• Published 16:47 13.07.10
  • Latest update 16:47 13.07.10

Israelis sue Al-Jazeera over reporting during Second Lebanon War

Group of Israelis wounded by rockets claims the Arab news network reported missile strike locations to help Hezbollah improve accuracy.

By The Associated Press Tags: Israel news Second Lebanon War Hezbollah

A group of 91 Israelis wounded by Hezbollah rockets during the 2006 Second Lebanon War is suing the Arab news network Al-Jazeera for $1.2 billion in a New York court for allegedly aiding the Lebanese guerrillas, their lawyer said Tuesday.

Nitzana Darshan-Leitner said the suit, which was filed Monday, claims the Qatar-based news network intentionally violated Israel's military censorship regulations and reported the precise locations of rocket strikes in Israel in live broadcasts during the month-long 2006 war.

Journalists at Lebanon border

Journalists photograph Israeli troop movements on Lebanese border

Photo by: Yaron Kaminsky / Archive

The reporting enabled Hezbollah to aim its rockets more accurately at Israeli targets, the suit alleges.

There was no immediate comment from Al-Jazeera.

Hezbollah launched around 4,000 rockets into Israel during the month-long war in 2006. The fighting killed 159 Israelis and 1,200 people in Lebanon.

"Al-Jazeera made itself a crucial component of the Hezbollah rocket offensive.The intent was to assist the terrorists in targeting and killing civilians," said Darshan-Leitner. "Without the assistance of Al-Jazeera's on-the-ground spotters, Hezbollah would have been unable to accurately aim its rockets into Israeli cities."

Israel's military censor prohibited media outlets from reporting the locations of rocket strikes during the fighting, and Israeli police detained Al-Jazeera crews several times for violating the edict and broadcasting real-time information, though no formal charges were ever filed.

The lawsuit was filed on the fourth anniversary of the start of the war.

Haim Kaplan, who was wounded in the first day of fighting and his northern Israel home damaged, said the lawsuit aimed to hold all those connected to the rocket attacks accountable.

"Anyone involved in supporting terror should pay the price and anyone who thinks about doing so should think twice," he said.
 

  • Print Page
  • Send to a friend
  • Share
  • Text Size +|-
 
 
TalkBacks

Why Facebook Connect?

Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.

Add a comment

Add your reply

  • 47. 5 14
    Money won't bring them back
    • Chaim Ben Kahan
    • 14.07.10
    • 10:32

    Al Jazeera should pay with much more than money, it is the media wing for Islamic jihad.

  • 46. 22 3
    These 91 Israelis are jobless
    • The Intellectual1000
    • 14.07.10
    • 09:42

    They are running out of money and this is their final resort. They should be suing their own government for their poverty.

  • 45. 25 4
    Mine
    • Rob
    • 14.07.10
    • 09:42

    Maybe the wounded Israeli can clean the milions of mines which Israel dropped in Libanon before going home.

  • 44. 4 8
    Get them, they deserve it
    • Dan
    • 14.07.10
    • 05:25

  • 43. 1 5
    good on you!!
    • Michelle Wayne
    • 14.07.10
    • 04:53

  • 42. 4 12
    Ye, I recall it
    • Avi
    • 14.07.10
    • 04:10

    Despite the war time military censor Al Jazeera broadcast multiple times the location of the rockets. When it'd done that many times its not a mistake - it's a policy. I hope the victims won't have to wait long in court before they get their compensations.

  • 41. 27 12
    LMAO, judaism now becomeing mandatory law around the world?
    • VIPER
    • 14.07.10
    • 04:04

    wow, this is going to be interesting, o.k then, how about this, lets charge all those jews from around the world who went to fight for israel and killed lebanese and pals, and we'll apply the israel doctrine of "guilty till proven innocent", sounds good to me.

  • 40. 9 2
    Al Jazeera would never do that.
    • murray of montreal
    • 14.07.10
    • 03:32

    All of their staff is objective. CNN? That's an entirely different story. What kind of imbeciles would allow Al Jazeera reporters into Israel?

