U.S. to increase military aid to Israel in decade-long deal
Bush announces proposed new deal after New York meeting with Olmert; sources: PM pushed for increase.
By Aluf Benn and Shmuel RosnerThe United States will increase its military assistance to Israel and sign a new agreement securing American aid to the country for the next decade, President George W. Bush announced Tuesday following his meeting with Prime Minister Ehud Olmert.
Olmert had persuaded Bush to announce the aid increase, senior political sources said Wednesday.
Prior to Olmert's visit to Washington it was agreed that the issue would be raised during their meeting, but the President gave his response to the Israeli request for increased military assistance only during the meeting with the prime minister.
"The increase of the military assistance is the most important result of Olmert's visit to the United States," the political sources said.
This year, Israel will receive $2.4 billion in military aid from the U.S.
The agreement concluded by former prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu, according to which the United States' economic aid package to Israel would be gradually diminished and the military aid would increase, is coming to an end this year.
According to the existing arrangement, most of the grant is meant for procurement from the U.S. industry, and Israel is allowed to spend 26.7 percent of the military assistance in shekel purchases for acquisitions from local defense industries.
Israel asked for a gradual increase in the aid over a 10-year period at the tune of $50 million per year. At the end of the 10 years, Israel will receive $2.9 billion annually in military assistance from the U.S.
Olmert told the president that an announcement on the increase in aid would be an expression of American support for Israel against the growing threats to its existence in the region.
In its announcement, the U.S. reiterated that the increased funds will allow Israel to deal with the new challenges it faces and to ensure a "qualitative military edge."
The prime minister asked U.S. Secretary of Defense Robert Gates for his assistance in expediting the handling of a number of IDF procurement requests meant to complete the replenishment of equipment and stores used during the Second Lebanon War.
Gates pointed out that though there is no problem with the requests in principle, there is an orderly procedure. However, Bush intervened and directed the defense secretary to expedite approval of the IDF's requests.
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
I am a veteran of the US army. I served during but not in Vietnam. I am currently on Diability because of a heart attack. My wife works and earns a little over 50K a year. In new York a tough number to live on. I am not entiled to veteran medical benefits because income thresholds have been established. So why don't we give Isreal another billion or so and increase the loan gaurantees of 7 billion plus a few more billion that way we can eliminate my Disability. And by the way isn't social security going bust?? Enough is an enough!
God bless america!
Rowan Berkely is right because the Military corporations love to keep the Middle east conflict going because there's no money in peace & the price of wars is paid by the Arabs & Jews only,on the other hand the Zionist Jews who're against any attempt of peace making are making more money by the tons every minute.
Okay, I will, but Google shows two websites for him...I only read bits but they were put there by his admirers. Before you ask me about Suez, I do know about it, my stepfather was there in the British army at that time. Not that he talks much. There is a young Jewish woman just come to work in the same office as me; I asked her about Yentah, she laughed a bit but her description was exactly the same as the one you wrote. She also told me about her trip to Israel early this year. Now, as for these lessons, you might think of them as a sort of public relations; if people understand more, maybe their minds will be changed. Did you think of that one??
Israel must make peace, its too late for more war.Play fair with your neighbors, stop bombing them, give some funds to secure a peaceful life.
Google Wikipedia's TIMELINES ARAB ISRAEL CONFLICT, Nassere will appear in two sections, 1956 Suez blockade and 1967 war, where he kept threatening Israel. Try Egyptian military leaders 1950-1980 or thereabouts. I'm going to start billing you for all these private lessons.
Google doesn't have everything. It's a Yiddish word. Many American do know what it means. I had told you, check it out with any Jew, preferably one that has some knowledge of Yiddish. Call a Synagogue, ask the rabbi.
I found two homepages for Gamal Abdel Nasser.
That's the description of the word "Yentah"? Then why didn't I find it on Google? As for Jews talking to me, as you phrase it, most of the doctors working with me are Jewish. And they certainly can talk.
Female busybody, sticks her nose in where it isn't wanted, gives worthless advice, talks endlessly to make herself feel important and makes her self obnoxious while doing so. Worst of all, she doesn't know what she's talking about. You should find any Jew that'll talk to you, his/her definiation won't vary far from mine.
GOOGLE "Gamal Abdel Nasser", told you this before. If you can't find him, get your eyes examined.
Okay then...now, you just go to Google, and look at the first page it gives you when you enter "Yentah"....what on earth does that tell me? Warm springs, message boards, matchmakers....I don't see a description!
Nasser - ruler of Egypt?
Palestinian's, prior to to Israels establishment didn't know what medical care was. Palestinina leaders gave them nothing, not even basic social services. I recall seeing a photo of an infant child sitting in the gutter in Ramle, near Lod airport (at that time Lydda), face covered with large black and green fly's. Child didn't attempt to brush their annoyance away. There was no DDT destroying insects before the Jews sprayed the area. Arab women actually gave birth in clean hospital surroundings instead of the earthen hovels they lived in. Doctors and nurses attended to their needs. That's the reason the Arab mortality rate was so low, medical care, medicines and sanitation assured it. Learn about Nasser, you sorely need education. Palestinian attend schools in the hope they can educate themselves and get out, away from other Palestinian's that only think of war and hate. Hatred doesn't fill bellies, the UN does via UNWRA. You have an awful lot to learn
In your capacity as a "Social Worker", with your lack of knowledge and rationale, you must have intended to write INMATE, acting under the delusion that you actually knew something. My underlings aren't paid to like or dislike, they're paid to do what what I instruct. Yentah, good question, LOOK IT UP!! You didn't know who Nasser was, a clear indication that your knowledge is superficial at best. Google him, learn something, stop pretending to be what you're not, that's delusional.
I'm not your teacher, I gave you homework, do it and then discuss. Thusfar your lack of knowledge has you talking through your hat. Come on back when you've done the reading and have the intelligence to discuss. Up till now you been blowing hot air. Try and get your thoughts together, I don't intend or have the time to reply to each bit of nonsense you write until there's a clear indication that you have some idea of what you're talking about. I'm not interested in a discussion with a human parrot. I can't get over it, YOU didn't know who Nasser was. Unbelievable!!
You say the Palestinians had a good life, the best life of all Arabs. Best educated, best medical, most cars, lowest infant mortality rate.... But when was this? Because Israel has been militarily occuping the West Bank and until recently Gaza for forty years, and the Palestinians haven't had all that during those years...and I can't believe you'd say something so uncharitable as "Palestinians deserve every affliction they are getting". That is an awful thing to say....neither Palestinians nor Israelis deserve awful lives.
"In my capacity as a corporate controller, if I catch any of subordinates discussing matters they shouldn't I warn them once, then can them" I wonder that you are allowed to get away with it! In my capacity as a social worker in a pychiatric hospital, I can say you must be greatly disliked by your co-workers (underlings?)... As for you calling me "Ballistic", at least Israel is lucky in one thing; it doesn't have you in charge of their secret service or Shin Bet....if you were; you'd be hitting the wrong people right and left as the body count grew and the real perpetrator laughed at you....
You are telling me that the Palestinans attacked the Israelis in the past, 5/15/48. Now, what do you say about the "Right of Return"? Do you deny that the Israelis chased the Palestinians out of their homes back in the 40s? If not, what do they want to return to? Their old homes in Israel, isn't it?
"Even in USA if you threaten me publicly which Nasser did...." Just a minute. Who is Nasser, and what was the threat? I agree with you that here self-defence is legal. Connecticut doesn't have very high crime rates, though.
I take exception to your comment "maybe it's in style in your circle to bash Israel". I can assure you the people I work with don't discuss politics at all (much as I'd like to!) and my friends aren't interested either, worst luck. That's one of the reasons I like being here. Also as I stated elsewhere I have an Israeli friend in Tel Aviv and we discuss (argue) these issues very often. A last question....you mention "obesity" in your post. What on earth does that have to do with Israel and Palestine???????
Your post left me in actual bewilderment. I have no idea what you are talking about. But no matter. It's not important.
Ben Jabo, the point here isn't really a matter of backing up anyone, just that I feel that it isn't always necessary or practical to insist or demand that posters tell the sources of their information. This just happens...I've asked questions here before, and never got them answered, or made suggestions, and never got them responded to...posters go on to other threads, or forget, or whatever. For instance, you've never yet replied to my two state solution post! As for the NY Times poll mentioned by Muhammed Al Swain, I can't remember where I've seen such polls, but I can honestly tell you that I have seen articles which state that many Americans do not approve of so much money to Israel. I live near New York and so see their papers, but maybe you don't...you don't post your own state.
Since you're backing up Al Swain, where did you get YOUR information from, other than gossip or talking to yourself. Mohamed REFUSES to substantiate his allegations, nor will he supply the name of the NY Times Poll that he claims has the figures. I'm starting figure that this is just another unsubstaniated statement that has no support from any legitimate source and was a lie made up out of the whole cloth. PROVE ME WRONG!!!
Umpteenth request, starting NOT to believe you. Prove what you claim, otherwise we'll know it's baloney...What is the NY Times Poll Called???......."#219 FACTS: "OST AMERICANS ARE AGAINST FREE HANDOUTS TO ISRAEL" Name: Muhammud al-Swain City: Dearborn State: Michigan More distortions of the truth. In a recent New York Times scientific poll "72% of Americans" stated they no longer want to send their hard earned tax dollars to israel. The israeli jews are very wealthy and they can afford to pay for their own military adventures
Silvienne Today is Sunday and just came in to delete the page.Gosh!So many of yours,I was blinded. Did you buy the whole lot,or what? Anyhow,I am off and will get rid of it as soon as I can. Carry on regardless,but I just read *BEN JABO's confirming your idendity as a person (who's name would never pass my lips ever again)! Enjoy your notoriety while you can.It cannot last too long I fear....
You made a totally outlandish claim. I've reminded you quite a few times regarding your sources. You've failed to reply. Now let's try something a bit different, TRY TELLING THE TRUTH..."AL SWAIN - YOO HOO - CALLING YOUR BLUFF Name: * BEN JABO City: USA State: Make my day. I`m eagerly awaiting the information I requested. After all you made the charge, now`s the time to prove it....."#319 Al Swain Name: * BEN JABO City: USA State: I`m amazed that you`re unaware that the NY Times is held in disrepute. Their reporters have been caught too many times faking stories. What was once a GREAT newspaper has turned far left, prostituted itself in the attempt to retrive readership. What`s the specific name of that alleged poll, really would like to check it out, if it exists. Everytime, without exception, one of you guys quote stats, percentages or anything related to number, when asked for the source or link, you get flumoxxed and retreat, never answering the question. NAME OF POLL, DATE, ETC. RSVP
Idd you would bring New Orleans into this. The U.S. spent billions, bought the wrong stuff and wasted time. On the other hand, Israel know how and what to do with the money. I've always felt that those that delve on money to a great extent, don't have it, wish they did, or didn't pay their taxes in the first place.
I mentioned many places were people suffer much, much more then Palis,were the obesity rate is much lower. And I asked you, if you have simmilar "care" and "love" for those. Or is it only the murderous Palis provoke your softer feelings????? I guess,if not for Israel, you would not have much feeling for Palis,or maybe it is in style in your circle to bash Israel.I would like to understand, why you are so missguided,AND NOT ONLY YOU.
"stolen" Does not mean a thing. Do you know how many said, that Stalin is good and right?? Or Khomeini,Or Mao, OR Sadam... Many are not always right. To parot what MANY do,or say, robs you of your own clear thinking. Try to work,read,analize, and develope your own oppinions.
own doing. They did it to themself. Before they started their murderous compagn against Israel, Palis had a prety good life, the best life of all Arabs.Best educated,best medical svc,lowest infant mortality rate,most cars per capita. .free no borders travel everywere in Israel...Than they made a decission to terrorize Israel, with a purpose not to have their own country, but to destroy Israel.Islamic extremism overtook the reality.They could have their country 6o years ego.If you do not have an agenda, then you are plain naive,do not understand the reality of ME.Palis deserve every afliction they geting. Nothing to be sorry for them.Even EU realized it. Your fellings are totaly missplaced.
Silvienne, the reason I'll ignore you is really quite easy to understand. Like any good boss, I despise office gossips. they stick their noses into situations and cause friction. Most of the time they have nothing intelligent to contribute, just like to feel importatn In my capactity as a Corporate Controller, when I catch any of my subordinates discussing matters that shouldn't be, I warn them just once, then can them. You've been canned for being a Yentah.
You really should "think" less and get your hands on some facts for a change. I'll give you the sources again shortly. Palestinian "IRREGULARS", in conjunction with five, count them, five arab armies attacked Israel on 5/15/48. Prior to that, the Pali's continually attacked Jewish civilian convoys containing food & medicines. Look up Mt. Scopus' attack on ambulances, murdering the doctors & nurses on the way to the Mt. Scopus hospital. Now for the sources, for the last, final and end of all listings, just read em and then talk. Always use the same search phrase, makes it easier. "TIMELINES ISRAEL ARAB CONFLICT". Wikipedia, Answers.Com & Concise Brittanica, ALL have the information. No vast "Thinking" required, just the ability to comprehend the written word...,"I didn`t think it was the Palestinians who attacked Israel in 1948"
Israel's right to defend itself was perfectly legal, Arabs attacks weren't. Get it?? If the Arabs hadn't of attacked there wouldn't have been a war in the first place. Understand? Even in the good old USA, if you threaten me publicly, which Nasser did, it's considered to be as if it was the actual assault, allowing me to defend myself. The fact you have a gun, wave it under my nose, is adequate reason for me to take necessary defensive actions. You started it, you live or die with it.
"Sure they want their land back, they should have thought of that before they attacked Israel in 1948". I didn't think it was the Palestinians who attacked Israel in 1948, and anyway, our own country has made many mistakes. Does this mean because Palestine "didn't think of that" in 1948 that they can never have their land back? Incidentally, Ben, you realise that by your statement, "they want their land back" you are tacitly admitting that their land has been stolen by Israel? Just thought I'd let you know that. I didn't notice Ballistic in our discussion, though. Where is his post?
"The attacks by the Egyptians and Syrians were far more illegal than the Israeli occupation"... That is disingenious, Ben Jabo. Either something is illegal or it isn't. One thing can't be "more illegal" than another. And two wrongs don't make a right, either.
"In the future anytime you get involved between myself and a third party you will be ignored" !!!! Ben Jabo lays down the law!!! Don't be so absurd and pompous, Ben; this isn't the workplace. Deborah doesn't have to answer you, and anyone here can get involved with anyone else! If I want to defend Deborah and Ballistic, I'm going to do just that. All you have to do is....ignore!
First of all, I'm not sure what you mean by asking me about "love" for others...when have I ever professed love for anyone in my posts? So I am confused - please clarify. As for "my Pali murderers", that is simply an insulting phrase with no value or meaning that I can respond to. As for calling Palestinian land "stolen", you will known very well just how often and by how many people that land is referred to as "stolen". So I am certainly not putting forward any radical term for what happened to Palestinian land. I don't know of any "agenda" that you claim I have. I'm simply stating my opinion. It is terrible to know the conditions under which the Palestinians are living every single day. Tell me the truth - would you like to live the life of a Palestinian in the West Bank? With half a million Israeli "settlers" coming closer and closer to what little land you have left? I doubt it.
Sure they want their land back. They should have thought of that before they attacked Israel in 1948. Go to the casino, place a bet, lose, ask for your money back, they'll heave you out the door. Ballistic, you're a real busy body. Henceforth when you step into a dialogue between myself and another, you'll be justly ignore. Get it??
Deborah gave fake facts, was challenged to back them up and went into hiding. I called her for what she is. In the future, anytime you get involved between myself and a third party, you will be ignored. I don't have the time or inclination to answer all your gibberish. Ballistic, you're so obvious it's pathetic. She had nothing intelligent to say because she refuses to back up her fictions.
The attacks by the Egyptians & Syrians were far more illegal than the Occupation that resulted. Occupation is a defensive postion, unlike the attacks that were offensive.
I notice that in #418, Silvienen aka/"B", agrees with you. Of course she does, she too states fake sources and facts. Al Swain, I challenged you to supply facts, etc., to confirm your allegations. Thus far, you haven't had the courtesy or courage to reply. I'm starting to feel that you made up stuff out of the clear blue, just the same way Silvienne does. Here it is again, third time, being posted. I dare you, prove me wrong..."#319 Al Swain Name: * BEN JABO City: USA State: I`m amazed that you`re unaware that the NY Times is held in disrepute. Their reporters have been caught too many times faking stories. What was once a GREAT newspaper has turned far left, prostituted itself in the attempt to retrive readership. What`s the specific name of that alleged poll, really would like to check it out, if it exists. Everytime, without exception, one of you guys quote stats, percentages or anything related to number, when asked for the source or link, you get flumoxxed and retreat, never answering the question. NAME OF POLL, DATE, ETC. RSVP
Interesting story. Just one question, where in the heck did you obtain that 40% figure from? Just a source, link or something that backs it up. I'm exhausted from all fakers that keep quoting stats, percentage and sources that never materialize or never were there in the first place. You don't like people getting rich, of course not, you're incompetent and jealous of anyone that has more than you do. Just let us know where the 40% came from. "40% of US Billionaires are jewish"
"Israel is like a lazy 45 year old who refuses to get a job and lives off his parents, pathetic" Actually, it's even worse than that, because this 45 year old has very adequate means of its own, and yet still whines and demands our money as well....
Well, Andrew, you must be one of those multi-millionaires we've been hearing about...
Excellent post. I've been saying the same things, but let's not expect Israel's demands to stop anytime soon, or our government's weak agreement to them to stop, either....
As a very small country, in any place desaster struck, Israel is among the first there with medical experts, rescue units, field hospitals suplies.In Turkey,Armenia,Bosnia,Tzunamy.....in every desaster case you will find Israely involvment. But people with agenda like you , will never see the reality.You did not tell me about your "love" for others I asked. Or Is it only the Palis???? And Israel never stole any land which does not belong to her.Arabs have over a 1000 times as much land as Israel, so stop with your paroting stolen, stolen, stolen..It is borring.Minwile your Pali murderers latly showing more and more of who they are.
This makes me sick to my stomach. Israel gets more money than most continents. The US taxpayers are living on their credit cards. The US Healthcare system is broken. The US education system is broken. If I could only imagine the money went to the elderly poor Israelis or something positive besides buying up enough bunker buster and antipersonnel bombs to kill your neighbors in the upcoming months. I think the US money is supposed to be spent only on defense, what a joke. In 2005 Israel got more military money than Afganistan, which might explain our success there.
