U.K. Muslim group ends boycott of Holocaust Memorial Day
Britain's biggest Muslim organization reverses decision which has done 'more harm than good.'
By Assaf Uni Tags: Holocaust Remembrance Day Holocaust education UKThe Muslim Council of Britain (MCB), the largest Muslim umbrella organization in the U.K., decided over the weekend to halt its boycott of the country's official Holocaust Memorial Day.
The council's working committee decided to put an end to the six-year boycott, which started with the inauguration of the memorial day in 2001.
The MCB has since been subject to harsh criticism by the British government and Jewish organizations, and was often accused of anti-Semitism over the boycott.
Last year the MCB indicated a policy change, but the working committee ended up voting against it. "The decision was taken because staying away was doing more harm than good and being misconstrued," an MCB spokesperson told The Times.
18 members of the working committee voted in favor of halting the boycott, while eight voted against. MCB representatives will attend the Holocaust Memorial Day ceremonies, which will be held in Liverpool on January 27 - the 63rd anniversary of the liberation of the Auschwitz extermination camp.
Holocaust Educational Trust Director Karen Pollock welcomed the decision. "It is right that the Muslim Council of Britain have finally decided to participate in Holocaust Memorial Day. It is important to note that the day has always commemorated the Nazi genocide and genocides since the Holocaust. This was particularly clear in 2001, the first year of HMD which was themed Remembering Genocides: Lessons for the Future and paid particular attention to Bosnia. Similarly, in 2004, the theme of HMD was From the Holocaust to Rwanda," she said.
"In the past, various Muslim organizations and individuals have been involved in HMD and it is the right decision for the Muslim Council of Britain to join them."
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
you remember the holocaust, but what about the millions of african descendents who were taken as slave and ujprooted from their country, why is that not being remembered and compensation paid. the jews are biased, you kill the palestinians and grab the land and build houses. even now you want peace but still you build on occupied land. are serious for peace. no, but for sure if you dont make peace now i am sorry to say always oppressors do not win it does not matter how long they do. open your eyes and see the history of this world. i know also haaretz is always biased they will not print my article because it soe not pleases the israelis.
Muslims should either admit they curse us in their mosques or renounce their confused beliefs. The muslim council of Great Britain is not elected,would usurp the place of British women and is self appointed and therefore not well thought of. This ploy is for their own self advancement and barely worthy of a mention. British women regard themselves as equally valuable in our society and regard muslim objectives as a negative and backward influence.
Hold on every body, just a moment, I don't know who to believe? the Jews or the Muslims. and it seems that the guy who wrote the history for the jews is different than the one who wrote it to the Muslims. which one is the true history? We are all stupid to keep fighting for the same mistakes our forefathers were fighting for. and where are they now? sooner or later we will join them, so please let's have some love and compassion to one another,or Am I just dreaming?
In the spirit of Groucho Marx, they should'nt let the Muslim Council of Britain attend especially since it is doing it under the auspicous of wanting to improve its 'image'. Nothing was 'misconstrued' about the boycott, the organization doesn't respect the genocide of others.
One state solution already exists. It is called Israel. For muslims Jordan is the other choice.
although you are not mentioning the truth,many moslems in Europe, in poland gave refuge to jews,in turkey too, and in Palestine. some people opposed it, but what was the end result? you stole palestine and threw the pals out, {christians and muslims}, would n't you oppose the muslim today if you know, that their aim is to throw you out of Israel?, your aim at that time was to establish Israel and Lord Belfor promise was dated back in 1917. the jews were massacred in Europe on the hands of Christians, you don't dare to mention that of course,the crusaders,and the Romans all were christians. the Muslims never committed a massacre against the jews. but what you can say to someone like you, who like to twist facts.but you know what?,continue your aggression against Muslims,they don't worry about that, because the God of Abraham and Moses won't let this injustice to go on forever, without holding you guys responsible. live in your fantacy,till you meet your creator one day.
When the net loss of Arab non-combatants to Jewish ones is 6 million, we'll give equal time.
41The only complete ethnic cleansing in ME was of Jews in Arab lands, who lived there for 2000 years, and had no choice to stay, while Arabs who wanted to stay in Israel did, and multiplied peacefully to be 20% of population.
