Settlers have broken ground on nearly 550 West Bank homes since end of freeze, survey shows
According to an Associated Press count, rate of construction since September 26 is four times faster than over the last two years.
By The Associated Press Tags: Israel settlements West BankIsraeli settlers have begun building new homes at a quick pace since the government lifted its moratorium on West Bank housing starts - almost 550 in three weeks, more than four times faster than the last two years.
And many homes are going up in areas that under practically any peace scenario would become part of a Palestinian state, a trend that could hamper U.S.-brokered peace talks.
|
Construction renewed in the settlement of Ariel. |
| Photo by: Nir Kafri |
According to an Associated Press count, ground has been broken on 544 new West Bank homes since September 26, when Israel lifted its 10-month freeze on most new settlement building.
The survey, while not comprehensive, marks the most extensive effort yet to quantify the construction. It was based on visits to 16 of the West Bank's more than 120 settlements as well as phone calls to more than four dozen settlements and interviews with construction workers and mayors.
"This figure is alarming and is another indicator that Israel is not serious about the peace process, which is supposed to be about ending the occupation," said Ghassan Khatib, spokesman for Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas' self-rule government in the West Bank.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has played down the new construction, saying it "has no real effect on the map of a possible (peace) agreement."
However, the renewed settlement construction has jeopardized peace talks relaunched only last month, with the Palestinians threatening to walk away if the freeze is not extended. And it could make the daunting task of partitioning the land even more difficult.
The building spurt of the past three weeks compares to average annual housing starts of about 2,000 in recent years, including just under 1,900 in 2009 and just over 2,100 in 2008, according to government figures. That is a rate of about 115 in three weeks, making the current pace more than four times faster.
The actual number is likely higher. When officials provided a range, the AP used the lowest figure. And it did not include 133 apartments a contractor said he was building in three settlements, because he did not say how many were already started.
The settlement watchdog Peace Now estimates there have been more than 600 housing starts and plans to release its own detailed report next week.
Much of the building activity witnessed by the AP involved leveling ground, and some settler leaders argue it is premature to define that as housing starts.
Asked about the AP count, a spokeswoman for the settler group Yesha Council said: "I prefer not to get into the numbers game because it's misleading."
About two-thirds of post-freeze work is preliminary and could be halted if the freeze is renewed, said the spokeswoman, Aliza Herbst.
Still, the scale of the construction is likely to harden Palestinian demands that a settlement freeze be reimposed as a condition for proceeding with the talks. Efforts by the United States to coax Israel into another building slowdown have so far failed.
In crisscrossing the West Bank, an AP team saw bulldozers and jackhammers tearing into rocky slopes in a number of locations.
One of the new building sites is in Karmei Tzur, a settlement with about 135 families located on the "Palestinian side" of the planned route of Israel's West Bank separation barrier, seen by some in Israel as the basis for drawing Israel's future border.
On Monday, jackhammers pulverized rocks on a barren slope as trucks carted off debris and heavy machinery drilled holes in preparation for pouring foundations. A woman answering the phone at the settlement's main office said 56 new apartments were being built.
A drive through Kiryat Arba, home to more than 7,000 Israelis, revealed two construction sites, for a total of at least 22 apartments, according to Palestinian laborers. And in the settlement of Revava, bulldozers were seen leveling ground along a slope. A contractor at the site said his company is building 83 apartments there.
In Kiryat Arba, Revava and many other settlements visited by the AP, officials declined comment on construction. In two places, armed guards denied reporters entry.
Other settlement officials were more forthcoming.
Avi Roe, who heads the Binyamin regional council, which represents about one-third of the West Bank settlements, said he is aware of at least 200 housing starts in his area.
Another 344 housing starts were confirmed by AP visits to settlements and interviews with mayors, construction workers and other officials.
Netanyahu imposed the settlement curbs last November in a bid to draw the Palestinians to the negotiating table. Netanyahu, who leads a rightist governing coalition, has said the slowdown was a one-time gesture.
The Obama administration has been trying to persuade Israel to extend the freeze and is expected to step up the effort after next month's midterm elections. Washington has floated the idea of a one-time two-month extension, during which Israelis and Palestinians would be asked to reach agreement on the future borders of a Palestinian state.
The Palestinians insist on a freeze for the duration of negotiations, saying two months is unrealistic to reach a border deal.
Nearly 300,000 settlers now live in the West Bank, along with 2.2 million Palestinians. Settlers have covered the territory - captured by Israel in the Six Day War in 1967, along with Gaza and east Jerusalem - with an increasingly intricate web of established communities and nearly 100 unauthorized hilltop outposts.
