Fischer: Olmert, Zelekha had disputes over Bank Leumi tender
PM, then finance minister, suspected of trying to influence tender in Leumi sale to favor Australian magnate.
By Yuval YoazBank of Israel Governor Stanley Fischer met with police six weeks ago and gave his testimony over the Bank Leumi affair, in which Prime Minister Ehud Olmert is a suspect.
State Prosecutor Eran Shendar has ordered the police to begin a criminal investigation into Olmert on suspicion of having attempted, in his former role as finance minister, to influence the tender for the Leumi sale in order to help his friend, Australian real estate mogul Frank Lowy, gain a controlling interest in the bank.
Fischer met with two senior police officers at his Bank of Israel office as part of the State Prosecutor's investigation following the suspicions raised by State Comptroller Micha Lindenstrauss over the sale of Bank Leumi.
The officers interrogated Fischer for two hours, during which he told them that during all of the meetings over the Bank's purchase, there were professional disagreements between Olmert and Accountant-General Yaron Zelekha, who filed the complaint against Olmert and is the key witness in the case.
According to Fischer, during the meetings each side presented his side and attempted to influence the other. In Fischer's opinion, both sides presented legitimate cases.
After giving his testimony, Fischer was asked to keep his meeting with the investigators secret.
During a Bank of Israel press conference last week, Fischer refused to answer questions regarding the affair, noting that it was under police investigation. He did however say that "there are professional disputes over the matter."
Lowy says he welcomes police probeAustralian real estate magnate Frank Lowy said Wednesday that he welcomed the police investigation into the affair.
In a statement released in Australia, Lowy said that his group had been invited to join an international syndicate that wanted to participate in the sale of Bank Leumi. He strenuously denied any indication that he or anyone connected to him had done anything illegal, adding that he was certain the investigation would prove this.
Lowy has not been implicated in any way in the affair, and is not facing any police probe.
The tender for the bank's privatization was published in November 2005, four months after Olmert replaced Benjamin Netanyahu at the treasury.
During that time, Olmert demanded various changes to the tender, which he explained were aimed at encouraging strategic, rather than merely financial, investors to bid. However, law enforcement officials suspect that the changes were meant to help Lowy.
In the end, however, Lowy withdrew from the tender shortly before it closed. The businessman on Wednesday welcomed the probe into Olmert's activities.
The suspicions against Olmert first emerged during an audit of the sale by State Comptroller Micha Lindenstrauss. The comptroller heard testimony from Accountant-General Yaron Zelekha and other officials in Zelekha's office. After finishing his audit, Lindenstrauss transferred the material to Mazuz, who then asked the police to conduct "preliminary inquiries" into the matter.
According to Shendar, this included questioning some additional people involved in the sale, aside from those who spoke with Lindenstrauss. Based on these findings, Shendar decided Tuesday to launch a criminal probe.
"The results of the preliminary inquiries led to the conclusion that the evidentiary infrastructure justified opening a criminal investigation," the Justice Ministry said in a statement.
One bit of evidence reportedly gathered by the police is a document listing changes in the terms of the tender, which Lowy allegedly read aloud at a meeting with Leumi officials. Olmert allegedly used this same document while demanding that treasury officials change the tender.
Police Commissioner Moshe Karadi announced Tuesday that the probe would be handled by the national fraud squad, which also conducted the preliminary inquiries. The fraud squad is also currently handling the probe into alleged influence-peddling at the Tax Authority, in which a key suspect is Olmert's office manager, Shula Zaken.
One of Olmert's aides said Tuesday night that his office "was not surprised by the decision" to open the probe, "in light of the contemptible leak a week ago, while the prime minister was in China.
"The prime minister is certain that his behavior in the affair was unexceptionable," the aide continued. "He acted impeccably, and if it were necessary to do it again, he would act exactly the same way. The [sale] process received the approval of Bank of Israel Governor Stanley Fischer and Finance Ministry legal adviser Yemima Mazuz. We are certain that nothing will come of this, just as nothing came of the investigations against previous prime ministers."
According to a senior Justice Ministry official, Olmert is suspected of breach of trust for having acted out of a conflict of interests.
The official said the decision to open a probe was based in part on the Supreme Court's ruling in the case of Shimon Sheves, a former director general of the Prime Minister's Office: "When a senior public servant has a conflict of interests, he broadcasts to those under him, and to the entire public, the failure of the public system, the breaking of governmental rules. When this conflict of interests includes a financial aspect, the public servant airs the connection between money and government."
The criminal investigation over Olmert's involvement in the Leumi sale may be only one of a string of legal proceeding facing the prime minister.
The Justice Ministry has not yet decided whether to open probes into two other allegations against Olmert, both involving his tenure as industry minister: that he gave unwarranted benefits to clients of his former law partner, Uri Messer, and made political appointments at the Small Business Authority.
Attorney General Menachem Mazuz will decide on these two cases.
