• Published 20:18 20.10.09
  • Latest update 23:45 20.10.09

Lieberman to Solana: Goldstone report puts peace talks at risk

FM says Palestinian conduct over Gaza probe calls into question their commitment to peace.

By Barak Ravid Tags: Goldstone report Middle East peace Israel news Avigdor Lieberman

Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman on Tuesday told his European Union counterpart Javier Solana that the Goldstone Commission's report on the Gaza war endangered the Middle East peace process and to the change of renewing negotiations with the Palestinian Authority.

The Palestinian Authority's conduct over the report calls into question their intentions regarding the peace process, said Lieberman. The foreign minister was referring to the PA's retraction and then resubmission of a proposal to debate the report at the United Nations Human Rights Council.

"The policy of subversion carried out by the Palestinian Authority against the State of Israel, which follows decisions at the Fatah conference in August in which there were calls for the resumption of the armed struggle, raises serious questions about the real aims of the Palestinians. The question now is whether the Palestinians want to establish a state, or to destroy the state of Israel," Lieberman said.

The foreign minister's comments came after the author of the damning report, Richard Goldstone, accused him of opposition to the Israeli-Palestinian peace process.

Goldstone, a South African Jurist, made the claim in a conference call on Sunday with 150 U.S. rabbis from left-leaning organizations. He was speaking in reference to an Israeli assertion that the report would harm peace talks.

"That just is a shallow, I believe, false allegation," he said. "What peace process are they talking about? There isn't one. The Israeli foreign minister doesn't want one at all."

Lieberman, a right-winger, has drawn fire for criticizing Israel's past efforts in seeking a peace agreement with the Palestinians.

Goldstone's report accused both Israel and Hamas of committing war crimes during the 3-week campaign, but mainly focused on alleged Israeli offenses. It set off an uproar in Israel, and Israeli officials have largely dismissed it as biased.

On Tuesday, the political-security cabinet decided to form a committee to deal with any legal implications which may arise should an Israeli officials be tried for war crimes in the wake of the report.

  • Print Page
  • Send to a friend
  • Share
  • Text Size +|-
 
 
TalkBacks

Why Facebook Connect?

Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.

Add a comment

Add your reply

  • 29. 0 0
    Realist (#2) Newsflash for you
    • Gil
    • 21.10.09
    • 12:27

    Realist In 2009 alone Hundreds of roadblocks have been lifted, Go and see Ramallah, same thing is now happening in Nablus what was regarded not so long ago by Israel as the capital of terrorism, in 2009 is now starting to look like a Palestinian commercial and trade center, people are saying their sales in 2009 have grew by 90%! Once people in WB could wait for two hours in the Havara crossing, today it takes them approximately 5 minutes Now that the roadblocks in Nablus have been lifted! Every Saturday 50 Busses Plus some 400 cars enter Nablus, bringing with them something like 4000 Arab Israelis who do their shopping there, or just go there to have a good time, this gets into the Arab Palestinian economy an extra 2 million NIS every Saturday! Seems those who you blindly despise are doing more for the benefit of the Arab Palestinians then any other government did (starting in 1987) and are taking grate security risks in doing it! Why don`t you jump to Ramallah and see, instead of being a know it all!

  • 28. 0 0
    No amount of censorship may change reality
    • Mark Lincoln
    • 21.10.09
    • 05:18

    Avigdor Lieberman is the same kind of fool who dragged Germany into disaster seventy years ago. Morally, ideologically, and fundamentally indistinguishable from the rabid right-wing racists who doomed tens of millions to death in WW II.

  • 27. 0 0
    avi & solana
    • DOV KORET
    • 21.10.09
    • 04:58

    Avi your boss is reported (in this paper) to be on his knees begging the terrorist abb'ass to dictate to ISRAEL again.....DK

  • 26. 0 0
  • 25. 0 0
    Stop peace talks nonsense!!!!!!!
    • no time for peace
    • 21.10.09
    • 04:40

    Lets stop pretending Pals dont want peace Israel cant do peace Abbas is finished Hamas are seen as heroes hahahaha The end No hope Pals

  • 24. 0 0
    UNHRC Farce threatens any faith in the UN & its resolutions
    • PETER SM
    • 21.10.09
    • 02:40

    dictated by the automatic majority marshalled by the Arabs. They just proved yet again by ignoring the minimal criticism of Hamas that they have no place in any peace process.