That the Lord for George W. Bush, may you and your family be blessed for supporting Israel. I AM GLAD MY TAX PAYER MONEY IS GOING TO A GREAT CAUSE. I HOPE THE U.S GOVERNMENT WILL STOP GIVING MONEY TO THE PALESTINIANS, I AM FED UP WITH U.S TAX PAYER MONEY GOING TO LOW LIFE TERROTISTS!!
When will Gods Chosen People be able to support themselves ?? Israel is like a lazy 45 year old who refuses to get a job and lives off his parents. Pathetic.
As an American who is struggling to keep going I agree with your post completely. As you say, end this financial aid to Israel. Israel is wealthy enough and doesn't need it, and we do. But Israel is never going to refuse it, either! Surprise, surprise!
"The Jewish people were chosen to bless the world, not rule it" But do you think that's possible, Virginia? They are certainly ruling the West Bank now and until recently Gaza too. And if so, how do you believe they will bless the world? Is this in the Bible?
That is my opinion exactly - the money could be used for better purposes rather than giving it to Israel - already a wealthy nation - and so doing makes America unpopular in the world.
Janice, every point you made in your post to Ben Jabo about the "morality" of Israel, and the illegal occupation, and returning to the pre-1967 borders, I have already made myself to him. However, all he did was call me names. Maybe you'll have better luck.
"I hope America did not make a payment to keep Israel out of Gaza" Don't worry Ben; as usual, American money went to Israel with no strings attached.
"Poor US taxpayer..." And getting poorer all the time......
....."alms for the poor", Israel says, just like in the Monty Python film. But Israel has a strong economy and is very wealthy, and even more, there are many American-Jews here who give private donations in the millions to Israel. Wouldn't you think that would be enough for any reasonable country? But no - Israel was asking for, what was it, 50 million more?? As you say, end the occupation and end the suffering of the Palestinians. Regards!
"How did you come to determine Israel's occupation of Palestine illegal"? Actually, it was not me who did that, DK. The International Court in the Hague has done that, and international law has done it. For an occupying power to build settlements and move its population onto the occupied land is also illegal according to international law. But I can't believe you needed me to tell you this and didn't already know it.
"Israel's neighbors are armed with better and better weaponry" The Palestinians certainly are not. They have stones, AK47s, and home-made Qassam rockets which Israelis themselves have said are unreliable.
"Name one Arab country that is more moral than Israel" The point is not that there is an Arab country more moral than Israel. The point is that as long as Israel continues its illegal occupation of Palestinian land, complete with settlements, military, oppression, etc., Israel has no justification for calling itself moral.
"USA gives aid to Israel not because they support Israel from the bottom of their hearts but because it is in the best interest of the USA to do this" I don't agree with you, Saimon...there is a presidential election next year and now the candidates are campaigning...almost all of them mention Israel repeatedly in their speeches; and Bush does often. Also, I don't think it's in America's best interests as you do; our support of Israel has made for very bad relations with the Arab world for us.
"According to you which is the most moral country in the Middle East" I really do not know the answer to that, but for sure I cannot believe it is Israel.
"First get it out of your noggin that the Occupation is illegal. It's quite just and correct". This being the case, then why has the occupation been declared illegal by the International Court in the Hague and also by international law? A poster here also mentioned that an Israeli court declared it illegal also, but you'd know best about that... When did I ever say that the Palestinians provide good examples of "brotherly love"? The fact that a people are treated badly does not make them any more noble.
I am 100% behind the money for Israel. It's one of our better expenditures. I understand the Israeli desire to not be obligated but as an American, I don't think of Israel as obligated. Seriously I think of Israel as not a part of America but everyone's land. It's my thinking that every nation on the planet should give to Israel.
With this post, #386, you've at last succeeded in shocking even me. To read your description of Palestinians: "they don't know how to work, create children willy nilly, shoot at each other all the time, use their kids and women for bombings" makes the reader understand how truly you must indeed hate the Palestinians. If a poster here had written a similar biased, prejudiced and hateful description of Israelis, how would you like it?
....as I've said before, the needs of our own country and people should come before Israel. What about New Orleans, not rebuilt since Katrina, what about the Twin Towers site, still a hole in the ground over five years later, what about the many various needs of our own population? Why is Israel put ahead of all this?
....it is much appreciated! If what you are actually trying to say is that I should hold fast to my own opinion, please rest assured that I intend to do so! As for the Washington Post, living in Connecticut, I have never read it. But perhaps I should as you recommend it so strongly. As for "being held accountable", if you are referring to posting, is anyone? Are you?
"All this love and care goes only as long as they can knock against Israel". You are quite wrong about that as regards myself, Tomy. I've been a supporter of Palestinian rights for many years, while living in England and America. This is because they are living in the most appalling conditions and have never seen any improvement. I can assure you that if it was Jordan or Eygpt or Saudi Arabia who was oppressing them and stealing their land, I would be just as strongly against those countries for it as I am against Israel.
....I don't mind disillusioning you a bit, but its the Palestinians who would like their land back, and that is surely a lawful and understandable position to take. If other Arab countries deny Israel's right to exist, does this matter? Obviously, Israel is here to stay, whether they like it or not. And in fact, as long as there is an America, there will be an Israel.
Why don't you discuss the issues instead of calling Deborah silly, childish names? So she has "nothing intelligent to say" because she does not agree with you??!!!
"I don't mind paying the israeli tax...Israel has a right to exist". Certainly Israel has a right to exist, and I for one have never once stated otherwise. So I agree with you on that point. But can't Israel pay for its own wars? You must be making a lot more money than I am, if you really don't mind paying for Israel.
"the support for Israel will wane". Making peace with its neighbors would be in Israel's very best interests. Even now, it might not be too late.
"the whole world is replying on Israel, learning from her..." Tomy, what on earth are you talking about? I can only hope that our own military refuses to learn any lesson from that of Israel...I expect the Palestinians would agree with me.
"The fairest, the most advanced, the most charitable, first to help in any emergency in the world, is the USA and Israel" The USA, absolutely...Americans are among the most benevolent people in the world. As a country and individually they hand out money to every cause. But...did you also say Israel...? What?? What does Israel give to anyone? Taking is their agenda...our money and Palestinian land.
So sorry to hear that the "likes of me" is boring, but if you reply to me I'll reply to you, of course. Again, I admire your total confidence in your position. You state (repeatedly) to me that every American government will continue their support for Israel. You state this with absolutely no hesitation. You may of course be correct; I wouldn't guess what politicians will do. However, I have a different opinion, and have every right as an American to say so. So that's that.
..when you said "Israel isn't getting any money". I wish you'd tell that to Bush then perhaps those billions just won't come your way this year....
....we should try using it to support the creation of an independent state for Palestinians, free of all Israeli control. As for Israel, as other posters have noted, it has a very strong economy. Let it pay for itself. Why should America be its constant paymaster?
....you've got it around the wrong way. Israel isn't fighting any wars for us, it's us who are paying for them to fight their own wars. In case you hadn't noticed, Hamas and Hezbollah are not likely to be attacking us any day soon. Al Quaida, yes, but are they in Israel?
....there have been several polls and opinion pieces in the papers which show quite clearly that not all Americans support our tax dollars propping up the artificial state of Israel. I don't understand why you'd deny this, or why it should even matter to you; you obviously don't mind what your taxes pay for.
As you say, our politicians who think they are acting on Americans citizens behalf in handing out our money to Israel are very much making us look bad, and generating hate for us in the Middle East.
....I don't believe any of this money is going to go back into the American economy at all. I can't imagine how you make that out. Economic aid Israel does not need, as you stated. Therefore, why can't it pay for its own military aid, which as you say we are giving it? And every faction which is anti-Israel is not automatically anti-American, either.
The only reason it "bothers me", as you said, is because it just doesn't seem very important. The issues are surely what we interested in discussing, not who is who and if not why not. But of course, your posts are your own business.
More than sad, it's a total waste of sending the UN most of the money they rely on to feed Palestinian refugees for the past 60 years. They don't know how to work, create children willy nilly, shoot at each other all the time, use their kids & women for homicide bombings, allow their leaders to steal most of the charity they receive from various sources. More than sad, another generation brought up to grub off the UN & America, the UN's main provider of cash. SAD INDEED!!
They work as one to force aid to the jewish state. Greenmail, blackmail, bribery,smearing all part of their MO to get more money for israel. Today another jew became a multu-billionaire at non-jewish Americans expense. Steve schwarzman. Also these people force the US to buy $10's of billions of israel goods.
Great point !
sad sending money to israel to support killings of arabs, when instead we americans could of used that money to better our nation. hmmmmmmm when will all the americans learn the truth of what goes on. wwwiamthewitnesscom
Your concerns are most touching. Since you're so involved, what have you done to ease the oppression of your Kurds?
GOD SAID TO ABRAHAM,I WILL BLESS THOSE THAT BLESS YOU AND CURSE THOSE THAT CURSE YOU.
Keep pressing your points aginst Israel and don't let facts or history get in your way. Keep reading the New York Times and the Washington Post, and don't stop now. And keep voting for the Democrat party. The best part is that they can't hold you accountable for anything you say since it's all based on thin air anyway. Keep you feet firmly planted in the air!!
All this "love and care" goes only as long as they can knock against Israel. As soon as Israel is out of the picture those will care for Palis as much as they care for Darfur were millions are reffuges,hundreds of thausands are butchered by Arabs, or care about massgraves under Sadam,or Syrian,Jordanian massacres against Homa and Palis,or Chinas oppression, or destruction of Chechnia and on, and on..... Their onesided bias is so obvious, it is screeming.The biggest haters of course the Arabs, again the reason for their "care" is only and only Israel. Real fony B.Sers
There were many foreign volunteers in Israel's armies, they came from the U.S., Canada & Europe. They've participated in all the wars. Christian's and their Clergy were among them. Check out a website "AMERICAN VETERANS OF ISRAEL", it't quite comprehensive. Also Machal 1948. American's, etc. didn't volunteer in the same manner that the lunatic Hihadi's do. NO bllod lust, no promise of 72 virgins, just wanting to help.
I hate to disillusion you, the neighbors are the ones that initiated the wars, commencing 5/15/48. Just check out "Wikipedia's TIMELINES ARAB ISRAEL CONFLICT", while you're at it GOOGLE "TIMELINES ISRAEL ARAB CONFLICTS", quite a few sources will give the sequences of event. It's not the simple matter of Israels wanting or making peace, it's the Arabs, who for the main part don't want Israel to exist.
You're truly a great prophetess. What will be, will be, what was, was. Now, do you have anything intelligent to say?
Israel is much like the left-leaning Spanish Repbulic of the mid 1930s, threatened by sundry fascist movements serving as proxies for the principal fascist nations of today -- in this case, fascist theocracies. What America *ought* to be doing, along with the EU and other civilised nations, is helping both Israel and themselves more fully, by completely disarming the fascist theocracies, which can be done fully from the air. And because this is of course likely to result in Israel's coming under attack more directly from the fascist theocrats' themselves, those of us who can should volunteer to assist in Israel, like the Liberty Brigades who faught Franco in the 1930s. I, though not Jewish, intend to be among them, assisting in a hospital or shelter. I very much hope there will be others, including some of the Arab Americans who believe in the liberal democratic project.
Ted, Don't talk like a fool! Israel has a right to defend herself against all enemies,real and perceived. If you were entirely surrounded by enemies, each one clamoring for your total annihilation, wouldn't you need a reliable friend, one upon whom you can depend for support? Well for your information that exaactly the situation Israel finds herself in. The United States will always be a trusted ally against the forces of evil. Israel is a target of the forces of evil, hence the U.S. must not, cannot, and it shall not relent in its support, so get used to it.
I don't mind paying the Israeli Tax to sustain Israel against the evil intentions of the Islamists to destroy her existence. Israel has a right to exist! Those islamic regimes that are against her existence better get used to having Israel around because she isn't going anywhere anytinme soon.
doctrines. As long as opposing/contradictory doctrines exsist, there will be no peace. Peace will come when we live as one.
...your naivety about America is astounding. America will abandon Israel as soon as they decide that the negative results of supporting Israel outweigh their gains. America has true loyalty for America and nowhere else.
There is a movement slowly gaining momentum. The support for Israel will wane. Make peace with your neighbors. You have much to lose.
Only one other poster in my memory has written so much, saying so little. I'm going to swear you're are the same. Your force of habit is a dead giveaway. I didn't need Kath or anyone else to detect you. Junkies are junkies, it's easy to tell when they're high on their own junk. Try discussing ACTUAL facts for a change, not your fantasies of what was and is.
New York Times. June 19, 2007. Mandatory reading for everybody.
the cold war. Israel was the only country in the world that time to asure the oil flow to the free world. Communists were trying hard to take over, Israel was the only obsticle for them And now, the whole world is relying on Israel,learning from her, to fight Arab/Moslem terror. A huge danger to the world. And all the contributions to the worlds vellbeing... It it mindbugling from such a small country.
reality the way Pssd does. The last time I heard so much lies when the communist politbureau give their oppinions.But you, Anarchists are out of style for now. To answer every lie would take too long. But in nutshell, I lived in many countries, and the only thing I can tell you, the fairest, the most advanced,the most charitable,first to help in any emmergencies in the world, It is USA and Israel.The lights to the nation. Envy,alterios motives,sometimes, darkens your vision.
Hey Silvienne You cannot wait for the end of President Bush' tenure.But whichever party wins the next elections they will always remain faithful to Israel and continue their support,whether financially or otherwise.They need each other. Your illusionary end game is just that.An illusion.The U.S.A will never abandon Israel irrespective which party wins,they need Israel ever more.Enough on this subject as it is getting a bit boring,especially from the likes of you......
Make my day. I'm eagerly awaiting the information I requested. After all you made the charge, now's the time to prove it....."#319 Al Swain Name: * BEN JABO City: USA State: I`m amazed that you`re unaware that the NY Times is held in disrepute. Their reporters have been caught too many times faking stories. What was once a GREAT newspaper has turned far left, prostituted itself in the attempt to retrive readership. What`s the specific name of that alleged poll, really would like to check it out, if it exists. Everytime, without exception, one of you guys quote stats, percentages or anything related to number, when asked for the source or link, you get flumoxxed and retreat, never answering the question. NAME OF POLL, DATE, ETC. RSVP
It is not through weapons that we have peace. It is through diplomatic means that we achieve stability in the region and through positive communication betwee Israel and the Arab countries.
Did not want to respond,but you asked for it. Hey Hannah my predictions are not tedious and I am right. However,if this cabal as you put it,can come to pass, its consequences would be catastrophic for the whole region. If and when Israel, or the U.S decide to embark on this venture it will have to be achieved with caution. That you say so much for lemmings running into the sea:Yes,quite correct. It is an unimaginable scenario,not only will Iran disappear,but the whole region will end into a large dust bowl. Intelligent people have a clear idea and know it. It will try to achieve it with caution and manage to carry it out without destroying the whole of the Middle East. We?ll see what transpires. If Israel decides to attack Iran and manages to carry out an attack it can,but will be extremely careful before embarking on it.Never underestimate the Iranian regime,and it would effect the whole world as a consequence.So,even you in Canada have to ponder on this subject,for you will not be immune.
When are idiots like Olmert and Bush going to realise that all the weapons in the world won't make a difference in a year or so from now? Once nukes enter the equation the whole Middle East could become a desolate wasteland in seconds. Maybe the whole world. Peace is the only way forwards. If the last few years still haven't taught Bush and Olmert that they can't win through war, we're all doomed.
Silvienne And I'll go mine how is that for accommodation Am I the FBI,now,there's a question!If I were do you think I'd announce it here for your edification?Certainlly NOT.All very hush,hush! If I inform people here it is necessary and should be noticed because some people are being led astray,especially some of dear ones. And why does it bother you?Or is it because it does not suit you agenda? Nuff said about it.The fact you noticed it and made a point of it shows it bothers you.Why?I am well aware for its reasons. END
Maureen It is a bit addictive coming here,and you just couldn't keep away.Don't blame you in the slightest. Now be a good gal and I'll send you a nice smile in return. o(~_*)o
Hi Jeff We both have something in common,I also have American Citizenship,so we are equal.(Labhras). Not quite Labhras.Jeff was born there and is a real American.What is more he is a real patriot unlike yourself.Great difference. YOU? perhaps follow David Duke? or like minded types of Americans. Botom line,no comparison!
God promised that whoever blesses Israel, He would bless them. So I agree with blessing Israel.
there is nothing to prove but you will be seeing the truth very soon--
US always supported Islamic regimes (it still does support the religious AK PArty in Turkey). The reason US supported Islamic regimes is that first: they are very easily corruptable second: they are always against the left wing, therefore the country would be open to exploitation by the US companies third: the religious states put the ignorant nations to sleep and make them accept everything as their 'fate'. Then the whole plan entered their arse in september 11. Now still, Americans are illogical enough to support the Turkish islamists hoping that the result will be "moderate islam", there is no such thing. Israel ? Well Israel is happy with any instability that gives rise to the weakening to any country apart from America in the world.
YOUR PROFOUND DISGRUNTLEMENT WITH THE USA SHOULD CAUSE YOU TO GET OUT !!
Does BTW stand for Brothers of the Third Wheel Official site bringing you complete information about trikes and triking. Or does it stand for Baths, Tiles, Woodfloors AFAIC and FWIW stop using acronyms BTW Tá deoch agat. TTFN EOM
Diplomany is the art of looking after your own interests. 1. Israel is the united states permenant aircraft carrier 2.All the military aid keeps Americans in work for years. 3.US acts in its own interests and nothing else Nothing in this world is given free
"In a recent New York Times scientific poll 72% of Americans stated they no longer want to send their hard earned tax dollars to israel." Sure pal... That is just a flat out lie. In every single reputable pol taken, financial support for Israeli defense is approved by a large majority of Americans and that number has been steadily increasing over the years. "... American taxpayers send $23.000.00 a year for each Jewish Israeli. Non Jewish Israelis don't see a cent..." What planet do you live on? The number in fact comes to less than $500.00 a year for each Jewish Israeli. Please allow me to do the math for you. You are only off by well -$22,500, which is a lot, and all Israelis benefit not just Jewish Israelis. Counting all Israelis, the actual amount per person is less than $350.00. A very economical way for the US to support the defense of an important friend and ally, especially compared to the $100's of billions annually we spend in support of the Arab countries.