Holocaust denial is cover-up for Pal Leader, Grand Mufti, who participated actively in it, and probably was the one who convinced Hitler to adapt the Final Solution, instead of continue allowing Jews to emigrate to then British Palestine. Hitler wanted the Arab World?s support, which he got. The Grand Mufti is still revered. Arafat considered himself the Mufti's heir, and Abbas ? Arafat?s heir...
In WWII, the people you spoke of were killed as a result of war. The holocaust was the mass extermination of people for no other reason than they were Jews. Or political prisoners, mentally retarded, or just not genetically "perfect". Subtle difference between that and a V-2 in the night, I know. In fact, 11 million died in the holocaust, but nowhere in history that I can find, have so many from a single "group" been put to death for no reason other than being who they were. In this case, Jewish. Read a book then tell me - before 1948, where were the other Arab countries screaming for a Pal state? But 8 hours after the 1948 resolution was signed, the first bus with women and children was bombed and the first lies..sorry, cries..of "stolen land" went up. Both by Arabs. Where's your condemnation of the bombers who blew up children? Infants, toddlers...guilty of nothing but being Jewish, and for the Pals, that was enough. Where's your outrage over that?? Hypocrite.
what rightful nation you are talking about? is it about Israel? where human rights of the pals are violated on a daily basis. A rightful jewish people who denied even the existence of the palestinian people, and want to forge the history. a rightful jews who are not prayin daily and who are not watching the Shabbat.and who support the zionist state in ripping off the land from its owners up till today. A rightful nation with gay parades and women trafficing, who you deceive? you can trick some people but you are not a rightful nation, you are a nation against God, and I hope Haaretz has the couarage to not sensor this.
Can people stop placing every Muslim in the same boat!! HELLO WE ARE INDIVIDUALS !!!! Or I'm sorry this would put a monkey wrench in the works for those who love to make us out to be a evil none human monsters. I am sick and tired of the BS that I have to read on feedback from people that have never meet a Muslim and if you have shit please don?t base that Encounter solely on that individual! and one last thing please don?t state Lebanese are Arabs, it?s like saying Jews are Pal's that how insulting it is to us! So here is the deal stop group us as thou we are all in it togther and I will stop trying to pick up Jewish women ........... Hmmmmmm maybe not!! Sorry once you have something that good there is no going back! Any nice single jewish women out there aged between 24 and 33 yrs live in Melbourne ????
With the Muslims yelling for the death of the British teacher something had to be done. This was a perfect time to do it. I hope the British population not fooled
Hmmmm nope The women from IDF are sexier then and female from Paki. Somthing about women in uniform and guns just make me feel right. Do a Google on it an you see what I'm speaking about, Miss Paki is ugly!!!!! Any women from the IDF would like to meet a Australian Lebanese for long term relationship???
They must suffer from collective oligophreny.. incapable of independent and critical thinking and that is why thery are in the situation they are.. either that or they really do not care about theo ir own... they preffer to celebrate the death of one Isareli ( no matter if its a man woman childern or baby as long as is israeli) even if in doing that they are left without work, fuel or electricity what a pathetic bunch of loosers...
Now on to healing all the rifts.
There are those who think Muslims can do no wrong. There are those who think Muslims can do no right. There are those who think. The third group is grossly under represented on talkback
What a load of non-historical hooey! You're living in a dreamland to even consider comparing the Holocaust with the rebirth (YES - REBIRTH, NOT INITIAL CREATION)of the nation of Israel. I've never, ever seen a map with a country called Palestine dating to Biblical times or after. Yes, a region named after the Philistines (long extinct), but NEVER a political entity called Palestine. You just hate Jews and our rightful nation.
They should take a good look at Darfur. The perps are muslim Arabs. So much for their humanitarian concern.
Let it be remembered that Muslims opposed allowing Jews into "Palestine" during World Ware II so that many more Jews died because they had no place to go. Let it be remembered that no Muslim country opened its doors to Jews in our hour of need. Let it be remembered that Palestinian Muslims in fact joined with the Nazis.
The age of European imperialism in Africa ended a generation or two back. When will the Arab occupation of North Africa finally end?
After years of irrational arguments about the Palestinian genocide or Holocaust, it's about time they opened their eyes and saw the real world. Perhapsa they can now have the courage to condemn the Arab occupiers' treatment of native Africans in Darfur.
