Hamas, PRC say will act to torpedo new U.S. benchmarks for Israel, PA
PLO Executive Committee to review U.S. timeline for Israel, PA action on Saturday; Meshal: Document is a farce.
By Avi Issacharoff and Aluf Benn Haaretz Service, AgenciesA Hamas spokesman in Gaza said Saturday the group rejects a new U.S. benchmark document detailing actions for both Israel and the Palestinian Authority to implement in the coming months.
"The American plan is rejected and we will work to make it fail by any means and by all means," said Fawzi Baroum, a Hamas spokesman in Gaza, echoing comments by Hamas' political leader Khaled Meshal.
The militant group Popular Resistance Committees also rejected the document. "The U.S. plan does not serve our people's interests," said PRC spokesman Abu Abeer on Saturday, vowing that "the [PRC] will work to make it fail."
The Damascus-based leader is the main powerbroker in Hamas.
The document, recently submitted to Israel and the Palestinians, calls on Israel to remove many West Bank roadblocks and improve operations at Gaza's crossings.
The Palestinians are asked to halt rocket fire from Gaza and weapons smuggling into the coastal strip.
Meshal told a rally in Syria on Friday that the Palestinians should not agree to halt rocket fire in exchange for an easing of travel restrictions.
"I swear it's a farce ... the equation has now become: dismantling the checkpoints, in exchange for [giving up] resistance," he said in comments carried by Al-Jazeera. "This has become the Palestinian cause."
Israel said Meshal's comments show the true nature of the group. "We never had any illusions as to the policies and goals of the Hamas and unfortunately his remarks do not come as a surprise," Foreign Ministry spokesman Mark Regev said.
Chief Palestine Liberation Organization negotiator Saeb Erekat said however that the document was reviewed by the PLO Executive Committee, a top decision-making body, on Saturday.
Erekat said the Palestinians welcomed the timeline as the only way to translate words into action, but did not formally adopt the document in light of Israeli reservations.
Instead, the Palestinians would ask the Quartet of Mideast mediators - the U.S., the UN, the European Union and Russia - to deal with implementation, he said.
On Sunday, PA Chairman Mahmoud Abbas was to head to Gaza to brief Palestinian Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh of Hamas on the benchmarks.
U.S. official: Benchmarks won't be imposed on Israel, PA
Deputy U.S. State Department spokesman Tom Casey said Friday that the United States would not impose the demands listed in the document on either side.
He also said that there are no deadlines for taking the recommended actions.
"These are suggestions and ideas that we have circulated, it's not any kind of formal agreement nor is it something that is being enforced on anybody," he told reporters.
"There is no effort to try and say 'Next week, you'll do this, the week after that, you'll do that,'" Casey said. "The idea would be to do these in fairly quick order, though."
He said the measures are related to implementing phase one of the road map peace plan for the region.
The timeline, meant to bolster Israeli-Palestinian talks, met its first resistance on Friday when Prime Minister Ehud Olmert's office said it could not commit to some of the demands, citing security concerns.
The officials raised concerns Israel was being asked to ease restrictions on Palestinian movements without assurances that Abbas has completed his own commitments on security.
While Israel appeared prepared to lift restrictions in the West Bank starting in mid-May, it has serious reservations about other demands, including one that would allow Palestinian bus convoys to travel between Gaza and the West Bank by July 1, officials said.
"Some of the ideas Israel is already implementing, others are already well advanced, and there are some that Israel will not be able to address in the present because of security concerns," an official in Olmert's office said.
Israeli resistance to elements of the U.S. plan followed an earlier rift between the close allies over Washington's decision to hold limited contacts with non-Hamas ministers in a Palestinian unity government
Senior officials had feared a confrontation with Washington over the document of benchmarks it presented to Israel and the PA setting a detailed timetable for measures each side must implement.
The document sets a schedule for removing roadblocks and opening passages in the territories and upgrading the Palestinian forces loyal to Abbas. Israel is also urged to approve requests for weapons, munitions and equipment required by defense forces loyal to Abbas.
U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice is to arrive on May 15 to discuss implementing the plan.
Officials in the defense establishment object to several issues in the document, especially the demand to expand the operation of the passages in the Gaza Strip and the removal of many roadblocks in the West Bank.
These officials believe that the benchmarks involve security risks.
Israel has not responded officially to the document and an inter-ministerial discussion on it was postponed on Thursday.
The Prime Minister's Bureau is still waiting for the positions of the defense establishment, Foreign Ministry and Shin Bet vis-a-vis on the plan.
The document, which Haaretz has obtained, sets a rigid timetable for implementing measures on either side.
The document was written by the U.S. security coordinator, Major General Keith Dayton, U.S. Ambassador to Israel Dick Jones and U.S. Consul-General in Jerusalem Jacob Walles.
It was sent to Washington, where it was approved by Secretary of State Rice before it was presented to Israel and the PA. However, both Israel and the PA's official answer to the document is still pending.
Palestinian sources told Haaretz that the PA has accepted the document, but it fears that Prime Minister Ehud Olmert will sabotage the turning of it into an agreement due to his precarious political situation.
If both sides accept the document it will become a binding agreement.
Rice was scheduled to arrive in mid-May to obtain both sides' approval of the document, but her visit may be postponed in view of the political situation in Israel.
Benchmarks include ongoing assistance to Abbas' forces
The document demands, among other things, that Israel approve and support in an "immediate and ongoing" manner the requests of U.S. security coordinator Dayton for the provision of required armaments, ammunition and equipment for security forces under the control of and reporting to the PA chairman in the West Bank and Gaza.
Each clause is accompanied by a precise timetable for implementation. For example, Israel and the PA are required to establish, no later than July 1, 2007, a bus convoy service operating five days a week between the Erez checkpoint at the entrance to the Gaza Strip and the Tarqumiya roadblock at the entrance to Hebron for passengers from Gaza and the West Bank.
Israel is required to remove specific roadblocks and other traffic and movement restrictions in the West Bank at specified dates. For example, Israel must remove restrictions and provide access no later than June 1, 2007 in the Bethlehem 1 and 2 clusters, in the Hebron clusters 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8, in Nablus clusters 1, 2, 3 and 4 and in the Tubas 1 cluster.
It must remove roadblocks in the Nablus area and specifically the ones in Beit Iba, Hawara, Awarta, Shavei Shmoron and Beit Foriq no later than June 15.
However, the timetable in the document is not entirely relevant as the measures in it were scheduled to begin on May 1.
Rice agreed on formulating the document during her last visit in Israel and the PA. The Palestinians received the document last Wednesday, April 25. Senior Palestinian sources told Haaretz that the PA accepts its principles, although the PA has not given Washington an official answer yet.
The PA and mainly its defense forces and national security adviser Mohammed Dahlan are required to take a series of clear steps, limited by a timetable.
Dahlan is required to develop a plan against Qassam rockets with the support of Abbas no later than June 21, 2007. The president must deploy these forces no later than that date.
The Palestinian forces are required to act to prevent arms smuggling in the Rafah area in coordination with Israel.
Abbas and Dahlan must subject the defense forces to the PA chairman by June 15.
Both Israel and the Palestinians are required to reestablish the coordination and liaison headquarters in the West Bank.
Meanwhile, Israel is discussing with the European Union the extension of the European observers' mandate at the Rafah passage. The posting of observers enabled Israel's withdrawal from the Philadelphi route and the opening of the passage between Gaza and Egypt.
|
U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice shaking hands with Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas during their meeting in Amman, Jordan in March. (AP) |
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
"Jews and Arabs lived together for many years without problems." Where, when? Point to where I said that. There's been a history of Arab on Jew violence since Mohamed slaughtered the Jews of Medina. "cause", I quoted that: The current violence has been caused by Arab declarations of war. Notice that you can't accept that -- or even address it. "ousted"? When? Where? By Whom? War was declared by Arabs, Arabs and Jews fled. That's part of war. That you focus on 472,000 Arabs rather than the 50 million refugees worldwide during the same period -- all absorbed and none w/RoR -- is clear and bigoted. "dubious land claim from thousands of years ago"? Really? So why do Ottoman and Brit records show Jewish majority in Jerusalem and massive sales of land by Arabs to Jews in the 19th and 20th centuries? On Brit official even recorded that the only thing slowing Jewish purchases was lack of money to buy all the Arabs offered. So much you can't address because it would rip apart your fantasies
Read your post. Jews and Arabs lived together for many years without problems. You address the effects without regard to the causes for what you have outlined. If the underlying cause cannot be identified and rectified, the effects will continue. Most folks can identify with the Pals being ousted in such a brutal manner based on a dubious land claim from thousands of years ago. People here would resist if the Indians made a 200 year old land claim. Anyway, regards. Keep blogging. Ballistic.
You want "laid out rather nicely"? Ok, here, again, is what you, Margeret, Dutch, JB, et al, run from: 1) The Muslim Brotherhood, of which Hamas is a member, declared global jihad its cause in 1928 2) The Arab League & Arab High Committee (The Palestinian Arabs) rejected UNR181 in 1947, then declared war against Israel's existence in '48 3) Fatah did so in '58 4) The PLO did so in '65 That is "resistance" to nothing except the existence of Israel.
Why do you give one whit one way or the other as to whether I am female or not? A couple months ago I saw that Kath posted another poster saying she had "just found out" from "IT" that Ballistic was a woman and that she could have been "knocked over with a feather" at the news of that fact. If you still have interest in this irrelevant subject, perhaps by directing the BS to Kath; she may choose to tell you her source. BTW, I still haven't seen any responses by you to Margaret's excellent posts. My guess is you have no response, but are rather a detractor slinging irrelevant BS. Carry on. Regards.
I have read some of your posts, and I agree that the Palestinians are living under a brutal occupation. I agree that the Palestinians shouldn't just roll over - that they should resist the occupation. I frequently visit the B'Tselem website. Of course, B'Tselem comes down like a ton of bricks on Israel, and rightfully so, but B'Tselem also documents and reports Palestinian violence - the Katyusha rocket attacks by Palestinian organizations against Israeli civilians are a breach of international humanitarian law and a war crime. I think to state that Israel's intent has always been to exterminate the Palestinians is hyperbole. There were about 750,000 Palestinian refugees in 1948. Now there are about 7.2 million 1948 refugees and their descendents, and a total of about 9.6 million Palestinians worldwide - of course, most live in the ME. I'm running out of space, and you may not see this post anyway...
You can credit Paul Harris for correcting my "cajones". When I started blogging several months back, I always called them kahunas, which I still prefer, slang or no. In deference to my long posts with Paul Harris, I made an adjustment.
"Let's see you respond to Margaret." I have noticed that out of all the bloggers in this thread, you want me to respond to Margaret. Ok, I shall oblige.
Regarding your education at Rutgers: Isn't it something that I did not believe you had attended Rutger's at all? "Yup, yessiree, nope, nosiree, have coffee, pack up the u-haul, get out the umbrella, and the gig's up" somehow don't seem to reflect a Rutgers and graduate school education - your most recent posts in this thread do. "You didn't even know that I was a woman." Did you undergo a sex change operation? Just kidding - "was" generally refers to the past. Actually, I do know that you claim you are a woman. I just don't believe it. Your use of the word "cajones" so often has led me to believe you are really a man.
Haaretz doesn't allow enough space, so I must reply to your post in more than one part: I do have an idea of what I am talking about in regard to Paul Robeson. I have learned a lot about him. He was truly a remarkable man. In your post #635, you claim that Paul Robeson was EXCLUDED from regular campus and dorm life at RUTGERS - that is the ONLY CLAIM regarding Paul Robeson I dispute. That he eventually moved from the U.S. because he was harrassed is not in dispute. At Rutgers Paul Robeson did experience some prejudice and racism, but he was able to gain the respect of the football team and became one of the most popular students on his team and on campus. That information I obtained from the Dubois Learning Center website. The Dubois Learning Center is no doubt named after the late W.E.B. Dubois, a great American civil rights leader. I believe what I read about Paul Robeson's popularity at Rutgers. Google "Walter Seward" - He lived in the same dorm as Paul Robeson.
What a very nice post. Unfortunately, there are people like Ben Jabo, Peter SM and a few others whose sole job is personal attacks, distraction, obfuscation and other assorted knee jerk reactions such as "antisemitism" charge to any critical discussion of the policies of the gov't of Israel. Unfortunately, the majority of people in the US and in Israel are good people, however, governments and their policies do not reflect the will or goodness of their people. Unfortunately, many here and elsewhere even in the US confuse the two. I do hope moderates on all sides will fairly settle the underlying issues here and in Israel. Things are looking pretty grim. Best regards. Ballistic.
I refer you to posts # 694 and 701. As I said, you have no idea what you are talking about. Paul Robeson not only had meg troubles at Rutgers College, he eventually moved from the US because of harrassment. His own accounts differ from the official ones. Women go to Douglas College, but the board voted in late 1970 to admit them to Rutgers. Obviously, it took time for them to view Rutgers College as a viable alternative to others and they did not come right away. I know when I was there and have used that education and graduate education in Boston as the basis for my livelihood. You didn't even know I was a woman. Try speaking on the issues as Nemesis has suggested. I see you never do. Mr. Sullivan tells me too much personal info given to folks like you is disastrous because of what happened to him. Let's see you respond to Margaret. My educational background became an issue months ago when Paul Harris asked about it. It was not relevant then or now. Regards.
Paul Robeson experienced a racial incident at Rutgers, but after that he became a very popular student on his football team and on campus: http://www.duboislc.org/ShadesOfBlack/PaulRobeson.html That should debunk your claim that he was excluded. "You find no post from me that I entered Rutgers in 1971...I didn`t enter college until the mid 70`s..." Refer to post #259 in the boycotting the boycotters talkback: you stated that you transferred to Rutgers the year afer women were allowed. The Rutgers' Board of Directors voted to admit women in 1970. If you would rather go by the date the first women were admitted in 1972 as the year they were allowed, then you must have transferred there in 1973 (1 year after 1972) - that is not the mid 1970s. The Rutgers info you posted had nothing to do with the topic of the boycotting the boycotter talkback. There are no issues in post #586 that are relevant to this Haaretz talkback topic. It is full of irrelevant gibberish and BS.
Ballistic writes about justice and promoting peace, with clear concern and sympathy for both Israelis and Palestinians. She is a credit to her people. You calumniate Afro-Americans, who are making painful progress to recover from centuries of slavery, and who, nevertheless, have provided us with the moral leadership of people like Martin Luther King. And you write with clear malevolence, no sympathy ? rather, contempt. For those of us who are proud of our Jewish heritage, you are simply a source of shame.
It appears you are gonna have a bit of trouble getting used to world scrutiny of the ME mess. It is telling you view it as a local issue and not wothy of great and nervous concern to the rest of the world. No need for me to go into what you posted; it is irrelevant to this thread and the issues. The issues with my people you enumerate mirror those of the Pals, however, theirs is worse. Forget about the distractions you and others put forth. There are other issues, yes, but none portend the good possibility of nuclear war or a front and center confrontation by the two major religions of the world, which have now come to a head. My people, among others, continue to serve and die in these useless wars. You have very little understanding of today's world members and their mindset and how this conflict fits into it. Unlike you, I have concern for more than myself. You better get to peace while you can and stop with the petty BS. You have failed to read the sign of the times.
There you sit, in NM, pounding the keyboard endlessly, avoiding a situation which should be close to your heart and of a personal concern. You claim to be Afro-American and appear to be totally unconcerned with your brothers & sisters, yet have time to devote yourself to matters so distant from home. Your concerns should be the welfare and advancement of the people you claim to be a part of. 70% Out of wedlock birth rate. 52% H.S. drop-outs. 94% black on black crime. Girl, as the old saying goes: "Tend to your own knitting".
enough to come in out of the rain while others don't. Your mistake is you think the hub-bub is all about Israel; it is not, it is the totality of world events, clearly worrying. Your downfall is common, you think a gig lasts forever. Reasonable people know it does not. However, you are in tune with Nero, fiddling while Rome burned. Despite what evangelical posters write to the contrary, knowledgeable Jews know that there is ample evidence that they may not be the favorite in the race and the reasons why not. However, you are not one of the reasonable posters, so my post is wasted on you. However, just keep on pushing as I know you will. God is on the scene; I believe that. There are certainly differing opinions as to what exactly that means in terms of events. We will all see. Stop gnawing on people and discuss issues, which you rarely do. Regards. Ballistic.
I like that glee, yup, shows how much you want peace. Firstly, that train is gonna leave the station with or without passengers, wait and see. Secondly, what are you now the Orthodox Police (#711)? Boy, one thing you don't lack is moxie. If a Jew has an opinion different from you, they are a fraud. If others differ, they are antisemites. Thirdly, I still use "hey" in my posts, since you are not the chairman of the linguistics dept. Have you moderated Margaret's correct view of events; I doubt it. That is sure one fine refreshing lady, and it is folks like her and a few others affected who will be responsible for Israel's survival, if God wills it, since truth cannot be defeated. Dubya's cajones are still in the wringer. According to Blitzer today, Zawahiri released a tape saying Dubya should be given the money to keep our troops in Iraq and which troops, according to him, have made a repeat of historical mistakes and must stay to be picked off like chickens, golly. con't
There seems to be a bit of doubt about your claim to being "Orthodox". First and foremost who was the Mohel that performed your Brit Milah? Your Parsha was? Then we can proceed to your statements about the Muslims. Have you ever read that portion of the Koran that pertains to Jews & Christian's. If you have, how could you have made a statement that Islam isn't facist when it advocates the less than 2nd class citizenship for the Jews & Christian's? If you don't respond, one and all will know you're sailing under false colors. Just to let you know, I suspect, with good reason, all those that proclaim that theyre American, New Yorkers, Patriots, Orthodox & similar. Usually they're phony's of the first magnitude.
Train won't be leaving the station. Two passengers have refused to board, Hamas & PRC don't want to make the trip. Now you have to refund their fares which they never paid in the first place. Before you schedule the next departure, make certain that passengers are willing to make the trip.
'ORTHODOX J...' is actually a muslim terrorist pretending to be Jewish in order to make it appear as though there were discord within the ranks of civilized human beings. Or, at best, she or he is one of those 'Orthodox' who attended the delightful little Shoa-deniers' conference in Tehran.
and an apparently retractable problem, however, Israel's survival is clearly an unknown sitting in a sea of Muslims. Yet the zealots on either side want it all and some are still pursuing the unrealistic dream of a greater Israel. I do believe that world opinion is against us and the US can no longer support itself and things are going downhill fast with chaos in both govts. There is TV talk by Congress of impeaching Dubya and calls to remove Olmert. Lebanon was a warning, just as Iraq and Afghanistan is. We learned nothing from Vietnam, and all for what we are now told is a lie. The people of both countries are good people; their leadership is not. Many of these posters seem to feel that time is on their side and they can continue to slurp Pal land and then call those Pals who object terrorists when acts of desperation become the order of the day. Unfortunately, Pals have no recourse to address their grievances after 60 years. As the saying goes, no justice, no peace. Regards
It is early Sun morning and I am just having coffee, how about you? My response to you answered what you sent. I guess you don't read all the posts because if you had you would have seen #688, or at least used the referral number to see it. My habit is to use that number and read the post the poster is responding to. Why do you think I am not okay? If I get a reasonable post, I send a reasonable answer. If I get a BS personal attack post, well, I send an appropriate answer to that too. That apparently upsets some posters, sobeit. Regards. Ballistic.
You emphatically stated yesterday that if you saw a "Hey", you were gonna go by the post. Unfortunately, like most of what you say, it was apparently more BS. I am gonna leave you to Margaret. I am still smiling at her the "likes of you" statement. Nope, you can't peddle BS everywhere as you do and then count the responses. I didn't post anything until Lynn started posting me with her various inaccurate characterizations. However, I will leave you to Margaret, a linguistically able poster, which you are not, to get you straight. Regards.
I agree and sympathize. One element of the present Israeli/Palestinian problem is that that both peoples think of themselves as history`s special victims, and, thus, almost anything that they do to their opponents (i.e., victimizers) is acceptable to them.
Are you feeling Ok..doesn't sound like you
It has nothing to do with this thread and is in response to #688, who apparently feels it does have something to do with this thread. Her interest in Rutgers College and my stay there is unknown as she sent 'facts' to me which are quite wrong and she attributes inaccurate statements by me about it. You will note that I answered "Mimi" and then steered her back to the relevant thread. Somehow, she also thought I was a man as evidenced by her "dude" refernce. Personal info is not imp; the subject of the thread is imp. You will need to send your questions to Mimi and perhaps she can lay out why she thinks it relevant; it is not. Regards.
Thanks for your post. It is my hope that all can be free from injustice of any kind. Our people share tragic histories. The most tragic portion of ours was the Middle Passage, the astounding number of deaths incurred during the Passage and the loss of self, name and identity, an imp element your people retained in spite of your horrors. In many respects, what blacks lost during the ordeal surpasses the horrors of yours since you retained what we lost. I support Israel; my Jewish boyfriend is a child survivor of the holocaust and lived for a short time in Israel before coming here. However, in spite of his trauma, he recognizes that his people cannot visit similar deeds upon the indigenous people of Palestine. It appears that many somewhere along the line have lost their soul and their empathy for others now suffering, much as they themselves had with the overlying goal and motive of removing the Pals from the area as quite bluntly laid out by Margaret. Regards.
What exactly does the fact that you went to Rutgers have to do with the topic here? Are you that full of yourself that you think anyone really cares? Unbelieveable.
"at least I have half a soul. That is more than what most people have." - Bird from Outerspace Most people have 1 soul. If you have half a soul than you have LESS than what most people have. (You divide what YOU have by what other people have to find your standing. Don't multiply.) Or did you want to say that you have more than most Martians have?
I am a Jewish American, and I assume that you are an African American. Comparing the histories of our peoples is interesting. You were mostly bought and sold like cattle and compelled to work with your hands. Until I found refuge in the West and in Israel, I was mostly forbidden to work with my hands and periodically murdered. The common element was that neither of our peoples were free. Let us make sure that we enjoy a future of creative choice.
Bush and Rice have raised the specter that the Palestinians, who need peace even more than the Israelis, will abandon Hamas and the even more militant factions. Further, Meshal is even more frightened by the prospect of a truly superior force commanded by Abbas, who has long pointed out the self-defeating stupidity of Palestinian violence. Now, it`s up to the Israeli Government to eschew its greed and fear and turn Meshal`s nightmares into reality.
Very aggressive poster..most of the content is the same thing repeated in a different way..believes in quantity over quality..I like your hemlock suggestion.
"Something EVERY human being need wonder". Virgina. Please correct your statement. 'EVERY' is a generality that dosen't apply in the real world since Kain killed Abel and answers G-d 'I am not my brother's keeper'. Your mouthful response; for reason of truth should read : "Something TRUE humanbeing NEVER need to wonder". Some under dogs are real ALSATIANS,
Hey Moshe; read your post to Margaret. I was wondering if you could expound a tad on the operative words at the end of the post which were "The Jewish forces also seized Arab land to either expand the Jewish territory for security purposes or for other reasons". Golly, how is that inconsistent with theft, terror and whatnot opposers of the conduct are talking about? That sounds like a euphemism for exactly what Margaret said it was, except you prefer to characterize more mildly than she put it. What exactly does that phrase mean? Regards.
as it describes completely your post. You have no idea what are talking about with blacks at Rutgers and Paul Robeson. I don't know what you looked at, but his history there and his racism problems are legendary on campus. Here's the cite: http://www.anc.org.za/ancdocs/history/solidarity/robeson-bio.html You find no post from me that I entered Rutgers in 1971. In fact, I am a woman and Rutgers College did not admit woman until well after 9/70, when the Board voted to do so. I didn't enter college until the mid 70's after transferring from a 2 year school. "Pants down"; hardly. I haven't been in the habit of lying and spinning and no need to start with that. The pants that are down is what Margaret is laying out and stop trying to rewrite the history of Rutgers, Robeson and the Jews. Apparently, you know nothing of any of it, you are just sending knee jerk BS rather than to respond to the issues. Try reading a tad and understanding "history", which is "his story". Regards.
You've just outdone the competition. You now have the title of Champeen Windbag. Of the 689 posts in this thread, you're the author of fifty three (53) worthless pieces of hatred & drivel. Pat yourself on the back as you enjoy your Jonestown Koolaid w/hemlock. I'm having a nice turd shaped pin goldplated to wear on your louse blouse.
King David Hotel was British H.Q. in Palestine. Warning was given to evacuate the hotel, Brits ignore it. Palestinin's kill innocent Israeli's every chance they get. When Palestinian women and children assume the functions of terrorists, they too are terrorists. The can't hide behind a curtain, claiming they're only women & children. It's women that board Israeli busses wearing bombs under their clothing and blow themselves up among innocent passengers, restaurants, shopping centers have all been targets. That sweet looking 14-15 year old is a fully trained terrorist, willing to go to Allah and collects his 72 virgins. Girls that have dishonored their family are given a chance for salvations as a homicide bomber. Don't worry, Israel will exist, if you can prove your Jewish, scum, such as yourself would also be granted entry. Drink the Jonestown Koolaid, it'll solve your problems.
refuse to see, read & learn. Tel Hai was PURCHASED, Arabs attacked it anyway. Early Zionist's BOUGHT all the land they built their settlements on. Hebron's Jews were attacked, raped & slaughtered, it's well documented, as were the timelines. There is none so evil as a person who hates his own people, such as yourself. Nobody denies the rights of the Palestinian's to exist other than the Pali's. They have a home in Jordan, now they want two parcels of land. If you're really so sympatico with the, surely they can find space for you to plant your unworthy carcass. Let the Pali's abide by the UN resolutions, starting with the 1948 Palestine Partition, which the ignored and attacked Israel. Read the Timelines again, apparentlyh you are too stupid to understand them the first time around. Have a cup of Jonestown Koolaid, there's plenty to go around. Still thirsty?, had another cup.
NOBODY writes as many nonsensical posts as does "Ballistic". If you look up "Ballistic" in the dictionary, there are two meanings, one has to do with accuracy, the other to being unhinged. Take your choice, I'm certain you'll come up with the correct answer. Her constant yammering is probably because she can't find anyone to sit down with and have an intelligent conversation. She's too full of herself, and full of you know what.
www.MEMRI.org has long since shown on countless instances that Muslim leaders will deliberately say something in apparent agreement or in acquiescence in ENGLISH tothe west, while in Arabic state the exact opposite to their own people. Moreover, a leader will pretend to agree wholeheartedly with the west, etc. and then when the actions of other Muslims (usually violence), clearly proves otherwise, the 'agreeing' leader will distance himself from the contradictory actions and pretend to be appalled by them. Never forget what the Hamas Charter states. It advocates the complete and total destruction of Jews and of Israel! You can find a copy of this charter on the Internet.
Anything that anyone posts on the Haaretz talkbacks is open for discussion. YOU should stick strictly to the topic of each discussion - 95% of your posts include irrelevant gibberish. You were caught with your pants down when you claimed that when you were at Rutgers (in 1971) no blacks were allowed, and you are still trying to cover your ass. Now you say that Paul Robeson was excluded from regular campus and dorm life at Rutgers, and you are absolutely wrong. Walter Seward lived in the same dorm as Paul Robeson: Paul Robeson became one of the most popular students on the football team and in college. From the Dubois Learning Center (a black website): FYI, Charles Ogletree, a Harvard professor and a leading slavery reparations activist, has said the movement has more vitality in the 21st Century than it had in the past.
Nobody in the M.E. wants peace. america must give up.
#668:I can hardly believe your understanding of the Israel/Arab conflict which is limited to bumper sticker mentality.To believe such nonsense that Israel was built on "theft and terror" is without foundation.Most of the land was purchased with the permission of Turkish authorities prior to the end of WWI and with permission of the British mandatory authorities until the establishment of Israel.During the war of independence of 1948, Arab leaders called for the local Arabs to leave their homes in order to ease the destruction of Israel by the invading Arab armies.The Jewish forces also seized Arab land to either expand the Jewish territory for security purposes or for other reasons.You ought to do some reading on the subject.
margaret: "Well, if my comparisons are so wrong why are all the zionist freaks and their evangelical nutcake friends coming out of the woodwork blathering like banshees?" Whatever 'zionist freaks' or 'evangelical nutcakes' have to say, does not make your comparisons valid - they are still fundamentally wrong. And you still are avoiding the real issues. margaret: "It`s because I`m so right that you`re all getting bent out of shape." margaret, if anything you are just funny. Doubt anybody would get out shape on this account.
Unfortunatelly, paulo, a lot is still left undone. There are still plenty of land left in the hands of palestinians(the renters not the owners). And soon the rightfull owners-Israeli Jews will claim the rest of the land. And so paulo you will like it even more, but in case you don't drink some water from the sea, isn't that what you love to say to whoever desagrees with you.
I remember that one. Nasty piece of work. BTW, a lot of US citizens are being hurt by Illegal Aliens, not immigrants, who are bringing the wages of the average worker down. One of the reasons the Senate was going to pass a new minimum wage act, which they haven't done yet. Six States have passed new minimum wage laws. Keeps the legal citizens from losing out. The construction industries have been hit very hard by the influx of untrained illegals.
What a surprise. I like to read some action and its been boring not seeing any slug out contests in a few weeks. It must be that intransigent ballistic we've been missing to get thinks mixed up. I truly love it. And I see she has some friends. What a treat. Keep it going.
on the causes and not its effects. I find Margaret has laid them out rather nicely today. Resisting the occupation I am sure will have untoward problems caused by the continued resistance. Care to speak on the core issues as Margaret is doing, or do you just wanna keep pointing to the effects as an excuse for your failure to address the core issues, your choice. Regards.
Speak for everybody in the US? No, dear me, you have that wrong, it is you who keeps pushing the idea on the blog that Americans support what is going on over there whole hog, no matter any evidence to suggest differently. Warm sunny skies every day, according to Lynn. Well, it's pretty hard being a black bigot, however, if that's what you wanna say, so be it. You are spinning the issues, and the issues are as Margaret has been laying out & now she is being attacked. She apparently is in NYC with you. Have you any response to what she is saying which coincides with what I have said, except that you can't get away with calling her an antisemite. Her posts indicate hope to anyone interested in peace. Her willingness to expose truth is VERY refreshing. I will watch for your responses to the attacks made on her. She sounds like one fine lady!!! You can't get to peace with the Pals in today's headlines without addressing the core issues, which you blithely gloss over! Regard
And your name is on the list of suspects! (kind of like an honor role). The prize is incredible too - more space! censor free for 1 week! Well, just couldn't resist. Too bad the punctuations all come out as question marks. darn that haaretz. Also that it failed to go up yesterday when I tried first. thanks for the tid bits on your own faithful faker. next to come up (in another day probably) will be the final faker profile. That one will be adapted to tosefta but we can easily string one up for you too. Actually, learning how to be a good faker could be useful exercise. Unfortunately, a desire for learning is not what motivates fakers....
remember your closing sentence to me in the offensive post, and I see you have again touched on it in this post, however, not as crude. I believe the offending "crack" part was a tad over the top. But that was long ago, and I have posted you since then and apologized even though your spunky post to me got the response. The only thing said about your family was that they should have raised you better to not say what you said. Since then, we've been putting along, not always agreeing, but at least have civil discourse about our disagreements, as it should be. I decided you couldn't be all bad when I found out you disliked the disaster Dubya. Best thing about America is we can disagree without being trounced physically. Lotsa people didn't go to college; I am the only one in mine fortunate enough to go to college and grad school; my parents could not. Nothing to be ashamed of. What matters is how one comes at folks. Regards.
Golly day, education for all is at hand. Regards.
My candidates: Flushman (aka The Hydra), Star of David, Gabe1.
I posed a question to Lynn to include those horrific examples you cite wondering whether the recipients of such injustices had any legitimate beefs with the US and/or Israel, as the case may be. I have not heard back. You are a tad off the track; the discussion here is about bad zionists behavior. As far as names called my people, well, let's just say we've endured them over the years. We've dealt with it a lot better than you have and the Pals will survive as well. Say, speaking of covert actions, have any idea how many the Mossad were involved in? CIA is well known. There is at least 1 or 2 books by ex agents laying it bare. MO is always the same whether you and yours or ours, it is all wrong. Save the antisemitism BS; I vote for the Pals, semites, remember? They have taken to calling opposers "bigots". Why aren't you on the front lines instead of being a 5th column in Canada, which, according to Bev a while back, had a large anti-apartheid rally. Did you take part?
Hamas has changed their minds, again. Egypt is going to dig a moat between them and the Pals. Sounds like the Arab States are going to wise up too. Do you think they will fill it with crocs from the Nile?
Do you use the "victimhood routine" to justify your bigotry? No one has claimed to be a victim, except you. And you seem to feel that it is your right to speak for everyone in the US. I also find it unusually funny you choose to use my name so often in your posts. Have you nothing to offer of your own? Now, be a good little poster and see what the title of the article now says. Does that sound like the leaders of Hamas truly want the peace you so loudly proclaim they do? Syrian and Iranian lapdogs, that is Hamas and Hezbollah.
months ago during our "slugfest,why did you resort to attacking me,my immediate family,my mother and father,my education,my heritage and even my dog?either your a cruel person or your feathers were and are ruffled.you can take a look back at your post in here today and see your feathers are truely ruffled.for me,i didn't have the opportunity to go to college,i learned how to work,period,so forgive or kiss my butt if you don't care for my methods or grammar.in dealing with the world and my business i have learned how to grab things by the horns and muscle them in my direction,so im actually better at dealing with things and people in person,rather than trying to impress them with my grammar and typing skills.go ahead,admit it,you were a little ruffled,wern't you.regarding post #644,i have suffered tremendously from the influx of illegals and wish SOMEONE had the nuts to actually do something about it before it's too late.more street language for you,lol
Well, if my comparisons are so wrong why are all the zionist freaks and their evangelical nutcake friends coming out of the woodwork blathering like banshees? It's because I'm so right that you're all getting bent out of shape. Nothing stings like the truth. And here's a bit more: your erstwhile pal George W Bush has ended America's rejection of talks with Iran and Syria. You people can keep on trying to spin the truth to suit the immorality of the zionists, but life is moving on.
I always accused Danite of faking my posts; he denies it. It is someone who posts a lot daily, as even if I am off a week or two, as soon as I return posting, up come the fake Ballistics. The posters have been gnawing on one another for so long that the 'fake' stuff doesn't really get it, cause you get to know the style and views of the poster. A couple of times I was off and when I got back on and saw a fake poster, somebody had already pointed out it was fake and not consistent with my views. What's the prize??? Getting gnawed on for a week (smile). Regards. Ballistic.
