• Published 12:16 20.10.09
  • Latest update 12:46 20.10.09

Galilee man gets 9 years for killing girl with ATV on Yom Kippur

Assad Shibli was operating an all-terrain vehicle which struck and killed Tal Zino on Yom Kippur two years ago.

By Eli Ashkenazi Tags: Israel news

Assad Shibli, who was operating his all-terrain vehicle which struck and killed nine-year-old Tal Zino on Yom Kippur two years ago in the Galilee town of Kfar Tabor, was sentenced on Tuesday to nine years in prison by Nazareth District Court.

Shibli was also ordered by the court to pay the Zino family NIS 50,000.

As the verdict was handed down, Zino's mother burst into tears. Shibli's father, though, shouted: "There was no fair trial here."

In July, Shibli was convicted of manslaughter in Zino's death.

Mohammed Shibli, a relative of the defendant who was also in the vehicle at the time, was found guilty of having fled the scene of an accident. He was sentenced to two years imprisonment.

He was cleared of manslaughter because it could not be confirmed that he was aware of Assad Shibli's intention to enter Kfar Tavor, where the incident took place on Yom Kippur.

The indictment alleged that the defendants drove into the town intentionally, knowing the Israeli custom for children to roam the roads freely on Yom Kippur as traffic comes to a halt.

Shibli's father Nassim said that he would appeal the verdict to the supreme court claiming the judge's decision was racist.

Judge Yitzhak Cohen said he could not trust the testimony of the two accused, who are both residents of the Bedouin town of Shibli, near Kfar Tavor.

"They understood the meaning of Yom Kippur and saw that there were many people on the road, including children. The driver ignored the amount of people, drove at high speed, on two wheels, while making a lot of noise, increased the speed and entered toward a crowd that tried to escape."

  • Print Page
  • Send to a friend
  • Share
  • Text Size +|-
 
 
TalkBacks

Why Facebook Connect?

Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.

Add a comment

Add your reply

  • 4. 0 0
    One has to wonder what the sentence would have been if...
    • Colin Wright
    • 21.10.09
    • 04:54

    The religions of the culprit and the victim had been reversed. You know, there probably IS a comparable case. What was the sentence?

  • 3. 0 0
    racist judge
    • bytheway
    • 20.10.09
    • 17:06

    If the judge would have been fair and impartial the man in question would have gotten a jail sentence of at least 15 years to life. Murder is murder everywhere except in Israel.

  • 2. 0 0
    Pitifully light sentence...
    • Ignored Talkbacker
    • 20.10.09
    • 16:56

    9 years and 50,000 NIS for killing a girl? Pathetic. Anyone and everyone who has EVER been in Israel on Yom Kippur knows that the whole country shuts down and all the children play in the streets, free from cars. Shibli knew this, and entered the town as a deliberate provocation. I cannot speculate whether he intentionally hit Tal, but an 'accident' was very foreseeable. A better lawyer might have pressed on with a murder charge, but negligence and manslaughter is easily proved here. That his father is complaining about a 'racist' sentence is sick. Racist like the OJ trial. 9 years for taking a life while trying to piss people off on their holiest day. 15,000 USD to the family for that life. Anything wrong here? Why is Israel so afraid of offending those that wish to destroy it. A criminal act should bring about an appropriate sentence, not one that will appease criminals.

  • 1. 0 0
    The accused deserve longer sentence
    • C2
    • 20.10.09
    • 16:34

    Cars are no toys, In my belief the judge was lenient.