• Published 00:00 11.09.06
  • Latest update 00:00 11.09.06

A Nobel Prize for peace - and image

By Yossi Melman

In 1942, in the midst of World War Two, Irena Sendler secretly packed a few Jewish children into an ambulance and smuggled them out of the Warsaw Ghetto. In the front passenger seat, next to the driver, she put a dog, whose loud barking drowned out the crying children. Throughout the war, Sendler worked to save Jewish children - 2,500 in total.

In an interview she gave in 1995 to Jewish-French writer and filmmaker Marek Halter, she said she regretted only one thing: "I could have done more," she said tearfully. "This feeling of regret will accompany me until my dying day."

Now, Polish president Lech Kaczynski, in Israel this week, is trying to change Poland's image in the eyes of Israelis, many of whom believe the country's residents helped the Nazis to exterminate Jews. Through the initiative Kaczynski is proposing both countries back a Nobel Peace Prize nomination for Sendler, now 96 years old.

However, the proposal may face opposition from an unexpected place: Yad Vashem.

Irena Sendler was born in 1910. Her socialist-leaning father was a doctor in Otwock. Most of his patients were Jews from the town, located 20 kilometers southeast of Warsaw. When World War Two broke out, Irena Sendler began helping the Jews of the town even before the Nazis established the Warsaw ghetto. She helped set up soup kitchens for the poor, for orphans and for homeless Jews whose property and bank accounts had been appropriated by the Nazis.

In 1942, Sendler, then a senior director of the Warsaw welfare department, joined the Zegota - the code name for the Council for Aid to Jews. Her underground name was Jolenta, and she was appointed to head the initiative to save Jewish children. In the Zegota, Sendler increased her efforts to rescue Jews. From helping them stay alive, she began working to save them, putting her own life at risk. There was only one punishment in occupied Poland for those who helped Jews hide - death.

Sendler conscripted a few assistants, partners to the secret conspiracy, and together they registered Jews under false Christian names, procured them documents and helped them obtain certificates stating they were very ill so the Nazis would not examine them. After the Warsaw Ghetto was set up, Sendler obtained documents from doctors so she and her assistant, Irena Schultz, could enter the ghetto daily on the pretext of preventing plagues from spreading to other parts of the city. They smuggled in money, food, medicine, clothes and messages to the Jewish underground movements.

Silent under torture

Sendler's efforts peaked when she began working to save Jewish children by smuggling them out of the ghetto and transferring them to Christian families or monasteries. She persuaded Jewish parents to leave their children in her hands, and found hiding places for sick youngsters until they recovered. When their condition improved, they were taken to foster families or to monasteries, after she and her Polish underground peers had obtained them forged documents.

Sendler also took pains to ensure all these acts were documented. She wrote down in code the original name of the child, the new name, and the name of the adoptive family or monastery. She did all this to ensure the children would be returned to their families after the war - or at least would be able to find out who they were. She stuffed these lists into glass jars and buried them in the garden. She saved some 2,500 children this way.

In October 1943, Sendler was arrested by the Gestapo. Even though she was severely tortured - her legs were broken and she has since then needed crutches - she refused to talk or reveal the identities of the children she had saved. A Nazi court sentenced her to death, but her colleagues in the underground freed her after bribing a guard to list her as executed. Sendler assumed a new identity and lived in hiding until the end of the war.

After the war, she worked at the Polish health ministry. Because she had been a member of the national underground, she faced threats by the Communist authorities. But they didn't dare touch her - even though they threatened to keep her children from attending college. In 1965, Yad Vashem granted Sendler the title of Righteous Among the Nations, and in 1991 she was awarded honorary Israeli citizenship. She is currently wheel-chair bound and living in a Warsaw old-age home.

Yad Vashem wants the prize

Kaczynski's visit, which officially begins today, is mainly for emotional and historical reasons. Officially speaking, Poland and Israel have no problems with each other. The ties in all fields - commercial, intelligence, security, cultural - are good and getting better. In the past few years, Poland has become Israel's closest ally in the European Union.

Unlike EU members such as Italy, Britain, Holland or Spain, Poland has no interests regarding Israel and makes no commercial or political demands. The only baggage weighing on the two countries' ties is historical, centered on the Holocaust.

In this regard, the Polish president would like to change Israelis' image of his country. Poland has become fixed in the collective Israeli memory as the country most responsible for the Holocaust. Sometimes Israelis believe it is more guilty than even Nazi Germany - because the Nazis set up the extermination camps on Polish soil. These camps have become synonymous with the most systematic destruction of humans in history - Auschwitz, Maidanek, Treblinka, Chelmno.

The fact that several brave undergrounds and individuals acted to save many Jews in Poland has been sidelined. In fact, it is uncertain Polish cooperation with the Nazi occupation was greater than that in Holland or France. The Polish president is extremely interested in stressing these two points in his country's relations with Israel.

In order to focus on the positive aspects of the two countries' ties, Kaczynski plans to make a unique request of his hosts: He is to ask President Moshe Katsav, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and Vice Premier Shimon Peres to lend their sponsorship to Sendler's nomination for the Nobel Peace Prize. In parallel, Nobel Peace Prize winners Peres and former Polish president Lech Walesa will also nominate Sendler.

Israel's ambassador to Warsaw, David Peleg, who is accompanying Kaczynski on his visit, supports the initiative. Nevertheless, the joint proposal may meet opposition from an unexpected place: Yad Vashem. Even though it would not admit it, the organization itself would like the prize. Last year a precedent was set in the granting of the prize to an organization: The International Atomic Energy Agency and its head, Dr. Mohamed ElBaradei, were honored for preventing the spread of nuclear weapons.

