Netanyahu: Gaza flotilla probe will show the world Israel acted lawfully
Israeli cabinet approves inquiry commission into raid on Gaza-bound aid flotilla in unanimous vote.
By Barak RavidPrime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said at the start of Monday's cabinet meeting that the main goal of the Gaza flotilla probe is to prove to the world that the Israel Navy operation on the Gaza-bound aid ship was appropriate and met international standards.
"The government decision will make it clear to the world that Israel is acting legally, responsibly, and with complete transparency," said Netanyahu.
|
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at a weekly cabinet meeting. |
| Photo by: Archive |
The cabinet approved the inquiry commission into the Gaza flotilla events in a unanimous vote. "It is not ideal, but the other options are less good," Netanyahu said regarding the probe. "The flotilla to Gaza was not a one-time incident. We are in the midst of a difficult and continuous fight against the state of Israel."
Netanyahu told the ministers that it was particularly important to announce the Gaza flotilla probe panel on Sunday and for it to be approved on Monday, since the foreign ministers of the European Unions are due to convene on Sunday to discuss the events that led up to the IDF raid on the Gaza-bound flotilla which killed nine Turkish activists.
North Irish Nobel laureate, Canadian jurist to serve as observers
The committee will include two international observers and tackle the legality of the blockade of Gaza and the legality of the navy's actions. The committee will also determine whether investigations of claims of war crimes and breaches of international law conform to the Western standards.
A retired Supreme Court justice, Jacob Turkel, will head the committee, whose members will included Shabtai Rosen, 93, a professor of international law who is an Israel Prize laureate in legal sciences and a Hague Prize laureate in international law. Also on the panel will be Maj. Gen. (res.) Amos Horev, former president of the Technion - Israel Institute of Technology.
Two foreign observers will take part in the committee's deliberations. The statement released by the Prime Minister's Bureau did not say what their powers would be. The first observer will be William David Trimble, a Northern Irish Nobel Peace Prize laureate.
Trimble joined the "Friends of Israel" initiative launched in Paris some two weeks ago, in which Israel's former ambassador to the United Nations, Dore Gold, was also involved. Gold is considered a close associate of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
The second international observer will be Ken Watkin, former military judge advocate general from Canada.
The committee will also examine the Turkish position and actions taken by the flotilla's organizers, especially the Turkish group IHH, which has alleged ties to terrorist groups, as well as the identity of the participants in the flotilla and their intentions.
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
Maybe one day I will understand jewish logic. You are a religious group that somehow feel you are owed a piece of dirt to call your own. Almost every other country in the world, thoughout history, has been based on nationality but israel is based on judaism, a flawed religion at best. It is a religion based on violence and provocation. I am an athiest and don't believe in any sort of supreme being, although I tend to allow others to "do their thing" as long as they don't interfere with my feelings. However, judiaism is like a gorilla in a china shop, throwing its weight around telling others what to do and then whining when they are accused of being prejudicial. When your stuff stops stinking, then you have the right to correct others. Until that day comes, back off and be quiet. There is an ever increasing number of nations that are leaning more and more away from israel and judiasm. It is NOT because of the anti-semetism that you think, but because of the anti-semetism that you are causing. When you learn to live with the rest of the world peacefully and stop blaming everyone else when they don't agree with you, you will be on the road to recovery. Until then you will be perceived as the bully that you are.
is that,while they themselves have already "condemned" Israel before any probe has been set and before any results have been made known,they find it strange that the Israeli PM expresses his opinion that the probe will show Israel acted legally. In other words,they believe their "truth" is the absolute truth,even if it is a blatant lie.
Murder is not right, killing 9 civilians on an Aid Ship is totally unacceptable, it's a War Crime.
It is state terrorism and it is something Israel will never be able to live down. The whole world hates Israel now That isn't going away but I imagine will escalate.. Dutch
you know whats really 'funny'?? David Trimble, one of the 'independent observers' has joined, 2 weeks ago, a group called 'Friends of Israel'!!! LOL why doing 'investigations' at all??
