IDF colonel sentenced to 6 years in jail for raping female soldier
Ataf Zahar must pay rape victim NIS 35,000 in compensation, gets demoted to lowest rank of private.
By Haaretz Service and Yuval AzoulayAn Israel Defense Forces colonel was sentenced Friday to six years in jail for raping a female soldier under his command.
The military appeals court at the Kirya military headquarters in Tel Aviv also ruled that Colonel Ataf Zahar must pay the woman NIS 35,000 in compensation, and busted Zahar down to the rank of private.
Zahar was convicted of the rape in July.
"Ataf coarsely trampled the complainant's body, transformed her into a sexual object, and made black use of her innocence to satisfy his sexual urges," the judges ruled.
The court rejected Zahar's request for permission to appeal to the Supreme Court.
|
IDF Colonel Ataf Zahar (Motti Kimche) |
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
If he had only been at least a general...
Why is this big news ? everyone knows this is very common in the Israeli military and especially amongst government officials.
When I was in the Israeli army in the early seventies nearly every senior officer had an eighteen year old soldier girl in his jeep. Moshe Dayan was a legendary predator of his soldier's wives and General Yitzik Mordecai turned it into an art form. In fact Tel Nof was known as "The Brothel". Now the President is up for indictment and the Justice Minister is in the dock. Such is life.
Hey Colin Wrong, 4 life sentences were not just handed down to a Jewish terrorist for killing 4 Palestinians, were they? It must be my imagination. Here's a little tip: The use of sarcasm goes best with a little intellect. Otherwise it just sounds ridiculous.
Remember the Jewish terrorist Asher Weisgan who got 4 life sentences + 12 years a couple days ago. That's not what the naysayers where predicting.
Evil human response (or inhuman response) is suggested not by the accused and convicted, but by the grins on the faces of the men behind the accused. I can't understand it! Amazing evil! if it is as it appears to be--indifference to this suffering defendant,and his ruined future.
Your response to clickfool, made me curious, so I did a search on druse, then i went back and observed the picture of the idf colonel and noticed that the men behind him laughing. So was this man set up for being a druse? Estimates of their total numbers range from a half million to one million. One source states that the approximate population of Druze in 1987 was: Lebanon: 325,000. Syria: 245,000. Jordan: 10,000. Palestine: 65,000. Other Arab Countries: about 40,000. Elsewhere: about 70,000. Total: about 755,000. According to Wikipedia: "The religion developed out of Ismaili Islam, a philosophical movement based in the Fatimid Caliphate, in the 10th century, a time of particular cultural wealth. The religion did not attempt to reform mainstream Islam but to create a whole new religious body influenced by Greek philosophy, Gnosticism and Christianity, among others. The main actors were Tariq al-Hakīm (meaning Ruler), also known as al-Hakīm bi-Amr Allah or Ruler in the Name of God, and Hamza ibn-'Ali ibn-Ahmad, the main architect of the movement. It was Hamza who first publicly proclaimed that Hakīm was the Ruler in the Name of God. Hakīm was opposed by mainstream Muslims for what was considered apostasy....The Druze believe that Hakīm disappeared and will return in the end of days. Because the Druze considered Tariq al-Hakīm to be the incarnation of God, they were persecuted by mainstream Muslims, especially after Hakīm's death in 1021. The Druze took up taqiyya ("dissimulation"), a practice whereby they conceal their true beliefs and outwardly accept the religious beliefs of those amongst whom they live, even as they secretly retained their true convictions.
of course the palestines MADE him to it i guess
Stop being paranoid. Your sense of second class citizenship is entirely self fulfilling. The article does not indicate the colonel is not jewish, to any outsider reading it the assumption would be made that he was in fact jewish.
I am not surprised. The U.S. military is plagued by the same mess: rapes (sigh). That just goes to show you, sin and wickedness doesn't just haunt the Israelis. It haunts us all.
They should execute rapists.
'This guy goes to jail because he wasn`t as high-ranking as Itzik Mordechai. Nevertheless, it`s a step in the right direction!' Maybe it's because he wasn't as Jewish as Itzik Morechai. It does seem that whenever the hammer drops, it's always on a Druse or a Bedioun or something. Possible that they're the ones committing all the crimes, of course.