Despite the recent building spate, settlement leaders complain that approval for the largest construction projects is being held up. Israeli media reported this week that construction of more than 3,700 apartments awaits the signature of Defense Minister Ehud Barak, who has final say in the West Bank.
"I'm pessimistic about the near future," said Benny Kashriel, mayor of Maaleh Adumim, a settlement of 33,000 near Jerusalem. He said he hasn't been able to start new construction since the end of the moratorium.
A breakdown of an Associated Press count of new construction in West Bank settlements since Israel's moratorium on housing starts ended on September 26:
-- At least 200 housing starts in the Binyamin region, which contains one-third of the West Bank's more than 120 settlements, according to Avi Roe, the head of the regional council.
-- Ariel: 45 apartments being built by former Gaza settlers, according to Yitzak Vasana, a spokesman for the group.
--Beit Arieh: 25 apartments, according to Avi Naim, head of the settlement.
-- Barkan: 62 apartments, according to Shmuel Elad, head of the settlement.
-- Emanuel: 46 apartments, according to Rabbi Ezra Garashi, head of the
settlement.
-- Har Adar: 20 apartments, according to Aviram Cohen, head of the settlement.
-- Har Hebron, a group of 15 settlements: 50 apartments, according to regional council leader Zvi Bar-Hai.
-- Itamar: at least three, based on the comment by a settlement spokesman, Moshe Goldschmidt, that there were a few housing starts.
--- Karmei Tzur: 56, according to a woman answering the phone at the settlement office.
--- Kedumim: at least 12, based on a site visit and conversation with a land
surveyor.
--- Kiryat Arba: at least 22, based on a site visit and conversations with
Palestinian construction workers.
--- Oranit: at least three, based on a comment by a settlement official that there were a few housing starts.
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
Peace in the middle of a sea of religious hate ! Isn't that what this conflict is all about ? Illusion is one lying to himself.. Isn't that what all this wasted efforts of peace are all about ? After all: Man is a thinking animal. Where is that in this tower of babylon conflict ?
This is according to facts of all the human history, not UN paper laws which nobody follows. So annex West Bank Area C where ALL the settlements are (and give citizenship to 4% of West Bank Arabs who live there). And build a Palestinian state in Areas B and C (build it yourself, as Arabs seem to be utterly incapable).
What else this article could be ?! When Israel faced with an enemy who is unwilling to talk only on his own terms & conditions. Such an enemy can't be a partner for peace. Isn't obvious that Abbas made himself a useless partner for peace by simple not talking only when Israel accepting there is nothing to talk about ! What else is left for Israel t do than to carry on living like any other country and use all that in its power to increase its existence like the rest of the world ! What else Israel is doing except what any other country wii do !. To deny Israel the right to protect itself must be an advice only her enemies will give her ! Israel can't exist if it will not hold on to life like any other country.
Peaxce
Keep building until a two-state solution is no longer possible. Then the only choice left will be a one-state solution shared equally by Jews and Arabs across Israel, the West Bank, and Gaza. After all the Palestinian refugees return to this newly-enlarged state of Israel, the demographic balance will be 50% Jew and 50% Arab whom will share power equally.
YOU ARE DIGGING OUR NATIONAT TOMB. GO AHEAD, BE PROUD OF IT
So what is the plan. The only right thing to do then is make the 2.2 million Israeli citizens--don't want that? Then get out. It is one or the other. The current status is called apartheid.
Do you care how many apartments were built in Tel Aviv? It's the same thing. According the Arabs, ALL of Israel is occupied territory. So, what's the difference?
Israel has recognised borders which it gave its word to accept. ALL involved groups have agreed to recognise those borders, and I cant remember any palestinian group complaining about building in the recognised capital of israel, tel aviv, not even once. So this argument is transparently false.
the borders were not recognized by most of the world and certainly not by the arab nations
The MAJORITY over ruled the Arab States legal objections. The MAJORITY of the International Community of Nations recognized Israel "as an independent republic within frontiers approved by the General Assembly of the United Nations in its Resolution of November 29, 1947," http://wp.me/PDB7k-Y#look
Why the hell are you building homes for Israelis in Palestine and then complain that the Palestines are protesting aboput it? Are the Pals building homes in Israel too?
