Haaretz regrets move to charge Uri Blau for 'doing his work as a journalist'
Justice Ministry announced that it's considering charging the Haaretz journalist with holding classified information without authorization, and without intention to harm the security of the state.
By Ofra EdelmanThe Justice Ministry announced on Wednesday that it is considering charging Haaretz journalist Uri Blau with holding classified information without authorization, and without intention to harm the security of the state.
The indictment is pending a hearing with the attorney general. The ministry said that although the clause of the law possibly violated refers to "aggravated espionage," Blau is not accused of espionage in the ordinary sense.
Haaretz responded in a statement that it received the ministry's announcement "with regret." It added: "We are confident the hearing will make it even clearer that throughout this affair, Uri Blau was doing nothing but his work as a journalist, and was acting according to the accepted norms in covering the defense establishment."
The ministry said that "once the investigation was completed, the attorney general accepted the general position of the state attorney, the Shin Bet and the police, and arrived at the conclusion that this case was unusual and extreme. Taken into consideration were the scope of the leak and the damage that it caused and could have caused, as well as Blau's own conduct throughout the affair."
Anat Kamm was charged in the affair for copying approximately 2,000 documents during her military service and making information available to Blau.
|
Uri Blau |
| Photo by: Tal Cohen |
The Justice Ministry statement said there were several reasons behind a move to prosecute Blau: the quantity of the documents that he held, the unmonitored and unsecured manner in which he held them, his conduct vis-a-vis the authorities in the matter - "the fact he failed to return to Israel to be interrogated when asked to do so - and the claim that he "misled the authorities, making them believe the classified documents have been returned to the IDF."
The ministry alleged that Blau was originally requested to return the classified documents under a promise he would not be charged, not be asked about his sources and the documents would not be used as evidence against him. He then returned some 50 documents to the Shin Bet, creating, the ministry said, a false impression that he had returned all the classified documents in his possession. When the investigation of the leak found the number of documents given to him by Kamm amounted to 1,800, he was requested to return them all.
Blau had left Israel the month Kamm was arrested and decided to stay abroad.
He returned some documents through his attorneys, during his stay abroad, but, the ministry claimed, he still retained some documents.
He then agreed to give over to the state all classified documents in his possession, including ones he did not acquire through Kamm, with the state promising to evaluate the damage their leak has caused, but to destroy them without trying to trace Blau's sources.
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
Damage to the state? Oh yes indeed! It revealed Israel's extralegal methods. But the funny thing is...nothing was ever again heard about that story...a story that had been approved by IDF censors IAW the law! It was buried, and never mentioned again. But lo and behold...some of those involved in plotting and carrying out this illegal act, have been since promoted to higher places. Damage to the state: Minimal!
Who can forget two famous quotes from Louis XIV: (1) I am the state, (2) It is legal because I wish it.. As the King of France, Loius XIV was one of the most powerful men of his time. He could get away with such ideas. Israel of today is a tiny democracy, with the emphasis on tiny, and a ? after democracy Still Israel's right wing government has more in common with a 16th century king than you would think. As for Uri Blau, he was not only doing his job, he was doing it very well and at some risk it seems. A free press is the cornerstone of democracy. The press must fill the gap when the government's opposition is silent.
very funny!!
Charging Ms Kamm reduced Israel's credibility as a democracy, but charging Mr Blau is on a different level. Here is a fun project for anyone. Google the three phrases **censorship journalist "uri blau" ** (without the ** and with only "uri blau" in quotes). Right now on Google in North America there are 10,900 hits. Within hours of a charge there will be a hop, but this is such a hot button (censoring journalists) that it will probably hit 100,000 in days and 1,000,000 in weeks. It will be the primary topic on dozens, perhaps hundreds of blogs. Who is running the show in Israel? Oh yeah, not the media. Got it.