Glad to hear it has already stopped everywhere else in the world.
Glad to hear it has already stopped everywhere else in the world.
when is israel and the west going to learn that putting superiors and subordinates in the position of supervising or being subordinate to others of the same sex in military situations only creates fertile ground for these types of abuses? in no way is this a defense for the colonel - if he is guilty, even 6 years is not enough. but at the same time we must acknowledge the human condition and create fences for ourselves - particularly in military environments
Let he who hasn't wished he was in a position of authority cast the first stone. Kennedy, Johnson & many others have attained prominence in this field. Poor Katsav seems to have gotten caught, or else the plaintiff's were looking for either revenge or compensation of services performed. If convicted, Sharia law should be applied to the offending part. No sword necessary, a Mohel's knife will suffice. All others who have done likewise, take a number and stand in line, you're next.
You must to be talking from personal experience.
This is definately NOT my writing. It is vulgar in the extreme. However, this animal deserves all that is coming his way.
I am not waiting for the person that will turn this around and blame the victim, saying ,"Well, maybe she asked for it?" I am not going to wait around for that idiot to respond. Goodby.
why just look who! Mr C. Fool as ALWAYS! I ask again Lasse were you a Mitnadev on Kibbutz Yizrael in 73/4???
& thank you Nechamia, glad to have helped you smile We all need it every now & again. Were you also in the HabKlub (HABONIM)? & if so what years? BTW How'd you land up in California?
Its Army Jail, its not like the regular ones..
At least he stays on the IDF payroll and won't lose his pension.
That requested congical visits with the Judge's wife? LOL, I am so happy this coward is in jail. Now GET TO WORK PRIVATE!
The only punishment to fit this crime is "Castration"
There are rape cases in all countries, even in closed societies where sex is banned. It's terrible and sad. Who was eager to throw the first stone?
Rape is the most cowardly crime a man can commit against a women. In Italy rape is no longer punishable with a jail sentence,you mereley get a police record,as you can immagine rapes have increased. For most rape victims,it is worse than death,they have to live with it for the rest of their lives.
love Haaretz editors, they have no idea what theyre printing. thanks for the laughs.
This Colonel's behavior is a blemish on the IDF. His ethnicity would not be valid if Israel's enemy did not use it to slander Jews. However his name his Arabic and he is a Druse. Regardless of Ethnicity his behavior is vile na and he should be punished severely. There is no room for this ANYWHERE in any Army or in any circumstance. Violence against women must end world wide or humanity will never advance. I hope they throw the book at him.
This guy goes to jail because he wasn't as high-ranking as Itzik Mordechai. Nevertheless, it's a step in the right direction!
Okay, six years (could be longer but it will have to do), busted down to private, to be expected. If he is not to be thrown out the army then what they should also do is once he has finished his six years make him continue to serve out his time in the army as a private. Under female corporals and sergeants!
Certainly sounds like it. So what were you inside for?
You're insulting me, Yonatan. I think rape, by anyone of any religion, is one of the filthiest crimes on the planet. Rape is about the abuse of power, and it destroys lives.
Finally, justice has taken its course. The officer's ethnic background is irrelevant, and all responses referring to it detract from the crime committed. I sincerely hope that this ruling will encourage other women to step forward and not be trampled on as this young was. I find it disturbing that many of the other charges were dropped and that the rapist does not start serving his sentence for another month, leaving the victim "jailed" in her home with fear.
This new is already there in French (worth having a look, even if you don't speak the language, the humoristic image says it all !) : http://www.mercure5s5i.com/lenouveaumonde/article.php?art=1124
she is not the first and last rape victim in the IDF.
Let's hope he enjoyed these few minutes. He will have time to think about it now ! lol
Well... I should say that may be a Druze does NOT need to bend to take the soap ! Cheers and smile ! :))
if you had known that he isn't Jewish, but Druse?
Now in jail, this dirty sod should beware the prison showers, and take the greatest care next time he bends down to pick up the soap.