  • 39. 31 4
    News agency sued for reporting facts!
    • Jaff
    • 14.07.10
    • 02:49

    go figure

  • 38. 2 10
    Al Jazeera part of Hezbollah War Effort
    • Predator Drone
    • 14.07.10
    • 02:41

    You know the Pals stop at nothing to attack Israel. This is a good step. Al Jazeera should once consider writing an article that isn't inflammatory about Israel. Perhaps one a little supportive here and there just as a cover for the bloodthirsty ones.

  • 37. 27 1
    In New York court ???
    • Rod, Edmonds Wa
    • 14.07.10
    • 02:38

    These people still see WMD everywhere and believe al-Qaeda envied them. They also must believe it was Taliban flying the planes. New York is just like having our very own Israel. Change of venue is required. A

  • 36. 4 9
    That's what Israel gets for allowing a free press
    • Californian
    • 14.07.10
    • 02:18

    Al-Jihadzeera exploits press freedom in Israel (one of the few countries in that region with any concept of a free press). Incidentally, after the 2006 Lebanon war, it came out that a lot of Western journalists in Lebanon were being managed and/or threatened by Hezbollah.

  • 35. 4 2
    Money Matters
    • Sephardi
    • 14.07.10
    • 01:32

    Maybe they'll heckle for the shekel.

  • 34. 2 1
    Equal Legislation?
    • 14.07.10
    • 00:15

    Does Israel have its own laws requiring impartiality of the media related to conflict (regardless of who benefits)? I think this issue points to a void in our global legal structure ...which exists due to national bias. Is, then, national bias a crime against humanity?...or rather, could it be, in the next iteration of peace?

  • 33. 18 4
    haha I swear israeli is so coward
    • Fighter
    • 14.07.10
    • 00:02

    You are still looking for excuses man you guys are so going down next wwar....

  • 32. 18 3
  • 31. 4 13
    Get every dime you can from Al Jazeera
    • Petra
    • 13.07.10
    • 23:50

    They've specialized in reporting for terrorists for years.

  • 30. 22 1
    Absurd
    • Mark
    • 13.07.10
    • 22:55

    Israel launches an invasion, Al Jazera covers Hebollah's return of fire, Israel's kill ratio is at least 4 to 1, Israel sues Al Jazera IN AN AMERICAN COURT OF LAW. This is a script for a comedy.

  • 29. 14 0
  • 28. 23 3
    I feel sorry for them
    • Jon
    • 13.07.10
    • 20:43

    It must be rotten to live in a country where freedom of speach and of the press are non-existant. Maybe just maybe, those rockets would never have been fired if Israelis were not bombing civilians and UN staff In Lebanon. Do onto others as you would have them do to you. Why not sue your government for starting a war that it could not win?

  • 27. 16 3
    Haha
    • George
    • 13.07.10
    • 20:36

    Organized Jewry! If they can't infiltrate the news network, they sue it. Very smart but wicked people. Long live real Jews, down with Zionism and Organized Jewry.

  • 26. 98 33
    Ungracious losers.
    • Maureen Ann
    • 13.07.10
    • 20:23

    Zionist Israel still looking for an excuse as to why Israel lost the war in Lebanon 2006.

    • 2 13
      lmao
      • eric
      • 13.07.10
      • 21:35

      and how did Israel lose that war.the other side lost 10 times more people and the south still has not recovered from the devastation.Israel on the other hand took a very short time to move on and rebuild from whatever mess those firecrackers caused.if thats a victory i wold hate to see what a defeat is.

    • 1 6
      Left wing govt was in charge back then
      • jason
      • 13.07.10
      • 22:18

      Israel has submarine nukes that could blow hezbollah off the map. One day all these non nuclear powers will learn not to mess with a nuclear power. Olmert and peretz are gone so the next war would be a real war and not olmert ordering soldiers to stay in homes in a small area and waiting for unifil to come in.