You guys just make it up as you go along. Sorry, but your misrepresentations don't work with me. I know exactly what the 1967 borders are and I know exactly what 242 says. Israel's intent from their own admissions has always been to exterminate the Palestinians only they call it reclaiming the land given them by God. Well, I want to see the deeds signed by the hand of God.
You said it Paulo: Israel is built on theft and terror!
:-)
margaret: "I`ve seen the graffiti on the wall that reads... " margaret, do you believe everything you see written on walls?
Just as another hint, the following potential suspects have already been categorically eliminated from our line up (If you disagree please send a 2000 word essay on no more than 3 posts, explaining your (faulty) reasoning)). a. god (christian version ? it?s all about love so why?d he/it do a thing like that?) b. Jeff Northridge (couldn?t figure out whether fakery is legimate according to the ICRC rules of occupation; alibi - still working on legal definition of ?fake? ? should take another month - or a week less if he stops going to sleep way so early) c. Dana (would do a better job of faking + way too busy with Tim R?s homework) d. Lee (I am too mad at him to care ? he was mean to me!) e. eric (is still my body guard, and has an alibi - been on much needed break) f. American in NY (same alibi as dana-the-not-suspect. Seen spending all his time - spare and otherwise - threading through Tim R's homework looking for weak links) Good luck to all contestants! ________
margaret: "it was all Arab land in `48 when the refugees from Europe were plopped down in the middle of the Middle East, unwanted troublemakers who soon showed themselves to be terrorists against the British." Margaret, you are wrong on all accounts - 1) it was not all Arab land; 2) Jewish refugees were not 'plopped' in 1948; 3) Jewish refugees - Holocaust survivors - did not terrorize anybody.
31. Olmert (decided he won?t take it anymore. Picking on Tosefta who may just be the last person to still be able to take anything from Olmert. Not fair!) 32. Livni (blackmail ? did you see how the (real) Tosefta suddenly supports her?) 33. Gaza clan holding Johnson (learning about how to fake a deal and eat their crows too + stick it to Haniye, who ? as everyone knows ? has been secretly whispering in Tosefta?s ear all this time) 34. Tosefta?s long suffering spouse(s) (or child(ren) or grandchild(ren) or students or the pet paraqueet) 35. aliens (landed most recently on the white house lawn. Exchanged Bush for a better model which can string together an entire sentence (wow!). Faking could just be the long feared prelude to invasion of the body snatchers) 35. Other (insert your own suspect) Disclaimer: our game directors extend their apologies to any potential suspect-in-good-standing not appearing on our list. We assure any of our contestants that such omissions were inadvertant.
about how hated you are around the world. I know there is a name that condition, i'll look it up and post it to you. Not much to say to you in Canada as I don`t believe they are mired in Iraq over there. Hold on to this fantasy Ballistic. By the way i almost forgot about that one, i was thinking of Viet Nam, Nicaragua,Peru, Cuba, Laos ,Cambodia , Beirut etc. etc. etc. ya ya and Iraq and hundreds of covert actions around the world and you have the gaul to open your big mouth about any other country. You are one sorry hippocrite if there ever was one. With that record behind you, i wonder what your agenda is. mayyybeee ANTI-SEMITISM ? Oh ya i'm sure some of your best friends are jews. Do you really think you are so hard to read.
21. klaudia (very strange that we haven?t seen much of her around) 22. Yaakov Sullivan (strong motive: make a deal to get rid of his own replicator pests) 23. Cipora JK (added so as not to hurt her feelings; too addicted to the real thing) 24. Tim R (he is driving me crazy with homework. Like I could fix the ME in a fortnight! I?d suspect him of doing anything just to make people work harder) 25. Joe from Ramallah (ah, we know about these Palestinian types, they are used to faking themselves as people, all the more as a nation!) 26. lakshmi (all this cozying up to Tosefta ? could be guilt, who knows?) 27. swiss (dino) (don?t know which side he is on any longer other than agreeing that olmert should get the heck out and that global warming is hurting the alps) 28. Dutch (another one who?s a bit scarce lately. Most peculiar ? why, no opinion on Olmert? Could be up to no good. No alibi whatsoever) 29. god (jewish version - where has he/it been lately? unleashing swarms?) 30. god (muslim version ? irritated at them jews ? always going on and on about everybody else?s problem and not fixing their own. Motive: LET?S SHOW THEM WHO?S BOSS? What about an alibi?)
Pals are semites, so they've changed to calling me a bigot. Say, what of that messy tennis ball you were lobbed in a response post on this thread? I didn't see any response. Are you sure you are a woman? One poster pointed out you are cold hearted, I believe that is what he said. Anyway that messy tennis ball that was lobbed onto your pristine side of the court went unanswered, didn't it? I'll have to look. Say, are you gonna stop posting your 'ravings' about how to keep slurping and squatting on Pal land and how to keep them fighting and distracted amongst themselves while you do so? I was just wondering. After I read your rant to Margaret, I now know about you-if they don't agree with your warped program, whack em, brethren or not. Have tea. Regards.
Rutgers College is a state institution, and when I say blacks and Jews were not allowed at one point in time, it did not mean there was an absolute BAN on all blacks cause that was a tad overboard for a state college. Paul Robeson was there MANY years ago, but was excluded from regular campus and dorm life. Read up on the history. Don't trouble yourself whether I am black or not. Last time I looked I was. And, as I said last time, if you find out about any white folks who love Min. Farrakhan, send me their names. That reparation movement has been around for ions of time; it is dead in the water. Have you anything to post on the issues of the maltreatment of the Pals? BTW, Rutgers College eventually got a Jewish President while I was there. Women were not allowed in Rutgers College either until the 70's; they had to go to Douglas. Google Rutgers College, you will see its history. Regards.
of condescension with you. I have read it. Let's talk about financing and the money? Without money or goods to trade, there would not have been a problem. Get my drift? Okay. I don't wanna get into your 'history' as it appears that it has upset a few folks, no matter. It exists. Do you care to discuss any role your folks have had in your people's misery. If so, I am prepared to do so. Point is, my folks sniffed it up. How about yours? That bible slaves were given about 'heaven' later on and 'turn the other cheek' as a reading primer was quite effective, don't you think? May I suggest to you "The Destruction of Black Civilization" and the well cited "Secret Relationship Between Blacks and Jews". They go nicely with the work you cite and which I have. As far as your accusation that I am a 'bigot', well, is that the new substitute for the ineffectual you are an 'antisemite'? If so, okay. Regards.
Possibly knock their heads together?
Margaret: "The Jews made every effort to kill Germans with their little petrol bombs" Once again - you compare Warsaw's ghetto to Gaza, and your comparison is wrong. The Jews did not target and murder German civilians. Palestinians do target and murder civilians. That is way we call these Palestinians 'terrorists' Further you say "Israel is commiting genocide in the Occupied Territories of Palestine... and there will be holocast museums for the Palestinians". It does not look like there will be such museums any time soon - the genocide seems to be horribly ineffective, it even looks like there's no genocide at all.
scattered here and there around the globe post me with BS. When was the last time I read something about a "cancer" needing excision? No matter, I can't remember. The problem with cancer is if not treated, it metatasizes causing death. Treat it and you get life. "Truth" my friend is not what you can make the jury believe it is, as lawyers are taught via the "Bramble Bush". Not much to say to you in Canada as I don't believe they are mired in Iraq over there. Anyway, nice chatting with you. How is the weather? Have some tea. Regards.
Why should I be banned from Talkback? Have I told an untruth, or have I told a truth you wish not to read? My response was appropriate to what I was sent. Feel free to use your right arrow key and pass me on by. I like chatting with right minded folks, not those who wish to hide "truth" under the bushel barrel, as the good book says. Sorry you don't agree with me and apparently many other posters. I didn't see where you laid out any specific objection to my Lynn post, so I guess you had none, but rather viewed the appropriate truthful response given as rather, let's just say, harsh. Regards.
Very leftwing de rigeur. Very "intellectual" Very proud of biggoted ignorance,displayed for all to see. What do you know about whispering? Regards? you can give them to the next suicide bomber in Europe. Do you bother to listen to what the Al Qeida types say they really want?.Israel is just a small stepping stone in the total plan. Are you not allowed to think or read outside the party line?
12. Tosefta (secretly undermining himself by faking due to deep issues going back to his yeshiva past; or is just looking for a way out using aversion therapy) 13. FOX (doing it as a charity fund raising activity for likud friends) 14. Indrajaya (practices faking as tool to improve his English ? and succeeding!) 15. Mark Lincoln (potential 5th columnist if there ever was one; a master of disguise; but wouldn?t he do a better job? Hummm?) 16. Clickfool (the real thing, practicing how to fake his own fake self; fake + fake = real thing) 17. johnboy (another suspicious Australian; could be conspiring with Maureen Ann, or ? god forbid ? Star of David; devastating combination right there. Capable of anything) 18. Ballistic (good motive: ultimate revenge on the Man) 19. Smadar (she is just too nice. Suspicious indeed) 20. Ronnie Wollman (pretending to be a friend, but would do anything to fix a favorite football match, given half a chance)
Rules: Pick 3 from the following list of 35 of the usual suspects: 1. gabe1 (has lots of motives. maybe too much?) 2. Star of David (has motive, opportunity and means. Comm?on mate - confess already or we?ll unleash Maureen Ann) 3. Flashman (aka the swarm ? yesterday appearing as peresforpm. But how do we catch ?em all?) 4. GABE 1 (actually gabe 1 but in cahoots with Paul Harris) 5. dana (disguised in her right wing alter ego. Bet you didn?t know she had one!) 6. bored haaretz operators (BHO) (could also double as the swarm. Tx kath) 7. danite (thou protests too much) 8. kath (who could actually be a BHO in desguise. A master stroke) 9. Ann Maureen (there?s something about these Australians; can?t trust any of them, especially after a couple of trips to the bar) 10. The fake clickfool (morphing fast ? tired of faking THE FAKE. Loves to play dress-up; try anything for attention) 11. maria (way too pious ? could be a subversive)
Enjoyed reading your posts and the facts that they have laid out. Regards. Ballistic.
Gee, last time you said that to anybody it was 'Barry Goldwater', you remember him, don't you? Well, he retired once again to his resting place and pulled the coffin lid down. You must be the cheerleader of the rah rah team. I thought it was Chanah. However, more folks are on this blog pointing out shortcomings and appear to be in no mood to massage victimhood, and they are letting you know. One suggestion though, try to find something other than the predicted "antisemitism" argument. It detracts from any point you are attempting to spin. However, it is impossible to refute truth with spin, no matter how ugly and unseemly the truth may be. Did you ever hear "the truth shall set you free". It has a ring of truth, doesn't it? Regards.
I just think they love the conflict. Not really sorry for the Pals, just anti-semitic. If they thought so much of the territories, they would understand why their sort is just making matters worse and definitely not better. That Rah Rah Club is part of the reason the Pals won't give peace and prosperity a chance to work in their favor.
This being a bit of a slow news day and seeing how Olmert just keeps hanging around, while US ?pressure? turns overnight into ?non-binding advisory?, here is the game you?ve all been waiting for to better liven up a dullboard. Fake Tosefta Contest: Nominate the culprit Grand Prize: 3 additional lines per post ? free for the next 3 months!! Bonus Prize: censorship free posting for an entire week! Instructions: Don?t be fooled by the occasional double entries ? this is also a test of your comprehension abilities. Warning: expect this exercise to tax your intuition, cognitive skills and, more than anything, your moral fortitude (and if you are the guilty slime, by all means vote for yourself ? we know you?re on the list). Think carefully as appearances may be deceiving and note the helpful clues. Please mail your entries in a plain envelop to Haaretz Talkback c/o dana.the.not.suspect, or if you?d rather, address to our angel Angelina who kindly agreed to serve as tabulator (?)
you responded to my post #586 to Lynn twice, however, it is no matter. As I told Lynn, I am WELL aware of the history of your people and of mine and what I said is truth, was appropriate and stands. If such is antisemitism in your view, so be it. I thought you had moved beyond that knee jerk response Zionists give to any criticism, no matter whether justified or not. Try spinning on others who might slurp up mischaracterizations you sometimes put out in defense of the indefensible. Injustice cannot and will not stand. You and yours are in for a long bumpy ride if you think the Pals are gonna roll over on this one, nor should they. You have some right minded views, peddle them to your people to save themselves and never mind gnawing on others who point out shortcomings. You know Israel won't survive on her present course. Why should right minded Jews go down the tubes on account of zealots, who want what is not theirs. Regards.
Title is a teaser, sorry (been reading tabloids for tips on how to do good bylines. Work in progress here). Just wanted to thank you for your kind words and profess violent agreement regarding yaakov's post. Should have gotten more attention than it did - but that's what happens on a long tangled up thread that goes to all the places every other threads has gone to before (the not-space-ship-enterprise). OK, changed my mind - can't resist a bit of space (by the way, do you know anyone who's willing to sell some)? The fake business is a potentially serious one, and so I take it to be. Just imagine if it was one of the more talented posters with a penchant for malice. Luckily so far, most of our fakers appear to be long on mischief and grudge but a tad short on skills (which latter is a key indicator, according to my profile). Of course, any one of us can fall off the deep end - even I'm hovering on a ledge here because haaretz has not put up my 6-post contest. Me thinking havock....
Say, Bush has made it clear that he wants the Mexicans here to work, and if he can't get a bill allowing that he cares not one whit about stopping them. Are you following the story of the 3 border agents who drew long prison sentences for shooting a drug toting Mexican who was fleeing, and the gov't gave him immunity and he testified against our agents. Congress is looking into that. Mexicans work the fields where I used to live and they build our homes here in NV. They do gardening and man our fast food restaurants. If USers wanted those jobs at that pay, they would not be needed. They earn very well in construction here; I saw a few checks of theirs being cashed. Pretty respectable amount. I have no problem with anybody not causing trouble, working and wanting to feed their family and have a better life. All very sad really. Regards. Ballistic.
Joe, would you mind contacting me, schafe82@yahoo.com I'll keep my fingers crossed!
Go on and lay it out. I love it. Say, I guess he is gonna call you, a right minded, justice loving person a self hating Jew. Boy, the ploppers are rich, they are really rich. Well, I am sure you will continue to take more flack than me and others saying the same thing, but not in the 'family'. Say, do you think there will ever be peace in Israel based on justice for those Jews living there in 1948 and their Pal neighbors, or will this be a short train trip off a cliff? Regards. Ballistic. And GZLives says what to Margaret (I can't wait to see the response)?
I don't get ruffled feathers. I am assuming that you are talking of my responding appropriately to a couple of out of pocket posts I received. Gee, my feathers weren't even ruffled when you and I had a slugfest a few months back. You know me better than that, however, I will stand my ground. If folks don't wanna discuss the issues, no matter whether we agree or not, and wanna resort to personal attacks on account of the disliked views, well, there are appropriate responses available for all. Glad to see you can laugh. I laugh a lot no matter the seriousness of circumstances. I see you still get upset with posters on and off, but you haven't sent me anything out of pocket and therefore you have not received anything of the sort back from me. Keep blogging. Regards. Ballistic.
"G-D will Bless those who Bless Israel and the Jewish people and Curse those who curse them . Genesis 12 :3" Was that written by a Jew by any chance? LMFAO
Say Lynn, that is not news, that is old hat. Breaking news would be that "Israel has no plans to romp the defenseless Pals as a result of a Zionist trantrum"! That would be news. Regards.
Dude (you do often mention "cajones"), are you still pretending to be a black woman? In the Boycott the Boycotter discussion you said that when you were at Rutgers no blacks were allowed. After I pointed out your slip of the tongue was evidence that you are not black, you came up with a pathetic attempt to cover your ass by stating that blacks were not allowed, but they got in anyway. I am sure that a black person who claims to have attended Rutgers in 1971 would know that blacks have officially been allowed to attend Rutgers since the late 1880s. Now you claim that African Americans have not demanded any 21st Century payouts/handouts for the atrocities they suffered. I am sure that an African American would have at least some knowledge of the reparations for slavery movement: Africa-America Foundation Reparations Project: http://www.aafnet.org/ReparationProjectOfAfr.asp They should receive reparations payments or restitution, wouldn't you agree?
Stop your anti-Semitic ravings.
Dumbite is not too smart so I am not spending time and money on him anymore. You have a good idea, though. If desperate, I will use a dog whisperer, a horse whisperer, or even a ghost whisperer. Thanks.
You say you are not a muslim, i saqy you must be. You said the the Christians got it wrong and you obviously have nothing to say for the jews. and tout that all about islam is true, so you only believe in Islam. ERGO you are a muslim. For your information jews say jesus existed , just that he WAS not god. he was just one of thousands of people running around the mid east at that time claiming to be THE prophit. Much like you running around like you know something.
That is more than what most people have. I have not forgotten that you are attempting to trash Dr. Rice. I am just not interested in your sordid little game.
My motto for living is, "each one, reach one". :)
Howdy Margaret; Are you referring to the armistice line of 1949 in the West Bank and the armistice line of 1950 around the Gaza Strip? There is no UN Security Council Resolution which requires Israel to withdraw completely to those armistice lines. The exact wording of UNSCR 242 implies that Israel is to withdraw from most (but not necessarily all) territory seized during the Six-Day War subject to the following condition being met with first: "Termination of all claims or states of belligerency and respect for and acknowledgement of the sovereignty, territorial integrity and political independence of every State in the area and their right to live in peace within secure and recognized boundaries free from threats or acts of force;" The Palestinians have never met that condition so an Israeli withdrawal to wherever the border turns out to be is not required until after said border has been mutually agreed upon. You, the UN, the ICJ, nor any third party has the authority to dec
As a History major whose subject matter dealt with black studies, I think your protests are a little much. You are a very bigoted person and know very little about reality. Your own kings sold you down the river and so did your church. Please read "From Slavery To Freedom by John Hope Franklin". It is considered to be the most authoritative book written on the subject. I'm sure Henderson has a local library.
No doubt he advised the irish govt on how to extract the maximum from the EU dole coffers, he should know, he has been doing to his country for decades.You make a good friend for Tosefta, you sit there in a half stupor letting him run and run at the mouth for hours all in anticipation of the liquid "reward".Go to him Labrhas he needs you.
Ultimately, the first threat to Israel is conventional. Any threat to her ability to navigate freely is a huge threat since it could strangle her economically. The major threat from Iran is conventional, through Hizbollah and Syria. Obviously, I do not cherish Iran going nuclear, but the slow, steady encirclement of Israel by "conventional" means is more worrisome. A nuclear Iran is everyone's worry, but an encircled Israel is not. Regards, Cipora
Who is this new imaginary creature dumbite?I see you are really going off the rails after the series of stinging defeats I have sent your way, I didnt realise you were so fragile, i will try to be more gentle in the future.At least in this troubling times you have dana to hold on to, she is a real safe harbour for you as you have new experiances, like being defeated.its not like those lab rats and school kids you terrorise is it.best of luck buddy.
You are absolutely right. I would not limit the road to Baghdad. It goes to Kabul and Mogadishu as well. More generally, the key to the war against terrorism is Palestine. I think some people in the USA are realizing it. Better late than never, is not it ?
Exactly! As long as Meshal is running the Pal show from Damascus, there will be no peace. Syria will always have their hand in the territories just like they have Their hand in Lebanon. Haniyeh is just another lapdog like Nasrallah to Iran and Syria.
Oh oh oh Mrs. Ballistic Farrakhan. Like a cancer you can't get rid of.Head of anti-semites of the desert. I wish i could say good to see you again.However it would be better to see the last of you. As in # 583 like you don't know about SPIN or B S. You are the champ in both areas
She shames her race and she tries too hard being an anti-Semite. If she is not banned from the Talkback, then I will not read her, not just ignorant, but stupid and hateful postings. REGARDS, my A&&
That's ridiculous. Bin Laden is a player here. He made himself so on September 11 and his voice is pertinent. It's foolish to discount your enemies.
The one you call degenerate Christa, friend of Lebanon, says hello.
I have read the degenerate anti-semitic leitmotiv already about me. Why is anybody that disgrees with you a degenerate anti-semite ? I am neither degenerate nor anti-semite, just anti-racist and anti-apartheid.
Yes Marc this has to work for all concerned,that means the Arabs are going to have adopt realistic end games as well.I think the taba geneva concepts are a good framework and end game for both.They are going to have share the Old City with us at least, they are not going to push out of there thats for sure.I want those freaks to get real so we can get away from them and put as much distance between us and those losers as possible.This will allow amoungst other things for israel to slip off the front pages everyday and find itself in splendid obscurity for a change so she can concentrate on herself and her development with out being distracted by the frothing maniacs screaming day an night at her.I cant wait to free israel from the whole bloody deranged lot of them.Regards
If you think either party is doing a bit of good for the US, then you are just wrong. The reality is the Minimum wage act was passed in the House and the Senate has not acted to approve it. Yes, they are lazy when it comes to what would benefit the populace. Both parties are into confrontation and not much else. The Dems first 100 days have accomplished zero.
The muslim believe that Jesus was a prophet, the Christians that he was god and the jews, that he was just a man. And remember, accordingt to Christianity, the jews who do not accept Jesus go straight to hell...."no man enters the kingdom of heaven but THROUGH me". Any addendums to that are false.
It seems to me we have not so much to worry about here.The Bridges look like as if it a fortification against the shiites in the North,which makes sense as per current geo politics.Still bridges are not nuclear warheads so Id worry more about Iran right now.
Muslims (i am not a Muslim by the way) believe in Jesus, the Virgin Mary and Mohammed which they consider the last prophet. They have lived peacefully with Jews for hundreds of years, in fact, when Spain kicked all the jews out, it was modern day Turkey, a muslim nation, that took them in. The quoran was written by scribes after a years of oral tradition (as in Christianity), it was the Angel Gabriel that appeared to Mohammed and told him directly the truth about Jesus, and god, and the Jews, because the Christians got it all wrong (surprise)...and they do not have a problem with jews right to exist, but rather the state of Israel, and today, more for the right of a Palestinian State to exist in the West Bank and Gaza. PEACE "Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called children of god" :)
"the God of Abraham,Isaac,and Jacob will defend Israel and His chosen people from her enemies" Really? Well it seems to me that if you were right, the holocaust should never have happened, the Temple should never have been destroyed in Jerusalem (the Romans prospered for over 350 years after that...longer than the US has been around!) and Israel would have been one of the oldest states in the world....it would never have dissappeared in the first place.
Maria, if there is a hell, I am sure that there is a special place for people who speak for god or who use his words to push whatever it is they think he meant, and in doing so cause misery. "sent her a lot of disasters and school massacres,but still she still in slumber party with aclu and democrats" no political party has a monopoly on virtue, as we can all attest by the hypocrite right. It is scary to see people who try to make things happen that there prophesies say will happen, if it will happen, it will happen, when it should happen, we cannot let any book dictate how it should happen, only god knows right? We should just strive to make peace let god make happen what he wants to happen. To do otherwise, to push things to happen is to play god. ...and who are you to say what a true Christian is? I am not sure which country YOU come from but I can assure you that if there is a god, there is not country in the world that it has blessed more than the old US of A.
The only words that come to mind when i read that post is "stupid anti semite" you are really a joke.
I am glad to see you are seeking her guidance in complex matters, I know you dont have much experiance with things out of the lab(shows in your knowledge of history) but she will be a stable force for you as you navigate the new waters of the social sciences.Well done Tosefta!
The anti Israel responses here prove that "never let the facts get in the way" is alive and well.
Perhaps a Dog "Whisperer" might get the required results. Rgds
"My real amazement is triggered when I see academics, like Condi Rice in this case, not able to think something thru. Academics are supposed to be experts in thinking. What is wrong with Condi?" - Tosefta "Academics are experts at getting degrees--they are not necessarily experts in thinking." - Bird from Outerspace #568 ""The document was written by Major General Keith Dayton." The State Department must have approved, but what has that to do with academics." - Bird from Outerspace #591 Can't make the connection, right? Why are we talking about academics? You forgot already. Let me try to explain how it happened. You must have heard that on a Sabbath the Jew has one extra soul. But you are weak in math (as in reality in general) and you tend to divide when you should multiply, as we saw here in the past. Instead of multiplying your soul by 2 you divided it by 2, and you found that you only have half a soul on Saturday. Too little to remember anything that happened more than 2 minutes ago. (I did not mean ½ a minute.)
Your reliance on being Jewish will not impress anyone. It has nothing to do with your arguments. I suggest that you stay away from your reference to Bin Laden, as you did in one of your other posts since all it does is negate anything else you might say.
Howdy Tosefta; Regardless of which group of idiots in the U.S. State Dept. came up with this plan to nowhere and regardless of who approved it, the fact remains that it is unacceptable to both Israel and the Palestinian militant/terrorist groups. We might as well toss it in the dumpster along with the Oslo, Camp David, Geneva, Taba, Roadmap, and Arab Ultimatum proposals. The bottom line is that there is no peace proposal that both Israel and the Palestinians will agree to so it's back to the status quo with the security barrier in the West Bank nearing completion and with the Palestinians' military options being reduced to near zero. What's the hurry? Israel can maintain the status quo indefinitely while the Palestinians continue to breed themselves into perpetual and abject poverty on their side of the fence until hell freezes over. Until the Palestinians are willing to accept 100% of the Gaza Strip and 92% of the West Bank as their Islamic Republic of Palestine, then nothing will
Condi the lame duck worthless token, is now putting pressure on Israel to put guard down, loose a few jews what the hell. Olmert would love to give it all to the Arabs since he is a US puppet. The Bush admin is no postion to bully Israel. So Israelie wimps, congress and the senate have your backs. Just ignore Condi and Stand strong. Get rid of Olmert and the other kadima Surrender monkies as well. Or soon Israel will Be IslaIsrael.
So how does ZOG in Washington respond to this dilema? It's not easy maintaining a schizophrenic foreign policy but you can't blame the Americans for trying. America can't tell Israel what it really needs to hear but loves telling Palestinians what they must do. I don't think a statement by the American government by any official directed at Palestinians EVER didn't include the word "must". That's all we hear from that Zionist infested Black House in Washington. The reality is, there is fifty proposals on the table, with Geneva Initiative, Saudi Inititiatives and others? What does America offer, always piece meal approaches, Tenet plan,Mitchel plan,Road Map--and now more "Benchmarks" to get to the Road Map and so the game continues OF SHIELDING ISRAEL from having to deal WITH FINAL STATUS ISSUES. They keep throwing smoke bombs to cloud the reality of Israeli rejectionism.
immigration is down 40%.she is dead wrong about the dems having a fat lazy ass.they have been in power less than 6 months and she expects them to fix what the ignorant and arrogant republicans have f88ked up for the last 7 years.lynn,how come the republicans,since they have controlled the house,senate and presidency for at least 7 years,and the house and senate even longer,passed a bill on minimun wages and immigration.hmmmmmmmmmmm,i wonder how fat and lazy their asses are?
You must have a strong stomach to deal with the revolting and backward views of ballistic.You are doing an excellent job there.keep up the good work! Regards
having read your post #586 go ahead and tell me you are anything but a degenerate anti semite.
Exactly who do you mean by "those incompetant , embecilic morons in Gaza"? Your postings are usually even-handed.
not happy the peace train has stalled,she just thinks its funny that your precious palestinians (hamas and prc)will "torpedo the peace train".looks like your the only one in the palestinian camp that wants the peace train,and again,the pals have made you look like a fool!you need to find new hero's!
I am glad you are reaching out to dana, she can guide you throught the quiz, and she will make a nice friend for you.Good Tosefta reaching out is the first step.
Announce a new policy: Commencing in one week, any time a rocket is fired into Israel, the square block from whence it came will be destroyed by a missile. It is for those who inhabit that block to leave (or prevent its use by vermin), not for Israel to perform surgery. Little by little, all hiding places used by these rocket vermin will disappear. When the Ps begin to police their own they will be able to live in peace. Until then, they will continue to die senselessly or leave.
yessiree,looks like your the one with ruffled feathers!i needed a good laugh,thanks for being you.
Both Iraq and the Pals want dearly a solution.They just dont want America and Israel respectively (or is it irrespectably?) involved in it. Lets talk about Hizbullah and the Iranian mullahs and their contituences first. Both of them,Hiz and the Mullahs,were pretty well despised by the greater portion of their countries,that is until the west and Israel got involved and then bang they switched in 3 seconds to support them because they are the same people and loyaly against the infifels is most important. America through some manipulation had a noble ideal in mind to bring democracy (ok and maybe some profit)to the area and they all loved the idea of Saddam Hussein being deposed....until he got deposed and now its the big bad wolf Americans.America with leave and the combatants left will kiss each other I guarantee it.The Pals too.Yes lets nego with Israel BUT How dare Israel is involved in negotiations???????????? This is what Arafat felt. The solution cannot contain infidels.
There is a plan in works by Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and Egypt to buld to bridges spanning the Gulf of Aqaba. The bridges have the potential to threaten Israel's freedom of navigation. It would also allow the movement of troops and weapons to pass directly from Arabia to the Sinai. While the Saudi peace plan was presented to dazzle a naive, ignorant world, this bridge is concrete evidence that the Saudis have both feet firmly planted to span two continents.
Your response makes no sense. It is human nature to resist losing control over one's life to an occupying force. Ask any American and they will tell you that, of course, they would resist an occupying army and should tanks roll down their streets, destroying their homes and killing their family, they would make whatever bomb they could, find whatever weapon with which to resist. Yet when the Palestinians resist the theft of their land, the loss of their livelihood, their dignity, their lives with whatever paltry means they can muster against the mighty IDF they are made the terrorists. Israel needs only to renounce violence, recognize the right of Palestine to exist, and to abide by the many agreements they have signed to return to the 1967 borders.
Yo Billy .... stick to Hollywood and babe you might think of writing your last post as a screenplay because what an imagination you have. I;ll give you a hint . all those russian and Polish people you mentioned ? Ask any Russian or Pole if these are really Russian and/or Poles and the answer will be first laughing at the very suggestion and then the reply that these aren't Russians or Poles but Jews. Now Billy my naive silly friend, if you actually opt for knowing more you'll find many books that will educate you to you understand these people originally came from ... you guessed it ... the Middle east/Israel were exiled by the Romans and made their way up into N Africa and into Europe. Sooo despite your attempt to tell us all those things you thought you knew, these people, these Jewish people are originally from Israel and those people you champion and defend ? They invaded, conquered and occupied and now lets see if you want the end of occupation or you're all talk ?
I'm hardly naive as I spend about 16 weeks a year there and since I am a Jew I can hardly be said to have "my Islamists". But should we simply address who is wrong in this conversation it would have to be you with your simplistic and morally degrading excuses for Israel's behavior. It is accepted international law that land taken in war must be returned and for decades Israel has defied international law and multiple UN resolutions calling for a return to the 1967 borders. And, of course, it was all Arab land in '48 when the refugees from Europe were plopped down in the middle of the Middle East, unwanted troublemakers who soon showed themselves to be terrorists against the British. So let's not make up our history to justify the moral occupation of the Palestinians' land. Of course, if you have land deeds signed by the hand of God to show then take it to court and stop killing people for their property.
I thought that at the very least an academic like you would know how to read: "The document was written by Major General Keith Dayton." The State Department must have approved, but what has that to do with academics.
Your anti-Israel bias really fries your brains, that is if you have any. Military exports are carried out by many nations, including those that should no better, such as Russia, in their drive to squeeze the last buck out of their sales to your favorite people, Hamas, Hezbollah, Islamic Jihad, Al Queda and other wonderful assortment of thugs, killers and kidnappers.
hard hitting no spin posts. They cut through the BS to the heart of the matters. Keep blogging. Regards. Ballistic.
whatever Fox news said about it. Just let our Congressman know you have more info on it than they do, problem solved and we should email those in the border towns and let them know that Lynn says they don't have a severe and growing problem as they allege. Liars one and all, right? Geez! Regards.
You are avoiding the issue. The Jews made every effort to kill Germans with their little petrol bombs and the zionists certainly blew up civilians in the King David Hotel. Israelis kill innocent Palestinians every day, many of them women and children, and they glory in it. I've seen the graffiti on the wall that reads "It would be cheaper to kill them all", referencing the Palestinians behind the wall. Israel is commiting genocide in the Occupied Territories of Palestine and it is bitterly in keeping with what Europe did to the Jews. And one day Israel will be paying reparations to the Palestinians and there will be holocast museums for the Palestinians who have perished at the hands of the IDF and the Israeli government - if Israel exists long enough.
have to do much"! Well, if that statement doesn't take the rag off the bush, yup it does! You must be stupid. My people did more to create the country you enjoy than you and yours. And, they have not whined or demanded any 21st payouts/handouts for the atrocities suffered, unlike Jews who are still whining about what was lost in Germany, wanting money. How do you compensate blacks for losing their names and history, what's the going rate? My ancestors worked with their hands. What did yours do, did they work, of course not, they financed. One poster said Israelis came to CA and she wanted them to go back to Israel cause she said they were lazy, thought they were too good to do manual labor and flubbed up what they did. Don't even go there as I am well aware of your history and those of my people. The history of you and yours is that they will finance and make money off anything, no holds barred, including the misery Jews suffering under Nazis. Okay! Regards.
I don't need a Jews-can-do-no-wrong lecture from the likes of you. The world knows the truth. The early Zionists were terrorists of the lowest order and the zionists of today are no better. They are an offense against all things decent. Let Israel abide by the numerous UN resolutions calling for the return to '67 borders, renounce violence, and recognize the rights of Palestinians to exist. Get your moral house in order before you lecture others.
of impending attack.
Let me ask you this, do any of these people who hate Israel and/or the US from the Arab world ( nd lots in Europe) have ANY legitimate beef with us??? If your answer is in the negative, you are the one who is naive, cause that is the issue. Installing the Shah in Iran after killing their democratically elected leader did not help our history there. Get a life. These people have grievances which need at least to be heart and mediated. Anything short of that is perpetual war. If those living there have your attitude, I am not surprised the neighbors want them out. It is because of their behavior, not antisemitism. Wise up.