Israel arranges an impartial investigation with international observers and it's not enough. Israel called your bluff and now that you see you have no real cards, you cry that the game is rigged. Have any Arab countries ever held any type of investigation into their actions with international observers. Iran? Syria? PA? Hamas?(HA) Saudi Arabia? Egypt? Libya? I'm open to suggestions...anyone? And, has the US or the UK allowed the UN to investigate actions by their armies in Iraq or Afghanistan...or Vietnam for that matter? No sane country would allow themselves to be served up to their enemies masquerading as concerned international nations while they oppress their populations at home.
"A friend of israel" on the jury! How about a friend of the Palestinians?
So, now comes the time for the cover up, as usual. This routine is getting to be all too familiar. It looks like the results of the investigation has already been announced before the investigations have even taken place. World is no longer deaf dumb and blind and God is certainly watching everything that you do.
The conclusion has already been decided, whats the point of an 'investigation' the accused has just said "Gaza flotilla probe will show the world Israel acted lawfully"
that IHH terrorists prepared and preplanned the attack on IDF soldiers They wanted martyrdom. - They got martyrdom. Turkish Erdogan is a scoundrel. He knew the result of raid. His task was to blame israel. You all know it now very well, but you continue to pretend that videos do not exist. Interview with the Turkish captain left no doubts about involvement of Turkish terrorists from IHH. The probe will make it more clear to the world
I never doubted it! God Bless Israel!!!
The damage is already done...what ever the truth. This is how it works, as with the Al Dura hoax. The Arabs and the anti-semitic media rush to tell the anti-Israel story, but never follow up with the truth. Even today we have the ICRC saying that the Gaza 'seige' is illegal. Of course it is not. But this statement will be broadcast unchallenged around the world. This is what Israel is up against - evil!
Isn't this the reason for insisting on an internal probe instead on an international probe? This probe's mandatory is to justify Israeli piracy.
yeah, I don't have to be psychic to know what the conclusion is going to be
that israel will find itself gulity of mass murder! Get real
The main point of the probe should be to reveal in an unbiased and objective fashion what really happened during the flotilla raid ... not to "prove to the world that the Israel Navy operation on the Gaza-bound aid ship was appropriate and met international standards." Nethanyahu is making no secret that the probe will not be impartial and that rather it will be used as a propaganda tool by the Israeli government. Unbelievable..
... Dore Gold has been a so devoted a chauvanistic supporter of Israel's right-wing for so many yearsfor, that Bibi couldn't-go-wrong with this choice of adviser...
once again Israel plays the victim when it is in fact the aggressor and the western world saddled with its self inflicted collective guilt of the Jewish suffering in WW2 will continue to deny the Palestinians their right to freedom and their homeland.Israel will continue to do as it pleases just the same way the US and its allies did in the Irag war...because they can....remember that in the history of time ..this is just one moment...Israel will for sure some day suffer the same consequences that it makes other suffer now....and the western world will come to rue its selfish, blatantly bias and self interested support...Much of the western world is as guilty as Israel for the atrocities it commits in the middle east in the name of security.
all that squawking you did about Goldstone having a predetermined opinion,(in your head). Any comments on Bibi,s ruling.
getting ptetty sick of everyone blaming Israel when islamisrt caused this.. In every way!.
The history of Israel borders the insane. In Israel's eyes on what they approve or taint is lawful, everything else is God promised, anti semitic, dangerous neighborhood, self hating jew, not share by your western values, the pals listened to their leaders to run away, "exodus " is legal but Mavi Marmara is not, blockade and cilantro go hand in hand to pressure Hamas, Berlin wall is illegal our is legal, absentee law is humane, plant a tree in israel but uproot the pal's olive trees, and certainly we did not kill Mabhouh. Get a life.
If Israel did in fact act legally and according to law, then no one would have been killed. 9 people were killed and are now dead, 9 counts of murder on the high seas. Now either they are incompetent or guilty but they are not not guilty and they are as well and also by this charade in contempt of justice and the world. Please Israel for the sake of your integrity and honor, sentence the responsible parties accordingly and appropriately. thank you.
