• Published 00:00 01.08.06
  • Latest update 00:00 01.08.06

Every night in a different hotel or hideout

Lebanese sources paint Hezbollah as far less than happy with the situation.

By Yossi Melman

Hezbollah's leadership is under increasing pressure, well-informed Lebanese sources reported a few days ago. "They only pretend that they are successful, in control, and that everything is going according to plan."

This assessment was correct up to the day the Israel Air Force accidentally bombed a building in Qana and caused the deaths of dozens of people. Although the bombing somewhat boosted support for Hezbollah in Lebanon or, more to the point, somewhat reduced hostility to it, the basic feeling of those in Lebanon who have had enough of Hezbollah remained unchanged.

The real sentiments of the majority of Lebanese do not get appropriate coverage in Lebanon, the international media or, to their disappointment, in Israel, said the sources. Fearing for their safety, they asked to remain anonymous. They said that morale among Hezbollah's leadership is low:

"The IAF bombing of the Dahiya neighborhood was a hard and humiliating blow to the Hezbollah leadership," the sources stated. "This is not only because the offices were destroyed. The offices were equipped with command, control and computer systems and valuable intelligence. But the psychological blow was just as important. They were surprised by the attack and by the precise information Israel possessed. The headquarters was their pride and joy. Its destruction served as a painful reminder of the gap, one that no Lebanese can miss, between their pretension of power and the truth."

The sources added that Hezbollah makes use of its security apparatus to terrorize opposing leaders and political activists. In fact, the sources claim, close to 70 percent of the Lebanese opposes Hezbollah and the escapade into which it dragged the country.

The Shi'ites, the source of Hezbollah's authority and power, constitute 40 percent to 53 percent of the Lebanese population. But the sources estimate that among them a third does not support the organization, and some even oppose it.

"But Hezbollah threatens people. Their security men wander armed in the streets of Beirut and, in fact, have control over the capital. The opposition ? Saad Hariri's party and other parties ? oppose Hezbollah, and they privately rejoice at the blows Israel gives the organization. But they are afraid to speak out. Only Druze leader Walid Jumblatt has no fear of publicly expressing his opinion."

According to the sources, Hezbollah almost openly promises that after the war it will settle scores with its opposition. This was confirmed in a Saturday article in "The Guardian," whose reporter talked to Hezbollah fighters. "The real battle will be after the conclusion of this war. We will have a score to settle with Lebanese politicians," they said. "We have the best intelligence bodies in the country, and we can reach anyone who opposes. Let us finish with the Israelis, then we will settle the rest of the scores."

Elusive leadership

The sources claimed that despite IAF success, Israel has still failed to hit any chief Hezbollah leader, especially any of the military command. Israeli sources said last week that Nabil Kauk, the commander of Southern Lebanon, and Nur Shalhob, responsible for rocket supply, were killed by the IAF. But the Lebanese sources said that Kauck escaped and only his bodyguards were killed in the attack.

The sources, however, named a few more of the military command that they believed Israel is interested in eliminating, and hoped it will do so. This Hezbollah command has experience both in terrorist activity against Israeli targets abroad and in the '90s guerrilla struggle in South Lebanon with Israel. They were trained by Iranian experts, and are proficient in covert activity. This military command is politically subordinate to Hassan Nasrallah, but also has fast ties with the intelligence apparatus of Iran's Revolutionary Guards. Chief among them is Imad Mugniyeh, "defense minister" of Hezbollah and responsible for its military force, the division of its terrorist operations abroad, its internal security and intelligence units and counter-intelligence operations. Mugniyeh, in his late 40's, is also the key figure in Hezbollah's liaison with Iran's Revolutionary Guards, which have advisers and experts now in Lebanon, although they try to keep a safe distance from IAF bombed areas.

Second to Mugniyeh is the less known Fuad Shukur. He is "chief of staff" of the military force of about 7,000 fighters in regular units assigned to specific roles and duties, such as rocket launchers, radio operators and frontline fighters. These are full-time fighters on salary. Alongside them operates a reserve force, less trained and prepared, but just as determined. Shukur, in his 40's, reportedly injured his left arm a decade ago when fighting the IDF in South Lebanon.