"Academics are experts at getting degrees--they are not necessarily experts in thinking. A case in point is your statement regarding Rice. She is not the one who came up with this plan." - Bird from Outerspace Rice is the one responsible for Middle East policy. It was either her or somebody in the State Department who suggested the plan, and she approved it. Approving is her responsibility and her fault. (I am sure she discussed it with Bush, and he approved too, but..) You forgot that on Earth we must use logic and not read minds via antennas. We don't have those. The Academics I am considering are those that can maintain themselves as Academics (by thinking and publishing good stuff). People like you are not among them.
Can't undestand people like you. For God's sake do something better with your time
No. No, if you can't visit your loved ones it means only one thing: they can visit you and stay with you forever. And you know why? Because you and "loved ones" are up to no good. Therefore unite but far far away from Israel.
Anne, Israel is in its 60th year and you did not learn anything.
Looks like the impasse has been met and accepted, again. I'm with you on the need for new leaderdhip, although, I must admit, I did have high hopes.
To look at america that is ruled by jews and christians.It is easy to forget that they killed 12,000,000 natives to get the power they now have.So if people think they wont do the same to palestinians,they are fooling themselves.They are religious fanatics that will kill all that they need to kill to create prophesy.They have moved a bunch of russian and polish people to the heartland of the middle east.And with them came death and destruction for the palestinians.But these people have done it all over the world.Fanatics have no compassion,it is just a job to validate past crimes.So it never ends.It is an evil cycle,fear to live with what is not like us.Seperation and segragation through religion.
Boyle Mexico, on the news. 23 billion per year to Mexico, earned by immigrants. It seems a lot of towns in Mexico are going to lose. Mostly border towns. Lou Dobbs doesn't live in Mexico. Glad to see you know the pain of your neighbors. Over 8 million deported and unless the Dems get off their fat lazy asses their will be no immigration bill. Along with many other things they have failed to address. Such as passing the increase in minimum wages. You know, the small things that make a difference to Americans.
My husband is German born and got his citizenship by serving in the military. You were lucky, your ancestors didn't have to do much to attain that.
Well worth the effort for Bush admin to put out a plan that is basically harmless to palestinians, but does not significantly promote the goal of the palestinian people to destroy Israel. The prompt rejection by the terrorist group elected by palestinian people helps to eliminate any doubt that palestinian people will never accept any solution that does not ensure the destruction of Israel. Meantime, the roadblocks in West Bank, along with the security barrier, are vital to reducing deaths and suffering of the israeli people. Reducing deaths and suffering of the palestinian people is responsibility of their elected rulers, Hamas, and once again it is made clear that they have no interest in reducing suffering and deaths of palestinians so long as it might result in the survival of Israel as a nation.
My dog Dumbite craves a lot of attention, which I am too short of time to give him. I am looking for an adoptive family for him. Dumbite is a very loyal dog. He will follow you wherever you go, even chase after your car. (He is in excellent physical shape.) You can see it in his behavior in the last few days. Give him attention, and he will be quiet and loving. If you can't, Dumbite will bark endlessly, as he is doing here. Only very loving people with lots of time on their hands should apply. Dumbite is not that smart, and seems to be unable to learn new tricks although he is not that old. His previous owner never sent him to dog school, so his repertoire of tricks is limited, but he can still be entertaining. If you have little kids at home, they will be delighted with Dumbite. He can be just at their level. Warning: If you just want to get a dog for free, this may not be a good deal for you. Dumbite can be very obsessive, and just the dog-psychologist will cost you more than the price of a comparable dog.
Have some coffee, consider the role of Iran and Syria. Rule from Damascus for the territories? You really are naive.
The good news is that Mossad exists, M. The bad news is that they are the Keystone Kops of world intelligence services. They couldn't even nick a passport in new Zealand without getting caught.
Just as the US needs in Iraq, a new paradigm here is needed, too. In Iraq, the Bush strategy seems to be delay and hope for the best. He seems to be following the Sharon/Netanyahu model. The "victory" definition keeps shifting with no end in sight. Here, too, neither side seems to have a real or realistic vision of what is needed to make an end of the conflict. The US cannot make peace in Iraq without involving Iraqis. Israel cannot make peace without involving Palestinians. I fear that new leadership is needed for the US, Israel, Iraq and the Palestinians before we'll see an end even defined. Meanwhile, it's time to hunker down and hope things don't get too much worse. And we have to remember that what will work has to work equally for Joe in Ramallah and Ibrahim in Michigan and at least a majority of the Palestinians living in Jericho, Jenin, Gaza and Qalqilia, too.
When there is nothing to do, it is not necessary to pretend to be doing something. The U.S. Administration should forget about the Palestinians for a while, and concentrate on stopping Iran.
Academics are experts at getting degrees--they are not necessarily experts in thinking. A case in point is your statement regarding Rice. She is not the one who came up with this plan.
I like lists. It can be very satisfying checking off, or crossing out items one by one. It takes, and reinforces, discipline which is a good thing. And stuff gets done. I believe that to relax the checkpoints, and give the Pals some breathing room will lead to only one result: more attacks. Hey, I like freedom, and I wish it for everyone, but not everyone can handle it. If you open the cage too much, expect to get clawed.
I much rather have no heart than a fool's heart. Now, what does my heart have to do with public international law?
The US cannot demand that Israel allow passage through her territory of people sworn to destroy her. Just in case you did not know, Israel is a sovereign state, in spite of the military aid that she receives from the US. People do not realize that Gaza and the West Bank are separate geographic entities, and were under the authority of different sovereigns before 1967. I fail to see why passage should not take place through the Sinai. I never said that the Palestinians are going anywhere, with the exception of Bishara, who is going everywhere.
the obvious. Regards. Ballistic.
I want only two things from the Palestinians and only two.That they sign a legaly binding end of the conflict treaty( no hudnas like that fool Tosefta loves)on the basis of Taba geneva and that they disarm hamas and the other degenrate gangs before one soldier is removed.After that they can all vote for Hitler if they want.better not to expect anythign from them except in exchange for a state, giving israel all the legal diplomatic political propoganda advantages in any future conflict.Giving them a state will be to their disadvantage in any future conflict.Regards Amigo!
There is a long tradition in elite British leftist circles of being apologists for the Soviet union and others.George Orwell called them on this and they hated him for it.Especially when he came from fighting in the Spanish civil war and claimed the Communists had stabbed the Revolution in the back!!!But I have no doubt the average "brit" has no illusions about the freaks the flake left adore, the British people are a solid folk and the best to have at ones side ina fight.Regards to you!
I offered hima simple quiz to help through what seems to be a very confusing issue for him, he doesnt seem able to answer it.Everytime I post it goes into some confused and troubled rage please see the mairovich thread and the post "can someone help tosefta" I think he would appreciate any guidance he could get.Poor guy.Thanks to all
Well, okay, red hot economy. The hottest export you have are arms, merchants of death. Sure, the zionists want peace, but can't do without exporting death, er, arms to others to support themselves. Shake your head a few times and join reality. Golly, unbelievable.
"Oh, yeah, such heroic stock." You should come from it, David. (;-) CF
but when the Palestinians resist occupation they are automatically assigned the name `terrorists`. Margaret Sometimes it is well deserved. But YOU do have an automatic and canned response.
What a funny post ie "The Palestinians are here to stay" ... well since they're only a few decades old at this point, I suppose that would be no big deal but "to stay" ? Does that mean for a hundred years? Or until some new Pan Arab charismatic leader comes along and Shazzzam the UAR is invented, but I bet you don't even know what I'm talking about do you? Obviously Jim, you don't know very much about ME history and probably as a good leftiest, you haven't yet explored the skill of Pallywood and Hezbollywood and their ability to make even you believe in myths ... nevertheless, all you display here is your silly naiveness and willingness to swallow whole all the revisionist history your "Palestinians" can dish out. Eat up Jim ...
Well I hate to agree with Hamas's bonehead leader but this time he has a point. So Israel will kindly remove a tiny fraction of the pain and misery they inject daily into Palestinian life and in return Pals give up all resistance to the occupation. SO Israel only has to remove something it put in place in the first place and the Pals are held to no resistance. Nice Deal, sounds great. Get of their flippen land, remove the need for Hamas, stop this pitiful joke about how poor Israel can't have peace, Israel can organise Peace in less than 12 months, but in reality it doesn't want peace. Peace means no more "confiscation" of land, no more settlements etc , all things it can't bring itself to accept as it's a greedy bully.
".....what a absurd pathetic joke to think peace israel has any sort of peace partner!!! The u.s. will turn on israel for short term gains at the cost of long term strategy!!" In geopolitics there are no friends... Right! Peace Israel??? What's that? No peace partner??? How sad. Long term strategy??? Winograd had something to say about that. Stop whining! You still have US money to buy weapons so you can flush those incompetant , embecilic morons in Gaza down the drain. What do you want for nothing? King Solomon's mines?
Whats really absolutely amazing is how many people believe the occupation just came about out of thin air and/or because the Jews just "prefer" to occupy Palestinian Arabs. Margaret, go and have a word with Jordan and Egypt and ask them why they walked away from Gaza and the West Bank ? And while your at it, maybe you ought to ask yourself why you hadn't any problems when these two countries "occupied" this territory. After that, ask yourself what any country would do if their neighbors propagandized to their children to kill and their leaders vowed never to make any peace. Article 13 of the Hamas Charter states: Initiatives, and so-called peaceful solutions and international conferences, are in contradiction to the principles of the Islamic Resistance Movement. Abusing any part of Palestine is abuse directed against part of religion Finally Margaret, stop being so naive. Your Islamists don't want peace with Jews now or ever and have said so again and again.
Since the proposal was made, Hamas leaders have said they will not stop firing rockets into Israel. Five rockets have been fired since Friday with one of them hitting a home in Sderot. I assume that Ms Rice and Mr Bush still consider these "people" still peace partners with whom Israel must negotiate. Shades of Jimmy Carter and his wonderful Nobel Prize efforts to destroy Israel. Le meme change plus de meme,
margaret: "when a few Jews resisted in the Warsaw Ghetto they were hailed as heroes...when the Palestinians resist occupation they are automatically assigned the name `terrorists`." margaret, Jews in the Warsaw ghetto did not murder German civilians in Berlin cafes and on buses, Palestinians, on the other hand do target and kill Israeli civilians. This is why we call them terrorists. Also, to make your example valid, Israel needs to kill ALL the Palestinians - men, women, children in Gaza, instead Israel minimized loss of life on Palestinian side.
There is still one unfinished business to complete and that is MESHAL.
You are sure of what it is,I am not and yet you call me Black and White.The reason I choose the defensive tact is that its the best choices for me in this situation. I dont know exactly what the arabs want so I take the worst case scenerio because taking anything but a conservative approach could be deadly.My view is show me.You know why? because we have the status quo and its lucky we do.I want a fair deal all the way around,I am not into this biblical history stuff but I dont trust.Maybe there are those that trust and they have bought into it but they dont quetsion either or if they do they rationalize. Find me some arabs that are willing to face their own fundamentalists and Ill show you many Jews if not most who are flexible.
All one has to do is read the Marxist and Communist trained propaganda oozing out of the P.L.O. to interpret their motives. This propaganda serves only to twist and propagate a false conflit for a false issue for a false people against the legitimate rights and freedoms of the democratic people of the State of Israel. You don't negotiate your Independence, you fight for it. These people, the Palestinian Arabs, have never been, nor are currently interested in peace with you.
What you call the ceasefire in Gaza means firing missiles into Israel. I can understand why Hamas would want to extend it but I can't see any reason why Israel would agree. Let the Iranian-stooge groups, Hamas and the others, do themselves a favour, release Shalit and observe the ceasefire agreement they signed for Gaza. Now that is what makes sense.
This is a 'tough stance?' We ask -- ask while making it clear she doesn't HAVE to comply -- Israel to make a few minor adjustments for the sake of progress towards peace while at the same time making it clear she'll still get her five billion a year in arms, her automatic veto at the UN, her rush arms deliveries when she gets a bit carried away slaughtering the neighbors, her cease-fires when she needs to get out of trouble. Boy, we're being tough. It's like with my son who robs liquor stores. Well, no more Mr Nice Guy: I proposed some guidelines. Nothing about how I might stop buying him ammunition for his assault rifle or anything. 'Just an idea son: maybe you could leave a store or two operating so the neighbors could buy milk and diapers and things...oh, you're upset by my words? Sorry I said anything...' Yessir: that's laying down the law. Real tough.
Where have all the postings gone? Long time passing Where have all the postings gone? Long time ago Where have all the postings gone? Slowman ate them every one When will he ever quit? When will he ever quit? Where have all the censors gone? Long time passing Where have all the censors gone? Long time ago Where have all the censors gone? Gone to party every one When will they ever work? When will they ever work?
the "rewards of man". However, a peacemaker cannot be a peacemaker by choosing sides. The American government has a very long way to go in understanding Israel's conflicts. And unless they begin to set a better example of their own "moral compass", they will never suceed in directing anyone toward peace. The American Government is no different than any other, in that they all stand in the same place. And that place is called In Need Of Prayer!!!
What makes this all a "farce" is not so much what Hamas says, but the fact that the USA is already back-tracking and hastening to say that nothing will be "imposed" on Israel.....Not even this minimum of permitting Pal movement within its own territory....
I will await responses to your succint, well written question to the naysayers. Always enjoy your posts. Keep blogging. Regards. Ballistic.
Dubya says that train can stall, derail, run out of diesel, lose one wheel, hit an overpass, destroy a stuck car on its track and lose its headlight, but it is gonna limp into the station. We will just have to wait to see. However, your glee that the train is stalled, according to your report, is not masked, not even an attempt at masking it, which MANY folks have noted. Nope, many Zionists don't want peace cause they don't wanna give up the land. That is understandable. Regards.
you got it all. No need to serve me up condescension. I have a better understanding of this mess than you. I read everything available and watch as much news on everything but FOX and read the internet to get different points of view from different people, incl relevant books. In fact, reading commentary and works of your prominent brethren, more intelligent than you, who lay out the case against what you are pushing here was very helpful. What is their motive to spin and lie? Well, of course, you, Kath, Danite and other assorted apologists dismiss them as "fringe". Well, you gotta love it. Say there are some pointed opposing posts on here, well written, have you responded to their irrefutable points. I'll go back and see and if you have not, I will send you the numbers to see how you spin what they said. Regards.
.....And Just As Clueless! And so are the rest of you out there who really think this is Bush's Policy. He could not find Iraq on a globe without help, much less Israel. Intellectual and Moral bankruptcy aren't conducive to forming a coherent foreign policy. His role, subservient to the Vice President, et al, is limited to repeating scripted phrases for an equally intellectual vacuum, Mid America, and not fully understanding the meaning or consequences . "Do As I Say, Not AS I Do", is as close to admitting hypocracy you can expect. Iraq is not what initiated the decline of US prestige; it happened in the election booth in Nov 1999!
You may not like it, Mark, but the US is stuck in the Middle East and will be back. This time, as in many other occasions, it is the US' own fault that its latest plan is rejected by everybody; it does not address the real situation. (take a look at my post #174.) The best thing would have been for the US to tell the Europeans: How about you coming up with a plan? Your understanding is so much better than ours. But for some reason Bush thinks he got some brain. My real amazement is triggered when I see academics, like Condi Rice in this case, not able to think something thru. Academics are supposed to be experts in thinking. What is wrong with Condi?
You gotta love these guys. Fatah would "accept" the terms 100% then fund terrorists to sabatoge. These guys say whats on their mind. But remember, they want you to fund them because they are the elected government. Who says we have to fund murders just because they are elected. Hitler was elected too.
where you get your news. It must be FOX as again you have put forth another patently false statement. I doubt those on the border would agree with you at all. Try watching Lou Dobbs, who is fixated on the # of Mexicans who are here and continue to come. Down 40%, yeah, right.
Say, once our beloved troops come home so we can stop hemorrhaging money and we stop BLIND support for Israel, you won't hear from most of the opponents of bad behavior by Israel. No point in our people dying and throwing good money after bad such that we can't take care of our own for a very failed ME policy. I don't live on this site as you and Kath do. Some days I post, sometimes I don't. I assume the blog exists for folks around the world to post. Perhaps you and yours should not have given the Germans an interest in Haaretz and kept it to a family affair where chronic victimhood could be discussed by like minds with no outside interference. So, what about it. After US is out, warmongers can float their own boat down that polluted river/sea they created, according to Haaretz, of course.
Dear Mr Clickfool. In response to your comments to the above person (which I do agree with you on); I was just wondering if you have ever been to, or lived in Israel as you seem to have some very strong opinions. I do think some of your comments are fair, but being a Brit we are exposed to news which is biased against Israel. This I believe was proven last week when the BBC refused to release a report on this very issue. Do let me know on your thoughts.... Thanks
What kind of crisis in Israel are you talking about? The economy is red hot - electronics, particularly computers and their chips are doing amazingly well and that includes advances in invention. Medicalresearch is doing well along with its export arms industry.If you think that Israel is not interested in peace, you ought to do some reading in the subject. Have you ever heard of the 3 no's, as an example of the Arabs' refusal to deal with peace in the ME? After the Israeli victory in the 1967 war,the Arab belligerents got together and agreed on the 3 no's: No peace with Israel. No recognition of Israel. No negotiation with Israel. Google the three no.s.Have a great weekend.
I cut and pasted parts of the Paletinian Media Watch report, and there are question marks replacing the apostrophe after Allah's name every time the word is mentioned. Very weird.
Howdy Jim; The U.S. cannot "demand" that Israel allow bus services between the West Bank and the Gaza Strip across 40 Km. of her sovereign territory under the threat of suspending military aid because the demand is coming from the State Dept. (executive branch) and the military aid is coming from Congress (legislative branch). It would be political suicide for any Congressman to vote against continuing military aid to Israel to the tune of $2.4 billion/yr. especially when she is an important ally in the War On Terrorism and Congress is not subject to orders from the U.S. Department of State. You said, "The Palestinians are here to stay!" That's fine with me just as long as they stay on their side of the security barriers and never set foot on Israeli sovereign territory ever again.
Would the US allow the revoutionary guards of Iran to bus from Iran to Jordan or would Saudi Arabia allow the Rev gauards of Iran to bus through their territory to Yemen?
They prevent Pali's from hurting themselves and innocent Israeli's.. I would really hate to see a Pali bus blow up because a homicide bomber was on board who pushed the detonator button at the wrong moment. Checkpoints check passengers to make certain they can't do damage.
You only have to go back in time to March 1920, when Arabs attacked Jewish settlement at Tel Hai. Advance to 1929 & 1936, when Arabs attacked Hebron's jews, killing many, raping the women, forcing the survivors to flee for their lives. Now all you have to do is Google "Wikipedia's "TIMELINES OF ARAB-ISRAEL CONFLICT" and realize who started the first war in 1948. Go ahead, stop spouting off, educate yourself instead...........Beginning-1948 Jewish immigration into the Land of Israel/Palestine under the Ottoman rule and later under British mandate increased tensions between the Jewish population and the Arab population in the region.[5] By the end of World War II, the conflict became a major international issue. The United Nations, the United States, and the Soviet Union were determined to initiate a two-state solution. The UN mandated partition was put into effect in 1948, but was rejected by the Palestinians and many Arab states.[6] Israel declared its independence on May 14, 1948. Almost immediately, Egypt, Lebanon, Syria, Transjordan, and Iraq declared war on the nascent nation. By the conclusion of the 1948 Arab-Israeli War, Israel had greatly expanded its borders, and signed ceasefire agreements with all its Arab neighbors.[7] [edit] 1949-June 11, 1967 In 1949, Egypt closed the Straits of Tiran to Israeli shipping, and blockaded the Gulf of Aqaba, in contradiction to the terms of the Constantinople Convention of 1888. Many argued that this action also constituted a violation of the Rhodes armistice agreement.[8][9] On July 26, 1956, Egypt nationalized the Suez Canal Company, and closed the canal to Israeli shipping.[10] Israel responded on October 29, 1956, by invading the Sinai Peninsula with British and French support. During the Suez Canal Crisis, Israel captured the Gaza Strip and Sinai Peninsula. The United States and the United Nations soon pressured it into a ceasefire,[10][11] which secured open shipping in the region, complete Israeli withdrawal from Egyptian territory, and the total demilitarization of the Sinai. The United Nations Emergency Force (UNEF) was deployed to oversee said demilitarization.[12] On May 19, 1967, Egypt expelled UNEF observers,[13] and deployed 100,000 soldiers in the Sinai Peninsula.[14] It then closed the straits of Tiran to Israeli shipping,[15][16] catapulting the region back to the pre-1956 status quo. On May 30, 1967, Jordan entered into the mutual defense pact between Egypt and Syria. President Nasser declared: "Our basic objective is the destruction of Israel. The Arab people want to fight."[17] In response, on June 5 Israel sent almost all of its planes on a preemptive mission in Egypt. The Israeli Air Force (AIF) destroyed most of the surprised Egyptian Air Force, then turned east to pulverize the Jordanian, Syrian and Iraqi air forces.[18] This strike was the crucial element in Israel's victory in the Six-Day War.[14][16] [edit] June 12, 1967-1973 In the summer of 1967, Arab leaders met in Khartoum in response to the war, to discuss the Arab position toward Israel. They reached consensus that there should be: No recognition of the State of Israel. No peace with Israel. No negotiations with Israel.[19] In 1969, Egypt initiated the War of Attrition, with the goal of exhausting Israel into surrendering the Sinai Peninsula.[20] The war ended following Nasser's death in 1970. On October 6, 1973, Syria and Egypt attacked Israel on Yom Kippur, overwhelming the surprised Israeli military.[21][22] The Yom Kippur War accommodated indirect confrontation between the US and the Soviet Union. When Israel had turned the tide of war, the USSR threatened military intervention. The United States, wary of nuclear war, secured a ceasefire on October 25.[21][22]
The Palis are here to stay for sure. But whether or not there leaders(?) allow the poor people to stop being perpetual pawns of the Arab leaders of other countries. As long as they have the common enemy of Israel then no threats to their rule will occur. If you look hard, you will realize that Israel would make peace in a heart-beat if only the terror groups would be satisfied not to destroy the country. Look what they are doing to all the other non-Muslim countries that they border.
Google Wikipedia's "TIMELINES OF ARAB-ISRAEL CONFLICT", you might just learn who started the mess Arabs inflicted upon themselves. Here's part, google and read the rest....Beginning-1948 Jewish immigration into the Land of Israel/Palestine under the Ottoman rule and later under British mandate increased tensions between the Jewish population and the Arab population in the region.[5] By the end of World War II, the conflict became a major international issue. The United Nations, the United States, and the Soviet Union were determined to initiate a two-state solution. The UN mandated partition was put into effect in 1948, but was rejected by the Palestinians and many Arab states.[6] Israel declared its independence on May 14, 1948. Almost immediately, Egypt, Lebanon, Syria, Transjordan, and Iraq declared war on the nascent nation. By the conclusion of the 1948 Arab-Israeli War, Israel had greatly expanded its borders, and signed ceasefire agreements with all its Arab neighbors.[7] [edit] 1949-June 11, 1967 In 1949, Egypt closed the Straits of Tiran to Israeli shipping, and blockaded the Gulf of Aqaba, in contradiction to the terms of the Constantinople Convention of 1888. Many argued that this action also constituted a violation of the Rhodes armistice agreement.[8][9] On July 26, 1956, Egypt nationalized the Suez Canal Company, and closed the canal to Israeli shipping.[10] Israel responded on October 29, 1956, by invading the Sinai Peninsula with British and French support. During the Suez Canal Crisis, Israel captured the Gaza Strip and Sinai Peninsula. The United States and the United Nations soon pressured it into a ceasefire,[10][11] which secured open shipping in the region, complete Israeli withdrawal from Egyptian territory, and the total demilitarization of the Sinai. The United Nations Emergency Force (UNEF) was deployed to oversee said demilitarization.[12] On May 19, 1967, Egypt expelled UNEF observers,[13] and deployed 100,000 soldiers in the Sinai Peninsula.[14] It then closed the straits of Tiran to Israeli shipping,[15][16] catapulting the region back to the pre-1956 status quo. On May 30, 1967, Jordan entered into the mutual defense pact between Egypt and Syria. President Nasser declared: "Our basic objective is the destruction of Israel. The Arab people want to fight."[17] In response, on June 5 Israel sent almost all of its planes on a preemptive mission in Egypt. The Israeli Air Force (AIF) destroyed most of the surprised Egyptian Air Force, then turned east to pulverize the Jordanian, Syrian and Iraqi air forces.[18] This strike was the crucial element in Israel's victory in the Six-Day War.[14][16] [edit] June 12, 1967-1973 In the summer of 1967, Arab leaders met in Khartoum in response to the war, to discuss the Arab position toward Israel. They reached consensus that there should be: No recognition of the State of Israel. No peace with Israel. No negotiations with Israel.[19] In 1969, Egypt initiated the War of Attrition, with the goal of exhausting Israel into surrendering the Sinai Peninsula.[20] The war ended following Nasser's death in 1970. On October 6, 1973, Syria and Egypt attacked Israel on Yom Kippur, overwhelming the surprised Israeli military.[21][22] The Yom Kippur War accommodated indirect confrontation between the US and the Soviet Union. When Israel had turned the tide of war, the USSR threatened military intervention. The United States, wary of nuclear war, secured a ceasefire on October 25.[21][22]
Hello Dana, I am anxious to know what your criteria, and conclusions, are. Did not see the police profile. Perhaps you can update and republish. I assumed you were going through some statistical analysis, for which you will need to select some choice expressions. Would really be interesting to see. Tosefta
The first sentence says it all.It also shows the mentality behind the knee jerk attacks on Israel no matter what the Arabs say or do. WHICH PART OF THE FOLLOWING CAN'T ISRAEL BASHERS UNDERSTAND ""The American plan is rejected and we will work to make it fail by any means and by all means," said Fawzi Baroum, a Hamas spokesman in Gaza, echoing comments by Hamas' political leader Khaled Meshal. The militant group Popular Resistance Committees also rejected the document. "The U.S. plan does not serve our people's interests," said PRC spokesman Abu Abeer on Saturday, vowing that "the [PRC] will work to make it fail."
Last time I took a count, Ballistic had consumed over 50 letters in a thread. She's improved,, of the 463 letters in this thread, only 31 were her repetetive hatred. Have a another sip of Jonestown Koolaid with hemlock, it appears to be working.
"In revenge for the killed militants, their terror organizations fire rockets from Gaza. Why from Gaza? Because that`s were they have some freedom of action" - Tosefta "And in return for the rockets being fired from Gaza because Israel cannot make roadblocks in Gaza they make them in the West Bank. Now you might call on the chicken and the egg to decide who started the situation" - Ronnie W. Ronnie, better start reading the papers and pay attention to DETAILS. The Roadblocks in WB have nothing to do with Gaza. There is real danger from the West Bank, with weapons and Suicide bombers. Roadblocks are not punishment. (Never mind that such is forbidden by Geneva Convention.) There is no point in discussing the matter based on fantasies. It is either Humpty or me.
Howdy Tosefta; In the first place, a checkpoint is not a roadblock. I'm sure that you can figure out the difference. 99% of the time, a Palestinian in Jenin can travel to Hebron, say, if he/she is willing to be searched for contraband several times, but he/she is not prohibited from doing so. I don't why the U.S. State Dept. managed to get this one so screwed up. First, it was a list of demands with a rigid timetable that both sides were supposed to meet. Then, the Israeli PMO expressed reservations about some of it due to genuine security concerns. Then, a senior State Dept. official backpedals and says that the proposal is not to be imposed on anybody and that the timetable was only "suggestive". Finally, Hamas and the PRC reject the proposal in its entirety. This new U.S. plan is DOA and I can't believe how naive and half-assed it was to begin with. What's the matter with the U.S. State Dept.? This entire initiative seems to have been concoted by a bunch of headless chicken
Help them set up an economy? This didn't seem to work in 1947 when the British proposed a joint Jewish-Arab economic structure between 2 sovereign states. It was vehemently opposed with acts of war and aggression against Jews. Perhaps if the Pals and other A-rabs didn't hate Jews so much they might be sharing in their economic prosperity right now. BTW, where is the economic aid coming from the oil rich Arab states? Oh yea, it only goes to fund more terror in the Holy Land....
It's clear you haven't read it. And I notice that you are still shouting yourself hoarse.Keep it down,will you ?
The Arabs committed to stopping violence in the Oslo Accords; for the Israeli government to give up something else in exchange for what they already paid for is beyond stupid and it is why Jews are still at risk and why Israel still does not have peace. The Israeli goverments are constantly negotiating with themselves...no wonder they never get the deal they want. The motivational speaker Zig Ziglar tells us it is OK to talk to yourself, and it is OK to ask yourself questions and it is OK to answer those questions, but when you find yourself saying Huuuhhh??? to the answers you give yourself to your own questions, then you are in trouble; and this is exactly where we find the government of Israel.
Storm clouds are welcome. Israel is a dry climate. In the event of a sudden downpour, we have our Mushroom Cloud shaped umbrella, which will cover a wide area. Sit back, sip your Koolaid with hemlock. the drink is very relaxing. If you prefix your reply with one of your sub-idiotic "Hey", it will be left unopen and unread.
New Mexico & Australia are twins when it comes to Jew haters. Must be something in the air that causes such bitterness. Notice they're expressing their hate from a safe distance, too cowardly to go where the action is. Guess they're afraid to stand in front of a bulldozer to defend those they claim to love so much.
Just to make sure that there is no misunderstan- ding Ronnie, with "bye, bye Mr. Nice Guy" I didn't mean you (although you surely would deserve that attribute...). I had of course the Wayne Gretzky kind of politicians in mind.... And nothing said against Wayne Gretzky with that, he truly was a great sportsman. But I am afraid he couldn't be a successful envoy for the ME....
Just a reminder. Anytime you prefix a message to me with "Hey", it get's tossed, I don't bother to open it or read it's contents. Now you can sit back and enjoy another cup of the Jonestown Koolaid, with a touch of hemlock.
You make a valid point. Most ordinary folk in the UK at any rate, always saw the Soviet Union as the greater evil, even whilst disagreeing with much US policy. The trouble with some of the 'flaky' left,(as you correctly call them)is they espouse the idea of 'moral relativism' whereby all the gross excesses and evil intent of the third world or anti-Western despots is excused under the cloak of 'western induced poverty and colonialism', whilst all attempts at exercising American influence is derided and condemned without thought.It has always been fashionable amongst the intellectual hard left to plough this furrow. It never quite catches on though. ie: the man on the street doesn't buy the crap they peddle. After 9/11 we were all Americans.Still are,by and large.
Could you do me a favour dana? Please look at the mairovich thread and maybe you could walk tosefta through the quiz in my post "can someone help tosefta.I really dont know what to do with him.I prove him wrong yet he repeats over and over again the same faulty assertions as if repetition itself proves their veracity.You seem to be one of the few that can penetrate his self serving and mendacious obscurantism designed to justify his self hatred with the anti semitism of others, even though he cant even ascribe the correct anti semitic charge to the correct anti semite.For example he says hitler was motivated by the supposed jewish sense of superiority and seperatness yet Hitler claims it was the degree of jewish assimilation that disturbed him.Anyway maybe you can help here, i am at a loss, he seems to be beyond the reach of reason, thanks alot!! Regards
#440: Your attitude is that of fool who doesn't know he's one.Let's take the issue of aid to Israel.That is the biggest bargain around. No GIs have been killed fighting Israel's wars of survival.That saves a bundle of lives and truck loads of cash. Besides Israel has had some very practical experience with USSR/Russian equipment and advanced US military systems as well as their own.This has saved the US billions in re-engineering and R&D costs.In addition, Israeli intel and security have provided major savings. So don't be so cute in your lack of knowledge about the ME. Ignorance can be cured by knowledge. Have a wonderful weekend.
ANY COMMENTS ISRAEL BASHERS"CLAIMING TO BE PEACEMAKERS"???
mystery, but I beg to differ.Chile: direct U.S. involvement in the overthrow of Allende.U.S. 's crimes in its former backyard are legion.No space to go into that.The fine distinction between neo con policies and old guard A.imperialism is interesting but in the larger scheme of things not useful.Neo con is just Israel added into the mix,the Israeli connection with colonialism goes back to the old imperialist Britain. Dana, so the mystery is cleared at least as far the present post is concerned but not the first two which T.himself said were not his.But keep up the good work Sherlock ! Ben Alof, my first intro. to you.Thanks for the kind words.Look forward to reading more of your fine posts and your work.Yes,YS.put it succintly.The problem is the Occupation.Everything else is smoke and mirrors.Re: Dana he is also our resident philsopher(possibly of science). Did ask him whether you could connect Godel's proof to the controversy between Hegelian pan logism and Derrida's andL's infinity.
"Pay the heavy price now, live free or die." Do you address that line to Israel or to Palestine? I have news for you: the Palestinians are here to stay! All the king's horses and all the king's men will not end this crisis for Israel. She will either waste herself making war forever, or wise up and take the road toward peace.
Cipora, I think the correct saying in Switzerland is: "Some women have a heart of gold, some have a heart of stone, and some have no heart at all...". To be honest, a heart of gold I could neither find in your, nor in Kaths posts concerning that subject.... As much as I tried....
It's absolutely amazing to me that anyone in his right mind would find it unreasonable for a people to resist a brutal occupation. Why would Israel and the USA expect the Palestinians to just roll over and accept an apartheid state where their every move was governed by an occupying force that is determinded to take every square inch of Palestinian territory even if it means killing every last Palestinian? When Americans resisted British rule and when a few Jews resisted in the Warsaw Ghetto they were hailed as heroes for all time, but when the Palestinians resist occupation they are automatically assigned the name 'terrorists'.
But Joe, You miss the point! Just think of all those $$$ that go from the American taxpayer's pocket into the coffers of the arms manufacturers! And when all is said and done America does love her economy - especially the Republicans! Right? Right!
Israel and Palestine have told the United States to get lost. They are unanimous and I suggest Uncle Sam take his money and go home.
I think Abbas would be willing for a realistic compromise as are many palestinians.If israel would only stop is pathetic and futile rear guard action for the relics of the failed and deluded greater israel policy and cut a deal with Abbas on the basis of taba geneva, abbas with the support of the arab league could force hamas to disarm.it is not as black and white as you suggest.Regards
The United States can demand that Israel allow bus services between Gaza and the West Bank simply because the US supplies the IDF with all that hardware that makes land-grabbing and settler-infiltration a success. Get the chip off your shoulder, Cipora, and wise up. The Palestinians are here to stay!