    • 2 3
      You leftists are hypocrites
      • jason
      • 13.07.10
      • 22:19

      You support hezbollah against gay rights who support sudan's butcher bashir. They deny the holocaust. You leftists have joined with hezbollah to launch war against israel. Olmert and peretz are gone so hezbollah would be demolished in any future war. This isn't 2006 anymore with pathetic leftist leaders in charge.

    • 2 5
      idiot irish supporting jihad
      • jpeditor
      • 13.07.10
      • 23:14

      The only reason Israel didn't finish wiping Hezbullah off the planet is because leftists like you got in the way. Please, next time be a human shield in Lebanon.

    • 3 0
      Winning or Losing?
      • Sephardi
      • 14.07.10
      • 01:36

      What intrinsically matters is winning polically.

    • 5 9
      How exactly did they lose?
      • Californian
      • 14.07.10
      • 02:20

      Hezbollah was on the wrong end of something like a 7:1 kill ratio, got all of its weaponry wiped out, got chased north a couple hundred kilometers to Beirut, hid behind the UN's skirt, and from there declared victory.

    • 0 0
      Are you blind, as well as deaf and dumb?
      • murray of montreal
      • 14.07.10
      • 03:34

    • 5 6
      funny
      • Avi
      • 14.07.10
      • 04:08

      4 years now and the drugs haven't kicked in. You still think you won when we had the entire south of Lebanon and over 650 Hezbollah terrorists dead. With your spiritual leader moving from bunker to bunker and your president crying on national TV, and all of this because of an adventure by Hezbollah(which later apologized) and yet your Arab ego still gives you illusions ^_^ just cute and sad at the same time

    • 1 6
      Funny
      • Chaim Ben Kahan
      • 14.07.10
      • 10:33

      You make us all laugh. If that was winning for the Arabs, imagine when they lose!

    • 0 0
      Lebanon remains Lebanon.
      • Maureen Ann
      • 14.07.10
      • 19:47

      No Zionist settlements being built in Lebanon. : )

  • 25. 91 32
    It takes Matzo Balls
    • MK Ultra
    • 13.07.10
    • 20:12

    To be that blatantly self-righteous! Al Jazeera should sue Israel right back. And then Lebanon should jump in. And Iran. And Iraq. And Palestine. And Egypt. And the US taxpayers. And any and all other countries who are being blackmailed by Israel under the blanket guise of "anti-Semitism(tm)" and "Holocaust (tm)"

  • 24. 64 12
    This Israeli are funny lol!
    • Bibo
    • 13.07.10
    • 19:55

    and the funniest of it all they might win it wahhaha... this is truly justice! what a shame

  • 23. 50 8
    clowns
    • sameer
    • 13.07.10
    • 19:48

    Only obama has a willing ear for this garbage.

  • 22. 19 63
    "159 Israelis and 1,200 people in Lebanon."
    • Robert Hand
    • 13.07.10
    • 19:44

    "The fighting killed 159 Israelis and 1,200 people in Lebanon." ...Ha'aretz Most of the 159 were IDF; most of the 1,200 were civilians! "We can forgive the Arabs for killing our children. We cannot forgive them for forcing us to kill their children. We will only have peace with the Arabs when they love their children more than they hate us." ~~~G Meir, originator of the Dahiya Doctrine, the Final Solution!!! http://fwd4.me/WoN

    • 48 1
      G. Meir
      • MK Ultra
      • 13.07.10
      • 20:15

      Is this G. Meir the same Golda Meir that said the following or a different one? "There is no such thing as a Palestinian people... It is not as if we came and threw them out and took their country. They didn't exist." -- Golda Meir, statement to The Sunday Times, 15 June, 1969. "How can we return the occupied territories? There is nobody to return them to." -- Golda Meir, March 8, 1969. "Any one who speaks in favor of bringing the Arab refugees back must also say how he expects to take the responsibility for it, if he is interested in the state of Israel. It is better that things are stated clearly and plainly: We shall not let this happen." -- Golda Meir, 1961, in a speech to the Knesset, reported in Ner, October 1961 "This country exists as the fulfillment of a promise made by God Himself. It would be ridiculous to ask it to account for its legitimacy." -- Golda Meir, Le Monde, 15 October 1971