Another key figure is Talal Hamia. Among his other duties, Hamia is in charge of the terrorist operations abroad, which have "sleeper" cells worldwide, mainly in South America, Western Europe and Africa. Since the 1994 bombing of AMIA, the Jewish community center in Buenos Aires, some of these cells have been activated, but their intentions were foiled. According to sources in Lebanon, Hamia was responsible for setting up some of these networks, and operated mainly in the Gulf countries and Africa. His modus operandi relies on sympathetic Shi'ite communities from which collaborators and agents are recruited, and funds are raised. The arsenal is delivered via diplomatic bags to an Iranian embassy nearby. Such was the case in the terrorist attacks on both the Israeli embassy in Buenos Aires in 1992 and on AMIA.

Hamia has spent the last few months traveling between Beirut and Iraq. Hezbollah sent him there to strengthen ties with Shi'ite militias and coordinate joint operations. The most important contact is with the Mahdi Army of the cleric Moqtada Sadr. It is not clear what exactly Hamia was up to in his sorties to Iraq, but presumably he wanted to recruit volunteers for operations abroad or to coordinate the possibility of dispatching Shi'ite volunteers from Iraq to Lebanon.

Sadr issued an announcement last Friday from his Najaf home, condemning the "Israeli enemy" and expressing support of Hezbollah. One of his men, Abu Mujtaba, said that the Mahdi Army was preparing to send volunteers. "We are choosing the men", he stated, and added that ways are being explored to send the fighters without the knowledge of the Iraqi government.

Incidentally, Sunni clerics ?(opposed to the Shi'ites?) also did not hesitate to condemn Israeli actions. Cleric Abd al-Rahman Duleimi called for volunteers and donations for the war against Israel.

According to the Lebanese sources, another key figure in the Hezbollah military structure, though on a lower rung than the others but also worth mentioning, is Ibrahim Akil, who was in charge of South Lebanon and now operates in counter-intelligence. Israeli intelligence made a failed attempt on his life shortly before the IDF withdrawal in 2000.

Most of Hezbollah's activities are carried out at night, which is when its leaders move about, said the sources. At night hundreds of rockets are moved from hideouts and warehouses to the firing positions while the leaders meet to plan the operations. The sources claimed that Mugniyeh and Shukur spend every night in a different hotel or apartment hideout. They keep switching cars and only a handful of loyalists are aware of their whereabouts. "They suspect everyone", it was stated. Once every few days they arrive at the Iranian embassy in Beirut. The embassy is in a large building with several levels underground. In those underground levels are branches of Iranian intelligence and intelligence units of the Revolutionary Guards.

The sources also claimed that Nasrallah uses the Presidential Palace of his supporter and admirer, President Emil Lahoud, as one of his hideouts. Obviously these claims can not be corroborated. They make sense just as any other assumption made during the fighting as to the hiding places of Hezbollah leaders.

Intelligence

The fact that Israel has failed so far to hit Hezbollah leaders can presumably suggest flawed intelligence, especially by the Mossad. The difficulty shows in the fact that Israel does not even have an updated photo of Mugniyeh. Mossad units face difficulties in obtaining information on targets during combat. Agents are cut off, many have to abandon the villages together with the rest of the population, and Hezbollah leaders have gone underground. In recent cabinet meetings Mossad head Meir Dagan disagreed with the assessments of Military Intelligence chief Amos Yadlin on everything related to Hezbollah's capabilities and resilience. Dagan sees himself as a great authority on Lebanon. During the 1980s, while he was head of the Lebanon Liaison Unit ?(Yakal?), he tried, and failed, to turn it into an intelligence operations unit to compete with the greater intelligence bodies. The unit under his command was involved in several operations. During one of the last cabinet meetings Dagan made several proposals for operations that reporters called "brash" and were rejected by the cabinet members. It is fair to state that during Ephraim Halevy's ?(Dagan's predecessor?) time, the Mossad also scored many important accomplishments in fighting Hezbollah; in thwarting terror attacks abroad; covering the dormant networks abroad; and especially in obtaining information on the Katyusha arsenal and infrastructure in Lebanon. The information obtained in this area contributed to the success of IAF strikes in the first days of the war: the destruction of the Dahiya in Beirut and the strike on secret storages of Katyusha rockets and launchers that Hezbollah set up in careful secrecy, especially those that stored long-range rockets.

