Israel mulls ban on underweight, 'Photoshopped' models
MK Adatto: Fashion industry builds a twisted ideal of female beauty, encourages eating disorders.
By Jonathan Lis and Shira Ben-Simon Tags: Israel newsThe use of underweight models and digitally rendered images in advertising campaigns should be restricted by law, a new bill submitted to the Knesset proposed on Sunday.
According to the bill, drafted by MK Rachel Adatto (Kadima) and MK Danny Danon (Likud), the chairman of the Committee on the Rights of the Child, advertising agencies would be banned from hiring underweight female and male models.
The authors of the bill relied on the Health Ministry's official criterion, which states that adults with a body mass index lower than 18.5 are considered underweight.
The bill also stipulates that advertising agencies should not be able to use digital imaging software, such as the widely-used Photoshop software, to narrow the waists of models in advertising campaigns.
"Eating disorders, including anorexia, have been on the rise in Israeli society, especially among young girls," the introduction to the bill stated.
The bill also said that, "Studies show that one of the causes for eating disorders among young women is the effect media and advertising campaigns have by presenting very slim women as role models, thus affecting the youth's standards."
According to MK Adatto, "The fashion and advertising industries have constructed a distorted ideal of female beauty, as many of the models appearing in the adverts are underweight.
"This bill is meant to battle eating disorders. It's important to understand that anorexia can kill, a fact which brings out the importance of tools that could curb its expansion among youngsters."
Danon said the bill "is meant to protect children's health by filtering the damaging messages of the modeling industry."
A similar bill had been proposed in the previous Knesset by former Yisrael Beiteinu MK Esterina Tartman, but was eventually rejected after some said it was wrong to discriminate based on overweight or underweight.
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
This is reasonable, in the light of preventing a distorted idea that underweight is 'beautiful'. Let us always remember that prolonged malnutrition results to poor mental condition.
But also ban overweight models with a BMI larger than 25. Keep only the 'healthy' BMI range of 19 to 25.
We have agents that sell a womans beauty for a season of life.In the old days a woman of flesh and roundness was a woman of beauty.She had teeth good skin and roundness of wealth.Now it is the extremely thin model with no curves who is mentally challenged and weak of mind.Their diets affect their minds and destroy brain cells literally.You have a generation who think that is the way it is.Eating disorder, drugs, and party hardy.What of the woman who has the chickie wow wow curves and all the boys turn their heads like Jordan Sparks.They walk by and every head turns.She not a reed blown away in the wind she is what a woman is with a goddess voice.Miley Cyrus another beauty of youth not anorexic and with a brain.The Royal Family of Saudia Arabia family member. Check out the 40's models.These children are used by agents and then thrown away. Protect the people who are used a little more.The game is addicting it is easy to fight though.Say NO MORE! Rankoo-Karoon
The objectification of women is good business, so it will continue in the forms of advertisement and pornography especially, which is a multi billion$ industry. As long as money is whats most important, they couldn't care less about peoples lives and physical/mental health.
#2 Why not ban everything and give the modesty police control like in Saudi Arabia
To #1 Did you serve in the IDF ?
A better idea would be to add a disclosure in writing to every modified image - like they do in tobacco products (big letters) - such as "This commercial/photo has been visually modified and does not reflect reality". Much simpler and less costly.
and why not ban pornography for a distorded image of sexuality? it destroys relatiionships and families.
Images of models that have lied to avoid being drafted in the Israel Defense Forces should also be banned.