Israel broke the law and now plans to change the interpretation to make the action leagal. If you make it leagal to kill, it will only hit back on you.
the results before the proble? how come! oh, yes, this is Israel. One has to learn to cancel his logic and mins and senses to be able to understand Israeli officials these days
Once a liar, always a liar!..
that's how the inquiry conclusion is already decided. so much credibility for an Israeli inquiry. If it's legal why not an international and neutral inquiry to pr ove Israeli contention. When Gaza blockade itself is illegal as declared by UN how a raid can be legal in International waters.
indeed recently (2 weeks ago) joined the group 'friends of Israel'. This is getting soooo predictable. So Israel still refuses a REAL investigation, there is clearly a lot to hide.
I cannot see how people can still support this regime! While killing people, then investigating onself and always claiming the role of victims while hijacking the moral highground, how does the world keep turning a blind eye and yet exclaim "never again!!!". Utterly disgusting and sad at the same time!!
David Trimble = member of Friends of Israel, background as supporter of Brittish occupation of Northern Ireland, so likely to have sympathy for another occupation state. Ken Watkin = military jurist, a profession generally for whitewashing and working around the law. Also convert to judaism; many Jews have integrity (for example Goldstone), but one hand-picked by Bibi for a whitewashing committee, not likely.
May I recommend Colonel Kemp for his military expertise?
Either the "independent public committee" is not independent form Netanyahu, or Netanyahu can't possibly know if this committee will prove this or that. Honestly, if Netanyahu can't tell "prove that..." from "investigate if..." and if he declares this publicly without blinking eye, then the country is ruled by a mad clown.
Wow, at least we now know how reactionary and brainwashed so many respondents are. What these simps fail to realize is that an event like that described doesn't happen in a vacuum. And furthermore, how the heck can you berate somebody for an agenda you IMAGINE they have, when you are clearly ESPOUSING an agenda of your own? How can these respondents take themselves seriously? After all, there are people going out of their way to justify their actions in paint-by-numbers terms, simply because of your vehement anti-semitism. Take a breath and step away.
Okay so it wasn't just me who saw that freudian slip from Netanyahu. In all honesty this has 90% chance of being a white wash and a 10% chance of credibility. I was hoping it was appear a little more legit, i just hope one of these observers spits the dummy at the whole thing half way through.
There is nothing leagal for exucuting 19 year old with 5 shots in the head, 30 shots total on 9 killed just like Goldstone report, Israel will reject if it was other way around anyways, please stop, how to fix this is to Israel should send high level representetives to Turkey and form a convoy and visit every killed Turkish citizens family and offer them condolences with restitutions, and distrubute Israel and Turkish Flags to every city or village alone the way and I assure you it will make all the difference in the World to get the things the way they were just an idea,
Israel you are the funniest joke in the world, LOL. and sure you would, report on rubbish like this Mr Barak Ravid
So your going to pervert the illegal act the whole world witnessed and saw into a post legal one by slight of law, persuasion and trickery? Don't bother, sounds boring to watch anyway and I saw the original. Looked like unprovoked manslaughter to me.
The conclusions of the report are already known. Israel acted legally. This is exactly the reason I will not believe a word of it. The inquiry is not an inquiry : It is one more try to whitewash israel.
that Israel is guilty,then I will not believe a word from you. What goes around comes around.
I was about to write the same exact words, but you beat me to it. The sick part is that Netanyahu has the guts to say to the world that the outcome of the probe will reveal Israel acted legally, but before the the probe even begins. Netanyahu does this and expects the world to actually belief this is an impartial inquiry? C'mon Netanyahu, do you really think the rest of the world is as stupid as you look?
Israel is trying to convince the world of the imparitality of a committee it set up with a complete conflict of interest. Instead, the committee should be set up like an American court system: jurors are selected by both sides with peremptory and for-cause challenges under a judge (ICC random selection?) and an investigatory tribunal held. Let a jury of 13 be selected and their decision be final and two-thirds vote as to all findings. (That part is not typical of an American jury.)
So, so quick to determine the form in which the criminal proceedings are to take place! Oh, you are so fair and just. Except for one thing. What is the crime? Do you even have an inkling? You seem to be just like the other rabid frauds here.
'Gaza flotilla probe will show the world Israel acted legally' Does anyone have any doubt what the outcome will be? It's nice there's something we can all agree on.
I can't even listen to this guy anymore. The lies! ... makes me ashamed to be a Jew.
How will the probe be impartial if Netanyahu already knows the outcomes. "Probe will prove we acted legally."