I'm not a Jew (yet) or a Christian (never will be), I'm simply a proud American. I want you all to know that despite what these people may say on this talk-back forum, they do not represent America. They seek her destruction (along with the destruction of Israel - G-d forbid). America stands behind Israel always, and will continue to do so even if it means walking towards our own destruction. Most Americans see Israel as a brother and not simply a partner in an ideological war. We see you as being in a situation that is at the very least existential. And what, in such a situation, would a brother do to help? To the people of Israel and for that matter --all Jews: You have been beset by enemies since the beginning. You have suffered immeasurable adversity and despite this you survive strong and proud to this day. No more should you have to suffer the pain and hardships you've known in the past. Above everything, you have an ally to the death in me. Fight for what's yours. Shalom
Stop fooling yourselves; the US doesn?t do deals, which aren?t in her best interest First of all Israel isn?t getting money, The Money stays in the US, Which means Israel is obligated to perches armaments of the US, That means work for people in the US how assemble armaments, If Israel has to get 30 air plans, and she can get 10 by aid, she still has to buy 20 US by this says to Israel look here is a fare deal buy a packet of 30 get 10 on the house If Israel can get a fare deal, the US knows that Israel won?t go and develop that same weapon, That means US has less competition in the industry, Armaments used by the Israeli army are brand by all armies as the best an army can have, which means more customers to the US industry. The US has a lot to gain from this more then the average person thinks. This deal is better for the US than for Israel ? but that is another story!
Great post. Not all are snookered by the BS! High regards.
What a nice thing to post. Regards.
toward the Israel Defense Fund, it's equal to a full tank of gas in my SUV, or 3 cases of beer, Israel is one of Americas allies fighting on the front between Democratic and Islamic fundamentalist battles,if the Palestinians get in the way,SO WHAT, choose sides now,but we like our freeedom of speech,and being able to see our Pretty Woman without a scarf,satellite tv,a better education,being able to go to grocery store and having every imaginable food available,no shortages of electricity,gas,running water always,or choose the Islamic Fundamentalist,live like the Taliban,or a better life with Hamas,Hezbollah,or Al-Quaida back in the stone ages.
T"he alternative is a war that Israel can`t win, and they will be forced to the negotiating table, with worse terms than they have now." Bernie, Do not be too sure of what you believe. The arabs believed they could destroy Israel in the past wars with Israel but they failed miserably. So I wouldn't bet all my money on the arabs if I will you. You might just lose your stake!!! Regards
I say aye but on condition that Israel use it for defence only!!!!!
I'm amazed that you're unaware that the NY Times is held in disrepute. Their reporters have been caught too many times faking stories. What was once a GREAT newspaper has turned far left, prostituted itself in the attempt to retrive readership. What's the specific name of that alleged poll, really would like to check it out, if it exists. Everytime, without exception, one of you guys quote stats, percentages or anything related to number, when asked for the source or link, you get flumoxxed and retreat, never answering the question. NAME OF POLL, DATE, ETC. RSVP
And it's a no brainer we're in the same boat in the Long War against the evil forces dreaming that this time they'll succeed in taking over the world after failing twice in the past. The Arab regimes have proved that the only thing they can be relied upon is that they can never be relied upon. Israel, OTOH, shares the same ideals we do, and we also share the same enemies. So, please keep paying your taxes well, we need all the help we could get.
Most of this money is going to go back into the American economy. So stop complaining that this money is just going to stay in Israel. Also, this is not economic aid, which Israel does not even need due to its great strides in many fields which lead to its good economic status. However this is military aid which Israel needs to protect itself from radical Islamic leaders, groups, and regimes which are not only anti-Israel, but are also Anti-American.
Off course,those weapons are useless against a culture of death. Death means martrydom to this people and they are brainwashed to believe that they will be rewarded with virgins in heavan. How pathetic!!!
POA, while i do NOT condemn all americans as they have no control over their government once elected, I do condemn the politicians that think they are acting on the citizens behalf, this is dangerous as it makes all americans look bad and therefore targeted, I make my decision on the individual regardless of race, religion or creed. you do have a right to be pssd off, it's your hard earned cash that not being re-invested in you and your country, not only is america doing it but australia too,i feel the pain.
FB:"You are helping the only democracy in the Middle East defend itself against fanatic regimes which are set to destroy the Jewish state.", you mean against something YOU have created, please spare us.
Interesting to see how much you seem to regard our money as your money. Typical of ungrateful and greedy Israel. Greedy for our money, for Palestinian land....
Thank god Bush only has another year and a half. Not but what he can't do even more damage in that time....however, his handing over of our taxpayers money to support the artificial state of Israel and its constant wars is one of his worst actions.
KUTW, your favourite word is "jihadists"! You are so often accusing people here of being in league with jihadists, being supporters of Hamas, of Hezbollah, and who-else-knows-what... You don't seem to understand that a great many Americans just don't consider Israel and America as "allies and partners". They wish Israel didn't have so much of our money.
"Ever seen what an aerial bomb does to a building and the people inside?" Just so, and don't forget those hellfire missiles that Israelis flying fighter planes use in their extra-judicial executions of Palestinians that they think belong to Hamas....and anyone else who looks like the person they think belongs to Hamas, and anyone else in the car, walking down the street, standing by...just has the bad luck to be nearby...
"Israel has never asked others to fight its battles" As we write, Rose, Israel is and has been desperately trying as hard as it knows how to incite America to attack Iran, because Iran hates Israel. Israel would like it to be us to do the attacking because we will then receive the retaliation. Naturally.
First you were complaining that Haaretz wouldn't post what you wrote, now you are posting all these investigative reports on "who's who"! What does it matter, Kath? Let's just discuss the issues!
"Its our tax dollars that allows the IDF to function". Yes, to our great discredit. We are subsidising the murder of innocent Palestinians by the IDF and we can't do anything to stop it.
....what's with all these posts tracking and researching all these posters? What on earth does it matter what name they post under or even who they are?
yes youre right... israel and the us are the best of friends... simply because you have no other friends, or simply lost those you guys had.
The only Americans not concerned about the monstrous amount of money sent to Israel must surely be those Americans who do not pay taxes!
people in glass house do not throw stones
Yes, and can you believe, the Israelis asked for even more of our money?! Their greed is incredible. It is only matched by our president's stupidity. Israel laughs at us and mocks us all the way to the bank to cash our checks, and they think we don't know it.
"In a recent New York Times poll 72% of Americans stated they no longer want to send their hard earned tax dollars to Israel". I live forty miles from New York in Connecticut, and, from all I've read and heard, your statement above is certainly correct. As you say, let Israel pay for its own military adventures. It can certainly afford it while we have our own priorities at home.
Please send proof via a internet link with your claim that: "More distortions of the truth. In a recent New York Times scientific poll 72% of Americans stated they no longer want to send their hard earned tax dollars to israel." Otherwise, your posting is just another typical example of how Anti-Israel/Anti-Semitic posters on this site will say anything they can think of to prove thier factless, baseless points. Come, on...prove me wrong....I bet you can't!!
"The relationship between Israel and USA is one of mutual support" Perhaps you'd explain how Israel is of any use to America. Actually America's constant support of Israel is a hindrance to good relations with the Arab world for America. It would be more correct to say that israel is America's number one client state. As for your saying that Israel "deserves all the military aid it can get from America"....well, please, just carry on helping yourselves to our tax dollars. After all, what do we need them for?
by giving it to the Palestinians then the US can do the right thing by supporting Israel!
The relationship between Israel and USA is one of mutual support. As the US staunchest ally, Israel deserves all the military aid it can get. What's the problem. Wait, I need to go and spend time with my intern...
More distortions of the truth. In a recent New York Times scientific poll 72% of Americans stated they no longer want to send their hard earned tax dollars to israel. The israeli jews are very wealthy and they can afford to pay for their own military adventures.
The israelis are very wealthy because they have played Uncle Sam for Uncle Sap. The israelis cry poverty but they control hundreds of billions of dollars. Hard working American taxpayers send the israelis USD$23,000 a year for each jewish israeli. Not one cent of that money ever reaches a non-jew. The israelis lavish themselves with luxury hi-rise apartments and villas and expensive clothing and jewlery. The non-jewish part of the population is left to starve. As an American taxpayer I cannot stand to see my hard earned tax dollars be wasted on these lazy good for nothing people who see our tax money is an entitlement. The israelis NOW want Americans to work longer hours so they can receive MORE FREE TAXPAYER MONEY.
You speak as a welfare recipient, surely.
Excellent post, pssd...do keep on posting. Regards.
smile ;)
I believe that your tediously recorded facts are probably right...it seems par for this particular course. D'ya know what? If this evil little cabal does strike Iran, it is the end of the zionist experiment. Much will survive, but so-called Israel will not. So much for lemmings running to the sea.
I just love your grasp of world economics. Brilliant!! LOL!!!
This is just meant to appease Israel, so that the deal to sell smart bombs to Saudi Arabia could go smoothly.
anti missile defense systems, works for me!!
Who is to blame that taxes cannot be spent on life's enjoyment rather than life's ruin? Who is exempt from fault? Who is trying to turn this around? What have YOU done? Promote peace, or encourage the fight?
The founding of both nations is tainted by the dismemberment and displacement of indigenous people. The political processes of both are corrupted by a powerful military-industrial complex. Both are disproportionately influenced by the fervently religious. Both have a legacy of racism and discrimination. Both have recently launched aggressive wars. Both are currently mesmerized by a "clash of civilizations" narrative of global events. Both are committed to torture, assasination, and governmental overthrow as instruments of policy. Both are confused as to why dropping bombs on civilians does not further their political ends. Both eager to test new military technologies on civilian populations. Both using military occupation to further their ambitions. Both working to suppress and subvert modernization and democracy in the Arab world. The mainstream media of both restrict the parameters of foreign policy debate. I could go on...
Post #272 says, "No need to blame others for your mistakes, just look inside. This is the main problem with the Muslim world, they never find fault in themselves and always blame someone else like Israel, etc." The same is true for Israel, the United States and virtually every other country. Most people and societies "blame others" for their own mistakes. It is inconceivable that the writer (post #272) comes from New York City and truly believes that it is the Muslims who always blame others for their mistakes and never find fault in themselves. Just look around and listen to your friends.
Can't do anything honest. I wish him well in his business endeavors. Three months a bankruptcy.
Israel might need the extra 50M to trigger a war before it's too late. "World oil demand is rising twice as fast as a year ago, straining the petroleum industry's ability to keep up with global needs and likely resulting in higher and more-volatile prices for some time to come." (source: WSJ)
Writing under all those aliases. Yeah, I've been tipped off. No matter how much cologne you splash on a skunk, it's still foul smelling beast. Just proves how honest you are NOT!!
I just knew something was fishy. I told him off in a post today. Hope Ha'Aretz censors let it through. Thanks, I've saved your info in my sh-t file, contains stuff on just about all the bashers.
Howdy Tess; The U.S. Congress decides who is or is not in violation of human-rights standards and not the biased, skewed, and narrow-minded opinions of "the World Court, along with data from Amnesty, HRW, and B`Tselem" which all seem to ignore the human-rights abuses of everybody except Israel. Civilians die in wars; that is an unavoidable fact. In order to show that a war crime has been committed, you will have to show that "protected persons" were deliberately targeted by the hostile force otherwise it is "regretable collateral damage" during a period of armed conflict. Actually, Israel has consistently maintained a civilian-to-combatant kill ratio of about 1-1 in the Palestinian Territories which is an excellent record since the usual ratio during a period of armed conflict is closer to 3-1. If anything, Israel should be commended and not condemned for that.
For allto read. IAF,USAF dramatically uprade cooperation status. The Israeli Air Force has significantly upgraded the level of its cooperation with the United States Air Force and now receives updates on American procurement decisions. An agreement on the cooperation reached at meetings last month between head of IAF Procurement and Equipment Brig-gen.Dr.Kobi Bortman and senior USAF officers in Washington and Dayton,Ohio. Can the IAF take out Iran's nukes?Bortman,an expert,on aircraft structural engeneering with a doctorate from George Washington University in St.Louis,gave the IAF's Entrprise Resources Planing system.The system serves as a single database for both manpower and inventory lists and enables cost-effective maintenance of supplies and other resources. "We are interested in many of the same platforms and systems,and the Americans look at us as a small-scale laboratory of themselves"a high-ranking IAF officer told JPOst."Now every time the USAF signs a contract and purchases something new,they will update us?. This updates will only be given to Israel,the officer said,when America purchases a system or platform related to the IAF. And there?s more of it,for the cynical lot of you who thinks the ties between the U.S and Israel is tenuous and not a reciprocal in every field particularly this latest endeavour can think again?
Kathy, I am at a disadvantage because I don't recall ever dealing with Clickfool (under that name) and not being familiar with his style. But I noticed he is from Sussex, the same as Star of David - my double. So you might very well be correct. I will pay more attention. Thanks.
Jeff hello Noe Labhras has admitted of having American citizenship(which I knew)I will not say more,bar to remind him that obviously he holds a dual citizenship and thus both passports.So,he should just keep his mouth shut when he mentions the Israelis who have the same privilege. He seems to think one rule for him(the Irish)and another for Israelis.I rest my case....
is using those weppons against civilians???? Do you read about Arab and Iranian intentions toward Israel??? Just wondering. Try to be a little realistic,do not let your opinions be tainted by prejudice,otherwise you make yourself irrelevante.
IAF,USAF dramatically uprade cooperation status. The Israeli Air Force has significantly upgraded the level of its cooperation with the United States Air Force and now receives updates on American procurement decisions. An agreement on the cooperation reached at meetings last month between head of IAF Procurement and Equipment Brig-gen.Dr.Kobi Bortman and senior USAF officers in Washington and Dayton,Ohio. Can the IAF take out Iran's nukes?Bortman,an expert,on aircraft structural engeneering with a doctorate from George Washington University in St.Louis,gave the IAF's Entrprise Resources Planing system.The system serves as a single database for both manpower and inventory lists and enables cost-effective maintenance of supplies and other resources. "We are interested in many of the same platforms and systems,and the Americans look at us as a small-scale laboratory of themselves"a high-ranking IAF officer told JPOst."Now every time the USAF signs a contract and purchases something new,they will update us?. This updates will only be given to Israel,the officer said,when America purchases a system or platform related to the IAF. And there?s more of it,for the cynical lot of you who thinks the ties between the U.S and Israel is tenuous and not a reciprocal in every field particularly this latest endeavour can think again?
Idealogicly. This two countries are the only democracies not tainted by a very ugly past,Unlike Europe.They are both progressive,inovative, multicultured and not held back by their past.Both can show huge achivments in relativly short time.Both are willing to face adversity and have the persistance to overcame. Both have the most nobel ideas for the world.Real lights to the nations.Proud to be a part of both. Al the ratlings on this talkback is a plain idiocy.
It's $10, not $100. Can't you do arithmetic? And 75% goes to US companies.
But your problem is. Increasing numbers of Americans are seeing through AIPACS propaganda and are asking if blind support of Israel is worth it. Then there are the five Israelis running around Brooklyn with multiple passports and thousands in American tax dollars stuffed in socks. They are getting close despite the Fox news report which was declared a state secret. Look up the Sunday Herald report you would be amazed and I will be branded an anti semetic I'll be another Steve Bull after this
If the USA wanted to destroy the middle east she would have done so already. What alot of you fail to understand is we have the means to blow an entire country off the map in about 3.2 seconds if need be... We just choose not to... Because of the UN and their human rights watch.
Is it real or is is Memorex but in reality who cares. I believe that Genuine Tosefta is the real article and the other one the impostor. So if the impostor disappears as did Benny Hill Gurion than problem solved. Was that not easy? Whoever you are stop with those ridiculous bulletins. They are annoying.
We do!!!
Those inventions Cipora speaks of didn't help the IDF in Lebanon, and from what is being reported, whatever she is talking about is not much help for our soldiers in Iraq either. Some folks never learn. Regards.
An attack on the Aswan Dam, by the way, would be more damaging to Israel than a Nuke attack. That would be Israel intentionally attacking and killing civilians, and this time they could not say that 'Hezbollah was hiding behind the Dam.' No, the next war will be rather simple. It will be like having mosquitoes in your bedroom. Just constant, random, infrequent rocket attacks designed to force Israel to attack its enemies on their ground. Israel will be forced to continue invading and occupying countries, and will bleed economically until it loses the fight. And if it attacks Damascus or Syria or Cairo or Amman or Riyadh ... well that will just make it harder for Israel to back out of the losing fight.
You wrote, "The US is Israel,s only friend". Ever asked your self why, if your cause is so right you have no other benefactors. The assumption must be that your cause is not credible. Regards.
are a tad askew, mate. It is like Bill O'Reilly's polls responded to by his "premium" members and only them. I have forgotten the term used for "premium" in this latest Israel pole, but the point was the same. They don't bother to ask plain ole americans what they think. Given Katrina, the pollsters are afraid to ask. Regards.
The tax is much higher if you consider the wars the the US is executing for Israel and its lobby. I guess that Olmert also fixed date for the attack on Iran - more taxes and more death.
The "D" in IDF stands for defense. If the people of the PA and other [not all] Arab countries were smart, they would stop the threats to destroy Israel and the constant attacks of various kinds and make Israel prove it stands for defense. Israel is NOT out to dominate the world, they are helping to defend against those who are. There is nothing "weird" about a Christian who seeks GOD'S reign as opposed to mans. None of us are here to rule over the other, period. It's just that some have to learn the hard way, because they either refuse to listen or have been deceived.
When Germans wer bombing London Churchill did not say (Our best defense is Love), he put his military power and the mighty AF to wrk and he also asked USA to supply it. He laso asked USA to join but unfortunately Roozevelt waited until 2000 died in Pearl Harbor. 5 Million Jews living in tiny Israel surrounded by many hostile countries where Iran is trying to acquire nukes, You are not serious that only love will protect Israel from them.
You may bless eachother.
Natalie you ask how much 'Isdef Tax' is per a paycheck and total? ANSWER a LOT LOT less than the "Arab Tax" we pay - US money to Pals-Abbas,Fattah, UN for Atab 'refugees' 70 years later; Egypt; Lebanon; Jordan ; Iraq... Then there is the money to 9/11 families and the costs of rebuilding NYC from 9/11, plus Guantanimo. So Natalie you see Isreal is cheap- is a real bargain. Now you know.
they can double my contribution.
