• Published 04:56 18.03.10
  • Latest update 10:52 18.03.10

Menachem Begin shot dead, Sadat in jail, Carter walks free

Police arrest 21-year-old Lod resident, who denies killing Israeli-Arab 'peace triplet'.

By Yuval Azoulay Tags: Israel news

Menachem Begin is dead.

That may not sound like news, since Begin the Israeli leader died 18 years ago, more than a decade after making peace with Egypt in 1979. That year, the "peace triplets" were born: Menachem Begin, Anwar Sadat and Jimmy Carter Kidasa.

"When the boys were born I truly believed in coexistence," said Ibrahim Kidasa, their father. He and his wife, Hitam, thought they would raise their three sons in a new society, one that has put down its weapons and chosen to focus on building the peace.

But yesterday morning, Menachem Begin Kidasa was shot to death in Lod.

The police arrested Na'ef Radwan, a 21-year old resident of Lod, as a suspect in the killing. He denies it. Police are investigating claims that Radwan was angered by Begin's drinking alcohol near his 19-year old brother, so he went home, got a pistol and shot Begin. Radwan is being held in custody for five days.

"How will this help me now? Nothing will bring Begin back," Ibrahim said.

"We are Arabs. When the killer is a Jew, Israel will do everything in order to bring the murderer to justice, from anywhere in the world. Here they killed an Arab and who cares? Another one that was and is gone."

Sadat, meanwhile, has been granted furlough from prison because of his brother's death. He landed in prison a decade ago with a three-month sentence, but has been serving time since then because he killed another prisoner two days before his release. Now he is due to be released again, in two months.

The morning the triplets were born at Assaf Harofeh Hospital in Tzrifin, the small home of the Kidasa family was filled with flowers and well-wishers. Yesterday, hours after Begin's death was confirmed in the same hospital, hundreds came to the house to offer their condolences.

Ibrahim has lost the hope that drove him to name his three sons after a historic peace, he said. He learned that good intentions will do nothing to get his family out of the poor neighborhood that offered them little beyond crime.

"Look at the children growing up in Rishon Letzion, in the afternoon," he said. "They go to after-school activities, they go to the community center. There is nothing like that here. Our children do not know what after-school activities are. This is no way to create coexistence."

On Tuesday night, Lod residents called the police to complain that drunks in the neighborhood were disturbing their sleep. The patrol found Begin there and the police officers say he promised them he would get things quiet. The officers left and two hours later, gunfire broke out in the same area. The police searched the backyards and the alleys, and found Begin bleeding on the ground. He had been shot in both legs and was bleeding to death.

Begin uttered a few words and lost consciousness. The officers called an ambulance and the medics described his condition as critical as they rushed him to the hospital. After a short battle to save him, the doctors declared him dead.

Like Sadat, Begin had also been in prison. Ibrahim never visited his sons in jail, though.

"It was humiliating for me and I could not bear the shame," he said. "I am an Arab, and before every visit they wanted me to strip to see I was not smuggling in drugs. For me this was new. I had never had any run-ins with the law, never been arrested."

"I am fed up," he said. "We had a lot of good will, but we were unlucky."

  • Print Page
  • Send to a friend
  • Share
  • Text Size +|-
 
 
TalkBacks

Why Facebook Connect?

Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.

Add a comment

Add your reply

  • 11. 0 0
    Coexistence
    • Inge Detlefsen
    • 19.03.10
    • 12:02

    Dear Israeli, You are ever so right, and I sympathise with you. All the best for you and my beloved Israel.

  • 10. 0 0
    jimmy carter abondoned the pals
    • abdalla
    • 18.03.10
    • 14:55

    was it all to sell books jimmy

  • 9. 0 0
    He is right about coexistance
    • Israeli
    • 18.03.10
    • 14:28

    We talk alot about coexistence and fairness. We have a carrot and stick approach to the Palestinians. A stick to beat the violence out of them, yet there is rarely any carrot to support those Palestinians who do want to coexist with us. There are many Palestinians who do want to live side by side but we do so little to make their voices heard and make them part of the country.

  • 8. 0 0
    How stupid we are
    • Amos
    • 18.03.10
    • 13:27

    What sort of life could they find , what have we done to improve the life of our citizens and not only arabs, go see the film ajami

  • 7. 0 0
    Short-lived attemts to subdue Palestinins and Muslim rights
    • sami abu ismail
    • 18.03.10
    • 12:46

    Policy makers and startegists know very well before anyone else that those defunct agreements with dictotor regimes or selserving leaders acting as wealers-dealers do not hold. The major peace agreements with Egyptm PLO and Jordan were merely ruses the West had concluded with people rejected life and maudit deads. The rights in the Holy land are for Palestinians, Arabs and Muslims. The Arab and Muslim nations would not compromise. Palestine is not for sale, not one inch of it. This truth is eternal and final even if Zionists and Westerners now rule supreme in our regions. But, freedom will be gained by every means.

  • 6. 0 0
    guns at home
    • Assem
    • 18.03.10
    • 12:38

    In our village, almost every house has illegal guns and rifles. When there is a conflict, often physical fighting including gun shooting takes place. When the police comes to investigate, it' s family, clan and village against the police. Blaming the government is beyond the point. We need to finish with blood feuds and comply with the law rather than tribal interests and customs.

  • 5. 0 0
    Where to start
    • Joseph
    • 18.03.10
    • 10:12

    First of all, my condolences on your loss. A parent should never have to bury a child. But the problem for you sir, so like many other Arabs, is a failure to take responsibility for your lives and always to blame others for failures. Let's take the issue of after school activities. First, what is the rate of arnona (municipal tax) collection in Lod amongst the Arabs. 20 or 30% at best and in Rishon more likely 90%. A well known but often ignored problem, is that the Israeli Arabs do not collect tax and then complain about poor service. And what about youth groups. I grew up in the Boy Scouts and Young Judea--organized by volunteer parents in their homes. Where were you and your community. You have a mosque which can be use for meetings. So you see, your community needs to take more responsibilty to solve its own problems.

  • 4. 0 0
    Jimmy Carter Kidasa
    • TW
    • 18.03.10
    • 09:56

    From reports on the news yesterday. Jimmy Carter Kidasa is a law abiding citizen without a blemish to his good name.

  • 3. 0 0
    Pathetic
    • Solovey Razboynik
    • 18.03.10
    • 09:28

    Mr Ibrahim sounds like an excellent human being, full of hope and a yearning for peace. How sad that society is so violent and that his family is now suffering as a result. Condolences and prayers for a better future.

  • 2. 0 0
    That was my question too?Where is Jimmy?
    • Mike
    • 18.03.10
    • 08:48

    My sympathies with the parents, to hell with Menachem Begin and where is Jimmy?

  • 1. 0 0