer once famously sung, you ain't seen nothing yet!
Mr. Leahy should cut aid to the CIA and other US military units who abuse human rights. The bottom line is that Israel lets Palestinians report abuses and Israeli soldiers are held accountable for serious violations. There is more to Israeli soldiers being disciplined then one should know.
Has Israel ever given any financial aid to America? They can surely use it now. The common people are so broke .
This guy is representing Vermont in the US Senate. For does of you that don't know, in the US Vermont comes about right after Guam and Hawaii when it comes about influencing important US foreign policy decisions.
Leahy is a senior member of the senate. For this reason alone he will be listened to. For those 100 senators, the state does not matter a bit. Only seniority matters.
is showing. Finally, a US Congressman with courage to stand up to the Israel (illegal) lobby. Hopefully the entire US population with come to its senses and see how the tail (MONEY, POWER) has wagged the dog and corrupted the US Congress.
Every State has the same influence in the Senate. As republicans have proven in the last 3 years, a single Senator can prevent any presidential nomination from approval. A single Senator may table any bill. A single Senator may prevent the Senate from doing anything. Every state has two Senators.
Leahy, who heads the Senate Appropriations Committee's sub-committee on foreign operations, was the principle sponsor of a 1997 bill prohibiting the United States from providing military assistance or funding to foreign military units suspected of human rights abuses or war crimes. The law also stipulates that the U.S. Defense Department screen foreign officers and soldiers who come to the United States for training for this purpose.
Is that a new American word?
I listen to a lot of talk radio from that part of the country and I'm telling you that patrick leahy is about to get a lot of flak. I am just waiting for him to demand the same for his own military and police.
This sounds like its ON TOP of the billions in annual military aid the US gives Israel - so it can can continue its human rights violations as an occupying power!
Patrick, My Check is in the Mail!
you come off as a complete fathead spitting out blatantly inaccurate information like israel receiving a quarter of US foreign aid. i agree with your opinion that israel shouldnt receive us foreign aid but please be accurate with your facts or it only tarnishes the credibility of the rest of your argument.
To all you Israelis wondering who this guy is, I offer the following from his Wikipedia biography: A big fan of Batman comics, Leahy lent his voice in the Batman: The Animated Series episode "Showdown". He appeared in a cameo role in the 1997 film Batman and Robin, and in the 2008 film The Dark Knight. Leahy wrote the introduction to the collected edition of Green Arrow: the Archer's Quest and the foreword to the first volume of The Dark Knight Archives, a hardcover reprinting of the first four issues of the Batman comic book. And that's who this guy is. Nuff said.
And I am behind him!!!!Thank god an American politian stands up for America instead of Isreal!!!!!! I suspect as Americans wake up to what they have been supporting, more and more Americans are going to applaud what Sen. Leahyhas only begun!
The tiny state of Vermont has great skiing, friendly neighbors, great sea food, and an abundance of snow. Sen. Patrick Leahy of Vermont knows nothing about living next to neighbors whose culture promotes suicide bombing and irrational hatred of Jews. Duvdevan, Shalag, and Shayetet 13 are vanguards that protect the safety and security of millions of Israeli civilians. Leahy's suggestion of withholding funding for such units is as logical as snow skiing in the West Bank.
He should cut aid to all USA Special Forces & put them on trial for crimes against humanity & may as well throw in the CIA & many other USA murderers.
I would not go so far as to say he has a set of ..... I would go so far as to say he is an empty headed socialist with commie leanings like his fellow senator the idiot sanders...vermont might be a beautiful state but boy their representatives are nuts.
Barak would like to sell you the Temple Mount for a very affordable price! What a crock!
patrick will always regret this shameful act.
If anything, he didn't go far enough. The bill should have called for a COMPLETE cutting of aid to Israel, not just to certain IOF (Israeli Occupation Forces) units. He's one of the very few politicians who hasn't betrayed the United States of America, and for that, I couldn't be prouder!
But Israel would be wise to start planning on ending US military assistance. US is going broke.
It seems to right to be true or to become a fact !!!!
" U.S. military assistance to Israel would be subject to the same restrictions that apply to countries such as Egypt, Pakistan and Jordan" What's wrong with that?
Is there any kind of democracy in Pakistan, Jordan and Egypt? No? If not, the cases are absolutely incomparable.
US aid to Israel is in the US` interest. Were it not thre would be no aid.
Israel can not claim to be a true democracy and expect to be allowed to act undemocratically.
Pakistan Jordan and Egypt dont continuously promote themselves to be 'democratic'.....though I would say the People have loudly voiced their desire for that...whereas the place that always claims it is a democracy is in fact devolving into a fascist place...where racism has been at the head of the table since day 1.
Just because Israel has proclaimed themselves a democracy, that means their human rights violations should have a different criteria than other regimes? You can call yourself anything you like, the proof is in your actions.
There is no democracy in Israel either, stop talking like it doesn't treat it's non-jewish citizens as second rate citizens.
Is there any kind of true democracy in Israel? No, the cases are absolutely comparable.
It is absolutely not anti-Semitic. It is about accountability and human rights and public trust in our representatives. He is one of our most respected leaders!
You're assuming Israel is a democracy. This is a zionist lie. It is in actuality an ethnocracy.