Every time there is a hope for peace, the israeli government do its utmost to ruin it and they always blame the other side. This is a classic. Israeli leaders are Obsessive-neurotic-paranoid with delusions of grandeur Israel is well aware of
No israel, No Palestine. One State Solution is the best for all. One Man, One Vote, Equality for all inhabitants. Equal Pay for Equal Work, Equal Water Rights. No Apartheid, No Segregation...A Very True Secular Democrac Let us call it: “State of Holy Land”.
Still got your head in your hip pocket, tony. It's all Israel and all for the Jews.
within the state of israel there is a severe housing shortage. places like yeruham have been neglected because of the temporary thorns built on the back of the zionist two-nation solution for peace. enough!
That was thousands of years ago. Its now known as the West Bank and its not part of Israel.
Ever since God gave it to Israel, it is , was and always will be Israel's. Pack up your arabs and send them back to the 57 muslim countries they came from. No room for them in the Inn.
There are 500,000+ Jews in West Bank TODAY. Many of them were born there. You support ethnically cleansing them on the grounds that 100 years ago this land did not belong to them? Then why not support ethnically cleaning Arabs from West Bank on the grounds that this land did not belong to them 2000 years ago?
First off:settlers are not second class citizens. Second: the freeze is over. Why cant building be done?How would any of you like to be told that you could not add on to your own home if the need is present?
why not building in israel itself and not on stollen lands of Palestine?
No one, not the UN or anyone complains when Jews build IN ISRAEL...what you dont seem to understand is the word ILLEGAL when you build OUTSIDE OF YOUR COUNTRY! No one builds on their neighbors property without having problems..NO ONE..not even the "Chosen ones"
Thousands of Palestinian homes have been destroyed because the family built after a permit was denied by the occupier.
Geez, tony! Don't you ever listen? There is NO 'palestine'. It's all Israel and it's all for the Jews!
settlers is the wrong word,"land grabbers" is the correct description. nice cosy description, i think not. give back the land that has been illegally occupied, by the way a naked arab looks the same as a naked jew.Thats the way you came into this world and thats the way you go out why try to make hell on earth ,get back, get back get back to where you belong to the land that you were given" illegally". start thinking of your childres ,childrens children. Eddie from Leeds yorkshire
Thanks Haaretz for this wonderful wonderful news. Also for the exact figures of houses etc. Very methodical very informative and a joy to read.
Trying in vain to save his Congressional majority. He no longer has time to focus on this issue. That time passed us by months ago, when the palestinians ignored the freeze and didn't respond, until the 11th hour. This is no longer on Obama's radar and, in two weeks, he will be a toothless lame duck. Once again, the Palestinians miscalculated and dropped the ball. Peter of Florida, HOW is *our* country being thrashed by these actions ?? It has no effect on our country (mine, too). Sooner or later, truth prevails over the BS claims of a fake entity. Time to build.
Jews are building the land of Israel.Jews have every right in the world to choose to reside in Judea and Samaria. Arabs live in Haifa , Tel aviv, the Galil and the Negev . Jews resided in Hebron for thousands of years. It's about time people around the world come to terms with the fact that Israel can never go back to the 67 borders coined by Abba Eban "The Aushwitz borders". There are several hundred thousand Jews living in the West Bank and Israel 's most precious landmarks are there as well (The Kotel, The Temple Mount, The tomb of the Patriarchs)
Jews where not living their for thousands of years. They where expelled out of this region for thousands of years!!!!! I'm not saying that they have no right to own the land but things have changed now you have millions of Palestinians that want to live normally so stop using religion and history to take more and more land from Pals. This will make you no difference from Taliban whose politics is based on religion. Look at Israel's reputation it has never been as bad!!
No israel, No Palestine. One State Solution is the best for all. One Man, One Vote, Equality for all inhabitants. Equal Pay for Equal Work, Equal Water Rights. No Apartheid, No Segregation...A Very True Secular Democrac Let us call it: “State of Holy Land”.
To bring up Aushwitz when you are talking about the 1967 borders is disgusting. Plain, simple disgusting. Let me guess - it will be another Holocaust if Israel is forced to go back to the borders that it really shouldn't even have under international law as it was defined in 1948. Pathetic.
IT IS ABOUT TIME THAT ISRAEL FOLLOWS IT'S OWN PATH, NOT A PATH THAT THE U.S. OR UN WANT! HOORAY FOR THE NETANYAHU ADMINISTRATION!
Then please don't complain when you see resistance.