G-D bless america
Nothing unujual hapened. Israel and USA are best friends,thrue thick and thin. And nothing will change that. Of course The anti croud is kicking and screeming, as they did thruout the history whenever they had a chance to go against the Jew.Because everybody who has two eays can see what the Israels neighbours intention toward her, they do not make a secret out of it,but old habits die hard.
Hi Michael, You recall Bush SNR and his sec of State James Baker, who told Israel "Here is my Number, when you are ready for peace call me ' Dubya Snr lost the next election.Lesson is, do not mess with the israeli lobby. Regards
Well, I am honestly not surprised by this announcement. One congressman has tallied the administrations violations of US laws near 27. This is one more to add to the pile. It is against US law to provide aid, especially military aid, to nations in violation of international human right standards. The recent rulings by the World Court, along with data from Amnesty, HRW, and B'Tselem should be adequate to see that giving Israel further support violates US laws. But, honestly, this has not bothered any Administration in a long while, Democrat or Republican. But, if US weapons continue to be used on Arab civilians, it will no doubt come to court here, given the rising affluence of the Arab communities in the US. That is when you will see an end to these aid packages, or the US will be exposed as hypocrits.
In addition to inelegant, your post is unfair because Israel and the US are allies and partners. They do business together which benefit both countries. Are you a hamas and co. supporter? If that is so, you should thank me and all the other Europeans, who have been financing the pal jihadists for many years?
Hi Jeff you and I have one thing in common, I also have American Citizenship.So we are equal.?????. Difference is I use mine to advance the American idea. Rgatrds
Quiet the opposite is true. Neither Isral nor USA wants destabilize teh ME. Especially for a small state like Israel theh only way to thrive is a stable peaceful ME. As far aas Turkey - it was the short sighted politicians from both AKP and CHP who voted against teh March 1 bill (Tezkere) which would allow Turkish troops to control north Iraq - that is causing al the dificulties. No need to blame others for your mistakes, just look inside. This is the main problem with the Moslem world, they never find fault in themselves and always blame someone else like Israel, USA or the western world and yet while the west goes ahead the moslem world is in chaos.
Gosh I hope for the sake of America , that they dont get too many of those type of Relationships. BTW , The norm as I understand it,is to loan the money. But who can blame Israel. They can get the Americans to continue funding their brutal Apartheid program in the occupied territories. Murphy and support for Israel is ?????.
"Cipora & all Israel, You are SO welcome!To God be the Glory! Praise God for unity, in light of sanctification. "Our God is an AWESOME God, He reigns!!! From Heaven above, with wisdom, power and LOVE!!!" Do you know that song? One we can sing together. Hallelu Yah!!! Shalom." So you're celebrating the sending of 2.5 billion dollars worth of bombs, rockets and shells to tear, main and destroy human flesh, are you? You're going to sing hymns while people die are you? Can't remember Jesus ever piloting an F16. "So the money is not to "kill" anyone. It is for defense to bring about a change. Our best defense is Love" Why the inverted commas? Ever seen what an aerial bomb does to a building and the people inside? It certainly "changes" them, and it doesn't just "kill" them, it blows great holes through them.
money well spent and a far better return than from pouring it into Islamist infested toilets.Israel has NEVER asked others to fight her battles, let alone refusing to fight at all.
*BEN JUST A QUICKY.HAARETZ IS BEING MEAN AND THUS WHAT I POSTED TO YOU ALL AS INFORMATION WAS NOT PUT OUT.I AM DETERMINED ONCE AND FOR ALL FOR THIS TO REACH YOU SOMEHOW. "DON'T FORGET STUFF"(CLICKFOOL) "EMPATHY" (CLICKFOOL) "JEBADIAH SPRINGFIELD" (CLICKFOOL) "DON CAMILIO" (CLICKFOOL) Lastly now he has business to attend and flew the forum.Of course,he has to spend sometime with his wifey and son.Hey! where is harzion? he would agree with me.Anyhow,respond,and challenge this pseudo DON(my ass)nevertheless. And do not let him get away with it.Clickfool did read my deduction and instead of denying,NOT A DICKY BIRD FROM HIM.Which goes to show..... P/S Haaretz this is for 220 *BEN JABO
Bernie, Israel does not need to nuke Egypt-a few bombs to the Aswan Dam and Egyptfloods to Med Sea result: massive death destruction of 90% of that counry/people.All the 23 Arab nations total GDP is -1/2 of Israel.Ever wonder why US uses israel electonics and weapons?Further,think - nuking Israel will destroy nearby Arab nations too.. .gather that is ok as long as Israel destroyed. Says much about your ilk. The Saudi royal house will not rule much longer. The Saudis need peace with israel to stay alive.
I believe you owe a BIG thanks to the U.S, Its our tax dollars thats allowing the IDF to function.
I bet you don't mind the US has spent billions of dollars to save from and prop up the Muslim Albanians in the Balkans. To top it off, the USA Army and Air Force was used to bomb Christian Serbs over there as well. It was your taxes too...
Tosefta hello Earlier,about an hour ago,I sent you all my brothers/sisters an announcement you about an interesting phenomenon that has been happening of late.I will now go on before I retire to have my nourishment. So Tosefta here goes,in hopes that Haaretz puts it out. There is an impostor here by several diguizes and they are all one and the same. 1-"Don't forget Stuff"(Clickfool), 2-"Empathy" (Clickfool) 3-"Jebediah Springfield"(Clickfool)BUT!you Tosefta,who has an incisive mind did question this odd name of Jebadiah.But still responded to him.No mater. 4-"Don Camilio" is the latest:(Clickfool). Tosefta,I am well aware of what I am talking about,and irrespective of who it may be,it behoves all of you to respond and challenge this person.This Jebediah responded to me briefly last week and quotted Blair. There's a thing,Blair was not mentioned in the said article,and thus another nail in the coffin for Clickfool.
Muhammud al-Swain, Thank you for speaking out. It is indeed shameful beyond words that US tax payers are propping up Israel's military they should be paying for their own evil weapons of war. And imagine people like Kath and Cipora are thanking US tax payers? How short sighted. They remind me of the spectators in the Rome Colosseum cheering on the Lions. Why can't they see brutalizing one's neighbors and bulldozing their way onto their land is a receipe for disaster not success? I can't see any future for those people in the ME anymore. It's just not going to happen stockpiling weapons. Dutch
them of your post is that the Zionists need to get a BIGGER beggin cup!!! They indeed have perfected beggin to an art, yup, they have. Beggars are never respected, no matter how the money is spent. Next time around, take a BIGGER beggin cup. If you are a beggar, no need to be bashful about demanding more. The amount does not matter, but a beggar is never respected. Regards.
FUNNY IS IT NOT,WHEN IT COMES TO KILLING THERE IS NO SHORTAGE OF MONEY.BUT WHEN IT COMES TO SAVING LIVES THERE IS NO MONEY.
BTW British fighting spirit no doubt help save my future life. Please do not try to imply that Britain or any other country went to war against Nazi Germany so that they could save Jews.That was the pro Nazi propoganda at the time and has been repeated here.
Your running monologue has more than a touch of verbal diarreah.
And there will be justice when Doris moves her arse out of occupied Natick, the sacred land of American Indians.
American support for Israel is galvanised and nurtured by AIPAC and the highly biased Fox News. "Your posts don`t reflect the views of most Americans" an neither are they intended to - I speak only for myself, not for the deluded idiots who voted for Dubbya. Actually the traditional support for Israelin the US is eroding - google 'Tikkun'. And unless the Pew Research Center asked every single American, it cannot statistically claim to represent the clear views of all Americans, many of whom are disgusted at IDF actions and those of the settlers in the OPT. Horseshit? Well, the American Christian Peacemaker Teams do honourable work in the OPT -folks from the US - goggle them to see what they do to protect innocent children in these parts. I will now check out this Pew Research Center.
How could any American be 'proud'? Hang your heads in shame for all that you have done! You, each and everyone of you, will not be forgiven in a hurry. There is blood all over your electoral hands.
Hello, Tony, I like the "'little executions' department" characterisation. Where you are mistaken, I believe, is thinking that he cares about this being noticed. He is a firm believer in relativistic morality, revolutionary justice, and cultural equality. He believes that Jews should be held to a higher standard than all others, and has appointed himself as the one to expound to us all just what those Jewish standards are and ought to be. I seriously doubt that he ever shared the burden of defending Israel. Yet, he is one of those, mercifully few, who thinks that his ideas will save the world from the corrupt, the ignorant, the stupid and the unfortunate. He does not fear being exposed since such fear of being exposed could stem only from a sense of shame, but shame is one emotion that he has not.
the country that has invited members of the Palestinian House Of Representatives for unexpected overnight stays, children for long periods in cells without trial, and barghouti who was especially invited over with escort, and vanunu who is still a 'house guest' Yes, Ben jabo safe over there in the Us of A, good old Dubbya territory.......... the answer is Israel. Bu it is not at war with Palestine so you can;t call Palestinians enemy aliens.
...What does Israel do for its money, apart from guarantee the US will never be popular with Muslims?... There you have inadvertently have touched off on the key to the whole problem. Nothing & no one is not only popular but a hated enemy as long as Israel is guaranteeing it with her existance & location. Fix that & you will solve the ME mistery. Good luck.
Mrs. Arafat has the millions upon millions that her husband stole for himself instead of his people that was given to him by the American tax payer. I think you Arabs need to change some of that selective memory or yours. Imagine that...money to a known pedophile...yes Arafat...
... account for your being in the US. The US supports Israel principally because Israel is a functioning liberal democracy, not only majority ruled but guaranteeing basic rights to its citizens, including the right not to worship in any particular way dictated by the state. It is the only such state in the middle east. The fact that there are no other such states in the middle east doubtless accounts for your presence in the US -- you doubtless emigrated there, or your parents or grandparents did -- both because it offered a safe haven from the backward regimes from whence they escaped, and because, in its munificence and generosity, it welcomed you as fully as it supports Israel. You should feel gratitude to America and kinship with Israel.
Every "Genuine Tosefta" post is by a fake, aka Star of David. I only use the name Tosefta. There were a couple of times were somebody faked this signature as well, but so far it was manageable. Why the fellow "Genuine Tosefta" does not publish under his own moniker? My assumption is that nobody pays attention to him; he is a rightwinger and we have those in abundance. The Fake needs some attention. Pity.
You wrote of Israel's "fervid rush to suppress democracy and truth in the Arab Middle East." Interesting, though, that the non-partisan Freedom House (freedomhouse.org) ranks press freedom in Israel as number one in the Middle East (strange way for a country to suppress truth -- by having the greatest press freedom in the region). Only Israel achieved the designation "free" press in this ranking; the number two country, Kuwait, was ranked "partly free. Moreover, the Economist Intelligence Unit, as reported by the BBC on 18 November 2005, ranked Israel as the country with the most political freedom in the Middle East (again, interesting way to suppress democracy -- by having the most political freedom in the region). I suppose that you, Hannah, could argue that your posts here are more objective and fair than rankings by organizations known for their rigorous research methodologies, but no rational person will believe you.
Oh, Chanah: please do your very best to see behind the scenes of that which seems apparent. You have a computer; why not use it? Do some research into more neutral areas other than the rah-rah cheerleader sites of so-called Israel. What is the common denominator of agreement between USofA/IL? Who is running the show(s) here? Where and how did this entire zionist preoccupation occur? Who, then, did it serve? Who, now, does it serve? And many more questions. Do try to look behind the shadows for no other reason than to see how you, personally, have been deceived.
The first UAV was the Hewitt-Sperry Automatic Airplane, developed towards the end of WW1. They were also used in the Vietnam war. In other words, it's not an Israeli invention.
Whenever you see one of these rabid zionists foaming at the mouth screaming about Palestinians being beggars I urge you to just laugh in his/her face and ignore them. Another thing is this propaganda about how this money "comes back to us". It doesnt come back to US it goes into the Defense contractors pocket. There is also the case of surplus goods where we (US Citizens) pay for these items as new for our defense and zionist within our govt take these new items and sell them at surplus prices to Israel using our own money some more. They turn around and resell these items to the highest bidder! Like Columbian drug cartels getting access to attack choppers sold to Israel so they can kill our children with drugs The Doctor Has Spoken
I am very pleased. Please continue to waste your money. Resistance cannot be defeated with military might. Similar to the jewish ghettos of germany, the palestinians are now resisting the dirty games of us imperialism. I love the israelis very very nice people, but they need to stop being an imperialistic pawn, same goes for the palestinians resistence is good, but not to the extent where you are resisting for other nations behalf.
Tosefta, is it such that all posts by 'Genuine Tosefta' are fake? Or does the fake use the name 'Tosefta' as well? Please let us all know. Regards.
Well, if you're right about the debt cancellation, I stand corrected. It's not the way it;s been portrayed in the British media, but you may be right. I stand, though, by teh fact that the US fought WWII mainly for its own reasons, not for Britain. Not that there's anything specially wrong with that. In terms of Israel, I don't think massive free arms shipments to them helps concentrate minds there on the need to compromise for peace. It also surprises me that the US, or certainly this Bush administration is never prepared to use the leverage of the money to persuade Israel to compromise. Bush has let Israel evade almost all commitments on settlements, crossing points, roadblocks. If they're paying the piper, they should call teh tune more.
part of my tax dollars are going to Israel. You are right about the economy and Jobs but you red states elected him twice voting against your interests. As for the sub prime mortgage debacle, caveat emptor, buyer be beware and lender to.
"It was aid! It was aid that allowed Britain to continue to fight heroically." You seem to be suggesting that this was a gift, Peter. We had to pay back every penny of the Lend-Lease money, with interest.
In several posts now, you have acted as Toast Mistress in giving thanks to whatever pimps happen to support your mongrel and motherless 'state' in its fervid rush to suppress democracy and truth in the Arab Middle East. Should I now assume that you chant as an auger of all zionist evil in the area? Or perhaps, to generously give you the benefit of doubt, you are merely a ditto stamp for the equally evil intentions and practices of your corrupt zionist regime?
And thank you for all you have endured to be that "lamp of David" and all you have taught us. How could we ever repay? We can't, but find great comfort in knowing God can, and will. Praise God for unity, in light of sanctification. "Our God is an AWESOME God, He reigns!!! From Heaven above, with wisdom, power and LOVE!!!" Do you know that song? One we can sing together. Hallelu Yah!!! Shalom.
In his post entitled "Why Should I Vote", John from "Katrina" writes: "Look at our presidential candidates even Mr. Obama. Have you heard any of them mentioning what happened to Katrina victims, I don`t think so, but all of them already paid their visits to Israel..." Uh, John? I *just this week* watched candidate and former US Sen. John Edwards going on at length about the inadequate response to Katrina. If memory serves he announced his candidacy from the 9th Ward (among the poorest and hardest hit areas in New Orleans). I'm going to go out on a limb and bet most of the rest of the Democratic candidates -- including Mr. Obama -- have mentioned it as well. Don't confuse your apparent dislike for Israel with any knowledge of domestic current events on your part. You may have a point in the title of your post - it might be best if you don't vote. Or at least study up a little first.
Of course, the fiscally and morally bankrupt USofA has to donate more weapons to so-called Israel in order that they decimate all signs and signals of Palestinian democracy. More to the point, so-called Israel is the only US stooge in the region to be called upon in the oncoming attack upon Iran. Good luck, to all of you zionists in your unerring call upon attracting bad luck upon you and yours.
Hello Tosefta, Did I miss your `humane behind` on Israel opening Erez crossing for injured Pals? There you are, all over the paper again, frowning with US aid to Israel, grapping about UN chief complains on Human rights commission blatant anti-Israeli biasness, pushing your key to peace in freeing Pal murderers, we get it. Welcome back Tosefta, or should you be humanly known from now on as `the little executions` department director, in dedication to your story of Hamas little executions as compared to the historical past. I believe I have told you before, when the people are twisting facts, conning, deceiving, fantasizing or trying to sell wishful thinking & personal agendas as the reality, the intelligence is not enough; they must also possess an absolute `coolness` & smarts to avoid being exposed. You `crack` very easily, every time the radical Islam showcasing itself or Israeli positives cross over your little, humane hart`. Same as Mark L vs Bush. God bless you for trying though
The Americans forgave Britain of the vast majority of its debts decades ago, leaving a remaining token sum of $83 million that was paid off last year. It is mind boggling how you can say "Britain never got any free rides." While I am inclined to agree that Israel should not accept these embarrassing American handouts, I strongly disagree with this protrayal of Israel as a "spoiled child", given its refusal to accept foreign troop assistance. I also do not discount the possibility that a future Israeli PM, in the spirit of Netanyahu, may forgo these payments, not to mention that Bush is promising money that may not even be there (as usual).
Ben - would you mind telling which country israel is at war with at the moment? israel is occupying lands it took forty years ago from countries that it has long since made peace with. and the only state in the middle east with a nuclear arsenal is israel. wo threatens who, again? so, what are you talking about? it seems to me he didn't answer because your question is misleading. also, it seems you are more loyal to israel than america, i suggest you make "aliyah". we need people here who support american, not foreign, interests. cheers.
While Americans struggle to make their mortgage and utility payments the state of israel DEMANDS another USD$50 BILLION. The American taxpayer already donates USD$23,000 annually to each israeli citizen. We do not have to send israel any more money. Let israelis pay for their own military adventures. The israelis have ripped us off for enough money. END ALL FINANCIAL AID TO ISRAEL, NOW!
The US gives "aid" which is infact a subsidy to the Us defence industry. It gives this aid to other countries in the region(Lebanon, Jordan, Egypt, irak). To make the jewish lobby happy, israel gets a little bit more and gun version 1.1 while the others get v1.0. Funny thing is, that these countries dont spend less of their own money on defence, but more. And even better, they spend it on US products. Of course the US ends up spending more on their own weapons due to inflated demand. The winner is hence the defence industry and to some extent their employes. The looser is... Mostly everyone else...
Israel was at the forefront in checking Soviet expansion during the cold war. In 1967, Egypt and other countries in the region, such as Syria, were allied with the USSR, and were armed by them. Defeating those countries in the Six Day War was a setback to the USSR. It must be remembered, that the Soviets had planned to participate on the Arab side in this war, but its speed and the very decisive victory, made this impossible. The Yom Kippur War was, again, a setback for the USSR. The war proved the superiority of American weapons, as they were tested on the battle field. This war also led to the development of stealth aircraft. Today, Israel is the only country standing in the way of Iran and its expension to the shores of the Mediterranian. Furthermore, much help has been provided by Israel in the field of weapons development. The unmanned arial vehicle was originally the idea of an Israeli. Israel has greatly contributed to the improvement of American fighter jets.
