• Published 00:00 14.03.07
  • Latest update 00:00 14.03.07

Taiwan political activists admiring Hitler draw Jewish protests

Simon Wiesenthal Center: Unacceptable to promote policies, images of Nazi Germany as worthy of emulation.

By Reuters and The Associated Press

An international Jewish human rights organization this week condemned a year-old network of Taiwan political activists who revere Adolf Hitler, and an Israeli official said he would protest to the Taiwan government.

The Simon Wiesenthal Center on Tuesday condemned the National Socialism Association for championing the former Nazi dictator and blaming democracy for Taiwan's "social unrest."

"In the global interconnected world we live in, it is unacceptable anywhere to seek to promote the policies and images of Hitler and Nazi Germany as worthy of emulation," Simon Wiesenthal Center Associate Dean Rabbi Abraham Cooper said in a statement.

About 1,000 people, all from Taiwan and mostly college-aged, belong to the 19-month-old National Socialist Association, said self-described "main leader" Yue Shu-ya, 23, of Taipei.

Members usually communicate via their Web site, twnazi.org, he said.

Co-founder Chao Lahn, 24, said he did not accept all of Hitler's Nazi ideology and denied he was a racist.

However, he said, he advocated imposing limits on the number of foreign workers in Taiwan. "My main goal is to develop Taiwan's strength and to foster national unity," Chao said. "I think we have to work hard to restore traditional Chinese values like Confucianism."

"We want to study Hitler's good points, not study his massacres," Yue said, suggesting that Taiwan learn from Hitler's "welfare state" model. "It has nothing to do with Nazism."

Israel's representative to Taiwan said he planned to protest to the Taiwan government about conditions on the island that led to the group's formation.

"(The group) is a reflection of ignorance and an emotional void as well as psychological and social sickness, or a combination of all the above," said Raphael Gazmou, the Israel Economic and Cultural Office representative in Taipei.

"It's also particularly sad that in Taiwan, where people have managed to achieve democracy and human rights, there is this kind of nostalgia for monsters as role model," he said.

Emile Sheng, formerly of Taipei's Soochow University, and now an official in the city's municipal government, said the emergence of Taiwan's Nazi movement reflected the island's ignorance of modern Western history.

"People here don't really understand what Nazism is," he said. "They're not really racist or anti-Jewish. They don't even know what it means."Sheng said one of his students at Soochow had been Hsu Na-chi, who is the other founder of the National Socialism Association.

"I barely remember her," he said. "She was quiet in class, not the kind of student who made an impression."

Hitler has been the subject of controversy before in Taiwan. In December 2004, Taiwan's Nationalist Party withdrew a presidential election campaign advertisement featuring a picture of Hitler following protests from Jewish groups.

In 2001, President Chen Shui-bian's Democratic Progressive Party also withdrew a television commercial with footage of Hitler. In a separate incident, a Taiwan bistro removed pictures of Holocaust victims and other decor that upset Jewish groups.

  • Print Page
  • Send to a friend
  • Share
  • Text Size +|-
 
 
TalkBacks

Why Facebook Connect?

Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.

Add a comment

Add your reply

  • 12. 0 0
    You people are idiots
    • The Devil
    • 20.05.07
    • 08:47

    The only person who knows what he's talking about is Aron. The Taiwanese don't hate Jews, they don't even know/care what a Jew is. These extremists want a super powerful China united with Taiwan. And they believe National socialism will be the backbone for this arrangement. And even though they aren't saying it, they want to rule the world. What does all this mean? Soon, I'm going to get alot of fresh souls.......

  • 11. 0 0
    small percentage
    • Shannon Lin
    • 23.04.07
    • 05:27

    I agree with Aron, Taiwan is an island of 23 million. 1,000 students, obviously still a very bad thing, but is similar to the fasctist groups of neo-naizs in america (if not less) in percentage. we cannot make whole assumptions about a place like taiwan until we take this into account. "Asians" have same ruthlessness", that is ridiculous! Ignorance all around!

  • 10. 0 0
    human nature --ignorance here too
    • Aron
    • 15.03.07
    • 07:01

    This discussion board also shows how ignorant and self-centered people could be. How little understanding about Asian politics. The fact is, Taiwan, unlike Israel, or even the US, or China, is NOT a place of ONE identity. There are multiple conflicting ones coexisting, most prominently on the two extremes of the spectrum -- Pro China vs Pro Taiwan. In fact, the TW Nazis in the news are more on the Pro China side. They aim to restore the glory of China as well as the traditional Chinese values, not the Taiwanese. If you still don't get it, consider this -- in short, these people have more a Chinese identity than the Taiwanese. Their ideas are probably more easily rampaging in China than in Taiwan (national glory ... etc). Take this into account and see if your comments still make any sense at all. Or you can wait until China demands Israel, Canada, or USA to “return” back to China one day as well. Pretty impressive how little people know outside their world.