Ben Alofs loves the reasoned argumentation of lakshmi he says, lakshmi who went into hysterics because tosefta dared to suggest that the US fought the evil of the soviet union, the only reason? Tosefta now must be a fake poster!!! it never ceases to amaze me to see the serial and systematic nature of the denial you of the flake left go into at the drop of a hat.it is as if it is a learned and automatic response.As long as the ideology suits you and your agendas,a mule taliking out of his a.s would be King Genius amoungst you.
Tosefta: 'In revenge for the killed militants, their terror organizations fire rockets from Gaza. Why from Gaza? Because that`s were they have some freedom of action' And in return for the rockets being fired from Gaza because Israel cannot make roadblocks in Gaza they make them in the West Bank. Now you might call on the chicken and the egg to decide who started the situation and you would be right about Israeli manipulation and instigation but pre that is something called intent and that intent is of the arab groups who are sworn to destroy Israel,its in their maps,badges and charter.THAT IS THE BOTTOM LINE.
IN ADDITION TOO SUPPLYING AL QAEDA AND HEZBOLLAH WITH WEAPONS...
looks like your "peace train" has stalled in Damascus, again. More brilliant Pal diplomacy by Meshal.
There is only an indirect connection between roadblocks in the West Bank and rockets from Gaza. Israel wants to secure the West Bank. For this reason it carries out military operations there and sets up Roadblocks to prevent arms transfer from place to place. The result of the military operations is that Palestinian militants as well as civilians get killed. In revenge for the killed militants, their terror organizations fire rockets from Gaza. Why from Gaza? Because that's were they have some freedom of action. In recently, to avenge the many civilians killed, Hamas started firing too. You would think that one should first take care of the DIRECT reason for the Qassams: Extend the cease-fire to the West Bank (as I pointed out in #174). But the US is not clever to this extent. Dumbya is still Dumbya, and we haven't heard of him undergoing a brain transplant operation. It should have been expected that Hamas will reject the US proposal. How does it address their concerns? What should be done is to start with a cease fire in the West Bank, as I outline in #272. Maybe Condi will get it by the next time she comes to visit.
And you? What brilliance have you come up with? Your comprehension is sorely lacking. You really should speak less and listen and read much more. I bet you only read headlines in the TIMES and watch MSNBC. Since you get cable, try watching some BBCA or CNN. Then read the Persian Journal, Arab News, JPost, Guardian, Herald-Sun, and a myriad of other news available online.
1, Abbas do as he said he would do after the elections; disarm the militias(he failed). 2. The informal ceasfire by the terror groups from Gaza violated over and over..... 3. The use of the agreement by Israel that ceded a border(Rafah) with Egtpt to Pa control has been violated with the connivance of the EU. 4. Did I mention the failure of the PA unity givt to recognize Israel....what is the basis of an agreement and with whos name in the BUSH administration is this latest travesty of Rice being forwarded by......
See the contest coming up. Then we'll talk. BTW - did you see my police profile of the suspect the other day? perhaps if we add your criteria to mine, we'll have something. Perhaps I'll post again the final version. Am down to 2 candidates + one runner up.
Ronnie, if your analysis is correct ( and I think it is extremly correct...), then the decision makers in the International community should rather start to use the iron fist, both to the Arabs and Israel. If we wanna take Ice Hockey (you see I am trying to deceive my faker-buddy; I just hope he doesn't hate hockey either...) we would rather need a Mario Lemieux or a Ken Baumgartner now than a Wayne Gretzky. No more sweet talking needed, bye-bye Mr. Nice Guy....
Yes, we are all fed up.
Like anything anyone says on this talkback will change the world? Yes, I do support Israel, just like you support jihadists.
Good nose, Dana. Post #400 was written by me, of course. And that Lakshmi post was by the real one too. In the US she would have been known as a true blue liberal. I mentioned the Gandhi approach a long time ago. Nothing new here. Too bad the Pals didn't use it, because it would have been effective. But Islamic culture is what it is, and Israel needs to deal with what it confronts.
Putin is stepping down next year. He has been made totally irrelevent. Has more problems in Eastern Europe then he can handle.
Funny thing about all that, illegal entry into the US is down 40%. I call that a very good start, no matter what Bush wants or says.
Hello to you, Lakshmi and Dana. Just to let you know that Talkback has definitely become enriched by both of your postings. I like the quality of your reasoning and especially appreciate Dana's light hearted humour, of which we definitely need more here. Re Tosefta I agree with Dana, Lakshmi. Post #400 to me reads like vintage Tosefta (old BG). Which brings me to the subject of faking. Most of the time is is clear when a post is faked, but there have been times where words were put in the mouth of a named poster by a faker with the aim of character assassination. It's not cricket. Personally I find it tasteless and proof that the faker is not interested in open and frank discussion, but rather in messing up or sabotaging this valuable forum for exchange of opinions. Many regards and looking forward to reading more of your postings. Ben
"Not everything they [US] did was correct, but in the larger scheme of things the US saved many countries from the fate of Eastern Europe. India chose to be a neutral country and nobody invaded it. Nations were not forced into servitude. (But you can complain about Iran, Chile, etc. Still, the local forces ruled.)" - Tosefta Lakshmi, it's the real me. It takes some time to get to know a person. Once you started talking positively about post-colonialist and deconstructionist reading, I learned to expect your previous (anti-imperialist) post to me. I mentioned Chile myself, which might be called "imperialist" interference, although it was carried out by local forces, so it would require a re-definition of the term. But on a larger scale, Latin America became by and large democratic. I suggest you incorporate a larger view into your ideology. I will not compare the Iraq war to previous US, Cold War behavior. The neo-con ideology is indeed imperialistic. The Iraq invasion was an act of imperialism. I made this distinction earlier in #400. Without distinctions, all talk is not worthy of academic consideration. P.S. For Hebrew speakers there is no distinction in sound between g and gh, or d and dh. Just a matter of memory.
Your frustration is understandable. As for my concerns with supporting Israel, you seem to be posting here a lot more then I do. You are like a lot of other people, blaming and whining and nothing constructive to offer. Rah Rah, Hey, Gee Whiz!!
You are right and that is why we all must try to make things better for everyone.
You need anger management my dear. Perhaps you could also ask your parents if they could teach you how to behave like a human being. I am against warmongers, and those who murder and/or take away the human rights of others. I don't care who is responsible, I care that we find a way to stamp it all out and make the world as peaceful as possible. I speak out against all violence in all people whether in war or one on one. I speak for a decent standard of human rights for all. Obviously your own guilt makes you hit out at me because you know that I unlike you stand for peace. I love my name and I am not at all suprised that you are unable to understand my wisdom. Hate will destroy you.
I support all people and peace for all and my posts here reflect that. It's this attitude of division that causes the problems. We all need to stand together for peace. The only division should be those who wish for peace and those who prefer war. Don't you understand that you can't have peace if they can't have peace? Oh and if your childish remark about 'an odd name for an Arab woman' is supposed to hurt me in anyway, you have missed your mark because I'm not a racist. Grow up!
."..asking Israel to have a clear mind at the moment and be wise is like asking a woman to make love to the man she is planning on divorcing..." Analogy not quite working. Check it out: Israel = woman clear mind = making love (is that how it works in NY? should look into this sometime - I mean the clean mind part) being wise = getting a divorce (now that's true sometimes) On the other hand, I have it on good authority that sometimes things (the making love part) work out best just when the end is in sight. You know - losing something can make the heart grow fonder, etc. etc. Therefore, maybe the analogy is working just fine - but in the opposite direction of what you intended. It's OK. You get one rewrite.
stunt.I'll give you some criteria about who the FAKE is: 1.The spelling of Gandhi as Ghandi is a typical mistake by Americans,especially of an older generation. 2.His anger at America being criticised. 3. The examples he gives of well may be America did something bad. . . Clearly,an American patriot.Someone who fought for America ? 4.The compulsion to use Tosefta's name ? Eacth time and everytime. Why not Dana or anybody else? He always uses T's name,suggesting an unconscious identification with T. possibly someone who interacts frequently with T's posts. 5.His lack of knowledge of the economic trends right now.T. would certainly know those trends. 6.In general,an ill informed post. Given my criteria 1 to 6, who do you think is the FAKE? 3 guesses.
I mean any parent or indeed any person preaching and teaching hatred and racism so that the cycle of murder and destruction never ever ends. As adults we all owe children the best world we can build for them. I do understand the strength of hatred in some people and I even see why they feel that way but the only way forwards is to rise above those feelings and adults (particularly parents) should be willing to do anything to make the world better for the next generation.
It is not easy to capture the essence of Israeli policies in a few sentences, like you did. Thanks for putting it so succinctly. Israel's continued unwillingness to give up the occupation in defiance of the will of the international community is a convincing argument why divestment and boycott of Israeli goods, cultural ties, the Israel Medical Association is becoming more and more justified. Israel in this respect looks very much like apartheid South Africa when it stubbornly defied the will of the international community until international and internal pressure became too big and it had to give in. That's why I as a medical practitioner have signed the petition here in the UK calling for a boycott of the Israel Medical Association and its ousting from the World Medical Association. We will meet again as colleagues in the future and I would be happy to buy Israeli goods, but only after the end of the 40 year old Occupation. Enough is enough!
What is 'The Palestinian Cause'???? The badges that all the groups carry is all of Israel.This IS the cause.'Resistance' is a misnomer.It is a cover for this end.What land is 'occupied'???? All of what is Israel???? Why do they carry these badges????? If we can get that clear at least we will understand the situation better. The idea of a poor,sad,victimized people is merchandising for the real end game and that is outlined in this badges and in the charter.
Lately - some new sentiments and revelations in Tosefta posts. This one could be real though there are a couple of somewhat out of character statements. may be we shouldn't put so much faith in the immutability of his or anyone's opinions, as expressed here. I was also surprised to see the reference to imperialism and recommending gandiesque stance to palestinians is nice (we all know it would have worked), but it's like telling zebras that they should really negotiate with the lions for reasonable quotas on herd culling. Would work. Not done. Anyways, he could just be trying a few new things. I mean it does get old to always have to carry the same baggage. I've been wondering myself lately whether consistency is as much of a virtue as I thought. On the other hand, how do I know this was not a fake Lakshmi? Ah, the trials and tribulations of the talkback!
agreement with the PA in November 2005 to allow access and movement.It did not honour it.In fact, it increased its oppression.This happens all the time.Arafat signed Oslo only to find that settlements had increased.Hamas agreed to a truce last year and kept it.Some commentators said that Israeli towns had not known such quiet for a long time.And then what did Israel do ? It went in and killed one of their commanders.And then the kidnapping of Shalit followed by Israel's rampage in Gaza.And so on. The so called demands by the U.S. are something of a smoke screen.The only thing that Israel should be asked to do is to come to the table and negotiate the Arab Peace Initiative.Everything else is stalling and stonewalling.
The document is a small step in the right direction. Total removal of the embargo is truly needed and should be absolutely done. Instead of saying No, Mishel should demand to discuss these points and present his case as a continuation of the dialogue and Israel needs to be honorable about its intentions. Both sides are reserved ..not only the Palestinians. So, at the moment, Israel has got a lot of internal problems and asking Israel to have a clear mind at the moment and be wise is like asking a woman to make love to the man she is planning on divorcing... Only with the presence of Moses, Jesus and Mohamad can we solve this issue... and they ain't 'comin anytime soon baby.....
Both the arabs and Israel want peace.There is no doubt.Everyone wants peace.But the end games are much more important at the moment. Israel loves the status quo and plays the game and the end game is to give up nothing.The arabs love the fight,the fighters stay in business and they love the game too,their end game,to get all of Israel.
If Jordan is "Palestine," Then "Metro NewYork/Los Angeles is Israel. The conclusion was drawn by the same twisted logic you used!
There certainly are end games.Israel wants to give up nothing and the arabs want them to give up everything.
FOR A CHANGE...
"always made demands", you mean like "we accept UNR181", signing peace treaties with Egypt and Jordan, and other agreements? Or perhaps it's terrible that we demand the Arab League, Lebanon, Syria, et al, honor the Armistice agreements. Then there's those pesky demands that the Pals live up to Oslo & the RM. Maybe it was the Camp David "demand" that agreed to almost all the Pal demands, but that still wasn't enough to Arafat restarted terror. Once again, the asp just bit himself there. What I demand is that Viper demand the Arabs unconditionally end the wars the unconditionally declared, but he's not interested in anything approaching morality or facts. Viper, JB & Maureen Ann continue to show that too many Aussies fall through the cracks of their educational system.
relax ian.... this is already happening.the americans will ensure that it does , sooner than later
Nelson: Helped build/maintain an empire where slavery was a foundation of the economy. When he was sued for illegally seizing for American ships, he bravely went into hiding for 6 months rather than go to court. TE Lawrence created many of the problems here in the ME. He conned the Brit Govt out of millions of pound sterling to give to the Hashemites who did very little to help the Brits. The Hashemites then lost a civil war for control of Mecca and Medina, but given the money & influence Lawrence gave them, they got the Brits to give them 80% of British Mandate Palestine, the "Jewish Homeland" and make that 80% judenfrei. Oh, yeah, such heroic stock.
I always said you were one smart guy!!Regards!
those rose colored glasses and pay more attention to what is going on here than in Israel. According to all your posts, all americans support the war, support Israel and your point of view. You really should get out and about more often amongst the 'common', non brethren folk. The insurance didn't pay cause they didn't want to; folks in the South, including Trent Lott, know it, so call it what it is. You think you have it all sewn up and that Americans have no idea about what you are really talking about, but you are wrong. Read a small selection of views on this thread and then extrapolate it. Your only concern is Israel and the hell with everybody else, a rather 'typical' view as has been posted by others. The homes in LV are built by Mexicans, even the multi million dollar ones; of course, to someone with your superiority attitude, nobody could do it like you. Get real, why don't you. Talks too much; no, not talking enough, but don't worry, americans will step up!
Sounds like they all just got off the boat. Dreadfully naive. Even more tragic is that the Israeli govt. still thinks its job is to accommodate US demands; the State Dept. thinks bargaining with a minority shareholder will control the majority when the minority is not controlled. Condi, you are overly-college-~educated, but should know better than to hang pinatas.
I am really sick of this man called Meshal, I do not know who elected him to speak for the Palestinians? What did he do for the Palestinians? All he says is NO No No without any practicle solution while he lives comfortably in Syria.
The only one on this thread seeing anything funny is you, but we already have one village idiot and one court jester. That's the spirit and I like it; sounds like what Nero did, yup, fiddle while all was burning. I am in awe of folks without sense enough to take an umbrella, despite its obvious need. You make my day. Regards.
it's not us or them like hamas says. That's why mechal's life could end soon...
Fatah wanting to set control with majority Hamas violently opposed to it? Voting Is A Weapon Of Mass Destruction Alon Fisher
"Why is it that your soggy little island produces wimpy buggers like you?" You mean Horatio Nelson, Winston S.Churchill, Oliver Cromwell, Francis Drake, T.E.Lawrence, David Livingstone, Florence Nightingale, William Wilberforce, Thomas Paine, Scott of the Antarctic, Ernest Shackleton... wimps like those? You should be made of such heroic stock... (;-) CF
Meshal, the chief Hamas terrorist, living in luxory in two-faced Assad's Damascus, has declared that he will "resist" till the very last Palestinian child. Palestinian democracy, so highly praised by Western far left intellectuals, is working and will continue to grow under the careful guidance of the Quartet.
There is only one way back to Civilisation and thats the way of the Saudis, not to mention Iran etc. There is a lot of talk about Sunnis and Shiites but behind that fog there is a big and ever lasting Arab unity. Yes, yes, no, no, not one inch of occupied territory and a right of return. This is not the end of Israel, but the beginning of assimilation.
The Saudi Arabian plan endorsed by the Arab League (except Libya, which supports the one-state solution, which in my mind would be better) is the best deal Israel can get. Of course, a few points must still be ironed out, like the compensation for the refugees. P.S. : degenerate is your word.
"Hamas politburo chief Khaled Mashal" A subtle daubing with hardline, Cold War, Soviet-era allusions, I do believe. Comparable to me calling the Mayor of Jerusalem Gauleiter Uri Lupolianski.
Palestine is the last colony in the world. In 2007, time has come to turn the page.
I don't think think one single rocket is acceptable. The whole rocket strategy is dumb in the first place. But then again, all the roadblocks are counterproductive, too, in my mind. Confidence building measures are fine, but in this case, I like Danite's idea. The biggest confidence measure would be to make a deal. And then have implementation of the deal be performance based. I've thought for a long time that the absence of an end game is a major obstacle. The goal shouldn't be talks, but something tangible.
i know what your saying dino, but i look at it this way, israel has always made demands, and always says it's demands must be met, never caring about the otherside, htey have negotiated previously with the road blocks and all, but have yet to still fill the agreement,i think the arabs are just so sick of them being demanded but their demands are rarely met, this time, their making demands to israel, without consessions as israel has always done, i think there peed off
by now 3 pals have been killed and Islamic Jihad has succeeded in landing a Qasam on a Sderot house. This will probably trigger what is already being described by the IDF as inevitable...the Gaza invasion. So this plan ( which the Us has no intention of enforcing) will soon find itself in the dustbin
yes..the world should insist that israel and the jews return to the 1948 partition. your redirection of hamas charter, initiatives has no wind. all this came after the fact. the fact of occupation and land theft.what part of this are you having trouble with?? i'll say it again.. back to the 1948 partition you go. you should count your lucky stars the arabs only demand the 1967 green line. i'd have to say that it is you who is in denial, and i can tell you have a bad case of dumb.
You're funnier than the Simpsons..LMAO!
Bush signed a fence bill with no money allocated. Listen to the border guards talk. There is no Mexico/US fence. There are some sites that have electronic fencing, however, americans in an uproar cause 3 US border agents drew long prison terms for shooting admitted drug toting Mexicans. So, let's not compare. The US cannot control that long border and Bush wants the Mexicans in to work. Stop mischaracterizing stuff for your program push.
Keep up Lynn. Putin's comments about the US/Iran were broadcast on our TV, get cable. I'm glad you are not in charge or in sync with voters in the US who have rejected, 60%, the Iraq war--those figures from Bush's Fox News. Keep pooh-poohing all the circumstances and keep pushing for business as usual. That's your style. What do you advocate now, whacking Russia caused she doesn't want Iran whacked? Yeah, right. Take Ambien. US will really be down the tubes listening to you and yours--straight off the cliff--the Masada complex projected.
are posting suggestions about how to deal with the problems they see, however, you are not one of them. Your total proposal is 'let's all go over the cliff together; no discussion'. What is a "hoot" is that you are clueless and apparently one who thinks a gig lasts forever. Read the other posts. Then relax and have tea. Regards.
he/she is a wolf in sheep clothing?...well said...
Almost all the posts, pro and con, are discussing issues which both sides contend indicate "storm clouds" gathering over Israel, with posters putting forth varying suggestions to deal with the issues. If you don't see any clouds, don't take your umbrella. Regards.
Those "storm clouds" you and yours don't see, as you claim, is rather the point of world opinion against you. There are some who just never have the sense to come out of the rain. Read some other posters on this thread. Your forecast of sun and warm temperatures is not shared by many, even among your brethren. Perhaps you and yours should be the ones to shake your head a few times and join everybody else in reality. You really are in a minority about sunny days ahead amongst Jews and non. Have tea and look again. Regards.
do believe this poster has answered your relevant post and batted a rather messy tennis ball onto your pristine court of the mischaracterizations you posted. I did find your characterization of the present mess in Iraq rather deficient in balance and accuracy. Regards.
The number of comments that keep telling Israel to do its own thing and forget USA are truley amazing. In every war Israel has fought since 1948 the USA has provided arms and munitions and political support. Without the USA support Israel would have been forced a long time ago to make peace. This ongoing tradgedy is simply the result of the USA and Israel not truley wanting a just peace. One could argue if Israel should have been created in the form it is today; I for one do not believe so but that is another story. Israel and the USA have used military force to try to solve the problem but after 60 years of failure you would think the penny would have dropped! Unfortunately these two countries still believe in solutions through the gun. Seek peace through bargaining as equals and try to see the other sides point of view.
The only time you push that stock cry, Israel is "sovereign" is when Israel is being asked to do something they don't want to do. When it comes to the US being in the ME, giving arms to Israel, money, turning a blind eye to occupation and the continual slurping of Pal land, you are a-okay with USA. You stated you are opposed to withdrawing our troops, this in the face of generals and Repubs indicating no military win is possible, no problem, keep them there. From your posts over a few months, you come across as one of a 5th column dual US/Israeli citizen who thinks what is good for USA is good for this Israel, no matter her conduct. "Demands", some pressure applied, now "suggestions", doesn't matter. You missed the point and that is that our brat is gonna have to step up to the plate or get some tough love by its parent. There is no longer support for that absolute position you take, and over time it has become quite clear. Read a couple posts of opponents on this thread.
Yes, I agree that is a problem, however, I doubt we can arrange for direct deposit or use of a electronic food stamp card, or its equivalent, given the circumstances. However, your snide complaint is of someone living in glass housses throwing stones. The US provides Israelis money, but we are a tad more courteus about transferring funds to banks, etc, however, the bottom line is the same, charity. Stop whining! Regards.
Your claim that the police in Iraq learned brutality from Americans is cynical beyond belief. Saddam had one of the most brutal and perverse regimes in the entire world. Calling me an arsonist tells me just what sort of a person you are. Obviously you are not concerned about people planning to blow up four hundred innocent little girls. You are more concerned about your pride. Whatever the faults of the West, the jihadists are not a Western creation. They can be defeated only by Islam within Islam.
CALL ME IN JAN 2009 JOHNBOY !! CONDI IS ABOUT TO DROWN WITHOUT WATER WINGS
Evidence - 1. Rice puts in Shiite controlled Iraqi govt. 2. Rice supports Hamas via pushing elections, and then funds them and gives them arms in the name of peace. 3. Rice demands ceasefire during Leb II war, right when ISrael was within weeks of destroying Hezbollah (Iran's proxty) - thus saving Hezbollah and Iranina influence in Leb. 4. Rice meets with Iran and Syria -who are killing our troop in Iraq, and tries to get their help 5. Rice wants to weaken Israel even with all the internal political turmoil. Conclusion - Rice works for Iran and radical Arab interests.
Because George W. Bush made all these dreadful mistakes that injured the USA, the enemies of the USA think they can take advantage of it, and hurt the USA even more than they have done up to now. I hope Israel does NOT make the same mistake. The USA is injured politically. But as an Empire, it can beat the shit out of its enemies if it wants to. And do not count on the Democrats not being able to do just that if the USA is provoked too much. After all even the Democrats want to live the "good life" of the Empire. Now, Israel was presented by the USA with some..."suggestions"! I hope Israel will study seriously these "suggestions", and not try to take advantage of the USA's "injury", because we are ABSOLUTELY FED UP with the Israeli-Palestinian CIVIL WAR; just as bad as the Sunni-Shia civil war going back 1,300 years.I may be a PhiloEvraios, but my allegiance is exclusively with my country, the USA.
I really love the calibre of the types that gravitate towards you.Enjoy your fame!LOL
SORRY MR CASEY ,UNABLE TO ACCOMMODATE YOUR DEMANDS..NOT ENOUGH VIRGINS,,HAMAS REPORTED THAT ALL GIRLS OVER 12 WERE RAPED BY ISRAELI SOLDIERS.WHO WILL BE GIVEN TO THE DEAD TERRORISTS. Suggest you try later after the arabs fulfill the quartets 3 demands still outstanding.Pass message onto Candi She does not understand plain english only the american language
Gabe1 and I have been at it for years, this is really tame compared to the way we usually go it.Any thoughts on my posts about an imposed solution?
the US will not dump israel and leave it to its fate,but Israel is going to have to play ball as the US looks for a solution within the international consensus.I wish israel would take the offensive and negotiate now with abbas on the basis of taba geneva that would be best.Regards
US is building fences and walls on its southern borders. Why not Israel? Double standards?
After the victory over the Arab armies of Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan, Syria and Iraq in the War of Independence in 1948,an armistice agreement was signed which called for negotiations among the warring nations.Temporary boundaries were established and the hostilities were ended. About 850,000 Jews had to flee with their lives from Arab countries who were or were not at war with Israel.About 600,000 Arabs fled Israel, although nearly that amount remained.Many Arabs were told to leave by their leaders in order to remove themselves from combat, others were removed by the Jewish forces for a number of reasons - to expand the Jewish state's territory or to increase the security of existing settlements.As they say, war is hell, some are going to lose and some, to win.Israel wanted to negotiate then and after the 1967 successful war in order to reach a peace settlement, but their adversaries only wanted its final and complete destruction.
If anyone triggers anything it will be Iran.
sovereign state. Seems the demands have turned into suggestions.
I don't hear you blaming the savage behavior of civil wars in the Congo, Southeast Asia, or Latin America on cultural deficiencies. I hear no mention of the systematic dissemination of CIA torture methods to Iraqi police, nor its role in horrific murders and reprisals. Brutality can escalate in any society, and to light a nation ablaze only to wash your hands when the blaze burns out of control is a cowardly evasion of responsibility. You exploit the horrors of the invasion and the civil war it unleashed to slander a whole ethnic group and push your political agenda. Democracy in Arab nations is what the West most fears, and it has undermined democratic movements in Arab nations at every turn. Why deal with a messy democracy when a brutal but pliant dictator is throwing his oil fields open to you? The West has sacrificed human rights for access to resources for centuries.
It looks like Saudis keep you in the loop judging by the number of guesses and overall content of your e-mails today.
I usually don't post,just read and laugh,but you're unique,in a weird sort of way. You refer to Ben Jabo as the court jester and say others have pointed this out?? I have never seen anything to indicate this. Actually,after reading your posts a few times,I think your turban is too tight,which is possibly why you see dark storm clouds everywhere..it's affecting your vision..try loosening it off a couple of turns,take a couple of aspirin and maybe see a physchiatrist.
LMAO!!!!
enjoyed reading your right-to-the- point view. Regards. Ballistic.
US economy is booming. the housing market is doing poorly in some small pockets, Los angeles is one. Mostly due to the poor building practises of illegals hired to perform work they do not know how to do. 35,000 lawsuits to be exact. As for Katrina, the problem there was with the Governor and the inept handling of local government more then anything else. Of course, certain insurance co's have not paid their clients due to the issue of moving earth and water as opposed to wind damage. You really know very little and talk way too much. I suggest you read more, learn more, and talk less.
The US has a vital security interest in the ME because of its oil. That is a simple well-known fact.The presence of a Jewish state in the middle of this situation complicates the managing of this interest.Generally the Arab world couldn't care less about Israel, except for one basic and irritating fact: the Jews have a state which contains a minority of Arabs, and among traditional people of the Moslem faith, this cannot be tolerated.In the past, Jews living in various Arab states were subjected to second class status - people of the book - but not Moslems( the same as Christians).The hatred of the Jews runs deep in the psyche of the Arabs, because they rejected the demands of Mohammed to support him in his quest to unite the peoples of the Arabian peninsula.
I mean it will allow Hamas not to break a promise given to God as they put it and liberate Palestine form the river to the sea. It can be done in numerous ways without US stepping everybody?s toes and putting the thumb screws to everybody here. Israel is too small to survive on its own and when I look at UN I do not see anybody there ready or willing to try US shoes if US decides not to support Israel any more due to the reasons you mentioned in your post.
Looks what is going on in Gaza. I thought that Hamas will bring an end to all these gangs and militants when the acupation ended. After all these years you are not acupied in Gaza and it looks as it is much worse now for the evarage Palestinian. you think that few guns will solve the problem?
in your post are stark. I saw Madeline Albright's interview; she said it has been a thousand years since the two major world religions and its issues are up 'front and center' with both sides insisting the other change its behavior and views. The Christians say, 'hey, bible says whatever Jews do, no matter, their God's people' The Muslims say, 'what kind of God you got sanctioning that kind of behavior;you must be Satan'. Torah/Bible is the whole answer; Koran is the whole answer; no discussion allowed there. How long will regular americans tolerate rapid decline in their personl circumstances because of our ME policy. Voters want out after 5 years in Iraq, out, out! So, what is the real issue here. What you aptly lay out is what everybody should be discussing, USA and Israel, perhaps they do in private. Under the present circumstances, how can this continue, we are hemorrhaging money, lives, prestige. Are folks talking Armageddon?Regards
The problem with your opinion of the Israeli-Palestinian dispute is based on your lack of knowledge of the history of the Middle East over the past 1400 or so years, particularly the Zionist movement, which began about 140 years ago.There are some very good books pro and con on the subject, but then you would have to go to your local library.The determination of right or wrong or a view of justice does not depend on numbers.If that were the case, Jews would have died out by the end of the devastating 2nd Roman Revolt of 130-135CE.
Egypt is considering a moat on the Gaza border. Speaks volumes to me.
As if you are the diplomat who decides anything for any given country. "What is your proposal"? What a hoot.
Sorry I used the wrong number, as i explained in a previous item, the Israelis won the additional land in '48 during a defensive war of attempted extermination if the Jewish state. Indeed,this act is perfectly legal under international law.Both Egypt and Jordan wanted to seize this land as well as the land assigned to the state of Israel in order to increase their land areas.Both these countries efforts to grab more land was not a subject of any complaints by other Arab countries, or for that matter by any other country.It is only when Israel took the land that the howling began.
an imperialist power although its economic influence is waning since the American dollar is sliding.Its record in Latin America is a disgrace. Its Middle East policies,most recently Iraq a crime, intended to enforce Pax Americana. I could go on and on but I strongly suspect that this is the FAKE Tosefta all over again. The spelling of the word Gandhi gives the FAKE away !Plus the gingoistic American sentiments ! You've given yourself away.
Since you're not new to my posts,well there's nothing much to say.So,ta ta ! And do take care of that sore throat,will you ?
tackling the gift of gab(e1) is a mitzvah.....
You're always going on about storm clouds,weather patterns,etc. Are you some kind of weatherman or are you just crazy?
BTW, who is the author of what you cite? I rest my case. Regards.
Palestinian's are the ones standing in food lines for the past 60 years, plates extended, coffee cups in hand.
Well, George, I agree with you, but is anybody listening over there? Probably not, but you said it anyway. Old folks say, 'a hard head makes a soft arse". As far as those who tell the US to go to hell cause they don't like what is being said, ole folks say "a cow will need his tail more than once to fan flies". I think these fit the situation. Regards. Keep blogging. Ballistic.
It has been reported by the American military that a school for girls that was being built by them in, or near, Baghdad was discovered to have been filled with hidden bombs, ready to be exploded under four hundred innocent girls. Now, you can have a good reason to be pissed off. As far as I am concerned, the Arab world has to reform itself, and the sooner, the better. Neither the Arabs, nor their sympathizers, can go on blaming all the ills in the Arab world on outside forces. Not only has there never been even a semblance of democracy in any Arab country, but more importantly, the most basic human rights are systematically violated. The horrific slaughter taking place in Iraq is a result of societies that have been violating human rights since their existence.
standards on issues of the day are ALMOST to ground level, as many posters have pointed out, but keep working on it while others amongst your people more linguistically able sort through whatever problems they are having without ANY meaningful input from you. Seems to me and as others have pointed out, you appear to function as the court jester. I've even come to appreciate Paul Harris' humor. Anyway, keep working on your deficient linguistic skills, which naturally function from a deficient mind which must feed those skills. And, have tea. Regards. Ballistic.
I suspect that the moment this Deputy Nobody spokesman suggested that these "demands" are merely "suggestions" that the Saudi Ambassador got on the phone to Condi and George and gave them a not-too-gentle reminder that this was a deal, and the Saudis always consider a deal is a deal. I predict that when Condi comes over in a weeks time that whoever is the Israeli PM will find that this Deputy Nobody spokesman was raaaaather mistaken, and this timetable is Set In Stone, and if Israel doesn't like it then Israel is gonna pay, and pay Big Time.
Just as soon as you leave your house doors open & keys in the car so they can be burgled, stolen & vandalized, Israel will remove it's protective roadblocks. Until then, to keep you slightly molified, pressure from the boot will move to the groin area.
Well not only will chastisement come to the USA, but her erstwhile brat, Israel, will also be punished. We are in for a bumpy ride, yup, we are. Look at the freak weather patterns the US has had and where the patterns occurred. Regards.
Palestinian Media Watch (pmw.org) reports: "The extermination of Jews is Allah?s will and is for the benefit of all humanity, according to an article in the Hamas paper, Al-Risalah. The author of the article, Kan'an Ubayd, explains that the suicide operations carried out by Hamas are being committed solely to fulfill Allah?s wishes. Furthermore, Allah demanded this action, because ?the extermination of the Jews is good for the inhabitants of the worlds" The killing of innocent Jews by terrorist attacks is portrayed as Allah?s plan for the benefit of humanity". Isn't the US paying ANY attention to the situation in the PA? Of the fact that a majority of Palestinians voted for Hamas? Of the fact that aggression by the Palestinians in the form of infiltrating suicide bombers and of rockets launched against Jewish towns have never stopped? The PA is a very dysfunctional entity and only a Saudi-influenced American adminstration could consider submitting such requests.
Lakshmi, I don't use the word "imperialist" as some dirty name to be attached to somebody I don't like. I fail to see why the US during the cold war would be denigrated for its struggle against the evil forces of totalitarianism. Not everything they did was correct, but in the larger scheme of things the US saved many countries from the fate of Eastern Europe. India chose to be a neutral country and nobody invaded it. Nations were not forced into servitude. (But you can complain about Iran, Chile, etc. Still, the local forces ruled.) The post Cold War world is indeed very different from the previous one. In particular, Israel has lost its value to the US as a strategic asset. Israel still has great influence, though. It is based on the value of money in US politics and on the many Christian evangelicals who have their religious dreams. I don't believe the Palestinians have been "betrayed". They failed to act in a politically wise way and fail to compromise, unlike Zionism. They also chose the way of terror instead of the Ghandi way. A very bad mistake. But with all their failings, they are not going away and Israel has to come to an agreement with them. It also must treat them decently so that the present enmity should be forgotten.
The USA must demand Israel abide by the 1967 borders and accept the UN resolutions and honor the agreements Israel has signed. Israel must be required to renounce violence, accept the right of Palestine to exist, and adher to all previously signed agreements. What a joke. Israel is committing genocide. They have no interest in peace, only in stealing the Palestinians' land and killing them all. God save Israel from its self.