How can Israel be fooling the American public if the details of US aid to Israel are transparent and there for all to see?
I can't believe what I'm reading here. In fact, one of the most important aspects of the Marshall Plan was the debt forgiveness for the UK. Billions upon billions of dollars that were owed by the British over the years were written off, and rightfully so, if you ask me, just as long as Britain recognizes this fact instead of fudging the facts and saying "Britain never got any free ride." And why equate America as a wartime British ally with France and Russia? France was occupied or Vichy-controlled early in the war. Russia had signed the Molotov Ribbentrop pact with Germany, which held until '41, and Churchill already saw Stalin as a foe-in-the-making in 1944. Also, don't forget that US was supplying and aiding Britain before Pearl Harbor.
whenever He Blesses us it is so that we may BE a blessing to others. The question the Arab Nations should be asking is: How can we bless others and thus serve our Creator God? I don't believe their Nations surround Israel by accident. I believe they are to be an extension of them, as blessing to the remaining nations. God has said, "HE" will rule from Zion and that ALL the remaining nations will come to celebrate, honor and praise Him [not that He needs our priase, we need to praise-we were made to Worship, to Love Him and be Loved by Him]. Arab Nations are closer than my nation, yet I do not cry and want to be them. I know how very far reaching the Love of God is and I am not affraid of missing any of it. I am grateful just to be a part, any part, of His plan!!! A heart of gratitude will change an attitude!!!
Defense aid to Israel from the US of about 2.4 billion in 2007 is about 8 dollars per US citizen. Most of the tax revenue comes from corporate receipts and the 10% or so of Americans who pay the greatest amount of taxes by far. Total US annual aid to Israel costs less than 1 dollar each for most taxpayers. For you Dovy, that's a burger at Micky D's. All the misinformed pronouncements here to the contrary notwithstanding, financial assistance to Israel is supported for many reasons by the overwhelmingly vast majority of Americans from both parties - Democrats and Republicans. Count me in!
Click, obviously the American government considered why it is giving Israel the aid, for one thing 74% goes back to its own technological sector. The claim that this is just the American/Jewish/Zionist/Fagin/Lobby is more anti-Jewish conspiracy mongering. My gosh, nobody would support Israel if they weren't gullible marks hypnotized by the Shylocks. In your imagination.
Anti-Zionist Christian United States citizen Israel-bashers: don't forget the money comes back to the U.S. technological sector--the taxpayer subsidizes, in essence, both Israel and *itself*.
Treaties are easily broken as are Armistices. German signed in 1918, attacked in 1939. Egypt has loads of pro-Palestinian fundamentalists. Jordan has more Palestinians residing than they have native Jordanians. Hussein had to kill over 10,000 in the late 70's because they rebelled. His son, Abudllah sits on a very shaky throne, hanging on with his teeth. Israel must ALWAYS be fully prepared and cautious.
US military budget this year is over 500 BILLION! Add another 200 BILLION for Afghanistan and Iraq. My poor math skills compute to an extra $2.75 billion for Israel out of the something like $10 TRILLION the USA will spend on the military over next decade. And where does this money go? To what Eisenhower called "the military industrial complex" 73.3% of the money earmarked for Israel will be spent in the USA so it's really a jobs program. So you can sit there and whine or do what I did. When Bush was elected I bought Exxon and United Technologies stocks figuring the neo-con war mongering imbecile would start a war. War profiteer! blood money you say? You got that right, and I'm going to buy a blood red Ferrari with the profits and fill it with Exxon gas made from the Saudi oil we are fighting to protect armed with all those wonderful United Tech weapons paid for with my tax dollars which I owed due to the profits I made on my Exxon and United Tech stock!
First, the reason the Arabs need a nuke is so that Nobody uses one. Everyone is afraid that Israel will rashly use theirs, that's why they want one, remember ... Saddam Hussein only wanted 3 Nukes. Second, this doomsday fight is not what it is going to be like. All the Arabs aren't going to invade. Imagine Hezbollah fighting from the North, Israel moving in, then Israel getting hit from the West, Israel moving in. Israel hitting Syria, Syria launching rockets ... The fight will be one of economic attrition. Each enemy will just fire fairly harmless rockets at Israel until Israel decides to talk peace. In the end, it will be Israel that is confronted with a dilemma. Do they respond with Nukes against katyushas? And if they do, that will end Israel. The alternative is a war that Israel can't win, and they will be forced to the negotiating table, with worse terms than they have now. I think 2012 Israel will be a secular state on all of Israel, or Jewish on a small piece.
I think you're just ducking. Be specific.
The problem, for you, is that most Americans just don't agree with you. The Gallup News Service reported the following on 5 March 2007: "For the nearly 20 years Gallup has been tracking Americans' sympathies in the Palestinian-Arab conflict, more Americans have continually sided with the Israelis. That remains the case today, as a solid majority of Americans (58%) say their sympathy lies with the Israelis and only 20% say their sympathy lies with the Palestinians." Other polling data support this (such as Pew Research). You (Dutch and Muhammud) have every right to disagree with the majority of Americans, but it is not surprising that, in a democracy, Americans, who strongly favor Israel, choose to support it in tangible ways.
Michael, I truly respect your opinion on all these matters. I have listed the website and a breif summary for USAID.GOV, which shows clearly that the giving nature of the American people goes far beyond the UK or Israel. I ask that you keep this in mind during your next opportunity to defend the United States of America. www.usaid.gov/locations USAID is an independent federal government agency that receives overall foreign policy guidance from the Secretary of State. Our Work supports long-term and equitable economic growth and advances U.S. foreign policy objectives by supporting: economic growth, agriculture and trade; global health; and, democracy, conflict prevention and humanitarian assistance. We provide assistance in four regions of the world: Sub-Saharan Africa; Asia and the Near East; Latin America and the Caribbean, and; Europe and Eurasia GOD BLESS YOU MICHAEL Sincerely, The Kid
The Israeli government's addiction to freebies continues. It began with taking Palestinian land that was not paid for. It continues with the taking of Palestinian tax revenue and the acceptance of American taxpayer money for weapons while many Israeli's live below the poverty line. I wonder where all those offensive stereotypes about money come from?
As an American citizen, you have a right to disagree with the foreign policy of this country. At the same time, you have no right to refuse to pay your taxes. Keep this important fact in mind.
To the UK's new treaty signed today with the US? Basically we are sharing all technology to US standard in aircraft and everything. Obviously it is a better deal than the Israeli one for instance. It means we can go to the peeps who build Abrams tanks and ask for the exact same model that is been driven around Baghdad ie the best of the best, and we pay for what we require, we don't need to be given the money to buy the things we require. We ask we get we negotiate a fair price. Isn't that what friends do? Careful though, don't tell Olmert, the US don't sell the equipment to Israel to the same standard as they do the UK. And all those people calling on the US to ditch the UK over the boycott. Given the choice? I know where America's heart lies.
Howdy Don; Israel's military edge would rapidly disappear without her keeping up with the latest technology. The biggest threat to Israel aside from nuke-crazed Iran is these rockets. They are too small and with such short travel times that they can't be shot down with anti-missle systems. There are some viable anti-rocket systems available now like the Phalynx system and there are more being developed. If Israel can acquire or develop a decent anti-rocket system, then the Palestinian militant/terrorist groups and Hezbollah will become impotent except for ground attacks and Israel can handle those. Some good seismic equipment would be nice too in order to detect infiltration tunnels.
Post #194 is by a fake.
STILL KEEPING US ALL AMUSED DORIS
the Will of our Creator based on His Nature. First, He is a Creator, not a destroyer. Second, through what He has created, we can clearly see, He Loves variety! And finally, His Word tells us, He IS Love. And it has served to show us that we have a very long way to grow to be what He has created. We were created as children to grow in His image. I know Islam does not teach that, it is true. We were created for Him to Love and be Loved by Him. He has SHOWN us this in so many ways. As I said before, He has a purpose for ALL He has created. When our purpose matches His purpose for us, we will find ourselves Loving one another and willing to serve and bless according to His Will. So the money is not to "kill" anyone. It is for defense to bring about a change. Our best defense is Love, and they know that, still they find themselves having to defend militarily. It is sad.
saying stuff that doesn't represent the truth. I'm still waiting for you to NAME ONE country that allows enemy aliens to enter during wartime. Shouldn't be so hard to do, it only involves one measly country..Not answering will destroy any credibility you didn't already have. "It seems you`re having great difficulty furnishing the example I had requested. Here`s a reminder of what I`m looking for. It`s really a case of put up or shut up, as they say. "#123 Don Camillo Name: * BEN JABO City: USA State: NO country during wartime allows enemy aliens the right of entry. The U.S. didn`t let German or Japanese citizen into the U.S. during World War 2. Let`s put the onus on you, NAME ONE COUNTRY that will permit enemy aliens to enter it`s territory in a wartime situation. All visitation, no matter what the reason, is banned"
Michael, A lot of the money that we are giving to Israel is probably coming from Saudi. They fear a nuclear Iran a lot more than we do. They would probably give it to Israel themselves if it weren't political suicide. We are the convenient vehicle, but nobody in the middle east want a nuclear Iran. I think the 'Deluded Council of Clerics' pines for a resurgence of the great Persian Empire of millennia past. Peace. Steve
"should Iran do like Saddam Hussein did to Kuwait...Israel would be a protector and first line of defense until our troops got there. All the Jew hatred in your mind will not affect the way the world works." I was actually tyring to understand your strange strategic fantasy, until I got to the ludicrous Jew Hatred bit. I live in a Jewish area and have always had a lot of respect for Jewish culture, partcicularly its emphasis on intelligence. Sadly, you seem to have been left out of that aspect of Jewish culture.
We have a loyal, democratic ally in Israel! Our troops aren't getting killed by IEDs in Jerusalem or Tel Aviv! The technology for that cell phone you use? That's right, developed in Israel. You don't see Israelis strapping on explosive belts! Of all the countries we support, Israel is the one not to bitch about!
G'day Eli! First of all as an American I'm happy to say you're welcome of course. As I posted earlier, I'm pleased to be able to contribute support to our close ally. And I thank you sir, for resisting the urge, now fashionable in much of the world as you pointed out, to bash Americans. I must however respectfully protest your intertwining of the American left and radical Islamism. I can assure you that although I (like most Americans) don't like George Bush, I have ZERO sympathy for radical Islamists, whether they are attacking my hometown, a nightclub in Bali or a pizzeria in Israel. Just because an American is not a "right-winger" does not make them bedfellows with terrorists. I'm a decidedly left-of-center atheist myself, yet I am unabashedly pro-Zionist. One of the nice parts about being a "citizen of the free western world" (as you so eloquently put it) is that I can make my own choices. I choose to oppose Bush, to support Israel, and to loathe terrorists. Shalom :-)
I am sure that there are enough strings tied to this military aid to make it worth our while. It will guarantee that we won't ever have to attack Iran ourselves. Should they ever begin construction on a nuclear weapons facility, it will be destroyed before the nuclear material is moved in but after the centrifuges are. Just set them back every five years or so. Quid pro Quo. We have all known this for years where is the 'news' here? Peace. Steve
Well, most of Africa, could use 2.5 billion dollars a year. As could much of Asia. I was an aid worker in Bosnia during the war. Believe me, there are a lot better ways to spend 2.5 billion dollars than on cluster bombs to spread across South Lebanon. I honestly don't think it's healthy for Israel either. However, diffuclt it is, they need to find a peaceful solution with their neighbours, not just rely on being able to throw free US bombs at anybody any time they like. On the creationism, can't say I understand it. I actually have a lot of respect for Jesus because he said some very wise things. But all that 'world built in 7 days' stuff, that just seems like a creation myth. Every race has them.
The state of israel is wealthy and does not need any more FREE UNITED STATES TAXPAYER MONEY. If israel is going to make war on her neighbors then the cost of the military adventures should be paid in full by the israeli people, not Americans.
Isn't this a shameful use of US tax payers money going to prop up Israel while needy states go without and other needy nations/peo- ple around the world? Bush and US lawmakers will hear from their peace loving constituents on this. This is sinful and Israel is inflamming hearts and minds in the US towards it and threatening US security with reprisals. Plus nothing is going to make Israelis safer while its government continues its reckless and unlawful presence in Palestinian territories. The Palestinian people will not be bullied out of the rights and I sug- gest Israelis and their settlers get that message straight and move their arses off Palestinian land. There is just so much good people will take before they hit back too and this isn't 1948 anymore. Dutch
"But I don`t think our money should be going to Israel upon their greedy demand in order to kill Palestinians." The Jewish people are not out to "kill Palestinians", take land that is not theirs or dominate the world. They, in fact, have removed themselves from the land they truly believe is theirs according to the Word of God, and that they won in battle. This they have done in hope of peace with their brothers. Still they find themselves having to defend themselves against the deceived who believe that they have taken their place in God's eye's and have been given dominion of the world. What was missed along the way is: The Jewish people were chosen to bless the world, not rule it. So if Muslims were to truly take their place in God's eyes, this would be their calling too. Instead, what we are seeing is Farfur, and children taught to hate, rather than bless. Mothers blowing themselves up for a cause that is FAR REMOVED from their God given purpose of motherhood and a relentless
Israel could stand on it's own two feet if she wasn't under attack or threat of attack. The U.S. always has to increase it's military budget because of the same factors. Egypt, Jordan & South Korea combined, receive more than Israel does. Your eyes are green with envy.
First of all the UK got bruised and humiliated by Iran recently with the capturing of British sailors. US aids Israel, Israel protects the Saudis in two ways.....giving the Islamic terrorists and enemy busy so they won't think about toppling the Saud Royal family...another is that should Iran do like Saddam Hussein did to Kuwait...Israel would be a protector and first line of defense until our troops got there. The world needs oil and the terrorists do not. All the Jew hatred in your mind will not affect the way the world works.
I can't speak as to the accuracy of your numbers, but if I'm paying $100/yr to support Israel, my country's only friend in the region, it's not enough. Make my contribution $200 please, and sign it "love and best wishes to Israel from your friend, the USA". (I'm a non-Israeli, non-Jewish, non-supporter of George Bush by the way.) If the killing of Palestinians are your concern, work against Hamas and Fatah, not Israel. I know it's an "inconvenient truth" to some, but one doesn't see any Israelis begging to be let in to Gaza for medical care because representatives of their elected government shot them or threw them off a rooftop.
The point is simple, she's surrounded by enemies and must adhere to the Boy Scout Motto, "BE PREPARED". Each and every war could be her last.
Howdy Don; You show me where it says that a sovereign country is legally obligated to accept foreign refugees in international law. There is nothing of the sort. There is a legal (and moral) obligation to help the sick and wounded (even those of enemy combatants) if possible, but if they are admitted to the country in question for that purpose, then the Principle of Refoulment applies (i.e., the host country cannot forcibly return refugees to their places of origin if it is likely that they would be persecuted there). Each country must make its own decisions on how many refugees that they are willing to accept on humanitarian grounds (but there is no legal obligation to accept any) since the host country will usually be stuck with them forever. International Humanitarian Law does not require a state of war to exist in order to categorize a refugee as an "enemy alien". An armed conflict will do just as well. You're inventing laws which don't exist (the ICRC is good @ doing that to
Michael, I am indeed a Creationist. Would you mind naming a few of the 100 countries that require US Assistance?
Much of the money is spent by Israel in the US to buy military hardware. It is very clear that the money helps the US economy and is good for jobs in the US. That the money is wasted as regards Israel as long as Kadima stays in power helped desperately by Labor, is quite another matter.
"I have to understand Israel is being considered as the 51st state of USA? Well, US governments never gave something for free." - Walt S Walt, you asked about the value of a Bush promise and I answered you. My own opinion is that Israel should try to reduce US aid further, not increase it. It is unbecoming to a state so well off to be a welfare recipient. Of course the US can expect Israeli obedience. But I doubt that this is Bush's purpose. He is a foolish ideologue and the present Israeli government is a soul-mate of his. The US Congress is simply not independent in this matter.
I concur with Cipora's well written response. Yes!we thank the United States and it's population for their loyalty to Israel,and for which the U.S.A benefits largely from our advanced knowledge and where the money was/is allways spent in America. Nothing further to add,bar to say to the jealous ones: SOUR GRAPES WILL GET YOU NOWHERE...
God Bless the USA!
The beggars of the Middle East Olmert scurries over to Washington with his begging bowl. Tells Daddy that there are some people who want to hurt us. Then stuffs his pockets with US taxpayers money. Before scurrying away again for Champagne and strawberries, whilst Americans from New Orleans continue to live in tents. Disgusting.
Hastaroth Best regards to you and all my fellow Israelis and Jews.And thanks to George Bush,for he knows his "onions"so to speak.As Israel is a great asset to the U.S.A.No doubt about it!
Steve, You say "Israel is a powerful country"...true but how powerful would they be without US support. After all Palestine would also be a powerful country with US support. You say "Israel...is filled with gifted individuals"? Are you saying that Israel has more gifted individuals than other countries? Your assumption that Israel will be forever powerful seems flawed when you look at the history of the world....
I cannot understand why we give so much aid to Israel as it is, never mind to increase it. Do the people of the US have any say in this? The US gives more money to Israel than the rest put together...why? Are they in such dire need of aid? Can't a modern democracy stand on its own two feet? What about all the problems at home in the US that need assistance? What about New Orleans? As Hamlet said "Something is rotten in the state"(S).
So, Tosefta, I have to understand Israel is being considered as the 51st state of USA? Well, US governments never gave something for free. It always was, in all cases, for their own purposes. Don't forget, Bush really stands with his back at the wall.
You are helping the only democracy in the Middle East defend itself against fanatic regimes which are set to destroy the Jewish state.
Meet The Carlyle Group! How will President George W. Bush personally make millions (if not billions) from the War on Terror and Iraq? The old fashioned way. He'll inherit http://www.hereinreality.com/carlyle.html
Israel, our friend, is surrounded on all sides by enemies. The same enemies that want to hurt us and the rest of the civilized world. To hear some people balk at a couple of billion a year is beyond petty.
People asky why Israel requires more military aid when Egypt, Jordan, Syria do not consitute serious threats. Conveniently ignored here is Iran, the right wing reactionary theocracy that conveniently develops and builds more and more missiles with longer and longer range, along with nuclear weapons capacity, all while also financing and arming theocrat proxies all over the region. War with Iran by the civilised nations is inevitable, and Iran will of course make Israel target #1, as would-be Holocaust-repeaters have done ever since 1948. So of course the US is aiding Israel further. The best aid to all in the world, however, will come when the US bombs the entire Iranian military apparatus out of existence within a mere day or two.
