• Published 01:28 25.10.09
  • Latest update 17:07 25.10.09

Analysis / Expect more trickery from Iran in nuclear talks

From Israel's point of view, there is an inkling of positive news in last week's developments.

By Amos Harel Tags: EU UN Iran nuclear Israel news

The excited responses, in praise or condemnation, proved to have been too soon. Iran continues operating at its own pace. The last deadline that the international negotiators set was Friday, and the Iranians did not bother to issue an official response to the draft agreement on giving most of their enriched uranium to Europe to be treated.

Instead of a response, Iran issued a rather murky promise of one toward the middle of the week, accompanied, as is customary, by contradictory signals. Last Wednesday's initial positive declaration was replaced with skepticism and further preconditions. We can assume fairly certainly that this is how Tehran will conduct itself in the future: more conditions, more delays, a strategy of making the powers believe it is still possible to resolve the crisis by peaceful means while squeezing out more concessions and buying more time for the centrifuges.

From Israel's point of view, there is an inkling of positive news in last week's developments. The draft agreement, as it was presented last week, would not end Iran's nuclear program, only postpone it. If it is adopted, it would make Israel appear to be an eternal skeptic. If on the other hand Iran rejects the deal, it will emerge as the refusenik.

A failure in the negotiations may expedite stricter sanctions against Iran. This will probably not be a Security Council initiative because China opposes this, but rather an American-European plan, which would have a shot at convincing the Iranians to reconsider freezing their race for the bomb. But we are still far from that. On the way there will be further ups and downs, certainly accompanied by other acts of trickery by Tehran.

Israel has responded wisely - it has kept a low profile, while retaining one advantage: its intelligence on the Iranian program is considered largely reliable and accurate, and is readily welcomed by the powers. The difficulty lies elsewhere. The international community, at least at this stage, does not favorably view an attack - by the U.S. or Israel - on the Iranian nuclear sites. It also appears that the declarations of the Iranian leadership, in particular President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, cause more fear in Israel than in the West.

Senior officers, most of them from Europe, visited Israel last week, and one of the hosts was surprised to note that most of their questions were about the Palestinians. When the issue of Iran was raised, the host was told that Israel's two basic assumptions - that Iran poses a serious existential threat, and that the Iranian threat precedes the need for a breakthrough on the Palestinian track - are not convincing.

  • Print Page
  • Send to a friend
  • Share
  • Text Size +|-
 
 
TalkBacks

Why Facebook Connect?

Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.

Add a comment

Add your reply

  • 8. 0 0
    Nobody yells death to Jews
    • Irani
    • 26.10.09
    • 14:38

    As abhorable as the present government in Iran is, they do not yell death to Jews. At least get your facts straight

  • 7. 0 0
    Israel is its own existential threat
    • Milad
    • 25.10.09
    • 18:42

    due to its addiction to its neighbors' lands. Every addict eventually peaks before the inevitable decline. Israel has to make peace asap. they cant be powerful all the time while their neighbors remain weak. The scale of power will obviously change one day.

  • 6. 0 0
    Iran's threat precedes Solving Palestinian Conflict
    • Stephen
    • 25.10.09
    • 18:20

    What political double-talk and it's not very subtle or sophisticated. Israel can not do much against Iran; but Israel expects the US to "carry its water." The US now starts with diplomacy with international conflicts--how novel a concept. And diplomacy is still not enough. Israel making peace is your one priority--start with Pals and other neighbors soon after. Remeber, Iran is afraid of Israel because everyone knows the Israelis have the bomb. Iran is not USA's highest priority--but we'll solve that too.

  • 5. 0 0
    West congratulates itself while Iran continues enrichment
    • Avi
    • 25.10.09
    • 16:52

    What a sorry world this will be if Iran tests their weapons on people. Not just Israel.

  • 4. 0 0
    "Trickery" is in the eye of the beholder
    • Druid
    • 25.10.09
    • 16:29

    Expect Iran to look after its own national interests rather than those of the U.S./Israel. Expect Iran to demand the absolute best possible deal for itself rather than give in in exchange for a pat on the head. Expect all this to be called 'trickery' by those who don't like it.

  • 3. 0 0
    Eric's existentialism
    • SDHD
    • 25.10.09
    • 09:07

    " that iran is an existential threat to israel is ludicrous" Would be easier to swallow if they didn't seem to be pursuing nukes, threatening Israel's existence through speeches, yelling "death to Jews" during rallies, feeding weapons and radical ideologies to proxies, and if Israel wasn't so small geographically.

  • 2. 0 0
    how come the west has it!!!
    • Najeeb
    • 25.10.09
    • 07:03

    I just want to hear convincing facts about who gave the rights to countries like USA, France, Russia, Israel, India, etc.. to build nuclear weapons and the rest of the world, like Iran cannot!! Iran is an IAEA member, yet India and Israel are NOt!!

  • 1. 0 0
    that iran is an existential threat to israel is ludicrous
    • eric
    • 25.10.09
    • 05:58

    even barak and lieberman have acknowledged that it isn't. and that dealing with the iranian threat is more important than a peace settlement with the palestinans is a concept nutured by israel as a way of sidestepping peace.