• Published 15:23 25.07.10
  • Latest update 15:23 25.07.10

Saudi clerics exempt women from wearing veils in France

French lawmakers passed a bill under which women could be fined for appearing in public with the all-covering burqa or the niqab.

By Reuters Tags: Israel news Saudi Arabia France Jews and Muslims Muslim

Two Saudi clerics have declared Muslim women are exempt from wearing full veils in France, which is planning to ban them, but added they should avoid visiting it as tourists.

Muslim woman wearing a veil

Muslim woman wearing a veil.

The comments, by Islamic jurisprudence scholar Mohamed al-Nujaimi and author and cleric Ayed al-Garni, come two weeks after French lawmakers passed a bill under which women could be fined for appearing in public with the all-covering burqa or the niqab, which leaves the eyes exposed.

"For a woman who permanently resides in France or is a French citizen, if there is harm in wearing the veil ... it is permitted that she shows her face when need and necessity demand it," Nujaimi said in remarks published by al-Watan newspaper.

Muslim scholars are divided over the veil, disagreeing on whether and how much of a woman's face should be covered. Saudi clerics widely recommend it.

The kingdom is ruled by the House of Saud in alliance with clerics from the austere Wahhabi school of Islam who oversee mosques, the judiciary and education and run their own coercive apparatus, the morals police.

Nujaimi and Garni are not members of the kingdom's official Senior Scholars Authority, which has not commented on the French parliament's decision.

Tourism

"Tourism to Western countries like France, while not forbidden, should be avoided in favor of Muslim countries where veils are allowed," the clerics said.

Every summer, tens of thousands of Saudi holidaymakers leave the kingdom and its searing heat to spend their vacation abroad, with many travelling to European countries.

"Tourism in a non-Muslim country is not indispensable, it is not needed, it is however allowed ... but we have a lot of touristic regions in our country and there are a lot of Muslim countries that do not ban the niqab," Nujaimi said.

Saudi Arabia is a major U.S. ally that has close trade and political ties with France, home to Western Europe's largest Muslim minority of almost 5 million. It is thought that only about 2,000 women wear the full-length veil in France.

The new law, which still has to be vetted by France's highest constitutional authority and approved by the Senate, could make France the second European country after Belgium to criminalize the veil.

Saudi King Abdullah postponed a visit to Paris that was scheduled to start one day before the French parliament voted on the ban, although Saudi officials did not link this postponement to the vote.

Comments by the two clerics come as the Louvre museum in Paris -- with the support of the Saudi government -- is displaying hundreds of artefacts from Saudi Arabia that have never been exhibited before, either at home nor abroad.

Among them are many pre-Islamic items. Exhibiting them in the kingdom would have triggered uproar from many clerics in the kingdom, who would see in it a revival of idolatry.
 

  • Print Page
  • Send to a friend
  • Share
  • Text Size +|-
 
 
TalkBacks

Why Facebook Connect?

Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.

Add a comment

Add your reply

  • 3. 0 0
    rigidity
    • arieh zimmerman
    • 25.07.10
    • 22:44

    I must admit that I am, pleasantly), surprised by the Saudi clerics' decision. My understanding of that nation in all its aspects is a result, almost solely, from what I read in the media. Thus a question has been opened in my mind. I would welcome any clarification than anyone wishes to add to this TalkBack.

  • 2. 0 0
    Rabbinical reasoning
    • Sherlock Holmes
    • 25.07.10
    • 18:56

    It's good to see that some Muslim scholars have the same common sense approach as traditional rabbonim in applying received customs to new circumstances. In the same way Jewish men worked out heterim for shaving without using a straight razor. There is some hope for Saudi after all!

  • 1. 0 0
    Reformed Islam?
    • Binyamin Dissen
    • 25.07.10
    • 15:50

    Or is the law not as claimed?