• Published 01:12 29.11.09
  • Latest update 09:54 29.11.09

Thanks to Arab boycott, Dubai meltdown skips over Israelis

Israeli tycoons have made investment plans in Dubai, but almost none of these joint ventures worked out.

By Ora Coren Tags: Israel news

Thanks to the Arab boycott of Israel, which partially included Dubai, few Israelis have been exposed to the country's financial crisis. Few Israelis export to Dubai, and it seems very few have business connections with the government's Dubai World development arm, which has asked for a six-month moratorium on interest payments on its $59 billion in debt.

That does not mean that many Israelis did not try to do business in Dubai. Many made all sorts of connections and investment plans, but almost none of these joint ventures worked out.

Beny Steinmetz and Idan Ofer visited Dubai many times, but they are not worried. Nochi Dankner's only exposure is through his investment in Credit Suisse.

The only real questions among Israeli tycoons involve Yitzhak Tshuva and Lev Leviev. Tshuva is involved in a joint venture in Singapore between his U.S. Elad Group and Dubai World, which along with a Singaporean firm is building a $1.77 billion real estate project. The project includes offices, hotels, luxury apartments, shopping centers and entertainment facilities.

Lev Leviev owns two jewelry stores in Dubai, and apparently helped establish the Dubai diamond exchange.

"Anyone involved in the business world has known for six months that Dubai is tottering," said an Israeli businessman with interests around the globe. "It is no wonder that the world crisis has reached them. They have no oil and they live on international trade and debt. There are insane real estate projects there, including artificial islands and extremely exhibitionistic buildings. Luckily, Israelis did not succeed in creating significant business dealings with Dubai, so the relationship between a few tycoons and the Dubai investment fund will not impact the Israeli economy," he said.

"There were several attempts by Israeli construction companies to participate in their large real estate projects, but it is not clear what came of those contacts," said an Israeli businessman knowledgeable about Israeli activities in Dubai.

Israel exported to Dubai only indirectly via other countries, said Dan Catarivas, the director of the Division of Foreign Trade and International Relations of the Manufacturers Association. He said Israeli companies built small, portable desalinization plants there in cooperation with American firms. In addition, software companies tried to build Internet infrastructure through American and European firms, but had little success, said Catarivas. Israeli farmers also cooperate with Jordanian farmers to export fruits and vegetables to Dubai, he said.

Israelis are allowed into Dubai only with a foreign passport, in general. There is an unofficial Israeli representation in Dubai, which helps Israelis receive the necessary approvals, but each visit requires special approval from the local authorities.

In January 2008, Idan Ofer told TheMarker: "The big money is in the Gulf, and anyone who doesn't understand that will have a difficult time doing business in the future with the West," referring in particular to the huge state investment funds of the oil-producing Arab countries.

World's tallest tower under construction in Dubai, in November.

Photo by: (AP)
  • Print Page
  • Send to a friend
  • Share
  • Text Size +|-
 
 
TalkBacks

Why Facebook Connect?

Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.

Add a comment

Add your reply

  • 23. 0 0
    "Is Dubai helping ethnic cleansing in Palestine?"
    • Maureen Ann
    • 29.11.09
    • 23:50

    Lev Leviev was planning to open two large diamond stores in Dubai. (Adalah-NY: The Coalition for Justice in the Middle East "Is Dubai helping ethnic cleansing in Palestine?" by Khalid Amayreh) http://adalahny.org/index.php/press-coverage-2/190-dubai-ethnic-cleansing-palestine-leviev American business flocked to Dubai. If such American business is a loser in the Dubai melt down, knocking the American economy even further, how will that effect Israel? : )

  • 22. 0 0
    2nd time How will this effect;
    • TOBIA
    • 29.11.09
    • 23:41

    My personal feelings because of Dubai the ME has not gone up in flames. Arab leaders have invested in Dubia and do not want to lose investment. How wil this failure effect the ME. Can anyone now stop Iran???

  • 21. 0 0
    as they sew, so shall they reap
    • jewish Doctorate
    • 29.11.09
    • 23:22

    see, it's not nice to shut out the Jewish people...

  • 20. 0 0
    WHAT A SURPRISE!!!THERE WAS DECEPTION
    • Ian
    • 29.11.09
    • 21:44

    If only western investors would consider the proposition that Islamic culture is based on elitism,mendacity and violence,they'll avoid getting their fingers burnt. THREE CHEERS FOR ISRAEL!!!

  • 19. 0 0
    Down the road
    • Arnold
    • 29.11.09
    • 21:13

    The main reason that Dubai took this hit is because the long term plan for the country was rushed too quickly. Too much outlay of capital before a steady cash flow was to be realized. As far as Israel's business relationship with Dubai as well as the other Arab emirates we can refer to this 2 ways: 1. See no evil - speak no evil 2. Don't ask ...don't tell Dubai is a country built on non-existing oil revenues except from their Abu Dhabi cousins...and on sand next to the sea. Dubai wants and needs Israeli expertise in water management. When Islamic countries finally accept Israel in the neighborhood...watch out...the whole Middle East will become a powerhouse of commercial property and economic spinoffs. But ONLY when Israel is accepted. The biggest shame is that the Palestinians have suffered for decades because they are on the front lines of the Islamic war against Israel. Had their attitude been more pragmatic they would be on the high road now.