Midway balance

So far Hezbollah has fired 3,500 Katyushas. The IAF and the artillery have destroyed 2,500 more. In toto, from 40 percent to 50 percent of Hezbollah's rocket capability has been destroyed. In addition, at least a third of its launchers has been destroyed.

As for Hezbollah's attempt at psychological warfare by hitting Israeli urban centers, this too has failed. The Israel rear displayed a resilience it didn't know it had ? and Hezbollah didn't expect.

Damage to the military fighting force is also insubstantial: approximately 300 to 400 of its fighters were killed, and dozens more were injured. Nevertheless the political and civilian leadership of Hezbollah, as far as we know, has not been hurt.

  • Print Page
  • Send to a friend
  • Share
  • Text Size +|-
 
 
TalkBacks

Why Facebook Connect?

Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.

Add a comment

Add your reply

  • 25. 0 0
    Military Intelligence???
    • Rami
    • 02.08.06
    • 13:11

    I am a durzi from lebanon, i am a supporter of walid jumblatt but no matter how much we have problems with other lebanese factions We ALL Stand united against the isreali agression. Isreal is our enemey and everything u said in this article stands as hopeless propaganda trying to hide ur losses!!

  • 24. 0 0
    mossad's failure to understand
    • ali
    • 02.08.06
    • 13:05

    mossad is failing not because they can't recuit spies, they can but they can never infiltrate the hizbulla organisation as they did with the PLO. This is the first time in history the IDF and the Mossad need so much propaganda probably to conceal their failures!!

  • 23. 0 0
    Don't trust too much
    • Zwi
    • 02.08.06
    • 12:49

    I can't see the point of the ultimate aim of the war being the establishment of an international monitored boundry when we all know to well that an Arab never keeps to his promise. I wonder if the so-called "international soldiers" will be ex-Hizbollah members?

  • 22. 0 0
    Important correction
    • Samir
    • 02.08.06
    • 12:21

    The Lebanese "source" mentioned in this article falsely puts the proportion of the Shia population at about 40 t0 53%, which is utterly inaccurate. According to the only valid and reliable source of statistics on Lebanese demographics, the eligible voters lists, the Shia make up to 25% of the population at best. The Sunnis are at about 26%. The rest is mainly Christians in addition to around 6% Druze.

  • 21. 0 0
    Syria - the key
    • Chaim
    • 02.08.06
    • 11:27

    Why not in the first place hold Syria responsible and hit them instead? They are a target, they have something to lose. And they can stop Hezbollah.

  • 20. 0 0
    #1 Paul
    • Diana
    • 02.08.06
    • 11:03

    Paul I appreciate your comments, but in my opinion, I'm afraid your greatly mistaken. Israel was taken completely by surprise, both by the attack on her soldiers and also by the extent that Hizbollah have managed to import rockets and goodness knows what else into their stock pile,(and believe it or not, under the eyes of the UN, thats very sad indeed).I think as to date,under those circumstances,Israel has managed extremely well to push those scum back from the border.I live in Haifa, and never realized before, just what those poor souls on our Northern borders have been living with for all those years. To live under the daily barrage of katshusha rockets is a horrific experience.I have past three weeks of katshusha's, but those souls are living 50years in terror.Israel has no choice but to establish once and for all safe and secure borders, so this terror will never happen again.It would be nice if we could end this pecefully, but there is no one to reason with...

  • 19. 0 0
    Ignores the external and internal "positives"
    • Rod
    • 02.08.06
    • 11:03

    Well, I'm sure that this article will play well to the "home audience" but it completely ignores the huge PR victories which Hezbollah have achieved as a result of the Israeli offensive. A tiny handful of countries around the world regard Hezbollah as a "terrorist" organisation (The US, Canada, the UK and Australia amongst them.) Here in Australia the savage impact of the Israeli air and artillery strikes has led to new pressure to remove them from the list. For every Hezbollah combatant that Israel kills two or three or more are created. For every civilian that Israel kills a dozen or twenty or a hundred are created. Just think how much anger every Katyusha causes in Israel. Imagine what happens on the other side when many times more 2000lb bombs rain down instead of "pop gun" Katyushas. Read about the London Blitz and you will see why things like the current bombardment simply steel the resolve of your enemies , and make enemies of former neutrals & friends. Its madness.