USA better discipline its ertswhile child, Israel, before Israel and the US go to ruin. If God was on our side in what is being done, we wouldn't be looking to leave Iraq and you would not have lost in Lebanon. Don't be stiff necked!!! If God is displeased with your treatment of the Pals, you will suffer his wrath, and your history shows what happens when he is displeased. Presently, the US is being hit by freak storms, particularly the "red" states, the bible thumpers, does God figure into that? Regards.
received US Congress approval , for this US Benchmarks may be connected to US Congress approval of 59M$ at US Condi or US Bush request ,remember the US Bush 89M$ affair that IDF objected to ,Haaretz reported Last update - 21:45 17/01/2007 , IDF objects to U.S. plans to give Abbas' forces battle equipment , , , An $86 million U.S. program to strengthen Abbas's presidential guard .... if this US Benchmarks is rejected by either or both Israel and terror PA , Then US Congress may request US Condi for a hearin' about 59M$ that US Congress approved at US Bush request , Kind of "what's up with my money" , US Congress may also want to know about the weapons trucks provided by Egypt and Jordan and stolen by Hamas at the Keren Shalom crossin' durin' pals infightin's, US Congress may find non kosher this PA Dual Strategy, of supposedly good cop , bad cop when both Hamas and Abbas are in fact dirty ,
hey short man, how ya doing? you obviously have nothing better to do than reply to posts that have nothing to do with you, other than that other activity that makes you go blind, and causes hand-blisters:-) You'll be happy to know that I'll be in your neck of the woods this summer, we'll be able to meet and 'bury the hatchet'! I'll even introduce you to my 'family':-)
The "gimme people" in this dispute are zionists who keep their beggin cup handy! For them to call the Pals beggars is surely the case of a pot calling the kettle black. You must realize that, right? Okay. Regards.
According to Israelis, Palestinians are not human and don't deserve any rights. The Palestinians stole the land from the Israelis before two thousand years ago and just past century Israelis remembered to come back to their stolen land and to claim it and get rid of the natives in Palestine. Get real and look honestly in the mirror to see how ugly and disgusting you are.
I was reading your post and saw Henderson, but I didn't post #339. However, if somebody came and said my home in NV had to be evacuated forthwith because the land was being returned to the Mexicans or Indians, I am sure my response would mirror what the Pals are saying and it would be the norm anywhere else. In fact, Americans were upset with the CT decision of eminent domain which took private land to give to private individuals to make more money. That's the problem with the Pal situation and they are objecting. This is not 2oo or 300 years ago, it has been during my lifetime. It is absurd to talk about ownership thousands of years ago as Zionists are doing and think it will be accepted. YOu would not accept it nor would I. So what do you propose, that the Pals roll over and play dead while Israel continues to slurp land in violation of int'l law? I don't think that will happen. Regards. Ballistic.
are as delusional as Saudi Peace plan, without pre-conditions that has pre-conditons. Diplomatic double speak, untrustworthy and useless. Rice always has the same smile on her face, must be frozen in place. OH well, she had a nice few days in Sharm, good time of the year, not too hot as yet. Iranian minister walked out, some lady was dressed immodestly in his view. He's probably heading home to his four wives and multitude of girl friends. Condi will be back on the next shuttle plane, same smile, same photo poses, same drivel. She's where she was when she first started out, back to square one.
The American plan calls for these measures.Roadblocks are to do with security and rockets are to do with insecurity.They go hand in hand and for peace to happen they would both still have to go hand in hand. But what happens if 1 rocket comes over after the deal? Is 1 rocket acceptable? 2 rockets? 5 rockets? 12 rockets? 28 Rockets? 56 Rockets? 322 rockets? 1500 rockets? How many rockets would put the peace plan back on its backside? and who will take responsibility for them? the government of the PA? Who????
The USA has been stoking and enabeling the fires of Jew hate for decades. Todays brewing Jew hate is manifestation of USA's manipulation of the dynamics playing in the middle east and elsewhere. Enabling and creating Jew hate very shrewdly. The 5th column which advocates the 'palistinans', and benefits from Hamas and Hezbullah, both in the middle east, and as a force within the US, as an JIHADIST ARMY LAYING IN WAITING. Very much LAYING IN WAITING. To be sure.
G-D will Bless those who Bless Israel and the Jewish people and Curse those who curse them . Genesis 12 :3 . Be Warned USA ; EU ; UK ; RUSSIA ; IRAN ; ISLAM ; ALL NATIONS .
No 'demands' -- 'recommended actions, suggestions'. No worries, no USS Liberty to sink.
bomb rockets from,smuggle weapons into and terrorize the Israeli people with. U.S. will face judgement for getting involved with this its already been spoken. 400 yrs now we've been a nation what happened to Eygpt after 400 yrs of oppressing Israeli People.
I am just a representative (one of several in this galaxy), temporarily sent out to scour the faithful and not-so-faithful at haaretz talkbacks. making sure everyone is on best behavior (which luckily for us all, is taken quite loosely, god being all-merciful for minor infractions such as name-calling, tail pulling and pig-headedness). FYI - god prefers not to be referred to as "he" or even "she' but is not taking offence to either ot to "it". Part of being almighty is being linguistically generous. though it is unfortunate that english - the neewly emerged planetary language - has so far failed to come up with a possible nomer for an entity that is beyond gender, and I'm sure you'll agree that transgender doesn't sound good. this is not my personal god I'm talking to either. as I said, more like an employer (a non-paying one, alas) btw, can't use capitals today. paul harris exceeded all of our quotas.
father a muslim? if he is ---the bible is right.he turns your mother from the God of Abraham,Isaac,and Jacob.do muslims really respect Jesus and Mary? Jesus is our messiah,but with muslims-Jesus is just a prophet/good teacher.Jesus is more than a prophet and a good teacher.He is the creator of the universe.true christianity is not a cult.the world is against true christianity.are you really a jew supporting hezbollahs/nazrallah?
Mrs.ORTHODOX JEW If you think you are so knowledgeable on Islam please feel fre to enlighten us of their Quran and what it comments in it.I find your reply the AmericanChritianMoM rather offensive.We need friends like them and just wake up. She does not STINK as you say,but I rather have her STINK than yours.You are totally ignorant on Islam,and you should do a bit of work on it before making such fool of yourself. That you say Islam respects Jesus and Mary coming from you shows where you are coming from, and it is not from an ORTHODOX JEW,but an Islamist one and we are not deceived. Islam is a fascistic religion and if you think about its comments you weill read what it has in store for the Jews and the Christians. It say and I quote:FIRST "THE SATURDAY PEOPLE"THEN THE "SUNDAY PEOPLE"This is a caution of what their design is in store for the Judeo/Christan religion according to their beliefs.Please don't take as fools here by pretending you are a Jew.....
hell is real.... Yeah, it's the Hypercol on Friday morning...
I happen to like Israel and dislike my own country. Don't let the door hit you in the back end...
I love how the removal roadblocks and checkpoints in the IOPT is framed as a concession by these talkbackers. Tell me Israel, what treasures should we lavish upon you for you to ease a bit of pressure from that boot to the throat? Cheerleading the Iraq invasion does not seem so wise in retrospect, now, does it?
What do you mean by the sellout?The US is going to have step on everybodies toes and put the thumb screws to everybody here.
FREE KASHMIR NOW!! END INDIAN OPPRESSION OF KASHMIRI FREEDOM FIGHTERS!! FREE KASHMIRI POLITICAL PRISONERS NOW!!STOP HIGH CASTE MILITIAS TERRORIST WAR AGAINST THE LOW CASTES IN BIHAR!! JUSTICE AND HUMAN RIGHTS IN INDIA NOW!!
Well I use taba-Genva as an indication of the basic ideas needed they both give an idea of the views that have the support of the international consensus, they are merely guides.Reagrds and Shabat Shalom
Thank you for that fine display of mental inertia.
It should be painfully obvious Israel has no intentions of abiding by our requests. They worry about their own security which directly affects our own (Ie:9/11). While Israel has no intentions of making Peace we should be seriously thinking about whats best for us and severing this one way tie. We get nothing in return from this association with Israel, she has nothing to offer aside from drugs, war, and weapons. If we were to finally do the right thing and not veto UN resolutions, cut off military aid, cut off yearly guaranteed Oil reserves, not only would we save Billions, it might bring us closer to the Arab nations turning against us. Israel has nothing whatsoever to offer us but continued heartache and problems by association. The wall, the roads, the road blocks, the killing the bombing must all stop and come down.Enough is enough.
My favourite "Jewish" anti semite has made an entrance. As usual with some idiotic comment about NOTHING. Taking advise from from priest again are we?
I know I need to learn more, but I don't see a connection between West Bank roadblocks and rockets from Gaza. Anyway, it appears that Bush isn't serious about this any more.
war over there, chances are very good it will be their last. Bush was warned not to go into Iraq, and he listened to Frum, Wolfowicz, Perle and other asst. fifth column neocon folks part of a dual gov't. If they go into folly again after Lebanon, Iraq and Afghanistan, there may not be any more wars anytime soon, if at all. Putin already told Bush not to go messing around with Iran and Pakistan is quite restless, Musharaff at this point being irrelevant to his population. Nothing any of us can do, but nothing happens without God's permission. Therefore, the prediction is that a surprise is in the works for warmongers. As the story goes, 'blessed are the peacemakers'. It has a ring to it, doesn't it? The good book said God heard the cries of the slaves. I am certain he has also heard the cries of the Pals. He is the author of justice, yup, he is. Hang tough and watch. Best regards. Ballistic.
I cannot disagree with your sentiments. But as you can see how this story has evolved in the past 24 hours, apparently, Bush wasn't serious, or he was caught by his own hypocrisy. I'm afraid that Israelis and Palestinians will have to make their own way and ignore the US for the next 18 months or so. Bush is a lame duck, and getting lamer. His Attorney General has Alzheimers and his SecState is an empty suit who can't even keep the party line straight.
I don't know which lands were owned by the Pals, but they lost them fair and square in a series of wars of extermination against the Jewish state.Say would you be willing to leave your beautiful home in Henderson, because a local Indian tribe said it belonged to them? This has nothing to do with the dispute between Israel and the Pals.I just want to keep you on your toes, if you are hanging by them.
All the Palestinian have ever done is say give me, give me.
He'll say:Man! Whew!Whew!Thank heaven it is over and I can get my buddies the(you know who)and we can get some more "dosh" have a good jolly time,and let the Democtrats or whoever takes my place sort out this "bloody" mess.Especially Iraq!Wooowy... Did anybody see that,not only have they got road blocks in Iraq,BUT A HUGE CONCRETE WALL! That should make people think twice,as far as whoever complains about Israel's flimsy fence they all moan about.What a load of "SHOWER"they all are some people are.... P/S Now Haaretz this is for BEN JABO #316 he needs a bit of a laugh......
the safety of the US, a back seat driver. Say, what is all this about "rights" and what kind of doctor are you anyway. Your post clearly indicates that you have not enough sense to recognize the storm clouds over the US and Israel and to put up an umbrella. I like the way you lay it out to those on the front lines about how they should stand up in the middle of 1.7 billion Muslim people and tell their only friend and ally to 'go to hell'. Yup, you must be a Dr. of Cajones, however, we Americans voted to remove our loved ones from Iraq and eventually from the ME. Too much trouble and the Arabs are not gonna let Israel or the US take them over. Forget it. New plan on tap. I remind you that the Zionists are newcomers to the area and the rights we should be discussing are those of the Pals. Your attitude is why there is a problem. I just love armchair generals from the comfort of home, yup, they are the best kind. If Dubya asks Israel's help, they might wanna think about it.
It is too bad, though, that the Palestinians send their suicide bombers to kill innocent Israelis, including Arabs and Christians. Maybe if the Palestinians decided to live in peace with a Jewish state. I know it is an enormous leap for them, but just think how the livability, security,the economy and even the truly good feelings of not being blown to bits would emerge to create a new day. I don't think they have the will or desire to live at peace with a Jewish state.The great myth of the golden age in Spain is doomed to failure in the ME, because the Arabs who would accept the presence of a Jewish state are fearful for themselves and their families from those who would kill them.
"Does the UN really have the right to expose our people to acts of terror and violence" - You did it to yourself when your country illegally settled a territory it has no sovereignty over and began to settle its citizens on this illegally acquired land. If you dont like it then return these crazy settlers to Israel. "Must first demand that the PA: accept Israel's right to exist and adhere to all signed agreements" - I would only welcome this if Israel recognised the rights of Palestinians to an independent and sovereign state and it also adhered to all its signed agreements. Its ridiculous for you to call for this when your country does not even follow these same standards.
another intelligent American...go ahead, offend an entire country, an ally, because you don't see eye to eye with one of it's citizens. It's really good to see that the US doesn't need allies...it wouldn't have any if you were one of it's ambassadors! Mind you, most Americans don't call their state USA, but hey, whatever floats your boat:)
I can certainly see what you are saying and there are many on these forums who obviously agree. The facts do speak for themselves - Israel had plenty of chances to strengthen abbas, long before hamas won the elections, but it did nothing really constructive. There was always the excuse that abbas couldn't control security - so there was no one to talk to. bingo - no more problems. All I'm saying is that unfortunately whatever moves it may look like the US is making are best perceived through a prism of internal election politics, rather than a true - and sudden - comprehension of the global politics at work. So far, US has shown way so little insight on the global stage since bush took office, that it's hard to expect wisdom now. What IS different is that Rice was indeed given some room to stretch, and that's what we are seeing - a more pro-active state department. However, as others pointed out - there'll be a limit on how far she'll be allowed to go, as seen in today's retraction.
Your argument is a typical crap of Islamist-Jihadists and antisemites.
Dana, you are, of course, right, God is too busy to bother with the ME at the moment, but you got the wrong end of the stick when he told what he/she/it is doing; Careening black holes are taking a back seat this weekend, too, to the De la Hoya / Mayweather fight. Even God's not gonna miss this one!!!
I suggest you go and take a good look at my last two posts regarding the matter. The issue has to do with the proper legal mechanism for the enforcement of public international law. Grow up.
#31:Oh,the double standard reasserts itself. The US Constitution permits petitions to the President and to Congress. Please read it - it can be found in any library in the US and on the internet. Read it carefully, study it. Maybe you will gain something from it - if you will only stop reading comic books.And please take you medicine.
I can assure you that the Bushies will hear a mouthful from the 13 Jewish Senators and 30 representatives in the House. Such demands will embolden the terrorists in the PA to make nice in order to ease their way into Israel proper and continue their carnage.
The agreement calls for the start of bus and truck convoys between Gaza and the West Bank, the reduction of obstacles to movement within the West Bank, the export of Palestinian agricultural products, authorization to begin construction of a Palestinian seaport and acknowledgement by the parties of the importance of a Palestinian airport, Rice said
imperialism(Baker et al) are gaining ground and conversely APAIC is losing ground.When Truman and Co. in the post WWII were beginning their consolidation of imperial power,the Jewish Lobby had the American president's ear.From then on. The geopolitics of the ME and Asia have changed.Russia re emerging as an important player in the immediate region,wants a stable flank in the south and won't be too pleased with American shenanigans there,China and India emerging powers have economic interests with Iran.The Arabs fear the rise of Iran and so on.Israel is not as indispensable to the Americans. The rules of the game have changed and what is happening is not a front although the Palestinians have been betrayed for so long and so often they are not going to let down their guard(and they shouldn't).
The Palestinians love to reach agreements, but they lack the will to implement them. They may be optimistic in English to the Americans and Israelis in reaching an agreement,but in Arabic to their countrymen, they are very negative. At this point in time, the Bushies are trying their darndest to reach some sort of an agreement in order to provide little Georgie with a singular, positive result to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict to balance the horror of the war or civil conflict in Iraq. So long as the Pals allow the continuation of terror against the Jewish state,no valid agreement will result.The desperation of the Bushies cannot be allowed to endanger Israel.
You can count on Bush being rational and that he will take into account all the factors for not attacking Iran that you just listed - but I know better. Bush has no say so on the matter assuming he is sane, which I question highly. The war on Iran will be decided in Tel-Aviv. The concerns you raise regarding American will or capability is not part of the calculation. Bush already said he will defend Israel- other candidates repeat the same line. So what is next? Israel can trigger American involvment simply by attacking Iran. As you can see, the ultimate decision will be made in Tel-Aviv.
need to lay it out to em straight away and without any euphemisms. Enjoyed your hard hitting post. Regards. Ballistic.
with the history you laid out, however, this is a new day with a new reality. The fact that the US is in trouble changes the equation. Nope, no more blind support for Israel. I doubt that Jews in New York wanna do without oil or see their investments go to shambles because of this intractable problem. So, they may have a plan, but man plans and God plans and here we have a 'perfect storm' of conditions to change the reality on the ground. Lots of us see storm clouds gathering and hopefully idiots will have sense to put up an umbrella. No gig lasts forever; I am sure you agree with that. There is a time and season for everything. Good to see you back; I haven't seen you much lately, although I have only looked in from time to time being occupied with other things with the weather changes. Regards. Ballistic.
to a personal God.the God of the Universe.the Prince of Peace,the Everlasting Father,the mighty God,Wonderful and Counsellor.God Almighty is not a "it".even the Holy Spirit is not a "it".are you a pantheism or enviromentalist or humanist?just curious.I'm sure you're not a wiccan.
Say, sounds like you are one of those who say Jews run America. Well, time will tell if what you think is really the case as Americans find their standard of living headed south. Opinions in the US change when you interfere with Nascar and beer. As to all those who doubt what Carter said in his book about Jewish control of our government, your post vindicates what Carter said to his people, the Evangelicals. Good luck with your plan there, however, remember that the best laid plans often go awry. Regards.
makes US a "Model" State for promotin' Islam political Jihad ,
The name of the game is LAND FOR PEACE, 2-STATE SOLUTION. Bottom Line -- If the PA wants something in the way of land, they have to PAY for it with credible Peace in exchange. Israel is not going to keep roads and passage open if the PA keeps reneging on its peace commitments. Regardless what Bush wants. Since Israel agreed to stop settling Eretz Israel in the W. Bank and Gaza as part of Oslo, and let 40,000 PLO return from exile in Tunis -- the right move now in light of the Hamas PA announcing it will NEVER recognize Israel it to TAKE BACK THOSE CONCESSIONS. Make Jewish parts of the W.Bank part of Israel, ship all PLO back to Tunis by force, and let Israelis settle anywhere they want in Eretz Israel -- two can play at that game. The "Palestinians" fantasize that they can wage war against israel while enjoying all the benefits of peace. It didn't work in 1948, and it won't work now. Olmert's successor will be the most hard line in Israel's history, and with exceptionally good reason.
You are doing the same as the "FOOLS", therfore you are one. Have a healthy weekend.
I heard in the news that the muslim world wanted to rule the world.they said that if they only knew more about politics,they would takeover the white house and amend the usa constitution.your quoran mentioned about jesus,but muslims have more reverence for muhammad than with Jesus.why is it that muslim arabs can't accept the jews the right to exist even though israel and hebrews are mentioned in their koran.tell me about this: surah 2:50 and remember we divided the sea for you[hebrews]and saved you.and drowned pharoah's people within your very sight.[who are "we"].who wrote the quoran?if the muslims take over the world or the usa-islam will take away all someone's freedoms,including freedom of religion,freedom of speech, and freedom of the press.
I don't read anything about the land Israel slurped up belonging to the Pals and any intent to return it. That is why your argument falls on deaf ears around the world, and not because of your race or religion. Recognizing Israel's right to exist should be limited to what she was given and not what she took. What about it?
Geneva is to be forgotten. Nothing should be considered that was not negotiated by official representatives. That kind of extra-diplomatic negotiation can have serious negative effects on both parties in terms of expectations, or even rejection of certain positions, which make subsequent diplomatic efforts more difficult. We should stick to official diplomatic chanels, be they in secret or not. Regards, Cipora
Bush & company are starting to put the screws to Israel. Just as anyone who was aware of implications of invading Iraq had predicted. The U.S. is bogged down in Iraq, is militarily weakened with no end to this war in sight. It needs Iraq's neighbors to help us get out of this horrific mess. Their price will be concessions on Israel.Let's hope Israel does not become the sacrificial lamb for the failed Bush/Cheney policies.
It is coming from the mouth of Tosefta. Dandy! Who do you think is going to have such a nice balanced view as yours?They are Tosefta's.They are a bunch of hypocritical morons(at least that is what I call them). It was nice to read what you put out,but they will not move an inch and you know it. They are trying to gain time,and need more "dosh"isn't that their way? Everytime I read your posts they sound so believable,but in effect it is a waste of your time.If they haven't managed to create a decent society throughout the decades what proof have you it will change as you suppose. I have had enough about them,and the Americans,about Condi's visits and etc.Just a good photo'opportunity and nothing else.How many visits will this woman make?And what has she achieved so far? Bye for now Tossy dear
You conveniently omitted the rest of my quote -- "they have no right under any agreements, because they failed to honor their side of agreements".. Israel agreed, and prepared to grant them this -- they responded with bombings, Kassams, and kidnappings. Now they can forget it for good. GONE. Maybe NON-SOVEREIGN passage can be discussed once Haniyeh and Hamas are as dead as Hitler and the Nazis -- since Hamas says they will NEVER recognize Israel. Does the US have sovereign passage across Canada to Alaska? Does Britain have it across Spain to Gibralter? No sunken roads, no Chunnels, no elevated monorails. They had their chance and blew it. They can drive to Taba through Egypt, take a car ferry to Jordan, and drive up to the Allenby bridge, its only the distance from London to Manchester. There's no "right" involved. They may want it. Too bad. They can pay through the nose for it, or trade for some land that Israel wants. Obvious, their only motive is warfare, not economy. The nerve.
Firstlymy views are not garbled, they are lucid and clearly stated.Second, why we need your views anymore than mine I really dont know.Third I have a coherent view of things do you? Fourth ,my views are not a matter of left or right, they are a matter of maturity versus infantalism fifth I am not a mouth piece for anybody. six, look at the big picture kath you are not in grade school anymore, seventh, think kath and think some more.
Germany?s actions for 5 years resulted in Jewish popualtion in Europe decreasing by 6 mln Israel?s actions for 60 years in Palestinian population increasing by 5 mln I wonder how 30% of Germans see it as the same.
If it is, Regards.
Nosirree, tea for me. Nobody knows where the peace train is going, but the call is for all aboard. Jewish members of Congress and AIPAC are a minute # of americans who have voted out of Iraq and are now concerned about US deaths and money hemorrhaging such that we cannot help with several natural US disasters starting with Katrina. In addition, the AIPAC spy trial is on tap. Don't flatter yourself, even with Evangelical Christians, let's see how steadfast they are if their lifestyle is interrupted; my guess is only a small #. Everyone recognizes that a quick flip of the spigot and the world economy is in trouble. Nope, something different here than business as usual. It appears that God himself has created the 'perfect storm' for peace. USSR is awake, US economy in trouble, housing first; honey bees are dead and disappeared around the world; Pakistan may be 'missing' nuclear material. Nope, AIPAC types won't get it this time around, nope, not this time! Regards.
The smell of ignorance stinks out of your post...everything about what you type and the way you think STINKS!!! Go and do your homework about Islam before making a fool out of yourself...At least Islam respects Jesus and "Virgin Mary" more than your corrupt bible. Islam isn't a fascist religious; it has no history of being a fascist religion. It is you and your ancestors who are racists and full of bigotry. PLEASE STAY AWAY FROM ISRAEL...WE DON'T WANT YOUR SUPPORT. YOU HAVE NO RIGHT TO SUPPORT ISRAEL NOR TO CLAIM ANYTHING RELATED TO IT. STAY IN YOUR CULT OF IGNORANCE.
I have nothing against the two states but everything against the sell out. I hope you are right but it seems to me that it is a sell out.
Well if anyone one does not open his/her eyes the Bible is coming true today and we need to prepare for the messiah's return soon but, NO ONE SHOULD let Israel stand alone back them with prayers even if you can't do it physically. God told Israel that their nation would be used to reveal Himself to the world!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Danite, MA CHERIE D"AMOUR, get off your high horse and stop advocating Israels destruction just because you hate the Settlers, The Orthodox, and the Nationalists in Israel. The two state solution is already her. We have an Arab State called Jordan and a Jewish state called Israel .We also have a lot of Jordanian squatters with Jordanian Citizenship in YESH. If you want to see a two state solution get on a plane and go and see your PARAMOUR Abbas and let him take his people just like Moses and lead them to the promised Land JORDAN.
Looks good on paper. Think of the short handed way it was done. Someone wants a legacy.
Ballistic, Did you notice perhaps that a plan which was to be imposed is suddenly only advisory? Perhaps it was only a mistake, perhaps Olmert called Bush and undermined Rice, or perhaps somebody else called Bush. In any case, in an election year there is no pressure. And I use AIPAC for what it really is: It does not give money itself, only coordinates giving by members and other PACs. They retain their influence regardless. The Congressman who get the money know who is pulling the strings. P.S. The AIPAC trial is a misnomer. The two former officials who are on trial were quickly fired and I believe AIPAC is not paying their lawyers' fees.
Keeps advising writers to have coffee. Now it's time to reciprocate. Ballistic, have a nice cup of that special Jonestown Koolaid, laced with a bit of hemlock. Solves all your problems and no more anxieties.
supporting israel financially....american jews have the right to support their country and people,haven't they?israel can stand alone without the usa support.she did it before,she could do it again.the world turned its back from the jews during the holocaust.it might do it again.the God of Abraham,Isaac,and Jacob will defend Israel and His chosen people from her enemies.you won't see the Hand of God if the usa or the uk support israel in time of war.the world saw the Hand of God when israel won wars.it was a miracle that they won wars against 5 arab countries.their fighters weren't even well trained soldiers[some were survivors from the holocaust].
OOOhhhh... you're so scary, Mr. Kangaroo!
A.M., the United States - my country - has no right to ask Israel to do anything which jeopardizes her security. We throw our weight around out there in the world, and just look at the misery it's brought to Iraq and other nations. I am not proud of some of the things the USA does. I am a patriot, not a rubber stamp.
The US has never been and never will be at war with Israel. Israel and the US are not enemies of each other. Who poisoned your mind?
Hey Clickfart - I've at least been to Israel - spent two months there. When's the last time you landed your sorry ass at Ben Gurion airport? Why is it that your soggy little island produces wimpy buggers like you?
`The authors demonstrate that numerous Western countries, especially the United States and Great Britain, have conducted repeated and willful spying missions on Palestine and later Israel over many decades. While on the surface these two countries and others profess to be ardent allies of Israel, they work in fact, through their intelligence services to betray Israel`s secrets to the Arabs. Their motive: oil and multinational profits, which must be attained at any price through international covert policies.` this "war on terror" is such a covert policy, terrorists and murderers and mercenaries are training in Iraq and elsewhere to bring what they learn and train for home to each one of us we are on the brink of Shoah2, this time it is an Illuminati orchestration of a global pogrom 11/9 (or 9/11) in 1938 was our Kristallnacht 9/11 in 2001 was our Kristalltag Shabbat Shalom Emor to all, everywhere and anywhere
Keith, you ignoramus, get over the fact that Jewish Americans are citizens just like you. I was born here, pay my taxes, vote, and do all the other things that every American does (or should) do. I am also a target of hate-filled bigots like you, I support the State of Israel (as do many Christian Americans), and will use my right of free speech to speak my mind. I don't agree with the Israeli government any more than I do my own. No nation is perfect. But when I feel that my ancestral homeland (yeah, just like England is for Americans with English ancestors) is threatened, I'll speak up, so deal with it, jerko.
should place additional preasure on the Hamas government to comply with the three demands of the Quartet: Recognition of Israel's right to exist, adherance to signed agreements, and ceasation of all acts of terror. If Hamas can't apply itself to these three simple demands, why should Israel or any other country assist Hamas in any way shape or form to continue to develop its collection of weapons, and train its personnel in the delivery of more terror into the buses, coffee shops and shopping centers of Israelis?!
#73:If you can get away from your anti-Israeli attitude for a moment consider the following:The AMA( Agreement on Movement and Access) requires the Palestinian Authority to prevent the movement of weapons and explosives at the Rafah crossing.Abbas did not clamp down on terrorists. Abbas did not destroy the multitude of tunnels under construction.Enormous amounts of exposives flowed through the tunmnels into the possession of the terrorists.Were the Israelis supposed to allow such movement of explosives, weapons and people into the PA in contravention of the "agreement"?
you need to be warned.the prophecy in the bible is indeed scary-read the book of reveletion.....american egg,the usa is exposed to christianity-it seems to me the true christians are just minorities in your country because america let her guard down....she let every pagan religions in.God already sent her a lot of disasters and school massacres,but still she still in slumber party with aclu and democrats.
She's met counterparts before. Nothing has materialized from all her traipsing around. This is a face saving effort to make Dubya look good. She'll apply the screws to Israel, Israel will say O.K. and then do what it wants anyway. Bush has lost all the muscle he had when the Republicans dominated Congress. Bush is now in the position of waiting for the end of his failed Presidency. Congress won't give him the right time, and he knows it. He's like a beggar in the street, with cup in hand, waiting for a handout. Condie, by her actions isn't throwing him a lifesaver, it's more like an anchor.
I don't hear complaints from Israelis when we give Israel our $3,000,000,000 each and every year, so why in the hell you should complain when we ask you to do whatever is necessary to make peace?
Peace Train may be leaving, remains to be seen who'll be on board. Engineer Rice hasn't be able to determine where & when Pali's will derail it by more attacks. Thus far, Rice hasn't had any success with her routing, road map is full of detours. Conductor Bush has big problems with Iraq & the Jewish members of Congress. Coffee is being flushed down the WC, have a cup.
Condi sends an impossible demand to Olmert with a wink. Olmert, strong leader that he is, stands up and rejects it. The Israeli public applauds Olmert. Olmert keeps his job. Love it.
AmericanChristianMom, Islam does not want to take over the world any more than Christians want to "save" the world or damn it to hell. The Quoran, talks of jesus, believes in jesus, the virgin mary is mentioned more time than even in the new testament! Stop demonizing people, I remember a time when people said that jews wanted to take over the world, indeed that they ran the world! and if they did, everything that ails the world must come from them...your rhetoric is as old as your christian inquisition, get over it.
what a waste of internet - these silly postings by insignificate people with too much time on their hands whine all you won't - on both sides - it doesn't lead to anything FOOLS
Apartheid infrastructure will not last and will disappear even Jimmy Carter and Nelson Mandela can see this. Most of the world see's Israel as enemy number 1. Even US Pres hopefuls Obama and Edwards see Israel as NUMBER 1 threat to world peace. Its time to lick your wounds, Israel, and face the music. American for Peace Not Apartheid!
Unfortunately, maria - I just talked to god the other day and he/it informed me that the middle east is no longer top priority for him/it. You see- there's a really big fight that broke out in the Andromeda galaxy between a couple of nasty dudes, and one of the combatants is threatening to send a bunch of black holes careening straight through the universe, and that'd totally interfers with god's plan for everything (could be major rupture for them, for sure). So he/it is very busy at the moment. For now he/it asked me to tell you to keep reading your good book because it's healthy for the bones and promotes rosy cheeks. The ME is, unfortunately, on its own for the next 100 years. Sorry to be the bearer of bad tidings, but you know, it's my job....
In post #55, I didn't say I believed a word of anything mentioned in that document. I know their words or non-demands demands are empty regarding easing hardships on Palestinians but I specifically focused on the part of aiding Fatah against Hamas. Now on that part, I believe Bush administration is serious in wanting to upgrade Fatah to confront Hamas. Isreal is happy with Hamas in charge. So Israel is no hurry and never had the intention of propelling forces in Palestine who WANT TO NEGOTIATE, quite the opposite, when Hamas was sending suicide bombers, Sharon was bombing Fatah security forces- not Hamas. That was the jist of my point, Zionists are not pleased Fatah is actually gaining ground politically, want to halt trend, Bush administraton eyeing early elections wants to put it's guys in office, as they did in Ukraine,Georgia,Lebanon,Iraq,Jordan, Egypt and the list goes on, Isaeli interests and American interests are colliding. Prior to 9-11, Israel could have gotten away with isolating both Fatah and Hamas. Bush's war on terror makes Fatah relevant irrespective of Israeli interests,wishes or whims. If Gaza goes to Al-Qaeda, as Zionist policy is aimed to achieve, that's not something America or the world can accept in post 9-11 era. I'm sure the plotters of 9-11 never imagined this situation, Palestinians become more relevant.
Don't be sad just because Great Britain lost everything. At least Texas voluntarily joined the U.S. We sure won't give Oregon and Washington back to the Brits!
The future was never under anyone's control. Israel is friendly with many nations and produces many weapons for export. Israel makes its own future, and to say that its future is spinning out of control is utter nonsense. It has learned a great deal from the second war in Lebanon, as its recent military maneuvers in the Golan have played out. I guess the only "fair agreement" that you would envision would be one that would result in the elimination of the Jewish state. Dream on.The US support of Israel will continue so long as our perception of honor, justice and the traditional relationship with a Jewish state (and it goes back to the early years of the 19th century - early 1800s) remains.If the Arab countries decide to attempt to remove any Jewish presence in the ME,such would be suicidal for them in the face of Isreali nuclear weaponry which is land, air and sea based.
Dubya may have hoped for war, but circumstances are such that he would be nuts. I don't think war with Iran is looming or any other Arab country because of circumstances. I think the demand for peace by the US, albeit comelately, is the recognition that moderate Arab states and our own predicament in Iraq and Afghanistan became evident. All those Arabs have do to do is shut off oil for a bit and our economies would be in shambles. As it is, gas here is in the trees. A Haaretz runner I read indicated Pakistan may, might or has missed nuclear material, but not to worry. Are they, if they are, where did it go? What type 'material' are we talking. Further, Putin has warned the US not to get too persnickety over there. No, no war with Iran or any other Arab country while we are stuck in Iraq and Afghanistan. I do hope you are wrong. Hold on as right minded Pals and Jews will set up a two state solution and sideline zealots on either side. Golly, we might actually see peace!