In response to the prosecution's announcement on Wednesday, the Prime Minister's Office urged the police to finish the probe as soon as possible.
Normally, only the attorney general can order the investigation of a prime minister. However, Mazuz recused himself from the case because his sister, Yemima Mazuz, was involved in the Leumi sale as the Finance Ministry's legal adviser.
Roni Singer-Heruti contributed to this report.
|
Prime Minister Ehud Olmert visiting Ephraim crossing, near the West Bank town of Tul Karm, on Tuesday. (Reuters) |
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
I think Olmert is a terrible PM. Zelekha is probably an excellent Accountant General. In this case however, I believe Stanley Fisher's statement "In Fischer's opinion, both sides presented legitimate cases" (although I have no idea what those cases were). What's wrong with a legitimate case presented by the Finance Minister? Maybe it's wrong, I really don't know, since I haven't, yet, been a minister.
we, from the diaspora, must help you, like Fisher does, in order to get out of the chritout plenter
To the highly intelligent one-sided Clickfool: You know what causes all of Israel`s problems and who gets into politics and the army. Do you also know what causes all of the Arab countries` problems and who goes to politics and army there?
When an illeterate poor man is caught stealing would it be fair to punish him like a lawyer,himself surrounded by lawyer advisors, caught stealing at the highest levels ? Surely not. The illeterate will be punished with all the force of the law and Olmert the lawyer will be sent to a minimum inconvenience Rehabilitation Center for a short lapse of time.
Whole transcation as of: - Could the benefit of this transcation "I personaly don't know about it" been better for your State, Economie and you people if done other way or No. I think if the answer is no then why Creating more pressure, and issue to your leader who is working for your best. Just Look arround you and see how the world picture is changing in a positive way and can be better soon and for your neighboor Also. If this Probe is to Prove how your state is very democratic then it is great, but why now, Why not after, or before even he become the PM of your state. If this is meant for other reason i really don't want to even think about it, that i feel sorry. AT the end is it a must to be a poor guy with No Appartment "LOL" to be a good public servant. try to do some limited rotation ... Very Freindly and Good Luck
"However, our Army is the best and most moral in the world."
Do you remember when Moshe Katsav welcomed the investigation into his sexual escapades???
Ehud go Home. You are so corrupt you should not even spend one more day as Prime Minister. GO HOME.
adjoining cells.
Halutz left, now is time for Olmert
...And before presumably, His Royal Arrogance did not know the ills of the Zionist Entity? Nevertheless, pretty decent post. That's saying a hell of lot for the 24/7 Man of Talkback. It's all correct except for the last 3 words. Sadly, most people in Israeli politics today do disgrace Israel, and are slime. They do not honor the Zionist ideal. The proverbial "this hurts me more than it hurts you" comes to mind. However, our Army is the best and most moral in the world. We all serve in the IDF. It is to be hoped that the new IDF Chief will take morality to greater heights and ease the stringent open fire orders now in place. This will serve to remove even more evil from our midst, increase deterrence, and save countless lives, both Jew and Arab.
let's wait and see. Maybe there will be some more.....
Olmert cannot be trusted. It is clear he is only looking out for #1 (that is, himself) and that makes him dangerous. The greedy, corrupt strategic infant ordered a war - Lebanon - that was not only unfounded and very poor strategy but he did so even after being told by some in the military that it could not be won. Unlike what we are fed in the media Israel is not in an existential fight. Why don't we hear that Ahmedinijad has lost the support of his people and government? That his antics and histrionics are meaningless and rejected by his own people? We are not told of these facts because we are meant to constantly live in a state of fear. How else can we be distracted from the dirty dealings of Mr. Olmert and the other dirty politicians? If we have no reason to be fearful, the military industrial complex (yes it exists here too) loses its footing and the tool Olmert loses his customers and financiers. Solution? Avishai Braverman. He truly may be our last hope.
A true civil society, like Israel, is based on the rule of law and order. That's what makes Israel such a strong democracy. I know there are many in the Arab world watching this and thinking - amazing, the law and the state can be above an individual. Israelis should be proud to have a society based on laws and judicial fairness.
Any effective politician, PM , Chief of Staff, or President needs to be a bit of a "Fixer", but it depends on the degree and more importantly whether it was with in the law.
We saw the reason only last week. The bright, decent Israelis go into medical research and come up with wonderful new antibiotics that will benefit all of mankind. The slimeballs and the dopes go into politics and the army.
OK,OK, I go along with all criticisms and condemnations of Olmert, if there was wrong-doing involved. However, what I cannot understand is the fact that all these deeds were carried out more or less openly while he was serving in various official positions. Surely it is customary and imperative to be given official legal advice all the way?! Why was Olmert not given effective official legal advice against these deeds? Even Yemima Mazuz was supposed to supply advice. Maybe these so-called legal-advisers are not doing their work properly?