You are fighting against YHWH. Resistance is futile!
only Greater Israel. So the Palesinians are right in their estimation that this rogue state has nothing to do with abiding international law
the palestinian authority should waste no time in asking the united nations to declare a palestinian state. it's pointless to wait for israel. there is no sincerity in its leaders. they continue to build more and more settlements right in the face of everybody. how long will it take for the united states to come to realise that the israeli government is not a sincere partner for peace. they keep the palestinians hanging on indefinetely. time to put a stop to this endless farce, and let the UN declare a palestinian state.
It is crucail to develop these mountainous areas of central Israel. By building, we prove to the Shoa-Denying, Munich Olympics Butcher & his friends that this is OUR LAND.
You and your attitude are the beginning of the end of Israel. You are an enemy not only of the US, but the world. You should be shunned and isolated in your cozy, illegal settlements. Go ahead: go to war with the world.
Yosef will win in his 'war with the world'. That's because one righteous Jew and YHWH are always a majority no matter who is allied aginst them. Give it up. Resistance is futile.
Yosef will win in his 'war with the world'. That's because one righteous Jew and YHWH are always a majority no matter who is allied aginst them. Give it up. Resistance is futile.
It's about time they built. Imagine if your toilet was backing up but you were prevented from fixing the problem for 9 months. Finally, you get down to business very very quickly. Homes need to be built as quickly as possible to allow for population growth. Of course, the "palestinians" won't approve, but then they don't want Israel to exist in the first place. Well, SOOORRRRY! This is Barry Zornberg with yet another reasonable comment.
let's hope that they will be given to the Palestinians who are building them when the settlers are forced out and peace, with a 2-state solution, is finally achieved
FYI, they were destroyed by Israel, rather than allow Palestinians to have them. And Gaza was RETURNED to them, not given.
Build, Bibi! Build!
and she is publically declaring that a two state solution is possible within a year. Clearly, Israel is saying no to her and that dream. Perhaps the next thing we will hear from Secretary Clinton will be that the US now recognises Palestine within the '67 borders and occupied EJ as the capital. That is the only way to deal with this expansionism that flies in the face of Israel's previous agreements, making its "word" worthless.
According to JP, 41% of Palestinians will choose another intifada if the peace efforts fail.
Palestinians will choose another intifada if the peace efforts fail.
that henceforth the settlements will serve as the bulwark between Israel and the hopefully nascent State of Palestine... so maybe this means that peace is about to break out with our neighbors, the Pals?!
is it not clear that it hampers peace? Is the Israeli government powerless? The sad thing is that as far as the rights of Palestinians the US and Israeli government seems to agree with Rabbi Yitzhak Shapira.
Although the vast majority of us denounce and disagree with the settlement industry, which has very much ended the two-state solution, it can actually prove to be benefical to the Palestinian cause. It;s now clear that the two-state solution has gone by, and that there's only one alternative which is the one-state approach. With this one, and the equal treatment of jews/arabs, there is a clear demographic advantage for the Palestinians, which will gain majority in the political structures. That will be the best outcome for the cause. South-Africa model, 101.
While the PA talks about building an airport with no money and the Palestinians live in squalor, the settlements continue to go up in the West Bank. Perhaps the PA should not be talking about the 1967 borders but figure out a way to emulate the Jewish state.
You mean they should steal Jewish land and put up colonies west of the green line. They should give the majority of the available water to these colonies, so they may have nice green lawns. And to ensure the safety of these colonies they will use their massive military given to them by the US to subjigate the indiginous Jewish population.
The freeze Obama forced on Israel lead to a lot of problems and was completely unnecessary. He should have pushed for unconditional negotiations instead.
how dare he try to bring Israel to account for its international crimes? the fool.
so go and build inside proper israel if you have to.
Netanyahu is not the Glorious Leader Of The Land Of Israel, nor is he The Master Of The Jewish People. He heads only the Government of Israel, and he is empowered only by the voting public of the State of Israel, no more and no less. And that position and those voters can not grant him a "right" to violate int'l law, and colonial expansionism is clearly contrary to int'l law. Never forget that, because the rest of the world certainly never has.
All the enemies of Israel hate this so build and build an d rebuild. Thye are silent on Hamas and their weapons smuggling but have much to say about Jews who build homes on their land.
To the thousand of Jews that are buried and forever maimed as a result of the brutal terror and murder my the thuggish Religion of Peace. May the land be built and bloom.
As a matter of fact, I have read nothing in which they are condemned for building on their own land. The point is specifically that - they are building on someone else's land. Using their own land is cool.
Israel must stop stealing Palestinian land....