    • 25 0
    • 3 5
      G Meir
      • Predator Drone
      • 14.07.10
      • 02:48

      yep, and she was right. Some of those who today call themselves Palestinians are descended from a few scattered towns and villages that had no national identity. They were part of the greater Islamic world under the Ottoman Turks. Many others immigrated to Palestine once economic activity was generated by Jewish immigrants from Europe and then from those thrown out of Arab countries by their local pogroms. Most of the town and village Arabs stayed after the War of Independence. Most of the drifters continued to drift and are now living in Europe or in refugee camps but they call themselves Palestinians instead of the nationality they truly descended from: Yemenites or Iraqis or Egyptians etc. Golda Meir's comment stands. The Palestinian 'people' is a new invention made after the rise of Israel and in direct response to Israel. Prior to 1948, Jews living in Palestine were called Palestinian Jews. That includes those that lived there since time immemorial as well as those that sought refuge there from inhospitable lands in Europe and Muslim countries.

    • 2 5
      Golda Meir smart woman, God bless her
      • Michelle Wayne
      • 14.07.10
      • 05:00

    • 1 7
      Can you send me the list of 1200 confirmed civilians by indepent institution that collected war statsitics? So I guess 0 Hezbo terrorist died?
      • Dan
      • 14.07.10
      • 05:30

      You keep repeating the same lie 100 times, people believe it. Out of the so called 1200 civilians more than 700 were Hezbo terrorists (dressed as civilians of course). But Hezbo controls the government and information and will never reveal the truth. Besides, the Brits incinerated 400000 in Germany in single week of fire bombing. So what's your point anyway?

    • 1 4
      Palestinian people
      • MK
      • 14.07.10
      • 10:07

      This is the same Golda Meir and she was 100% right. How many times is it necessary to explain there is no such thing as a Palestinian people? Both ARABS and JEWS who lived under the British mandate in Palestine before 1948 were called PALESTINIANS. There had never been an independent Arab state in the terrtory called Palestine. Gaza strip belonged to Egypt while West Bank belonged to Jordan. Neither Egypt not Jordan want them back. I wonder why? Maybe of the problematic population?

  • 21. 7 54
    Spies
    • Shmuelshachor
    • 13.07.10
    • 19:25

    The spotters on the ground doing the work for the hizballah under the disguize pf al=jazirah redporting,should have been turned into double agents,and made to broacast false information to their puppet-masters...The brits did the same with hitler's spies caught in England during WWll...Afterwards they should commit suicide with a bullet or two to the back of their dung stuffed heads...and the Isrfaeli Police did nothing to them

  • 20. 36 8
    reply
    • 13.07.10
    • 19:11

    should not Palestinian Sue Englan for selling Palestine off , what about sue Israel for compensation for all of those years ..... it sounds more realistic suits.

    • 9 1
      what about this...
      • VIPER
      • 14.07.10
      • 04:06

      the pals and lebanese sue all those that supply israel with all the destructive weapons used to kill lebs and pals? that sounds even better to me.

  • 19. 73 10
    Anne
    • A compensation?
    • 13.07.10
    • 19:03

    Israel never compansated anything for the families of four UN soldiers killed in Lebanon. They had asked help ( heard by Israeli army),the place had been in the same place over 10 years, it was also easily seen even from the planes. Still the answer was, that the maps were old and it was an operatinal mistake. Israel never gave any possibility to real investigation by the others.

  • 18. 145 23
    what about a lawsuit challenging the illegal israeli occupation of Palestinian land?
    • palestinian
    • 13.07.10
    • 18:45

    Should there not be a formal lawsuit challenging israel's continued illegal occupation of the palestinian west bank and east jerusalem. Oh, I forgot. Israel already lost that lawsuit at the International Court of Justice a few years ago!