Israel currently receives $2.4 billion annually in militry aid. This is in addition to the dozens of million dollar loans given to Israel of which most have been forgiven. Since 1973, Israel has cost the United States about $1.6 trillion. If divided by today?s population, that is more than $5,700 for every man, woman and child in Israel, yet Israel is listed as one of the top twenty wealthiest nations. Sure would be nice if our own government could hand every man woman and child in the United States $5,700. Nope, instead we get some bullsh** tax break from Bush amounting to a couple hundred bucks. Someone please explain to me why Israel needs more U.S. foreign aid? P.S. U.S. law prohibits the President from providing military aid to any country that ?engages in a consistent pattern of gross violations of internationally recognised human rights?. Under the 1967 US Arms Export Control Act, it is illegal to use U.S. weapons to carry out extra-judicial killings. This act stipulates th
Get a grip!!! There is no such thing as a "Israel Tax" As and American taxpayer and top 2% earner, I will tell you (since my tax bracket pays (1/3 of the taxes in my country)2.4 billion will barely be a nickel (5 cents American). I think I can spare a nickel for Israel. Just think about what I'm paying for An Arab Tax to countries like Iraq, Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan etc. etc.. need I say more...
we have starving kids throughout the world and the USA is giving money to Israel to buy missiles and bullets. no wonder people dont like the USA.
The discussions I recall most memorably between Israel and US Military involved the sale of top secret US missle guidance technology to the Chinese by the Israelis, followed by sales of similar technology to the N. Koreans. So much for our 'close ally' and their need to access our military capabilities.
Thank you for posting up this text. All it does is increase my puzzlement as to why Israel needs yet more on top of the military high-tech research dividend it already enjoys from the US, given that Israel is not facing a conventional military threat from any of its neighbours.
This is only a small percent of the Israeli Budget and Pennies to America and it comes at a far higher cost. Israel needs the Freedom to spend its money on Israeli Equipment and sell its technology as it sees fit. The best way America can help Israel and help itself, is to stop playing on both sides of this War. The weapons America sells to Arabs will be used against Americans. Israelis give America missile technology, America gives it to Arabs to use against Israel. Of course they will use it against America too. America approves a contract Israel signs with China, then changes its mind years later because America decides that China is a bigger threat all of a sudden and might somehow threaten America. Is China more likely to attack America with Drones or are Arabs more likely to attack Israel with missiles? Seriously, there are fickle winds here and our survival can not hinge on such flaky politics. Israel needs to extract itself from such sticky deals.
"A deal with Bush? The lame duck?" - Walt Schweitzer Walt, a deal with Bush about increased aid to Israel can be taken to the Bank. Such a plan must be approved by the US Congress. However, their approval is guaranteed, given support of Israel by both the Democrats (AIPAC dependents) and Republicans (Evangelical influence). Israel can take the deal to the bank and borrow money against it.
What follows is not a matter of interpretation or opinion and it is your choice as to whether you choose to like it or not. Israel is a member signiatory of the United Nations and the ICRC. It is legally obligated to accept refugees under these statutes as well as the Geneva Protocols which it has also signed (but stupifyingly maintains they don't apply' to Israel). So it must help refugee families. Secondly, under international humanitarian law Israel cannot classify Palestinian refugees as enemy aliens (by the way , when did Israel so decree? Or is this just you?) because Israel is not at war with Palestine - no such state of war exists because as Israel and folk like you point out ad nauseam, there was never any such sovereign State as Palestine. So Israel cannot, under any Protcols, claim that Palestinina refugees are 'enemy aliens'. Happy to provide chapter and verse if you are still not satisfied with my response. But it may be a lot later tonight.
Every Empire through the centuries, have built themselves up to crumble. Every single one. The law of the djungle never worked.
Ben Jabo, no country that continues to occupy another people's lands, that continues to confiscate its fields and resources, that continues to humiliate them and to make life miserable for them can call itself moral. Occupation is IMMORAL. Theft of another people's land and resources is IMMORAL. The destruction of more than 400 Palestinian villages in 1948 was IMMORAL. Not allowing people to return to their lands and homes is IMMORAL whether it is an act by Israel or by any other country. You want morality, Ben Jabo? End the occupation. Pull back to the 1967 line and be the decent country that so many had hoped you would be.
The occupation costs roughly 1 Billion ILS/month. In todays rate , strangely enough $2,9 Billion is 12 Billon ILS. Accounting is a long traditon of those instrumental to the Aid.
how much of their military inventory is top notch? Probably not much owing to budgetary pressures. Much of their military eqpt is to support internal security duties. My point is that Egypt and Jordan have both signed peace agreements and Syria wants to. Times and politicians have moved on since Yom Kippur 73. So why does Israel need more military muscle? Combatting terrorism requires a less expensive and totally different arsenal.
"UK, British assistance to US is payback For the billions of $$ and thousands of American lives spent in keeping Britain from getting invaded in 2 world wars." We are very grateful for the Americans who fought alongside us in World War 2 (and the French, Russians etc.), but America was fighting for its own reasons. Did you and the US really want a world dominated by a Hitler-run Europe? Remember, we fought Hitler for 2 years before Pearl harbour forced America into the war. Also we paid back every last dollar America loaned us. Repayments only finished last year. The UK never got any free rides from the US, even though we are good allies and hopefully will remain so.
Howdy Aero; $2.4 billion plus $50 million increase per year for 10 years = $2.9 billion at the end of the ten years.
Media Note Office of the Spokesman Washington, DC November 3, 2003 U.S.-Israel Joint Political Military Group, U.S.-Israel Agreement of FY 2005 Security Assistance Levels 2003/1112 The 36th meeting of the U.S.-Israel Joint Political Military Group (JPMG) was held in Israel, October 29-30. The meeting was hosted the Director General of the Israeli Ministry of Defense Director General, Amos Yaron. Assistant Secretary of State for Political-Military Affairs Lincoln P. Bloomfield, Jr. led the U.S. delegation. During the 2 days of discussions, the United States and Israel exchanged views on regional security matters and defense cooperation issues. A major event during the JPMG was the Joint Security Assistance Planning presentation, which allowed the United States and Israel to review Israel?s requests for future security assistance. As part of that presentation, the United States and Israel exchanged letters on October 29 confirming the intent of the administration, subject to Congressional approval, to provide Israel $2.22 billion in foreign military assistance in FY 2005. In addition to noting the importance attached to the U.S.-Israel strategic relationship, the letters reaffirmed the administration?s commitment to enhancing Israel's security and maintaining Israel?s qualitative edge over any combination of adversaries. Assistant Secretary Bloomfield reiterated the administration?s support for cooperative U.S.-Israeli programs and its commitment to continuing to seek funding for future U.S. participation in selected joint research and development projects with Israel. The two sides discussed the importance of maintaining effective controls over weapons and defense technology once exported internationally.
If Olmert had really put the squeeze on Bush maybe he could have had that failed "president" pledge the entire US foreign aid budget to Israel. For Israel to receive a only a meager one/third of the entire US foreign aid budget (more than all of Africa together) just isn't right. Israel must have it all. AIPAC should put more pressure on the White House and the Congress and make sure Israel gets ALL the money. Even though Israel has the fourth most powerful military in the world it just isn't fair that they can't be the first. Get the money Olmert!
Howdy Labhras; The last vestage of economic aid to Israel (which isn't very much) terminates on 10/1/07. All U.S. aid to Israel is military aid and it's not exactly a one-sided deal since most of the money must be spent in the U.S. plus technological, security, and intelligence information sharing. The occupation of most of Areas C in the West Bank will end after the conditions for an Israeli withdrawal (as specified in UNSCR 242) have been met. There are no other occupied areas in the Palestinian Territories. The security barriers will stay for quite awhile but they may be moved somewhat depending on where the border winds up being. The treatment of the Palestinian people will improve right after they stop trying to attack Israel. The U.S. will do what it wants to with its money without your advice or permission. You are in no position to be giving other people orders or to be making demands.
The relation between Israel and the US is based on a deep closeness of the two peoples and is independent of current governments. This must be difficult to understand for someone whose country is well known for its hate against the United States. I understand that you are unhappy that the US is such a strong ally of Israel at a time where your country is the closest partner of the mullahs in Tehran, helping them to realize their goal to perpetrate a new Holocaust. US congressman Tom Lantos wanted to call your last chancellor a political prostitute for the big cheques he gets from Putin and Arab countries. He said that he refrained from doing so, because he would not like to offend the whores in his electoral district.
High international finance where the profit is in the relationships and the politics isnt for you.
If you increase $50M per yr, for 10 yrs, the total becomes $500M, and when added to the initial $2.4B, it is $2.9B. Seems you lack basic skills in both math AND reading comprehension. Perhaps it is you that needs an editor....
Glad you are not my Financial advisor. Hint. I give you $20,000,00 and you order a car from me . I purchase all the material and do all the work and pay for it.Cost to me $16,809,00. I then give you the car and you return my $20,000,00. Question' How much profit did I make. Rgards
The US aid baseline for Israel was $3 billion each year. Netanyahu suggested gradually eliminating the economic aid part and increasing more slowly the military part. This year the goal has been reached: The economic aid is zero and the military aid is $2.4 billion. With the new Olmert plan, the aid will go up to 2.9 billion over 10 years. I say, let's not fool around and go all the way up to 3 billion. The US showed it was willing to carry such burden, so why not let them do it? Why not? Bush is thinking of the world in strange military terms. The Cold War is over, and yet, under Bush the US is developing new advanced weapon systems such as advanced airplanes, and all for enemies that use roadside bomb and suicide bombers. US military budget almost doubled under Bush. Some items have justification, such as better armored humvees and anti-RPG defense. But these are small items compared to what the old dead enemy required. Israel is not in a very different situation. We need fewer planes and tanks and better anti rocket systems. (The Arrow anti missile system was a special project, I believe its funding was over and above the usual US Base support.) P.S. According to Israeli civilian analysts, the IDF carries a lot of fat in the form of misdirected moneys, and its budget should be reduced greatly. Fatman was just saved from its unpleasant diet.
Rather than bleat about the amount, consider what the money will buy... bulldozers to wreck homes and farms, concrete to build more separation walls, fletchette bombs for schoolyards, small arms for settlers' 'peace of mind', rubber hoses for 'prisoner dialogue', bullets for 'post birth population control', aerial bombs for 'crowd control', and a myriad of other pleantries that Israel has provided to all of their neighbors for decades.
Ephraim! What you don't seem to understand is that this is not economic aid. The US and Israel has sponsored joint military projects for year. The drones that the US uses is Israeli technology. These are joint military ventures between the US and Israel. Israel has a booming economy thank you!!
A deal with Bush? The lame duck?
It is extremely generous and signs of friendship that the US increases its aid to the one democracy in the Middle East, North Africa and Persian Gulf. But I hope it was not "payment" to keep Israel out of Gaza where it should go to create a buffer zone to protect the people in Sderot! Nor for Israel to make too far rwching deals with Palestinians that endanger security
If you read the article again, you will find it is $50 million per anumn for ten years. Do the numbers---again. Regards to Einstein
For the billions of $$ and thousands of American lives spent in keeping Britain from getting invaded in 2 world wars. Not to mention post-war reconstruction and Cold War costs. What America has done for Britain is unprecedented. At least, Israel can say no foreign troops fought on its behalf in wartime. Not so much of a "pampered, indulged son" after all.
US and Taiwan - allies forever. US and the Shah of Iran - allies forever US and South Vietnam - allies forever
$2.4 billion plus $50 million does NOT equal $2.9 billion. Check your elementary school math. You guys ever heard of an editor? Surprising how many errors like this I catch reading this site.
You might as very well informed person who know how to search google, search for Obama Israel and lets see what you would get.
Most Americans tax bill was under one dollar for Israel and only the top 1% paid more than one half of the whole US tax load. It always seems that the people who bitch the most about our tax dollars usually don't pay a penny or very little....If they had a job they could earn their "dollar or two" very quickly.
So much for the great sucess story, Israel has to get, "Economic Aid".What a sham it all is. End the occupation, Tear down that Wall and end the brutal treatment of the Palestinian People. Do unto others as you have them do unto you.Then the US can do as it wishes with it,s Money. Regards Regards
First, I'll remind you about a statement you had made and haven't backed up with any facts. Based on this, any and all so-called facts you put forth are subject to extreme suspicion. I'll post a reminder (for the second time) at the end of this session. Israel, in conjunction with American does R&D of defense items that are of mutual advantage to both countries. Drones, anti-missile systems, missile systems and electronics components for aircraft are a part of the agreement. Now, we can get down to brass tacks. The following is being posted for the second time, It's high time you responded before going on to other matters. "Camillo - still awaiting your response Name: * BEN JABO City: USA State: It seems you`re having great difficulty furnishing the example I had requested. Here`s a remindder of what I`m looking for. It`s really a case of put up or shut up, as they say. "#123 Don Camillo Name: * BEN JABO City: USA State: NO country during wartime allows enemy aliens the right of entry. The U.S. didn`t let German or Japanese citizen into the U.S. during World War 2. Let`s put the onus on you, NAME ONE COUNTRY that will permit enemy aliens to enter it`s territory in a wartime situation. All visitation, no matter what the reason, is banned"
Is this a good idea for the US? Is this a good idea for Israel? Is this a good idea for peace? I don't know. We have a lame duck in Bush who seems to haves motives within motives. Olmert sems close to lame duckism, but like the energizer bunny, keeps on going. Both govern by press conference. This year and next will take care of themselves. It might be better to wait on anything long term until there is leadership in place in both countries that can see beyond the next press conference.
That is an easy one. Egypt needs military harware in the amounts it has to counter the threat of a rogue nuclear state which refuses to abide by the Nuclear non proliferation act. If I had a nuclear armed Israel on my doorstep I woul be screaming for arms from anybody who woul sell me them. As it is any threat from Israel is countered by the UK having a nuclear deterrent. A nuclear deterrent which is used to protect Australia by the way.
Curious, silvienne. How did you come to determine the status of "Israel's occupation of Palestine" illegal? I really would love to hear the response/ rationale for this.
without US aid. The idea that Israel is a succesful western democracy able to stand on it's own two feet is an illusion. Israel is a dependency of the United States just as Costa Rica is.
You may wish to read Edward Litwack, in terms of Nasser and his armies. True the Gypos ran way , but that was a very small number. They gave a fair account of themselves. As for arab states with modern equipment, they will need a reason for using it. Fighting and dying to get rid of ISrael is a passe reason. ISrael has no oil to speak off, so ther is no economic benefit. Occupying her will only cause more enemy casualties (remember Poland). The so called rich Arab states stand to lose much much more if ISrael were to hit back. Saudi oil fields could be renedered useless by radiation for 500 years with one nuclear strike, same for Kuwait. Iran really has little to offer the world but oil, and that too can be taken out easily and also rendered unuseable for 500 years. Read the US studies on what happens if a nuke goes off on the oil fields. Arab states dont buy into this pan arabism, and they wont risk their future because some nutbar in Iran wants to kill a few jews.
"I agree that the UK is a great ally to the States. In my opinion that has never been in question. I do however; take issue that all you do for us (USA) can be traced to your philanthropic nature" You're mistaking free for philanthropic. We help the US because the US helped us in the past and will probably help us again. The question is, how has Israel ever helped the US? "I know that Mr. Darwin has influenced your society over the last few, "very brief years", but let`s not forget there are more enduring reasons for the support of the American People to our friends and brothers in Israel." What? Why support Israel to the exclusion of 100 other countries around the world that need US help? And what's Darwin got to do with it? Great scientist mind you. You're not a Creationist are you?
VERY sinplr answer. isreal is surroundedby countries that want to destroy her and her people. Isreal MUST , at all times "stay ahead of the game" in terms of state of the art weapons. Why? because her neighbors are being armed with better and better weaponry, Isreal has to have a formadable array of weapons to make anyone think twice about attacking her. While Isreal has a strong economy it still is a small nation having to fight off forces 20 times her size. It is also in the western countries that Isreal remains strong.
Why does Egypt need so much military hardware?
#44: The way I was brought up, if you live below sea level in a hurricane prone area, you buy top notch insurance. If the government rebuilds New Orleans, it's sending out a message: "JoJo don't need no insurance, cause Uncle Sam got JoJo covered." And what about people that wrecked their trailers, and the government isn't pursing? Sorry, but New Orleans was a bad example on your part. That said, as I wrote earlier, it was foolish of Olmert to compromise Israeli sovereignty for some peanuts.
With America's debt where it is; this will anger the American people. The U.S. is the only real ally. Israel should not take aid knowing their economy is being stretched. "LEND LEASE" might be a better approach!
Michael you wrote, "The UK, as an ally of the US, helps promote US interests in Europe and the world, helps it fight wars etc. etc. and all for free". I agree that the UK is a great ally to the States. In my opinion that has never been in question. I do however; take issue that all you do for us (USA) can be traced to your philanthropic nature. I know that Mr. Darwin has influenced your society over the last few, "very brief years", but let's not forget there are more enduring reasons for the support of the American People to our friends and brothers in Israel.
You wrote: "Have you heard any of them (presidential candidates) mentioning what happened to Katrina victims, I don't think so...." A brief (about two-minute) Google search revealed that Obama has issued more than one press release concerning Katrina and its victims. And that's just two minutes and one candidate searched. If you haven't heard any mention of this among presidential candidates, perhaps you are not as well as informed as you should be as a citizen of a democracy.
You wrote: "Have you heard any of them (presidential candidates) mentioning what happened to Katrina victims, I don't think so...." A brief (about two-minute) Google search revealed that Obama has issued more than one press release concerning Katrina and its victims. And that's just two minutes and one candidate searched. If you haven't heard any mention of this among presidential candidates, perhaps you are not as well as informed as you should be as a citizen of a democracy.
Notwithstanding your loving relationship with everything Iranian. The reality is that their economy is poor and the middle class suffers and though that holds weight in China, these people can topple the little madman at any time. He can be removed as easily as dew evaporates on the first day of summer.
You nicely avoid the mention of the aid given to Europe and the rest of the world by the USA. Yes the USA was isolationist at the beginning of the war and Britain fought heroically but I do not remember that being the issue.It was aid! It was aid that allowed Britain to continue to fight heroically. We were talking about US aid given to countries all around the world not just the ones you love to hate.