Yes, I read your posts. I do not agree that we can put the cart before the horse. That was precisely the problem with Oslo and all subsequent agreements. On the Israeli side, two conditions must be met: a really unified Palestinian Authority; an end to lawlessness and terrorist groups. Gaza is in such chaos, that I see no way forward at this point. Negotiations with Abbas while Hamas is in power, even if successful, which I seriously doubt, would only yield a paper that would lock in Israel in positions, whereas the Palestinians would continue on their present course. I do think that Israel should freeze all settlement building and should start dismantling illegal settlements. To the extent possible, humanitarian conditions should be taken into consideration regarding roadblocks. Other than that, let the Palestinians sort out their own abysmal state of affairs. Israel cannot be expected to be a nurse to the Palestinians.
what we gone do about the plan of the "greater israel" lol
In post #55, I didn't say I believed a word of anything mentioned in that document. I know their words or non-demands demands are empty regarding easing hardships on Palestinians but I specifically focused on the part of aiding Fatah against Hamas. Now on that part, I believe Bush administration is serious in wanting to upgrade Fatah to confront Hamas. Isreal is happy with Hamas in charge. So Israel is no hurry and never had the intention of propelling forces in Palestine who WANT TO NEGOTIATE, quite the opposite, when Hamas was sending suicide bombers, Sharon was bombing Fatah security forces- not Hamas. That was the jist of my point, Zionists are not pleased Fatah is actually gaining ground politically, wants to halt trend, Bush administraton eyeing early elections wants to put it's guys in office, as it did in Ukraine,Georgia,Lebanon,Iraq,Jordan, Egypt and the list goes on, Isaeli interests and American interests are colliding. Prior to 9-11, Israel could have gotten away with isolating both Fatah and Hamas. Bush's war on terror makes Fatah relevant irrespective of Israeli interests,wishes or whims. If Gaza goes to Al-Qaeda, as Zionist policy is aimed to achieve, that's not something America or the world can accept post 9-11 era.
Exactly how is AIPAC an insurance plan? Insurance for what? Insurance for who? It would seem with the AIPAC spy trial looming, they would want to lay low lest they give credence to Carter's assertion laid out in his book, and which Jews deny. Regards.
Keep right on pushing. Good sense is needed despite what others may say to you about it. Regards. Ballistic.
Kath' - please read the book and you'll see many events and situations and people is a new Light. President, then Governor, Bush said seven years ago, in 2000, during Republican primaries, "if elected, I'll go after America's internal terrorists," and I knew immediately that he was a "new" Hitler, especially knowing the sorry saga of the whole Bush clan plus (Skull and Bones, CIA, China, (Vice) Precidency, etc.), all manipulation and mind control. Now, the news is that World Bank leader Wolfowitz turned a blind eye on Indonesia; so where were all the other so-called world leaders, why only pick on the Jew(s)? Shabbat Shalom to all.
The last nail in Americ'a coffin is her TREACCHEROUS bullying and betrayal of Israel to appease Israel's enemies to gain lost ground for Bush's colossal failure in iraq. There is hell coming to the U.S. for TREACHEROUS backstabbing of Israel.
The Israelis LOVE the status quo: Suppress the Palestinians, cage them into walled cantons, all in the name of security. View with glee their inability to make anything viable out of their isolated ghettos. Use their bad behavior in the face of hellish conditions as evidence that they are uncivilized and unworthy of freedom or dignity. Gobble up more land in the meantime...of course, all the while, saying you want peace... The US is losing ground in Iraq and elsewhere. Our standing in the world has plummetted. A show of resolve in resolving a core issue between West/MidEast would go a long way towards our strategic interests. At some point, coddling Israeli fantasies about territorial expansion will not be worth the trouble (notwithstanding the whacko evangelical influense on the Bush Admin).
israel can negotiate with abbas over a realistic end game without pulling one soldier out untill Hamas has been disarmed.One doesnt cancel the other, in fact implementation can be predicated upon disarming Hamas, furthermore with an agreement Abbas will be in a much stronger postion against Hamas than without one.Even if he were to exterminate Hamas today as we speak by this evening, what offer does the present govt have for him.?? We must be realistic here.
So, we now know that the powers in the US want to see Netanyahu in control, ASAP. Obviously, when the US makes demands to the sitting PM of Israel, he either denies them outright or the Israelis fear US action and go for a new leader that will both refuse to comply and will provide yet another rationale for delay. Bet the farm folks! Israel will NEVER agree to steps that would bring peace to the region. I've been watching for 40 years and it's only gotten worse and no one seems to care or learn from it. As for you US "citizens" that put Israel first, you are nothing but disgusting....
In post #55, I didn't say I believed a word of anything mentioned in that document. I know their words or non-demands demands are empty regarding easing hardships on Palestinians but I specifically focused on the part of aiding Fatah against Hamas. Now on that part, I believe Bush administration is serious in wanting to upgrade Fatah to confront Hamas. Isreal is happy with Hamas in charge. So Israel is no hurry and never had the intention of propelling forces in Palestine who WANT TO NEGOTIATE, quite the opposite, when Hamas was sending suicide bombers, Sharon was bombing Fatah security forces- not Hamas. That was the jist of my point, Zionists are not pleased Fatah is actually gaining ground politically, wants to halt trend, Bush administraton eyeing early elections wants to put it's guys in office, as it did in Ukraine,Georgia,Lebanon,Iraq,Jordan, Egypt and the list goes on, Isaeli interests and American interests are colliding. Prior to 9-11, Israel could have gotten away with isolating both Fatah and Hamas. Bush's war on terror makes Fatah relevant irrespective of Israeli interests,wishes or whims. If Gaza goes to Al-Qaeda, as Zionist policy is aimed to achieve, that's not something America or the world can accept post 9-11 era.
The USA should know by now. Israel wants weapons and money...not advice. The USA is abliged to give Israel whatever it wants and not preach to them on how to deal with the Arabs. This is because the USA and all Gentiles owe the Jews for not saving us during WW2. This is a never-ending guilt trip, and no amount of money or passage of time will end America's debt to the Jews. So pay up and keep quiet.
The USA should know by now. Israel wants weapons and money...not advice. The USA is abliged to give Israel whatever it wants and not preach to them on how to deal with the Arabs. This is because the USA and all Gentiles owe the Jews for not saving us during WW2. This is a never-ending guilt trip, and no amount of money or passage of time will end America's debt to the Jews. So pay up and keep quiet.
Here is the thing: I am a US citizen. So, I can be loyal to Israel, to Mars, to the fishes in the sea, to humanity, or the Indians in the Amazon jungle, or the Japanese crown. I happen to like Israel and dislike my own country. This is a right I have under the US constitution. It is called freedom of thought. It means that I can love Jews and not love Americans. It means that I can be loyal to whomever, wherever. It means that I can leave for Israel, if I choose to, or stay in America, if I choose to. What part of the US constitution don't you understand? Where does the US constitution require anyone to love America? As far as the hand that feeds me: the only hand that feeds anyone is one's own. If America has chosen to support Israel, it is for a reason. Nothing in life comes for free. That is the reason that the Palestinians will suffer in poverty, misery, and starvation, forever - because they hope someone else will help them. Nobody "helps" anyone between states, and between people
Dear Kath, if Danite is a "Leftie", what would you consider yourself....??? Mainstream....??? (Ha, ha, ha...) By the way, what is the name of the "comfy" place you are sitting in...??? And with regard to your post from yesterday on the Dichter thread, if you and Cipora see no problem in the intentional killing of more than a dozen civilians then both of you ladies have come a long way.... A very long way. In Switzerland we have a saying: Some women have a heart of gold and some have a heart of stone....
is a slow autodestruction natural process that some people might have naturaly and forever. arguying the current step in an attempt to design a new (next) that will put the actual ongoing one downgrade as last step will lead to the future step will be just and exactely the last one, and the game goes on and on and on in an unlimated circle. No thing will change except some will get sane people will become insane, some rich will become poor, some right will become wrong all in hold for onther better day in the immagination of some brain. it is not a game people
Leena Although some of us are aware the circumstances pertaining the countries in question who have been in "cahoots"to spy,against Israel while showing support for it.I will have to read this Autor's book to justfy my personal feelings all along.They have always tried to manipulate our country in various means and the only people we can trust is ONLY OURSELVES. I thank you for your summation and it is a cautionary tale for the leaders of Israel to bear in mind and not be deceived. Actually the name of the Author is familiar to me,but will have to refresh my memory of it. Thank you and Shabat Shalom
"the devious plans you lay out in your post worked in the past, however, this is a new day, new reality." - Ballistic I assume the devious plan is the Olmert plan (and previously Sharon's) to undermine progress by a timely attack on some Palestinia(s). This is not a thing of the past; it even happened recently (9 Pals killed; Hamas fires Qassams). In order to continue with this you need 2 important elements: 1. Only short term vision, don't worry about the future. Olmert and Sharon specialty. 2. Some insurance, in case Uncle Sam gets impatient. The insurance plan is called AIPAC. US President cannot afford to pressure Israel.
My views are not emotional, thats what Tosefta uses when he has no arguments.It is not what I wish for, it is what will be.To have expected this status quo to go on and on for ever without outside intervention is the emotional point of view.Tell me Cipora what do you think will or should happen realisticaly in the near future.Any comments on my responses to you, about negotiations with Abbas etc? We must face the facts here Cipora,if israel will not take charge and do it itself it will be imposed.Look at the big picture these are the facts of life.Regards
The kidnappers holding BBC reporter Alan Johnston are demanding the release of a would-be female suicide bomber, al-Rashiwi, held by Jordan, as well as the release of ten terrorists held in the UK. Conditions in Gaza are so perilous that Egyptian negotiators no longer sleep in Gaza and have asked Israel to allow Egypt to station some troops in Gaza city. Unless, and until, order is restored in Gaza, it is not possible to expect Israel to make concessions that would only further jeopardise her security.
Like i said that we cross paths on the road for a second or two doesnt mean anything.I talk as a Zionist and jew and friend and a brother to my people,our world views and approach to this subject are totaly different.I have understood since the early 80s even before the PLO did that their is going to have to be some form od two state solution.My postions are nothing new.
Ordinary life was much better for the Pals before Oslo happened. The promise and failure of Oslo was the real turning point. It revealed that the Pals were unwilling to reach a fair settlement. Review Clinton's comments. He said it very clearly. Israel finally realized that no matter what concessions were offered, it was not dealing with a partner in peace. Hope and denial were begrudgingly replaced by acceptance and realism. The Pals must share the land in peace, or they will get hammered, as they should.
This is not a sell out this is reality knocking on everybodies door.get ready for the Two States because here they come.
About time somebody did. Aside from that, this is for the good of the children on both sides.
No Labharas, you are the one being the rogue here and Arab nations are the bloodsucking rogue states. The Arab/Israeli conflict problem is simple, it's because of the rogue pals are squatting on Jewish homelands and your kind wants to use oil as leverage in your quest to destroy Israel. Be careful, food can be a weapon also. Many of us here in the USA will stand by Israel regardless of our government's position. You are very mistakened if you think that Israel will fall if it doesn't have American government support.Israel will survive your nation by many light years. You should be ashamed of yourself, for saying those nasty things about the Jewish state, but I bet you aren't.
"Israel`s not allowing Arabs to travel from Gaza to W. Bank is not -- quite the opposite, they have NO right to passage across sovereign Israel under ANY international law" This is exactly the reason the Palestinians will reject any peace proposal that does not lead to an inviolable link between a contiguous Palestinian State on the West Bank and Gaza (the best option from the point of view of both Israel and Palestine would be a high security sunken road). If they don't have such a link we'll always get Zionists such as Dr L.Brnd, finding reasons why free movement of Palestinians should be subject to the whims of Israelis.
You chide me and Danite; Danite chides me and others. However, Danite recognizes, from Canada, what you do not living in Israel. The gig is up and the Pals MUST have a state and Dubya's gonna see they get one before he leaves office and before oil is interrupted. You cannot keep the stolen land and the Pals must be given justice. It is sad that you and many others continue to refuse to accept the clear clouds hanging over the US and Israel, and that is sad. Danite and I have our disagreements, which are based on my blunt posts, but in content his posts agree with the right minded posters. Despite what you and others say, I wish Israel no harm, however, right minded Jews like Danite will save you from your own destruction due to your stiff necked view, which is I want it all. Relax, God is in control, not you, me, posters, Olmert or Dubya. Have tea and practice democracy for those with views differing from your own. Regards.
Once again a so called american jew throwing stones at the hand that feed it. I wish you would grow a pair and move to Israel and then give demands
"The US must first demand of the PA" Israel never has to do anything, does it, Varda? It's always what the Palestinians must do. It would be the easiest, least dangerous thing for Israelto show goodwill by stopping the expansion of its illegal settlements (as it promised the USA it would). We're not talking here about getting out of them - simply stopping their expansion. Israel can't even bring itself to do that. Israel demands of others. It never feels compelled to do anything itself. It is arrogant beyond belief - a gimme sort of a state.
Yes This USA administration wants to Get rid of Israel. Evil and stupid as it is it wants Israel to make the hanging noose herself . CARTERS ALL.
And will the US Have BenchMarks for Iraq as well!? And what about Fatah's Al Aqsa terrorists?! Or is this a "special case"? www.whysaudiplanwrong.info
A pox on the US administration who has no clue , who knows only how to sacrifice Israel and still get nothing from the Arbs for it other than contempt. Those here who go along with this idiotic repulsive behavior deserve the same contempt . Got it?
1. Israel extends the cease fire to the West Bank; Fatah and Hamas guarantee that they stop all fire by everybody. (They already promised it.) One week after the last shot is fired, move to step 2. 2. Roadblocks in West Bank and traffic between Gaza-WB resume, Israel easing imports exports, Abbas security forces check for tunnels and smuggling. All takes about 1 month. 3. Peace talks between Abbas and Israel begin. EU resumes aid to PA. UA aid, and Israel to resume transfer of PA money only after Shalit is released. Settlement activity ceases. 4. at the end of peace talks, have a referendum in PA on peace deal. Continue with implementation. Have a happy future.
It has been known for a long while now that 'America always loves a Winner'. It would seem that Israel has to thank the Olmert/Peretz Government for their miserable failure in conducting the Second Lebanon War which has led to America making such demands on Israel which will ultimately lead her not to the road to Peace but rather the road to Annihilation. The 'apparent winners' are waiting in the wings and unfortunately, they be not Israel. Thank you Olmert and especially the Defense Minister Peretz for 'Israel's Downfall'.
Golly day, the devious plans you lay out in your post worked in the past, however, this is a new day, new reality. It appears you think the issues over there are gonna stay in suspension indefinitely for another 40 years while Israelis dither about. Sorry, it is not what Dubya has mandated, oops, suggested Israelis do, it is the total situation in the world, which does not revolve solely around Israel. I hope you guys can get to peace while you can cause at this point the US can't help itself and as Danite points out in his post on today's thread, all of us are in for a bumpy ride. Regards.
People have to appreciate the fact we are dealing with a sinister and evil entities in Washington and Tel-Aviv where there is no limit to their treachery and deciet. The apparrent gesture of evanhandeness by America in this latest report is precisely aimed at inoculating the Arab street before Iran is bombed. Whenever Washington or Tel-Aviv talk about peace, rest assured WAR is around the corner. This is all an act, USA issues demands to it's problem child in the Middle East, problem child has a hissy fit, all part of a ruse. We have seen this routine before, Bush offered Palestinians a blind "vision" of statehood before attacking Iraq. Once again, they throw gold dust our way in hopes to neutralize Arab street response TO THEIR OWN PUPPET GOVERNMENTS for colluding with ZOG in a upcoming war against Iran. The Palestinian cause becomes a pinata hanging from a tree promising goodies for those who join let's bomb Iran party. Maybe time to pack it up, war with Iran,Syria,Lebanon is coming.
Unfortunately, I wouldn't count any chickens yet (never do, being vegetarian and all (sort of)). You should view these new, supposedly stronger, words as just a gambit in the ongoing election politics. Which in America never stop (we only get a break for like 6 months, right after presidential election when everyone is in post traumatic recovery). All the speeches and all the words, and all the 'pressure" on Israel just means that Bush is hearing an earfull from republican leadres telling him they will get a major drabbing, unless something can be done to change things. Since no one has appetite (or money, or troops) for another little war - say on Iran, and since they now know that Iraq will remain a festering wound, the next best miracle solution is: Let's-pretend-to-do-something-about-ME peace. All sound and fury, signifying nothing. Not that something cannot be done (I'm the optimist, remember?), it's just the will isn't there to pay the price. Hint to all US politics: follow the money
political situation". What a surprise. And of course the same old reaction from the posters here on Haaretz (myself included!). So what's new? It's the same old demands, nothing but baby steps, same old "security" dodge, although Israel remains infinitely more powerful, etc. Meanwhile Bush is still incompetent and there is another political crisis in Israel. Even the photo op looks as if Abass and Rice are repeating outfits. Next time how about they drop trou and moon the camera? Leadership? Where? Saudi peace plan? I once heard of it. Sail on oh mighty ship of state - its the USS Minnow and Gilligan is at the wheel. (For those of you not familiar with my oblique cultural reference - "Gilligans Island" is a TV show, the character Gilligan is an incompetent First Mate on a pleasure boat which hits the rocks and founders leaving its passengers stranded on a desert isle).
Dear Kath, thank you very much. Their lies will bring their down fall and they be hunged with their own rope. Repulsive and unashmed. And you can see them over their lands which they turned into their own Hell.
Reuven A well documented post thank you.Did we not say NEVER AGAIN,AND AGAIN,AND AGAIN??? So,time has come to act like adults because after 2000 years of exile(I call it semi exile)because there was a Jewish presense still there even after the Roman expulsion. So, this dependence is very bad for Israel,friends are fine up to a point.When push comes to shove,it is always for "the number one" and let the other "go hang".I get very frustrated each time I come here to read articles and leaves me discontented.BUT!I will not give in,or give out. You have said all that I would have wished for myself and I will end my post here while I commend yours...............
We have already done this in the 90s!! Where are the 15000 guns we gave to Arafats PLO? Maybe we should give them some cluster bombs as well!
The Palestinians accept the proposals and the OLmert government"Cannot commit to some of the demands citing SECURITY CONCERNS", next will be 14 ammendments to it, then some intolerable delay until the whole thing die a natural death in some 5, 10 years time. In the meantime, settlers improving their settlements (natural Growth), new Private roads to join the settlements, and the WALS/FENCES on confiscated Palestinian Lands....... and next the 3rd Intifada and the inevitable retaliations, and next Awaiting for the next US President to get involve for another 4/8 years and the CIRCLE goes on and goes on., and the sufferings from both sides goes on and goes on. This is life in the ARAB/ISRAELI conflict.
Stop using Pal human shields, demolishing homes, harassment and violence of Arab neighbors by settlers... And then find a non unilateral peace agreement with PA, something like the one with Egypt and Jordan.
"the measures are related to implementing phase one of the road map peace plan for the region." - Condi's spokesman The Roadmap has been around for 5 years, and was supposed to bring peace by the end of 2005. It did not move thru its stage I which requires dismantlement of all terror organizations, removal of illegal outposts, and stopping settlement activity. What do the Dumbyas in Washington want now? Let's try again, except that by now things have gone backwards so they need to build a road to connect to the road map. The Roadmap itself is an unattainable foolishness which turned a peace plan into a Roadblock to peace. And the present extension builds another roadblock on the way to the big Roadblock. The Roadmap: What is the chance that Hamas will be willing to dismantle before a peace plan is signed? Whoever heard of a liberation movement disarming before a peace agreement? Did the IRA do that? If they disarm too early they lose all influence in the peace talks? Better forget the Roadmap, Dumbyas. The new plan: It does not require Israel to extend the cease fire to the West Bank. This is the cause of Qassams from Gaza. It also does not require that Israel engage Abbas in real peace talks. How can you expect quiet from the Palestinians if they are being attacked in the West Bank? Is Condi completely dumb? The nice thing is that she expresses no expectation from Hamas (which she refuses to talk to). Abbas is supposed to preach to them to behave. Or may be he will threaten them that if they do not behave then he will keep preaching until their ears fall out. Forget this plan too.
This government is going to retire soon. Who cares what they want/say/demand. Anyway, the United States has no right to interfere in Israel's internal affairs. We should mind our own business. And as far as the money to Israel, yes that should be interrupted. But no money needs to be sent to Egypt/Pakistan/Turkey either. Anyway, everyone understands that the Palestinians will remain in their state of poverty/hunger/starvation forever. The reason is, that they have become addicted to being victims. And victims never win. In addition, their suicide bombings have turned the rest of the world against them. Indeed, no Palestinian can get a visa for any country, even Arab ones. The reason is, that everyone is scared that they would blow themselvses up. Likewise, Palestinian businesses in the US are not frequented. The only people who support the Palestinains can be found on this blog. That's about a hundred for the whole world. Out of 6-7 billion people in the word. So it ain't much.
Danite Firstly listen to Cipora's advice.Then stop giving out prognosis in a sentimental way being such lefty mouthpiece for Israel.We do not need your garbled concept on what may be good for Israel's future. Especially from a leftist persuation.Fine for you to think,or advocate sitting in "comfy" Canada.Just so's I'd remind you,in case it never occured to you,once if God forbid Israel is diminished,and were you to need a safe "haven"where will you go for "succour"? Hastiness is bad Danite,think before you jump in at the deep end,or you are liable to "drown" Be careful,be very careful..............
rights to expand illegal settelements yet it does; why don't you demand they stop doing this. Your a Dr. do some research and find out all the resolutions Israel ignores before demanding PA commitments.
And like Christians don't have blood on their hands: Germans have Jewish blood, Americans have Aferican and Native American blood, etc. "Stop telling Israel what to do! Israel BELONGS to the REAL GOD Jehovah, the God of Israel!" I don't care what God it belongs to; if its a democracy then it needs to seperate Chruch and State.
If you think the trajedy that is occurring right now in Iraq ranks up there among "the worst crimes in history of mankind," you have been at an extreme disadvantage with those who have taught you history. Sadly, there are in fact innumerable and much, much darker chapters in human history than this trajedy. So, lets just try and keep some perspective on the situation. Second, while the US ultimately share culpability in the events taking place in Iraq, it is unconscionable to place the blame for what is currently happening there squarely on US shoulders. The Iraqi people, despite there sectarianism, could have chosen any number of paths other than this one. Its very easy to blame ALL your problems on the obvious catalyst, the US. Its much more difficult to recognize that day in and day out, it is Iraqis, sunni and shia alike, not US soldiers, who are committing atrocities upon one another with their death squads, and suicide bombers, etc.... This is civil war by definition.
from Iran and Syria. Then the next day this gets published. Interesting
All war is a game of profit and death to the global Illuminati military industrial complex. All incitement to hatred, hamas and sinat chinam, for any reason against and toward anyone is based on the same principle of "divide and conquer." Both Iraq and Lebanon were baits and traps to scapegoat Israel and the Jewish People for all warmongering. In a 2002 speech to "commemorate 9/11 and its 6th month (!) anniversary, Bush said so... 9/11 is the date of Tisha B`Av and Kristallnacht. 9/11 was our Kristalltag. This Shabbat, make "Shalom" the only word you think of and speak, no matter what, no matter where you are, no matter who you are and then, when enough people say so, Baruch Hashem, there`ll be Shalom, as the Hebrew language is the cosmic code language for Biblical (= metaphysical, no "religion") Revelation on Shavuot. Shabbat Shalom Emor to all
from Mark Aarons' and John Loftus' eye and mind opening book, "The Secret War Against the Jews:" 'The authors demonstrate that numerous Western countries, especially the United States and Great Britain, have conducted repeated and willful spying missions on Palestine and later Israel over many decades. While on the surface these two countries and others profess to be ardent allies of Israel, they work in fact, through their intelligence services to betray Israel's secrets to the Arabs. Their motive: oil and multinational profits, which must be attained at any price through international covert policies.' there is no "war on terror" but a(nother) Illuminati Skull and Bones fascist war against Judism and Israel the Iraq and the Lebanon wars that aren't / weren't were the baits and traps to scapegoat Israel and the Jewish People for all the ills of all Mankind, again Never Again! Shabbat Shalom Emor to all
Let's take a closer look at the US demands. The Palestinians must give up their resistance, the one and only pressure card they have remaining, and in return the Zionists simply remove roadblocks and give Abbas bombs to kill Hamas. The Americans have a sick sense of humor.
On March 11, 2002, our Skull and Bones Naz(a)i and Naz(un)i Spirited "war President" knew to say, "There will be a day, when the organized threat against America , our friends and allies, is broken. And when the terrorists are disrupted and scattered and discredited, many old conflicts will appear in a new light - without the constant fear and cycle of bitterness that terrorists spread with their violence. We will see then that the old and serious disputes can be settled within the bounds of reason, and goodwill, and mutual security. I see a peaceful world beyond the war on terror, and with courage and unity, we are building that world together."
"History shows us what is possible" said Bush when he visited Auschwitz... Reagan visited Bitburg Nazi cemetary in 1985 with Helmut Kohl, remember? "Republican" Mitt Romney launched his Presidential Campaing at Nazi Henry Ford Museum, remember? Yesterday's "Republican Presidential Debate" took place at the Reagan Presidential Library in Arnold's California. CNN broadcast "Es Ist Die Wirkschaft" in German when Arnold won - wink, wink - his Total Recall campaign in CA, a campaign that he launched on Jay Leno on Tisha B'Av (in 2003). We've all been tricked into believing this Illuminati illusion of what is. Now run here www.zohar.com for Refuge. Shabbat Shalom Emor to all
It is the likes of you good Christians that know and matter and we can be proud of our Jedeo/Christian ethics and beliefs. One would have to be deaf and blind not to see what is happening throughout the world with the rise of Islamic fundementalism.Even the so-called moderate Islamists are not to be trusted. In point of fact,they are even worse because they hide under the "mantel"of being moderates. Whereas the openly hostile Muslims are hateful,and carry their deeds all over the globe.We must remain cautious and not forget. The numerous terrorists being hunted down and caught daily in the U.S and U.K shows what a dangerous world we are living in,with these lot on the loose. Vigilance is the word we must bear in mind and take care of ourselves and loved ones....
Hello Ned, good post. And can you please tell me what these American Values are? I hope they are not 1. telling lies 2. bringing democracy etc.,
Tired of fighting for honor, tired of fighting for land, tired of fighting for respect, tired of fighting for peace, tired of fighting for ungrateful people. Seems like a good time for Hamas, Zionists, Israel, Palistine, America - all get together and resolve this mess.
You allow flea bitten bastards to Harrumph as much as they like (52/54). Much as you have done for years now with that IGNORANt fool from bloody sussex, the FAILURE from NYC, the Moronic & Mad witches from Oz yet will NOT allow responses to their BULL SH*T. If those are the bedfellows you favour & whose HATRED you wish to encourage is there someone at Ha'Aretz with the BALLs to at least come out & say so. It'll save the rest of us an awful lot of time wasted responding when the posts are subsequentaly not published. I wrote to Bradlley Burston on this subject a few weeks ago as I expected that he, at least, would have the common decency to reply. Sadly I was mistaken!
planning to relocate to Israel anytime soon? If not, your post sounds a tad unusual for an American, especially when you must have taken notice of the problems Bush has encountered trying to execute his little plan of getting to the pearl of the ME, Iran. What exactly are you proposing since it is clear there will be no military victory in Iraq and we are hemorrhaging money? What if the King turns off the oil spigot? The BS over there could collapse our economy. BTW, Dubya has aroused the Bear, the USSR, from her slumber and Pakistan claims no one should worry that they may have "lost" some nuclear material (Haaretz had a runner yesterday on it), according to the BBC. So, what is your plan? Things are looking VERY scary, as poster Virginia points out. Reasonable folks should be worried, but what must be done? I do hope God is in control. Regards.
Anybody familiar with planning of large projects recognized immediately that the original "Road Map" was going nowhere because it didn't contain specific enough, measurable goals, and a time table for their implementation. (Any project manager who issued such a "plan" would soon lose his/her job.) Now Rice is apparently, and very belatedly, trying to correct some of the Bush regime's original mistakes. Already we see that her attempts are pointed toward the same "Nowhere." The question is whether the Bush administration is prepared to take on the Israel lobby and force these things through. FOR HAARETZ: you say you have a copy of this latest document. How does it compare with Sharon's "14 points" document issued at the time of the original Road Map to Nowhere, which stated what Israel objected to? Did Bush & Rice ignore it or follow it in their latest demands?
Read the new headline at the top of the story, Irish. You and the anti-Jews got hornswoggled by bad Haaretz headline-writing (the first headlient they put on this story) Seems the "demands" aren't quite demands after all; more like diplomatic suggestions. We all should be encouraging both sides to take positive steps, instead of (as you are doing) using other peoples (incorrect,it turns out) writing to further our own little propaganda efforts. Shame, shame..Irish
there is no "war on terror" but a(nother) Skull and Bones Illuminati fascist war on Judaism and on Israel Bush is a "Republican" Skull and Bones fellow, Kerry (in 2004) a "Democratic" Skull and Bones fascist. In 2000, Bush and Gore - who are cousins of "royal" descent - debated all the issues from the two "opposame" sides of the aisle? And so on. Wake up from this spiritual coma of (y)ours. We've been presented an Illuminati illusion of what is. Free you from Illuminati mind control and mind occupation by refusing to hate anyone or anything right now. Shalom, Salaam, Peace, Mir, Paix, Paz, Rauha, Fred, Frieden...
I assume the plan is that the US will bolster Abbas's security forces (the already on going funding and training) and implement security and rule of law. Having a passage way from the WB to Gaza will allow Abbas's security forces to go into Gaza and halt the rockets attacks and the rule of law there too (where it is needed most).
Nobody knows how much Jewish people want peace unfortunately the political situation in the Knesset makes it difficult to make progress. Everybody says they want peace but when they are faced with the compromises they have no heart to make them. Eventually people will wake up and just decide to live in peace together eventually and when they do the whole world will thanks G_d and heave a Sigh of relief.
Everything should be based on merit. Palestinians renouncing terrorism in their independence struggle. Ensuring good government according to Arab norms. Israel signing the Nuclear Non Proliferation treaty, Israel stopping targetting civilians, Israel stopping holding people, even from other soveriegn countries without trial. Israel closing down prisons such as facility 1361 where people are held with no recourse to law in violation of western emocratic values. The Israeli government abiding by western norms for good governance. Then prehaps there will be peace.
The Americans hate the arabs more than Israel, until this position changes,your choice of words and threats are meaningless. You have little or no knowledge of middle eastern problems. I heard that the Gallah population is increasing.
Lifting travel restrictions and removing check points at this time would only lead to more terrorists killing more Jews. What is the administration thinking? Are they thinking?
The lesson of the new headline :US Official: demands not being enforced..." is simple. Look at how many people got jazzed by bad Haaretz headline writing. This is a diplomatic American move. Nothing;s being forced, DEMANDS are a traditional journalistic description as are "outraged" "slammed" etc. Whenever a journalist writes "People here are outraged" I ask, what does it mean??? Who is people? All, Some? Anyway. Tempest in a teacup.
OK, who is this imposter and what happened to the real Olmert?
"I demand that you do this thing...er...I mean, I recommend that you do this thing...er...I mean I don't know what the hell I mean."
Lots of room here and you would not have to contend with the US. We have our own bad boys but al least they are ours !
Be very careful what it is that you wish for. You should keep in mind that you are wishing it for some six million people who were never consulted about the matter. You have a tendency to get emotional.
Since you say the US can't handle Arabs, are you suggesting that Israel knows how to "handle" Arabs? Well, okay, what do you propose since it is clear that the US cannot occupy Iraq much longer, either militarily or economic wise? Regards.
Sorry mate, it is WAY too late to come up with that knee jerk response. Different world, different day. Recognize the storm clouds, the time and what must be done. The UK is hauling ass outa Iraq, so what are you suggesting?
USA is finally getting the idea and is emerging from the "Shameful" support of the Rogue State of Israel. Long live the new America that will embrace the concept of Justice for all. Americans that are more committed to America "than they are to Israel" will see Israel for what it is. A blood sucking and intrusive International Law Breaking pariah state. Time for America to cut Israel loose and fend for itself.
Regarding the rest of your e-mail, there's not much that can be said to influence the mind of a terrorist supporter.So, I will take it as an indication of where you stand on terrorism and suicide bombers. PS.-I'm sure your next talkback will just claim the same of me, so don't bother-I'm outta here
Akram That woman falsely called Deborah,is a self serving,irrational,attention seeking,biased against Israel,hatred for the Jews and altogether unworthy to carry the very precious name which she has falsely adopted.This not the first time she applied her stance against Israel,so no surprise there. Madam,you are no Dvora OUR PRECIOUS JEWISH JUDGE of old.You are a disgrace and should join your Pali brethren and leave our country,before it is too late,......
and if I read it correctly, sounds like you are one who recognizes the time and what must be done for Israel to save herself. Hopefully, those Jews and Pals who no longer want perpetual war will find common ground. Hope they step up as time is short; US and Israeli governments appear to be in chaos and Dubya can't even taken care of what he started in Iraq. Are there any sane folks in either gov't? Regards. Ballistic.
Can you explaine then why Israel begs for fincancial support and leaving USA alone if Isreal is better off without US support. On the other hand, can Isreal offer to sell something else other than weapons? Can it offer to make this a better and a safer word? I just doupt that you have logical answer because there is none. Please, Please and I beg you guys to leave U.S alone because Amercan Values are higher thazn supporting agroup of gangs
Dumb,blind and VERY naive!
All that name calling and psychoanalyzing you send to me and other right minded posters and, as I said in several posts, we don't disagree at all. Your beef is you don't want somebody outside the 'family' to say the same thing you are saying to family. The point me and others have been making over many months is that you and yours don't see storm clouds gathering or any circumstance under which the US will be forced to enforce the 'donkey parable'. Circumstances will make a monkey eat red pepper and Dubya is munching away. You have lately accused me of 'hate'; wrong again, what I hate is the behavior and I hate the fact that those affected don't recognize the time and what must be done because of the storm clouds. You clearly see them, so stop sending out msgs to those who point them out. Get your umbrella. Regards. Ballistic.
5/4/07 President Bush vetoed timetable subbmited to him when to withdraw from Iraq. How is it that he could demand timetables of Israel, especially, when these demands means simple "suicide" for Israel
I think it WAY past time for people to become educated on the reality of Islam! It wants to take over the world! For the west and other civilized people to continue to pander this radical ideology is only to lead to western civilizations demise! But wait a second, ISN'T that the goal of Islam? Stop telling Israel what to do! Israel BELONGS to the REAL GOD Jehovah, the God of Israel! The west NEEDS to stand with Israel NOT give it away to radical Islamic fascists!