Why not some balance by including a member of ISM. David Trimble is a criminal who murdered people in Northern Ireland and will be quite at home in the compamy of Zionist criminals . Israel is finished--I give it ten more years and then it will be consigned to the bin of History under the heading of, "Failed States".
So Bibi now knows the result in advance! What is the point of the probe then?! If you want to waste your time be my guest, but after reading this piece I now know for sure who was the terrorist.
Well if the outcome of the probe has already been predetermined, why bother with it at all? Its just for "show" then is it, alrighty then. How much are the tickets?
Netanyahu: Gaza flotilla probe will show the world Israel acted legally Advanced conclusions, military people and members of the Friends of Israel. What a joke. No wonder the world does not believe anything the Israelis say and do.
Israel has become a threat to the safety of Jews. Far from the rhetoric, that Israel is a refuge, Israel has become a pariah state. Jews worldwide are suffering for their support of Israel. Israel no longer represents the honor and decency of Judiasm. Israel has become the anti-semites dream, an ugly caricature of Judiasm. The sooner this farce is over the better it is for Jews worldwide.
Since the verdict is predetermined, why bother playing out the farce? I would have hoped for at lease some respect for our intelligence, maybe you could at least pretend this was an impartial inquiry? This is just going to be another Israeli atrocity whitewash.
Glad to hear that Netanyahu already knows the conclusions of this "independent" probe. With powers like these you'd think he would have done a better job of avoiding the killing of 9 people in the first place. Maybe later, since he's not travelling much these days, he can tell us who is going to win the World Cup?
An "independent" observer of the panel having joined the group "friends of Israel" 2 weeks ago....??? I mean, this is getting absolutely hilarious now, it has almost reached the slapstick level of Woody Allens earlier films....:
Of course the world will believe Zionists as usual Israel plays the game , once they declare (We will prove) then it is done , Media will make people think they have already proven that Israel was right I won't wonder if later the world's media will consider everybody on the flotilla as a terrorist , why not? it will certainly happen The same game : " We Israelians we are the innocent peaceful people.. we just want those Muslims to leave us alone , and we won't harm them" Yet , whenever there is a peaceful reaction from Muslims it is considered as an act of terrorism and fought with fire. Yes world is BLIND
Do you believe the guys on the Mavi Marmara reacted "peacefully"?
The irony in everything you wrote is outstanding.... Congrats on blindly following main-stream media, being a part of incompletely-informed public opinion, AND criticizing else for doing the same thing. Yes, the world is BLIND... I agree.
Well why go through the whole probe if he knows the results from now:) ?? I might save some of my tax shekels this way
Why don't we just let criminals prosecute and judge themselves from now on?? Israel as always is acting as a spoiled bratt!!! That will come to an end very soon.
If you don't agree with Netanyahu saying that the probe will show Israel is innocent,then why should I agree with you saying that Israel is guilty BEFORE the probe?
since you're likely to keep repeating this, did you ever consider the possibility of a statement like "we await the findings of the investigation and will proceed accordingly"
"The independent public committee will prove that the IDF raid on the Gaza-bound ship met international standards, PM says at start of cabinet meeting." This is like being told the result of a World Cup match before the kick off. We all know the fix is about to take place, the only interest is in watching how skilfully the fix is carried out. This article suggests that Bibi seems to be handling the fix with his usual mix of arrogance and incompetence.
when you wonder if "the guilty will probe itself". So when the "advance verdict" is "Israel is guilty",that's acceptable to you. When the "advance verdict" is "israel is not guilty",that's not acceptable to you. Double standards eh?
"The independent public committee will prove that the IDF raid on the Gaza-bound ship met international standards, PM says at start of cabinet meeting." This is like being told the result of a World Cup match before the kick off. We all know the fix is about to take place, the only interest is in watching how skilfully the fix is carried out. This article suggests that Bibi seems to be handling the fix with his usual mix of arrogance and incompetence.
In making a probe, if the result is given beforehand? An Israeli probe on Israeli terms is worthless considering the current goverments nonexistant credibility!
in making a probe if you and MichaelUK and Swiss Dino(saur) and the others already believe Israel is guilty?
I don´t believe anything, besides credibillity! If a probe isn´t credible, whats the point then?