Ed Miliband prefers to avoid Israel
The newly elected Labour leader departs from the pro-Israel proclamations of previous British prime ministers.
By Anshel Pfeffer Tags: Britain British Jews Israel newsIt's difficult to find any kind of comment about Israel or the conflict in the Middle East in the past statements of the British Labour Party's new leader, Ed Miliband. If it's up to him, he'd rather prefer to keep it that way.
The party's last two prime ministers, Tony Blair and Gordon Brown, frequently mentioned their enthusiastic support of Israel. According to several political commentators, Blair's support of Israel during the Second Lebanon War, against the wishes of the majority of the Labour party, brought about the end of his residency at 10 Downing Street.
|
Britain's opposition Labour Party leader Ed Miliband greets his brother David Miliband, September 27, 2010. |
| Photo by: Reuters |
Brown, for his part, had already managed to bore the Jewish community with incessant stories of his father, a Zionist Christian minister, who would travel to Israel in the 1950s and 1960s and show him films of the trips upon his return.
The situation in London today is completely different. British Prime Minister David Cameron, ostensibly a member of the Conservative Friends of Israel, has already managed to anger the Israel lobby in the U.K. when he called Gaza a "concentration camp" during a visit to Ankara. He has also not yet followed through on his pledge to change the law that allows Israeli military officials to be handed indictments for war crimes as they touch down at Heathrow Airport in London.
Britain has undergone a revolution since the Blair era, when it was the Bush administration's closest and most loyal partner in its military maneuvers and diplomatic actions in the Middle East.
Barack Obama is not seeking the confidence of his counterpart on the other side of the Atlantic. In any case, what most concerns Britons right now is their economy, which is struggling to come out of recession, and their massive budget deficit.
Since British soldiers left Iraq at the beginning of the year, the Middle East has dropped out of the headlines. The new Labour leader that aspires to return to power will not waste his time on foreign policy.
Ed Miliband's campaign focused on economic and social issues, but friends of Israel are suspicious of the opinions of the Labour Party's first Jewish leader. He and his brother David - who vied with him for the party leadership - grew up in a home that was not Zionist. The Milibands' late father was a known Marxist and their mother, who is still alive, is a member of a pro-Palestinian organization. Both siblings are self-proclaimed atheists, they did not participate in Jewish community activities in their youth, and their partners are not Jewish.
David - the elder brother - has made relatively friendly statements regarding Israel in the last two years, has visited Israel, and has participated in Jewish community events. But these were part of his ministerial duties as foreign secretary under the Brown government, and it is not known if this reflects his actual personal opinions.
Ed Miliband also raised suspicions when refused to fire an important campaign worker who had participated in anti-Israel activity in the past. The fact that he was elected with the help of the unions, most of whose members support a boycott of Israel, confirms that at least in regards to support for Israel, the Blair-Brown era is definitely over.
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
Hopefully he will never become Prime Minister,he would be a burden for Israel.
A couple of corrections. 1) Edward Miliband was chosen by an electoral college consisting of Labour MPs, Labour party members and members of trade unions, not the trade unions themselves. 2) Israel is a small country 3,500 km from Britain. Most trade union members neither know nor care much about it, any more than most Israelis know or care about Wales, which is about the same size as Israel. Why should the Milibands be interested in Israel? As British politicians they should be promoting the interests of Britain. I can't think of any Israeli politicians who are interested in any country but Israel, so why expect the Milibands to be concerned about a foreign country that is not particularly important to British interests? Finally, it may be the Milibands appreciate that as members of a minority group in Britain they still have a real chance of become prime minister, unlike the minorities in Israel.
The thing about Ed is he doesn't want to offend anyone. He is outspoken about social causes but no one knows what his international political beliefs are. I would consider voting for him, but what do I know, I voted three times for Blair.
& his trade union power base is a turnabout not just for Brit.- Israel relations but a great leap backward for Britain
His a Jew don worry Born in London, Miliband is the son of Polish Jewish immigrants Marion Kozak and the late Marxist intellectual Ralph Miliband (a Brussels native whose parents were from Warsaw), who fled Belgium during World War II.[1] As a teenager, he reviewed films and plays on LBC Radio's Young London programme as one of its "Three O'Clock Reviewers", and worked as an intern to Tony Benn.[2] (WIKIK PEIDA)