Better late than even later! It was an own goal to refuse to take part and reenforced the negative public image of British Muslim leaders. Perhaps traditional British virtues of tolerance and fair play have seeped through. Good timing -- just after the Teddy bear named Mohamet.
Just another day in Islam, religion of pieces. Let's see, what moral atrocity do we have today? Wait! I know........ a schoolteacher in Sudan is threatened with prison, lashes, and beheading, but gets a reprieve at the last moment. Crime: letting her class name the teddy bear Mohammed, the most popular name in the muslim world. ooooooooooooh. And let us not forget the fatwah of death still lingering on Salman Rushdie's head over a book that was never read by those who created the edict. I was in San Francisco at the onset of the Lebanon war, and had the weird experience of watching a bunch of 8 yea olds in full Hijab screaming: 2 4 6 8! Israel is a racist state! how charming that just your everyday muslims in the USA are teaching their children the elements of anti jewish philosophy.
Chris Linthwaite: No, they boycott it because they want to hurt Jews. That's it. The only people on earth who boycott or attack Holocaust memorial/facts stuff are neo-nazis and Islamic organizations. No one else does it. Because they want to harm Jews, whether it's related to Israel or not.
To '1 state Solution' guy who posted no.7: Palestine was a land territory. About 80% of it became Jordan. That's when Palestine became a country. As for 'one state' Arabs have several dozen countries, Muslims have dozens of countries, including several 'Islamic republics,' Jews have one tiny little country that people like you want to undo the existence of because it's Jewish. You are an idiot.
It may be only a belated baby step, but it is about time. Recognizing each others tragedies is a good first step to healing.
It is obvius that strict historical facts, like the Partition of Palestine, are nowhere in the arab mentality; they prefer to live in that imaginary world where wishes and allucinations are the reality. Wake up people,until you recognize the many blunders your liders have commited and the profound historical ignorance that allow those extremly corrupt political liders a free pass in this mistakes, your people will not have a future in the 21st century, you will be condemn to keep living in the 8th century, but is your desition.
the arab world calls it Naqba (tragedy) because: -they lost one giant garbage dump in jerusalem (now the western wall) -the arab world lost the first of many wars The suffering and persecution of Jews 60 years ago hurts the Arab world because another world leader beat them to it.
should be banned from attending Holocaust Memorial Day activities. Who needs their crocodile tears anyway? When the Muslim groups stop naval gaxing and reflect upon what Holocaust means then they should be readmitted into the human race.
#10. There was never a Palestinian holocaust.Lying about this is hateful antisemitic racism.
"celebrated" is again you being your bigotted self. The holocaust of the Jews is used because it represents a lot more than pure ignorance, barbarism, savagery and slaughter that is Darfur, Rwanda, Cambodia etc. Mechanised, proceduralised, scientific, documented mass murder of people including a million children with everybody from train drivers, chemists, builders, secretaries, plumbers etc taking part and then sitting down together for their evening meals and beer as if they were only working at the Hereford Sun Valley Chicken Slaughter House supplying M&S is mankind possessed by the devil and a lesson for us all. For you to add insult by comparing this to the Palestinian issue is simply a reflection of who you are.
Have you not been able to afford your daily medication? Go run to your doctor ASAP!
Hey Mr. 1 State Solution you must have been educated in Gaza. Naqba means the so-called Palis (Muslims) rejected their own state. It means Jews in current Israel were liberated. Unfortunately, the real Naqba was the 850,000 Jews forced to leave so-called Arab lands. Did they teach you that Jordan is Palestine yet?
When the Islamo Fascists and or moslems in general condemn terror in Jewish Israel I may take note of some kind of change. Otherwise, the moslems are just covering political bases.
War causes suffering. Look at the displacements after the Second World War - millions of Germans forcibly removed from hundreds of years of living in Silesia. Muslims driven from Hindu areas, and vice-versa, during partition of the Indian subcontinent. You don't hear the descendants of those people talking about being refugees 60 years and more later. They did what the Arab Jews who were forcibly removed from their homes did - made the best of a bad situation in another land. But the Palestinians were never given the chance - unwelcome in Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, or Egypt. Pawns used by these Arab governments, consigned to the dung-heap politically econonomically and culturally. Encouraged radicalism and fanaticism - Arafat was 'appointed' to head the PLO because the Arabs wanted a Fifth Column to help destroy Israel. Arabs already HAD the West Bank and Gaza. They weren't interested in rehabilitating the poor Palestinians. Only the destruction of Israel would do. So it seems.
