• Published 00:00 01.06.07
  • Latest update 00:00 01.06.07

IDF officer resigns, says division's failure in Lebanon was his fault

Commander is second to step down due to crticism of performance in Lebanon, says IDF not to blame.

By Amos Harel

Brigadier General Erez Zuckerman announced Thursday that he is resigning from the Israel Defense Forces due to his failure as a commander during the Second Lebanon War.

"Even during the final days of the war, I felt I had failed in my role as division commander and I decided to take personal responsibility for my failure," he told Haaretz on Thursday.

"However, I felt if I resigned immediately after the war, it would be evading my duty to restore order and train the division properly," he said. "After almost a year of work, I am convinced my division is capable of handling any mission given it."

"I am certain that the IDF will succeed in the face of all future challenges under the leadership of its senior commanders," Zuckerman said.

"I blame no one but myself for the way I led the division during the war."

Zuckerman, 43, spent most of his military service as a marine commando and as first officer of an elite combat unit where he earned a reputation for bravery and talent.

When the Second Lebanon War broke out, he pressured the IDF to call the Pillar of Fire reservist Armored Corps division for duty, and allow him to lead it. "If I had just sat quietly, I would have continued to rise through the ranks after the war," he said.

Zuckerman had never had any Armored Corps training and was not given any before being assigned to the tank unit and sent to fight in July last year.

In February, Zuckerman and several other commanders underwent weeks of training at an army base in the Negev, seven months after the war had finished, as part of the IDF's bid to implement the lessons learned in the conflict with regards to training its senior staff.

Severe criticism of Zuckerman's performance in Lebanon led him to consider resigning several times, and he had discussed this with his seniors since last October. However despite findings against him, then Chief-of-Staff Dan Halutz elected he should remain in his post for a third year.

He made the decision to resign last week and met with current Chief-of-Staff, Gabi Ashkenazi, who commended him on his long service and accepted his resignation.

In December, former division commander Brigadier General Gal Hirsch also left his post after the investigations of an army-appointed panel found him responsible for the cross-border abduction of two IDF soldiers which was a major cause of the Second Lebanon War.

  • Print Page
  • Send to a friend
  • Share
  • Text Size +|-
 
 
TalkBacks

Why Facebook Connect?

Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.

Add a comment

Add your reply

  • 6. 0 0
    natalie durson
    • aisha
    • 01.06.07
    • 17:51

    "a trained and dedicated force" says durson of the hizb. then why did they lose 800 men in combat to israel's 115?

  • 5. 0 0
    He should be PM
    • Yehuda
    • 01.06.07
    • 17:36

  • 4. 0 0
    here is a soldier with honor
    • Jacob
    • 01.06.07
    • 16:49

    Zuckerman deserves commendation for doing the right thing under difficult circumstances. If only certain politicians would follow suit.

  • 3. 0 0
    Three Americans Kidnapped, No Resignations.
    • Dave Levy
    • 01.06.07
    • 16:45

    After reading excerps from the Winograd Commission report on the Internet, I am more confused than ever about why Israel did not achieve a total victory over Hezbollah (their destruction). They pointed the blame at communication problems between the leaders of Israel and subordinates. Well maybe. However, Israel's democracy has everyone embedded in everyone else's responsibility. When a quick decision has to be made (hitting Hezbollah back hard and maybe getting the kidnapped soldier back), too many cooks spoil the broth. The real question should be, considering Hezbollah's fortifications, did the IDF use the best military tactics possible under the circumstances, and HOW MUCH DID AMERICAN PRESSURE AND UN PRESSURE play in these military decisions? Was Condi controlling the IDF from afar. What was said between Condi (Bush) and Olmert, if anything? 3 American soldiers were kidnapped and thousands of GIs searched for them, to no avail. One of the kidnapped was found dead. So?

  • 2. 0 0
    Not His Fault
    • Natallie Durson
    • 01.06.07
    • 15:43

    It would have happened to anybody. The entire IDF was sloppy and over confident in spite of the fact that hardly any IDF members had ever actually seen combat against a trained and dedicated paramilitary group. The IDF failures in Lebanon awakened Israel to some of their weaknesses, but the entire world also took note that the IDF is much less fearsome than expected.

  • 1. 0 0
    CEO of Nokia would be great as a CEO of BP,not so in the
    • Absolute Sweden
    • 01.06.07
    • 15:25

    military,armored corps isn't Marine Commando unit. Not so strange the apparatchiks leading Israel have thought an officer was an officer ,no matter of speciality. Kudos to Gen.Zukerman for his sincerity.