  • 23. 0 0
    Lieberman's war process is at risk
    • Georgie
    • 21.10.09
    • 02:34

    what Lieberman really wants to say to the West: Please don't spoil our incursions against the Palestinian people; since ethnic cleansing of the Gazan's has become Israel's privelege and reward for being G-d's "chosen (ha ha) people."

  • 22. 0 0
    A funny thought
    • Colin Wright
    • 21.10.09
    • 01:58

    Imagine anything that Lieberman could say that would have any positive value at all. He might as well recite limericks to Solana. They'll be more entertaining, and of equal value practically.

  • 21. 0 0
    Lieberman is wrong messenger for such accusations
    • Get Real
    • 21.10.09
    • 00:32

    It simply sounds ridicilous from Lieberman's mouth. Goldstone's integrity and past track record is simply amazing (and Jews should be proud of that) while Lieberman is a sad political mishap - the Haider of the Middle East.

  • 20. 0 0
    Can't we just boo Lieberman off-the-stage...
    • Esther
    • 21.10.09
    • 00:11

    ... he is causing Israel so much harm and embarrassment... ... is repatriatian to Moldavia an option?... with a handsome financial award from Israel for past services rendered...

  • 19. 0 0
    What peace talks?
    • Mark Lincoln
    • 20.10.09
    • 23:20

    There is nothing to risk. Netanyahu and Lieberman have made it very clear there will be no agreement with the Palestinian, no halt to settlement expansion and no peace. What astounds is that Lieberman clearly things everyone in the world is and idiot.

  • 18. 0 0
    yes what peace process ain't no peace
    • tea man
    • 20.10.09
    • 23:01

    The Joke is over and no body is laughing is it something wrong with the comedian or just or way of telling it or people giving up on broken record Citizen arrest now catch them if you can

  • 17. 0 0
    Realist (#2) Newsflash for you
    • Gil
    • 20.10.09
    • 22:49

    Realist In 2009 alone Hundreds of roadblocks have been lifted, Go and see Ramallah, same thing is now happening in Nablus what was regarded not so long ago by Israel as the capital of terrorism, in 2009 is now starting to look like a Palestinian commercial and trade center, people are saying their sales in 2009 have grew by 90%! Once people in WB could wait for two hours in the Havara crossing, today it takes them approximately 5 minutes Now that the roadblocks in Nablus have been lifted! Every Saturday 50 Busses Plus some 400 cars enter Nablus, bringing with them something like 4000 Arab Israelis who do their shopping there, or just go there to have a good time, this gets into the Arab Palestinian economy an extra 2 million NIS every Saturday! Seems those who you blindly despise are doing more for the benefit of the Arab Palestinians then any other government did (starting in 1987) and are taking grate security risks in doing it! Why don`t you jump to Ramallah and see, instead of being a know it all!

  • 16. 0 0
    Israel fears to face Goldstone report
    • Tony Silver
    • 20.10.09
    • 22:27

    If Israel has not committed any war crimes, if the IDF has a perfectly good conscience, then what do you have to fear? The more rage you demonstrate fighting the report, the more guilty you appear. Make an inquiry into the charges and prove to the international community that they are wrong. This is the only way you will convince the world. Not by lobbying against Golstone.

  • 15. 0 0
    The avoidance of peace
    • alan
    • 20.10.09
    • 22:21

    Well said Vladek. Israel however has no reasonable explanation. Israel made a big mistake with "Cast Lead" (choice of name a PR disaster) and are now wriggling on the hook of legitimate recrimination. Israel has lost the plot and is suffering from a lack of intelligent leadership. Biblical inheritence fiction must be put aside in favour of reality!The government of Israel however is hostage to the religious and political mafia who put them in power!!

  • 14. 0 0
    When facists talk
    • Ronen
    • 20.10.09
    • 22:17

    Lieberman is an outspoken opponent of the peace process and he blames others to put it at risk?! Q: Are there any Israelis left that still believe what their FM babbles?