In an official response, Yad Vashem stated it does not object to the idea of nominating Sendler, even though it would prefer the prize be awarded to all the Righteous Among the Nations, many of whom did no less than Sendler did. Yad Vashem added that for several years it has been acting behind the scenes to promote this idea.

If Kaczynski succeeds in persuading the Israeli government to back Sendler's nomination, the next hurdle will be the Nobel committee itself. If Sendler actually wins, this will be the first time a Nobel prize would have been awarded in connection to the Holocaust.

  • Print Page
  • Send to a friend
  • Share
  • Text Size +|-
 
 
TalkBacks

Why Facebook Connect?

Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.

Add a comment

Add your reply

  • 11. 0 0
    A Nobel Prize for peace - and image - excuse me?
    • Evil Chauvinish Pole
    • 24.05.07
    • 07:13

    "Poland has become fixed in the collective Israeli memory as the country most responsible for the Holocaust. Sometimes Israelis believe it is more guilty than even Nazi Germany - because the Nazis set up the extermination camps on Polish soil." Pardon me for asking but are Israelis REALLY this dense and idiotic as portrayed in this article? Holding Poland as more guilty than Nazi Germany in perpetrating the Holocaust because the alien occupying power chose to setup their death factories in Poland is frankly...unbelievable. The penalty for aiding or hiding a Jew in Poland was death. So if a rural polish family was caught hiding a Jew or a group of Jews, all of them would be shot on the spot immediately - men, women and children. We can start with this fact and go from there. What exactly is taught in Israeli schools these days?

  • 10. 0 0
    Irena Sendler as Symbol
    • Jack
    • 18.09.06
    • 00:00

    Heroic Irena Sendler richly deserves the highest recognition as a symbolic representative of the hundreds of other brave and compassionate Righteous Ones who followed their highest human instincts. They defied torture and death to rescue the doomed. At a time of incredibly strident Holocaust denial, the inspiring story of Irina and, by proxy, all the other Righteous Ones, would serve a nobel purpose.

  • 9. 0 0
    Does Sendler excuse POlish Jew-hatred?
    • Yaakov K.
    • 11.09.06
    • 22:27

    Sendler, from what I read, probably is one of the world's "Righteous Gentiles." Does that doc away with the prwevalent Polish Jew-hatred?

  • 8. 0 0
    how many did Yad Vashem save ?
    • some old Yid
    • 11.09.06
    • 20:01

    this is not the only occasion of Yad Vashem behaving - to keep it polite - 'strangely'. I came across an example in France where children had been hidden and saved. Yad Vashem had been contacted and, for reasons that were very vague, refused to acknowledge what had happened, despite full proof being available. Yad Vashem wants to be careful in its self-seeking opportunism that it does not find that it is working against the very principles that it pretends to uphold. many of my family (and many of your families too) were lost. Yad Vashem has no right nor authpority nor, from its conduct, adequate standards to presume to represent them.

  • 7. 0 0
    Nobel Prize
    • Dan
    • 11.09.06
    • 19:40

    She will not be the first Nobel price connected to the Holocaust. Have you forgotten about Eli Wiesel?

  • 6. 0 0
    Sendler prize
    • Michael Checinski
    • 11.09.06
    • 18:46

    No daubt. First give the prize to Sendler, before she could pass away. Sendler is a simbol of Polish most rightful people. I was also saved by Poles (not only) and know what kind of risk it was. I am asking Jews and Israelis to support with they heart and mind, publicly, to prefer the Nobel Prize for Ms. Sendler Michael Checinski

  • 5. 0 0
    Nobel for Sendler
    • Allan B
    • 11.09.06
    • 18:01

    She deserves the recognition. Yad Vashem can get the word in some future year. Ms Sendler doesn't have much time at age 96.

  • 4. 0 0
    A Nobel Prize for peace - and image
    • Dan Coleridge
    • 11.09.06
    • 17:38

    Yad Vashem please grow up. Why bring this up when the process to grant the prize to Sendler is already being considered. Given the world today there will be more positive feedback if she gets it. Colly

  • 3. 0 0
    For image only ?
    • Quido
    • 11.09.06
    • 15:44

    brave woman , but everybody should realize that single -handed she would had done nothing. Rescuing of every child nedeed an army of people ,in every stage of their stay. People who organized transport,people who organized asylum ,delivered regullary food and clothes,who was able to tamper documents,aspecially baptismal certificates. And at last people who took the child to their home not to notice threatening punishment in case of foul-up ,which according to Nazi rules in occupied Poland was only one: death penalty for all family. Very often children found asylum in catholic monasters'orphanages. Difficulties and risk were even greater ,because very often these children didn't know Polish language ,in homes and in own schools speaking only jidish. Little boys were circumcised . All this demanded help of a great underground movement organisation.

  • 2. 0 0
    Humbled
    • Eli
    • 11.09.06
    • 15:35

    One can only be humbled by the bravery and selflessness displayed by Irena Sendler and other wonderful people like her who risked their lives to save Jews. Awarding the Nobel Prize to Irena Sendler would be an appropriate message to Iran's President and all the other anti-semitic holocaust deniers.

  • 1. 0 0
    Sendler deserves the title-nomination
    • ziggurat
    • 11.09.06
    • 13:29

    like many others do (but there is only one title). For that purpose, only her individual action counts, not the number of other Polish citizens who acted like/unlike her.