Hezbollah vs. Israel: Who has 'real' video of Lebanon blast site?

When Israel can explain how its drones can legally be over Lebanon, we can ask Hezbollah what it is doing with what appear to be weapons. Generally, if one country violates the territory of another, the issue is not what they find, but the violation itself.

The Hezbollah footage and Israeli footage are completely different and ARE NOT showing the same thing by any stretch of the imagination. In the Israeli footage, Hezbollah is clearly walking an elongated white object from one location onto a truck. They ARE NOT loading it from an adjacent platform onto a truck. This footage is of two completely different events in the first place. They in no way resemble one another. Where is Hezbollah's footage of the elongated object being WALKED from one location onto the truck?

In easy operated hand held digital cameras in every phone. Media has taken a new turn into the future, you tube has footage of many many Israeli human rights violations reported by Betsalem the Israeli human right organization. Yes Hizbo has weapons stocked up in south Lebanon but where are those weapons. that proves that hizbo did not only win the military war against Israel but they won the intelligence and propaganda war laced with a physiological factor and this video is witness with that, give us peace why does Israel want to wage war. falafel Taza

Lets assume you are correct and Hez recorded the removal of garbage becuase they thought they would be accused of doing wrong. Was this the only garbage pick up being filmed? Release other video taken the same day of garbage removal. Get real, some film school student was hired to recreated a garbage pickup scene to match what IAF filmed from the sky.

Read the comments, then watched the clip, and will now propose answers to some of the questions and comments. Why film the removal of debris? Well, if I had a pretty good idea that I was going to be accused of doing something nefarious when I was in fact doing something innocuous, you can be sure I'd make as good a record as I could of what I was doing. As for the sound quality, I've done sound work in studio and from live recordings. They've cleaned up the sound through the use of filters and an equalizer (I think they boasted the high end a little more than I would have, but then again I hear a little more in that range than most), but unless they have some foley artists who put the pro's to shame, that was live sound.

After the last explosion I think Hezbollah knew Israel would try the PR game with this one and they were ready. The only thing these videos show is that bothsides play abit loose with the rules. I think Israel is more worried about Hezbollah right now than Iran, since it would need to be weaken before any attack on Iran. The UN may want to increase it forces soon or start pulling them out. I surprised that they are not shooting down the drones, the US already has a system to quickly bring them down, I sure Russia has one or soon will.

Those people record everything you can imagine.

That wasn't just any garage door! It was a newly fabricated state of the art Al Aqhbar-7 garage door designed by the famed American artist Jesse Yousef Jackson inscribed with numerous statements from the renowned Muslim Imam Jimmy ibn Carter and inscribed with pictures of hundreds of virgin volunteers for the Shaheeds. It is fully automated with an IP link allowing the Ayatollahs perpetual access as proscribed by abu Goldstone. It is a valuable piece of art. OF COURSE they would tape it. It is a remarkable piece of Islamic art in the making. Apologize now!

Speaking as both an actor in both film and theater, I must complement them on their sound it is almost as if the microphone is right next to the truck... quite an achivment considering the distance that the camera is place, this can only mean that either they have planted a boom mike/directional mic in the area (not likly to film the removal of a garage door) or this whole film is staged, not to mension that the actors/personal seem to be a bit rehersed. Overall looking at this clip I can only conclude it was staged and badly at that, my prof. would only give this a 70 and that would be if he was in a merciful mood Bad acting guys, try again and make it real

depends on whose side you are on. Personally I believe they are both probably faked. As I am not an expert in interpreting military survelliance videos, and was not present when Hezbollah videoed their version of events. What we are seeing is a propaganda war in which Israel is trying to get Unifil to be more proactive and Hezbollah are trying to reassure UNIFIL that there is nothing untoward going on. Very entertaining though.

lol i guess there were some budget cuts in Hezbollah, and maybe they needed to get some contracts on the side to compensate, either that or this explosion had def. something to do with them.

I think what peeves Israel the most is that they're being played at their own game. This one is called "anything you can fake, I can fake better." And, also in true Israeli style, the attention is now deflected away from the real issue. Instead of discussing the weapons, the debate now centers on who has the real video. I think this round goes to Hezbollah.

they should have tagged the door and next time a door land in haifa israel should say to the world aha aha we told you so any way doors can be transformed into missiles but the leak if you get my drift

Israels never ending war and the need for spy,s and surveillance will subjugate us all! This "war" on terror are the last nails in the coffin for any possibility of real freedom that following generations will pay the price and have to live under. ....who new Israel would be the scientific testing grounds for the future 1984?

This staged video undermines the "Hezbollah Story" and in no way refutes the Israeli video.

Israel made it look as if UNRWA trucks were used for rockets... as to get rid of its then head, angry for his telling truth about Israeli crimes.

a drone where it allegedly showed Hamas members moving rockets into a truck. then the IDF bombed them. B'Tselem later showed the site where it was actually bottled gas warehouse and those people were killed for false positive and misinterpretation of the footage. go to B'Tselem's page and see for yourself

The battle is surely lost! If Israel is battling terrorists who have enough money, not only to film their rubbish collectors, but also to give them uniforms, then we really are in trouble. What puzzles me is why they are in army fatigues? Must have got them from a local army surplus store!

What possible reason could some random Lebanese have to set up a video camera to record people moving rubbish on to a truck?

Rest assured that Silvienne, etc will believe the Hezbollah video.

Hilarious! Complain to the UN that Israel is keeping an eye on them.. yeah, and for no reason at all as we can see.. Twist it 180 degrees and the UN has already lost eye for the truth.

How ridiculous that people would belive hiz's film clip