Settlers make water sources a tourist site and bar Palestinians from entering
West Bank Jews are making tourism sites of water sources that Palestinians use for agriculture.
By Zafrir RinatSpringwater continues to be vital to Palestinian farmers, but recently, at the settlers' initiative, many springs on the other side of the Green Line have been turned into tourism sites from which the Palestinians are barred. Hebrew-language signs have been posted near many springs; some places have become memorial sites for settlers killed in terror attacks or during military service.
Brown signs dot Samaria's roads bearing the Hebrew name of a nearby spring. This name is likely to appear on the Springs Route's site list on a tourist map of local councils such as Mateh Binyamin in southern Samaria.
|
A spring near the Eli settlement in the West Bank, Nov. 21, 2010 |
| Photo by: Dror Etkes |
Near the settlement of Talmon, which can be entered through guarded gates, a sign points to a site called Tal Springs. While a reporter visited this site, a settler appeared with a herd of goats, claiming he was in charge of the area and every visit must be coordinated with him.
"Thanks to me you don't see any Arabs here," he said. At a nearby spring, which was added to the list of tourism sites, it was made clear that the area's non-Jewish residents are not wanted. A large sign on a building nearby declares "Death to the Arabs."
According to Dror Etkes, who has been researching construction in the settlements for several years, at least 25 springs are undergoing development for tourism. "Access to these springs has been blocked to the Palestinians, and there are dozens of other springs that the settlers have marked as targets for takeover," he says.
Sometimes a memorial
Some of the springs combine a tourist site and a memorial. At Ein Arik, also known as the Spring of Heroism, a sign memorializes two residents of the nearby settlement of Eli who were killed in a terror attack. "In the place where life was cut off, new life will grow," says the sign. "Living waters will bubble, water the soil and make it flourish. We will continue to build and to be built."
When this reporter visited the place, a picnic was being held by a group of American Christians who had come to work in the settlements. Nearby Oz's Spring has become the Harel Oz memorial site, named after a settler killed by Palestinians.
"He gave his life to redeem the Samaria hills, he made his way along the paths of the land," reads a sign. Settlers planted an orchard at the site and painted a seven-branched candelabra.
At many sites chairs and tables have been set up for tourists. At one of them, Amasa Spring near the settlement of Har Bracha, there are "wading pools," one for men and one for women. At some sites access roads have been built, new pools have been filled and part of the area has been paved.
Actually, most of these sites are not just springs, but part of an ancient agricultural system that includes pools and channels that divert the water to plots cultivated by Palestinians.
"The takeover of the springs, while blocking access to the Palestinians, is only one reflection of an extensive project being implemented by the settlers with the full backing of the state," says Etkes. "They are trying to appropriate for themselves points of unique historical and landscape value such as nature reserves, lookout points and archaeological sites."
Stop-work orders
The Civil Administration's spokesman was asked to discuss the situation at four springs where there has been very extensive tourism development: Amasa Spring, Ma'ayan Hagevura, Oz's Spring and Meir's Spring near Neveh Tzuf (Halamish ). According to the Civil Administration, the construction work and the posting of signs were done illegally, so law enforcement has been stepped up; in the case of Meir's Spring the signs were removed.
In addition, stop-work orders were issued at several springs where illegal construction was done. The enforcement activities the spokesman was talking about did not have much of an effect because all the sites are now full of signs and structures built by the settlers.
The Civil Administration spokesman says he has no knowledge of any problem regarding Palestinian farmers' access to the areas around the springs. The Civil Administration and army noted that the Meir's Spring area has been declared a closed military area on Fridays because of demonstrations by Palestinians against what they see as the takeover of a spring they used for agriculture.
The Binyamin Regional Council said in response: "During the past two years there has been tremendous development in tourism. As part of the development plans of the Tourism Ministry and the regional council, we are also repairing murky springs and turning them into enjoyable tourist sites.
"The springs are not the council's private property and they are open to the general public. For clear security reasons, and in the wake of past terror attacks, the Israel Defense Forces does not allow Arabs access to the springs near the settlements. Other springs are open and accessible to everyone."
The Tourism Ministry, on the other hand, called the issue a local initiative of the authorities in Judea and Samaria that the ministry does not fund or market. "The ministry welcomes any initiative that leads to an increase in ... tourism, on condition that it is done according to the law," the ministry said.