  • 18. 0 0
    Creativity comes in many forms
    • bbl
    • 02.08.06
    • 10:59

    Somehow Israel has gotten 10,000+ troops into Lebanon. They have carried out operations with land troops that have reached further in Lebanon than any time since 1984. Meanwhile, not only is the world press reporting on Israels descision to halt air bombardment for 48 hrs, but it is also opining on how Israel "lost the war" -- I assume because they had a hard battle and pulled their troops back from a town in Southern Lebanon. I think that there has been some clever and creative moves from the makers of War on both sides. But I think in a few weeks, it will be the Israelis who will still be standing relatively undiminished.

  • 17. 0 0
    Wishful thinking
    • Fairplay
    • 02.08.06
    • 10:43

    Yossi Melman's piece is a nice morale booster for a war-weary Israeli public. However, this is not an objective analysis because the author lacks access to the necessary sources in the Lebanon. The sad reality is that Israeli forces are still battling hard to advance several hundred metres beyond the border, and sustaining significant losses. Meanwhile, the rocket attacks on the north have not been attenuated. Indeed, in the south the Palestinian militants are still managing to hit Ashkelon with their primitive kassams. It is time for a sober reappraisal rather than flights of fancy.

  • 16. 0 0
    #1 & #2
    • Niall
    • 02.08.06
    • 10:43

    I don't agree. I can see that the air campaign followed by a ground war, looks very much like the pattern established by the USA in their 2 Iraq wars, but I think the whole world has been taken by surprise at the ferocity of the Israeli response. Creatively thinking though, using transport helicopters to drop a "rangers" style force in the Ba-albek is impressive, and I bet Hezbolla didn't expect that. Getting them back out again without the loss of a single soldier and from the report Hizbolla prisoners as well is damned impressive. As for Nasralla and Meshal, they will not have the luxury of dying a natural death at a ripe old age. If there has been a failing, it is in the PR campaign. Israel seems to have few spokesmen who can charasmatically make their case to the wider world, and that in part at least is why world opinion seems to be against Israel. That and the fact that world opinion is fickle at the best of times.

  • 15. 0 0
    nice piece of propaganda
    • Skeptical
    • 02.08.06
    • 09:48

    Nice use of unnamed sources. I wonder if any of them came from your imagination?

  • 14. 0 0
    Utter ignorance or propaganda
    • samusa
    • 02.08.06
    • 09:11

    "well informed lebanese source" seems to know all hizboulla's movement and hideouts. If you are that naive to beleive it, pass it on to the mossad. Either you are naive, or you think the readers are. Either way, it sounds like rubbish.

  • 13. 0 0
    Armed Drones?
    • John
    • 02.08.06
    • 08:59

    I'm curious if Israel's unmanned drones(like US predator?) are equipped with hellfire missiles or some other kind of projetile. I assume some of these rockets can be placed on a timer but I'm sure a large portion are fired by operitives on the ground. The current strategy has been to use the drones to detect the heat signature of launches and then use artiley and airstrikes on the target. Frankly this tactic seems to be overkill in some instances and also wastes precious minutes used by the operitive who might escape. To my knowledge armed drones are not as expensive as fighter aircraft so I was curious why the military hasn't bought up some US Predators with hellfire missles and have them patrolling the skies over Lebanon en masse. Israel has until the end of the week before the U.S. begins to start seriously pressuring for a cease-fire so this may be out of the question, but surely as #1 pointed out Israel's tactics need to improve if they wish acheive their stated objectives.

  • 12. 0 0
    Flank them from the north
    • David
    • 02.08.06
    • 08:28

    Hezballa is well prepared to fight in a southern orientation. Why not a mass sea invasion north of Hezballa and surround them? No land mines in the way of the IDF. The IDF definitely needs to be more creative. Pushing Hezballa north means they'll still be there to throw their weight around in Lebanon when the dust settles. I agree that they have lost much of the former brilliance of their early days and replaced it with a dependance on their more recent military supremecy.

