Alleged Mossad spy granted bail in Germany, 'can return to Israel if he wants'

In which case was Mr Mobhouh not entitled to the same treatment as Mr Brodsky?

germany was the only country to issue an actual international warrant against an alleged agent, if indeed he is an agent. germany had to back down from charges of espionage since poland would not extredite on such charge. poland is not beholden to germany.

please tell us why

"Germany is the last Western country to dare offend Israel, and rightly so." - Logios Germany requested Extradition of a criminal suspect. Poland agreed and delivered the suspect. Germany treated the minor passport violation as it would have in anyone else, it allowed bail and suggested the culprit prove his crime by fleeing. Where did German not act in it's own interest?

Aaaah.....mmmm....well....ehm!.....you know.... ghrrr ...errrr....ehm!.... OK. We do it too. Happy now?

When you have no solid arguments to refute what someone writes, you call it names or discredit its accuracy. Most people outgrow this behaviour by the time they're 10 but not the apologists for the Islamic fundamentalists.

So does England who helps Russian spys get forged passports to the USA

Israel gives medals to those who fight against those movements that would take away your rights as a woman, would cover you from head to toe, and would execute you if you so much as spoke to a man other than your husband. Wake up and smell the coffee. You're free because of countries like Israel, not Iran.

Even have freedom for its own women Gilles.

you don't know much about common, roman, and international law, right? and where exactly is the connection hidden between german legislative & german judiciary in this case?

...is a valid question :(((

once you start killing people it never stops. I can't beleive Gran, that you actualy wrote this remark.

israel is not considered to be part of the "club." indeed, israel is considered to be a state somewhat appart.

Best Regards, S

Russia gave up some people the US wanted out. And contrary to Cipora and S, Israel never offers the US anything in trade. The government 'Friendship' is a one-way street.

so he will pay some bucks and its ok...

No, you just send back people implementing extra-judicial killings in the name of germans back so that they can continue doing their form of justice and "death penalties". But G_d forbid they get the same treatment...

...that killers are just killers ! Preparing an assassination by faking a german passport usually should be considered a major crime. As a german I feel ashamed !

Where in the judges statement does he somehow support "terrorist hunters" jamor? Might be time to clean those milk bottle thick glasses of yours mate!...and yeah, we get it, you and many like you support extra judicial killings.A fine moral person you are indeed. The question is, as always, who might they come for next...next...and in the end?

mumbling something about extra judicial killing?So what he was killed do you regret he won't kill anymore?What kind of morality do you have if you protect a murderer instead of murdered? Who tried Kurds that Turkey kills them almost on a daily basis Mr.Moralist? Shame on you for trying to make terrorists untouchable by using principles of democracy to protect and save their lives.

it was a help for murder and so it should be punished.

Moral standards, eternal values and civil rights apply to every human being. That’s the base of west-european democracies - and I am happy to live in one of these states. If you refuse these rights to anyone your own rights might be in utmost peril. Murderers must be prosecuted by law, not by Israeli killing squads. If those standards don’t apply to Israel till today they should be installed.

When governments take too much time to do the right thing when it comes to terrorists, thank God there is the Mossad... an eye for an eye... those who mess with Israel are on notice... no bad deed goes unanswered

and in fact protect murderers instead of their victims. Following your theory all terrorists have to do after killing is to go to a country they know won't extradite them and use it as a sanctuary after each new attack.How leftist to use humanitarian laws to chain government's hands so it cannot defend people against terrorists! What's the difference between you and them?

For his part in helping to obtain fake passport, he will pay a fine and possibly spend a couple of months in jail. This is how it should be. This will send a clear message to Mossad that next time they will have to be more careful. We are all grateful for the work Mossad does for all freedom loving people, just be more careful next time, that's all.

You very obviously have no clue what the Mossad is doing...

This is simply a precedent between friends. Germany has no reason to damage Israel (like you wish they did) in its fight against terror. Regards!

For sure I have a clue what the Mossad did in Dubai. They did the right thing by killing a Hamas commander for committing many violent attacks on civilians. Of course, I don't like the method the Mossad used, but it is the lesser of many evils. Hamas terror shall not go unpunished.

Most policeman who prevent violent crimes, whatever their methods, are generally thought of as heros. Besides, maybe the evidence presented was was weak?

If Germany had no intention to define the new terms of the relationship S, then why did it demand extradition. Germany and Poland have BOTH sent a very clear message. Don't embarrass us again by breaking our laws.

And I was alive back then. I thought Germany made a deal that fit it's needs, but was wrong. I do not think Germany did anything wrong, and this deal fits it's needs. American CIA agents were convicted in Crypto-Fascist Italy a few years back. Israel has been served notice by many nations that it will no longer be able to engage in criminal activity involving those nations with impunity. Germany and Poland have sent a message. A simple message. Keep your crimes off our turf.

I only meant that that the Germans did the best under the circumstances - to do good, instead of what others would have preferred - make a BIG STINK out of it. Like Turkey....and so many others....here on the talkback. AND LOOK HOW MANY THUMBS UP YOU GOT!

Germany maliciously bought suspects freedom. They are party to the offence. Shameful episode.

If he does not come back for his trial he will never be able to travel to Europe again in his life. I doubt he wants to spend the rest of his days locked in Israel.

we have the United States, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and India. Wide open spaces to visit and enjoy.

... he will come back to Europe on a FORGED PASSPORT ... ha ha ha !!!

I wouldn't want to spend the rest of my days unlocked in Israel.

Lol Esther I think I can hear you ! you're shouting so loud. As to what you are actually saying,...erm... what are you saying ? I can't really make it out. If I didn't know any better, I would have said you come across like an ignorant, backward fanatic. thank you

We all know who the other Esther is. But what angers you is that she's happy Germany released Brodski. (Which, by the way, I am happy too). C'est la vie..... notre vie....Best regards, S

you know, the same ones that distribute sweets and scream out "god is great", no offence to the muslims or good jews here.

To your question: if found guilty Brodsky would have to pay a few hundred, maybay thousand €s fine. Giving that fact, Brodsky is a "free" man -- the bail he had to pay seems to be enough in case of a conviction.

Israel and Germany have an extradition treaty, meaning that it will be a blemish on Israels record if they allow him to leave/disappear. Also, I believe that this could allow him to do his jail sentence in Israel were he convicted. Two important facts that everyone seems to miss though. This guy isn't guilty of killing a member of Hamas. He is accused, but based on at best circumstantial evidence. So far, the most damning evidence is fake ID. In all developped countries, we cannot try someone based on circumstantial evidence. Second important fact is that if he really is a spy, this may be the last we hear of this. When was the last time we saw a spy tried in public court. There is always some kind of backdoor dealing that allows them to slip free. I guess they know too much to be allowed public forum.

Whenever has a blemish on Israels record ever bothered them?