You asked, "Which other country is threatening Israel so bad thatit needs this amount of money to maintain a qualitative edge? Egypt? Jordan? Lebanon? Syria?" Your answer, "Yes, as well as, all of the Terrorist operating as states within states, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Iraq, etc....."
At some point, we might have to ask the Israelis to lobby for us to get back on our feet. We vote for our politicaians and our politicians main concern is the state of Israel more any state in the states. Look at our presidential candidates even Mr. Obama. Have you heard any of them mentioning what happened to Katrina victims, I don't think so, but all of them already paid their visits to Israel and all of them mentioned so many times that how much support they have for Israel.
which goes back into their economy,then let them stop,but for crying out loud cut this scapegoat crap,it gets nobody anywhere.
Sussex program. Lets use your source Combat aircraft Israel 570 Iran 210,Egypt 680,Syria 600,Saudi 350. Combat vehicles Israel 10500 Iran 3500,Egypt 7400,Syria 8500,Saudi5700 Add together the forces and weapons of just Iran,Syria,Saudi Arabia,Egypt their weapons and men that can be mobilised. Countries like Iran Egypt and Syria have compulsory military service their populations far exceeds that of Israel. CIA Factbook on Iran says men available for (compulsory) military duty ismales age 18-49: 15,665,725 females age 18-49: 15,005,597 there are female trained martyrs. The money spent on weapons by Egypt and Saudi Arabia alone is not always in the public domain Saudis it was recently revealed tried to do a secret defence deal in Britain for 20 billion pounds. Thats what I am talking about.
Actually, American support for Egypt, at least, is premised on its being a moderate state in the Middle East and on its potential to be a democracy, at least at some point in the future. It is unfortunately the case, though, that Mubarak has quashed free political activity in Egypt aimed at democracy for over two decades, despite "American pressure" on him for democratic reform(New Republic, 2/17/05). So your perspective, when you say we get what we pay for with Egypt, would seem to be, once again, one-sided and prejudiced.
The bottom line, according to the non-partisan Pew Research Center, in a publication dated 30 May 2007, is that for "40 years, public opinion (in the U.S.) has consistently favored Israel over Palestinians," and that "has persisted through every war in the region." That is why American support for Israel is strong, whether you would like that fact or not. Your posts don't reflect the views of most Americans, as polling data clearly show, and that fact clearly upsets you, but the American people have spoken clearly, as the Pew research data show.
"Talk about biting the hand that fed you.Without the US you would either have become a colony of Nazi Germany or the workers paradise that was the Soviet Union." I would remind you - yet again, Peter - that the world owes Britain a vast debt of gratitude for standing firm against Hitler in 1940, when common sense suggested we should have reached an "accommodation" with the Nazis. Our solitary stand (when America was keeping nicely out of the "European War", thank you very much) required Hitler to delay his plans for an attack on the Soviet Union and attempt the conquest of Britain. He failed, and the delay in the attack on the Eastern Front cost him the war, on the outskirts of Moscow. Had Britain not made its solitary stand I suspect the world, including America, would now be speaking German and you, Peter - a Jew - would not be here to post on Talkback from Melbourne. No need to thank Britain for its courage, Peter.
I am glad that you mentioned Egypt and Jordan. Implicit in the aid that America gives those countries is that they maintain peace with Israel. I agree that those payments are excessive, but at least America got what they paid for. In the case of Israel, Bush has asked that west bank expansion be curtailed and that a 2 state solution be pursued. In this case, America has definitely NOT gotten what was paid for because west bank expansion continues to increase. One gets numbed to the idea that government wastes 90% of the taxpayers money, but it is especially galling when a thumbing of the nose is all one gets in return for the dollars.
Ben, actually Israel is the only nation on earth that the US does NOT insist that 100% of the money is spent in the US. 23.6% can be spent within Israel on Israeli defence contracts, and the US requires (again uniquely) that Israel does not have to account for a single cent of this cash transfer (cash). This article is about the military aid package of some 14 million shekels a day in cash, so not sure where your point on humanitarian aid comes from. I have the US Congress report source if you don't believe me - see earlier post from me on this subject.
are there?Syria just had their "elections" they are not exactly part of the US protectorate,nor is Iran. Was the USA popular during the cold war when it sided with the Arabs against Israel,till the 1970's? The Arabs happily played one side against the other,some were part of what was laughingly called "non aligned" nations,like for example Cuba.They talked the same socialist revolutionary,anti-West,jargona and happily opressed their people.Israel was a great uniting cause and excuse for dictatorship. Why not admit the standard M.E. totalitarian rule is the very antithesis of Western democracy.? It may hurt to hear something bad about third world despots,"intellectuals" must never deviate from THE cause.My fraternal commisserations.
I wonder if Olmert said "OK Dubbya, you want me to be seen to be giving the nebbbisch Abbas and his cronies a place at the roulette table? Fine - one one condition - renew the Netenyahu jackpot for a further 10 years. Or no deal!" Far from being victimised and picked on, Israel is unique in gettng its money in cash aid: ?Among the real benefits to Israel that are not direct costs to the U.S. taxpayer are the cash transfer of economic and military aid, in-country purchases of a portion of military aid, and loan guarantees. The U.S. gives Israel all of its economic and military aid directly in cash, with no accounting required of how the funds are used. Furthermore, Israel can spend 26.3 percent of the military aid in Israel, clearly a subsidy to the Israeli defense industry at the expense of American defense contractors.
3% Isrealis fooling 97% americans, stealing their money in the form of aid. blind americans. WAKE UP
No Arab State possesses nuclear weapons - Israel would never allow it. I have no idea what you base your emotive statements on but certainly not fact. What is your source for 'endless billions' being spent by 'the other side'? The neighbours that have peace treaties with Israel? I think not. For facts on who has how many guns, see: http://www.strategypage.com/fyeo/howtomakewar/databases/armies/m.asp
To combat terrorism requires efficient and effective overseas and internal intelligence services that are well-funded, rather than an even bigger conventional and nuclear arsenal, both the latter of which Israel has already. Militarily Israel is vastly superior to all of its neighbour's armies, most of whom have signed peace treaties with Israel, so my original question as to what or who Israel needs a military arsenal qualitative edge over, you have avoided directly answering. Terrorism (Hamas, Hizballah) is fought by mustarabi units not conventional forces.
can you see the surprised look on my face ?
You've neglected to mention a paystub classification for Egypt/Jordan Tax. Combined, they receive as much aid as Israel, under the very same conditions. You wouldn't make a good paymaster, you overlook too many things.
When Al Qaida decides to take over Turkey and install Shariya Law....who do you think will come to your aid??? Only the US, backed up by Israel will rescue you. Wisen up man!
As an American, I support Israel, as do the great majority of Americans I have met, from many backgrounds, social strata, and occupations, in this country (and I have lived in four different states for more than several years in each state).
As an American, I support Israel, and the great majority of Americans, covering a wide range of different backgrounds, occupations, and social strata, whom I have met in this country (and I've lived in four states) do also.
No need to feel sorry for us. As an American, I support Israel, and, in my experience, support for Israel is very strong here in the Midwest of the United States.
It may be that US taxpayers want to pay 100 dollars each a year to prop up Israel. If so, that's their right. (Though I can't help feeling that if there was ever a big public debate on the subject in America, many Americans might prefer to spend the money on themselves.) I'm just surprised at anybody arguing that spending money on Israel is in America's own interests. Like I say, it's easy to see all the problems the Israeli alliance brings the US. It's really hard to see the advantages. Israel may help prop up US Arab client rulers, but if it wasn't so unpopular because of Israel, the US wouldn't have to rely on undemocratic rulers in the Middle East.
And, Israel will continue to be under the heel of the United States, doing its bidding - or else.
Your reflections on the United States and on the relation between Israel and the United States are thoughtful and heartfelt. Beautifully stated. As an American, I found myself moved by your post.
Weapons AID in keeping Israel alive. Otherwise, Arabs would have conquered her years ago.
Just as an example Israel helped maintain the status quo when Jordan was threatened by Syria. Joint projects go on between Jordan Israel and Egypt and have been reported right here in Haaretz. I hate to say this but if you believe the public utterances of the ME leaders match their private allegiances or actions than you are thinking like a European and sadly mistaken. Arafat I understand,with a good degree of confidence,was roundly despised by many ME leaders.The public kissing was for the public.
American paycheck stubs show what money was deducted from the check by the government. There is federal withholding tax, state withholding tax, medicare tax, social security tax, and sometimes some others as well. The American taxpayer has been paying so much for so long to the state of Israel, that I think it deserves a seperate deduction box on the check stub. I would love to hear people asking .. "hey, what is Isdef tax?" .. . .
these are bad news indeed
Qualitative edge over those who keep on attacking and threaten further attacks. The 1948 War and the subsequent wars inflicted upon Israel, proves that Israel must be prepared. Which country threatens, it's any and all of them. Last rockets were fired from Lebanon, or have you forgotten? Rockets are being fired daily from Gaza. U.S. Dollars are for humanitarian purposes, creates jobs in the U.S., since the funds MUST be spent there. The humanitarian purpose that's for Israel's benefit, it helps to keep Israeli's alive, allowing them to defend themselves. Since Israel exists in a region where Palestinian brothers are killing each other daily, flinging their enemies from rooftops, blindly firing into passageways containing refugees attempting to flee, launching rocket attacks into Israel, it's to Israel's benefit to do her utmost to obtain as much money as she can for defensive purposes.
Nasser was NOT posturing, he had 100,000 troops sitting on Israelis borders, 40,000 MORE than he had in Yemen. He had been threatening war for months. Arabs may fire rockets, Israel has more than adequate firepower. Don't forget all involved are targets in limited areas. It isn't how much equipment that either side has, it requires guts to carry it off. Don't be overly concerned with Pakistan, India will be involved and will neutralize them. They're just sitting and waiting for an unfriendly act, their mutual animosity has had them engage in warlike situations since their independence in 1947. Just keep one thing in mind, Israel has had a reactor for many years, atomic weaponry is a virtual certainty. Arabs are still looking to attain nuke status. A single Israeli rocket will pack a lot more punch than a slew of Arab rockets.
... there's always a temptation to underestimate the possibilities of peace, when there's too much military muscles. Too much military might makes one blind for wisdom and true religion. This is, what happens to US and Israel now. This is, what happened to proud little Germany in the past. Where does this militarism come from? The answer is: Fear and spiritual blindness. But warplanes and propaganda alone can't bring peace, and with this approach Israel will continue to be a threatened and threatening alien element in a more and more dangerous Middle East. It is never too late to change the course and try something, that is based on truth and courage.
Israel defended itself against an attack that emanated from Lebanon, it was war. During war, each side exerts it's utmost to do the most destruction. Lebanon fired 4000+ rockets at Israeli targets. Money Israel receives helps maintain high levels of employment in the U.S., since it's all spent, (by Law) to purchase U.S. manufactured supplies. If you're really that concerned by foreign aid, you really should look into the amounts that Egypt & Jordan receive, it virtually identical to Israel and for the very same purposes.
"The United States has been Israel`s most steadfast friend and ally for decades. This alliance is based on mutual security needs" It's clear what Israel gets out of all this. What does the US? It might get a bit of inteligence, probably weighted to reflect Israel's interests but what else? The UK, as an ally of the US, helps promote US interests in Europe and the world, helps it fight wars etc. etc. and all for free. What does Israel do for its money, apart from guarantee the US will never be popular with Muslims? Evem if it wanted to, Israel can't be involved in US Middle East projects, because then none of the locals would touch the project. Israel doesn't seem like a normal US ally, it seems more of a pampered and indulged son.
Once again: it is all about Israel's survival! What's wrong with that?
I'll wager that the asteroids will hit earth long before you gather the courage to undertake your Human Shield mission. As for what will be 5-10 years from now, I can safely say you'll still be hiding in Australia... "Who can say what will be 5-10 years from now?"
Let's put the shoe on your foot. Name just ONE ARAB COUNTRY that is more moral than Israel, just one. I won't hold my breath waiting, since you won't be able to come up with ANY.
how long the conflict has been going on, and had to be corrected for making erroneous statement, you sure have a lot to say. Most of it being nonsense. First, get it out of your noggin that the Occupation is Illegal. It's quite just & correct. Necessitated as a defensive measure, caused by repeated attacks against the State of Israel, commencing and prior to 1948. I've given you the sources and links, it's quite evident, you'd rather rant on endlessly and ignore hard cold facts. Nowdays, all you have to do is look at the news and absorb some of what you read and see. Palestinians are fleeing each other in Gaza, executing one another in the streets, flinging their brothers from high rise buildings, etc. Yup, real examples of brotherly love and of your ignorance of what is actually going on.
most of the tax money of US citizen is being wasted in providing aid to Isreal for no good reason but to wage a unwanted war against its neighbours and killing innocent people. American people "Dont you think you guys are paying tax for killing innocent people"
This once, I agree fully with Clickfool,...for the rest...
US reached its goal of creating a civil war in Iraq because what US (and Israel) needs is instability in all middle eastern countries including Turkey. US, Israel (and EU for that matter) support the pkk terrorist organization and this serves 2 purposes (instabilize Turkey and fragmenting Iraq). US one day will pay for all this very but very badly. For now everything is good for them and Israel but it won't continue that way.
The United States has been Israel's most steadfast friend and ally for decades. This alliance is based on mutual security needs, but it could not have been possible without the genuine friendship of the American people. The people of America, who have saved the world twice from destruction, and who have been a beacon of democracy for so long, have shown on many occasions that their generous spirit will extend to those who are most in need of friends.
What good is 2.3 Billion Dollars or even 100 billion dollars, if the people that live in Israel do not have enough money to live on for basic necessities. This is like Israel's answer to demographics, i.e., build big buildings. But what good will big buildings be if no one can afford to live in it.
Israel is outgunned many times over in all services and the Arabs have WMD's. Look at the endless billions spent by the other side on offensive weapons. Look at what they say in their OFFICIAL media about Israel and Jews. Thats what!
Why not use this money to buy off the claim of return from the Palestinian refugees? Give them money for their lost property. Make a deal with the countries around Israel of financial aid in return for full citizenship. Wouldn't that be more useful, then buying cluster bombs? off course, it would mean a recognition from Israel and the US for the Palestinian claim in the first place. And that requires some courage.
THE CLAIM TO THE LAND IS 1919/20 SAN REMO CONFREWNCE 1922 MANDATE THE BIBLE OR GOD IS NOT MENTIONED
Which is why you have the confience to make Aliya and go and live in Israel. Rather than pontificate from Canada a minimum of 3500 miles from the country you so profess to love and support. Also living in Canada you avoid, unlike Americans, the need to have to pay taxes to fund this. But why let small matters like that get in the way?
Now you have to put up with rude zionists and polite people like Marylin,Johnboy,Hannah,VIPER etc.etc.who as we have all seen would NEVER utter a naughty word.
HOW DO YOU LIKE YOUR EGGS COOKED ??
until israel has proven that its ways... have and will forver be changed any additional military aid is wrought with shame!
To Mr. Camillo, Maybe you have been living on the moon for the past couple of years. Have you ever heard of the name Iran?? Or maybe Hizballah, or even Hamas? But, no, of course, you are right, Israel can lay back and has nothing to worry about! WAKE UP!
The Aborigines will reclaim Australia in 5-10 years from now. Just start packing.....
As a non-American, I'm interested. Does the average American know how much the US pays Israel each year? What do they think America gets in return for its money? Whatever you think of the rights and wrongs of the Israel/Palestine issue, Israel seems much more of a stragetic problem for the US than an asset. It is a permanent barrier to warm relations between the US and any Arab country, and it can't act on the US's behalf in the Middle East because none of its neighbours will tocuh it. For instance, it can't help openly with US efforts in Iraq or Afghanistan, because it would upset the locals so much. I'm sure a bit of intelligence is passed from Israel to the US, but even that I would bet is weighted to serve Israel's interests, and portray the Middle East to the Americans how the Israelis want them to see it.
You wrote to GILI that he is the one living in lala land??? Do you realise NO COUNTRY will give ANYTHING away IF IT WAS NOT IN THEIR interest to do so??? USA gives aid to Israel (NOT ONLY ISRAEL for that matter !!!) not BECAUSE they SUPPORT ISRAEL from the bottom of their hearts BUT BECAUSE it is IN THE BEST interest of the USA to do this.... Remember STRONG ISRAEL = STRONG AMERICA... otherwise IT WILL NOT MAKE sense that EVERY US PRESIDENT have STRONG SUPPORT for ISRAEL at all times (since 1967 !!!)
According to you,which is the most moral country in the Middle East?
Practically this means that Israel can easily hold on to occupying Palestinian territory for another 10 years. During these years there is no need to make any concession, murdering innocent people by the IDF is approved beforehand and Palestinian misery can continue, since they are powerless anyway.
Most of it goes right back into US industry. It's a much-needed boost to the America economy, turning the money over. It's used to buy the means of defense for five million people threatened by 350 million: fair? Unfair?
"These idiots really think the fight is going to last 10 more years?" If only the fight would last only another 10 years...
The US gives aid to many countries around the world to day but you cannot help yourself you have to have your little dig. Talk about biting the hand that fed you.Without the US you would either have become a colony of Nazi Germany or the workers paradise that was the Soviet Union.
Yes, Israel as a US Dependency as you said. In fact, Israel will be in future known as America's number one client state...
.....nice bit of Dylan you quoted there! But I don't think our money should be going to Israel upon their greedy demand in order to kill Palestinians.
The American people are not all supporting the Israel war tax by any means whatsoever. I didn't know about the US ship "Liberty" bombed and the crew killed by the IDF. When did this happen? And I wonder if anyone told Bush? (As he can't read he couldn't have read about it for himself...)
Nice call David. I'm sure the average American can spare 4 days of fast food expenses for a country that shares some of the load in securing the oil supply chain. After all, we all know that's what this is all about. And, as I wrote before, Olmert should have suggested a reduction of aid while at the same time suggesting that the US keep a BIG warehouse of weapons here, to be used only in true emergencies.
Don't be so arrogant. It's still too much to give. How much is Italy's contribution, or is Italy smarter than we are?
you're right, who can tell?
Israel faces a future of terrible uncertainty and danger, it has no-one to blame but itself and its arrogance". How true that is. And even now, late in the day as it is, Israelis will still not admit to any wrongdoing whatever in what's left of Gaza and the West Bank. But Israel most probably thinks that with American money it can exist forever. And if Iran attacks, it can drag America into the war. Let's hope the idiot Bush has long since gone when that happens.
