PA hits back at Ahmadinejad: You have no right to speak about Palestine
Palestinian Authority spokesman lashes out at the Iranian president who criticized Palestinian negotiations with Israel and PA President Mahmoud Abbas.
By Haaretz ServiceA Palestinian Authority spokesman lashed out at the president of Iran for criticizing Palestinian negotiations with Israel and PA President Mahmoud Abbas in particular, Ma'an News Agency reported on Sunday.
"The one who does not represent the Iranian people, who falsified election results, who oppressed the Iranian people and stole authority has no right to speak about Palestine, its president or its representatives," Abbas spokesman Nabil Abu Rudaineh said about Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.
|
Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas attending a PLO meeting in Ramallah on August 20, 2010. |
| Photo by: Reuters |
Ahmadinejad addressed a rally last week at Teheran University, where he dismissed the Israeli-Palestinian peace talks, saying the fate of Palestine would be decided in Palestine and through resistance and not in Washington.
The Ma'an News Agency reported that he also said Mahmoud Abbas was a hostage of Israel who lacked the legitimacy to negotiate on the Palestinian's behalf.
"President Mahmoud Abbas came to power through free, democratic and authentic elections supervised by more than 2,000 international and Arab monitors," Abu Rudaineh said in response. "We are the ones who fought for Palestine and Jerusalem ... the Palestinian leadership did not oppress its people as did the Iranian leadership under Ahmadinejad."
Last week, Egypt canceled a visit by Iran's foreign minister to protest comments he made accusing Arab leaders of betrayal for attending the new round of Mideast peace talks in Washington.
Iranian Foreign Minister Manouchehr Mottaki had been scheduled to visit Cairo for a meeting of Nonaligned Movement members.
"Some leaders ... who follow America's orders must understand that they are betraying their nations," Iran's Fars news agency quoted Mottaki as saying.
Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak and Jordanian King Abdullah II attended the talks.
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
Of course they don't have the right. Why are they asking for the creation of Arab country #23, the second in Palestine after Jordan and Gaza, and at the same time deny the Kurds their one and only country, under Iranian, Turkish, Syria and Iraq occupation?
PA shows signs of wanting peace. Ahmadinejad wants nothing less than apocalypse. I wish that the U.S. and Israel would assemble a coalition of the willing and defang Ahmadinejad and the mullahs to remove their nuclear aspirations.
Not 0only that, I also understand that you are against peace between Israel and the Palestinians, and that you also opose the very existence of the state of Israel. Thesre are the only logical conclusions to be drawn from your diatribe against Mahmoud Abbas.
Abbas position seems to be Israels liaison to the Palestinian people. The problem is that the Palestinian people have no leader. perhaps nobody has noticed this critical flaw in the peace talks.
You mean the Palestinian people have no leader that agree with your views. The moment there is a glimmer of hope for peace, you renounce that hope. Why? Because your true goal is the destruction of the State of Israel.
you oppose any peace agreement between Israel and the Palestinians that would be the result of compromise.
All praise belongs to the Almighty. Pray to Allah that this peace process should succeed and muslims, jews and chrisitians should live as brothers. I see the hand of messiah who has recently appeared on the world stage, the promised deliverer for the chosen state of israel and the entire humanity. I also pray that muslims will realise that israel belongs to the nation of prophet moses (may peace be on him) as mentioned in the Holy Quran. The formation of the state of israel is a sign of the end times according to the holy quran.
I thought the hamas was elected as well, yet the Abbas group does not want to acknowledge that little fact, therefore excluding half the palestinians from these negotiations. Funny how things only apply when they are in your favor and not your counterparts favor.
"The one who does (snip) has no right to speak about Palestine, its president or its representatives," Inaccurate. He cannot speak on behalf of or legitimately claim to represent, but he can surely comment. "...the Palestinian leadership did not oppress its people as did the Iranian leadership under Ahmadinejad." Although I have no hard evidence to offer the reports of corruption amongst the Fatah hierarchy seem never ending personally speaking I would find that very oppressive. Perhaps Mr Nabil Abu Rudaineh carried away by his rhetorical zeal simply forgot to be accurate in his choice of words, and let’s not forget Mr Abbas does not represent all of the Palestinian people. What do you think? I’m just curious.
the Lebanese government would jump on the bandwagon and make peac with Israel too. Imagine what a peaceful Lebanon, Israel and Palestinians State wold ddo for the people in this region - fantastic tourism, economic boom and prosperity for all Lebanese, Palestinians and Israelis. What can be bad about that?
Come on guys, give I'm a Dinner Jacket a break. If I was a little sawed off runt like him, I'd be pissed at the world too.