    • 28 91
      palestinian land?????
      • Dan
      • 13.07.10
      • 19:17

      Sorry what is palestinian land? there is not such thing.

    • 2 1
      maybe
      • potobac
      • 14.07.10
      • 00:54

      The rest of the world thinks so, but keep on thinking your good thoughts.

    • 4 7
      Palestinian Land
      • Canadian Perspective
      • 14.07.10
      • 02:52

      Agreed. There was an Ottoman Turkish empire that was defeated in battle by Britain in the First World War. Churchill took a vast land called Palestine made up of Jews, Druze, Circassians, Hashemites, Bedouin and many other muslims---and gave 75% to the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan. Perhaps 'palestinian' wants the lawsuit to challenge Jordan holding this land? Likely not, he wants to challenge the only tiny part of a vast ocean of Islam that is held by Jews. And why not? They want it all and always have. If they can't win it by sword then by lies. Crocodile tears to the international media.

    • 3 6
      palestinian
      • Michelle Wayne
      • 14.07.10
      • 05:04

      first u have to have a country coaled Palestine to coll illegal occupation don't u think so?

    • 3 5
      Let Me Remind You
      • Israeli
      • 14.07.10
      • 08:05

      The W. Bank was part of Jordan and Gaza was part of Egypt. But both those countries couldn't disown the "Pals" quick enough when given the opportunity. Keep repeating the lie...

  • 17. 71 20
    claiming compensation
    • ego
    • 13.07.10
    • 18:41

    How come that the group don't think of compensating all the pal refugees instead, or the war victims of gaza and lebanon. Dubble standard I would say.

  • 16. 25 64
    attack to iran
    • unknown irani
    • 13.07.10
    • 18:36

    only way for solve israel problems in region and world military strike to iran terrorist regime and collapse regime in iran.we support israel army.I am pilot in iran viva israel

  • 15. 65 9
    Origin
    • A
    • 13.07.10
    • 18:31

    "Why don't they sue the one who started the war? Their own government?" Haha ! right on target mate .....

  • 14. 115 11
    Those israelis should become comedians
    • John Cooper
    • 13.07.10
    • 18:28

    They are funny. ''Anyone involved in supporting terror should pay the price and anyone who thinks about doing so should think twice." Are they going to sue Netanyahu?

    • 39 19
      funny
      • Dan
      • 13.07.10
      • 19:19

      we can sue american government for put his nose in every country ass in this planet trying to democratize.

    • 13 5
      funny
      • Dan
      • 13.07.10
      • 19:22

      we can sue american government for put his nose in every country ass in this planet trying to democratize.

  • 13. 86 14
    I remember Sky news showing a Katyusha strike on haifa
    • Chris Linthwaite
    • 13.07.10
    • 18:27

    Why aren't these Israeli Jews suing them? Is it because Rupert Murdoch sponsors Israel in his media?

  • 12. 37 6
    I remember Sky News showing Katyusha
    • Chris Linthwaite
    • 13.07.10
    • 18:24

  • 11. 37 60
    Murder of Israelis was their precise purpose .
    • TOMY
    • 13.07.10
    • 18:17

    Al-Jazeera is a mouthpiece of terrorists and is financed by oil millions . It is all open secrets , but the question is why Israel let them operate in the land of Israel ?

  • 10. 30 50
    Al-Jazeera the siren song
    • jewishness
    • 13.07.10
    • 18:05

    Al-Jazeera is a megaphone to nutballs to come and hate Israel. It could be a leader in the arab community if it goes after all the corruptions. a worthless rag that needs to be converted to something positive, non destructive and for once, truthfull, showing the huge and ongoing corruptions of the arab leadership...follow the money Al-Jazeera, and show what you can do!