The IDF Spokesman's Office said that as a rule, the army does not prevent Israeli citizens from going to Area A (under Palestinian control ) and Palestinians from going to the areas of Jewish settlements. But depending on security developments, a reappraisal is sometimes done to prevent friction among the local people.
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
Interesting analysis on history here. There is a history of loss by the Jewish people of the land - the Egyptians, the Babylonians and the Romans. It was Darius (Persian) who freed them from Babylon and ordered the temple to be rebuilt - the one the Romans destroyed. Jerusalem was a Canaanite city with a history at least 1000 years prior to the Jews arriving. The Canaanites are the ancestors of the modern Palestinians. Sinful Israel(i government) should be more concerned with its own actions than those of other men? The fear is that history will repeat itself.
to justify the huge injustice you are doing to the palestinians.Yes you are confiscating the Land,but you are also gaining alot of hate and resentment that will hunt you back and violently when the palestinians can strike back defending themseleves and that is going to be sooon.
as the saying goes, "too clever, by half"--thereby exposing that side of themselves which the vast majority will absolutely refuse to defend--thus leaving themselves (and their defenders)--to fend for themselves.
Everybody talks about settlers as if they are a separate country inside israel. They do what they do from stealing Palestinian land,to uprooting palestinian olive groves and attacking palestinian houses of worship and sometimes killing palestinians with the blessing of the israeli government. Israel the strogest of all ME contries combined and srtronger than most European countries militarily can surely stop the gangs of settlers if they wanted to.
And it has always been with the blessing and even instigation of the bosses at government and IDF and what is called the Civil administration in the West Bank, let alone the settlers gangs
I was in Samaria first time two weeks ago, and I didn't see any ""agriculture" near muslim cities. Only BIG houses, and BIG cars, such as mercedes 500 SEL, BMW's etc. On the contrary - near jewish cities in the same area I saw small houses and a lot of plants and everything was green. As we know that muslims actually DO have water (otherwise there wouldn't be any water heaters, and muslim houses are full of them) - why they don't plant anything? And then start to brag about ""water needed for agriculture""
I have visited our Land Samaria last year. I personally witnessed palestinians living is good houses and having adequate transportation. Samaria roads are full of yellow brand new minivans transporting palestinians. Jewish presence is nNECESSAY
I was in Bethlehem , among Christians who bought me bottled water to drink. I asked for tap water. They laughed. No tap water for 22 consecutive days. Israel shuts off the water mains regularly . While nearby Gilo was green and watering the lawns..Au , you have no clue of what you are talking about....
Several of the more progressive commentators try to "convert" those who are indifferent by deploring the effects of petty oppression on the Palestinian mentality (Israel is creating more terrorists than it kills). I, however, am more concerned by the deleterious effect on the Israeli / Jewish mentality. -- Read history. When a nation brutalizes and suppresses others living within it, in the long run it itself becomes brutalized and impoverished.
Any nation might be exposed to what you claim, i.e becomes brutalized if it suppresses others, BUT rememeber, you are talking about God"s chosen people. And Jews believe they are...!!! As for me personally,,,I know it should be a must. History is a witness to it
Most of the year there is no water flowing in these so called springs! Maybe some of the year there is a little trickle. It is a complete lie and an outrage to say that Palastinians actually use this as a water source! The truth is that the Israeli government pipes water to the Palastinians just like they pipe it to the Israeli "settlers". And by the way, if you have never been there yourself, you have no right to comment!!!
Exactly right! Before you say anything negative - witness it yourself, otherwise it is lashon hara!
not everyone can just up and go to these areas. we have to rely on the news agencies reporting.
I don't know of any Arab or Muslim head of state visiting Anwar Sadat's grave, a favorite haunt for American presidents and ex-presidents. Sadat is known in the Arab Muslim world is the "traitor" who sold out the Palestinians and surrendered to America and Israel. Egypt, under Gamal Abdel Naser, took Arabs into the Six-Day War and lost the West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem, Sinai and the Golan Heights to Israel. At Camp David, Sadat, his successor, settled for the recovery of Sinai and made peace with Israel, leaving the Palestinians under Israeli subjugtation. Had Egypt, the strongest Arab state, stood by the Palestinians, their agony would have been over long ago.