It's about time the Palestinians stood up for what is best for their people. There is a way to achieve independence and autonomy while their people can take advantage of the prosperity that peace will bring to Israelis and Palestinians. Countries like Syria, Iran, Saudi Arabia, etc... have been using the Palestinians to deflect attention from their own despotic and poor leadership. Kol Ha-Kavod Hamoodi!
And told all those who use the Pal plight as a means to maintain power to mind their own business
Most likely Abbas will not live to regret this or any other statement
Mr. Abbas has no other choise. He is more democratic than the system of radical islam of the Iran and the Hamas. In peace with Israel he can save his democratic system and keep away more and more the Hamas. On the other hand Israel wil be more occupied with the Hamas etc. House of King David, family of Avicenna (Ibn Sina) Maimonides etc.
Yes, wrongs were and are committed by both sides. But it is high-time for our peace-seeking majorities to stand up and take control of our own, and work together to achieve what we so badly desire. Shalom - Salaam.
Most Arabs are seriously worried about Iran. Iran are also hijacking the Palestinian problem. Its only a matter of time before the Arabs will seriously feel threatened by Iran in all sorts of issues.
do not worry about abbas statement, he is under too much pressure from US, because US aim is only securing the Israeli, not even thinking about our nation, Fatah, and Hamas are speaking the same language.all arab nations are aware of this US-led polt against Pa
do not worry about abbas statement, he is under too much pressure from US, because US aim is only securing the Israeli, not even thinking about our nation, Fatah, and Hamas are speaking the same language.all arab nations are aware of this US-led polt against Pa
I hope you are a tiny-minded tiny minority amongst your people. Leaders need to lead through courage and foresight. Mr. Abbas is finally showing some signs of this.
I sure hope Abbas didn't sign his death warrant with that statement , Im sure Iran will not be pleased considering that they currently sponsor Hamas/ Hizbulla with cash and military weapons etc.. But i have to say it is encouraging to hear Abbas tell Iran to keep its nose out of Palestinian affairs when we all know Iran's true agenda .. An assassination attempt at this point in time would look bad for Iran and the certain Palestinians who see these peace talks as threatening , Its also encouraging to see other Arab countries who want to get involved in these peace talks adding some backing and legitimacy , Lets hope that those palestinians(Iranian backed) who strongly oppose any type of peace with Israel these talks stay away from violence / provoking Israel and/ or Assassinate Abbas ... wich is highly plausible considering the deep Hatred they harbor towards Israel and jews ...
keep and build up the faith on all sides
I can say the same goes for you ... Hamas is the only legally and democratically elected government .... You have absolutely no legal right to represent the Palestinian people ... without consultation with hamas.
I wish you G-d speed on your final journey to live with Hamas. May you enjoy the rest of your days with them.
Abbas was elected too.Why do you hate the Palestinians so much
I am surprised to read about the PA's comments towards Iranian president AhMADinejad. Very good, I am pleased to see that PA wants to talk about peace in the region, whereas folks like AhMADinejad make no effort at all. Good luck to the peace makers. I pray peace will rule the ME, if not during our time, then for our future generations.
"President Mahmoud Abbas came to power through free, democratic and authentic elections supervised by more than 2,000 international and Arab monitors," What NAR doesn't say is that (1) Abbas' term has long ended but he manages to stay in power through political games, political oppression, and arrest of Palestinians who object to the direct negociations (2) Hamas won the elections yet Abbas manages to keep it out of the so-called government (3) Abbas is pleased with the fact that many Hamas legislators are in prison. ""We are the ones who fought for Palestine and Jerusalem ... the Palestinian leadership did not oppress its people". Yeh, sure! What is the PA doing for Palestine when it can't even keep its own offices open there? What have they done for the people who are being evicted from their homes? And what about the wave of arrest that took place just last week and the beating of demonstrators who were protesting the direct negociations? Nabil Abu Rudaineh might speak for Abbas, but he does not speak for Palestininas who are not on the PA payroll!
Well if Hamas is your voice expect the conditions of Gaza. If the PA is your voice expect the booming economy and eventual statehood.
The same and more can be said about Hamas. Elections should have occured last year. Hamas is a brutal, radical regime that would rather subjugate its people for another 60 years as refugees than to allow them to build a flourishing nation state.
This is one of the most encouraging statements i've heard from a Palestinian in a long time. It's nice to know that the Palestinians (the PA leadership, anyway) is increasingly offended by those who try to ride their coattails, to somehow claim and share in their victimhood... while doing little to actually help the average Palestinian, and simultaneously acting to make a just resolution less likely. Like Iran and it's proxies.