Pete Seeger officially joins anti-Israel boycott
Seeger, 92, one of the fathers of American folk music, is a veteran political and peace activist.
By Nir HassonAmerican folk music legend Pete Seeger on Monday officially joined the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions campaign - an international movement to pressure and sanction Israel through economic means.
Seeger, 92, one of the fathers of American folk music, is a veteran political and peace activist. In the 1950s he was interrogated by the McCarthyist House Unamerican Activities Committee and two years ago performed for U.S. President Barack Obama's inauguration concert.
|
Pete Seeger |
| Photo by: AP |
His songs "We Shall Overcome," "Turn, Turn, Turn," "If I Had a Hammer" and "Where Have All the Flowers Gone" have all become anthems for peace movements and civil rights.
Seeger contributes half of the royalties from "Turn, Turn Turn" to the Israeli Committee Against House Demolitions.
On Monday, Seeger withdrew his support of a project associated with the Jewish National Fund's American branch, after Israeli and Palestinian activists told him of the JNF's role in driving the Bedouins out of their Negev areas.
After a meeting with ICAHD coordinator Jeff Halper, Seeger reportedly said his participation in the JNF project had been misunderstood and announced his support for BDS.
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
There's no fool like an old fool. He could sing all of his song in Israel, how many could he sing in tha Arab world?
When Pete supports something against Israel, does he then supports those who want to destroy Israel? I think that Pete should clarify his position, so we know where he stands. His recent shifts shows poorly for the once very popular idealist. It seems like history now for the old man.
Pete Seeger was a big supporter of Israel. However, I am also very saddened with the way Israel is going. Some nationalistic trends are taking us in a direction that is detrimental (especially in the long-run). We have to stop vilify everyone that criticises Israel. It is neither good for our standing internationally, neither is it good for ourselves. Pete Seeger & many of his fellow folk singers have had a very pro-human approach in their music. He is a positive man. If he takes a stand, I do listen!
Jewish organizations and agencies like the judiciary must not only act in a fair and just manner they must be seen to be acting in a fair and just manner. Surely, the JNF's actions towards the Bedouins has done more to sully Israel's reputation in the rest of the world than the whole war on Gaza. Hamas presents as Israeli's clear and sworn enemy, while a few Bedouins with their tents and little else are seen as powerless and victimized. Don't blame Pete Seeger - blame the JNF for turning our friends against us.
I wish I had the guts to do it too.
"I tell people I don’t think God is an old white man with a long white beard and no navel; nor do I think God is an old black woman with white hair and no navel. But I think God is literally everything, because I don’t believe that something can come out of nothing. And so there’s always been something. Always is a long time. This would be my argument with most religious people. They think of God as being mainly concerned with what goes on in our Earth. God has got many things to think about." - Pete Seeger
"I tell people I don’t think God is an old white man with a long white beard and no navel; nor do I think God is an old black woman with white hair and no navel. But I think God is literally everything, because I don’t believe that something can come out of nothing. And so there’s always been something. Always is a long time. This would be my argument with most religious people. They think of God as being mainly concerned with what goes on in our Earth. God has got many things to think about." - Pete Seeger
Instead of supporting BDS, Seeger should support J Street and organizations like the New Israel Fund, which stand for the values which Israel should embrace.
I admire your work, music and politics, over the years, so I am perplexed to know why you have taken a stand against Israel. When you weigh the rockets and anti-semitism, and calls for Israel to be wiped off the face of the map and compare that to the work Israel has done from being the first to set up a medical center in Haiti to the many freedoms in Israel compared to all the other nations in their neighborhood, well, do the math. Criticizing Israel is good, it's healthy; so, by the way, is praise when deserved. To sign on to deride Israel, the good and the bad become all bad. I'm sad to see you do this because I admire, still admire, what you have done over the years, but many people will now unthinkingly say, "We'll if Pete Seeger has joined in, so will I."
I guess Israel is a safe place to protest, after all he cant go after all the dictatorships, they would probably hand him his head on a platter. Poor old fool.
did he listen to or investigate the other side of the story? Palestinians have a good propoganda machine. PR is no longer the prime domain of the Hebrews!
As a lover of Pete for over 60 years, he has now reached my boycot list. I have been pro-peace for all my yeARS SO i DO NOT BOYCOT THE only democracy in the middle east!
God speed.
Get a grip Adam...noone would mind a Jewish state that agreed to a fixed set of borders and ended its violent threats against its neighbors. THere is a context to the anti-Israel sentiment in the world and it has a lot to do with Israel's BEHAVIOR towards its neighbors, particularly the Palestinian living under occupation.
