ANALYSIS / Israel-PA relations have never been so good
Abbas and Fayyad have quelled anti-Israeli incitement, tightened control over PA security forces.
By Amos Harel Tags: Salam Fayyad Mahmoud Abbas Israel news PalestiniansMohammed Na'if, a 14-year-old Palestinian from the Jalazun refugee camp near Ramallah, was killed Monday night by Israel Defense Forces fire after Na'if and another youth threw firebombs at the settlement of Beit El.
A force from the Kfir Brigade saw them, and one of the soldiers shot Na'if. The IDF investigation showed that a bullet aimed at his legs hit the youth in the abdomen. He died of his wounds in an Israeli hospital.
The death of a teenager during Ramadan would normally have set off a wave of riots in Ramallah. But current relations between Israel and the Palestinian Authority are very different from what they used to be, and the city remained calm.
Tuesday morning, a senior PA official called Brig. Gen. Yoav Mordechai, head of the Civil Administration in the West Bank, and said "there are rumors in Jalazun that the boy was not even throwing firebombs." Mordechai denied this, adding that if his Palestinian interlocutor were not convinced, he would send over photos from the scene. "There's no need," the Palestinian said. "If you say so, I believe you."
Mordechai is a key member of the Israeli troika that has been carrying out a silent revolution in the West Bank for more than a year. Its other members are GOC Central Command Gadi Shamni and Brig. Gen. Noam Tivon, commander of the IDF forces in the West Bank - both of whom will soon be leaving these positions.
The process has been closely watched by Chief of Staff Gabi Ashkenazi, Defense Minister Ehud Barak and, lately, also Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. But it has mostly been built from the bottom up: It began in the field and only later expanded to the government echelons. The chief of staff describes it simply: "Wherever they [the PA] take more action, we will take less action."
The international community is mainly interested in the lifting of restrictions on Palestinian movement and the optimistic forecasts for economic growth on the West Bank (at least nine percent in 2009). But what will determine whether the experiment succeeds or fails is how much blood is spilled.
Since the start of 2009, 13 Palestinians have been killed in the West Bank, and four Israelis. In 2008, 51 Palestinians died, and no Israelis. The last suicide attack inside Israel took place in February 2008, claiming the life of a woman at a Dimona mall. The security situation has changed completely, and it has led to the improvement in the Palestinian economy - though Netanyahu's promise of "economic peace" still seems exaggerated.
In view of the calm, senior IDF officers have begun referring to the PA's leadership - President Mahmoud Abbas and Prime Minister Salam Fayyad - in terms never before heard from such highly placed Israelis. Even during the brief period of hope that followed the Oslo Accord, the attitude was not like this.
Abbas and Fayyad have completely ended the former Palestinian doublespeak about violence, lowered the level of anti-Israeli incitement and tightened control over their security forces. Moreover, there is now close cooperation among the IDF and the Shin Bet security service, the various Palestinian security organizations, and their American advisers.
All this does not mean the Palestinian leaders have ceased to be tough opponents in diplomatic negotiations: On that front, they are making no concessions. And the compliments about their behavior on the security front have bolstered their negotiating position in the international arena.
The most noteworthy change in the PA's behavior has to do with the fight against Hamas. The PA got the point after the Islamist organization took over the Gaza Strip in June 2007. When Fatah emerged from its shock, senior PA officials recognized that if they wanted to prevent a repeat of Gaza in the West Bank, they must stop leaving the war to Israel.
First, they targeted Hamas' charitable network and placed Fatah-affiliated imams in mosques. Then they arrested Hamas operatives en masse, killing those who resisted.
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
It is so nice to read the thoughts of left-wing dreamers who have not read the statements coming out of the latest Fatah conference. Please tell us how your dreams coincide with Fatah's reality.
Of course Fatah is not inciting violence openly lately! Israel protects their leaders from Hamas! All of the terrorist in their group are either dead or in prison and no one wants to be the next!
According to this article, four Israelis were murdered by terrorists in 2009, while none were murdered in 2008. Is that what Amos Harel calls good relations? When no one has been killed on either side you can say that relations have improved.
but it's still a one way street. cooperating with Israel does not make the PA popular. There's still daily raids and many closures. And ofcourse as another article shows, Israel does not even want to stop building.
When Israel retreats to its 1967 borders, lock, stock, and barrel, than the proccess of Palestinian liberation will be complete in practical terms. The opposite of that statement is likewise true: peace will never come until Israel retreats to its 1967 borders.
phony baloney - complete masquerade palestinian israeli relations never been that's the story
As long as they are not hitting Ramat Aviv and Herzelliya, all is fine.
Change within the Palestinian society and politcal atmosphere are essential if they are to form a viable state. The lack of a democratic tradition is unfortunate, and the Hamas take over of Gaza shows the tendency of Palestinian politics to resort to power and suppression instead of a free flowing democracy. Unfortunately, Hamas must change and join Fatah in a united representative government for there to be a functional state. may that happen with all due speed.
It's been a struggle, hasn't it?
Israel, Egypt, Jordan, US are scared of Iran taking over the West Bank through Hamas. Therefore are at pains to be nice to Abbas and keep West Bank in peace. Unfortunately, this is a fools paradise - Abbas will simply use this to turn the diplomatic tables on Israel. The bottom line for Israel is that it is not in a position to strike any real deal - as long as the ultraorthodox are unwilling to cede an inch. Doing so would force them to break Halacha - something they just can't do. Not for Israel, not for anyone else.
Amos Harel, author of the libel against the IDF in his self-described "expose," now begins to try and sanitize the PA terror-abetting apparatus in the West Bank. Note how he writes nothing about the recent Fatah platform and its commitment to terrorism. The left wants Israelis to return to the delusions of Oslo, but it isn't going to happen.