• Published 10:46 21.10.09
  • Latest update 12:20 21.10.09

Leftist jailed for 1 month for assaulting police in West Bank

Ezra Nawi was convicted of assaulting police during the demolition of illegal Palestinian caravans.

By Chaim Levinson Tags: Israel news Palestinians West Bank Israel settlers

The Jerusalem Magistrate Court on Wednesday sentenced left-wing activist Ezra Nawi to one month in prison, after convicting him of assaulting police officers during the 2007 evacuation of illegal Palestinian caravans in the southern Hebron Hills.

"Ideology is ideology, but this trial is not about ideology," said Judge Eilata Ziskind. "Wild behavior from the right or the left is inconceivable, even if the goal is to help the weak. Without order, there can be no democracy."

Justice Ziskind described repeated instances in which Nawi threatened police or prevented them from carrying out their activities.

Nawi will serve an additional six months if he participates in similar activities during the next three years, and he was also ordered to pay a fine of NIS 750,000 along with an additional NIS 500 to each officer he assaulted.

Nawi accused the court of authorizing the occupation of Palestinian land for years and said that the court has long been trying to neutralize and silence him. "The punishment doesn't scare me," Nawi said.

The Yesha Human Rights Organization criticized Nawi's one-month prison sentence, saying, "One month in jail emphasizes the selectivity of law enforcement officials in Judea and Samaria, which allow Nawi to run wild, to hurt settlers and their property," in a statement.

Nawi was convicted in March for assaulting policemen during the demolition of illegal Palestinian caravans in the southern Hebron Hills. Nawi, who has prior convictions for sexually assaulting a minor, illegal use of weapons and drug offenses, has been active for Palestinian rights in the southern Hebron Hills in recent years.

Nawi has in recent months received the support of prominent international leftists, including Professor Noam Chomsky, former deputy attorney general Yehudit Karp and author Naomi Klein.

  • Print Page
  • Send to a friend
  • Share
  • Text Size +|-
 
 
    This story is by: Chaim Levinson
TalkBacks

Why Facebook Connect?

Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.

Add a comment

Add your reply

  • 11. 0 0
    Now there's a contradiction in terminis if I ever saw one
    • John
    • 23.10.09
    • 09:47

    "Yesha Human Rights Organisation"... You can't both have a "Yesha" and Human Rights.

  • 10. 0 0
    Settlers Kill Palestinians, Walk Free
    • Dolphin
    • 21.10.09
    • 19:25

    The judge writes, "Wild behavior from the right or the left is inconceivable" Quelle joke! Settlers are ONLY about wild behavior.

  • 9. 0 0
    Interesting
    • Mikesailor
    • 21.10.09
    • 15:42

    The judge speaks of 'preventing' the police from carryimg out their duties but makes no mention of the use of physical force against said police. She also fines the defendant $750,000. Funny, but I have never heard of a similar fine being placed upon settlers for any actions whatsoever. And their are many stories about settlers using actual physical violence against police. Also, there is a story in this same newspaper where the prosecutors have declined to prosecute the police who filmed themselves beating and humiliating Palestinians. A kangaroo system of justice is a kind way of describing the legal system of Israel.

  • 8. 0 0
    Gerald -- Zang
    • jake 1948
    • 21.10.09
    • 15:39

    I have just seen the video on U-tube. How anyone can talk about justice or be proud of the IDF is beyond me. If this is an example of the most moral army in the world then God help the Palestinians and God help the Israelis too.

  • 7. 0 0
    Some Israelis are more equal than others
    • W
    • 21.10.09
    • 15:31

    Today's Haaretz also reports that "State won't prosecute officers filmed beating Palestinians" because " "the beating in the case was extremely slight and did not cause any actual damage." Does this standard apply to Mr. Nawi?

  • 6. 0 0
    A sick joke
    • Mike Friedman
    • 21.10.09
    • 15:13

    I have been to the area of South Hebron Hills where Nawi was arrested. The settlers there routinely attack local villagers, including children on their way to school. They are never arrested or punished in any way. Instead, they are allowed to continue building - even housing that is officially considered illegal by Israeli authorities. Meanwhile, the local Palestinian population are denied proper water supplies, electricity and the chance to build even basic structures. The name of the game in this part of the West Bank is ethnic cleansing, pure and simple. And what do the Israeli authorities manage to do? Punish an activist for resistance. A tragic reflection of a truly warped society hell-bent on evil.

  • 5. 0 0
    Nawi jailed for 1 month?
    • Gerald -- Zang
    • 21.10.09
    • 14:44

    Question: Why only one month? Assaulting a police officr is a serious offence, in my opinion, and deserves more than only 1 month in jail! The fines imposed on Nawi are also rediculously low. There has to be respect for the law and for those who enforce the law, otherwise CHAOS.

  • 4. 0 0
    Justice
    • Wilma Lobstertree
    • 21.10.09
    • 14:02

    Eilata Ziskind is a credit to the Israeli judiciary. An intensely intelligent and beautiful woman. A bit to the left but honest. G-d bless her.

  • 3. 0 0
    observation
    • potobac
    • 21.10.09
    • 12:30

    Certainly no one can have a problem with the judge's pronouncement (as long as the same treatment is given to settlers protesting illegal settlements being torn down). If, however, one group is allowed such behavior while the other gets a month in jail, one can't help but suspect a politically inspired imbalance of treatment here. In some countries equal administration of justice without fear or favor is considered good form -evidently not in Israel.

  • 2. 0 0
    Article failes to mention international support
    • Woody
    • 21.10.09
    • 12:02

    Tens of thousands of people world-wide, mainly in the US, signed a petition in support of Ezra Nawi. 1-month, 3-year ban, and 750K is NOT a light sentence. Jewish Voice for Peace, among other groups, have rallied behind him - he got a feature in the New York Times. This judge made a mistake and I would expect to see this as another nail in the growing abandonment of Israel by the international community. Keep calling occupation and abuse "democracy" and the punishment of those who resist as criminals and Israel will find herself a nation of a few million so brainwashed they don't realize what happened to them when everyone turns on us or just cause.

  • 1. 0 0
    Congrats to Haaretz for correcting its previous untruths re Nawi
    • Mark
    • 21.10.09
    • 11:40

    Read http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/1094150.html which states, "The policemen claimed Nawi raised his hand against one of them; Ezra denies this, and anyone who knows him believes him. He is a man committed, in every fiber of his being, to non-violent protest." That article did mention the facts that Nawi has prior convictions for sexually assaulting a minor, illegal use of weapons and drug offenses, and that Nawi has repeatedly threatened police.