  • 18. 0 0
    HAD enough. So what ?so its not just billionaires
    • PETER SM
    • 29.11.09
    • 20:25

    Hence the reply to your posting. Pity was not mentioned.

  • 17. 0 0
    See, we were looking out for you own good.
    • Abed
    • 29.11.09
    • 19:45

    So finally you appreciate what we are doing for you. Rest assured you will never have to suffer the consequences of any future economic meltdown in arab worlds for another few centuries, that's if neither you nor the Iranians bring down the house too soon.

  • 16. 0 0
    UK Banks will be hardest hit
    • Lynn
    • 29.11.09
    • 17:48

    unemployment will skyrocket.

  • 15. 0 0
    The only investment that did not suffer is NO investment
    • Mikael
    • 29.11.09
    • 17:42

    I was trying to invest in Dubai and couldn't. I invested in USA and still took a big hit. This article has no value....

  • 14. 0 0
    PETER SM... So What!...
    • had enough
    • 29.11.09
    • 17:35

    my shares dropped too, but will go up again, such is the nature of financial markets. The markets are driven by human emotion as much as anything, if you are handing out pity, pity the poor who have no stocks, just low paid construction work in a country where they have no rights..

  • 13. 0 0
    Goo bye Dubai (and good riddance)
    • Space Cowboy
    • 29.11.09
    • 16:08

  • 12. 0 0
    To bad, So sad, Who cares.
    • ottomatik
    • 29.11.09
    • 15:51

    Looks like they will have to close the indoor ski moutain and eat Camel dong for a while.

  • 11. 0 0
    Leviev's Aircastles
    • rafiq
    • 29.11.09
    • 15:07

    nr 1) indeed who cares... Whole Dubai is one place where people pay for an appartment which costs some ten thousands dollars on building cost, easely half a million dollar. Building projects which takes disadvantage of foreign workers. And makes more money on the "air" they sell then the actual buildings. All this Dubai is just not more then an oil-less little sandy place with a lot of over paid concrete buildings.

  • 10. 0 0
    Dubai
    • Samuel
    • 29.11.09
    • 14:38

    Typical Arab miscalculation so what,s new it,s part of their mentality ,however who,s now going to bail the state out ,try those Swiss banks holding billions of taxpayers dollars meant for Palestinian resettlement ,another embarrassment for these clowns ?

  • 9. 0 0
    Re: #1
    • Steven
    • 29.11.09
    • 14:29

    I care. Wealth doesn't exist in a vaccum, it affects many people in society, creating jobs. What makes you care enough to leave that nonsense comment?

  • 8. 0 0
    One Battery Away
    • Ron
    • 29.11.09
    • 14:23

    I would not invest in any Arab country. The world is on the cusp of alternate energy sources, electric cars are coming and so many of the Arab states are already in debt. Better investments are to be had in just about any other area in the world.

  • 7. 0 0
  • 6. 0 0
    will affect Israel, albeit indirectly
    • vernonmarriott
    • 29.11.09
    • 12:39

    Dubai's crash will affect Israel - albeit indirectly. Firstly, it is a bit of a hiccup or blip on the road to global recovery, as witness the effect on stock exchanges and companies with investments in Dubai. This in turn affects global exchange rates making Israeli exports more expensive overseas. Secondly, the money that might have been used to invest in Israel may well go towards companies that need to be bailed out as a result of the Dubai crash. Finally, Dubai's property market was seen as a bit of a bubble - might not the same be said of the Israeli market? Particularly if the Shekel strengthens, foreign buyers may well take fright.

  • 5. 0 0
    We are more exposed than you think!!
    • Aryeh
    • 29.11.09
    • 11:09

    If you put your money in your local Hapoalim, it could go anywhere as all the banks lend to each other so Hapoalim could lend Credit Suisse who lend Dubai bank. It was always going to crash, it grew too fast. Besides some of Dubai's investments are rubbish such as the purchase of manchester City football club. The Emirates airline grew too fast. Go figure how they could spary Emirates on every plane using Gold Dust and receive delivery of an A380 every three weeks and then claim to make a profit in the reccesion? Biggest Ponzi scheme ever.

  • 4. 0 0
    HAD enough.A major payment default has global ramifications
    • PETER SM
    • 29.11.09
    • 10:38

    finance tightens globally,business suffers globaly. The Australian Stock exchange has dropped as a result of this. Including superannuantion funds of the man in the street.

  • 3. 0 0
    HAD enough.A major payment default has global ramifications
    • PETER SM
    • 29.11.09
    • 10:38

    finance tightens globally,business suffers globaly. The Australian Stock exchange has dropped as a result of this. Including superannuantion funds of the man in the street.

  • 2. 0 0
    Laugher
    • Boycotted Israeli
    • 29.11.09
    • 10:28

  • 1. 0 0
    Who cares,... really?
    • had enough
    • 29.11.09
    • 10:14

    so what if some billionaires lose a few hundred million? Israeli or not, this bubble was built with their insatiable greed.