  • 13. 0 0
    Goldstone investigator not peace envoy
    • elj
    • 20.10.09
    • 22:09

    Leiberman is just looking for someone to blame for Israel's failures and crimes. To start with Goldstone did not come to the region to act as a politician nor as as a peace envoy. He was tasked by a respectable UN body with carrying out an investigation into Israel's war against Gaza. The fact is Israel knew rightly what he was going to find out and that is exactly why they tried to stop him first and when they failed refused to cooperate with his investigation. Of course these Israeli tactics are not new and they successfully used them when the UN tried to investigate its war crimes in Jenin and in Lebanon. Fortunately they were not able to stop the investigation this time. Goldstone simply reported what he discovered and this time even Israel's staunchest friends could not protect it. They just were not be able turn a blind eye to the crimes After all these crimes were watched live by millions of people around as the world. So don't go blaming Goldstone instead try the criminals.

  • 12. 0 0
    Abbas shelved the Oslo Process. FM still trying to keep it alive
    • Fake Realist 2
    • 20.10.09
    • 22:08

    Read the article again and you will see what I mean. You will not be a Realist but you will get a clue.

  • 11. 0 0
    If Israel is to have the respect of other nations, it needs to
    • Observer
    • 20.10.09
    • 21:57

    elect leaders that have integrity instead of stonewalling and trying to bully everybody to ingnore their transgressions.

  • 10. 0 0
    Human Rights Watch Founder Bernstein's opinion
    • philtlucre
    • 20.10.09
    • 21:51

    http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/20/opinion/20bernstein.html?_r=1

  • 9. 0 0
    Lieberman admits to no peace talks
    • Stephen
    • 20.10.09
    • 21:40

    Reading the foreign minister's quote, it's so obvious. Why does Israel send a delagation to Wash DC for negociations, last week? Lieberman has to learn how to "play" with other countries; many countries and their foreign ministers are coming down on him.

  • 8. 0 0
    Lieberman's whopper of the week!
    • Ivar
    • 20.10.09
    • 21:33

    The diametric opposite is true: Pressing Israel to full responsibility for not only its Gaza war crimes, but more importantly, violation of the Fourth Geneva Convention which prohibits territorial expansion by military means in general and by settlement in particular, is the ONLY solution to the peace proccess which Israel has evaded and violated since 1967.

  • 7. 0 0
    Goldstone agenda
    • abbadabba
    • 20.10.09
    • 21:20

    Goldstone's remarks clearly indicate that his actions are entirely politically motivated, further substantiating that his report is by no means fair or impartial. As much as I dislike Netanyahu and Barak, they are right to repudiate the report in its entirety. It's simply an internationally sanctioned in-road for further anti-Semitism.

  • 6. 0 0
    peace talks useless in Lieberman's opinion
    • Carol Scheller
    • 20.10.09
    • 21:13

    Mr Solana is permitted to be confused by this statement. Mr Lieberman was reported by Ha'aretz, as well as newspapers in Switzerland, quite recently as warning that any peace in the near future was impossible.So, why would he now be worried about jeopardizing talks he believes will go nowhere?

  • 5. 0 0
    Lieberman or Goldstone
    • kibishi
    • 20.10.09
    • 21:12

    Goldstone desrves a million times more credit. The real phrase is: The Goldstone report endangers peace because.... Up to now no reasonable because. The Goldstone reprot is unbalanced because ... Up to now no reasonable becuse.

  • 4. 0 0
    Israeli Cover-up Threatens Peace Talks
    • Vladek
    • 20.10.09
    • 20:49

    If Israel conducted a fair and impartial investigation of the Gaza invasion, its findings could have been included in the Goldstone Report. If Israel had cooperated with Goldstone in the research and preparation of the report, perhaps the report would not have been seen as so offensive to Israel. If Israel had a reasonable explanation for everything captured on video and displayed on YouTube, the world would not be offended by Israel's actions. If there is a failure in initiating peace talks, the blame needs to be placed at the feet of Lieberman, Netanyahu and Barak. Freedom of information on the internet has revealed the true barriers to just peace.

  • 3. 0 0
    Lieberman was against peace talks anyway
    • PA nothing to lose
    • 20.10.09
    • 20:31

    so now what? leiberman is a loser

  • 2. 0 0
    What peace process?
    • Realist
    • 20.10.09
    • 20:29

    How can Goldstone's war crime report put on risk what Netanyahu, Lieberman and Barak have shelved already?!

  • 1. 0 0