I quit Labor post over Barak failure to push peace
Is it possible Ehud Barak hasn't changed? Is Ehud model 2009 really the same as model 2001?
By Daniel Ben-Simon Tags: Israel settlements Ehud Barak Israel news West BankThe last time we met, two days before the opening of the Knesset winter session, I asked Ehud Barak where he was heading. He said the Labor Party was on the right track. I asked why West Bank outposts hadn't been evacuated as promised, and he said that day was fast approaching. I posed a similar question to him toward the end of the summer session several months ago, and he told me the same thing - the day was approaching.
We would meet often in his favorite fortress, his spacious office in the Defense Ministry. As usual, he was in good spirits. Did he know something we didn't?
"Look, Ehud, there is no peace process, there are no negotiations, there's no settlement freeze or outpost evacuation. We haven't done anything we promised the public," I told him. "What will we tell the Israeli public?"
To my astonishment, he said we have no partner, that there's no one to talk to. I remembered that nearly a decade before, when we heard similar lines from Barak, they sank the country into despair and brought a series of misfortunes in their wake.
Is it possible Ehud Barak hasn't changed? Is Ehud model 2009 really the same as model 2001?
It wasn't easy to bring the party into Benjamin Netanyahu's coalition. Only after Netanyahu agreed to move mountains for the sake of peace and economic and social progress did the Labor members consent to joining. Meanwhile, I looked forward to the pairing of Netanyahu and Barak, hoping the two had learned some lessons from their first miserable term in office, that miracles were possible in the political arena.
If they wanted to move forward, nothing would stop them. If the charismatic speaker and decorated general decide to make history for the nation's sake, who can stop them?
They cooperated as no pair of leaders had before, and the power concentrated in their hands had not been seen since the days of David Ben-Gurion. If they made a breakthrough, the wider public would follow them blindly.
"Ehud," I pleaded with him at one of our meetings, "The public is waiting for news. Party members are despairing - they're beside themselves with worry. They fear that at this pace, the party won't even be there at the next election."
"Danny," he said, his voice rising. "You don't understand who we're dealing with. We made them a lot of offers, but they refuse to enter negotiations."
I reminded him that we had yet to remove even a single outpost. What message does that send to the Palestinians? Why should they believe us while the hammers at the settlements and outposts don't stop pounding for a minute? Is this the way to help a U.S. president full of good intentions advance a genuine peace effort?
I was left without any comforting answers. I reminded my boss on several occasions that unless things changed, I would create a crisis within the Knesset faction, just one more crisis in a crisis-ridden party.
Yesterday, two hours before I intended to announce I would be leaving my post as the party's faction chair, we held another talk.
"I sat with the prime minister yesterday until 1:30 A.M.," Barak told me. "And you know what we talked about? Outpost evacuation and renewing talks with the Palestinians."
To mark the happy occasion, Barak suggested I postpone my retirement. For some reason, I chose not to meet his request.
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
Ben-Simon keeps harking on about illegal outposts and he is right to do so: their removal **IS** part of Barak's ministerial responsibilities. Those outposts are on occupied territory. The IDF is the occupying power. The IDF answers to the Defense Ministry. The Defense Minister is Ehud Barak. It Is His Responsibility To Evacuate Illegal Outposts In Occupied Territory. And, as Ben-Simon points out, not a one of those outposts has been evacuated even though Israel agreed FIVE YEARS AGO to evacuate them. He's had enough of Barak's duplicity, and I for one applaud him.
"Look, Ehud, there is no peace process, there are no negotiations, there's no settlement freeze or outpost evacuation. We haven't done anything we promised the public," I told him. "What will we tell the Israeli public?" - Daniel Ben-Shimon It is not as if Israel is a nation with a few fairly stabile parties, but Avoda, and before it Mapai were the leaders of the left for a long time. Now there is no Israeli left left, and Labor has become Barak's personal hobby horse. Daniel Ben-Shimon couldn't go along with Barak's prevarication's anymore.
is not months, but weeks away. But did I say the months and weeks of a specific year?
Yes be dodgedly pursuig your innocent dream; but you shouldn't take to your heart Danny, and you know what I mean,,,these days. I never thought that Barack has the fabric of a history making, but Netanyahu has it in him, His whole outlook has peceptebly changed and moderated his thoughts and possibilities are just waiting to become reality. Thus, Danny, don't give up, you'll be in need in a future configuration of Israeli Government. Inter alia: it should be said whom, not who...
... that a new official authority has been set up, together with the Ministry of Defence, with an annual budget of three million shekel... the sole purpose of which is to prove the "legality" of various settler aquisitions... whatever, this official chutzpa, with the compliance of the Defence Ministry, is mind-boggling...
Ehud Barak is the Defense Minister for Israel and his job is to safeguard the safety of the people living there. We can ignore the fact that he is doing a poor job of doing that, but how is fighting for peace with an enemy determined to exterminate you any part of his responsibility. Labor as well as other leftist parties did poorly in the last Israeli election. The fact that he has any government position at all is a gift to the leftists.
But you didn't manage to make a difference. Barak's become what he always looked like he was going to become and the Avoda party really is shot. Much better to start a new one so that the work towards peace can begin. That's right, begin. It hasn't started yet. Moral of the story: Never believe ruthless go-getters who play Chopin on TV.
You cannot affect policy if you quit the team. Moreover, the safety of the Israeli people ought to be the first concern of ALL Israeli politicians. So, if that was not your top concern, mabe it's better that you did quit. Enjoy retirement!
I: "Ehud sacrificed almost anything humanley possible for peace(with Arafat96% of the WB and a 100% of Gaza even the Saudi king told them to grab that offer with both hands) guess what happened next?" I can tell you: Arafat wanted to see a map showing that "96% of the West Bank", and Barak said "No, you can't". Case closed. After all, would you buy from a dodgy used-car salesman when he won't even let you inspect the sales brochure?
Ehud sacrificed almost anything humanley possible for peace(with Arafat96% of the WB and a 100% of Gaza even the Saudi king told them to grab that offer with both hands) guess what happened next???? 72 virgins are alot more desirable than peaceful co-existence for some people. Case closed