Turkish filmmaker takes aim at U.S. and Israel
Most expensive Turkish production set to tell story of Palestine, by man accused of anti-Semitism.
By Reuters Tags: Israel news anti-SemitismIsrael may not like it, but a popular Turkish TV and film franchise which once depicted a Jewish doctor stealing organs from Muslim prisoners in Iraq now has plans to release a film set in Palestine.
"Valley of the Wolves: Palestine" is projected to cost over e10 million, making it one of the most expensive Turkish films.
Scheduled for a November release, the new project follows the 2006 feature "Valley of the Wolves: Iraq."
That film, which showed American soldiers running amok in northern Iraq, racked up 4.2 million ticket sales in Turkey and accusations of rampant anti-Americanism and anti-Semitism.
"After Iraq, we decided that in the next Polat movie we are going to tell again an international story," said scriptwriter Bahadir Ozdener, sitting in an office lined with antique cameras in Nisantasi, an upscale Istanbul neighborhood.
The series' hero is Polat Alemdar, a gun-toting agent with a fondness for sharp tailoring and a dearth of facial expressions.
Played by Necati Sasmaz - who had never acted before - and dubbed by another actor, Polat is sometimes described as the Turkish James Bond. Millions of young Turks idolise him, imitating his mannerisms and speech.
Alternate takes
In the new film Ozdener says his intention is "to shed light on the history, on what's really going on in Palestine."
He described the conflict as "a very good example of the imperialists' targets".Turkey is a long-time NATO member, a traditional ally of the United States, and a friend of Israel's since the mid-1990s.
The country has a secular constitution, but Turks are Muslim and Valley of the Wolves reflects some sentiments that may not always be sympathetic towards Israel.
"The narrative of the serial is an alternative narrative to what is going on," added Orhan Tekelioglu, an academic who has written about the show in his column in the Radikal newspaper.
"It simply says, Turkey is under the attack of foreign powers, firstly the U.S., secondly Israel."
Israeli Ire
Valley of the Wolves: Palestine comes shortly after the franchise's last brush with Israeli disapproval.
In January - following an episode of the television serial that showed Israeli agents kidnapping a Turkish child - Israeli Deputy Foreign Minister Danny Ayalon summoned Turkey's ambassador.
Their meeting turned into a very public snub, when Ayalon refused to shake Ambassador Ahmet Oguz Celikkol's hand and sat the Turkish diplomat on a low chair in front of TV cameras.
A furore ensued, and now Israeli officials remain tight-lipped about the upcoming film, which will see Polat Alemdar at large in Gaza, the West Bank and Jerusalem. "
We cannot respond on anything we haven't seen yet," said Tal Gat, Israel's deputy consul general in Istanbul.
The Anti-Defamation League - an American group that campaigns against anti-Semitism - argued that the franchise sits at odds with Ottoman traditions of religious tolerance.
"Turkey has a unique history of not having been infected by anti-Semitism," said Abraham Foxman, the ADL's National Director. "The irony is that today it's engaging in anti-Semitism through mass media."
success
The Valley of the Wolves franchise - made by production company Pana Film - has enjoyed tremendous success in Turkey.
The title evokes mythological images from a story beloved by nationalists of a lone wolf that guided Turks out of a Central Asian valley where they had been trapped by enemies.
The television series, known as 'Kurtlar Vadisi' in Turkish, first aired in 2003. The initial, mafia-focused plot saw Polat Alemdar tasked to penetrate Turkish organised crime.
With a regular quota of gunfights and mayhem the series rapidly gained and maintained an enormous following. Today, Pana claims between 20 and 40 million Turks watch each week.
Then came Valley of the Wolves: Iraq, the 2006 feature film, which saw Polat Alemdar avenging in fiction the real-life events of July 2003, when American forces captured and hooded a team of Turkish Special Forces in northern Iraq.
Styled like a Hollywood blockbuster, the film prominently featured abuse at Abu Ghraib prison.
After Iraq, Pana Film began a series about Turkey's long conflict against Kurdish separatist guerrillas. But government pressure forced them to shelve Valley of the Wolves: Terror after just one episode as the subject was too sensitive.
The next series cast Polat as a secret agent defending Turkey against foreign threats.
Styled like a Hollywood blockbuster, Turkish film critic Alin Tasciyan believes Valley of the Wolves carries a very different message.
She called the 2006 Iraq film, "Anti-American in the most American way possible."