Pete Seeger, we need more people like you in the world. Maybe then it will change and get better. You are one of the very very few Americans who know right from wrong and have dedicated you life to make things better for those who suffer and need help. You are a true and model human being. Toda Raba.
Let's review: He is a staunch supporter of repealing all laws banning illicit drugs; Supported the likes of McGovern who promoted the demise of Israel; and now performs for Obama, admittedly one of the most Antisemitic pro extreme Islamist Socialism leaders ever to disgrace the WH. Speaks volumes
Keep on signing the truth as long as you can Pete. Your positions have always been moral and the propagandists and distorters will continue hating you for it.
But being deluded and arrogant also. What has that to do with Pete Seeger?
I'm not surprised. he wrote an anti FDR song in early 1941, when the CPUSA was still anti war (and the nazi soviet pact was in effect). After June 1941, that went down the memory hole.
Seeger was a member of the Communist Party before WW II when Stalin and Hitler signed a peace treaty. When asked how he could be friends with the Nazis, Seeger said he was trying to prevent the WW II Really? He did not succeed.so well. Also Seeger showed his anti-antisemitism is the famous Newport Festival in 1965 when he insulted a Jewish musician called Bob Dylan.
Boycott Pete Seeger
What's to boycott?
Kapo
exist in this world. Good for him...
If you succeed in bringing Israel down who will you boycott then? The islamic jihadists that will wreck havoc on the country leaving death and destruction in their midst. You Joe will be as responsible as the attackers. Don't join something you know nothing of.
It isn't about bringing down Israel, it is about bringing down the right-wing policies that support fundamentalist Judaism and discriminate against progressives.
Seeger was, many decades ago, part of the US' far left camp. Clearly he's learned nothing over his long life, as he still hues to discredited "progressive" values.
...is that he's been consistently right all those years. About Vietnam, Cuba, Nicaragua, civil rights, human rights. Certain values are absolute and don't go in and out of fashion.
This leftie made a career out of visiting college campuses to foist his leftist world view on as many college students as possible. He was doing it when I was in college, and believe me, that was a loooong time ago...
The Israelis that have tunnel vision don't seem to see that it's religious fanatics are being noticed. What sort of anti- is it when Former Chief Rabbi Yosef, leader of the Shaa Party, claims that non- Jews were created, like donkeys, to serve the Jews. The government remained silent on his comments. Do they belive them?
Only people like you will save israel from self-distruction
I prepared a dossier o n the question and sent it to Pete, who's been a good friend and comrade for over half a century. He said he would read it carefully. Clearly, he has done so.
propaganda conducted by Karl Dallas is immoral. feel good. do bad things. opposite of Gene Sharp, John Rawls.
a comrade huh? Haven't you heard communism failed and is dead....why would you want to belong to a failed and ugly way of life that only benefited the leaders and brutalized "the useful idiots"?
as are his patrons.
A new record coming out?
Arabs are always innocent victims,never responsible for anything they do.
After all, given the track record of 'egregious, and likely deliberate mistranslation' that has been put forward and accepted as 'what they tell their people in Arabic' it would be idiotic to rely on translations by certain parties. (PS, I leave it to the reader to go digging for the source of that description of the translations provided so thoughtfully. Good luck hunting though, because unlike the 'genocidal quotes' who's quality prompted that outburst from someone who had thought them to be actual quotes, it isn't repeated ad nauseum by website after website)
or notice the Arabs make no attempt to prepare their people for reality there will be no millions of Arabs moving to Israel
or is it called Leibermanism these days?
Not a mention of the real problems in the Middle East,but this is the usual behaviour by people like Seeger,it does'nt matter that innocent civilians around the Middle Eastern countries are slaughtered on a daily basis,the problem here is,if he says something,there is nobody to say,well done and it is not fashionable to critisize other Middle eastern countries,only Israel.
Seeger is just part of a growing trend, for whatever reason he finally joined. The movement is growing and for Israel's sake I hope it grows fast. Like South Africa, the only thing which is going to save Israel from itself is international pressure. Let's hope there is still time. At this point the chances of a two state solution are pretty slim although nothing is impossible. Within years, if not months there will only be a one state solution and everyone knows that will be the end of a religiously defined State and possibly the end of a State called Israel. Thinking Israelis should be supporting BDS not taking offence.
because they refuse to tell their people the truth.
Except by Jews.
senile alter kacker...
no credibility noticed in Pete Seeger's support fro BDS. Let us hire lawyers to defend the Bedouins. Let us see if the case is credible.