So when Hamas approves attacks days or hours before a major concession by the jewish state, Israel must accept and uphold their side of the deal regardless? No way.
EC: The $3 billion is now equalled by aid to Egypt and to Jordan. Get rid of that stupid old canard. Russians are putting way more into Syria and Iran. "demands" are the words used by Haaretz and other journalists. The word "demand" or "demands that" are nowhere in the US statement. People have been working behind the scenes on this stuff. Some of it will happen and will be called "real progress"; some of it won't and will be called "major hurdles and obstacles remain" but there's not going to be any abandonment of anyone by anyone else. This is going to ne much more oif a propaganda-fest for the Palestinians. They will loudly proclaim their willingness to assume ALL their responsibilities (while actually undertaking none) and will characterize Israeli concerns about giving tangibles without getting a thing back as "outright Zionist refusal". Same old same old.
An odd name for an Arab woman.Worse than disgusting.She is always advocating things which are against Israel and false sympathy for the terrorists. Get thee behind us WOMAN and SHUT UP........
I hope someday the high echelon in Israel understand that millitary power can not solve any problem forever, but postpone it a little. Thank you very much for your post, which sums up Israel's 'looping and cyclic' policy. Regards,
Howdy Chaim; There is very little economic aid to Israel from the U.S. (about $130 million/yr. currently and it is schedualed to be terminated permanently as of Oct. 1st of this year). U.S. military aid to Israel amounts to $2.4 billion/yr. currently and, like you say, it must be spent in the U.S. so that the actual money stays here and Israel only gets the hardware. Israel's GDP (Purchasing Power Parity) is $166.1 billion/yr. (2007 est.) and is increasing at a rate of 4.5%/yr. which is about triple the rate of her population increase which, in turn, increases her GDP/capita and standard of living. Although Israel could do without the monetary value of the military aid, it behooves Israel to take advantage of the R & D which the U.S. puts into her weapons systems. Developmental costs of state-of-the-art weapons systems are very expensive. It is cheaper for Israel to purchase some military hardware (like aircraft) from the U.S., Russia, France, etc. than it is to develop it hersel
If the terror groups were to go forward with the groundrules of the Quartet and stop the evil quest for ALL of Israel, there could be peace. No one can demonize what Israel has to do to stop the terror and get the Unity government to organize and police the terrorists. To do less would be not protecting the Israeli people both Arab, Jew and Christian. All the blathering about what Israel is doing is meaningless until the Palestinians are either willing to live under Egypt or Jordan governments or really and truly start the process for their own PEACEFUL state and give up the destruction of Israel. Israel will and must do what it needs to do to survive......PERIOD.
THE AMERICAN ADMINISTRATION HAS LOST ITS FRIGGEN MIND!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Just EXECUTE US NOW! WHY WAIT TO "IMPLIMENT" YOUR "BENCHMARKS" Jew haters!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Want us dead.
"70% of Pals that support terror" - And who could forget the 100% of Israeli taxpayers that support an illegal occupation of foreign land, that finance a brutal military rule that denies 5 million Palestinians that basic human rights. "Change the brainwashing of Palestinian children" - And what do you propose we do with those Israelis who claim this land is for their exclusive use? That they are fulfilling a divine promise? "The majority voted Hamas" - And your country voted for a morbidly obese PM by the name of Sharon, a man responsible for the violent deaths of thousands upon thousands of Palestinian women and children in Southern Lebanon. So Ben tell me again how you are the good guy and the Palestinians are the bad people?
Now they are left with a never ending war - just like Israel has. They've grown tired of you.
The current US plans must be resisted and denied implementation.
Sorry
"The whole reason we're still in this mess is b/c the Pals have not been willing...to stop terror" - Oh I see, this is the crux of the issue. Forget the fact of Israel's illegal occupation of Palestinian land and its continued thieving. Forget that it denies Palestinians their basic human rights because Jay seems to think the only obstacle to peace are some amateur rockets. Idiot! "In which Israel gives the Pals something for nothing" - Israel has never given the Palestinians anything, it just takes.
Maria is totally scary! She reminds me of Osama Bin Laden or Heaven's Gate cult, to the Davidians! She sends shivers dowm my back! It is people like that that have little qualms executing people or creating a holocaust...so long it goes to my sick plans.
You got confused there. It is the US Army who targets women and children. You can check your record. It is quite impressive. You started your in mass killing civilians in January of 1945 by bombing Dresden, then came Japan, Korea, Vietnam, Grenada, Panama and now Iraq. This are the places where US was directly involved. Almost forgot there was also Yugoslavia.
Look, it seems pretty obvious, given the content of so many of the comments I so often read here, that Jews not only control the US, they control the whole world. If Jews are in charge, then how is it that this document came about, if it isn't a trick to delude the Arabs?
The American people are not behind Bush on this nonsense. Congress will have a field day with Bush rejecting an Iraq timeline, but demanding a timeline from Israel -- whether the PA keeps its side of the deal or not. Holding Shalit and firing kassams into Israel are acts of war, violations of international law; Israel's not allowing Arabs to travel from Gaza to W. Bank is not -- quite the opposite, they have NO right to passage across sovereign Israel under ANY international law, they didn't have this right before 1967, and they have no such right under any agreements BECAUSE THEY FAILED TO HONOR THEIR SIDE OF THE AGREEMENTS. Gen. Dayton has misled the White House if he thinks this plan he proposed makes sense, is workable, and fits with the overarching War on Terrorism; he should be relieved. Given Olmert's weakness -- it ain't gonna happen, anyway. All the more reason for Israel to go to the mat to block JDAMS sales to the Saudis.
VIPER, I fully agree with you, if there is one thing the Israelis still have to learn, then it is to see the other side as equal partners, and not as submissive beggers. However, the Saudis (and the Arab League) have also to change their ways with regard to the Saudi initiative. They simply can't expect from Israel to fully accept the plan, before negotiations even can start. Sorry, but that's an absolute no-brainer.
"Iraq has shown that the US doesn`t know the first thing about managing Arabs." but we know how to manage jews. You are crazy! what kind of talk is that? Israel cannot even make peace? They are in perpetual state of war, sorry guy that is not what the US wants to be in. Carry your own water and get off the US taxpayers payroll...then talk.
I see you?re dumb and blind
By making more unrealistic demands upon Israel, GW (the world's biggest fool) just tighened the screws upon himself. He will lead the USA down the path of destruction! Israeli's you had better eject lapdog Olmert, before give's into more stupid USA demands! I will bless those who bless Israel and curse those who curse Israel (Genesis 12:3).
for the US for that? Or for vetoing everything in the UN?
Lynn, if those "demands" are an important step towards peace, then I am the king of Tonga. And believe me, I am not.
We cannot allow the situation in Israel to affect the US or the western world negatively, if Israel chooses to do what it wants then fine, we should saction them and isolate them financially and militarily...even travel restrictions.
What happens when the bus, loaded with explosives, makes an "illegal" turn off of the West Bank-Gaza highway, and heads for an Israeli military base? In just twenty months, Condoleezza Rice will be gone, and I can not imagine anyone else who would hire her.
Hi Mario, there seems to be a Swiss "invasion" here on Haaretz Talkback, but at least you don't seem to be a (Swiss) fake.... With regard to the settlements, of course you are correct, at least from our point of view they are all illegal (many Israelis may have a different opinion, of course). I usually only make a distinction because the outposts are even illegal under Israeli law, the other settlements aren't. But I agree with you that most of them should be abandoned rather today than tomorrow, because together with the Palestinian suicide bombings they are the main obstacle towards peace. However, it was agreed in Taba that Israel could keep some of the big settlement blocks along the 67 border in exchange for land. So if even the Palestinians have no problem with that, it should be okay for us....
This is the second step in that direction. The first step was Carter?s book. They needed Israel to look bad first to prepare ground for a sell out.
Multiple US administrations have supported Israeli security needs. However, last summer's efforts to allow Israel to destroy a terrorist organization failed because of the incompetence of Israel's government and military leadership. The US cannot afford Israel a blank check anymore. Of course the US realizes the dangers from its requirements that Israel essentially deal with a terrorist PA. However, what's the alternative? Israel has shown ineptness and unwillingness to confront the terrorists and destroy them. US, and western policy, can't be held hostage to endless Israeli stupidity.
Of course the pals "welcome and accept the document"..it involves removing roadblocks,checkpoints,and bus service from gaza to the westbank???Through Israeli territory?? How many suice bombers can you get on a bus anyway.The Israelis will never go for this,and of course all the bleeding hearts will now say that Israel is turning down a chancefor peace.Unbelievable!
LETS FACE THE FACTS: The whole WORLD knows that my country, USA, born out of principles IS funding the worst longest running occupation in modern human history, the occupation of Palestine. A society of US university professors has seriously questions the moral and other costs of the US Israeli Alliance. It is time that Israel stops this shem game, and its well documented legion of crimes. Israel needs to stand on its own two feet without immoral and unflinching US support which is not sustaniable in the long run.
I know the bottom line and it's oil. The USA leaders making these insane demands on Israel, is in actuality, a move of appeasement to the Islamic world, to keep the almighty oil flowing to America. My USA is so different from the USA that I grew up in. We have become a decadent nation of G-Dless, selfish, spoiled morons that pay more attention to the Anne Nicole saga,than truly important issues that should concern us. I despise the Republicans and I despise the Democrats. Both parties are owned by corporate America and are driven by a leftist,lying news media. I fear the sorry day may come, when the USA will entirely turn her back on Israel. In that day, I promise all reading this, that Jehovah will curse the USA. Both Bush and Rice are peeing up a rope trying to appease the Muslims. I am ashamed of my USA for this latest drivel against the Jewish state. I apologize to Israel for this USA treachery. Our leaders are mere fools that can't see beyond the gas pump. Long live Israel
Frank Israel always negotiating in good faith... Oh my, at least do not lie, we are not stupid: what about freezing the settlements. Please... we are all blinded by ideology, but we should at least try to get rid of it. At least try to think that not all your readers are stupid.
S, maybe my proposal didn't sound very realistic, but I was not stating the things that will be done, I was making clear what SHOULD be done. Otherwise there is a danger that people will start to believe that the crazy thing is the normal thing in the ME. Bad enough that the politicians of our world are so insane (or rather calculating) that all they can bring up are worthless cosmetical steps as we see in those "demands". Good enough for the shredder machine.
The lethal infantilism of the israeli right and Hamas is going to be crushed under the boots of hard cold reality.Those of you think that the big players who are getting all their big intrests f..... day and night by this garbage are just going to sit back watch the deluded on both sides ruin their intrests are living in the same world of delusion that will be soon smashed.Those are the facts.Two States is coming and whoever stands in the way is in for a real nasty ride.Just watch.
or just in a state of acute denial to ignore Article 13 of Hamas Charter "Initiatives, and so-called peaceful solutions and international conferences, are in contradiction to the principles of the Islamic Resistance Movement." What part of this are you having trouble with Sam ?
You mean the way pal parents raise their children to be suicide bombers?
The U.S. proposal demands too much of Israel without any guarantees that the PA will be willing to control the Palestinian militant/terrorist groups. What happens when a bus route is established between the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, the Qassams continue to fly, and dozens of terrorists jump the bus and infiltrate Israel? Similarly, with the checkpoints in the West Bank. What happens when a suicide bomber from Jenin is able to freely travel to the southern West Bank, cross into Israel where the security barrier hasn't been completed yet, and blow himself up in Beersheba or Eilat? There needs to be a clause in this plan which calls the whole deal off if the PA can't or won't honor its commitments. The PA has not had a very good track record with respect to doing anything about stopping terrorism which they are required to do ever since Oslo.
Rice developing Anti-semitic policy this time crossing that "diabolical line" providing and allowing Palestinian access to murder and maul Jews at will.Bush still does not have control of the US State Department.
no more giving something to pals for nothing but promises that they never intended to keep. i hope our leadership is finally wising up to the constant lies and propaganda spewed out by the pals.
Did you see my response to you on yesterdays thread? Also as I have often said this new list of demands by the US is the start of the imposed solution.Another good reason for israel to face reality and take the diplomatic offensive on the basis of tabe geneva,israel will look very good, put the arabs in a tight spot and do what needs to be done anyway.Two states is coming, it is a law of the universe.Regards
oh israel...to the natural eye you had no hope. the nation was destroyed and the people dispersed into all the world.the romans destroyed your temple, your center of worship. the nations persecuted and rejected you from country to country. the vision of the "valley of dead bones" was a perfect picture of you[oh land of israel]after your destruction in 70 AD. there was no hope.ezekiel does not end the hopelessness. he shows that by a sovereign act of God, the nation was to be reborn.the first step is the bones coming together.the sinew holding the bones follow this. and,finally the flesh covers the bones.God put life in the body, and that life will happen at the 2nd coming.God is working in the affairs of men and govt. to resurrect the "valley of dried bones" into an exceedingly great army.this will happen according to the will of God in order to fulfill His covenant with Abraham,Isaac,and Jacob.Ezekiel 37:1-9
The US is dictating policy to an extent but I believe Israel will always have its final word for ultimately they are close friends. Israel is not only Israel against its neigbours,its also a piece of a puzzle of the whole ME,so American cannot grant Israel to work completely on its own whenever it wants.It would be nice for Israel to be totally dependent but its hardly a reasonable goal. Israel needs US cover and help both militarily and especially politically in a very diffciult climate.For you to cut the umbilical cord before the baby is ready could be a disaster,though I must say for some people chutzpah knows no bounds.
This is the first tentative step towards an imposed solution.The US knows it is headed for a major defeat in Iraq that will make it imperitive to show something on the Palestine israel front in order to salvage american prestige and power and the leagacy of this administration.I knew this would happen all along, this is the first tentative step in that direction.
What will happen if we jerk his chain? At the worst he will flush himself,who cares.
The Big Gorilla is going to undo all the nice plans. Israel is NOT required to extend the CEASE FIRE to the WEST BANK, which it has been refusing to do since it has an advantage there. Israel hunting down Jihadists in WB pushes the Islamic Jihad to fire Qassams from Gaza in revenge. All the terror groups were asking Israel to extend the cease fire. Hamas and Abbas even promised to control the Qassams of Gaza in return. No deal. Imagine the following: Olmert sends the IDF on a hunting operation in WB, a fight breaks out, then it becomes TOO DANGEROUS (and rightly so) to remove roadblocks. Back up they come. And since the WB is not pacified, it becomes too dangerous to let people from Gaza free access to WB to enhance the fighting force. Bush and Condi, you have to start thinking about causes. You don't cure anything by rearrabging the chairs. Comment: Another beauty is the Shalit/Johnston release: "(Palestinians) AS SOON AS POSSIBLE: The Palestinian Presidency will continue to urge PA government acceptance of the Quartet principles, including renunciation of violence, and in that context the release of Israeli Corporal Shalit and BBC reporter Alan Johnston." Note that what is required is that Abbas should preach to Hamas. Maybe until they get desperate to stop his talk and release Shalit. No mention of prisoners exchange. It is an utterly useless bit of requirement. PROSNOSIS: This US plan will quickly join the Roadmap in the trash bin of history.
israel should stop the checkpoints because new zealand has no neighboring borders.and australia is a peaceful continent/country.
Oslo, the RM, multiple cease fires, etc. It's time for them to match actions to words. While their actions continue to be war, there's no need for Israel to do anything further on the road to peace.
the countries close to them can deal with it.thanks for the idea.
palestinians should insist that israel move back to the partition line of 1948. then the security concerns are a mute point. its obvious the zionisat want nothing to do with peace, for if the zionist did, it would have come long ago. the world is getting tired of the zionists excuses.
Have we not heard this before. Don?t we already know how it will play out for time being? What would be interesting is banning US Weapons and Aid to Israel for next ten years. Then only Israel will not object to peace process.
The U.S. provides Israel with perhaps $3 billion of aid annually. This is a small fraction of Israel's G.N.P. Much of the aid must be earmarked for purchase of U.S. arms. This aid compromises Israel's independence and makes the U.S. feel it can meddle endlessly in Israel's internal affairs. Israel probably loses more money on potential arms exports (many of which much be approved by the U.S.) alone than the sum of U.S. aid. Israel must be weaned off U.S. aid. It's price is far too high.
Kate suggests responding to the U.S. with the following demands. Here are my responses to her demands: 1. Demand the PA restore Law and Order in every area under their control by August 1st. RESPONSE: Israel obeys all United Nations Resolutions by August 1st. 2. All Palestinian militias and armed groups - other than officials - are to be disarmed - using non lethal force whenever possible by July 1st. RESPONSE: Same for Settler Militants. 3. Palestinian Officials are to be trained and held up to rules of conduct (aka: real law and order) by Sept 1st. RESPONSE: Same for the renegade IDF commanders who target women and children. 4. Palestinian civilians should be able to walk to the bank or eat dinner without be shot by some armed militia (aka: real law and order) by July 1st. RESPONSE: Allow the Palestinian government be armed sufficiently so that they can control the Palestinian militias.
"basic human rights" Deborah. Hard to say it: Go to both cemeteries, Israeli's & Palestinians Deborah and you will see how many human rights are being observed. If you are left with any more strenth in you; cross out of the borders to more Middle East cemetries and see many more human rights are buried. There is as much tears in the middle east as oil.
Is it Fatah or Hamas, if its the latter I doubt Hamas will amount to anything less than conflict with Israel As we both know they want to drive the Lahoudeen(Jews) into the sea and create a totalitarian Islamic state. Please Post and Reply Alon Fisher
All the actions tasked to Israel are ones that she ALREADY agreed to on Nov 15 2005. What is new about this statement is that the USA is slamming its fist on the table and shouting "I'VE HAD ENOUGH. YOU ISRAELIS - DO THIS. YOU PALS - DO THAT. IF YOU HAVE A PROBLEM THEN COME TO ME, DON'T SULK IN THE CORNER." There is nothing for the Pals to loose by agreeing to this plan. Nothing. There is nothing for the Israeli's to loose either *IF* the original agreement in 2005 was made in good faith. But there is plenty for them to loose *IF* they never intended to live up to that agreement. Bush needs this settled, and he is in no mood to piss around. So Israel better not jerk his chain, or they are gonna regret it. Never stand between a US President and his last chance to redeem his legacy......
USA PRACTICES HUMAN RIGHTS AS MUCH AS JAPAN PRACTICES SHARIA LAW.
there are two streams among the Arabs: the extremists and the moderates. The extremists, led now by the Iranian President Ahmadinejad, projecting instant death for Israel, and the moderates now led by Abu Mazen (Abbas), the late Yasser Arafat's right-hand man, who dream of a process of "phases," each phase bringing closer Israel's ultimate demise
If what you say is true. Israel's minister of defence could order the three US battle groups in the gulf to go into action,after all we Jews control the US,or am I wrong? Like I always say,yours is only an opinion shared by a few other anti semites.
I thought they built the wall for security. Why would Israel need the couple thousand check points inside the Weast bank if it has the huge wall to protect it from Palestinians entering into Israel? Is it Israel and the Israelis got addicted to the occupation?
alwasys screwing it up.the last instance of it is when israel pulled out of gaza and what did it get them,closer rockets!as far as basic human rights go,the security of civillians comes before human rights,maybe you can get you buddies to act like humans,then they will be treated accordingly.
"Someday, the USA will wise up and practice what it supposedly preaches... human rights!" Yes Boyd and then I suppose you'd be in favor of supporting those who stone homosexuals to death for being gay, prohibit Jews from entering their countries because they are Jewish and prohibit western style haircuts ? Just the ol' hypocrisy check
Olmert, baby, I don't think the USA is *asking*...... Condi's coming in less than two weeks, and it is just possible that you will still be Prime Minister when she gets there. So I suggest you start your limbering up exercises now, coz you are going to be doing one very spectacular back-flip. Abbas has to complete HIS obligations first? I don't think the USA is going to be willing to let YOU determine that any more. Condi's gonna be telling YOU guys to look after YOUR commitments, and leave the little fellow to her.
what our idiot president has proposed!
That's right, Kiwi girl. Israel should stop the checkpoints, and all open and unending free thoroughfare for every attempted Hamas suicide bomber as they seek access to move freely around. And who'll be there to take the consequences, to pick up the dead innocent Israelis body parts? YOU??
Sounds very much like the Iranian cries of "USA the Great Satan". Just goes to show that Israel really *is* just a dinky Middle East country in a sea of other dinky Middle East countries, and not some sophisticated Euopean country transported by magic carpet. Look, all you puffed-up, chest-thumping zionists; if America really, really needs you to "jump" then you guys better learn to leap, coz that's what you are gonna be doing. Tell Bush to go to Hell??? Ha! Sounds very hollow when put alongside the talk of just a few months ago: "Syria?? We can't talk to Syria - Bush won't let us". You've had the USA wrapped around your finger, and now this President desperately needs the Pals to be looked after, not just AIPAC. This is the result. Don't blame Bush - he's ALWAYS been an idiot. Blame your own hubris, coz you've been cocky and lazy and arrogant for just a little bit too long. Reality is about to whack you like a wet towel on your bare backside, guys and gals.
When the U.S. wins the war on terror,then Israel can safely withdraw to the 1967 borders. The Palestinians will have their state and live in peace with Israel. Iran will have fallen in love with Israel,Syria will have back the Golan,Hezbollah will have become a law abiding organization having given up on terror. All security checks at airports will disappear. Then I can once again be invited to travel on the flight deck of a British airways Boeing 747 like I occasionely did up until 1992. Lets hope the above is possible.
sorry if this seems like a witch hunt, but many jews here stuck up for america harshly, now that america is making demands for peace ( for their own interest of course ), the country that has helped israel immensly and to no end is now being critised, are you people actually biting the hand that feeds you? i think jews have a saying for this, don't you? someone reply please.
"How can the United States demand that Israel allow bus services between Gaza and the West Bank through sovereign Israeli territory?" answer: 3 billion $ a year to israel
First, because it is commited to not implementing them. Second, the political scene is in a shambles. Olmert, like his master bush, is immune to change or pressure. As for the removal of the roadblocs, Israel will continue to use them as leverage, as one piece in the fabric of humiliation that is part and parcel of how it occupies. As for meeting "benchmarks" where is Israel's implementation of illegal outpost removal? How many times has it commited to doing so, over how many yrs now, and how many have been removed? Israel's policy is clear and it is thus: commit verbally to do what they have no intention of doing, expand and entrench the colonies and their infrastructure and make life as unbearable for the occuied as possible without international action taken against Israel's occupation. So, keep land, create irreversible facts on the ground and use "security" to resist meeting its commitments to rice.
the pals need to band as one, although it will be very hard with all the in fighting and these factions trying to fight for dominance, but you are right, it is the only way you have stated.and israel CANNOT be the one who dictates, there can never be peace when only one side dictates what should be done, this is why saudi arabia has revived it's version, because all the arab countries must sign on the conditions they have asked for, they cannot reneg, if they do, they will be seen as the biggest hypocrites and liars,BUT, i will say this as i said in an above post, israel has been known ( and said by certain commanders) that they deliberatly provoke arabs, THIS must cease in order for true peace, hopefully then, all will live in peace and jews can cross countries without fear, and arabs can finally have a close destination that has much to see.
For those who are rejoicing at the apparent shrugging off of the Zionist puppet masters in Washington, consider this: It is obvious that the masters told their servants to come up with a plan that gives the appearance of being something that requires Israel to submit to unwanted demands, so that the Palestinians will be duped into accepting an agreement that not only does not serve Arab interests, but is unquestionably an agreement that does serve Israel's. Only those who are naive enough to think that the United States actually is run by Americans will fall for this deceptive ploy.
Much of this is a joke anyway. I can never understand what part of NO do the Leftists here not understand. Pals in charge DO NOT WANT PEACE and will sabotage it no matter what is done by Israel. The bottom line for Islamists is NO JEWS ALLOWED UNLESS DHIMMIFIED and so remove a checkpoint and results will be BOOOM, bombs, allow convoys and results will be BOOM and after a few people die, the checkpoints will return and the borders will close and the Leftists will curse Israel. Another words, status quo. Since its destined to happen, might as well get to it sooner rather then later so the world gets its quotta of Jewish blood spilled.
well said daniel take that document and shove it,where "the sun don't shine mr u.s.a. If the U.S thinks Israel is going to commit suicide they can think again!! And to think they chose this time,during the Vinograd Report too!How dare they ??? Just forget about the whole thing,and leave them to stew in their own juice and look to their own problems they have to solve with Iraq. U.S get out of Iraq first before you decide of Israel's demize...................
very well stated. it seems sad that the jewish people are suposed to be very intelgent but cannot see what is right in there face. violence begets violence
Well now.......where are all the Jews procaliming that Bush was "the best friend that Israel ever had"? Where are they huh? This man is a phony and Rice is just his proxy. It was so predictable that he would sell Israel out as soon as it became a political necessity. He needs Arab backing for the mess that he created in Iraq. So.......put the pressure of Israel! What a clown and a disgrace.
How can one impose a ruthless, mercyless occupation and allow them for food and access to hospitals at the same time? It just doesn't make sense and Olmert's PMO should make this very clear to Dr Rice on the first ocassion, "when they become Fins" is still operational and unless the Fins are a very hungry and skinny people, I don't see any evidence of this happening. Let them suffer as Jews suffered under the Reich of the Nazis.
Israel always negociated in good faith and Arabs are always trying to use negociations to get more firepower, that's why the Condi approach cannot work because the Palis won't lose anything if they don't comply to their commitments. Israel should propose a new approach: if Palis don't respect a portion of an agreement, they have to pay penalties and since Americans want Israel to take risks, the must be ready to pay for the risk taken as well. One example could be that if Israel give weapons to the Palis and Palis use them for terror attacks, Palis will lose large chunks of land and America will import 100000 Palis from Judea-Samaria.
I am amazed: you can spell "albatross". Charming. Considering the rest of your ill-spelt post, I think most of us here have no problem in trashing its poorly expressed content.
You tell the USA to go to herll. If we antagonize the americans and they cut their help, this country is doomed. Remember Sinai after 1956? Nobody in Israel wanted to leave it. the The USA said : leave! and the rest is known.
It's all worth nothing as long as upwards of 70% of the Palestinian population support terror and do not consider suicide bombings of jewish civillians to be immoral. Change the brainwashing of Palestinian children to consider Israelis as subhuman and ONLY THEN make demands on Israel. The MAJORITY voted HAMAS yet the world expects them to behave like Europeans?!?!?!
What will the IDF do? They will have reason for incursions that the Palis do not want. Here is an idea.....how about the Unity government police it's criminals.
You guys claim you want peace in the mid-east but your soceiety at home is falling apart? Do some housework you silly child!
an I'm amazed by how many right wing fanatics are attracted by Haaretz.
Less roadblocks I understand, but give the PA which is still hostile towards Israel and has Hamas incharge(vowed to destroy Israel) weapons?what kind of lunacy is this?do we look like the type to train our enemies to kill us? Sorry Yanks we not Bin Laden and the CIA! No Thank You Alon Fisher
Looks as if the West is making some very poor moves.
"U.S.presents Israel,PA with detailed demans"Ed It is an 'open door' policy. It will just put the clock back. What else could it be than to show (as if it needs to be show any more) that the Palestinians are unappreciatives and don't miss a chance to loose their chances. It could only be an expensive test to a forgone conclusion. Or it could be the Palestinians last chance ?! Israel should look at it only this way. And don't let us muddle ourselves with hypothesis.
Dear Mr Clickfool. In response to your comments to the above person (which I do agree with you on); I was just wondering if you have ever been to, or lived in Israel as you seem to have some very strong opinions. I do think some of your comments are fair, but being a Brit we are exposed to news which is biased against Israel. This I believe was proven last week when the BBC refused to release a report on this very issue. Do let me know on your thoughts.... Thanks
Well, it's about time the USA began to recognize the atrocities of the Israeli government and hopefully break from supporting a government and nation that is causing it to be weak and at odds with the entire international community. Anyone who has ever had to go through Israeli checkpoints are a witness to the humiliation, oppressiveness, and inhuman treatment by the Israeli military. Do I think this will happen? No! But someday the USA will get an administration with a backbone and stand up to Israel, the Jewish lobby, and the American evangelicals. Someday, the USA will wise up and practice what it supposedly preaches... human rights!
and Israel has a choice too,or not,as we know we are reliant on US resources which is part of their 'sovereign' country. The key point is this: Will it help or hurt the situation? And Israel will discuss its concerns and America will counter with either a resolution of a change in that particular demand. But this is a funny time,it looks like not long from now the government will fall and either the left or the right will take over and its according to that how the relationship with the US will develop and they have their elections too.
It seems to me that these are Israeli interests and not American. Since when does our government decide for another on how to govern? Or which people they must supply with arms? A little over the top with your comment.
Your argument doesn't stand the test of History Israel has seen much..much darker days. As for me, I always see the light in everything that concern the Jewish State. It is always sun shine since the day Israel was declared as a Jewish State. Remember spyguy it is darker on the other side and all of them and their countries are in an intensive care. History is the judge of nations and Israel has passes its test many times over.Mine is not an idle talk,my witness is the great philosopher stone;History itself. One other important point; if you are Jewish have faith..if you are not then you are wrong from the word go...
If you had been kept from visiting your loved ones, wouldn't you hope that someone would do something so that you could travel just a few miles to be with them again? Maybe you should swap places and see how you feel because you obviously don't care about the basic human rights of others.
Your argument doesn't stand the test of History Israel has seen much..much darker days. As for me, I always see the light in everything that concern the Jewish State. It is always sun shine since the day Israel was declared as a Jewish State. Remember spyguy it is darker on the other side and all of them and their countries are in an intensive care. History is the judge of nations and Israel has passes its test many times over.Mine is not an idle talk,my witness is the great philosopher stone;History itself. One other important point; if you are Jewish have faith..if you are not then you are wrong from the word go...
Than come to Israel and the PA with some bona fides instead of a failed resume.
I think you have a technical problem with your PC: the Hebrew reads from left to right. It took a while to translate that one! BTW: 'Palestine' is not (yet) a sovereign state, & I'm not sure Bush can resolve much at the moment, considering his 'lame duck' status. Rice? She appears to be as sadly ineffective as Tzipi Livni - nice people, but not the World's best stratergists...
Your argument doesn't stand the test of History Israel has seen much..much darker days. As for me, I always see the light in everything that concern the Jewish State. It is always sun shine since the day Israel was declared as a Jewish State. Remember spyguy it is darker on the other side and all of them and their countries are in an intensive care. History is the judge of nations and Israel has passes its test many times over.Mine is not an idle talk,my witness is the great philosopher stone;History itself. One other important point; if you are Jewish have faith..if you are not then you are wrong from the word go...
Palestinians agree and Israel stalls and makes excuses but I do believe that times are changing and the world will demand an end to this conflict whether Israel likes it or not. I live in hope of peace.
What is really sad here on Talkback is how many of you don't want peace at all. Anyone who prefers the dead to keep on piling up on both sides rather than finding a peaceful solution is sick. I only hope that those of you who prefer to live by the sword aren't parents because all children deserve parents who seek a peaceful world for them to grow up in.
such as allowing access to free movement(Dec. 2005).As for the checkpoints, about time ! Let us hope this will expand to other agreements such as the withdrawal from Occupied Territory. Israel has always used a truce to go in and attack the Palestinians.Good example is the truce that Hamas honoured last year and Israel went in and killed one of their commanders. But times are changing,so it would seem.The U.S. mired in Iraq and hated by the international community is not willing to continue its past carte blance support of Israel,which has become that 800 lb.albatross round its neck. Now is the last chance for Israel to be sensible and implement the Arab Peace Initiative.
Dahlan and Abbas have to present a plan to stop the rockets and basically control any belligerent action to Israel but what happens if they cant??????? How many rockets will it take before Israel will put the roadblocks back up???? How many???? Meanwhile Im not against a solution here,infact Id like to see one but I dont trust it.
Quote: '...every value we Americans hold dear.' & what values are these, John? The right to carry a gun & kill people in college/school? The right to use 85% of the World's resources? The right to set up Camp Xray? etc. etc. Perhaps you would prefer to root for the Arab states: which one of these police states lives the American Dream? Saudi maybe? Oh, they don't let women even drive. Egypt? Very democratic! Algeria, where they microwave your children in front of you? Funny how people's views get distorted by propaganda, or is it just me??
terror and violence? Why doesn't the international community apply more preasure on the PA to comply with the three demands it placed on the table for the PA to meet, and then there will be room for talk about additional measures? The US must first demand that the PA: Accept Israel's right to exist, adhere to all signed agreements with Israel, and ceas all acts of terror and violence. Israel, if these requirements are not met, has the full right to stop all trafic from moving between the West Bank and Gaza. If they don't comply with agreements, Israel must not do so either.
America is in moral decline. We are now totally screwed in the middle east. We will be retreating with our tails between our legs and the entire region will erupt in war. Terrorism in america will not be countered all the time. They will hit us again and hard. Bush is a boob. America is to a certain extent a Satanic nation, we can no longer make excuses for all the evil we do and permit to be done. America is worshipping false gods and we are selling these false gods to our "allies". Israelis easily and willfully worship these false gods we offer them. Especially the euro trash stock that believes america is the greatest.
Confrontation with Washington? I very much doubt it! Why has this report come up now? Anything to do with weakness due to Winograd commission, perhaps? Or even hanniyeh's castration? There is probably the usual behind the scenes noises coming from various diplomats, but the fact remains that the PA, in its present form, is not about to agree to ANY of the Quartet's demands. So, terrorism continues, & pals lives get worse (if that's possible). Will hamas do what the UVF did in Ireland just yesterday? What a pathetic bunch of losers these Islamists are; just look at their record on womens' rights for a start, oh, & what about Alan Jonston??
You're a moderate Dino ... but still you went too far ... There is no such thing as an "illegal settlement" because that implies that some are indeed legal ... They're all illegal and they should/will all be dismantled ...
I would think Israelis and those of my own countrymen who are sympathetic to Israel would want her to succeed. The US is not going to sell out Israel, and Rice will certainly consider any reasonable objections Israeli leaders may have to US plans, but I would hope that it is the civilians in the Israeli government who are making the final decisions and that they are considering the political and diplomatic issues as well as immediate security concerns.
Why these nice suffering people elected these "some extremists" ?
Did palestinian pm Hanieh accepted the US plan?
Wow, does this ever sound familiar
Something EVERY human being need ponder.