  • 9. 0 0
    whatever, China will invade within 20 years
    • Ryan
    • 14.03.07
    • 20:33

    They better drop the Hitler thing and put up the Mao, Chinese Army and Yao Ming posters because China will take that place back soon enough...

  • 8. 0 0
    KMT & Taiwan
    • Mark Lincoln
    • 14.03.07
    • 17:40

    Let us not forget that Taiwan was for years a dictatorship. The dictator was Chiang Kai-sheck, and the party was the Kuomintang. Although it had leftist and democratic origins, Chang turned it into a right-wing dictatorship. The dictatorship fell in the early 1990s and Nationalist China is now a democracy. In an extreme irony, the KMT has become the foremost party in reaching out to the People's Republic of China. Thus anyone wishing to form a party to the right of the KMT has to appeal to the most base of right-wing emotions. Hitler is a very useful icon for making that appeal. I can't see the "National Socialist Association" becoming a major player in Chinese politics. The citizens of both Nationalist China and the PRC are looking forward, not backward.

  • 7. 0 0
    Should not play with matches!
    • Alicia
    • 14.03.07
    • 14:31

    Taiwan is being "protected" by both the U.S.A and Japan from the Mainland China, who represents Communist ideology, which the Taiwanese do not want. These Taiwanese youngsters quite naeively, without any reality bases, imagine to discover practical means to "defend" their separate standing from the Mainland China in Hitler's nationalistic ideology. I do not believe that this their interest in Hitler is directed in any way against the Jews or Israel, but there is a big danger that the Taiwanese young people, who start supporting Hitler's ideas, will become just as dangerous toward the Mainland Chinese as the Nazis were toward the "different" from their ideal-person. A healthy alternative would be to provide them with up-to-date information on the Mainland China and tell the Taiwanese that China is NO boogey-man, they need to fear, but has become a MORE TOLERANT, thriving society, where there are constant reforms and improvements underway affecting people's lives positively.

  • 6. 0 0
    Israel stand tall
    • Robin
    • 14.03.07
    • 12:22

    Dear Geulah, don't jump to conclusions victimising yourself. I strongly believe this has nothing to do with anti-semitism. As far as I can see, Taiwan and Israel have little involvement with eachother, and there's absolutely no reason why Taiwanese would want to offend Jewish. When I studied in Taiwan during the 2004 presidential elections, a candidate was blamed for proposing Hitler policies. When it came to my European ears, I was shocked. How could they so lightheartedly refer to this figure, when the allegations were skin-deep and didn't cut ice? Taiwanese references to Hitler are to be seen as a scream for attention. They do not grasp the sensitivity of the subject, only that it causes a ripple. In my humble view, the best response for Israel would be stand tall and disregard. For it is easier to read their motivation for referring to the topic, than having them understand and act in accordance with your emotional connotation.

  • 5. 0 0
    #4 They admire Hitler because Asians have same ruthless like
    • dzone
    • 14.03.07
    • 12:12

    Hitler.We are doomed when Asians(China and others) become major powers.

  • 4. 0 0
    Why do they admire Hitler?
    • David Nigel Braham
    • 14.03.07
    • 11:41

    Just goes to show that there is no political leadership around the world capable of encouraging the young,in the right direction. It is a sad day when the young look towards a dead criminal for political ideas.

  • 3. 0 0
    It fascinating how anti-Semitism rises in places
    • Geulah
    • 14.03.07
    • 11:36

    where there aren't and never have been Jews.

  • 2. 0 0
    Taiwan
    • Jehiel
    • 14.03.07
    • 11:33

    During WWII, virtually the only nation to provide sanctuary to undocumented Jewish refugees was China. Perhaps it is time to repay this debt by assisting the nation of China with the reabsorption of its breakaway province of Taiwan This by the transfer of indigeneously developed modern Israeli technology in the area of the armament industry. I am sure that pro-Nazi philosophy would not be tolerated by the Mainland Chinese government.

  • 1. 0 0
    TAIWAN
    • PARIS
    • 14.03.07
    • 11:00

    In Asia they know almost nothing about the jewish saga and they have shaky notions about the european civilization and the judeo-chrisitan notions of good, wrong and guilty. It is dangerous and vexing because they may become the 21st century dominant powers. Something must be done before it is too late.