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
Its not targetted at America so much as its targetted at you. The Turks know well who their friends are and certainly who they aren't. As do many of us, even if our Governments don't.
Now that would be a successful Turkish movie - "The Armenian death march! Or maybe "The Failed Entry in the European Union". A lot of money can be made, I am sure but personally I would not invest my own savings in such projects.
This is dramatic. Some named as David, writes in the name of "Ibrahim from Ankara". you get the message.
The biggest "Israel basher" is Dogan Media Group. Albeit, it does it subtle. It is also no secret that it receives its financing from Germany. Kurtlar Vadisi is Dogan Groups most lucrative TV series. You know that show that depicts IDF soldiers as deliberate Child murderers....Prima facie, it's easy to blame everything on the "Islamist" Turkish PM yet a close analysis will show that the issue is much deeper and that it is not about religion or State interests.
Media oulets like Zaman, Vakit, Sabah are the real Israel bashers and they do it in the harshest and most unfair language. As you know Sabah is owned by PM Erdogan's son in law. Dogan Media Group is relatively innocent.
Every country has a parliament...so what ever one country can legislate on the other can too. The US legislates Turkish history...Turkey legislates US history viz about its native Indian population. Every country has a media industry...it's not only hollywood that can cash in on populist yet unrealistic movies. The muslim "terrorists" in hollywood media have been lucrative business for Hollywood itself. Now Israel "bashing" has been lucrative business for Middle Eastern media companies such as Dogan Group...owned by Mr. Aydin Dogan...Prime Minister Erdogan's number one "enemy".
The Turkish government has hired Israel's top PR agentto bring Israeli tourism back to Turkey. http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/1153292.html
They won't. They can't. Never, ever. They are Israeli.
With the present regime in Turkey they are likely to start killing non-Moslems soon in any case so the production costs should be quite reasonable.
Valley of the wolves: Kurdistan. Of course more anti-semetic propaganda comes out of Muslim countries surprised. Whats next? They are gonna use the centuries old lie, again, and tell them to lock up their kids during passover or we are going to kill them for our matzah.
Maybe a time travel episode for some good old fashioned revisionist history, Turkish-style. Let's hope the E.U. has both the brains and courage to keep Turkey out indefinitely.
They should close their eyes to the attrocities in Iraq. They should watch the american movies like `orient express` characterizing the turks as embecile and barbars. They should watch the movies like `Ararat` which falsifies the real history as a clear propaganda. They should admit the insult of Lieberban`s crew, eventhough it is groundless. They should always be critisized but they should never dare to criticize others... as to the movie, I will not watch it coz above all, the cast is not satisfactory...
That is the real story, and thats the real movie, if any Turk has the guts to make it. Turkeys real tirst for blood is coming back, . How can the Islam of Drakula be satisfied otherwise. Edrogan has placed his black cap, and he is ready.
more films about the slaughter that the Ottoman's brought on the world. They lined up thousands and shot them in mass genocides. Armenia should demand that the world never forget just like the Jew should demand that the world never forget the holocaust. turkey is once again under a dictator and the world should shun turkey, Iran and Syria. But of course the US has a weak ineffectual president. I can't wait to be part of the group of Americans who vote Obama out of office just like we did Carter. Then we will get a president with wisdom and sense to lead the world out of this.This is what happens to a world without an American policeman. too many low souls on this planet
Now turks are the biggest supporters of iranian islamo-fashism.This is their way of saying thanks to US and Israel for helping them to be what they are today.Together with Iran and Syria they will try to"wipe out" Israel and of course will end up like Saddam.
Wonder how the Turks and all the advocates of "free speech" will react.
"The Anti-Defamation League - an American group that campaigns against anti-Semitism - ..." Suuure it does...
Dutch MP Geert Wilders & his anti-Islam film was considered freedom of speech by 95% of the people who post here. Will, this is the same freedom of speech, go and bite your nails.
Israelis are constantly looking for the monster under the bed. One wonders why? Grow up, guys!
Like other talkbackers--what delicious hypocrisy. I really hope Israel's defense establishment is milking Turkey for everything because these guys are not western and will probably go the way of the Shah one day.
should be produced.
yes, absolutely. does this happen in the us? of course. plenty of hollywood action fims depict arabs as the villian. if this movie is boycotted, why not go a step further and condemn all films which vilify and stereotype a people into one type of character. this is bigger issue than one ethnicity/group.
It seems radical Islam /base Islam debases other religions and non-muslim culture is being nurtured and tolerated in Turkey.