There are legislators who do try to stop the billions of dollars Bush sends to Israel. But the problem is, as Clickfool said, the Jewish American lobby is all-powerful here. It does not represent the views of many Americans.
Israel is currently posting nice budget surpluses. Olmert should have suggested a gradual decrease in military aid. That way he gets much more sovereignty. But, oh no, Olmert the Despicable always chooses the easy way out. He never makes the tough calls. Soon he'll ponder over all these things from his retirement home.
"This deal is a tribute to the assiduous work of the American Jewish lobby" And to the stupidity and shortsightedness of Bush.
Great post John. Couldn't have said it better myself.
"Israel's concessions in terms of land and sovereignty have only brought it misery..." You're looking in the wrong direction, John. The misery is all on the Palestinian side...just look at the West Bank - that's if you can see it with all the Israeli settlements in the way.
Bernie, in your scenario, are you joking? During any attack by its neighbours, Israel will hide behind America, just as it always does. Why do you think Israel is trying so desperately to push America into war with Iran?
Your post concerning the great success story that Israel is - the Intel chip, the tech innovations, the thriving economy - left me somewhat puzzled. If all this is true, why does Israel need American money so much that it actually asked Bush for 50 million more a year??
US$2.4 billion aid a year - gosh - that is as much as whole of sub-Saharan Africa, south Asia and central America get in aid a year from the USA. Just shows that the war on the democratically elected Arab parties (like Hamas, Hizbuallah) can only happen due to this US aid.
"Israel will be a failed state within ten years" What, with all the money Bush hands over? I doubt Israel will disappear as long as it can exist on our tax dollars.
I think you and many others over estimate the strengh of the American Jewish community,if they were that powerfull,America would have attacked Iran long ago.
something is wrong. We always talk about what is happenning. All news sites are same. WE ALWAYS TALK SAME THINGS. NOTHING NEW TO SAY, NOTHING NEW TO START. why ? Love, Atilla
He probably tried, but Bush might be scared to return to Washington if he flung away any more of our money on a cause which many Americans do not support. I only hope the Palestinians understand that there's a lot of Americans who would rather give the money to them.
...about American taxpayers being "charged" to support Israel. But is there really such a tax? If so, why on earth do we have to be the ones doing this, when so many of our own people are in need? This is disgraceful. Even more disgraceful is that the deaths of so many Palestinians have been brought about with our money that Bush so grandly gives away.
Oh well, some say asteroids wiped out the dinosaurs. Who can say what will be 5-10 years from now?
You are the one living in lala land, not the Talkback posters, if you really believe that Israel is the most moral country in the middle east! Israel has "got out just fine" from previous critical situations with an enormous amount of help from America. And now Israel is going to get even more of our money, while New Orleans remains in ruins. By all means, let Israel be "here to stay", as you said. But could it possibly do it on less of America's money?
Yes, we always like to see our tax dollars going to a worthy cause. A ten year increase in military aid to Israel - as agreed to by the unspeakable Bush - will certainly buy a lot of dead Palestinians for Israel. And Israel had the nerve to ask for 50 million! Well, why stop there? Why not force every citizen to contribute to the illegal Israeli occupation of Palestinian land? Bush is just idiot enough to fall for it.
I think your arithmatic is wrong.At $100,00 per American citizen,that would be 30 billion dollars.I think you should go back to school and learn a little about arithmatics.
It's a "failed state" that without the subsidies of the US would have long since evaporated. And without the 60 years of inflamatory abrasion of the "natives" i.e. Palastinians there woud have been no Qaida, no 9-11, and no war in Iraq... Hopefully the American people will get a life beyond Ms. Hilton, O.J., lost puppies and the rest of what passes for "news" there and stop supporting Israel through the "Israel War Tax". For all the US support one got the bombing of King David hotel by the original "founding" Zionist terrorists, and US ship LIBERTY torpedoed/bombed and crews machine gunned in their life boats by the Israeli "IDF" and..., and... oy geweh!
If they were not such violent racists the ME could have been an oasis of peace and development. They chose war and pogroms from the 1800's (when they were not killing each other).
This is a despicable deal cementing Israel as a US Dependency which will live in infamy if it is passed. It will mark the beginning of the end of Israel as a sovereign nation. Olmert will go down in history as the next Queen Liliukolani, the last sovereign of Hawaii. Israel is on its way to becoming the next Puerto Rico or Marshall Islands. Maybe in 100 years it will become a state, with Caesaria as state capital.
Complaining about military aid to Israel? In the past about 80% of this money is spent on the US military industry and therefore is injected back into the US economy. So what's all this whining about this money going out of the US? These grants support the US industry, so enough with the pointless conjecture. On top of this, joint Israel-US ventures in a wide variety of industries inject further funds back into the US economy. So this argument that US citizens pay 'Israel taxes' amounts to nothing.
many of us are shopping there as well, to further boost their economy. Isn't technology grand :) And then of course there are the American Jews, Messanic congregations and Evangelicals gathering their portion for the storehouses of Zion... Oh, the times they are a changin... Come senators, congressmen Please heed the call Don't stand in the doorway Don't block up the hall For he that gets hurt Will be he who has stalled There's a battle outside And it is ragin'. It'll soon shake your windows And rattle your walls For the times they are a-changin'. Bob Dylan - 1964
NEtanyahu created the precedent for Israel to phase out its dependence on American handouts, and Olmert went against that, in the true spirit of the 'spoiled child'. He is harming the Israeli military industry, harming the Israeli relationship with America,and harming Israel. It is time for this infant to go back to his cot, and the next Israeli leader to pro-actively repudiate handouts..
"If Israel is not prepared to perpetually subjugate the region, it will have to make a just peace. Neither of these of course are possible and Israel will be a failed state within 10 years." You're right, Jerry. There's an ephemeral feel to the State of Israel. It is now too late to make peace with its neighbours, and Israel is too set in its ways anyway. Enormous changes are taking place in the balance of power in the Middle East. The giant that is Iran is rising. When it has acquired its nuclear deterrent, what price that stock of illicit nuclear warheads Israel has squirreled away? The forces of Islamic extremism are growing throughout the region. In ten years time the geopolitical map of the Middle East will look totally different. Israel faces a future of terrible uncertainty and danger. It has no-one to blame but itself and its arrogance. It should have settled with its perceived enemies six years ago, when its regional power was at its peak.
But only slightly. All the Arab countries are enemies of Israel and their oil income alone makes Israel's defence budget look by a nano-peso. On top of all this, Arab's have a huge population advantage. Hence, this only goes a tiny way to evening the playing field. Israel puts more intellectual property into the coffers of the world, and the U.S. in particular, then all of the Arab countries put together, much more. In pure investment terms, Israeli companies are being taken over by U.S. companies regularly and add to the wealth. The so called Israeli tax is a much more complex calculation. How about the savings of $ and lives brought about by Israeli military experience and intelligence that is being passed on to the U.S. Israel will not fail because it can't. If it does, yes much of the middle east and a lot of the world will go with it.
"you know the ones the West backs" We do indeed. Repressive military dictatorships (Pakistan and Egypt). Sleazy medieval kingdoms (Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, the Gulf States). Repressive Apartheid states (Israel) Puppets (Jordan, Iraq). What was that American joke about spreading the "sseds of democracy" throughout the world?
Dovy you are perfectly right, when is the american people (altough 80% of them are just average people with no culture and who know nothing outside the states)gonna wake up and stand up to their leaders who are played like puppets by powerful jewish lobbys forcing them to send billions of $ of american tax money to Israel to kill their neighbours and take their land (claiming its for security reasons of course)!
If the diaspora want to subsidize Isreal as their fantasy theocracy, let them, as theRoman Catholics do the Vatican. Otherwise NOT WITH MY MONEY! The US is mixing religion and politics and that is, however o.k. with Bush and his "End-timers", NOT o.k. with US tradition or Constitution. It's mixing Church and State! QED
Sam, Israel doesn't have to negotiate with Hamas, Hezb, or Iran. Negotiate with Syria and close the deal over the summer. Closing the deal with Syria for the Golan will crush Hezb. strength. This allows Siniora to negotiate a deal with Hezb to be absorbed into the Leb. Army at the cost of some political compensations. With Shebba resolved by the Israel/Syria treaty, negotiate peace with Siniora that stops the overflights and border conflicts. There you have peace on your northern border without negotiating directly with any terrorist organizations. With Iran, let them swing on a short rope that the UN holds for them. They will continue to defy the UN demands, but will also continue to only refine fuel grade uranium. This is a default stop of any Nuke weapons without a conflict or talks. Iran will be so proud about standing up to the Americans by enriching to 5% under IAEA observation, that they will never get a chance to enrich to 90% No nukes with no talks
Israel isn't the same country it was when American aid first began. It is now prosperous and rich and perfectly capable of supporting its own defence needs. Israel does not need this money. This deal is a tribute to the assiduous work of the American Jewish Lobby.
Israel is a powerful country filled with gifted individuals who are on the forefront of science, art, medicine, and technology. It also has as its best friend the greatest country the world has ever seen -- the United States. If you bet against Israel you will lose. All who have ever sought to destroy the Jews have themselves been destroyed. It is Iran that is on the path to destruction. It will never see a single nuclear weapon in its arsenal. By contrast, although Israel sits quietly as Ahmedegenerate rants about wiping out Israel it is Israel who right now possesses the power to wipe out Iran five times over. Mark my words, all who seek to destroy Israel will be reduced to ashes.
with that money going to Israel annually, the entire US social system could be revamped - a health insurance for everyone would be possible, the education system could be greatly improved, war veterans would get the care they need ... but hey, what are 280 million americans compared to 6 million Israelis..... Israel can stand on its own two feet, American money should first go to Americans!!
Lets do some math...We pay $65.00 per barrel for Saudi Crude, and got back the murder of 3000 Americans and considerable financial assistance to hamas and other terrorist in and from the mid east. America fought a war for Moslems in Bosnia, saved Hussian in the Iran/Iraq war only to have to save Kuwait and most likely Saudi Arabia 1n 1990. By the way, if Israel did not blow the Iraqi reactor at Osirak in 1981 there would not have been any bail out of Kuwait. And, is the only power that stands in the way of Iran and nukes. Moreover, we are the protector of Gulf oil, the threat being from Iran. America bailed out the PLO in 1982, Abbas in 2007. Arming Israel is a bargain. Arab oil and dealing with arab cartoon states, now that is expensive. I can't even venture a dollar amount.
This is not about the USA, they are great, and their support has been a great strength to Israel. This is about Israel and the need to act like sovereign independent nation. With aid comes strings, and also becomes a symbol for Israeli's of disempowerment. It is time for Israel to be masters of their own fate. Stay strong allies with the US but on a more equal footing. Enough is enough!!!! Olmert strikes again! the man is a curse for national policy, I mean everything he does just poit to the opposite and then we know the right way to go!!!!
are you kidding me!!!!!! with all the economical issues in our backyard this moron goes and adds more to a surplus that is about to explode for what for whom... this is absurd, he denies a $2 minimum wage increase over 3 year period to the hard working American families that are losing their homes by the millions ,yet he has no problem approving billions to a foreign country that has no value but that to be the cause of death and wars...
This beggars belief. Israel already has the 4th most powerful Armed Forces in the world, is the only Power in the region with a theatre nuclear strike capability, yet it asked for, and got, yet more money for more arms to maintain a 'qualitative edge'. Qualitative edge over what or whom, and why? Which other country is threatening Israel so bad thatit needs this amount of money to maintain a qualitative edge? Egypt? Jordan? Lebanon? Syria? 33% of Israeli families live below the poverty line. Why can't Israel ask for US dollars for humanitarian purposes?
I should think the whole lot will end up with Lockheed Martin and Co., possibly in return for F22s, but more likely just in return for keeping the F16's up to date - as against Saudi Arabia's air defense systems, which come from us here in Britain. In other words, all the fine words are just smoke. This is 100% subsidised Big Business of the nastiest sort. It keeps quite a few of our skilled workers employed though, and that is all the British political culture professes to care about. Same in the USA - you can always find the current 'senator from Boeing', even if it isn't the flamboyant Scoop Jackson any more.
Now, if only the Israelis would make a few good decisions on their own behalf. Such as not taking in permanent Gaza refugees, giving up the Golan, providing fuel to Gaza without Shalits release and not encouraging Arabs to leave Israel.
Bernie and Jerry talk about the need for Israel to make a "just peace" as if its really in Israel's hands. So myopic. Can't you see that Israel's concessions in terms of land and sovereignty so far have only brought it more misery, have only emboldened its enemies? It's tough to make what some consider a just peace (total withdrawal, return of millions of refugees, demographic suicide) when the other side indicates that even all of the above is not necessarily going to end the conflict. No, when the Pals (not the Saudis) are ready to settle this conflict, Israel will meet them half way. Anything else is an Oslo-style pipe dream.
"You can`t turn back the clock and bring back the dark ages." I agree with you and the West can't use the Torah or Bibile to claim the land is Jewish; people living there disagree. Israel a moral country? I think the average Pal would disagree. Saudi and Egypt are dictators; you know the ones the West backs.
Then: Nasser was posturing, he had 60,000 troops in Yemen fighting his 'real' war, he was shocked when Israel attacked him, Egyptian army didn't even fight, they ran home, syria and Jordan were even less prepared. Now: Hezbollah and Hamas are ready. Syria is digging in to defend itself. Iran is preparing. If dragged into it, Egypt, Saudi Arabia and Jordan all have current military hardware given to them from the United States. The next time Israel attacks, it will be faced with an incredibly complex force against it, and a group of targets that it will not be able to beat. In response to Israel's attack, rockets will land on Israel, maybe just 5 or 10 a day, for months while Israel's economy crumbles. Israel will lash out with great force to try and stop the rockets, to no avail. It will not be able to use nukes, for fear that Pakistan will destabilize, and the extremists that take over there may strike back 'for their muslim brothers.' Peace talks must happen now.
try TO read A LITTLE, BEFORE SPOUTING OFF. iSREAL IS AN ECONOMIC POWERHOUSE. The Intel chip in your computer is from Isreal. ANY three of Isreals' neighbors do not have 1/2 of what Isreals economy produces. A huge number of tech innovations COME from Isreal. As I said READ a bit on the subject before making so foolish a statement. Isreal is a SUCCESS-as opposed to ALL of her neighbors.
The US shouldn't be giving Israel any more aid. If you have the ability to level a country (Lebanon) then you clearly don't need more money for weapons. And furthermore if you have an economy that is comparable to a country like Spain, then I think the money would be better spent in places that are significantly poorer. And finally the US should cut funding to Israel so that they are finally pushed to the bargaining table- all the US is doing now is allowing them to drag this out while settlements continue to be built, there's no incentive to create peace when the status quo is in you're favor.
Imbecile Olmert has mortgaged Israel's future for nothing more than a minimal annual adjustment for inflation, assuming inflation is 2%. In exchange for a public announcement to help his image, the jackass has actually negotiated a FREEZE in military aid to Israel for 10 years, no matter how dangerous and expensive to Israel are massive US arms sales to Arabs in the region (is this the JDAMS "accommodation"?), nor "risks for peace" that the US wants Israel to take with Hamastan & Co., like Gen. Dayton arming the Force 17 terrorists. Such is the power of Olmert's "negotiating" skills. Sounds like the phony "deal" he worked out for UN "peacekeepers" in Lebanon.
To all Americans, thank you. As a Jew, a Zionist and a citizen of the free western world, I thank you for your continued support of the Land Of Israel. Its fashionable these days to bash most things American. And I'm sure that this latest announcement will cause another severe heat rash for the loony left and their strange bedfellows the radical Islamists. But this is a correct action my a moral country to her close ally. Israel stands alone in the M.E as the only law abiding and free society. Any aid generously given by the USA should be seen for what it is. An investment in freedom and a down payment on the continuing need to let Israels enemies and by definition, the wests enemies, know that we wont buckle in the face of their myopic dark age view of the world. G-D BLESS AMERICA. Amen and dare I say it, Inshallah
I have to agree with Bernie from Detroit. With US influence in the Middle East waning, I think Israel's status there will dwindle as well. If Israel is not prepared to perpetually subjugate the region, it will have to make a just peace. Neither of these of course are possible and Israel will be a failed state within 10 years.
Olmert is a poor negotiator. He should have hit up Bush for at least an extra billion per year.
They know this and we know this...whatever tanks or planes you buy mean nothing against several nuclear bombs. Hence, they are so concerned about Iran, nukes are the great equalizer, enabling Iran and possibly Syria in the future be more aggressive without the suicidal threat of regime change as Israel with all its conventional weapons (and nukes mind you) would be uttely destroyed, Iran might too, but as a midwest Christian, I'm find with it. :) Don't bother me! :) Lets do it! Lets hope it all comes to fruition, as it seems it will...there is no stoping Iran, the world knows this.
All Americans are required to pay a tax called the Israel Tax. It's a tax that amounts to about $100 per year per American citizen. It is time Americans tell their legislators that they no longer wish to pay taxes to support the Zionist regime to kill Palestinians!! NO to the Israel Tax!!
Bernie, It's not Israel that will declare war, it will be her neighbors. There is nothing Israel can do to stop the Arab countries who feel Israel is being cornered and they will soon be able to go in for the kill. You can't negotiate with Hamas You can't negotiate with Hezbollah You can't negotiate with Iran You may not be able to negotiate with Syria Israel is a tremendous military power in terms of conventional warfare and will just have to accept the fact they may be forced to use it on any neighbors who get their confidence up and force a war upon her. In a war of survival, I wouldn't want to bet against Israel prevailing once again.
It is quite obvious you don't believe Israel has a right to exist. That in its own right is racist. But to top it all you are also quite ignorant. Israel has been in much worse situations numerous times in the past and it got out just fine (1967 was such an incident). Israel is here to stay. It is the most morale country in the middle-east, at the very least not worse than human right abusers Saudi Arabia, Syria, Iran, and Egypt. We will make peace with the moderate Arab countries and the rest of them will fade into oblivion. You can't turn back the clock and bring back the dark ages, no matter how much you'd like to.
These idiots really think the fight is going to last 10 more years? Israel must make peace with the Arab Countries prior to the US leaving Iraq, let's say, 2 years MAX. If the US leaves Iraq, they will not go back to the middle East. If Israel has not made peace by then, it will have chosen war, and one which it cannot win. Let's say 2012, or 5-6 years if War is Chosen over peace. So this 10 year military arrangement is a waste of time. Everything is probably going to be settled within 5 years.