  • 9. 26 65
    Al-Jazeera has never been impartial or accurate.
    • jewbie
    • 13.07.10
    • 18:02

    the cheerleaders for the enemy have their own press. treat their presses as you would an Irantian smuggled s-300 rocket and blow it to kingdom come!

    • 4 1
      query
      • potobac
      • 14.07.10
      • 00:53

      Is the Israeli press impartial?

    • 0 0
      expression of freedom
      • axel s. - germany
      • 14.07.10
      • 07:24

      of cause u cant tolerate calling of elimination in ur news. but to show the other side is just necessary. if our media would give every dead a sec or 0.1 sec, it wouldtnt be. maybe. but we need a free press, from that everyone feel represented.

  • 8. 28 70
    public disgrace of Al-Jazeera
    • dav zee
    • 13.07.10
    • 18:00

    it is about time someone showed Al-Jazeera for the 5th column it is. they hide behind their "journalism" which is not known for it's veracity or accuracy...it is known and has always been known as an enemy of all JEWISH peoples. And should be treated as such...a vicious enemy.

  • 7. 72 24
    really!
    • northern neighbor
    • 13.07.10
    • 17:57

    yet another approach to intimidate the free press, a soviet style regime will suit Israel best, and talking about compensations, Israel will have to compensate lebanese for the numerous massacres commited against them, the files are been prepared.

    • 1 4
      soviets??
      • Michelle Wayne
      • 14.07.10
      • 05:12

      the "soviets" where supplying arms to the Palestinian terrorists, Hasballah in Lebanon got it arms from them, so who is really soviet style??

  • 6. 88 30
    Laughable
    • Critic
    • 13.07.10
    • 17:49

    Why don't they sue the one who started the war? Their own government?

  • 5. 64 23
    Who pays for the legal costs of the Israelis?
    • Ernst
    • 13.07.10
    • 17:46

    Clearly this is a rediculous accusation. The damages of 1,2 BILION dollar is only meant to damage AL Jazeera. DON'T SHOOT THE MESSENGER!

  • 4. 66 22
    Absurd
    • Nth Republic
    • 13.07.10
    • 17:44

    Israeli citizenry's reaction to truly free and independent media is to bring frivolous and ridiculous lawsuits against it on the grounds that its employees acted as forward observers for indirect fire? I realize this may be hard to fathom for many Israelis, who live in the land of subservient media, gag orders, closed military zones and daily journalist arrests, but not every citizen or worker is an organ of the state or a non-state political actor. Indeed, that "Katyusha spotting" was no doubt just plain-old accurate reporting, something Israeli reporters are either prevented from doing, or willingly forgo in service of the "Motherland".

  • 3. 53 15
    How odd. The ISRAELI press reported the same....
    • CJ
    • 13.07.10
    • 17:28

    ...just a small, but significant point....

    • 33 8
      media compensation
      • ego
      • 13.07.10
      • 19:28

      the Israeli media simply does not have the means to pay compensations my dear, they live from donations (bakshish) if you know what I mean, just like their government.

  • 2. 39 15
  • 1. 33 12
    if this is true..
    • Jordan P
    • 13.07.10
    • 17:17

    If this true..wow. but is there any proof to these allegations??

    • 72 18
      Of course there isn't any proof
      • Chris Linthwaite
      • 13.07.10
      • 18:30

      This is about moving the news scycle away from the Flotilla incident. Standard Zionist practice. wait four years before suing Al Jazeera for the fact that Hezbollah foired a rocket from Lebanon that hit her car. There is no way that the plaintiff will be able to prove that Hezbollah targetted her car thanks to the intelligence that Al Jazeera was supposedly sending to Hezbollah. Notwithstanding the fact that Israel didn't arrest and charge a single Al Jazeera employee.

    • 40 3
      No Proof
      • jake
      • 13.07.10
      • 19:26

      Agree.Good story though for internal consumption. And that's about as far as it will go.

    • 4 0
      very good analysis
      • Alexander K.
      • 14.07.10
      • 07:43