Our demands are much more "humane" - and here they are: 1. Demand the PA restore Law and Order in every area under their control by August 1st. 2. All Palestinian militias and armed groups - other than officials - are to be disarmed - using non lethal force whenever possible by July 1st. 3. Palestinian Officials are to be trained and held up to rules of conduct (aka: real law and order) by Sept 1st. 4. Palestinian civillians should be able to walk to the bank or eat dinner without be shot by some armed militia (aka: real law and order) by July 1st. 5. Use whatever influence you have to help them accomplish this - as g-d knows we have no such influence. Then we can sit down and talk - really talk. Even have breakfast or share burekas. We can discuss how to cooperate with each other and build a nation - rather than a clan war pit. If you can't do this though - don't come to us with a bunch of ridiculous recommendations that we are not able to put into place.
The U.S. presented the plan to Abass and Olmert both of these leaders are no longer in power to implement the plan. Just to recap Abass was voted out by Palestinian people to be replaced by a terrorist group and Olmert is currently not in a position to even talk about any new plans that include giving Palestinians? weapons
I am amazed of how mny of the people in this forum are against peace....disgusted at the same time
As an American, I can assure you that I love to hear israelis tell us to "stick it where the sun don't shine." And I would erally love it if the U.S. goverment would do just that! I loathe israel - a disgusting racist state that flies in the face of every value we Americans hold dear. Out idiot politicians have bent over backwards for this looser place, condoing hidieous crmies against Palestinians, and all we get in return is the hatred of the world for supporting israel and its moral vacuum - and after totally corrupting our values for this so-called state, this is what we get? Screw you israelis! I dream of the day that we are free of this albatross called israel! I dream of it! Please guys, send your comments to my government! We DO NOT WANT ANYTHING TO DO WITH YOU EITHER!!!! LET'S PATR WAYS AND NEVER SPEAK AGAIN!!!!!
So the pals do not have to actually do much. While Isreal has been ladened with numerous "dates and times" the pals basically carry on. There was no time frame to dis arm or dis band any terror group what so ever. Basically this new peace plan in another hare brained idea from some one with very little knowledge of whats really going on.
Arabs, my friend, are not animals to be "handled." Your cultural elitism and bigotry does nothing but blind you. If only Israel would let go of the occupied territories... oh well. Thats a pipe dream.
My dear Cipora, How can the order that a woman with stroke in her 73 must go out of Hospital at the same day she had stroke. USA is about money. They see a lot of it now at Palestinians and on the other side smashed Israel. You were involved in wars in decades. Many of them for USA. Shabat Shalome from Sweden
In fact, your requirements for Israel are so mild that even Lieberman may accept them after drinking a bottle of vodka. But the requirements for the Pals are such that only you can make them comply. I always said you are a nice fellow! PS - Sorry for your Man U.
"Just one little question" Cipora. Dear Cipora. Your little question need a big answer. Self interest is not a true love.
Israels inconceivably harsh treatment of the Palestinians cannot last. The US can only allow/fund injustice for so long until it too is considered the proprietor of the injustice. Israel deserves peace and safe sovereign country. But no more than the Palestinians! Try to understand Israel, we love you but youre hurting us with your acts of impunity. Your the only nuclear power in the Middle East, no one country can end your existence, w/o themsleves being destroyed after any kind of attempt. The settlments havent stopped, the occupation is in its 40th yr. both need to end somehow..hopefully this is a step in that direction so peace can have a chance. A real chance, not under occupation.
If the PA gets the appropriate tools to do this, they need to make sure they do not screw this up; regain law and order and get rid of the rockets and the weapons of the streets. To achieve peace, we need to build confidence and trust between the Pals and the Israelis and this would be a step foward.
Considering the quagmire the US is in with Iraq and the problems Bush has with the Democratic controlled Congress on Iraq and the weakness of the Israeli Government which may fall at any moment, submitting such demands at this time is ludicrous.
Of course the Palestinians approve. It makes for excelarating terror in Israel and the hizballization of the West Bank. What do the Americans think. Do they think that these are the relations between the USA and Canada? They are acting as if there is no such thing as Hamas ,Islamic Jihad and AlAqsa Brigades. The PA will never lean heavy on the 'organizations'. Why should we be the 'good guys' who turn the other cheek?
sir during the batle of the bulge in belgium an german officer send an ultimatum to a group of surounded americans, surrender or else.the american commander send it back with one word.NUTS.may i suggest we do the same with this idiotic demand. joe.
as long as the arabs have gilad shalit in the gaza strip and the rockets keep falling on sderot and the negev and the incitement against israel continues unabated let them stay behind road blocks, checkpoints etcetra and the u.s plan can go to hell...
It appears that President Bush and Secretary Rice are resolved that the people of Israel and Palestine shall live. (האנשים של ישראל ופלסטין יחיו) Thank you Mr. President.
Do not allow Middle East Czar Baker, well that is who he is, tie the noose around your necks while you are distracted. Abbas is your enemy no less than Hamas or Iran. You cannot afford to make any more stupid mistakes. You are being led by your short hairs to your deaths. Do you want to die? You think Syria is afraid you will attack and that is why they are building up on the border? Well that is what your leadership seems to believe. You will have no one to blame but yourselves.
It appears that President Bush and Secretary Rice are resolved that the people of Israel and Palestine shall live. (האנשים של ישראל ופלסטין יחיו.) Thank you Mr. President.
expose its civilian population to acts of terror pepetrated by Palestinian forces. Israel has all the right in the world to resist such demands. The US must first demand of the PA to adhere to the three points demanded of it by the international community: End all acts of terror and violence, recognize Israel's right to exist and adhere to all signed agreements.
It seems that also US (like EU) start to accept that In Gaza and in West Bank there are living people, who have nothing to do with terrorism and to start making the difference between the terrorist and the ordinary people. Innocent men,women and children cannot be punished collectively for ever because of some extremists. It is like (everywhere) whole family should suffer because of the violent,abusive and irresponsable husbent and farther who is still living in the house and the others have no possibility to flee.
There is only one way that would bring peace: Extend the deadline for the demands (half a year) but change them dramaticly: For the Palestinians: Terror-organizations like Islamic Jihad have to be totally dismantled, all weapon smuggling tunnels destroied, only one military/police force allowed and in a referendum a majority of Palestinians must accept Israels right to exist. If those demands are not met all finacial aid by the West and the Arab league will be stopped. For Israel: All the illegal settlement outposts must be destroied, all other settlement expansion freezed, all under age prisoners must be released and Israel must accept the Geneva accords in principle (details can be worked out in negotiations with the Palestinians). If those demands are not met, Israel will face the same International sanctions as South-Africa did during the Apartheid. I am afraid that's the only language both parties would understand....
your really are a fool, live free or die? your dead then, funny how you attack a country you live in, if you do this ethinic cleansing, you will not have only the u.s on your back, but the whole world, the arabs can bump up the price of oil to tighten the screws on the u.s and the e.u, then your in for a ride of your life, down hill all the way.
if you don't like what we're doing , go home. it's funny how things come back to bite you in the butt hey? many jews have said that about arabs in other countries, now it's their turn.
what the hell are you talking about? it is blatantly a lie, some of the idf's commanders have gloated that they provoked pals into a clash, and as by certain zionist own plan, they do this to rid all of israel of arabs, it has also been stated by certain army chiefs that they provoked syria into one of the wars, go read then come back, otherwise, keep your fake posts to yourself and don't waste haaretz's time nor ours.
Israel should tell Bush and Rice where to shove their demands. Israel has taken enough risks and not one of them has proven worthwhile. We should not have to continue to commit suicide. Enough is Enough.
ANOTHER FANTASY TAKES THE FRONT PAGE !! THE INK STILL WET ON OSLO AND THEN THE ROAD MAP WE PRINT SOME MORE UNWORKABLE DEMANDS !!CONVOYS OF WHAT TO THE WEST ?? QASSAMS PERHAPS ?? ARM ABBAS ! WHAT HAPPENED TO THE GUNS FROM OSLO !! THESE "BOYS OF THE USA WATCH TOO MUCH US TELEVISION"
is america trying to suck up to the arabs? seems the king of saudi arabia is getting sick and tired of american policy, trying to change it all into a democratic society which is failing itself, those were the days of " we won't talk to any terrorist state until they straighten up" are over, these days it's " o.k, we'll talk to you, but you still have to straighten up", the bush government is failing dismally and he knows it, he bagged pelosi but sees the american community is favouring her and her policies, so he is now trying to change to win back support, olmert is a dead duck too, he has failed israel to the max, but hey, so is our prime minister, but ours is on his way out the next election, good riddens to bad rubbish i say.
An US general a supremo over Israel?!
working on this anymore. A lot of Talkbacks here on the Pals who are not to be trusted. Come on, Israel is the same. Many times Israel has broken a cease fire and triggered the Pals in returning fire by assassinations from their helicopters with rockets. Almost everytime there is a cease-fire, Israel starts assasinating Fatah/Hamas/Ialamic Jihad operatives with foreseeable consequences.
Israels policy of occupation is the most unsafe, unneccesary and hypocratic policy in the world today. A Democratic country practicing apartheid and colonialism to make a few extremists happy (the settlers) are endangering the struggle for democracy and HR in the rest of the world. It's time to make turn Isarel into a normal country accepted by the rest of the world, and also let Isarel gain support against anyone not accepting Isarel within it's accpetd borders (1967). Israel's main problem is not even Iran, the major problem is as Isarel creates enemies who clearly have their rights violated. This prevents Isarel from international acceptance, ruins the safety of the state, ruins the economy etc.. etc..
DB: "Demands are for the most part always accepted by Israel and implemented while the PA also accepts and breaks the following day." Go here, Damon: http://usinfo.state.gov/mena/Archive/2005/Nov/15-811620.html "The agreement calls for the start of bus and truck convoys between Gaza and the West Bank, the reduction of obstacles to movement within the West Bank, the export of Palestinian agricultural products" Does THAT sound familiar? It is the list of demands that have just been delivered to Israel, yet it is dated Nov 15 2005. How Can That Be, Damon? Dare I suggest it is because Israel ALREADY "accepted" that it would do all these things back in 2005, and has "implemented" exactly NONE of them.
"Once again the US presents Israel and the PA with demands. Demands are for the most part always accepted by Israel and implemented while the PA also accepts and breaks the following day." Tell us something, Damon, about how well Israel obeys the US demand that it should not expand its existing illegal settlements or build any new ones.
Sure it is, Reuven. You tell the Americans to go to hell, but at the same time you kiss goodbye to that $5,000 million a year you get in aid, that automatic veto at the UN and all those lovely hi-tech arms you can buy. Is it a deal?
..a signatory to a "prior agreement" where it made a legally binding committment to do the things listed above. It hasn't carried out ANY of them, and now the USA has simply run out of patience with her. Condi is finally putting the foot down, and she can do that because the Israelis have ALREADY AGREED TO DO THESE THINGS. They did so in November 2005, when they signed the "Agreement on Movement and Access" with the PA. Condi was there when Israel signed it, and she has decided that Enough Is Enough. Israel has managed until now to get away with signing agreements in bad faith precisely because the USA has been indulgent with her. That happy time now appears to be over; if Israel "signs up" to an agreement then she will have to "live up" to that agreement. About bloody time too.
Our government should tell the Americans to stick their timetable where the sun don't shine.
Again all these arrogant comments from the usual arrogant Jews here on talkback bluffing their way through. Israel is dependent from the US, without the US it will not survive one month. Illusions are always dangerous and stupid, but the one that says Israel can walk on it's own feet in particular.
whats really messed up about this is that these are tiny demands that will allow Palestinians to live slightly less imprisoned lives, yet we get the same old "security concern" arguments as if these trump any and all issues the Palestinians face. The level of narcissism is breathtaking and heinous/tragic, the good news is that the Israel is like all other nations in this respect, the bad news is that this will be the death of human civilization
weapons trucks to Abbas-fatah thru Keren Shalom crossing that Hamas kidnapped , it is waht they now call unity gov't isn't it , whether Abbas-fatah or Hamas , pals dual strategy is used by both , Arab League want all the cake , jews transfer , withdrawal from Golan , pal State , half in Iran terror Gaza and half in west bank , US out of Iraq and nukes for Iran ,
Tell that to your government sir. Israel is nothing but an extention of American hegemony in the Middle East. The only reason why Israel hasn't been wiped off the face of the Earth is because of INCREDIBLY self interested, but still generous, donations of the American government to Israel. Not that I condone at all the wiping of Israel off the face of the map. I recognize Israel's existence, but not the nonsense about its "right" to exist. To much manifest destiny for this atheist. Anywho, 2.8 BILLION dollars a year in exclusively military aid? Without that, where would Israel be?
Israel agreed to allow bus convoys between the Gaza and West Bank on 15 November 2005, when they signed the "Agreement on Movement and Access" with the Palestinian Authority http://usinfo.state.gov/mena/Archive/2005/Nov/15-811620.html What THIS current issue is about is that Israel has consistantly refused to carry out that binding obligation. It's called a "prior agreement", Cipora. The Quartet are supposed to hold very great store in parties adhering to "prior agreements". Or so I am told......
Once again the US presents Israel and the PA with demands. Demands are for the most part always accepted by Israel and implemented while the PA also accepts and breaks the following day. When will the US and EU, etc. ever learn that you cannot negotiate with a terrorist organization. One has only to look no furthur than the cease fire in Gaza. WE CEASE - THEY FIRE.
sticks.grow up,join the 21st century!
...if the destruction of Israel by world class terrorists is the goal. No problem. Is this, by chance, a belated Haaretz April fool's joke? If not... someone needs to shred this "document" before flushing it so the toilet doesn't clog.
Quote " Finally the US is begining to realise that they cannot try to befriend the arabs in Iraq and other parts of the middle east while letting their bretheren suffer in Palestine, the road to Baghdad is through Jerusalem. It will NEVER get what it wants in this oil rich region, especially as Iran rises, while letting this festering sore continue. " , , , so much jealousy and hatred packed in a couple of fabricated clichés lines , your iranian shiite grief comes from centuries years old oppression of sunnis against shiites , it is an irreparable tragedy between muslims , the disrespect shown between each others for their choice as followers of Mohamed or Ali , between sunnis or shiites will always be a source of instability in the Mideast , the proof is thru the use of oil's revenues deepenin' their disrespectful discord , Iran's choice to seek nuclear weapon is the same as Saudia's choice to promote its Wahabism , they both see it as a psychological pride to display thru their disrespectful discord , they both seek absolute recognition of their pride , they nonetheless both must be stopped for they both have blood in their hands , their Iraq mutual battlefield is a striknin' proof of their absolutism , their terror tentacles hezbollah or pals are just pawns same as gatherin' votes from arabs states in this struggle ,it doesn't mislead neither deviate attention from their evil intents taken between them , against them and whatever internal muslims problems and muslims plots , muslims throw at the Zionist State doorsteps ,
THese demands will never be met by Israel. If they remove roadblocks, how are they going to continue to destroy the Palestinians lives so that they will move away from their homes and leave the land for Jews? This will defintely hinder Israeli ethnic clensing plans, and therefore all the good Zionists here will resist it under various prevarications and ruses. And in the end the U.S. will of course cave into their Israeli bosses.
These one-sided demands cannot even be considered by Israel. Rice and the US state department are engineering the defeat of the US in Iraq and trying to engineer the demise of the state of Israel. Israel must rid itself of the same philosophy that brought our demise 2000 years ago when we asked the Romans for help. We must wake up and understand the US state dept is and always has been Arabists and cares not a whit whether we exist or not. In fact, they'd love to see us go because they believe we are a "stumbling block" to peace in the region and the free flow of oil. We must rid ourselves of the false (pretend) philosophy/ideology that wars cannot be won (significantly, our enemies don't believe this) and stop thinking that we can trust other nations/entities to safeguard our borders. Israel must start acting as a sovereign state whose enemies STATE DAILY they don't want a TIE, the want victory and their definition of victory is our destruction. Pretending otherwise means death.
the words handle arabs and manage arabs do you think hitler Managed the jews better? for sombody to manage other race is as bad as my Q ?
Olmert could regain some credibility by accepting this plan if the Americans first remove their roadblocs throughout Iraq and then put in place a bus convoy, 5 times a day from the border of Syria to Bahgdad.
Why is it when politicians/governments are at their end of term/life, they try in desperation to create an event that they think they will be remembered for or that will solve other problems? It is like the rollercoaster ride in the amusement park. No good ride ends with a flat track- there is a giant last minute, hold onto your seat climax that takes your breath away. Good for the parks- BAD FOR GOVERNMENTS! Remember Jimmy C's strong drive for ME peace, Barak's dangerousely overboard offers to Arafat, Olmerts upsurd decisions on Lebanon II. Can't wait to see how Peretz/Olmert will design their final thrill as they struggle to survive. Bush/Rice are reaching their final ride and the ME curve they want to design is so thrilling, it could Kill! Sorry, enough demands USA- friendship is based on mutual interests-not just your own. Test your plans in an amusement park. If the ride creates ultimate thrills, it is NOT good for policy- especially Israel's.
tell the us to go to hell! what would you do as an American jew if the us is in war with israel ? you loyal american Jew
You are seeing the boomerang effect of Israeli policies. First you have Israel claiming Hamas is a "terrorist organization". Ok, Washington bought into that scam, Washington suddenly has a keen interest in not seeing a "terrorist organization" rise to power. Bush in many speeches said he would come to the aid of those seeking to get rid of "terrorists" in their midst. As a result, Israel's problem has become America's problem. Now interests diverge, Olmert's war of occupation is meeting Bush's war on terror. Bush is eager to bring down Hamas - at any cost, Israel wants both Fatah and Hamas destroyed. I wish America would play a constructive role than stoke the flames with dumping more weapons. That includes weapons to Israel. It looks like Bush is bringing Iraqi style democracy to Palestine. Hooray, what better way to start things off than with a shipment of M-16's.
For the Bush administration, a flea-covered bedfellow of Israel, to come up with this long and detailed list of so-called "demands" should give people some idea of the misery that the road blocks are causing the Palestinian people. Even the imbecilic, Zionist Bushco can see that they are a scandal and a humanitarian disaster.
This once again reinforces the idea that in geo politics there are no friends ...just interests! The u.s. demands on israel despite the other side having a jihadist led govt. rockets falling within the green line, none of the educational reforms implemented by the palestinians, and soldiers still kidnapped.....what a absurd pathetic joke to think peace israel has any sort of peace partner!!! The u.s. will turn on israel for short term gains at the cost of long term strategy!!
I see you're harrumphing for stern measures by Israel, far away from all the danger and misery in the relative safety of Missiouri. Could I suggest you go and live in the hellhole that is Israel, then we might respect your opinion a little more? You're another "Shouter Not A Shooter For Israel".
Just as well that somebody is prodding us in the right direction..... and ofcourse our first response is GEVALT!!.......
If you look at the list, it is the USA telling Israel to stop dragging its feet on existing undertakings; reducing roadblocks, opening borders, allowing convoys b/t Gaza/WB. By comparison Abbas doesn't even have to stop the Qassams; he just has to be seen to be TRYING to stop them. Not good from Israel's point of view, because it means that the USA is loosing patience with the Israeli claim that it doesn't have to do anything until Abbas stomps on all the other Pal groups. Apart from the Qassams, Abbas is not obliged to do any stomping at all; tho' he does get to go shopping for heavy-duty boots. In effect the USA is now saying to Israel "Concern yourself only with your own tasks, sonny, and leave the Pals to me" That means, of course, it is only as good as the USA willingness to be fair and unbiased when it comes to applying the thumbscrews to BOTH sides. Which does rather depend on what Bush has promised the Saudi's, doesn't it...
We will not be sacrificed for Bush's war in Iraq. Bush & Rice are 100% clueless when it comes to the Middle East. Presidents come & presidents go, but Eretz Yisroel is forever! Am Yisroel Chai V"Kayiam!
You are beginning to understand what is happening and what will happen to Israel. You are quite correct that the future is spinning out of Israel's control as I have tried to point out here many times. Even with a new president in 2009, the US will care less and less about what happens to Israel because of the turn inward the US will take. As Israel loses the protection of the US and Israel's enemies continually grow stronger, Israel is going to be faced with more and more crisis until one day Israel either gives up its dreams and reaches a fair agreement with the Arabs or is destroyed by the Arabs. The future is vastly different frorm the past.
With all its imperfections,the plan set up in this document should be accepted and let work.Although the most important obligation of the Palestinians (PA government acceptance of the Quartet principles, including renunciation of violence) has the vague deadline of "as soon as possible",I would be curious to see whether the PA Security Forces will deploy and conduct counter-smuggling operations between RCP and the Mediterranean coast, and begin to destroy tunnel networks "No Later Than June 15,2007" as specified in this document.......
how can US give weapons to a terrorist organization like PA? They even do not recognise Israel and their only goal is to whipe Israel off the map. Unless they give up this horrible attitude Israel cannot deal with them. Also not with Hamas being even worse. US mind your own business. You have overplayed your card in Iraq and don't know how to handle properly.
first the US must remove all roadblocks in Iraq
How on earth do you expect the Palestinians to stand up to the lawlessness prevailing in Gaza and the territories if they do not have a security force adequate enough?! Yes, if the weapons fall in the wrong hands it would be disastrous for Israel, but definitely there will be many assurances in that regard since the US is brokering this deal. And we all know how crazy the US is about Israeli security. You always whine about your security and the "terror" from the territories. The Pals do not want you sweeping in every now and then killing a few militants and the occasional innocent few as well. Let them clean up their own mess.
As a Palestinian, I like the tone of the article and the reciprocal steps required by each side, eventually over time, the hatred will go away and peace will shine..Jon, Alex and American Jew, you are the reason why the host countries of jews turn on you, all you do is hate and talk crap, if you are such a big jew then why don't you live in israel?..the fruit is there for the picking..you are nothing but a bunch of armchair critics...all bark, no action.
civilians in harm's way, and America has no right to even suggest that Israeli citizens should pay with their lives for a policy that is a substitute of demanding of the Palestinians to cease all acts of terror which that have not done even for a single day!
Where are the provisions about the Temple? Where are the provisions about Hebron? This plan is designed to create a Palestinian state. Fine. But if we are going to give land for peace, we should get control of our holy sites too.
Given the fact that US are conducting some of the worst crimes in history of mankind in Iraq and Afganistan, nobody would listen her demands about anything.
About time the hard word came down on Israel although I doubt the weak Bush regime will have the balls to push it through. Abbas cannot stop rocket attacks unless he has the armed men to do it, and at the same time Israel must stop its raids and murders of suspected freedom fighters if they truely want to find any sort of peace. There is just too many citizens killed and disabled by the IDF to ask for any respect to be given from the Pal side. To assassinate someone means you have no respect for the law, and "innocent until proven guilty" in a court of law. It is the way of savages, an uncivilized and backward way of achieving what you want. Get rid of the road blocks and help the Palestinians establish some sort of economy, (instead of collective starvation) and just maybe a road to peace can start to be paved.
Wow, What a blatant sell out. Nohing but vile stab in the back. but thats nothing new from the US. In a nutshell: Israel must AGREE to let their sworn chiled murdering enemy travel freely within its land to kill its people. The enemy is only asked for a plan, a piece of worthless unenfocable paper, to prevent indiscriminite bombing by Qassams. Anybodey with any sense of self worth and sense of survival ought to flush such a proposal down the toilet. whats worse, however, is that this is simply a contimuing thrust by the USA begun at and after OSLO. The US is reeling in defeat, and so must also be Israel after Lebanon. But Lebanon was not the real debacle. The disaster was not even the exit from Gaza and the non-obliteration of the Hez and the Pals. The disaster was the knuckling under to ther US in the first Lerbanon war and letting Yasser out alive. The only solution now is to re conquer Gaza, eliminate the bastards living there. Pay the heavy price now,live free or die.
You are seeing the boomerang effect of Israeli policies. First you have Israel claiming Hamas is a "terrorist organization". Ok, Washington bought into that scam, Washington suddenly has a keen interest in not seeing a "terrorist organization" rise to power. Bush in many speeches said he would come to the aid of those seeking to get rid of "terrorists" in their midst. As a result, Israel's problem has become America's problem. Now interests diverge, Olmert's war of occupation is meeting Bush's war on terror. Bush is eager to bring down Hamas - at any cost, Israel wants both Fatah and Hamas destroyed. I wish America would play a constructive role than stoke the flames with dumping more weapons. That includes weapons to Israel. It looks like Bush is bringing Iraqi style democracy to Palestine. Hooray, what better way to start things than with a shipment of M-16's.
How can the United States demand that Israel allow bus services between Gaza and the West Bank through sovereign Israeli territory?
You can rest assured that the Council on American/Islamic Relations has some influence on the "demands" if it came from the Bush administration. It seems so easy for other nations to tell Israel how to commit political and national suicide. Sigh. Were it not for oil the other nations wouldn't even be paying attention.
The world should have woken up a long time ago. Israel also needs to learn lessons and so far no one told them what to do. Arabs or not, Israelis or not, this is not the request...simply to respect the basics of HR. Though the Palestinians should also stop their attacks on Israeli civilians at once...but I guess, they only will, once aggression and occuopation against them will stop.
I think you got it all wrong. Israel is the one that hadn't kept any promises or agreements that it had signed with the Pales. They are too many to list (road blocks, assassinations, withholding Pales tax funds....etc). Come out of your shell and read the news
Completely disgusting of our so-called friends. They must be told emphatically where to get off.We should arm our sworn enemies and allow them free access into our land?! Are they out of their minds?
I would call you "Jew who somehow holds American citizenship and uses it to promote Israeli interests over American Interests". a.k.a. traitor.
...we are not under your command. Beware of where you tread mighty America for there is one mightier than you watching over Israel, and not even you will be able to withstand his wrath. Our American friends need to rein in the Bush administration before he brings them to ruin.
Talking to Syria. Trying to talk to Iran. Pressing Israel. Israel on the altar of Iraq.
will in a pavlovian manner diligently obey to Washington and as part of US Benchmarks relief every Islam terror demands , P.S , the 72 years old virgin request from US Condi a guarder for Olmert's biweekly Jdate with Jihad Abbas ,
Sounds more like demands to Israel and more blah blabah for the Arabs, plans and plans and plans that will never be executed by the Arabs. Why not make a time table for them to execute the demands of the Quartet which ought to be: NOW! Maybe to set up a multilateral force led by the US to invade Gaza and the West Bank with the hope it will have better results than in Irak.
It's time to stand up and become men not mice, every US lead proposition has led to failure. Forget the US failed peace they can't even handle themselves. Look at the mess their country is facing!
Israel should firmly tell the USA to fix its own problems - especially in Iraq - before requiring her to give arms and munitions to forces which do not even formally recognize Israel's right to exist. The chutzpah inherent in this American craziness is an embarrassment to me as an American citizen, and a threat to me as a Jew. Tell Condi Rice and the US bullies to take a long walk on a short pier...
So, explain this again to me...what are the "measures" or "demands" the Palestinians must meet. The only thing the entire article mentions is "to develop a plan against Qassam Rockets", is this some sort of joke, was this not a commitment Abbas made over 2 years ago? Either this is the most poorly written article ever, or this list of demands is complete joke...a farse by the Bush administration to try to do what every US president does at the end of their term, its a smoke screen. Here is an idea Bush, since you consider yourself jesus's disciple to fight terrorism, tell Hamas to cease terror or there will never be a Palestinian state, doesn't seem to be hard to do in Iraq, or does it?
"Demands" Ed. Israel is loosing its grip on the situation in all fronts. Whatever the reason for this mad deterioration in Israel's situation; there is one reason that can't be disputed. Israel is becoming like a truly Arab Middle East country.Infighting takes a higer priority than the national security of the nation.This is the result of almost tribal politics all the parties conducting in runnig the affair of the country. The government is weak for a long time now.Foreign powers are taking advantage of the weakness of the government and started to dictate their own demends. For a small country like Israel this will put Israel on the slippery slop. Once Israel will loose the steering wheels of power, its future will not be in its hands. Its destiny will be in the hands of others. Israel has the pontential but it is letting it go from its hands. Too much of internal politics too little of patriotism and much less of self pride with the among the politiations.
try to befriend the arabs in Iraq and other parts of the middle east while letting their bretheren suffer in Palestine, the road to Baghdad is through Jerusalem. It will NEVER get what it wants in this oil rich region, especially as Iran rises, while letting this festering sore continue.
Maybe somebody should tell George that benchmarks and time tables are OK. Of course any application to George is anathema. Is Condie out on a limb with this? Does George know? If they're OK for Israelis and Palestinians, why not for Iraqis and Americans? Sauce for the goose, Mr. Bush!
Iraq and corruption are keeping Bush too busy to take on a fight with Israel. Impeachment is a threat of some degree to most high ranking officials of the administration. Secretary Rice is in trouble for false statements and other actions prior to the Iraq war. Everybody in Israel should know by now that Palestinians never keep promises. Therefore the proposed time table is worthless. Israel will keep commitments and Palestinians will have excuses for not doing what is required.
Iraq has shown that the US doesn't know the first thing about managing Arabs. I don't think they are the authority to tell Israel it's safe to arm terrorists intent on destroying them. I love the US but common, they don't have a clue about how the world works outside their borders. I'm amazed how little 5 years of war in Iraq has changed their cultural ignorance of others.
WOW...It is hard for me to imagine a scenario on which these opposing forces could come to this kind of agreement. And certainly not over a long period of time as the violence will only continue, only worse. With transport and knowledge moving back and forth Israel would sooner find itself back at war and eventually choosing the option they should have chosen at the very beginning. The elimination of those who don't want to live peaceably in the land of Israel. Ask them nicely to leave. Punish those who stay and rebel. Simple.
WHO THE HELL IS AMERICA TO DEMAND.?????LET RICE AND CO DEMAND FROM THE AMERICANS WHAT SHE WANTS.ANY SO CALLED DEMANDS WIL BE THE LAST TO BE ACTIVATED.
in Israel are involved. America would not risk its own civilians, and it has no right to even suggest to risk the life of Jewish children, the elderly and people of all agaes in between who are Israaelis. If the Arabs are not even able to denounce terror and vilence, let alone to apply themselves to it, why should we provide them with tthe opportunities to murder us? If the Arabs are not even able to accept Israel's right to existence and to adhere to signed agreements, why should Israel take risks with people whose goal is to annihilate the Jewish state?
Give back Texas and California to the Mexicans. Return Manhatten to the Indians. They were ripped off. Close down McDonalds, Burger Kings, Wendy's and Wal-Mart
Not entirely a fair proposal, but reasonable. Certainly everyone can agree that just as important as stopping Qassams is removing checkpoints. But Israel should not be responsible for providing any weapons to the PA. That just goes against the best interests of all parties involved. Israel, cause the weapons can be used against them. The U.S., causethe PA isn't always going to be "moderate". And the PA itself cause it'll now be seen as a lackey of Israel.
White House has given Rice the order to push Israel around a little to make the Pals happy so that Syria and Iran lay off Iraq. Bush is so desperate over Iraq that he is slowely relenting and has sent Condi to speak with Syrian officials. Israel has to start learning to be independent and not rely on US welfare $$$ because U.S. can and will always push you around for their agenda when they will need to. Remember Clinton years and how Arafat's PLO/PA was trained and later used Israel supplied M-16s against Israel in the first and second intifada.
This only shows the ignorance of Rice, she just blew off the Makkah agreement, and if this continues, only violence will escalate both on the Israeli and Palestinian Sides, she is definitely a failure. The demands on Israel are very minimal; removing road blocks and providing transportation! Is this some kind of joke! If you stole 5/6 of a person's home, and left him cornered in 1/6 of his home and you continually attack him, would you accept them to agree to peace and justify your occupation of their home! Of course not! By retreating to the 1967 borders, Hamas and Fatah will agree to a long term peace plan that will develop into a final solution between both sides, and if not, the result will be what has been described in the Quran, Bible, and the Torah, the fall down of Israel. So do good to yourselves so that G-d does good to you, no human being enjoys the slaying of other human beings, not even the most extreme on the Israel side or the Palestinian side.
Stronger Goverment Now to Say NO NO. Show some guts for once SAY NO WAY
are realized by opening border crossings?
once again, israel is asked (told) to do a through z and pals are asked to plan, and try to prevent terror. when will people learn that the whole reason we're still in this mess is b/c the pals have not been willing to DO that same solitary condition that they are always asked to do and thats to stop terror! israel should refuse; no more 'deals' in which israel gives the pals something for nothing.
Risking the lives of Israeli civilians in exchange for "ease of tensions" with Hamas is simply not worth trying. You can't negotiate with terrorists whose minimum objective is your utter destruction.
I don't even know what to say. Except, Israel remains in my prayers. Praying that God will bless each and every heart with prayer to lead you in the way you should go.
reach anyones benchmarks.. so what does this mean? ISRAEL will be forced to reach thiers and pay the price for a lost war in Lebanon and be forced to make REAL PAINFUL consenssions AGAIN!
This is just a delaying tactic. It won't work, it's not necessary and it's doomed to fail. Either do it all at once(Saudi plan) or don't do nothing at all (current U.S./Israeli pla buy time to be able to impose a unilateral (the wall)) plan. Condi doesn't have a clue to what it takes to be a Secretary of State, just like everyone else in the "W" administration. Sad that we have morons on both sides while the Pals seem to have their sh** together.
There is no way for Abbas to implement a plan to stop the Kassams or any other aggression by the "resistance" without appearing to betray the Palestinian cause to many if not most Palestinians. Why do it and weaken the Palestinians so that in the end Israel will be in a stronger position vis a vis the Palestinians? The Palestinians "know" that Israel will not carry out its part anyway. There may a way of proceeding to peace. It is predicated on the assumptions that there exists a peace agreement acceptable to Palestinians as well as Israelis. If such an agreement exists, it can be attained by both sides negotiating a definition of such an agreement without stop until such a common definition is attained, covering all aspects of the conflict including refugee compensation borders and Jerusalem. Backed by such an agreement it is possible to start negotiations to obtain a staged implementation agreement. The last stage will be the preagreed final status.
"Palestinian sources told Haaretz that the PA has accepted the document..." Bravo to the Palestinians. Clearly they want peace.
Hey there Paul Harris, are you looking?? You better learn a new two step, yup, peace train is leaving the station. No more excuses!! Have coffee. Regards.
Rice or any country cannot play god on Israel.