Weekly defamation of hated settlers by Zafrir Rinat is no news!
By the way, it is not a matter of hatered toward settlers, it is a matter of justice on one hand and Israel's chances of survival on the other!!!
i do not know why everyone gets so upset now, afterall, this has been going on for about 150 yrs!...the world did even praise the Zionist enterprise at the times of socialist copy paste, ie. kibutz movement...but in fact, the underlying motivation has allways been the same, sabotage Palestinian life, get them out, and occupy their land. "it was an empty land" so they say...
These are the offsprings of holocaust survivors , people risk their lifes to save their parents so they have chance to be born,...
I wouldn't want to have to face Him. This is evil. No way around it.
Salute, and thanks Colin, Even I couldn't have expressed myself better.
The Palestinians are "protected persons". They can not be barred from "water sources" merely by claiming them as "tourist sites". That is illegal; you must have a SECURITY reason for excluding them, and that requires a military order from the commander of the army of occupation. This. Is. Illegal.
You simply can not legally do this. Both the Hague Regulations (which are customary law) and the Geneva Conventions (which are treaty law) does not allow **any** occupying power to do this.
and loses
As a means to exert pressure on the Palestinians before negotiations this might be defended . If continued, this petty hooliganism on the part of the settlers will turn each and every Arab into an implacable foe of Israel . The Israelis should beware of putting the Palestinians in the same spot that Hamas tries to put Israel; turn to amed brutality or be turned into a loser. It is easy to see which part the Palestinians will choose.
might be ok. Harassing farmers and villagers will always work contra-productive, is stupid and illegal! Thus it can't and it shouldn't be defended!
Really humane to bar people from their water resources for tourism. They'd rather be called land stealers.
If you had to live like the Palestinians, would you not do everything in your power to gain your freedom? Israel creates more terrorists every day than they kill. The above article is but one reason why. Is Israeli tourism to illegal settlements more important than agriculture for Palestinians? Israel demonstrates every day that they consider Palestinians less than human and treat them accordingly. We all know who did that to such an effective degree. Do you really want to emulate Germany in the 30's? That's precisely what you are doing. What you call anti-semitism, we call anti-fascism. Gone are the days when the world looked up to Israel. If you continue on this path, you will never have peace and will be a pariah state.
Stop with the bs already as might is right Israel and it,s so called settlers are the stronger of the protagonists ,that,s the way it,s always been,might is right just as Islam is still occupying Constantinople that it too k from the Crusaders during the Ottoman ,eeEmEmpire
If you think that the success of Jewish immigrants in establishing the State of Israel is because "might is right", you know amazingly little about history. Israel exists because of the support of the West, and unfortunately for you that support comes with some inconvenient points such as a belief in human rights, international law, and decent treatment.
If you think might is right, don't complain about the Shoah.
I don't know who you are or what your philosophy is. But as an American Jew who lost all his relatives who remained in Europe to the Holocaust, I thank you for making this point, so that all those people will not have died in vain. "When will we ever learn? When will we ever learn?"
And this is one of them. Bravo
How impressive your words are, It surely touched me. May HaShem listen to you and lead you to the truth and reality.May peace prevail to both our Nations.
This is where I agree with you. The above article creates more terrorists every day. Of course the article has very little connection to reality, but that is a minor point. Hint: Haaretz routinely makes up stuff to demonize anything connected to "right-wing", and I suspect it isn't for ideological reasons but because this is what Haaretz is payed to do.
Nothing is more vital to a farmer than access to water for his animals and plants. Failure to stop this effort by settlers to drive out the farmers would be more proof, if any were needed, of Israel's duplicity in dealing with the natives of this territory.
what do you have to say about this one????
They are determined to undermine the leadership of their own country before, in and after negotiations with other heads of states regarding their own future. Not to speak about destroying their own economic future / standard of living in an ever more competitive world. Most peculiar and almost comical (if not so tragical as well) species.
That is about the way they could be described. Social Darwinists, too. But they'd hate that term because it involves a scientific concept.
Most people in Israel now fear lack of control more the another war. The same could have been said of the US South 150yrs ago or S. Africa 30yrs ago or even Spain of 500yrs ago.