You're sounding like Mubarak and Qaddafi with your declaration that "palestinian activist - who want a fundamentalist Palestinian prison state". This scare tactic has long expired!
Another friend and admirer of Israel who is apalled by Israel's behaviour. Pete Seeger has been a beacon for lovers of peace and freedom for more than half a century.
He didn't have much upstairs before. He should be a good boy and take his hippy medication.
I guess daffy duck is next to announce his boycott.
that is the boycott will keep growing, until israel starts hurting. its just a question of how much hurt they can take. eventually they will fall in line for their own good. for the record i endorse and follow the boycott, for whatever its worth.
& who the hell are YOU? Talk about arrogance are YOU "giving back" Kashmir?
a piece of a gandu, ma ka chut, what on the earth do you know sitting in your India village about Middle East or Israel?
a gandu is a gandu...... whats a piece of a gandu? your hindi is rusty
He was brought up as a racist and thats all he is. He is ignorant and un-educated. He can not realize what is right or wrong and has no idea of the world he lives in. Much like Hitler was and Netanyahu is now.
This guy been always doing the right thing!!! His conscious is alive .. not buried yet like the settlers ..
He died long ago and they forgot to bury him.
It will be his loss !!! You guys can Hire Beyonce or Usher, they will perform anywhere if the pay is good !! No question asked.
Pete Seeger has to know better. Boycots bring deeper suffering to the weak and the poor of the society. For the same Bedouin he wants to protect from the reforestry he will indirectly make life harder in many other ways. Speak out against the Israeli governement policies, protest, do something creative to bring out your anger, WRITE A FREEDOM SONG but do not deprive the regular Israeli citizen,may it be Jew or Arab. The ones whom anyways struggle on many levels, far beyond of what can be comprehended from far away comfort zones. Economic boycots are not the way you hurt the people you try to help and that counts for everywhere, not only here.
The World view of Israel has changing and now see it as the oppressor of the Palestinians, where as 10yrs ago all they saw were the terrorist attacks. Some movement toward peace is needed very soon or it will only get far worst.
I'm not offended at all. And note that the article states "reportedly" in connection to his latest actions.
to get him to see it their way .
Not that I ever listened to his music, though over the years I have been enlightened to the antisemitism of a number of artists I did like, notably, Neill Young. I stopped listening to him totally. There are plenty of hall-of-fame musicians who proudly support Israel, placing the truth and integrity before popularity and profit.
Pete Seeger is not anti-semitic. Far far from it. He is a hero to many people, Jews included. He stood up for the working man when speaking out meant a trip to prison or being black listed (he experienced both). His music is the stuff on which Americana is made. What child grew up without singing IF I had a hammer or This land is.. He made a stand on the Israeli-Palestinian issue. You may or may not like it but he is a hero. BTW, I am Jewish, love Israel and always wanted to hear Pete Seeger and Arlo Gutherie in concert. Please resolve the problem between Israel and Palestine.
why doesnt he boycott libya mianmar cuba venezuela or other countless dictatorships because its ok to boycott israel and cool i guess antisemitism disguised as anti israelism i will burn his CDs so my royslties from listening do not go to suicide bombers
You can burn his CDs, but the royalties are already paid ...
YOU ACTUALLY BOUGHT HIS STUFF...
1) I wonder if Seeger and the other "BDS" "artists" are also boycotting China, Russia and every other police state in the world. 2) Of course not. Instead, the boycotters focus on a pretty small market to use as self-promotion. You look hip, and it doesn't cost you much. 3) Even as much as I am disgusted with the whole scene in the terrortories,I won't support boycotters.
so you are boycotting boycotters????
at 92 this old relic is about to expire...
The only thing you are a hostage to is your ignorance. Yep, Israeli Arabs have it so badly that they have been actively protesting against the state .... not. Although Israeli Arabs are treated in many ways as second-class citizens or a potential fifth-element, they are far, far from being either unrepresented in Parliament or denied the basic human rights of life, liberty, freedom of speech, religion, etc. I don't see any of them clamoring to be included in a Palestinian Arab state.
Israeli Jews take offence very easily. Joining a boycott of Israel is all it takes. They should not take it porsonally that Seeger has done this. He should have done it long ago. He had to have his face rubbed in it before he would geek.
During the McCarthy era and during Vietnam is when some of his best works were written. He wasn't blacklisted because the MAN couldn't.
If you can take some "should: advice for yourself: there is mainly grey between your black and white....
which got him and his group blacklisted at what should have been the peak of their career!