Is in Jordan. You expect no consequences for Four Wars?? You just think there's free lunch, like a free spin in Jeopardy. Go to war and lose, but make believe it never happened. There's no stolen land, classify it correctly. LOST LAND, due to foolishness and thuggery of Arab Leaders.
It's illegal to confiscate occupied land. Fess up to the fact that Israel is a pariah and you support land theft. The current sanctimonious hypocrisy is nauseating.
Under international law it is illegal to acquire land through war. The Jewish People received land in Israel with the support of the International community, by the decision of Western Colonial Powers and the USSR, in particular. Therefore, Israel is morally and legally obligated to respect the International law (regardless of quarrels with the Arabs/Palestinians).
The situation now and from now on is different and the world public opinion knows what type of society is Israel:a very sick state.Nobody backs Israeli and zionist politics.1947 and not 1967.It is a question of time and political evolution to the region.EVOLUTION is the key of all the phenomenon.Be sure that the world has a new definition of your country.
Israel signed the Geneva conventions. They define what happens after war. So yes stolen land.
... for a growing population. The settlements may all be buldowzed anyway, if Pals ever decide to get serious about negotiating a state. But after last week's developments, it is clear that Pals will never recognize a Jewish state, or give up trying to destroy it by the Right of Return strategy.
if this report is indeed accurate, then in 10 months period the settlers used to build ~1600 units, and they'll reach this line by the end of this year, making the freeze a meaningless gesture, it didn't even halt settlement building.
in fact and practice...might is right. Israel has the 'right' to settle its ancient lands despite modern opponents. like other nations, grab first and settle later! do as others have done unto you!
This is ridiculous - Israel has no genuine desire to acheive peace it simply wants to grab land. The Palestinians should do a Kosovo, declare a state and seek international support.
The day the settlers leave their illegal settlements, all this will become palestinian, exactly like it happened in Gaza.
settlers and members of the nationalist camp may think renewed building is a victory, but in fact it supplies the cause for the next war and thousands of killed on both sides. an historic tragedy, which israelis should have opposed not cheered.
This is great news which if it is sustained may even prevent the next war.
It is delusional thinking like Realist here (which is actually nothing but fantasy) that will not only start the next war but will ultimately lead to Israel's defeat.
Open cheques for them to sit back is not an incentive for them to get serious. They cant even make up their own mind what they mean from one day to the next
yesterday, they wanted a real, total freeze on construction. they didn't get it. today, they want a freeze on construction. they won't get it. sounds like they made up their mind a long time ago. we're still waiting for something other than empty slogans from israel's side of the negotiating table.
Looking for the holes in the cheese while not coming clean on what they really want including the "refugee winning card" and what they will or will not recognise changing daily,is not negotiating. 9 months of sitting back during the freeze and waiting Obama to do it all for them has backfired. Time to come clean with the bottom line.
yes to the right of return, yes to east jerusalem, yes to the 1967 borders is unclear to you? that is their bottom line. that's exactly what they want. the negotiations can start there. unfortunately, the other side has said No, No, and oh yeah, No to all three. Neither side is willing to actually negotiate, though Palestine has been much more upfront in calling for borders first.
Yet they refuse to quantify and so on Quite likely because they know when it comes to the crunch the leadership know they can't deliver and when land comprise is reahed the demands will continue They cant have both states and they know it so they obfuscate and vacillate
I think most of the WB settlements will eventually be evacuated - that is, if there ever is an agreement - but until then, construction must go on. Freezing co nstruction now would be a victory for the Palestinians, and only whet their appetite for more Israeli concessions without granting any of their own.
Go on ! Go on building everywhere. Jewish people will never be expelled from his land again.
Your god is powerless. The worlld is ruled by the whims of human beings.
It is written: The fear of God is the beginning of wisdom. It is also written: It is better to keep your mouth shut and be thought a fool than it is to open it and provide proof.
Lucky Uganda so. They escaped the outright theft of their land. Unlike the downtrodden Palestinians.
Demand here is so much higher than anywhere else in the country, so of course we need to build a lot more; especially in light of the 10-month freeze which hurt so many people.
i suppose you're right
if we break the covenant, isn't that more than 'mischief'? We are each responsible before G-d. Shalom.
..was in the real estate business as well. Did he give you a signed deed?
So why not build meanwhile?
many settlements will be ploughed under like yamit and gaza, so this is a perverse developement. misinterpreted judaism and misinterpreted zionism setting the stage for war and more jewish victims.
That's why it's called The Promised Land.
YHWH sure did give a written deed. It's called the Torah.