"Because it only CELEBRATED the Jewish holocaust." C.-L Sir, Beatufully said
The poverty of your thinking is astounding…. Even in the modern period of human history, there have been countless wars, invasions, massacres and subjugation of peoples. One of those was WWII with perhaps as many as 50 million deaths. And yet you go on to say, that the Naqba is one of the saddest events to have occurred in modern history. Do you know how many refugees there were after WWII? Millions…Do you know how many are still refugees? None. Why? Because they were absorbed into their host countries and assimilated into their societies. Why was there a refugee crisis in 1948? Because the Arab states (and the Palestinians) could not countenance a Jewish state on even the tiniest sliver of the region. So they attacked en masse the fledgling Jewish state – and helped create the 600-800,000 refugees (which you label one of the saddest events in modern history). Why are they still refugees? Because their Arab “brethren” refused them human rights, citizenship, employment, dignified housin
Hmmm...Naqba is like the Holocaust...the worst tragedy every in the whole wide world...wow, you taught me something I didn't know. But wait, I'm puzzled....how many Israeli Arabs are fleeing to Gaza or West Bank? In anticipation of the formation of the Palestinian state, how many Jerusalem Arabs want to maintain Israeli citizenship because the benefits are better, as compared to those "stepping all over each other" to run to Gaza or WB?? Holocaust indeed, Mr. Troll
from the Jordan river to the sea.
Muslims should stay away from Holocaust, they are hypocrites.
Doesn't equate. No ovens. No gas chambers. You are off-base.
BUT SAID NO!!! Stop trying to ignor and deny history as it happened and writing your own version...it will not work.
Although one sympathizes with the sufferings of all victims on all wars anywhere, do not compare the number of victims with a policy at state level of extermination of an entire population (or others for the matter). DYOR and check the support for the Nazis' policies in the Middle Eat, pre and during WWII. Regarding the Naqba, there was also another tragedy, that is the systematic expulsion of Jewish populations from many countries in the ME. Note that here they succeeded, so you can imagine if they had succeeded on their drive to expel the Jews to the sea. Arab governments, the propaganda at the time of the wars is abundant and for all to see, used an entire group of people to advance (and fail) their political agenda.
You tried to steal it all and call it Naqba. Now you want to do it all throught the back door. Who is denying the tragedy of others in WW2? Maybe the Moslem SS or the followers of Al Husseini who helped bring it all about.
Represent them self not Britain Muslims , you can call them poodle of the number 10
I hope they mean the slaughter of 3800 Serbs by the mujahedeen. That 'srebrenica' thing is a work of fiction. Read Jared Israel or Francisco Gil White.
Because it only celebrated the Jewish holocaust. The Muslim Council of Britain thought that it should commemorate other Holocausts such as Darfur, Rwanda, Cambodia, Armenia, Russia, Tibet, Palestine amongst others. Holocaust Memorial day has been adapted for that purpose. In January we will be teaching about the Holocaust in Dharfur. As well as teaching the Shoah of the late 1930's and early 1940's. Personally I think it should be a day when we teach our kids that been different is good, and if we pick on people who are different then this can occur. Thus combining this particular day with anti bullying initiatives as well.
The Muslim Council of Britain has just decided to stop boycotting the UK's Holocaust Memorial Day. How is this bad news for anyone, let alone London?
If we are going to remember the holocaust, and ignore the other 50,000,000 who died in WWII (Russians, Chinese, Japanese, American... other goyim), then we should have a memorial for the Naqba - the day when Palestine ended and Israel began. Not as many were massacred, but the real Holocaust lasted 5-6 years, the Naqba has lasted nearly 60 and caused 60 years of suffering for an entire people, generated Islamo-terrorism, and is one of the saddest events to have occured in modern history - mostly because its tolerated and supported - rather than being condemned.
The decision was a practical more than an ethical one. These are "my" muslums...
I am puzzled. not sure what boycotting Holocaust Memorial Day has to do with Israel or taking a political stance against Israel. Perhaps the UK Muslim groups misunderstood basic things, like what the Holocaust is about, what persecution is about, why they love to hate so much, etc
why is this bad news for london? please explain. thanks
I say we all throw in the towel and worship Miss Pakistan.
muslims in UK are very extremist. this is bad news for London.
Well, well ...