  • 11. 0 0
  • 10. 0 0
    it's not over yet
    • Harry
    • 02.08.06
    • 05:33

    The war isn't over yet, so don't be too tough on Israeli Intel. It sounds like there are enough people in Lebanon who dislike Hezbollah to provide a constant source of valuable information. Good hunting, Israel! Harry

  • 9. 0 0
    Hotel Hades
    • NJ
    • 02.08.06
    • 04:45

    This is far from over and why would anyone expect a quick victory? The IDF is showing the world once again the meaning of bravery, sacrifice, and service to the nation. Nasrallah and his clique have their days numbered even if they are hiding under Assad's bed as the US will not lift one finger to stop the IDF from doing what needs to be done. This is not the holy war they dreamed of is it?

  • 8. 0 0
    Every Night in a Different Hotel
    • Richard R.
    • 02.08.06
    • 02:34

    To #1. Ani m'od modeh l'cha, Ramat Kal Paul.

  • 7. 0 0
    to paul #1
    • Alon
    • 02.08.06
    • 01:58

    You are 100% correct. We now seem like an angry child flarring its arms around. We should have been smarter. Then again, the international community would have been much tougher on Israel had the scenario you suggest happened. Nevertheless, I agree with you whole-heartedly.

  • 6. 0 0
    "well informed sources"
    • lebanese111
    • 02.08.06
    • 01:53

    these well-informed sources appear to be very misinformed. I hardly believe someone on the run would be able to stay in a hotel every night in a country as tiny and tight knit as Lebanon. Hezbolla is not and has never been in control of Beirut and people are certainly not terrorized by them as a Lebanese anonymous poll woudl tell you. This article or source is an attempt at showing that Israel is winning while it is not. Nobosy else is winning however. Only poor helpless civilians die.

  • 5. 0 0
    HIZBULLAH IS GOING DOWN
    • dale
    • 02.08.06
    • 01:03

    hizbullah is going to crash and burn and israel will help them do it. the arabs can lie for only a short while ,but then the truth comes out just like in past wars.

  • 4. 0 0
    Will the Lebanese be jarred into action?
    • Mark
    • 02.08.06
    • 00:48

    The big question after the cease-fire will be: Will the Lebanese finally take power into their own hands. It is clear that Hizbollah has the same evil influence over the Lebanese as the Nazis had over the Germans. All about threatening people with guns and having unlimited power. Hizbullah really does not give a damn about the Lebanese, except for their own selfish interests. Nobody can do this 'house-cleaning' for the Lebanese. However they will have to face this task on their own if they are ever to get their country back.

  • 3. 0 0
    Re: Paul
    • Richard S.
    • 02.08.06
    • 00:28

  • 2. 0 0
    IDF lacks creativity in this war
    • paul
    • 02.08.06
    • 00:00

    where are all the brilliant thinkers israel has? Just in hi-tech? why not in the IDF? the strategy for this lebanon war is weak. The IDF also has to use elements of suprise. In my opinion right after the soldiers were kidnapped Israel should have not acted, done everything to get them released including trading some low level prisoners or even sami kuntar. Hizbollah would have been over confident and riding on a high from this. As soon as the Israel soldiers were back in Israel, Israel then should have assasinated nasrallah by any means (how can they get him now? he's probably in Damascus). This would have given hizbollah a serious blow and left them in a vacuum without a leader. Then the war would have started, rockets falling but it would be the same as now only with Israel taking the queen off the chess board from the start. they could have also assasinated sami kuntar and other prisoners they released in the ensuing battle. Some of these IDF guys think that '67 was only yesterday.

  • 1. 0 0
    Talk is Cheap
    • Chris
    • 01.08.06
    • 23:36

    Of course the people who are opposed to Huzb Allah would claim that there is no support for Huzb Allah in Lebanonm the fact is almost all Shiites support it, a majority of Sunnis do as well and some Christians and Druze which makes it supported at least by 65-75% of the population.